Chander Kumar vs Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal Cum Labour Court Ambala And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

1-
CWP-26134-2025 -
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
(249) CWP-26134-2025
Date of Decision: 13.11.2026
Chander Kumar ......Petitioner
Versus
Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal cum Labour Court, Ambala
and Others ......Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE KIRTI SINGH
Present: Mr. Bachan Singh, Advocate and

Mr. Sonu Bhatia, Advocate for the petitioner.
Ms. Saumya Ahluwalia, Sr. DAG, Haryana.
Ms. Sukhmani Patwalia, Advocate for respondent No.2.
None for respondents No.3 and 4.

KIRTI SINGH , J. (ORAL)
1. The present writ petition under Articles 226/227 of the
Constitution of India has been filed seeking issuance of a writ in the nature of
certiorari for quashing of the impugned Award dated 08.05.2025 (Annexure P-
12), passed by respondent No.1, whereby the claim petition filed by the
petitioner-workman seeking reinstatement in service with consequential
benefits was dismissed.
2. Briefly stated, the case set up by the petitioner-workman before
the learned Labour Court was that he was selected and appointed as a Mali
pursuant to Employment Notice No.12226/HALSA/2015 dated 18.09.2015
and was issued an appointment letter dated 29.10.2015. He joined the
respondent-authority on 02.11.2015 and was posted at Panchkula. His last
drawn salary was Rs.10,900/- per month. The petitioner claimed that he
continued to work till 05.04.2017, when his services were illegally terminated
RITIKA
2026.11.20 14:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
without complying with the mandatory provisions of Sections 25-F, 25-G and

2-
CWP-26134-2025 -
25-H of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act').
It was his further case that he had completed more than 240 days of
continuous service during the preceding twelve months and that persons junior
to him had been retained in service. Thus, he sought reinstatement with
continuity of service and full back wages. Per contra, respondent No.2
contested the claim petition, asserting that the petitioner had been engaged
purely on contractual basis against a temporary and non-sanctioned post, with
the specific understanding that the engagement would not confer any right to
regular or future employment. It was further pleaded that the work relating to
gardening and sanitation had been outsourced to M/s Sunrise Agency in terms
of the Government's outsourcing policy, as no regular post of Mali had been
sanctioned. The management also maintained that the petitioner himself
stopped reporting for duty after his request for payment of wages at DC rates
was not acceded to and that all admissible wages had been paid to him.
3. On the basis of the pleadings, the learned Labour Court framed
issues concerning the legality of the alleged termination and the petitioner's
entitlement to reinstatement and consequential benefits. The petitioner
examined himself as WW-1 and produced documentary evidence in support of
his claim. On the other hand, the management examined Avinash Gupta,
Officiating Law Officer, Haryana State Legal Services Authority, as MW-1
and also produced documentary evidence. Vide the impugned Award dated
08.05.2025, the learned Labour Court dismissed the claim petition, holding
that the petitioner had himself stopped reporting for duty after his request for
payment of wages at DC rates was declined. It was further observed that his
engagement was purely contractual against a non-sanctioned post and that
mere completion of 240 days of service did not confer any right to the post.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the learned
RITIKA
2026.11.20 14:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Labour Court has failed to appreciate the material evidence available on

3-
CWP-26134-2025 -
record. It is submitted that the petitioner was duly selected pursuant to the
public advertisement dated 18.09.2015 and was appointed as a Mali vide
appointment letter dated 29.10.2015. It is argued that no specific period of
engagement was stipulated in the appointment letter and that the petitioner had
continuously worked from 02.11.2015 to 05.04.2017 under the direct
supervision and control of respondent No.2. Having completed more than 240
days of service, his services could not have been brought to an end without
complying with the mandatory requirements of Section 25-F of the Act.
5. Learned counsel further submits that the management has
wrongly attributed abandonment of service to the petitioner, despite his
request seeking payment of wages at DC rates and the failure of the
management to formally transfer his services to the outsourcing agency. It is
also contended that another similarly situated employee, appointed pursuant to
the same advertisement, was retained in service, thereby violating the mandate
of Section 25-G of the Act. Reliance has also been placed upon the judgments
in CWP-19834-2011 titled Pyare Lal vs.The Presiding Officer, Industrial
Tribunal-cum-Labour Court and others and LPA-1110-2024 titled Atlas
Logistic Pvt. Ltd. vs. Mr. Jitendra Kumar, in support of the aforesaid
contentions. Accordingly, it is prayed that the impugned Award be set aside.
6. Per contra, learned State counsel opposes the petition and
submits that the impugned Award has been passed after due consideration of
the circumstances of the case and the material available on record. It is
contended that no illegality or perversity is made out in the findings returned
by the learned Labour Court warranting interference by this Court.
7. Learned counsel appearing for respondent No.2, while opposing
the petition, submits that the petitioner was appointed purely on a contractual
basis against an unsanctioned post of Mali, with full knowledge of the terms
RITIKA
2026.11.20 14:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
and conditions of his engagement. It is contended that the petitioner himself

4-
CWP-26134-2025 -
left the service on 06.04.2017 without giving the requisite notice and that all
his admissible dues had been duly paid. It is further submitted that, in view of
the Government's outsourcing policy, the work of gardening and other related
services was entrusted to an outsourcing agency, as no regular post of Mali
was sanctioned. Learned counsel also points out that the petitioner has failed
to produce any material to establish that he remained unemployed after
leaving the service and that the present petition is bad for non-joinder of the
person presently working as Mali. Reliance has also been placed upon the
judgments and decisions referred to in the written statement filed on behalf of
respondent No.2. Dismissal of the writ petition is, accordingly, sought.
8. There is no appearance on behalf of respondents No.3 and 4.
9. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
relevant material available on record.
10. The principal question which arises for consideration is whether
the findings recorded by the learned Labour Court, particularly with regard to
the circumstances in which the petitioner ceased to work, the contractual
nature of his engagement and the alleged violation of the provisions of the
Act, suffer from any perversity or legal infirmity warranting interference by
this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Articles 226/227 of the
Constitution of India.
11. A perusal of the record reveals that the petitioner was selected
pursuant to the employment notice dated 18.09.2015 and was issued an
appointment letter dated 29.10.2015 for engagement as a Mali on a contractual
basis. The terms of the appointment clearly stipulated that the engagement was
purely contractual, carried no promise of future employment and was liable to
be terminated at any time without prior notice. The petitioner had also
furnished an affidavit acknowledging the terms and conditions of his
RITIKA
2026.11.20 14:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
appointment. Further, the material placed on record, particularly the Haryana

5-
CWP-26134-2025 -
State Legal Services Authority Rules, 1996 (Exhibit W-8), was considered by
the learned Labour Court to conclude that the post of Mali did not find
mention in either of the relevant Schedules and was, therefore, not a
sanctioned post. Thus, the petitioner's engagement was not against any
sanctioned regular post and did not confer upon him any right to claim regular
appointment merely on account of his initial selection pursuant to an
advertisement.
12. The record further establishes that the petitioner had worked with
respondent No.2 from 02.11.2015 till 05.04.2017 and had completed more
than 240 days of service during the preceding twelve months. However, the
mere completion of 240 days of service, by itself, does not establish that the
petitioner was retrenched by the employer in violation of the provisions of the
Act. The protection under Section 25-F of the Act becomes relevant where the
cessation of service amounts to retrenchment within the meaning of Section
2(oo) of the Act. The foundational requirement, therefore, is that the cessation
of service must be attributable to an action of the employer, subject to the
statutory exclusions.
13. In the present case, the learned Labour Court, upon consideration
of the evidence, has specifically found that the petitioner himself stopped
reporting for duty after his request for payment of wages at DC rates was not
accepted. The said finding has been examined in the context of the
contemporaneous material, including the request made by the petitioner in
April 2017 (Exhibit W-7), the contractual terms of engagement and the
outsourcing arrangement brought on record by the management
14. The contention that the petitioner had completed more than 240
days of service and was, therefore, necessarily entitled to the protection of
Section 25-F of the Act cannot be accepted in isolation. The applicability of
RITIKA
2026.11.20 14:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Section 25-F has to be examined in the context of the nature of cessation of

6-
CWP-26134-2025 -
service and the statutory provisions governing retrenchment. In the present
case, the learned Labour Court has returned a specific finding that the
petitioner himself stopped working after his request for payment at DC rates
was declined. Thus, the learned Labour Court did not find the case to be one
of termination by the employer so as to attract the provisions relating to
retrenchment.
15. It is clarified that the mere description of an appointment as
contractual does not, by itself, bring every cessation of service within the
exception contained in Section 2(oo)(bb) of the Act. The applicability of the
said provision depends upon the nature of the contract and the circumstances
in which the service comes to an end. In the facts of the present case, since the
learned Labour Court has found that the petitioner himself stopped reporting
for duty and that termination by the employer was not established, it is not
necessary to rest the conclusion solely upon the applicability of Section 2(oo)
(bb) of the Act.
16. The plea regarding violation of Sections 25-G and 25-H of the
Act also does not advance the case of the petitioner. The provisions relating to
the principle of 'last come, first go' and preference in re-employment operate
in the context of retrenchment and the conditions prescribed therein. In the
present case, the petitioner has failed to establish, in the first instance, that his
services were terminated by the management by way of retrenchment. Merely
asserting that another employee appointed pursuant to the same advertisement
continued to work would not, by itself, establish an illegal termination or
confer an automatic right to reinstatement. No sufficient material has been
brought to the notice of this Court to establish that the petitioner was
retrenched while a junior workman was retained in violation of the statutory
mandate. The petitioner's contention, therefore, does not furnish a ground for
RITIKA
2026.11.20 14:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
interference with the impugned Award.

7-
CWP-26134-2025 -
17. Another circumstance which assumes significance is the
management's stand regarding the outsourcing of gardening and sanitation
work to M/s Sunrise Agency. The learned Labour Court noticed the
outsourcing policy (Exhibit M-3) and the material relating to the entrustment
of the work to the agency. It also noticed that the petitioner was given an
opportunity to work through the said agency but did not avail himself of the
same. The petitioner, on the other hand, failed to establish before the learned
Labour Court that the alleged difference in wages or the change in the terms of
engagement was such as to establish an illegal termination by the
management. The fact that the work was subsequently entrusted to an
outsourcing agency, when considered along with the contractual nature of the
appointment and the other evidence on record, lends support to the
circumstances noticed by the learned Labour Court. It does not, however,
independently determine the issue of termination, which has to be assessed on
the basis of the entire evidence.
18. The judgments relied upon by learned counsel for the petitioner
have also been considered. However, the controversy in the present case turns
upon the specific factual findings returned by the learned Labour Court
regarding the circumstances in which the petitioner ceased to report for duty.
The mere fact that the petitioner had completed 240 days of service or that
another employee continued to work would not, in the facts of the present
case, be sufficient to dislodge the finding that termination by the employer had
not been established. The aforesaid judgments, therefore, do not advance the
petitioner's case so as to warrant interference with the impugned Award.
19. It is well settled that this Court, while exercising jurisdiction
under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India against an award passed by
the Labour Court, does not sit as an appellate Court to reappreciate the
RITIKA
2026.11.20 14:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
evidence or substitute its own conclusions merely because another view may

8-
CWP-26134-2025 -
also be possible. Interference is warranted where the findings are perverse,
based on no evidence, suffer from patent illegality or disclose an error of
jurisdiction. A mere disagreement with the appreciation of evidence by the
Labour Court would not, by itself, furnish a ground for interference in the
exercise of supervisory jurisdiction.
20. In the present case, the learned Labour Court has considered the
appointment letter, the contractual terms of engagement, the absence of a
sanctioned post of Mali, the Government's outsourcing policy and, most
importantly, the circumstances in which the petitioner ceased to report for
duty. The finding that the petitioner himself stopped working after his request
for payment at DC rates was declined is based upon the material available on
record and cannot be said to be perverse or unsupported by evidence. Learned
counsel for the petitioner has failed to point out any material evidence which
was ignored or any patent legal infirmity in the approach adopted by the
learned Labour Court so as to warrant interference by this Court.
21. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no ground to
interfere with the impugned Award dated 08.05.2025 passed by the learned
Labour Court, Ambala.
22. Consequently, finding no merit in the present writ petition, the
same is hereby dismissed.
23. Pending civil miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of accordingly.
(KIRTI SINGH)
JUDGE
November 13, 2026
Ritika
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
RITIKA
2026.11.20 14:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document