Ramkrishna Chauhan vs State Of U. P.

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 895
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(ARISING OUT OF SLP (CRIMINAL) No.5113 of 2023)

RAMKRISHNA CHAUHAN …APPELLANT(S)
VERSUS
STATE OF U.P. & ANR. …RESPONDENT(S)

J U D G M E N T

VIKRAM NATH, J.
1. Leave granted.

2. The present appeal assails the judgment and order
dated 10th April, 2023 passed by High Court of
Judicature at Allahabad in Criminal Appeal No.930
of 2023 whereby the High Court dismissed the
appellant’s appeal under Section 14A(1) of the
Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes
1
(Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and declined to
interfere with the summoning order dated 8th
August, 2022 passed by the Special Judge, SC/ST
Act, in Sessions Case No. 642 of 2022.
3. The facts necessary for adjudication of the present
appeal are as follows:
Signature Not Verified

1
For short, “SC/ST Act”
Digitally signed by
SHIPRA NARANG
Date: 2026.08.20
17:07:12 IST
Reason:
CRL. APPEAL @ SLP (CRL) No.5113 of 2023 1

3.1. Respondent No. 2 lodged FIR No. 37 of 2020
dated 25th January, 2020 against the appellant
and other co-accused persons for offences under
Sections 147, 323, 342 and 504 of the Indian Penal
2
Code, 1860 and Sections 3(1)(r)(s) of the SC/ST
Act.
3.2. The prosecution case, as set out in the FIR, is
that the sons of Respondent No. 2 were studying in
the school where the appellant was the Manager.
On 24th January, 2020, one of the sons of
Respondent No. 2 suffered injuries in a quarrel
with other students. Respondent No. 2 thereafter
approached the appellant. It is alleged that the
appellant abused and assaulted Respondent No. 2
with lathis, sticks and fists, along with the school
staff, causing him injuries. It is further alleged that
the appellant used caste-based abuses against
Respondent No. 2.
3.3. The chargesheet was filed against the
appellant and the co-accused persons on 17th
March, 2020.
3.4. By order dated 8th August, 2022, the Special
Judge took cognizance of the offences and the case

2
For short, “IPC”
CRL. APPEAL @ SLP (CRL) No.5113 of 2023 2

was registered as Sessions Case No. 642 of 2022.
3.5. Aggrieved thereby, the appellant preferred
Criminal Appeal No. 930 of 2023 under Section
14A(1) of the SC/ST Act before the High Court.
3.6. It is also relevant that FIR No. 39 of 2020 was
lodged by the appellant’s wife against Respondent
No. 2 on 25th January, 2020 for offences under
Sections 323, 504 and 506 of IPC stating that while
she was in the school office, Respondent No. 2
abused and assaulted her, following which the
appellant intervened and was also assaulted. A
chargesheet was filed against Respondent No. 2 on
27th April, 2020 and cognizance was taken by the
Magistrate on 3rd December, 2020.
4. The High Court, by the impugned judgment,
dismissed the appeal. It held that the mere fact that the
present case was lodged as a counterblast could not, by
itself, be a ground to quash the chargesheet or the
summoning order. The High Court further held that,
having regard to the allegations in the FIR and the
statements of the informant and other witnesses, a
prima facie case was made out against the appellant.
5. We have heard Mr. Siddharth Aggarwal, learned
senior counsel appearing for the appellant and learned
counsel appearing for the Respondent-State. Despite
CRL. APPEAL @ SLP (CRL) No.5113 of 2023 3

service of notice, Respondent No. 2-complainant has not
entered appearance.
6. Learned counsel for the appellant contended that the
High Court erred in holding that the alleged incident
took place within public view, despite the site plan
showing that the occurrence took place inside room ‘A’
in the school premises. Reliance was placed upon the
site plan dated 25th February, 2020 prepared by the
Investigating Officer, which identifies the place of
occurrence as room “A”. It was submitted that the room
was enclosed and had no window or public access. It was
further contended that the statements of the witnesses
do not establish that they were present inside the said
room at the time of the incident. At the highest, the
statements establish the occurrence of a scuffle between
the appellant and Respondent No. 2. It was also
submitted that the FIR contains no specific allegation
attributing any caste-based words to the appellant and
is general and vague in this regard.
7. Learned counsel further submitted that the appellant
had no prior acquaintance with Respondent No. 2 and
there was no material to suggest that he knew his caste
or intended to humiliate him on that ground. It was also
contended that Respondent No. 2 had assaulted the
appellant’s wife first, whereupon the appellant
intervened, and that the High Court had erroneously
CRL. APPEAL @ SLP (CRL) No.5113 of 2023 4

proceeded on the basis that a civil dispute existed
between the parties.
8. Learned counsel appearing for the Respondent-State
supported the impugned judgment and submitted that
the incident occurred within public view. It was
contended that, at the stage of taking cognizance, the
Court is required to consider the FIR, chargesheet and
material collected during investigation to determine
whether a prima facie case is made out. According to
learned counsel, the material on record was sufficient to
establish such a case.
9. Having considered the rival submissions and the
material on record, we find merit in the submissions
advanced on behalf of the appellant. The principal
question for consideration is whether the material on
record discloses the essential ingredients of Sections
3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST Act, particularly whether
the alleged caste-based abuses were uttered at a place
“within public view”.
10. Before examining the material on record, it would be
apposite to reproduce Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the
SC/ST Act:
“3. Punishments for offences atrocities.— (1)
Whoever, not being a member of a Scheduled
Caste or a Scheduled Tribe,—
CRL. APPEAL @ SLP (CRL) No.5113 of 2023 5

(r) intentionally insults or intimidates with intent
to humiliate a member of a Scheduled Caste or a
Scheduled Tribe in any place within public view;
(s) abuses any member of a Scheduled Caste or a
Scheduled Tribe by caste name in any place within
public view;
shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term
which shall not be less than six months but which
may extend to five years and with fine.”
11. The expression “any place within public view” has
been considered by this Court in several decisions most
recently in Karuppudayar v. State represented by the
Deputy Superintendent of Police, Lalgudi, Trichy &
3
Others. Relying on Hitesh Verma v. State of
4
Uttarakhand , this Court reaffirmed that:
“11. It could thus be seen that, to be a place ‘within
public view’, the place should be open where the
members of the public can witness or hear the
utterance made by the accused to the victim. If the
alleged offence takes place within the four corners
of the wall where members of the public are not
present, then it cannot be said that it has taken
place at a place within public view.”

3
2025 INSC 132
4
(2020) 10 SCC 710
CRL. APPEAL @ SLP (CRL) No.5113 of 2023 6

12. Tested on this principle, the prosecution case does
not satisfy the statutory requirement. The FIR does not
state that the alleged caste-based abuses were uttered
in the presence or hearing of members of the public. On
the contrary, the incident is alleged to have occurred
inside a room in the school. The site plan dated 25th
February, 2020 prepared by the Investigating Officer
identifies the place of occurrence as room “A”. The
material on record indicates that the room was enclosed
and had no window or public access.
13. The prosecution case also suffers from the absence
of any specific allegation of caste-based abuse against
the appellant. Neither the FIR nor the statement of
Respondent No. 2 attributes any specific caste-based
words or slurs to the appellant. The allegation that
Respondent No. 2 was abused on the basis of his caste
remains general in nature. The material relied upon by
the prosecution, at the highest, discloses a quarrel and
scuffle between the parties. It does not disclose any
specific caste-based utterance attributable to the
appellant.
14. During investigation, statements under Section 161
of the Code of Criminal Procedure were recorded of four
private witnesses, namely, Pradeep Kumar, Soorbeer,
Sudha and Pooja Chauhan, all teachers at Krishna
Public School. Pradeep Kumar stated that Respondent
CRL. APPEAL @ SLP (CRL) No.5113 of 2023 7

No. 2 came to the school office, where an altercation and
scuffle took place between Respondent No. 2 and the
appellant, with co-accused allegedly assisting the
appellant. Soorbeer, Sudha and Pooja Chauhan gave
substantially similar accounts, stating that Respondent
No. 2 came to the school office and that a quarrel and
scuffle thereafter took place between the parties.
15. None of these witnesses stated that they were
present inside the office when the alleged caste-based
abuses were uttered or that they heard any caste-based
words. While they stated that they were present in the
school, their statements do not establish that they
witnessed or heard the alleged caste-based abuse. Their
mere presence in the school premises, therefore, does
not establish that the alleged utterance was made within
public view. Learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-State could not demonstrate anything to the
contrary.
16. We are conscious that, at the stage of cognizance,
the Court is not required to conduct a meticulous
appreciation of evidence. However, the basic ingredients
of the offence must emerge from the material placed
before the Court. In the present case, the essential
requirement that the alleged caste-based insult or
intimidation occurred at a place within public view is not
borne out by the material on record.
CRL. APPEAL @ SLP (CRL) No.5113 of 2023 8

17. The finding of the High Court that the incident
occurred within public view cannot be sustained on the
material placed on record. The requirement of “public
view” depends upon whether the alleged utterance was
made in circumstances in which members of the public
could witness or hear it. The mere fact that the
occurrence took place within the premises of a school
does not, by itself, satisfy this requirement. In the
present case, the FIR and the site plan place the
occurrence inside an enclosed room, while the
statements of the witnesses do not establish that they
were present inside the room or that they heard the
alleged caste-based utterances. The material on record,
therefore, does not establish that the alleged utterances
were made in the presence or hearing of members of the
public. The essential requirement of “public view” is
consequently not satisfied.
18. In view of the above, the offences under Sections
3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST Act are not prima facie
made out against the appellant. The summoning order
dated 8th August, 2022, insofar as it relates to the
aforesaid offences, therefore cannot be sustained.
19. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed. The judgment
and order dated 10th April, 2023 passed by the High
Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Criminal Appeal No.
930 of 2023 is set aside. The proceedings arising out of
CRL. APPEAL @ SLP (CRL) No.5113 of 2023 9

FIR No. 37 of 2020, insofar as they relate to the offences
under Sections 3(1)(r) and 3(1)(s) of the SC/ST Act
against the appellant, stand quashed. The proceedings
shall, however, continue insofar as they relate to the
remaining offences under IPC.
20. Pending applications, if any, are disposed of.

……………………………………J.
(VIKRAM NATH)


……………………………………J.
(SANDEEP MEHTA)
NEW DELHI
AUGUST 20, 2026
CRL. APPEAL @ SLP (CRL) No.5113 of 2023 10