PARDEEP SINGH AND OTHERS vs UT OF J AND K TH SHO PS VIGILANCE ORGANIZATION JAMMU AND OTHERS

Court
Jammu and Kashmir High Court

HIGH COURT OF JAMMU &KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT
JAMMU
Reserved on: 30.10.2026
Pronounced on: 19.11.2026
Uploaded on: 20.11.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
CRM(M) No.29/2022
PARDEEP SINGH & ORS.
...PETITIONER(S)
Through: - Mr. Abhinav Sharma, Sr. Advocate, with
Mr. Abhirash Sharma, Advocate
Mr. Asheesh Singh Kotwal, Advocate.
Vs.
UT OF J&K & ORS. …RESPONDENT(S)
Through: - Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG, with
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate.
Mr. J. A. Hamal, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1) The petitioners, through the medium of present
petition, have challenged the charge sheet emanating out of
FIR No. 03 of 2014 for offences under Section 5(1)(d) read
with Section 5(2) PC Act and Section 420, 467, 468, 471 and
120-B RPC registered with Vigilance Organization Jammu
(now ACB), which is stated to be pending before the Court of
Special Judge Anti-Corruption, Doda (hereinafter “the Trial
Court”).
2) As per the prosecution case, a complaint was lodged by
predecessor-in-interest of private respondents with the
CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 1 of 12

Vigilance Organization on 03.02.2011 alleging therein that
land measuring 60 kanals and 16 marlas falling under
Khasra No.2772/583 min, which was shown in revenue
records since 1971 as government land, has been
fraudulently mutated by the revenue authorities in the name
of the petitioners on monetary considerations. It was alleged
that the said land was coming within the alignment of
Kishtwar-Chatroo-Sinthan Road and involved huge amount
of compensation, which prompted the above action by the
revenue authorities with a view to confer undue benefit upon
the petitioners.
3) The respondent investigating agency proceeded to
conduct a preliminary verification, during which it was
found that the land in question was not State land, but it
was ‘Shamilat Deh’ land, and the proprietary land owners of
the village had proportionate share in the same. It was found
that Shri Abdul Rashid Bhat, the then Tehsildar Kishtwar
(expired), Abdul Qayoom, the then Girdawar Halqa Pouchal
(retired), Shri Om Dutt, the then Patwari Halqa Pouchal
(retired), Mohammad Iqbal Kichloo, the then Patwari
Pouchal, and Abdul Aziz Tak, the then Patwari Pouchal,
entered into criminal conspiracy with the petitioners by
abusing their official position and made fraudulent entries
in the revenue record exclusively in their favour in respect of
CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 2 of 12

the portion of land falling under Khasra No.2772/583 of
Village Pouchal, which was coming under alignment of
Kishtwar-Sinthan Road. It was found that initially the status
of the land was changed from ‘Gair Mumkin Jarh’ to ‘Gora’
in the year 2003, and subsequently mutations of the said
land were attested in favour of the petitioners in the year
2010 by showing their possession over the same since the
year 1971, even though petitioners Kuljeet Singh and
Pradeep Singh were born in the years 1977 and 1964
respectively. Thus, FIR for offences under Section 5(1)(d)
read with Section 5(2) of PC Act and Sections 420, 467, 468,
471, 120-B of RPC was registered and investigation was set
into motion.
4) After investigation of the case, the aforesaid offences
were found established against accused Mohammad Iqbal
Kichloo, the then Girdawar Pouchal, accused Abdul Rashid,
the then Tehsildar Kishtwar (expired), accused Om Dutt, the
then Patwari Pouchal, accused Abdul Qayoom, the then
Girdawari Pouchal (now retired), and the petitioners herein.
5) The petitioners have challenged the impugned charge
sheet on the ground that the mutation order Nos.3614 and
3615, both dated 30.03.2010, which are subject matter of
challan, were challenged by the private respondents before
Additional Deputy Commissioner, Kishtwar, but the appeal
CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 3 of 12

came to be dismissed by the appellate authority in terms of
judgment dated 08.12.2021. According to the petitioners,
once the basis of the charge sheet, which is the aforesaid
mutation orders passed in their favour, has been knocked
down by the appellate authority by upholding the said
mutation orders, there is no logic in to prosecuting the
petitioners. It has been contended that the appellate
authority has come to the conclusion that Shamilat land
under Khasra No.2772/583-min of Village Pouchal was in
cultivating possession of the petitioners through their
predecessor since the year 1971, and that in the year 1998,
when they had attained majority, the entry in respect of land
measuring 20 Kanals was made in their favour. It has been
contended that even the private respondents do not deny the
fact that the petitioners are holding proprietary land in
Village Pouchal, and, as such, they are share-holders of the
Shamilat Deh land. It has been submitted that the private
respondents have neither any physical possession on spot
nor any revenue entry in their favour in respect of the
Shamilat land, as such, the petitioners have not taken away
any of their rights.
6) It has further been submitted that as per the report of
Tehsildar dated 11.11.2012 submitted to Vigilance
Organization, petitioner No.1 has entitlement of 35 kanals
CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 4 of 12

06 marlas of Shamilat land, petitioner No.2 has entitlement
of 36 kanals 09 marlas of Shamilat land, and petitioner Nos.
3 to 7 have entitlement of 45 kanals and 15 marlas of
Shamilat land. It has been further contended that Sehat-i-
Kasht in respect of the land in question was made in the year
2003 in favour of the petitioners when not even the
notification for acquisition of the land was issued and
further, when the mutations in respect of the land were
attested in favour of the petitioners, the land had not been
acquired for construction of the road, as such, it cannot be
stated that the petitioners had under a design got the
mutations attested in their favour. It has been contended
that registration of FIR and filing of challan against the
petitioners in these circumstances is an abuse of process of
law.
7) The official respondents, in their reply, have reiterated
the allegations made in the charge sheet. However, no reply
has been filed by the private respondents.
8) I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the case.
9) The main ground, on which petitioners are assailing
the impugned charge sheet, is that the mutation orders,
which are subject matter of the impugned challan, have been
upheld by the appellate authority, thereby appending the
CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 5 of 12

seal of approval upon the same. It has been contended that
once the mutation orders have been upheld by the appellate
authority, the very basis of the impugned criminal
prosecution against the petitioners gets knocked down.
10) Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the private
respondents and learned Senior AAG appearing for the
official respondents have contended that the order passed by
the appellate authority was challenged by the private
respondents by way of an appeal before the Divisional
Commissioner, Jammu, who, vide order dated 11.10.2025,
has made adverse observations with regard to the order
passed by the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Kishtwar,
and it is for this reason that the petitioners proceeded to file
a revision petition against the order of the Divisional
Commissioner before the Court of Financial Commissioner,
Jammu. It has further been contended that the learned
Principal District Judge, Kishtwar, vide his judgment dated
05.10.2023 passed in a reference made by the Collector,
Land Acquisition, at the behest of the private respondents,
has clearly held that the mutation entries in favour of the
petitioners are manipulated, and that the petitioners were
never in exclusive possession of the portion of Shamilat land,
regarding which mutations have been attested in their
favour.
CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 6 of 12

11) It is pertinent to mention here that the judgment
passed by the Reference Court has been challenged by the
petitioners by way of appeal before this Court, and vide
interim order dated 16.10.2023 passed by this Court in RFA
No.40/2023, the judgment of the Principal District Judge,
Kishtwar, has been stayed. The appeal is still pending before
this Court.
12) It is not in dispute that the petitioners and the private
respondents are estate holders of Village Pouchal, therefore,
they have proportionate share in the Shamilat Deh land.
According to the petitioners, they were in exclusive
possession of the portion of Shamilat Deh land which has
been mutated in their favour, whereas the same is being
seriously disputed by the private respondents, who have
vehemently contended that there has been no partition of the
Shamilat Deh land and, therefore, mutation in respect of a
specific portion of Shamilat Deh land, which has come under
the alignment of road, could not have been attested in their
favour. According to the respondents, this has been done by
the revenue officers of the relevant time by misuse of their
official position with a view to confer undue benefit upon the
petitioners.

13) The order of the Additional Deputy Commissioner,
whereby the mutation orders passed in favour of petitioners
CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 7 of 12

have been upheld, was challenged by the private
respondents by way of appeal before the Divisional
Commissioner, who did not express any opinion on the
merits of the case, but after noticing the facts, rendered an
opinion that in view of pendency of the civil proceedings
before the High Court, adjudication of merits of rival claims
and validity of mutations in question cannot be conclusively
decided, as final decision of the High Court would govern the
core issue relating to respective rights of the parties. Merely
because the petitioners have challenged the said order of the
Divisional Commissioner by way of a revision petition before
the Financial Commissioner does not change the fact that
the Divisional Commissioner has not rendered any opinion
on the merits of the order passed by the Additional Deputy
Commissioner.

14) We have also before us the judgment passed by the
Reference Court, according to which the mutations attested
in favour of the petitioners are manipulated and that there
was no partition of Shamilat Deh land between the
petitioners and the private respondents. The said judgment
of the Reference Court is under challenge before this Court
in appeal and the same has been stayed.

15) From the narration of aforesaid facts, it becomes clear
that validity and legality of the mutation orders, which
CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 8 of 12

according to the investigating agency are manipulated and
have been attested by the then revenue officers by misuse of
their official position, is subject matter of determination
before this Court and also before the revenue courts. The
fact that one of the revenue authorities, Additional Deputy
Commissioner, has proceeded to uphold the validity of the
impugned mutation orders, and the fact that this Court has
stayed the judgment of the Reference Court, goes on to show
that regarding legality of attestation of mutations by the
revenue officers in favour of petitioners different views have
been expressed by various courts/authorities and a final
word on the issue is still awaited.
16) In case every order passed by a revenue officer and
every order passed by a judicial or quasi-judicial authority is
viewed with suspicion and subjected to criminal
prosecution, it would be difficult for the revenue officers and
quasi-judicial or judicial authorities to function fearlessly. A
statutory or a quasi-judicial authority is bound to make
mistakes while passing orders, but every order passed by
such authorities cannot be made subject matter of
investigation, unless it is clearly shown that the orders of the
statutory/quasi-judicial authority have been passed with a
dishonest or mala fide intention, which can be gathered from
the surrounding circumstances.
CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 9 of 12

17) In the present case, Sehat-i-Kasht in respect of the land
in question was made in favour of the petitioners in the year
2003, when the land in question was not even contemplated
to be acquired. In fact, notification under Section 4 of the
Land Acquisition Act in respect of the subject land came to
be issued only on 03.12.2010. Even before that date, Sehat-
i-Kasht had already been attested in favour of the
petitioners. The mutations were also effected in favour of the
petitioners on 30.03.2010, well before issuance of
notification under Section 4 of the Land Revenue Act.
Therefore, the inference drawn by the investigating agency
that Sehat-i-Kasht and the mutations were attested in favour
of the petitioners with a view to obtain compensation for
acquisition of land is far-fetched, unless it is assumed that
the petitioners had foresight that one day the said patch of
land would be acquired.
18) Merely on the basis that some of the petitioners were
minors in the year 1971, and while passing the order of
Sehat-i-Kasht, it was observed by the revenue officer that
they are in possession since the year 1971, it cannot be
stated that a gross illegality has been committed by the
revenue officer concerned. By recording that these
petitioners were in possession since the year 1971. The
relevant revenue officer intended to convey that the
CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 10 of 12

petitioners and their predecessors were in possession of the
land since the year 1971, which fact has been explained by
the Additional Deputy Commissioner in his judgment, which
is a possible and plausible view.
19) Thus, mere attestation of mutations by the revenue
officers in favour of the petitioners would not by itself attract
the provisions of Prevention of Corruption Act or any other
penal provision. The material collected by the investigating
agency during the course of investigation does not disclose
allegation of acceptance of illegal gratification or other
pecuniary advantage by the revenue officials from the
petitioners nor there is any material on record to show that
there was a prior meeting of minds between them for
securing attestation of the mutations through abuse of
official position. The foundation of the prosecution case is
the mutations attested in favour of the petitioners. These
mutation orders are amenable to scrutiny by the
appellate/revisional authorities. Therefore, mere attestation
of mutation orders, without there being any material to show
that these orders have been attested with a dishonest
intention, would not attract the provisions of Prevention of
Corruption Act. If the logic of the investigating agency is
accepted, then even the Additional Deputy Commissioner,
CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 11 of 12

who has upheld the mutation orders, becomes a co-
conspirator, which would be a preposterous proposition.
20) In view of what has been discussed hereinbefore, it is
clear that lodging of FIR and filing of charge sheet against
the petitioners, in the facts and circumstances of the case,
is nothing but an abuse of process of law. Therefore, the
impugned FIR and the charge sheet emanating therefrom
deserves to be quashed.
21) Accordingly, the petition is allowed and the impugned
FIR and the charge sheet emanating therefrom as against
the petitioners is quashed.

(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge

SRINAGAR
19.11.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the judgment is reportable: YES/NO

CRM(M) No.29/2022 Page 12 of 12