Union Of India And Others vs Col Rohit Parhee And Another

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court



IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH


126

CWP-37007-2026 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 11.11.2026

UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS
...Petitioners



Versus


COL. ROHIT PARHEE NO.IC34353M AND ANOTHER


...Respondents



CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MINDERJEET YADAV


Present: Mr. S.K.Sharma, Senior Panel Counsel
for the petitioners-UOI.





HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI, J. (ORAL)
In the present writ petition, the challenge is to the impugned order
1.
dated 21.11.2023 (Annexure P-1) passed by respondent No.2-Armed Forces
Tribunal, Chandigarh, ( hereinafter referred to as ‘the Tribunal’) in OA
No.1747 of 2020, by which, respondent No.1 has been allowed the benefit of
rounding off the disability element of disability pension @ 50% as against 30%
for life, w.e.f. 01.07.2011 to 31.12.2015, on the ground that the same is
perverse.
GAGANDEEP
2026.11.16 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
High Court, Chandigarh






CWP-3693



38-2026 (O&M) - 2 -
2.
Learned counsel for the petitio
oners places reliance upon the rep
port
of medica
al examination of respondent
No.1 to contend that though
the
disability
of “PRIMARY HYPERTENSION
N” as assessed @ 30% for life a
and
declared a
as ‘aggravated by Military Servic
e’. However, the grant of benefi
it of
rounding o
off of the disability element @ 50
0% as against 30% w.e.f. 01.07.20
011
is incorrec
ct and the said benefit of roundin
ng off could have been granted o
only
w.e.f. 01.
01.2016 in terms of Instructions
s dated 09.02.2018 (Annexure P
P-4)
which fac
ct has not been appreciated in c
correct perspective by the Tribu
unal
while pass
sing the impugned order dated 2
1.11.2023 (Annexure P-1). Furth
her,
learned co
ounsel for the petitioners argue
that there is delay of 09 years
s in
raising the
e claim therefore arrears should be
e restricted to 03 years.
3.
We have heard learned couns
sel for the petitioners and have g
one
through th
he case file with his able assistanc
ce.
4.
It is a conceded fact that at t
the time when respondent No.1 w
was
discharged
d from service on 30.06.2011, he
e had already rendered more than
n 34
years of se
ervice with the petitioners-Union
of India.
5.
With regard to the grievance o
of the petitioners qua grant of ben
nefit
of roundin
ng off of disability element, as pe
er the settled principle of law sett
tled
by Hon’b
le Supreme Court of India in C
Civil Appeal No.418-2012, titled
d as
‘Union of
f India and others vs. Ram Avt
tar’, decided on 10.12.2014, , it
has
been held
that an Armed Forces personnel
l is entitled to be granted the ben
nefit
of roundin
ng off with regard to disability pe
ension, irrespective of the fact that
t he
was invali
idated out of service, or retired on
n attaining the age of superannuat
tion
GAGANDEEP
2026.11.16 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
High Court, Chandigarh






CWP-3693


or on com
38-2026 (O&M) - 3 -
mpletion of his tenure of his engag
gement, if found to be suffering fr
rom
some disa
ability which is attributable or a
aggravated by the Military serv
vice.
Relevant p
paras of the judgment in Ram Avt

tar’s case (supra) are as under:-
“4. By the present se
et of appeals the appellant(s) raise
e
the question, whether
or not, an individual, who has
s
retired on attaining th
he age of superannuation or on
n
completion of his tenur
re of engagement, if found to be
e
suffering from some dis
sability which is attributable to or
r
aggravated by the mi
ilitary service, is entitled to be
e
granted the benefit of r
rounding-off of disability pension.

The appellant(s) herein
would contend that, on the basis
s
of Circular No. 1(2)/97
7/D(Pen-C) issued by the Ministry
y
of Defence, Governmen
nt of India, dated 31.01.2001, the
e
aforesaid benefit is ma
ade available only to an Armed
d
Forces Personnel who
is invalidated out of service, and
d
not to any other categ
gory of Armed Forces Personnel
l
mentioned hereinabove.

5. We have heard l
learned counsel for the parties to
o
the lis.
6. We do not see
e any error in the impugned
d
judgment(s) and order(
(s) and therefore all the appeals
s
which pertain to the
concept of rounding-off of the
e
disability pension are di
ismissed, with no order as to costs.
7. The dismissal of t
these matters will be taken note of
f
by the High Courts as w
well as by the Tribunals in granting
g
appropriate relief to th
he pensioners before them, if any,

who are getting or are e
entitled to the disability pension.”

The Hon’ble Supreme Court
6.
of India in Civil Appeal No.113
311
of 2025 d
decided on 01.09.2025 titled as U
Union of India and others vs. R
Reet
MP Singh
h and another , the grant of bene
efit of rounding off the disability
y as
GAGANDEEP
2026.11.16 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
High Court, Chandigarh






CWP-3693


per Ram
38-2026 (O&M) - 4 -
Avtar’s case (supra) has again
been upheld, which fact has go
one
un-rebutte
ed at the hands of the petitioners
.
7.
The grievance qua restrictin
g the benefit of arrears, it may
y be
noted tha
at the said issue of grant of arre
ears to the army personnel, wh
hich
issue has
been in dispute, has been settled
d by the Hon’ble Supreme Cour
t of
India in a
recently passed judgment in Civ
vil Appeal Nos. 6820-6824 of 20
018
titled as
‘ Union of India through Secr
retary and others vs. SGT Gir
rish
Kumar an
nd others’, decided on 12.02.20
026, whereby the Hon'ble Supre
eme
Court of I
India has held that pensionary en
ntitlements partake the character
r of
property
and same is neither a bounty
nor ex-gratia payment and sa
ame
cannot be
e withheld, reduced or extinguish
hed except by authority of law. T
The
Hon'ble S
Supreme Court of India has fu
urther held that UOI has taken
n a
conscious
s policy decision so as to gran
nt benefit of arrears of disabi
ility
pension to
o all eligible ex-servicemen from
m 01.01.1996 or 01.01.2006 as
the
case may
be, which is clear from para 2 o
of letter dated 15.09.2014 issued
d by
Deputy S
Secretary (Pension), Governme
ent of India and by letter da
ated
10.10.201
18 issued by Director, Departm
ment of Pension and Pension
ner's
Welfare,
wherein also same benefit w
was granted to all eligible fr
rom
01.01.199
96 or 01.01.2006, as the case ma
ay be. The relevant paragraphs N
No.
15 to 21 o
of the judgment in SGT Girish K
Kumar's case (supra) are as unde
er:-
"15. Pension, as authoritati
ively settled by this Court, is
neither a bounty nor an ex gra
atia payment dependent upon the
grace of the State. It is a defer
rred portion of compensation for
past service and, upon fulfilm
ent of the governing conditions,
matures into a vested and
enforceable right. Pensionary
GAGANDEEP
2026.11.16 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
High Court, Chandigarh






CWP-3693


38-2026 (O&M) - 5 -
entitlements, therefore, partake
e the character of property, and
cannot be withheld, reduced
d, or extinguished except by
authority of law. This princip
ple applies with full vigour to
disability pension, which is gr
rounded not merely in length of
service, but in the impairmen
nt suffered by a member of the
Armed Forces in the course of
of, or attributable to, the service
rendered to the nation. The dis
sability pension is not a matter of
largesse, but a recognition of
sacrifice made in service of the
nation.
16. The Union of India, as a
a model employer, is expected to
act with fairness, consistency
y and even-handedness in the
administration of benefits co
onferred upon those who have
served the nation. When a bene
efit is recognised by a policy and
affirmed by judicial pronounce
ement, its application cannot be
selective or uneven. The judgm
ment rendered by a three-Judge
Bench of this Court in Ram
m Avtar’s case (supra) was a
judgment in rem and, therefor
re, the benefit of same ought to
have been extended by Unio
on of India to the eligible ex-
servicemen instead of requ
uiring them to file original
applications before the Tribuna
al seeking their entitlement.
17. It is pertinent to note th
hat the Union of India itself had
taken a conscious policy decis
sion to pay arrears of disability
pension to ‘ D.S. Nakara v Uni
ion of India, 1983 AIR SC 130,
State of Jharkhand & Ors. v.
. Jitendra Kumar Srivastava &
Anr., AIR 2013 SC 3383, Vij
ijay Kumar v. Central Bank of
India & Ors., 2025 INSC 848
8’ all eligible ex-servicemen from
01.01.1996 or 01.01.2006, as t
the case may be. This position is
clearly borne out from par
ragraph 2 of the letter dated
15.09.2014 issued by Deputy S
Secretary (Pension), Government
of India, to Chiefs of Army, N
Navy and Air Force. The similar
intent is also evident from pa
aras 3 and 6 of the letter dated
10.10.2018 issued by Directo
r, Department of Pension and
Pensioner’s Welfare, Governm
ment of India , wherein civilian
GAGANDEEP
2026.11.16 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
High Court, Chandigarh






CWP-3693


38-2026 (O&M) - 6 -
Medical Officers were granted
d revised disability benefit from

01.01.1996 or 01.01.2006.
18. The aforesaid communi
ications reflect a conscious and
deliberate policy choice on the
e part of Union of India to confer
upon all eligible pensioners th
he benefit of arrears of disability
pension with effect from 01.01.
.1996 or 01.01.2006, as the case
may be. In view of decision of t
this Court in Ram Avtar (supra) ,
the Government of India, by
y an order dated 18.04.2016,
expressly conveyed its approva
al to the Chiefs of the Army, Navy
and Air Force for implementa
ation of the directions issued by
the Courts and Tribunals grant
ting the benefit of broad banding
of the disability element to Ar
rmed Forces Personnel who had
retired or were discharged on
completion of engagement with
disability, attributable to or a
aggravated by military service,
from the date specified in the re
espective judicial orders.
19. The order dated 18.04
4.2016 was a conscious policy
determination taken with ful
ll financial concurrence. Thus,
where the State itself, by a
conscious policy decision, has
determined that arrears of disa
ability pension are payable from
a specified cut off date, it is not
t open to it to subsequently resile
and contend that such arrears
ought to be confined to a period
of three years preceding the c
claim. To permit such a course,
would amount to acknowledgi
ing the right in principle while
denying its substantive content
t in effect. Any such deprivation
of accrued arrears which has
become due to ex-servicemen in
view of judicial determination
as well as policy decision taken
by the Union of India itself,
would constitute deprivation of
property and would amount to
infraction of Article 300A of the
Constitution of India.
20. This Court has, in a
consistent line of decisions6,
recognised that right to receive
e disability pension is a valuable
right and once found due, the
e benefit of the same has to be
given from the date it beca
ame due. The same cannot be
GAGANDEEP
2026.11.16 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
High Court, Chandigarh






CWP-3693


38-2026 (O&M) - 7 -
curtailed by restricting K.J.S.
. Bhuttar v. Union of India &
Anr., (supra); Davinder Sing
gh v. Union of India & Ors.
(supra); Madan Prasad Sinh
ha v. Union of India & Ors.,
(supra); Piyush Bahuguna (O
Order dated 25.03.2022 passed in
Diary No.10713/2021) and Bij
ijender Singh v. Union of India
(supra) the benefit to a perio
od of three years preceding the
filing of the original applic
cation. In the absence of any
compelling reason to take
a different view, we find no
justification to depart from the
e view consistently taken by this
Court.
21. The contention advanced
d on behalf of the Union of India
that the claim for arrears of
disability pension is barred by
Limitation Act, cannot be acc
cepted. The issue with regard to
broad banding of disability p
ension attained finality only on
10.12.2014. Thereafter, Union
n of India in the order dated
18.04.2016 addressed to Chief
fs of Army, Navy and Air Force
acknowledged in clear terms t
that arrears of disability pension
were to flow from 01.01.1
996 without any curtailment.
Therefore, in the facts and
circumstances of the case, the
contention that the claims of
f ex-servicemen were barred by
limitation does not deserve acc

ceptance.”

Further with regard to the a
8.
argument of the petitioners qua
the
delay of 0
09 years in raising the claim, it ma
ay be noticed that it is a trite law t
that
pension is
s not a bounty but a continuous
statutory and welfare entitlement
t as
observed b
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court o
of India in Civil Appeal No.4100
0 of
2022 , title
ed as ‘Shri M.L. Patil (Dead) thr
rough LRs Versus The State of G
Goa
and Anr.,
, decided on 20.05.2022 . The r
relevant portion of the judgmen
t is
reproduce
ed as below:-
3. Having heard Shri R
Rahul Gupta, learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the
e appellant and Shri Ravindra
GAGANDEEP
2026.11.16 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
High Court, Chandigarh






CWP-3693


38-2026 (O&M) - 8 -
Lokhande, learned counsel
l appearing on behalf of the
respondent – State of Goa and
d considering the fact that even by
the impugned judgment and or
rder, the High Court has held that
action of the State Govern
nment in requiring the original
petitioners to retire at the ag
ge of 58 years or not permitting
them to continue in their ser
rvice upto the age of 60 years is
illegal and null and void, w
we are of the view that the High
Court has erred in observin
ng that the appellant will not be
entitled to any arrears of pens
sion and the pension at the revised
st
only from 1 January, 2020. As
rates will become payable o
such, the High Court may be
e right and/or justified in denying
any salary for the period
of two extra years to the writ
petitioners if they would ha
ave continued in service, on the
ground of delay. However, as f
far as the pension is concerned, it
is a continuous cause of actio
on. There is no justification at all
for denying the arrears of pe
ension as if they would have been
retired/superannuated at the
e age of 60 years. There is no
justification at all by the High
h Court to deny the pension at the
st
ly from 1 January, 2020. Under
revised rates and payable on
the circumstances, the impugn
ned judgment and order passed by
the High Court is required
to be modified to the aforesaid
extent.
4. In view of the above and
d for the reasons stated above, the
present Appeal Succeeds in P
Part. The impugned judgment and
order passed by the High Co
ourt to the extent of denying any
arrears of pension and hold
ding that the appellant shall be
entitled to the pension at t
the revised rates only from 1st
January, 2020 is hereby quas
shed and set aside. It is held and
ordered that the appellant –
original writ petitioner shall be
entitled to pension at the revi
ised rates from the date he attains
the age of 60 years. Now the
arrears accordingly shall be paid
to the appellant within a pe
eriod of four weeks from today.
GAGANDEEP
2026.11.16 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
High Court, Chandigarh






CWP-3693


38-2026 (O&M) - 9 -
Present Appeal is Partly Allow
wed to the aforesaid extent. In the
e no order as to costs.”
facts of the case, there shall be

9.
Keeping in view the facts and
circumstances of the present case
e as
well as set
ttled principle of law settled, claim
m of respondent No.1 for the ben
nefit
of roundin
ng off of the disability from 30%
to 50% has rightly been allowed
d by
the Tribun
nal from the back date along with
arrears.
10.
No other argument has been
raised. The order is dictated in
the
open Cour
rt in the presence of the learned co
ounsel for the petitioners.
11.
Hence, in the absence of any
y perversity being pointed out in
the
impugned
d order dated 21.11.2023 (Annex
xure P-1) either on the basis of
the
facts or th
he settled principle of law, no gro
und is made out for any interfere
ence
by this Co
ourt in the facts and circumstanc
ces of the present case and the w
writ
petition is
accordingly dismissed.
1 2 .
Pending application(s), if any
y, stands disposed of.




HARSIMRAN SINGH SETHI
(H

I)
JUDGE




(MINDERJEET YADAV)
JUDGE

Novembe
Gagan

W
er 11, 2026

Whether speaking/reasoned Y
Yes
W
Whether reportable N
No

GAGANDEEP
2026.11.16 18:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
High Court, Chandigarh