Ashlesha M Mehta vs All India Radio
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
: 1: OA No.120/365/2019
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH
Original Application No. 365 of 2019
Reserved on: 07.08.2026
Ordered on: 01.10.2026
CORAM:
Hon’ble Mr. Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Mr. Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
Smt. Ashlesha,
Wife of Shri Mihir V. Mehta,
Age 56 years,
Working as TREX in the office of the respondents,
Residing at — M 14/159, Vidyanagar Flats,
132 feet Ring Road,
B/H Himmatlal Park Il,
Ahmedebad 380015,
… Applicant
(By Advocate Shri M.S. Trivedi)
V/s.
1. The Director General
O/o. DG, All India Radio,
Akashwani Bhavan, Parliament Street,
Sansad Marg, New Delhi-110 001.
2. The Deputy Director
O/o. DG, All India Radio,
Akashwani Bhavan, Parliament street,
Sansad Marg, New Delhi -110 001.
3. The Assistant Director (P)
O/o. AD (P), All India Radio,
Bhuj, Kachchh - 365 201.
… Respondents
(By Advocate Shri H.D. Shukla)
ORDER
Per: Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
1. The applicant's grievance is that the respondents, after having duly
considered and accepted her claim on merits and having issued orders
dated 29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018 granting TA and treating the period
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 2: OA No.120/365/2019
spent by her in attending the CBI Court, Ahmedabad, as duty,
subsequently and without affording her any opportunity of hearing,
sought to withdraw the said benefits by communication dated
05.08.2019. Earlier the applicant approached this Tribunal by filing OA
No. 277/2019, which was disposed of by this Tribunal on 21.08.2019
with liberty to the applicant to submit a representation and a direction
for consideration of the matter by the competent authority. Pursuant
thereto, she submitted a detailed representation dated 05.09.2019,
specifically raising all relevant grounds and seeking personal hearing;
however, without properly considering her contentions and without
granting her the requested opportunity of hearing, the respondents
issued the impugned communications dated 09.10.2019 and 15.10.2019,
cancelling/withdrawing the benefits earlier granted to her and rejecting
her said representation. The applicant, therefore, challenges the said
impugned communications in the instant OA.
2. By filing the present OA under Section 19 of the Administrative
Tribunals Act, 1985, the applicant is seeking the following reliefs:-
“(A) That the Hon’ble Tribunal be pleased to allow this petition.
(B) That the Hon’ble Tribunal further be pleased to quash and set
aside the impugned order/communications No.
15/1693/95/S/VII/475 and No. 15/1693/95/S/VII/476 dated
9.10.2019 and dated 15.10.2019 (Annexure A/1 & A/2) issued by
the respondents regarding cancellation/withdrawal of the
communication dated 29.6.2018 & dated 5.10.2018 regarding to
grant/treat the applicant on duty for the days/period for which as
she attended CBI Court at Ahmedabad and to give her TA for the
same and rejecting the request/representation dated 5.9.2019 of the
applicant.
(C) That, the Hon’ble Tribunal further be pleased to direct the
respondents to consider the request dated 5.9.2019 of the applicant
in its entirety, including the contents raised in the petition which is
enclosed with the request dated 5.9.2019 including the request of
personnel hearing to the applicant.
(D) That, the Hon’ble Tribunal further be pleased to call for relevant
file/papers on which the communication dated 29.6.2018, dated
5.10.2018, dated 5.8.2019 and dated 9.10.2019 and dated
15.10.2019 issued and the request of the applicant dated 5.9.2019
is considered by the respondents, for perusal of the Learned
Tribunal.
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 3: OA No.120/365/2019
(E) Such other and further relief/s as may be deemed just and proper in
view of the facts and circumstances of the case may be granted.”
3. Pursuant to notice issued by this Tribunal, the respondents have filed
their reply opposing the claim of the applicant to which the applicant
has filed his rejoinder refuting the contents of the same.
4. FACTS OF THE CASE
4.1 The applicant is a permanent employee of the respondents and is
presently working as TREX in the office of respondent No. 3. She has
been serving in the said capacity since March, 2013.
4.2 In the year 2007, while the applicant was working as TREX in the office
of All India Radio, Ahmedabad, a complaint was lodged against her by
the then Station Director, All India Radio, Smt. Sadhna Bhatt. Pursuant
thereto, the then Vigilance Officer of the respondents, Shri Nani
Vadekar, lodged an FIR before the Special CBI, Gandhinagar. After
investigation, the CBI filed a charge-sheet against the applicant before
the learned Special Judge, CBI Court, Ahmedabad, which came to be
registered as Special Case No. 06/2009.
4.3 As the criminal proceedings arose out of the discharge of her official
duties and required her to regularly appear before the CBI Court at
Ahmedabad, the applicant requested the respondents to grant her
travelling allowance (TA) for attending the said proceedings and to treat
the period spent in attending the CBI Court as duty, in accordance with
the applicable rules and provisions of the FR/SR.
4.4 The respondents considered the applicant's request and, after examining
the matter in the light of the applicable rules and Government of India
instructions, accepted her claim. Accordingly, orders dated 29.06.2018
and 15.10.2018 were issued, whereby the applicant was permitted to
attend the CBI proceedings after informing respondent No. 3 of the
dates of hearing and obtaining prior permission. The period spent by her
in attending the CBI Court was treated as duty and TA was also
sanctioned to her for such attendance.
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 4: OA No.120/365/2019
4.5 The aforesaid decision was also preceded by a departmental note dated
21.06.2018, which reflected consideration and approval of the
applicant's claim on merits with reference to the relevant rules and
Government of India instructions governing the subject.
4.6 Subsequently, however, the respondents, without affording any
opportunity of hearing to the applicant, reconsidered and sought to
withdraw the benefits already extended to her under the orders dated
29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018. By communication dated 05.08.2019,
respondent No. 3 was directed not to treat the period spent by the
applicant in attending the CBI proceedings as duty and to take action in
respect of TA in terms of para (ii) of SR 153(A).
4.7 Aggrieved by the aforesaid communication, the applicant approached
this Tribunal by filing OA No. 277/2019. The said OA was disposed of
by this Tribunal at the admission stage vide Order dated 21.08.2019
( Annexure A/3 refer). This Tribunal observed that the communication
dated 05.08.2019 contained guidelines requiring the Head of Office to
review the matter and take a final decision. The OA was accordingly
treated as premature, while liberty was granted to the applicant to
submit a representation raising her contentions before the competent
authority.
4.8 Pursuant to the aforesaid Order dated 21.08.2019, the applicant
submitted a detailed representation dated 05.09.2019 to the respondents
( Annexure A/4 refer), specifically placing on record her contentions
and requesting that the benefits earlier granted to her be continued. She
also sought an opportunity of personal hearing so as to explain her case
and the difficulties faced by her.
4.9 The respondents, however, did not accept the applicant's contentions
and issued the impugned communications bearing No.
15/1693/95/S/VII/475 dated 09.10.2019 and No. 15/1693/95/S/VII/476
dated 15.10.2019 ( Annexures A/1 and A/2 respectively refer), whereby
the earlier orders dated 29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018 were sought to be
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 5: OA No.120/365/2019
cancelled/withdrawn and the applicant's representation dated 05.09.2019
was rejected. Hence, this OA seeking the reliefs as quoted above.
CONTENTIONS OF THE APPLICANT
5. Learned counsel for the applicant contended that the impugned
communications dated 09.10.2019 and 15.10.2019, whereby the
respondents have sought to cancel/withdraw the earlier orders dated
29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018 granting the applicant the benefit of treating
the period spent in attending the CBI Court at Ahmedabad as duty and
sanctioning TA for such attendance, are arbitrary, illegal and
unsustainable in law and, therefore, warrant interference by this
Tribunal.
5.1 Learned counsel further contended that the criminal proceedings against
the applicant in Special Case No. 06/2009 arose from an FIR lodged
pursuant to a complaint made by the then Station Director, All India
Radio, while the applicant was discharging her duties as TREX. The
CBI, after investigation, filed the charge-sheet against the applicant
before the learned Special Judge, CBI Court, Ahmedabad. Since the
applicant was required to attend the said proceedings at Ahmedabad
from her place of posting at Bhuj, she legitimately requested the
respondents to treat the period of such attendance as duty and to grant
her TA in accordance with the applicable rules and Government
instructions.
5.2 Further, it is contended that the applicant's request was duly examined
by the respondents on merits and, after considering the relevant
provisions of the FR/SR and the Government of India instructions, the
respondents accepted her claim. The departmental note dated
21.06.2018 itself demonstrates that the applicant's claim was examined
and approved on merits. Pursuant thereto, the respondents issued orders
dated 29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018, under which the applicant was
permitted to attend the CBI Court proceedings after obtaining prior
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 6: OA No.120/365/2019
permission and was granted TA while the period spent in attending the
proceedings was treated as duty.
5.3 Learned counsel argued that, having once considered and accepted the
applicant's claim in accordance with the applicable rules and having
extended the consequential benefits, the respondents could not have
subsequently, without any justifiable reason and without affording the
applicant an opportunity of hearing, unilaterally reviewed and
withdrawn the benefits already granted to her. The communication
dated 05.08.2019, directing that the period spent by the applicant in
attending the CBI proceedings should not be treated as duty and that
action be taken regarding TA under para (ii) of SR 153(A), was thus
issued behind the applicant's back and in violation of the principles of
natural justice.
5.4 Learned counsel submitted that the applicant had earlier approached this
Tribunal by filing OA No.277/2019 against the communication dated
05.08.2019. The said OA was disposed of vide Order dated 21.08.2019,
wherein the Tribunal noticed that the matter required consideration by
the competent authority/Head of Office and granted liberty to the
applicant to submit a representation raising her contentions. Pursuant
thereto, the applicant submitted a detailed representation dated
05.09.2019, specifically requesting the respondents to consider all the
contentions raised by her in OA No. 277/2019, which was enclosed with
the representation, and further requested an opportunity of personal
hearing to explain her case and the difficulties faced by her. However,
according to learned counsel, the respondents failed to consider the
representation in its proper perspective and proceeded to issue the
impugned communications dated 09.10.2019 and 15.10.2019.
5.5 Learned counsel then contended that the impugned communications
suffer from patent non-application of mind. In particular, despite the
Tribunal having directed consideration of the matter by the competent
authority/Head of Office, the decision was taken by respondent No.1
and not by respondent No.3, who was required to review the matter. The
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 7: OA No.120/365/2019
respondents also failed to deal with the specific contentions raised by
the applicant in her earlier OA and incorporated by reference in her
representation dated 05.09.2019.
5.6 Learned counsel also contended that the applicant's specific request for
personal hearing was rejected without assigning any reason. The
impugned communications do not disclose any consideration of the said
request or any reason why an opportunity of personal hearing was
denied. Learned counsel, therefore, submitted that the decision-making
process was vitiated by breach of the principles of natural justice.
5.7 Learned counsel further submitted that the repeated and inconsistent
stands taken by the respondents regarding the very same claim create
serious doubt regarding the basis on which the benefits initially
sanctioned to the applicant were subsequently withdrawn. It is,
therefore, urged that the original departmental files and records relating
to the orders dated 29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018, communication dated
05.08.2019, impugned communications dated 09.10.2019 and
15.10.2019, and the representation dated 05.09.2019 be called for to
ascertain whether the applicant's claim and representation were duly
considered by the competent authority.
5.8 Learned counsel also submits that, during the pendency of the
proceedings, the applicant was acquitted by the learned CBI Court in the
criminal case in which she had been arrayed as an accused pursuant to
the departmental complaint and FIR. According to learned counsel, this
subsequent development, coupled with the fact that the criminal
proceedings themselves arose out of the applicant's discharge of official
duties, reinforces the applicant's claim that the period spent by her in
attending the CBI Court ought to have been treated as duty and that she
ought not to be deprived of the TA benefits already granted to her.
5.9 On the strength of aforesaid grounds, learned counsel contended that the
impugned communications dated 09.10.2019 and 15.10.2019 are
arbitrary, contrary to the applicable rules and Government instructions,
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 8: OA No.120/365/2019
suffer from non-application of mind and breach of natural justice, and
have been issued without properly considering the applicant's
representation and the earlier decision of the respondents and therefore,
prays that the impugned communications be quashed and set aside and
the respondents be directed to restore the benefits earlier granted to the
applicant under the orders dated 29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018, including
treatment of the relevant period as duty and payment of TA.
CONTENTIONS OF THE RESPONDENTS
6. Learned counsel for the respondents submitted that two criminal cases
have been registered by the CBI against the applicant, Smt. Ashlesha
Mehta, Transmission Executive (TREX), before the learned Special CBI
Court at Ahmedabad in relation to matters arising during her tenure as
TREX at All India Radio, Ahmedabad. Since the criminal proceedings
are sub judice , the applicant's allegation that the FIR was lodged on the
basis of a false and frivolous complaint is specifically denied. It is
further submitted that disciplinary proceedings in respect of the same
issues are also pending against the applicant before the Directorate of
All India Radio.
6.1 Learned counsel also submitted that the present OA has been filed
essentially seeking grant of Travelling Allowance (TA) for attending the
CBI proceedings and treating the period spent by the applicant in
attending the said proceedings as duty. It is contended that the applicant
is presently working as TREX at AIR, Bhuj, since 2013 and had
submitted a representation dated 25.04.2018 raising several grievances,
including her request for transfer from AIR, Bhuj to AIR, Ahmedabad, a
complaint against another employee, and her request for TA and
treatment of the period spent in attending the CBI Court as duty.
However, the applicant had not referred to any specific provision of the
FRSR in support of her claim in the said representation.
6.2 Learned counsel further submitted that, on consideration of the
applicant's representation dated 25.04.2018, the Directorate initially
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 9: OA No.120/365/2019
issued Office Memoranda dated 29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018, accepting
her request for grant of TA for attending the CBI cases and for treating
the periods spent in attending the CBI proceedings as duty. The said
orders were issued on the basis of the then understanding of the
Government of India's orders contained in SR 153-A and SR 154 of the
FRSR. However, while considering the claim for TA, reliance was
placed upon para 1(i) of the Government of India's orders under SR
153-A, which contemplates grant of TA where a Government servant,
whether under suspension or not, undertakes journeys to attend a
Police/Special Police Establishment enquiry in connection with a case in
which he is suspected to be involved. Likewise, while considering the
claim for treatment of the period spent in attending the CBI proceedings
as duty, para 3(a) of the Government of India's orders under SR 154 was
taken into consideration, which provides for treatment of the period as
duty where a Government servant is summoned by a Court of law to
give evidence regarding facts which came to his/her knowledge in the
discharge of his/her public duties.
6.3 Learned counsel contended on the basis of the aforesaid provisions that
the applicant was initially granted TA for attending the CBI cases and
the periods spent by her in attending the CBI proceedings were treated
as duty vide the Directorate's Office Memoranda dated 29.06.2018 and
15.10.2018. However, subsequently, upon consideration of AIR, Bhuj's
letter dated 07.06.2019 and the applicant's subsequent representation,
the Directorate noticed that the earlier orders had been issued on an
incorrect interpretation of the Government of India's instructions under
SR 153-A and SR 154.
6.4 The respondents’ learned counsel contended that, so far as the claim for
TA under SR 153-A is concerned, the applicant was no longer merely a
suspect in the CBI case by the relevant time, but had already been
charge-sheeted. According to the respondents, the benefit contemplated
under para 1(i) of SR 153-A is available where a Government servant
undertakes a journey to attend a Police/Special Police Establishment
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 10: OA No.120/365/2019
enquiry in connection with a case in which he is suspected to be
involved, and no provision was found in the said Government
instructions extending such benefit to an accused/charge-sheeted officer
for attending the criminal trial.
6.5 It is further submitted that the claim for treating the period spent in
attending the CBI Court as duty was also found to be covered by the
specific language of SR 154. According to the respondents, the said
provision applies where a Government servant is summoned by a Court
to give evidence regarding facts which came to his/her knowledge in the
discharge of his/her public duties. The applicant, however, was
attending the CBI Court as an accused/charge-sheeted officer and not
for the purpose of giving evidence. Hence, the respondents contended
that the provisions of SR 154 did not authorise treatment of such period
as duty.
6.6 Learned counsel further submitted that, when the aforesaid factual and
legal position came to the notice of the Directorate, it was found that the
Office Memoranda dated 29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018 had been issued
due to an erroneous interpretation of the Government of India's orders
under SR 153-A and SR 154. Consequently, the Directorate withdrew
the said benefits vide communication dated 05.08.2019. It is submitted
that the subsequent action was not arbitrary but was undertaken to
correct an erroneous departmental decision and to ensure that public
funds were not disbursed contrary to the applicable rules.
6.7 Learned counsel also submitted that the applicant thereafter approached
this Tribunal by filing OA No. 277/2019 challenging the withdrawal of
the earlier benefits. The said OA was disposed of at the admission stage
vide Order dated 21.08.2019, granting liberty to the applicant to submit
a representation to the respondents. Pursuant thereto, the applicant
submitted her representation dated 05.09.2019, which was duly
considered by the Directorate. It is also submitted that after carefully
examining the applicant's representation dated 05.09.2019, the
Directorate passed a reasoned and detailed speaking order dated
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 11: OA No.120/365/2019
09.10.2019. Thereafter, upon consideration of AIR, Bhuj's request dated
19.08.2019 seeking legal and administrative advice regarding
implementation of the communication dated 05.08.2019, the Directorate
issued Office Memorandum dated 15.10.2019 to facilitate further
processing of the applicant's claim by AIR, Bhuj.
6.8 Learned counsel denied the allegation that the applicant's representation
was not considered. It is submitted that the representation dated
05.09.2019 was duly examined and a reasoned order dated 09.10.2019
was passed. The respondents, therefore, contended that the allegation of
non-application of mind is misconceived.
6.9 As regards the applicant's request for personal hearing, learned counsel
submitted that the request was duly considered by the Deputy Director
of Administration (Programme), DG: AIR, but it was decided that
personal hearing was not necessary before taking a decision in the
matter. It is, therefore, contended that there was no violation of the
principles of natural justice merely because the applicant was not
granted a personal hearing.
6.10 Learned counsel further submitted that the contention that the impugned
communications were issued by an authority other than the competent
authority is also misconceived. AIR, Bhuj had itself sought legal and
administrative advice vide its letter dated 19.08.2019 regarding
implementation of the communication dated 05.08.2019. After
consideration of the matter, the Directorate issued the Office
Memorandum dated 15.10.2019 enabling AIR, Bhuj to process the
applicant's claim in accordance with the applicable rules and
instructions. Thus, the respondents' action cannot be faulted merely
because the applicant had earlier been granted the benefit. Learned
counsel argued that an erroneous administrative decision cannot create a
vested right in favour of the applicant to continue receiving a benefit
which is not authorised by the applicable rules. The respondents were
entitled, and indeed obliged, to correct the mistake once it was noticed.
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 12: OA No.120/365/2019
The applicant cannot claim an undue advantage merely on the basis of
an earlier erroneous interpretation of the rules by the department.
6.11 Learned counsel also disputed the applicant's reliance upon her alleged
acquittal by the CBI Court. It is submitted that the applicant has referred
to Special Case No. 31/2009 in one place and Special Case No. 06/2009
in another, thereby creating an apparent inconsistency. It is further
pointed out that the applicant has not produced a copy of the judgment
of the CBI Court evidencing her alleged acquittal in the present
proceedings. In any event, according to the respondents, the alleged
acquittal does not alter the applicability or interpretation of SR 153-A
and SR 154 governing entitlement to TA and treatment of the period
spent in attending the CBI proceedings as duty.
6.12 Learned counsel, therefore, submitted that the communications dated
05.08.2019, 09.10.2019 and 15.10.2019 were issued after due
examination of the applicable Government of India rules and orders
under SR 153-A and SR 154 and were intended only to rectify the
earlier erroneous grant of benefits. The impugned communications
cannot, therefore, be said to be arbitrary, illegal, or contrary to the
applicable rules.
6.13 On the strength of aforesaid grounds, learned counsel for the
respondents contended that the applicant has failed to establish any
enforceable right to claim TA for attending the CBI proceedings or to
have the period spent by her in attending the proceedings treated as
duty. It is accordingly prayed that the instant OA, being devoid of merit
and disclosing no cause of action against the respondents, be dismissed.
REBUTTAL TO THE RESPONDENTS’ STAND
7. Learned counsel for the applicant has not disputed that the CBI had
registered two cases against the applicant. It is, however, contended that
the respondents cannot seek to distance themselves from the
circumstances in which the criminal proceedings came to be initiated.
The then Vigilance Officer of the respondents, Shri Nani Vadekar, had
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 13: OA No.120/365/2019
stated on oath before the learned CBI Court, and the same is borne out
from the record, that the FIR against the applicant was lodged pursuant
to the complaint made by the then Station Director, AIR, Smt. Sadhna
Bhatt, to the Director General, AIR. On the basis of the said FIR, the
CBI instituted the criminal proceedings against the applicant.
7.1 Learned counsel also submitted that the applicant was transferred from
AIR, Ahmedabad to AIR, Bhuj in connection with the aforesaid
proceedings and has been working at AIR, Bhuj since March, 2013.
While posted at Bhuj, she was required to regularly travel to
Ahmedabad for attending the CBI Court proceedings. Accordingly, in
her representation dated 25.04.2018, particularly in paragraph 6 thereof,
the applicant specifically requested the respondents to grant her TA for
travelling from Bhuj to Ahmedabad and to treat the dates on which she
attended the CBI Court as duty.
7.2 It is further submitted that the respondents' contention that the applicant
had not quoted any particular rule or provision of the FRSR in her
representation dated 25.04.2018 is wholly immaterial. The applicant had
placed the relevant facts before the competent authority and had
specifically sought the benefits admissible to her under the applicable
rules. It was for the competent authority to examine the claim in the
light of the governing rules and instructions, which it admittedly did
before taking the decision in her favour.
7.3 Learned counsel further submitted that, as admitted by the respondents
themselves in paragraph 9 of their reply, the decision to grant TA to the
applicant and to treat the period spent by her in attending the CBI Court
at Ahmedabad as duty was taken by the Director General, AIR, New
Delhi. Thus, the respondents cannot now contend that the earlier orders
were issued merely on the basis of an inadvertent or isolated mistake at
a lower level. The claim of the applicant was consciously considered
and approved by the competent authority.
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 14: OA No.120/365/2019
7.4 It is also submitted that, while considering the applicant's representation
dated 25.04.2018, the respondents were fully aware of the
circumstances in which the CBI proceedings had arisen, including the
fact that the FIR had been lodged by the then Vigilance Officer on the
basis of the complaint made by the then Station Director. The
respondents had, therefore, consciously taken into consideration the
factual background and the applicable provisions before granting the
benefit. The subsequent attempt to characterize the earlier decision as a
mere "wrong interpretation" of SR 153-A and SR 154 is, therefore, an
afterthought and is not supported by any cogent justification.
7.5 Learned counsel also referred to the correspondence exchanged between
AIR, Bhuj and the Directorate. It is submitted that, as reflected in the
letter of the Assistant Director (Programme), AIR, Bhuj dated
08.05.2019, the applicant was asked to furnish certain details.
Thereafter, in the applicant's representation in June 2019, it was
specifically stated that, despite the benefit having been allowed by the
Director General, AIR, New Delhi, the same was not being extended to
the applicant by AIR, Bhuj pursuant to oral instructions allegedly
received from the higher authorities. This, according to learned counsel,
demonstrates that the issue was not merely one of rectification of an
inadvertent clerical or interpretative error.
7.6 Learned counsel emphatically denied the respondents' allegation that the
Office Memoranda dated 29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018 were issued due to
a wrong interpretation of the Government of India's orders under SR
153-A and SR 154. It is submitted that the subsequent withdrawal of the
benefits vide communication dated 05.08.2019 was not occasioned by
any genuine discovery of a legal error but was the result of extraneous
considerations and pressure. The applicant further submits that the
departmental noting dated 16.07.2019, relied upon by the respondents,
itself requires scrutiny, as the factual premise recorded therein is alleged
to be incorrect.
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 15: OA No.120/365/2019
7.7 Learned counsel also submitted that the respondents' stand suffers from
serious inconsistency. Having initially examined the applicant's claim
and granted TA and duty benefits by specific orders, the respondents
subsequently sought to withdraw the same on the ground that the
applicant was an accused and not merely a suspect. However, the
respondents have failed to satisfactorily explain why the same factual
position was not noticed when the applicant's claim was originally
examined and approved by the competent authority.
7.8 Learned counsel further submitted that the subsequent acquittal of the
applicant assumes considerable significance. The applicant was
attending the CBI Court at Ahmedabad in Special Case No.06/2009
since March, 2013, and the learned CBI Court ultimately acquitted her
vide judgment dated 04.05.2019. A copy of the said judgment,
according to the applicant, had already been forwarded to the
respondents along with her subsequent representation. Thus, the
respondents cannot disregard the fact that the criminal proceedings in
which the applicant was required to appear ultimately culminated in her
acquittal.
7.9 It is, therefore, contended that the respondents' reliance upon the mere
fact that the applicant was charge-sheeted/arrayed as an accused does
not, by itself, answer the applicant's claim for TA or treatment of the
relevant period as duty. The applicant's case has to be examined in the
factual context in which the proceedings arose, the nature of her official
duties, the circumstances leading to the FIR, the earlier conscious
decision of the competent authority granting the benefits, and the
subsequent acquittal.
7.10 Learned counsel accordingly submitted that the impugned decision
dated 05.08.2019 and the consequential communications dated
09.10.2019 and 15.10.2019 deserve to be interfered with, as the
respondents have failed to demonstrate any substantial change in
circumstances warranting withdrawal of the benefits earlier sanctioned
by the competent authority. The applicant, therefore, prays that the
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 16: OA No.120/365/2019
impugned communications be quashed and set aside and the benefits of
TA and treatment of the relevant period as duty, as granted under the
earlier orders, be restored.
8. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and also carefully perused
the pleadings available on record.
9. It emerges from the records that the applicant is a permanent employee
of the respondents and has been working as Transmission Executive
(TREX) at All India Radio, Bhuj since March, 2013. In connection with
criminal proceedings initiated by the CBI against the applicant arising
out of matters relating to her tenure at All India Radio, Ahmedabad, a
case was registered before the learned Special CBI Court at
Ahmedabad, pursuant to which the applicant was required to attend the
Court from Bhuj. The applicant sought grant of TA for attending the
CBI proceedings and treatment of the period spent in attending the
Court as duty. Upon consideration of her request, the respondents issued
orders dated 29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018, granting the said benefits.
Subsequently, the respondents reconsidered the matter and, vide
communication dated 05.08.2019, directed withdrawal of the benefits
earlier granted to the applicant on the ground that the relevant
provisions of SR 153-A and SR 154 did not cover her case. The
applicant challenged the said communication before this Tribunal in OA
No.277/2019, which was disposed of on 21.08.2019, granting her liberty
to submit a representation before the competent authority. Pursuant
thereto, the applicant submitted a detailed representation dated
05.09.2019, which was considered by the respondents and rejected vide
communication dated 09.10.2019, followed by communication dated
15.10.2019 concerning implementation of the said decision.
10. Having noted above, we find that the controversy involved in the instant
case essentially gives rise to three questions: (i) whether the applicant
had a substantive entitlement under SR 153-A or SR 154 to TA for
attending the CBI criminal proceedings in which she was herself
admittedly an accused/charge-sheeted person; (ii) whether the
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 17: OA No.120/365/2019
respondents were legally competent to correct/withdraw the benefits
earlier granted on an erroneous interpretation of the applicable rules;
and (iii) whether the impugned action is vitiated for violation of the
principles of natural justice or non-application of mind.
11. So far as the first question as noted in preceding para is concerned, the
distinction between a Government servant attending a proceeding as a
witness and attending a criminal proceeding as an accused is material.
The Government instructions under SR 154 contemplate the situation
where a Government servant is summoned by a Court to give evidence
regarding facts which have come to his knowledge in the discharge of
his public duties. The underlying requirement is, therefore, that the
Government servant should be attending the Court in the capacity of a
witness or for giving evidence concerning official matters. The
applicant, admittedly, was attending the CBI Court as an accused
pursuant to the charge-sheet filed against her. On the facts pleaded
before us, she was not summoned to give evidence in the criminal case.
12. Similarly, the benefit contemplated under the relevant Government
instructions under SR 153-A is referable to journeys undertaken in
connection with a Police/Special Police Establishment enquiry in a case
in which the Government servant is suspected to be involved. The
material distinction pointed out by the respondents is that the applicant's
case had progressed beyond the stage of an enquiry into a criminal trial
pursuant to a charge-sheet in which the applicant was arrayed as an
accused. The applicant has not demonstrated before us any separate
statutory or administrative provision, which confers a general right upon
an accused Government servant to claim TA as on tour merely for
attending his or her own criminal trial.
13. Indeed, the Government's instructions concerning legal proceedings also
distinguish between different categories of proceedings and prescribe
different consequences regarding reimbursement of travelling expenses.
th
The Government's instructions dated 8 January 1959, read with the
subsequent instructions governing TA for court attendance do not create
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 18: OA No.120/365/2019
an unrestricted entitlement in favour of a Government servant who
appears before a criminal court in his or her own capacity as an accused.
14. Consequently, we are unable to accept the applicant's submission that
the mere fact that the criminal proceedings originated from
circumstances connected with her official duties automatically
converted her attendance before the CBI Court into official duty or
entitled her to TA. The nature of the proceeding and the capacity in
which the Government servant attends the Court are decisive for
determining the applicability of the provisions of SR 153-A/SR 154.
15. The fact that the applicant was ultimately acquitted also does not alter
this legal position. An acquittal may undoubtedly have relevance to the
applicant's service related consequences arising from the criminal case,
but the entitlement to TA and treatment of the period of absence as duty
has to be determined with reference to the rule governing the
entitlement. The subsequent acquittal cannot retrospectively enlarge the
scope of SR 153-A or SR 154.
16. We may now consider the applicant's contention that, having once
granted the benefit by orders dated 29.06.2018 and 15.10.2018, the
respondents had no authority to withdraw it. This contention also cannot
be accepted in the absolute form in which it has been advanced. The
earlier orders were administrative orders granting a financial/service
benefit. If the competent authority subsequently discovers that such
benefit was granted on an erroneous interpretation of the governing rule,
the mere fact that an earlier administrative decision was taken does not,
by itself, create an indefeasible right to perpetuation of an illegality. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court has distinguished between a statutory/quasi-
judicial review and reconsideration of a purely administrative decision.
The proposition that review must be conferred by statute applies
principally to review of judicial or quasi-judicial determinations; purely
administrative decisions stand on a different footing. Thus, the
respondents were not precluded merely by the earlier orders from
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 19: OA No.120/365/2019
examining whether the benefit was actually authorized under the
applicable rules.
17. At the same time, the power to correct an administrative mistake is not
an unfettered power to act arbitrarily. Where an administrative decision
has conferred a financial or service benefit and its subsequent
withdrawal visits the employee with adverse civil consequences, the
decision-making process must conform to the requirements of fairness
and natural justice. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has consistently held
that administrative action producing civil consequences is subject to the
principles of natural justice, and that fairness in administrative action is
a constitutional requirement.
18. In the present case, however, the procedural position has to be examined
in its entirety rather than only with reference to the communication
dated 05.08.2019. That communication was challenged by the applicant
in OA No.277/2019. This Tribunal, by order dated 21.08.2019, granted
liberty to the applicant to submit her representation before the
competent authority. The applicant thereafter submitted a detailed
representation dated 05.09.2019, in which she raised her substantive
objections and specifically sought personal hearing. The respondents
thereafter considered the representation and passed the communication
dated 09.10.2019, which, according to the record placed before us,
contains reasons for rejecting the applicant's claim. The subsequent
communication dated 15.10.2019 was issued in the context of
implementation/processing of the decision.
19. The contention that the applicant was necessarily entitled to an
oral/personal hearing, merely because she had requested one, cannot be
accepted as an absolute proposition. Natural justice does not invariably
require an oral hearing in every administrative matter. What is required
is a fair opportunity to place one's case, and the adequacy of that
opportunity depends upon the nature of the decision and the
circumstances of the case. The applicant had already submitted a
detailed written representation after the aforesaid Order of this Tribunal
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 20: OA No.120/365/2019
dated 21.08.2019. Her grounds were before the competent authority.
The respondents considered that representation and passed a reasoned
decision. Therefore, on the facts available before us, the absence of an
oral personal hearing, by itself, does not vitiate the final decision.
20. More important fact is that the applicant's grievance cannot be
adjudicated merely on the basis of the fact that the respondents had
earlier granted the benefit. An administrative authority is not bound to
perpetuate an erroneous interpretation of a statutory rule merely because
the error was committed earlier. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has
repeatedly held that an employee cannot claim a substantive entitlement
contrary to the governing rules merely on the basis of an erroneous
order passed by the employer.
21. The plea of non-application of mind also does not persuade us. The
respondents have identified the precise provisions which, according to
them, governed the claim, namely SR 153-A and SR 154; they have
explained why the applicant's status as an accused/charge-sheeted
person did not fall within those provisions contained in said SRs; and
they have considered the representation dated 05.09.2019. The decision
may or may not have been agreeable to the applicant, but disagreement
with the conclusion cannot by itself be equated with non-application of
mind. An administrative order must, however, stand upon the reasons
contained in it and cannot ordinarily be supplemented by entirely new
reasons subsequently through pleadings. The principle is well settled
from Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner , reported in
(1978) 1 SCC 405, and has been reiterated by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court subsequently also. In the present case, the respondents' principal
justification for withdrawal is already discernible from the impugned
decision, namely, the alleged erroneous application of SR 153-A and SR
154.
22. We also do not find the subsequent acquittal sufficient to alter the result.
The applicant's acquittal is certainly a relevant subsequent event, but it
does not convert her attendance at the criminal trial, while she was an
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS
: 21: OA No.120/365/2019
accused, into attendance as a witness within SR 154. The entitlement
under the TA Rules is not determined by the eventual result of the
criminal prosecution.
23. We are also of the view that the mere fact that the respondents had
initially granted TA to the applicant, by orders dated 29.06.2018 and
15.10.2018, cannot confer upon her a vested right to continue to receive
a benefit which was found, upon subsequent examination, to be contrary
to the applicable statutory provisions. The initial grant of TA was
evidently founded upon an erroneous interpretation and application of
SR 153-A and SR 154. The respondents were, therefore, not only
entitled but also competent to rectify the error and correct the erroneous
application of the said provisions by withdrawing the benefit
prospectively, particularly when no independent substantive entitlement
to TA could be claimed de hors the governing rules. An administrative
authority cannot be compelled to perpetuate an error merely because
such error had been committed earlier.
24. In the result for the forgoing reasons, we find that the present OA is
bereft of merit and the same is accordingly dismissed.
25. There shall be no order as to costs.
26. Pending MA(s), if any, shall stand disposed of accordingly.
(Sanjiv Kumar) (Jayesh V. Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)
/pv/nk/
2026.10.01
15:51:17
+05'30'
PRATIK
VYAS