ARJUN vs MUKESH

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 227

Non-Reportable

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Civil Appeal No…………. of 2026
(@Special Leave Petition (C) No.157 of 2026)

Arjun & Anr.
…Appellants
Versus
Mukesh & Ors.
…Respondents


O R D E R

Leave granted.
2. Apart from the legal issue involved, a strange family
story unfolds where an old man attempts to protect his land
from his children and grandchild, allegedly wayward, by
gifting it to his great-grandchildren. This man, Rameshwar
was in possession and enjoyment of 3.16 hectares of land
as obtained from his father Chokharam. Rameshwar had
two sons and one daughter, Mahavir, Arjun and Jinku
respectively and a grandson Dalchand, born to Arjun. The
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by gift deed was made by Rameshwar to the children of
Deepak Guglani
Date: 2026.03.11
17:27:58 IST
Reason:
Page 1 of 6
CA @ SLP (C) No.157 of 2026

Dalchand, namely, Mukesh, Ramesh and Praveen. The
children of Rameshwar, Arjun and Jinku filed a suit
challenging the gift deed on the contention that they along
th th
with Mahavir, the 5 defendant and Rameshwar, the 4
th
defendant had 1/4 share each of the ancestral undivided
property of the Joint Hindu Undivided Family. The three
th
minors were the defendant Nos.1 to 3 and the 6 defendant
was Dalchand, the grandson who died during the
pendency of the suit.
3. Rameshwar, concerned with preservation of his
property and to sustain the gift deed in favour of his great
grandchildren, filed an application under Order VII Rule
11 of the Civil Procedure Code before the Trial Court. He
pleaded that Mahavir, his elder son and Jinku had
separated from the family after their marriage and were
given their due share, despite which the former tried to
cheat him of the property relying on a Will, allegedly
executed by the wife of Rameshwar, who was mentally
unstable. Arjun, his second son is alleged to have
Page 2 of 6
CA @ SLP (C) No.157 of 2026

murdered his wife upon which Dalchand, the grandson’s
protection was taken over by Rameshwar. Protection of his
great-grandchildren; fell on him when Dalchand too hit the
bottle and wasted himself away, forcing him to gift the
property to the great-grandchildren. Other than the
pitiable story, it was contended that the Civil Court could
not have considered the khatedari rights of the plaintiff
which definitely will have to be determined by the
Revenue Court as per the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955. The
Trial Court rejected the plaint and the High Court by the
impugned order confirmed such rejection on that sole
ground.
4. We heard Ms. Shobha Gupta, Senior Advocate
appearing for the appellants/plaintiffs and Mr. Gagan
Gupta, Senior Advocate appearing for the
respondents/defendants.
5. Based on the Tenancy Act, it was contended on behalf
of the appellants that if a suit is filed where the question of
khatedari rights arise then necessarily the Civil Court has
Page 3 of 6
CA @ SLP (C) No.157 of 2026

to raise an issue and refer it to the Revenue Court for
consideration. In the present case in fact before the civil
suit was filed, the plaintiffs had approached the Court of
Sub-Divisional Court, Sikar with a suit for declaration and
permanent injunction numbered as Suit No.01 of 2013
produced as Annexure A-1 along with the application for
permission to file additional documents. On behalf of
respondent it was submitted that unless that suit is
finalized, there is no question of a challenge against the gift
deed being considered.
6. As is found from the Tenancy Act, if a question of
tenancy arises in a civil dispute, the Civil Court would have
to raise an issue and refer it, for consideration of the
tenancy rights, to the Revenue Court. In the present case
the finding is also that only the Revenue Court has the
jurisdiction to decide khatedari rights based on which the
plaint was rejected; while the suit for the relief to declare
the tenancy rights was pending before the Revenue Court,
which fact was not noticed by the Trial Court and the High
Page 4 of 6
CA @ SLP (C) No.157 of 2026

Court. Even if the suit before the Revenue Court was not
pending, if a dispute is raised with respect to khatedari
rights before the Civil Court, an issue ought to have been
raised and referred to the Revenue Court. The rejection of
the plaint on that ground was highly improper. However,
in the circumstances of the suit pending before the
Revenue Court, we do not think that now there is any
requirement for a reference. The civil suit challenging the
gift deed can be restored and the Trial Court directed to
keep the suit in abeyance till the other suit is decided. If
any of the parties in the civil suit so desires, they can seek
to implead themselves before the Revenue Court for a fair
disposal of the claim of the khatedari rights agitated before
the Revenue Court, which has the jurisdiction to decide
that aspect.
7. On the aforesaid reasoning, we set aside the
impugned order of the High Court and the order of the Trial
Court rejecting the plaint and restore Civil Suit No.29/2016
to the files of Additional District Judge-03, Sikar, Rajasthan.
Page 5 of 6
CA @ SLP (C) No.157 of 2026

The same shall be kept pending till Suit No.01/2013 filed
before the Court of the Sub-Divisional Officer, Sikar is
disposed of. The Court of the Sub-Divisional Officer is also
directed to decide the issue and transmit the final order to
the ADJ, Sikar upon which the trial in the suit be resumed
and taken to its logical conclusion.
8. The appeal stands allowed in the aforestated terms.
We make it clear that we have not opined on either the
khatedari rights or on the validity of the gift deed.
9. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed
of.

.……….…..…….…………. J.
(SANJAY KUMAR)

.…….….…….……….……. J.
(K. VINOD CHANDRAN)

NEW DELHI
FEBRUARY 27, 2026.
Page 6 of 6
CA @ SLP (C) No.157 of 2026