ALLI AHAD vs STATE OF ODISHA

Court
Odisha High Court


IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
WPC No.17775 of 2025
ODHC010445152025

(An application under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of
India)

Alli Ahad …. Petitioner

-Versus-

State of Orissa and Ors. .... Opp. Parties


For Petitioner : Mr. Kishore Kumar Mishra,

Advocate

For Opp. Parties : Mr. S.N. Patnaik,
[Additional Government Advocate]
M/s. Satyabadi Mantry &
A.K. Sharma, Advocates
[For Opp. Party Nos.5 to 8]
___________________________________________________________________

CORAM:
MR. JUSTICE SASHIKANTA MISHRA

JUDGMENT
20.11.2026


SASHIKANTA MISHRA, J.
The petitioner seeks to quash the parallel record
of rights (RoR)/ Patta recorded under the Sikimi Khata No.04-
Page 1 of 10

4 under Sthitiban Khata No.28 situated in Mouza Rampei,
Tahasil Athagarh, Cuttack.
2. The facts of the case, briefly stated are that the
grandfather of the petitioner namely, Moulabi Abdul Ahad
was recorded as the original Sthitiban tenant under Khata
No.28, as per settlement RoR finally published on
14.01.1963. The above record of rights was prepared
pursuant to the Amin Report No.38 and the Munsarim
Mistake case No.4/132. After the death of the original tenant,
Mutation Case no.6965 of 2024 was initiated to mutate the
property in favour of his legal heirs. A portion of the property
under Plot No.1568 measuring Ac.0.50 decimals out of the Ac.
5.40 decimals was acquired by the National Highway
Authority of India (NHAI). However, a part of the
compensation was awarded to the Opp. Parties Nos. 5 to 8
basing on a parallel record of rights created under the Sikimi
Khata No.04-4 in the names of their predecessors Krushna
Chandra Khuntia and Gobinda Khuntia over plot Nos.1568
and 1569. The said record of rights is challenged in the
present case.
Page 2 of 10

3. Counter affidavit has been filed by the private
Opp. Party Nos.5 to 8 stating that the title and ownership of
the property under Khata No.28 corresponding to Sikimi
Khata No.4-4 was subject matter in Civil Suit No.74 of 2012
before learned Senior Civil Judge, Athagarh, which was
disposed of by judgment dated 14.08.2023, holding that the
predecessor of the petitioner had duly transferred the land
under plot no.1568 through RSD Nos.1312 and 1311
recognizing them as valid sikimi tenants over the property. It
is further submitted that the court held that the rights of the
sikimi tenants were heritable and transferable relying on the
decision passed in the case of Daitary Swain vs. Kartika
1
Swain and Ors. They further submit that the said judgment
of the Civil Court is under challenge before the learned
Additional district Judge, Athagarh in RFA No.12 of 2024,
which is presently pending consideration for the prayer for
condonation of delay.

1
2019(I) ILR-CUT 659
Page 3 of 10

4. Heard Mr. K.K. Mishra, learned counsel for the
petitioner, Mr. S.N. Patnaik, learned AGA and Mr. Satyabadi
Mantry, learned counsel for the private Opp. Parties.
5. Mr. Mishra would argue that the settlement
authorities lacked jurisdiction to create sikimi tenancy in
favour of the predecessors of the private Opp. Parties
contending that the creation of a parallel Sikimi tenancy
record under Khata No.4-4 without statutory proceedings
under the OLR Act was void ab initio . He further submits that
the part compensation paid by the NHAI for a portion of the
land under Plot No.1568 was fraudulently disbursed to the
private Opp. Parties and their alienees. Hence, the parallel
RoR under Annexure-4 should be quashed and the rightful
proprietary rights of the Sthitiban family be protected.

6. Per Contra, Mr. Mantry would argue that the title
over the suit land has already been decided by the civil court
in Civil Suit No.74 of 2012 holding that the petitioner did not
have the title over the suit land and upheld the rights of the
opp. parties as sikimi tenants. He further submits that
Krushna Chandra Khuntia and Gobinda Khuntia were lawful
Page 4 of 10

sikimi tenants under the recorded landlord/raiyat, Moulabi
Abdul Ahad, and the Settlement Authorities, acting well
within their jurisdiction, recorded their names and prepared
the record of rights under the Sikimi Khata. It is contended
that since the original recorded raiyat never disputed the
sikimi tenancy nor challenged the settlement entry within the
statutory period of limitation before the Board of Revenue or
the Civil Court, the petitioner lacks to challenge
locus standi
the same alone after an inordinate lapse of nearly 62 years.
He further submits that until the said Civil Court judgment is
reversed, it remains fully binding on the parties and cannot
be bypassed through a writ petition to invalidate the finally
published settlement records.
7. Mr. Patnaik would argue on similar lines and
submit that the settlement operations were carried out
lawfully in accordance with the existing revenue records and
the disbursement of the land acquisition compensation was
carried out accordingly. He further submits that since a
competent civil court has already decided the matter on
merits, the revenue entries published in 1963 cannot be
Page 5 of 10

reopened or subjected to collateral challenge through writ
jurisdiction.
8. Having heard both parties at length, it is evident
that the dispute between the parties relates to right, title and
interest over the case land, which has already been decided
in Civil Suit No.74 of 2012 by the Senior Civil Judge,
Athagarh.
9. It is not disputed that the private Opp. Parties
claim title and sikimi rights over the case land on the basis of
the recording in sikimi Khata No.04-4 published in 1963 and
the subsequent sale deeds. The petitioner, on the other hand,
claims title as a successor-in-interest of the original recorded
Sthitiban tenant and assails the original settlement entry as
void ab initio for want of proceedings under the OLR Act and
challenges the consequential disbursement of NHAI
compensation.
10. Perusal of the judgment in the civil suit shows
that learned Civil Judge did not award the title of Khata No.
28 to the petitioner; rather, in respect of the suit land within
Plot Nos.1568 and 1569 out of the three plots comprised in
Page 6 of 10

the khata, the trial court negated the petitioner's claim and
upheld that Gobinda Khuntia and Krushna Chandra Khuntia
(Defendant No.1 in the civil suit) acquired tenancy under
Sikimi Khata No.04-4, thereby attaining raiyati status over
Plot No. 1568, and later made lawful transfer of portions of
the land through valid registered sale deeds being R.S.D. Nos.
1312, 1311, 355, 1105, 659, and 625 to different individuals.
11. As regards the third plot, namely Plot No.1579,
although the trial court recognized the same as the property
of Moulabi Abdul Ahad, it declined to grant any declaratory
relief in respect of the plot on account of non-joinder of the
other legal heirs of the said Moulabi Abdul Ahad.
Furthermore, as the Regular First Appeal remains pending at
the threshold stage of condonation of delay and has not yet
been admitted, the judgment of the Trial Court continues to
remain in full force and effect.
12. As regards the contention that the original
settlement entry creating Sikimi tenancy without statutory
proceedings under the OLR Act is void ab initio , and that the
petitioner came to know of the said parallel record of rights
Page 7 of 10

only upon disbursement of NHAI compensation and filing of
the mutation proceedings in 2024; this court feels that such
a plea is wholly untenable as the record reveals that the
petitioner was a party to Civil Suit No.74 of 2012, wherein the
validity of Sikimi Khata No.4-4 and the transfers flowing
therefrom were adjudicated upon on merits. Having contested
the matter in the civil suit, the petitioner cannot circumvent
the civil adjudication under the guise of an alleged
void ab
initio entry, especially when the legal heritability of such
tenancy stands recognized by judicial precedent.
13. It would be apposite at this stage to refer to the
judgment in the case of Jitendra Singh v. State of Madhya
2
Pradesh and Others , wherein the Supreme Court held the
following: -
“6. It is not in dispute that the dispute is with respect to
mutation entry in the revenue records. The petitioner herein
submitted an application to mutate his name on the basis of
the alleged will dated 20.05.1998 executed by Smt. Ananti
Bai. Even, according to the petitioner also, Smt. Ananti Bai
died on 27.08.2011. From the record, it emerges that the
application before the Nayab Tehsildar was made on
9.8.2011, i.e., before the death of Smt. Ananti Bai. It cannot be
disputed that the right on the basis of the will can be claimed
only after the death of the executant of the will. Even the will
itself has been disputed. Be that as it may, as per the settled

2
2021 SCC OnLine SC 802
Page 8 of 10

proposition of law, mutation entry does not confer any right,
title or interest in favour of the person and the mutation entry
in the revenue record is only for the fiscal purpose. As per the
settled proposition of law, if there is any dispute with respect
to the title and more particularly when the mutation entry is
sought to be made on the basis of the will, the party who is
claiming title/right on the basis of the will has to approach the
appropriate civil court/court and get his rights crystalised and
only thereafter on the basis of the decision before the civil court
necessary mutation entry can be made.”
(Emphasis Added)
14. Thus, in light of the above view, when the title and
ownership of plots in Khata No.28 have already been
adjudicated upon by a competent Civil Court, they can only
be finally settled through the hierarchy of the Civil Courts.
Consequently, the petitioner on his own cannot seek to quash
the record of rights concerning the suit land and the claim of
compensation disbursed by the NHAI, which is dependent
upon the adjudication of the proprietary rights. Thus,
extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution cannot be invoked as a parallel forum to
interfere with subsisting civil court findings or circumvent the
statutory appellate hierarchy.
15. In light of the foregoing discussion, this Court
finds no reason to interfere with the impugned record of
rights. The writ petition is, therefore, dismissed. However, it
Page 9 of 10

is made clear that dismissal of the writ petition shall not
preclude the petitioner from pursuing the available legal
remedies in the pending regular first appeal.

.........................................
( Sashikanta Mishra, J.)









Orissa High Court, Cuttack,
th
The 20 November, 2026/ B.C. Tudu, Sr.Steno

Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHIGAL CHANDRA TUDU
Reason: Authentication
Location: Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Date: 20-Nov-2026 14:30:03
Page 10 of 10