PREMIKA MAITY (PARAI) & ANR vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Rai Chattopadhyay
WPA 18548 of 2019
(CAN 1 of 2019)
Premika Maity (Parai) & Anr.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioners : Mr. Debabrata Roy
: Mr. Debashis Sinha
: Ms. Sharmistha Dhar
: Ms. Sarbani Mukhopadhyay
: Mr. R. Ray
: Mr. Aditya Mukherjee
: Mr. S. Majumdar
For the State : Ms. Chandreyi Alam, Ld. AGP
: Mr. Aniruddha Bagchi
Heard on : 31.08.2026
Judgment on : 16.11.2026
Uploaded on : 16.11.2026
Rai Chattopadhyay, J. :-
1. The writ petitioners have challenged an impugned memo
dated August 19, 2019, issued by the respondent No.
2/Commissioner of School Education, West Bengal (being
Annexure P-16 in the writ petition), by dint of which, while
considering the matter of appointment on compassionate
Page 2 of 18
ground of the writ petitioner No. 2, due to permanent
incapacitation of the writ petitioner No. 1/his mother, the
said authority has rejected such prayer. The petitioners have
prayed for the relief that order be passed directing to give
appointment to the writ petitioner No. 2 on compassionate
ground in a suitable post due to the reason as above and in
terms of Rule 14 (2) of the West Bengal Primary School
Teachers Recruitment Rules, 2001.
2. The instant writ petition has a chequered factual
background. Facts relevant to be discussed for due
adjudication of the instant case may be stated in the
following manner. The writ petitioner No. 1 has been a
primary school teacher, appointed on January 6, 1984, under
the Howrah District Primary School Council. She was
scheduled to retire with effect from January 30, 2011, her
date of birth being on January 20, 1951.
3. Since the month of November, 2008, the writ petitioner No. 1
became physically incapacitated and disabled to discharge
her duties, due to non-curable disease “Sehizo affective
disorder – a mental illness”. On December 29, 2008 she
writes to the West Bengal School Council for arranging
medical examination for her. Similarly, she has made prayer
to declare her as physically incapacitated and permanently
disabled to discharge the duties and also to provide
appointment to her son, the only dependent family member,
successor and legal heir that is the writ petitioner No. 2, on
compassionate ground. In response to her application and for
the purpose as above a 3 men committee was constituted,
which conducted an enquiry on May 9, 2009. Thereafter, the
Chairman of the West Bengal Primary School Council
Page 3 of 18
requested the Superintendent, District Hospital, Howrah, vide
his letter dated August 21, 2009, for medical examination of
the petitioner No.1 and to furnish report. The medical board
at Howrah hospital had found and opined the petitioner No.1
to have suffered with the incurable disease as above. As per
the advice of the medical board at Howrah, she has been
further examined clinically at the Neuroscience and
Psychiatry Department at Bangur. A similar report dated
September 7, 2009, was issued by Bangur Hospital about
incurable unfitness of the petitioner No.1, resulting into her
incapability to continue with the employment any further.
4. After obtaining the said two reports about incurable medical
condition of the petitioner No.1, the Chairman of the West
Bengal Primary School Council referred the matter to the
Deputy Director of Health Services (Administration), West
Bengal, vide letter dated September 30, 2009, with the
request to permit the petitioner No.1 to appear before the
medical board for examination in terms of government
notification No. 1176 Edn(P) dated August 23, 1979. The
petitioners have stated that during this period all leave of the
petitioner No.1 got exhausted and therefore the authority
concerned had stopped her salary. The petitioners have
further stated that no medical board was ever constituted
pursuant to the request of the Chairman of the West Bengal
Primary School Council in letter dated September 30, 2009.
5. This prompted the petitioner No.1 to move her first writ
petition being W.P. No. 1593 (w) of 2011, before this Court.
The Court directed for constitution of medical board in the
Medical College Hospital Kolkata and examination of the writ
petitioner No.1. the medical board furnished its report dated
Page 4 of 18
July 26, 2011, stating inter alia therein that the petitioner
No.1 was completely and permanently incapacitated for
further service of any kind in consequence of her disease
namely Bipolar Disorder.
6. Pursuant to the said report, a further application was made
dated June 6, 2012, along with bio data of the petitioner No.
2 and inter alia praying for acceptance of the request of the
petitioner No.1 of premature retirement on medical ground,
from the date of her initial application that is from December
29, 2008 and grant of employment to her dependent that is
the writ petitioner No.2, on the ground as above. The same
since did not receive any response from the authorities, the
second writ petition was filed being W.P. No. 16555 (w) of
2012.
7.
During pendency of the said writ petition the Chairman,
Howrah District Primary School Council, writes to the
Commissioner of School Education, West Bengal, to accord
approval of voluntary retirement to the writ petitioner No.1
with effect from December 29, 2008, pursuant to the
certificate issued by the Medical College and Hospital Kolkata
dated July 26, 2011. Later on, the writ petition W.P. No.
16555 (w) of 2012 was disposed of by the Court vide order
dated February 27, 2015, directing the Commissioner of
School Education, West Bengal to take decision in the matter
in time bound manner.
8. The first order of rejection of the petitioners‟ prayer came
thereafter, that is dated March 1, 2016, in which the
Commissioner of School Education, West Bengal observed
that the claim of the petitioner for appointment on
compassionate ground due to physical incapacity of his
Page 5 of 18
mother would not be accepted as she was neither declared
permanently incapacitated before her retirement nor she was
actually permanently incapacitated before her retirement.
This order was challenged by the petitioners in a writ petition
being W.P. No. 12370 (w) of 2016. The order of the Court
dated September 27, 2016, in W.P. No. 12370 (w) of 2016
assumes importance with regard to the instant writ petition
relevant portion of which is as follows:
“My attention has been drawn to Rule 14 of the West Bengal
Primary School Teacher Recruitment Rules (2001) and its
amendment under notification dated 28th January, 2008. Rule
14(2) of the said rules specified that when a teacher applies to
the Council for being declared herself as permanently
incapacitated on medical ground before attaining the age of 58
years and discontinues to attend his duty for the reason of such
incapacitation, the Council may direct him or her for appearing
before the Medical Board set up for the purpose according to the
procedure laid down in the relevant rules or order for the time
being in force, and after receiving the report from the Council, if
the Medical Board declares him permanently incapacitated to
continue in further service, he or she may be allowed by the
Council to retire on and from the date of submission in such
application and by virtue of his early retirement, if his family is in
such extreme financial hardship that it fails to provide two square
meals and other essentials to the members of the retired
teacher's family, the –
i) spouse;
ii) son;
iii) daughter
of the prematurely retired teacher, who is possessing required
educational qualification as laid down in clause a) and c) of sub-
rule 1) of rule 6 and unemployed and not below 18 years of age
and not above 45 years of age and found eligible to teach, may
make within two years from the date of such retirement, a prayer
in writing to the Council for appointment as Primary teacher on
compassionate ground. Sub-rule 3 further provides that on
receipt of the application under sub-rule 1) or sub-rule 2) as the
case may be, if the Council considers that the case deserves the
compassionate consideration, it may, with the prior approval of
Page 6 of 18
the Director or his authorized officer, give appointment to the
applicant as primary teacher.
Therefore, after the recommendation was made by the Chairman,
Howrah District Primary School Council when the matter was sent
for approval before the Commissioner of School Education, the
Commissioner of School Education ought to have considered the
matter taking into consideration of Rule 14(2) sub-rule 2 and 3 of
the aforesaid rule in its true and proper perspective and ought to
have granted its approval but instead by the order impugned
passed by the Commissioner of School Education on 1st March,
2016 sought to justify the declaration of the Medical Board by
which the petitioner was declared to be unfit and disabled. While
considering the case, the Commissioner of School Education has
also failed to take note of the Recruitment Rules 2001 and has
illegally passed the impugned order by rejecting the petitioner's
claim declining to accept that the petitioner has been declared
permanently incapacitated before her retirement or that she was
permanently incapacitated before the retirement.”
9. The Court had finally held in the said order dated September
27, 2016 that:
“Therefore, the order impugned cannot be sustained being
contrary to the aforesaid Recruitment Rule 2001 and the same is
set aside. The Commissioner of School Education, the respondent
no. 2 is directed to reconsider the matter taking into
consideration of the certificate issued by the Medical Board
declaring the petitioner as permanently disabled and
incapacitated and also taking into consideration of the Council's
recommendation being annexure P-9 to the writ petition that the
voluntary retirement should be considered with effect from the
date of her application, that is, 29th December, 2008. The
respondent No. 2 is also directed to take appropriate decision
taking into consideration of the recommendation of the
Chairman, Howrah District Primary School Council and forward
his approval to the District Primary School Council for
appointment of the petitioner on compassionate ground. Such
decision is to be taken by the respondent no. 2 within a period of
eight weeks from the date of communication of this order.”
10. By a subsequent order dated August 11, 2017, the Court
modified the said order of September, to the extent that the
Page 7 of 18
Commissioner of School Education, West Bengal should
forward its decision (and not approval) to the District Primary
School Council, in a time bound manner as directed.
11. Thereafter, on November 16, 2017, the responded issues
another order, that too rejecting the petitioners‟ prayer as
above and ignoring the recommendation of the Council, as
was directed earlier. Therefore, in a subsequent contempt
proceeding the Court has set aside the said order dated
November 16, 2017 and directed to revisit the matter taking
into consideration the date of first application by the
petitioner No.1, for compassionate appointment. The
resultant order is that dated August 19, 2019, which is
impugned in the instant case. It has been submitted that on
the same date that is August 19, 2019, the petitioner No.1
has been issued with the pension sanctioning order.
12. In this backdrop Mr. Debabrata Roy, learned advocate for the
writ petitioners, has attacked the said impugned order on the
following scores. Firstly, that the said impugned order is a
result of non-application of mind by the respondent and
emerges to be arbitrary and perverse, in so far as the
respondent has not considered the factual background of the
case, while passing the said order. It is submitted that in the
said fairly longish order the Commissioner of School
Education has failed to consider that the petitioner No.1 has
not been provided with the pension on her retirement, as yet.
Hence, according to Mr. Roy, learned advocate for the writ
petitioners, he could not have considered „financial hardship‟
of the family, while considering the prayer for compassionate
appointment of the petitioner No.2, by including therein the
so-called income of the family consisting of factors including
Page 8 of 18
the pension earned by the petitioner No.1. He also submits
that even if the pension was received by the petitioner No.1, it
could not have been made a component in calculating the
family income of the petitioners, while considering the
„financial hardship‟ of the family, in accordance with the
settled law. Mr. Roy learned advocate for the writ petitioners
has further submitted that the first application made by the
petitioner No.1 on December 29, 2008, was made within the
time stipulated as per Rules and had to be considered
accordingly, which the respondents failed to do. That, the
delay in considering such application by the writ petitioner
No.1 is solely attributable to the respondents, for which the
petitioners cannot be made to suffer. According to Mr. Roy in
consideration of the date of her first application, which was
made on December 29, 2008, the petitioners‟ case including
prayer for compassionate appointment should have been
considered in accordance with the Rule prevalent at that
time, that is, precisely Rule 14 (2) of the West Bengal Primary
School Teachers Recruitment Rules 2001. It is submitted that
there is specific noncompliance and gross violation thereof by
the respondent authority in the said impugned order, while
rejecting the petitioners‟ prayer for compassionate
appointment. It is submitted that rejection of the prayer for
compassionate appointment, considering financial hardship
of the family not to be there as per the Rules, by taking into
account the pension of the petitioner No.1, on a date when
such pension was still not granted to her, stands in stark
violation of the Rule as above prevalent at the said relevant
point of time. It is further submitted that till date the
petitioner No.1 has not been granted pension, though record
has revealed that on August 19, 2019, a pension sanctioning
Page 9 of 18
order has been issued to her. For all the grounds made out
by the petitioner in the instant writ petition as stated above,
Mr. Roy, learned advocate for the petitioner has sought for
necessary order granting compassionate appointment to the
writ petitioner No.2.
13. So far as grant of pension to the petitioner no.1 is concerned,
the respondent in the impugned order has narrated that she
has been requested to submit all necessary documents along
with her application for grant of retirement benefits with
effect from December 30, 2008, that is the date of her initial
application, to the Sub-Inspector of Schools, Shyampur North
Circle, Howrah. It is further stated in the said order that the
Sub Inspector of Schools, Shyampur North Circle, Howrah
has been further requested to submit all relevant documents
to the District Inspector of Schools (Primary Education)
Howrah, within 10 days of receiving the documents from the
concerned teacher, that is the present petitioner No.1. The
respondent authority further has stated in the said impugned
order that the District Inspector of Schools (Primary
Education) Howrah, being the Pension Sanctioning Authority
has been requested to take steps to sanction pension to the
petitioner No.1, considering December 29, 2008 as the
retirement date of the teacher, in accordance with law.
14. The other aspect dealt with by the respondent in the said
impugned order is that relating to the prayer of the
petitioners for grant of compassionate appointment in favour
of the petitioner No.2. The authority has considered that,
taking into account the date of retirement of his mother to be
on December 29, 2008, the pension granted and enjoyed by
the father of the petitioner No.2 and the Rule prevalent on the
Page 10 of 18
said date, the monthly family income of the incumbent
amounts to be more than the salary drawn by a Group-D
employee, on the said relevant date. The authority considered
that since this is the test on the basis of which the eligibility
of the dependent of the retiree should be considered for grant
of compassionate appointment, the petitioner No. 2 does not
fulfil the said eligibility criteria. The respondent has found in
the said order that the petitioner prayer for compassionate
appointment was beyond the scope of the governing Rules,
precisely that is Rule 14 (2) of the West Bengal Primary
School Teachers Recruitment Rules, 2001 [vide the
notification No. 57-SE (Pry) dated January 15, 2002]. Hence
has rejected his such prayer.
15. The respondent‟s first defence in the instant writ petition is
that the petitioner No.1 could not have been granted pension
till date due to the reason only attributable to her, for that
the petitioner No.1 has not submitted relevant documents
before the respective authority till date, in order to process
and release her pension. It is submitted that several
requisition letters of the respondent authority has not been
responded to by the petitioner No.1. Ms. Chandreyi Alam,
learned advocate for the respondent authority, has submitted
with all her usual fairness that, no sooner the petitioner
would submit all requisite documents, than immediate
necessary and appropriate steps would be taken up by the
respondent authority, for release of pension to the petitioner
No.1. It is pointed out that the petitioner No.1 would be
eligible for pension, treating her date of retirement on and
from December 29, 2008, due to her permanent clinical
incapacitation.
Page 11 of 18
16. Two issues emerge for determination in the instant writ
petition, the first of those is whether the petitioner No.1 is
entitled to pension; and if yes, from what date she is entitled
to the same. The writ petitioner No.1 has first made her
application desiring to retire from service at an earlier date
than scheduled due to her physical incapacitation, on
December 30, 2008. The development of events which
followed thereafter, as discussed in detail as herein above,
like clinical examination and assessment of disability of the
said person by various hospitals, have been done from time
to time, as per directions of the respective authorities.
Though on the date of her application, the petitioner had two
more years left in her service, however, to fulfil the directives
of the respondent authority from time to time for her clinical
examination, the said time period had elapsed and also the
scheduled date of her superannuation was surpassed. A
reasonable person can always find no active dilatory tactics
to have been adopted by the said writ petitioner in surpassing
her scheduled earlier date of superannuation, in the process
or any intentional latches of her in the same. The subsequent
medical reports have clearly transpired that the said
petitioner was not physically capable to continue with her
duties in the school and was incapable for the job any
further. That duly supports the petitioner‟s contention and
justifies her prayer in her first application dated December
30, 2008, that she should be considered as superannuated
due to physical incapacitation, with effect from the said date.
Also, it clearly transpires from the impugned order as
mentioned above that the respondent authority has allowed
the petitioner No.1 pension, with effect from December 30,
2008, subject to her submission of all the relevant documents
Page 12 of 18
with the said authority and has also directed for release of
pension within 10 days from receipt of the relevant
documents from the petitioner No.1. Hence, with regard to
the applicable date of pension to be granted to the petitioner
No.1, there remains no further ambiguity or uncertainty as
the respondent authority has already sanctioned pension in
favour of petitioner No.1, with effect from the first date of her
application, that is, December 30, 2008. However, there is no
material on record to show that the relevant documents have
been received by the respondent authority duly, in order to
progress towards releasing pension in favour of petitioner
No.1. In that case, inability of the said respondent to proceed
to release pension in favour of the said petitioner is well
presumed. Let it therefore be held and directed that the
respondent authority shall release pension to the writ
petitioner No.1 within 10 days from receipt of relevant
documents of her, with effect from the date of her initial
application made, that is December 30, 2008. Subsequent
enhancement in pension, if any, shall be given effect to duly
and arrear of pension shall be disbursed, maximum within a
period of 60 days from the date of issuance of Pension
Payment Order, in favour of the petitioner No.1.
17. This brings the Court to adjudicate as to whether the prayers
of the writ petitioners, precisely prayers (a) and (b) in the
instant writ petition is justified and sustainable or not. Prayer
(a) is to seek a direction to set aside the impugned order
dated August 19, 2019 of the respondent/Commissioner of
School Education, West Bengal and further directing the said
respondent to extend benefit to the petitioner No.2, in terms
of Rule 14(2) of the West Bengal Primary School Teachers
Page 13 of 18
Recruitment Rules 2001. Whereas prayer (b) of the writ
petitioners is for directing the respondent to give appointment
to the petitioner No.2 in a suitable post on compassionate
ground, due to permanent incapacity of his mother to
continue in employment any further.
18. The necessary criteria can be found in Rule 14(2) of the 2001
Rules, relevant portion of which may be quoted below:
"14(2) When a teacher applies to the Council for being declared
permanently incapacitated on medical ground before attaining
58 years of age and discontinues to attend his duty for the
reason of such incapacitation, the Council may direct him for
appearing before the Medical Board set up for the purpose
according to the procedure laid down in the relevant rules or
order of the time being in force, and after receiving the report
from the Council, if the Medical Board declares him
permanently incapacitated to continue in further service, he
may be allowed by the Council to retire on and from the date of
submission in such application and by virtue of his early
retirement, if his family is in such extreme financial hardship
that it fails to provide two square meals and other essentials to
the members of the retired teacher's family, the - (i) spouse; (ii)
son; (iii) daughter of the prematurely retired teacher, who is
possessing reqired educational qualifications as laid down in
clause (a) and (c) of sub-rule (1) of rule 6 and unemployed, and
not below 18 years of age and not above 45 years of age and
found eligible to teach, may make within two years from the
date of such retirement, a prayer in writing to the Council for
appointment as primary teacher on compassionate ground:
Provided that only one member of the family of the retired
teacher may be appointed under the provisions of this sub-rule:
Provided further that if the Medical Board shall not declare the
teacher to be permanently incapacitated, the Council may allow
him to rejoin the duty and the period of his absence, if any, shall
be regularized as per existing leave rules applicable to him.
Explanation - The expression "financial hardship", in relation to
income of a teacher retired under this sub-rule, consisting of
upto five members in his family for consideration of
appointment under this sub-rule, shall mean an amount of
income less than the initial gross salary of a group D staff of the
Council at the material point of time. For computation of
income of such family, an income of an amount earned from
Page 14 of 18
any other sources by each family member than provident fund
and gratuity at the material point of time, shall be taken into
account:"
19. For a primary school teacher retired due to permanent
physical incapacitation on medical grounds in 2008, Rule
14(2) dictates that a compassionate appointment can only be
granted if the family is in: "...such extreme financial hardship
that it fails to provide two square meals and other essentials to
the members of the retired teacher's family." Because the Rule
emphasizes actual extreme destitution, the respondent is
legally mandated to look at the household's total income.
20. In the impugned order as above the respondent has held that
the monthly pension of the petitioner No.1 being declared as
permanently incapacitated to retire prematurely on December
29, 2008, was Rs.8150/-, which was greater than the initial
gross salary of a Group-D staff at the material point of time,
amounting to Rs.7684/- [as per paragraph-(vi) of the
impugned order]. This reference is for a time period, when the
respondent has not even issued a sanction order declaring
the petitioner No.1 as permanently incapacitated or retired
prematurely than normal. Issuance of any Pension Payment
Order or grant of actual pension in her favour at the said
point of time is only hypothetical on part of the respondent
authority. In doing so, the respondent has taken into account
irrelevant factors (a pension that is blocked and not actually
released) and ignored relevant factors (the actual starvation
or lack of cash flow in the family). A right to receive a pension
in the future, or a pension stuck in litigation, cannot be
considered as an "income in hand." Under no stretch of
imagination, a person can be perceived to have actually
enjoyed the benefit and protection of his/her deferred
Page 15 of 18
compensation in the form of pension, that has not been paid
to her. A family cannot be considered to have been provided
with "two square meals and other essentials ", using a
blocked or non-existent cash flow. Court looks at the actual
financial distress at the relevant time period. The non-release
of the pension to the writ petitioner No.1 proves, rather than
disproves, the immediate financial crisis of the family, which
has not only to arrange for the two square meals, but also for
the huge treatment cost of the petitioner No.1, over and above
the other financial burdens.
21. In this regard the Court finds argument of the respondent
that pension could not have been released due to non-
submission of documents by the petitioner No.1 appears to
be inconsequential on two counts; firstly that no material is
available to show any steps being taken up by the respondent
in this regard, rather contrarily, the respondent‟s silence is
overwhelming; secondly that delay in suggested medical
examinations of the petitioner No.1 cannot be found to be
attributable at any fault of her. It is also significant that the
obligation to process and release the pensionary benefits of
an employee, particularly after the employer has itself
accepted the employee's entitlement to premature retirement
on medical grounds, cannot be treated as an obligation
resting exclusively upon the employee. Once the respondent
authority had undertaken the exercise of determining the
petitioner's medical incapacity and had ultimately recognised
her entitlement to retirement with effect from December 30,
2008, it was equally incumbent upon the authority to take
appropriate and timely steps to give effect to the
consequential financial benefits. The respondent cannot be
Page 16 of 18
permitted to rely upon its own inaction or procedural
omissions to justify the non-release of pension and, at the
same time, attribute an imaginary income from such
unreleased pension to the petitioner's family for the purpose
of defeating the claim for compassionate appointment. Such
an approach would amount to allowing the authority to take
advantage of a situation substantially arising from its own
failure to complete the requisite process and would offend the
settled principle that no party can be permitted to take
advantage of its own wrong. Consequently, the respondent's
explanation regarding non-submission of documents, in the
absence of convincing material establishing the petitioner's
deliberate default and the authority's corresponding bona fide
efforts, cannot furnish a legally sustainable justification for
the impugned assessment of the family's financial condition.
22. It would be beneficial to refer to the Supreme Court's decision
in this regard in Balbir Kaur versus Steel Authority of
India Limited reported in (2000) 6 SCC 493 and Canara
Bank versus Mahesh Kumar reported in (2015) 7 SCC 412 .
The Supreme Court has held inter alia that family pension or
terminal benefits cannot be treated as a substitute for a
compassionate job. The Court held that a pension is a
statutory deferred payment earned by the employee for their
past services. In Canara Bank versus Ajithkumar G.K.
reported in (2025) 11 SCC 178 . The said Court further
clarified that pension is not a replacement for an
appointment. The Court held that an employer must evaluate
the actual economic status and financial hardship of the
family. Here, the Court finds that the fallacy in the impugned
order passed by the Commissioner of School Education, West
Page 17 of 18
Bengal, as above, is clearly evident in so far as a pension has
been taken into consideration by the said authority to deny
compassionate appointment to the petitioner, which was not
actually sanctioned and granted towards the so-called
pensioner. Therefore, the finding of the authority that the
family was not living in the state of penury or extreme
destitution is absolutely illusive. The ground reality has been
something else and juxtaposed to the findings of the
respondent authority in the said impugned order.
23. All the reasons as discussed above clearly render the
impugned order of the Commissioner of School Education,
West Bengal, dated August 19, 2019, as an irrational, rather
arbitrary, illegal and an unsustainable one. Hence, the
present writ petition should succeed, setting aside the said
impugned order.
24. The instant writ petition is allowed with the following
directions:
i. The impugned order passed by the Commissioner of
School Education, Government of West Bengal, dated
August 19, 2019, is hereby set aside.
ii. The respondent authority, including respondent No. 6, is
directed to give appointment to the petitioner No. 2 on
compassionate ground in an appropriate post under the
Howrah District Primary School Council with immediate
effect, maximum within a period of eight (08) weeks from
the date of communication of this judgment.
25. The writ petition No. WPA 18548 of 2019 is allowed and
disposed of. Any application connected with this writ petition
is accordingly disposed of.
Page 18 of 18
26. Urgent certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance with all requisite
formalities.
(Rai Chattopadhyay, J.)
Later :-
After pronouncement of the judgment in open Court, Mr.
Bagchi, learned advocate appearing for the respondent has
sought for stay of operation of the instant judgement.
Prayer as above is considered and rejected.
(Rai Chattopadhyay, J.)