SMT.SANGEETA W/O SHIVAJI @ SHIVAPPA TILE AND ORS vs SHIVANAND S/O BABU KAVATAGI AND ANR
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
AT KALABURAGI
TH
DATED THIS THE 30 DAY OF NOVERMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R.DEVDAS
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BRUNGESH M
MFA NO.201686 OF 2016 (MV-D)
BETWEEN:
1. SMT. SANGEETA
W/O SHIVAJI SHIVAPPA TILE,
AGE: 37 YEARS,
OCC: H.H. WORK,
2. VIJAY
S/O SHIVAJI SHIVAPPA TILE,
AGE: 15 YEARS,
OCC: STUDENT,
3. SUPRIYA
D/O SHIVAJI @ SHIVAPPA TILE,
AGE: 13 YEARS,
OCC: STUDENT,
4. SNEHAL
D/O SHIVAJI @ SHIVAPPA TILE,
AGE: 11 YEARS,
OCC: STUDENT,
5. AVADHUT
D/O SHIVAJI @ SHIVAPPA TILE,
AGE 10 YEARS,
OCC: STUDENT,
Digitally signed by
BASALINGAPPA S
D
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
APPELLANT NO.2 TO 5 BEING MINORS,
R/BY APPELLANT NO. 1
AS MINOR GUARDIAN
(NATURAL MOTHER)
6. YESUBAI
W/O VITHOBA TILE
AGE: 72 YEARS,
OCC: NIL,
ALL ARE R/O. VALASANG, TQ,
JATH, DIST, SANGLI,
NOW AT C/O L.S. UMARANI,
VAJRA HANUMAN NAGAR,
VIJAYAPUR-586101.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. BABU H. METAGUDDA, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. SHIVANAND
S/O BABU KAVATAGI,
AGE: 30 YEARS,
OCC: AGRICULTURE & BUSINESS,
R/O. A/P, JADAR BABALAD,
TQ: JATH, DIST: SANGLI,
DEAD BY LRS. [DIED ON.14-8-2015]
A) NIRMALA
W/O SHIVANAND KAWATAGI.
OCC: H.H. WORK.
AGE 35 YEARS
B) PRAJWAL
S/O SHIVANAND KAWATAGI.
OCC: STUDENT
AGE 12 YEARS
C) MANJUNATH
S/O SHIVANAND KAWATAGI
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
OCC: STUDENT
AGE 10 YEARS
R/O. A/P, JADAR BABALAD,
TQ: JATH, DIST: SANGLI,
MAHARASHTRA STATE-416404.
2. THE BRANCH MANAGER
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD,
1, FLOOR, BIDARI COMPLEX,
S.S.FRONT ROAD, VIJAYAPUR,
PIN CODE NO. 586101.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI MANVENDRA REDDY, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
V/O DATED 22.09.2025 SERVICE OF NOTICE
TO R1(A) IS HELD SUFFICIENT;
R1(B) AND R1(C) ARE MINOR U/G FOR R1(A))
THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF M.V. ACT
1988, PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE RECORDS IN
M.V.C.NO.812/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE III ADDITIONAL
SESSIONS JUDGE AND M.A.C.T NO.IV VIJAYAPUR AT
VIJAYAPUR AND ALLOW THIS APPEAL AND SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 06.04.2016 PASSED IN
M.V.C.NO.812/2014 BY THE III ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE
AND M.A.C.T. NO.IV VIJAYAPURA AT VIJAYAPUR AND AWARD
THE COMPENSATION OF RS.67,35,000/- WITH 12% INTEREST
AND ETC.,
THIS MFA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
04.08.2026 AND COMING ON FOR PROUNCEMENT OF
JUDGMENT, THIS DAY, THIS COURT DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R.DEVDAS
AND
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BRUNGESH M
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BRUNGESH M)
This appeal is filed by the appellants- Smt. Sangeeta
and five others, questioning the legality and correctness of
th
the judgment dated 6 April, 2016, passed in MVC No.
812 of 2014 by the learned III Additional Sessions Judge
and MACT-IV, Vijayapura (hereinafter referred to as “the
learned Tribunal” for brevity).
2. The present appellants, Smt. Sangeeta and five
others, were the petitioners, whereas the present
respondent Nos.1 and 2 were respondent Nos.1 and 2,
respectively, before the learned Tribunal in MVC No.812 of
2014.
3. For the sake of convenience and clarity, and to
avoid any confusion, the parties are referred to as per
their ranks assigned to them before the learned Tribunal.
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
4. The petitioners claim that petitioner No.1 is the
wife, petitioner Nos.2 to 5 are the children, and petitioner
No.6 is the mother of Shivaji alias Shivappa. The
petitioners contend that Shivaji was killed in a road traffic
th
accident that occurred on 27 July, 2013.
th
5. According to the petitioners, on 27 July, 2013,
Shivaji (hereinafter referred to as “the deceased” for
brevity) was riding a Hero Honda Splendor Pro motorcycle
bearing registration No.MH-10-BE/9670 cautiously and
maintaining proper lane discipline. When the deceased was
riding the motorcycle near Hawaldar Vasti at about 7:45
p.m. on the same day, the driver of the Bajaj Tempo Trax
Cruizer Jeep bearing registration No.MH-13/AC-1186
(hereinafter referred to as “the offending vehicle” for
brevity) drove it in a rash and negligent manner and at
high speed and dashed against the motorcycle being
ridden by the deceased. As a result of the accident, the
deceased was thrown onto the road, sustained grievous
injuries and died on the spot.
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
6. The petitioners also contend that the
postmortem examination of the deceased was conducted
at Rural Hospital, Jath-Maharashtra State. After the
postmortem examination, the dead body of Shivaji was
handed over to them, and they brought it to their native
place to perform the funeral and last rites. They contend
that they spent Rs.15,000/- towards transportation of the
body and Rs.50,000/- towards funeral and obsequies.
7. The petitioners further contend that the
accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of
the offending vehicle by its driver. It is also stated that a
case in connection with the accident was registered at Jath
Police Station in Crime No.25 of 2014.
8. The petitioners contend that at the time of the
accident and his consequent death, the deceased was
aged about 43 years and was serving as a Grama Sevak at
Jath. He was receiving a salary of Rs.31,000/- per month.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
He was also engaged in agriculture and earning
Rs.2,00,000/- per annum from that activity.
9. The petitioners also contend that they were
entirely dependent on the income of the deceased for their
livelihood. They suffered financial loss, apart from mental
pain and agony, because of the untimely death of the sole
earning member of their family. On these and other formal
grounds, they filed MVC No.812 of 2014 seeking
compensation of Rs.67,65,000/-.
10. The petitioners further contend that the first
respondent, Shivanand S/o Babu Kavatagi, was the owner
and the second respondent- Oriental Insurance Company
was the insurer of the offending vehicle. The insurance
policy was in force as on the date of the accident, namely
th
27 July, 2013. Therefore, according to petitioners, both
the respondents were/are jointly and severally liable to
pay the compensation.
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
11. After the presentation of the petition, the same
came to be registered, and notices were issued to the
respondents. The record shows that the first respondent-
Shivanand, despite service of notice issued by the learned
Tribunal, did not enter appearance. Hence, he was placed
ex parte.
12. The record shows that the second respondent-
Oriental Insurance Company entered appearance before
the learned Tribunal and filed written statement,
specifically denying all the factual allegations made by the
petitioners. The second respondent specifically contended
that the vehicle bearing registration No.MH-13/AC-1186
had been falsely implicated in the case and, therefore, the
petition itself was not maintainable. On these and other
formal grounds, the second respondent prayed for
dismissal of the petition.
13. After the completion of the pleadings, the
learned Tribunal framed seven issues for its consideration.
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
Thereafter, the learned Tribunal afforded reasonable
opportunities to the parties to adduce their evidence. The
first petitioner, Smt. Sangeeta wife of Shivaji alias
Shivappa Tile, examined herself as PW1. The petitioners
also examined Abhijit son of Ratanrao Pawar as PW2 and
Dundayya son of Shanmukh Swamy as PW3. The
petitioners got marked 20 documents as Exs.P1 to P20.
Per contra, the second respondent examined its officials,
Sangamesh and Raghuram, as RW1 and RW2,
respectively, and got marked a copy of the insurance
policy as Ex.R1.
14. After the completion of the evidence, the
learned Tribunal heard the arguments of the learned
advocates for the petitioners and the second respondent
th
and passed the impugned judgment on 6 April, 2016. By
the said judgment, the learned Tribunal dismissed the
petition. Aggrieved by the judgment of dismissal, the
petitioners, Smt. Sangeeta and five others, have filed the
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
present Miscellaneous First Appeal, primarily disputing the
conclusion drawn by the learned Tribunal.
15. The learned counsel for the petitioners,
Sri Babu H. Metagudda, would contend that the impugned
judgment passed by the learned Tribunal is contrary to the
probabilities of the case and the materials available on
record and is therefore unsustainable in law. He would
further contend that the learned Tribunal has grossly erred
in concluding that the petitioners are not entitled to
compensation.
16. The learned counsel for the petitioners would
also contend that the learned Tribunal has erroneously
concluded that the jeep bearing registration No.MH-13/AC-
1186 did not cause the accident and the same had been
falsely implicated. According to him, the documents
produced by the petitioners and the evidence of the
eyewitness-PW3-Dundayya are sufficient to accept the
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
petitioners’ case. Therefore, the impugned judgment calls
for interference.
17. The learned counsel for the petitioners would
further contend that the learned Tribunal has erroneously
appreciated the facts of the case, the police records and
the provisions of Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act. He
would also submit that the learned Tribunal has not
appreciated the oral and documentary evidence in the
proper perspective. Consequently, interference by this
Court is warranted. On these and other formal grounds,
learned advocate for the petitioners prayed for allowing
the appeal and awarding compensation to the petitioners.
18. Per contra, the learned advocate for the
Insurance Company, Sri Manvendra Reddy would seek to
justify the judgment passed by the learned Tribunal. He
would contend that the learned Tribunal has properly
appreciated the evidence available on record. He would
further submit that, according to the petitioners, the
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
th
accident occurred on 27 July, 2013, whereas the first
st
information report was lodged on 1 February, 2014,
resulting in a delay of six months and four days. He would
also contend that the evidence available on record is not
trustworthy enough to conclude that the vehicle shown as
the offending vehicle caused the accident.
19. Heard the arguments of the learned advocate
for the petitioners and the learned advocate for
respondent No.2 - Insurance Company. The trial court
record has been secured. This Court perused the entire
materials available on record.
20. In the considered opinion of this Court, before
proceeding to discuss the rival contentions raised by the
parties, it is necessary to refer to certain facts borne out
by the record. According to the petitioners, the accident
th
occurred on 27 July, 2013. This Court finds no reason to
doubt the date of the accident, having regard to the
information available in Ex.P4.
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
21. The Ex.P4 is the inquest panchanama prepared
under Section 174 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. It is
in Marathi language, and Ex P4(a) is its Kannada
translation. A perusal of these documents makes it clear
that the inquest panchanama over the body of Shivappa
th
was conducted on 27 July, 2013 itself.
22. It is necessary to note that Section 174 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure provides that when the officer
in charge of a police station, or another police officer
specially empowered by the State Government, receives
information that a person has committed suicide, or has
been killed by another person, by an animal, machinery or
in an accident, or has died under circumstances raising a
reasonable suspicion that another person has committed
an offence, the officer shall immediately inform the
nearest Executive Magistrate empowered to hold inquest.
Further, Section 174 of Cr.P.C. also makes it clear that
unless otherwise directed by a rule prescribed by the State
Government or by a general or special order of the District
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
or Sub-divisional Magistrate, the police officer shall
proceed to the place where the body is situated. In the
presence of two or more respectable inhabitants of the
neighbourhood, the officer shall investigate and prepare a
report of the apparent cause of death, describing the
wounds, fractures, bruises and other marks of injury found
on the body.
23. The Exs.P4 and Ex.P4(a) show that an inquest
was conducted over the body of Shivappa on the date of
the accident itself. Tukaram Birappa Hukke and Nana
Saheb Vithal Patil are the witnesses who signed the
inquest panchanama. The information recorded in these
documents supports the petitioners’ contention that
th
Shivappa died in a road traffic accident on 27 July, 2013
itself. However, whether the identity of the vehicle
involved was known at that time must be examined with
reference to the specific contents of the documents and
the other evidence available on record.
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
24. The record further shows that the first
st
information was lodged on 1 February, 2014, which is
conspicuously after a lapse of more than six months,
alleging that the accident had been caused by the vehicle
bearing registration No.MH-13/AC-1186. On the basis of
that information, the officers of Jath Police Station
registered the FIR, alleging that the accident occurred
solely due to the negligent driving of Shivanand son of
Babu Kavatagi, who was driving the said offending vehicle
at the time of the accident.
25. This Court has perused the first information
report marked as Ex.P1 which is in Marathi language, and
Ex.P1(a) is its Kannada translation. Ex.P2 is the first
information, commonly referred to as the complaint.
Ex.P2 is also in Marathi, and Ex.P2(a) is its Kannada
translation.
26. A perusal of Exs.P1 and P2 makes it clear that
the first information was not lodged by any of the
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
petitioners herein. It was lodged by Patang Rao Vithal Rao
Ghorpade, who was working as Police Head Constable
No.1029 at Jath Police Station, Sangli District,
Maharashtra.
th
27. It is recited in Exs.P1 and P2 that on 28 July
2013, another Police Head Constable, by name Pujari,
Buckle No.214, handed over the case file in UDR
No.72/2013, registered under Section 174 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, to Patang Rao Vithal Rao Ghorpade for
further investigation.
28. It is further recited that while Patang Rao Vithal
Rao Ghorpade (hereinafter referred to as ‘Ghorpade’ for
th
brevity) was on duty at Jath Police Station on 27 July,
2013, he received a telephone message through Ananda
Chandrakant Pawar, Hawaldar, Jath Police Station. The
message was to the effect that shortly before 8:20 p.m.
that day, near the Hawaldars’ quarters, a Grama Sevak
riding a motorcycle bearing registration No.MH-10/BE-
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
9670 had lost control of the motorcycle, and dashed
against a roadside tree, sustained grievous injuries and
died on the spot.
29. According to the recitals in Exs.P1 and P2, upon
receiving that information, Ghorpade registered the case
under Section 174 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and
deputed Amaldar, Buckle No.1776, to investigate the
matter. Thereafter, the said officer examined the body,
had the inquest panchanama prepared and sent the body
for postmortem examination. The postmortem report
recorded the cause of death as “shock due to head injury”.
30. It is also recited that the police officers
subsequently ascertained the identity of the deceased as
Shivaji alias Shivappa Vithal Tile, aged about 45 years,
resident of Walasanga Village, Jath Taluk, Sangli District.
31. Exs.P1 and P2 further state that a spot mahazar
was conducted at the place of the accident. At that time,
the body of Shivaji alias Shivappa and the motorcycle
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
were found at the spot. The police also recorded the
damage sustained by the motorcycle. Thereafter, the
police recorded the statements of the witnesses, namely
Ananda, Rao Saheb, Vasanta Daya Gude, Smt. Yesubai
Vithoba Tile, Smt. Sangeeta and Krishna.
32. It is important to note that Exs.P1 and P2 recite
that all the witnesses, examined during the investigation,
specifically stated that the deceased Shivaji alias Shivappa
became drowsy while riding his motorcycle, lost control of
it, went to the wrong side of the road and dashed against
a roadside tree, sustaining grievous injuries. It is also
recited in Exs.P1 and P2 that all the witnesses stated that
Shivappa alias Shivaji succumbed to the injuries on the
spot.
33. It is equally important to note that Exs.P1 and
P2 state that the police, thereafter , received an objection
application alleging that the accident, in which Shivaji alias
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
Shivappa lost his life, had been caused by the Cruiser
vehicle bearing registration No.MH-13/AC-1186.
34. According to the recitals in Exs.P1 and P2, the
police, thereafter, summoned the owner of the Cruiser
vehicle namely Shivanand S/o Babu Kavatagi. On inquiry,
th
said Shivanand stated that on 27 July, 2013, he and his
friend Swamy were travelling in the said vehicle from
Karada towards Jath.
35. Shivanand S/o Babu Kavatagi is further quoted
as saying that he was driving the vehicle at the relevant
time. When he reached near Hawaldar Quarters, Jath, a
motorcyclist was approaching from the opposite direction
and had moved his motorcycle towards the eastern side of
the road. At the same time, a heavy transport vehicle
approached from the opposite direction. According to
Shivanand S/o Babu Kavatagi, he could not see the
vehicles plying on the road clearly because of the bright
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
headlights of that vehicle and consequently dashed his
Cruiser vehicle against the motorcycle.
36. He is also quoted as stating that, because of the
impact, the motorcyclist lost control of the motorcycle,
dashed against a roadside tree and was thrown onto the
road. Thereafter, Shivanand stopped his Cruiser vehicle,
got down and went to see the condition of the
motorcyclist. On noticing that the deceased was bleeding
profusely from his head, Shivanand panicked and sped
away from the spot in his Cruiser vehicle.
37. It is further narrated in Exs.P1 and P2 that
Shivanand S/o Babu Kavatagi stated that on the following
day, he came to know that the injured motorcyclist was
Shivaji Vitoba Tile, aged about 45 years, a resident of
Walasanga.
38. According to Exs.P1 and P2, after recording the
statement of Shivanand S/o Babu Kavatagi, the police also
examined his friend, Dundayya Shanmukh Swamy, a
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
resident of Achakanahalli, Jath Taluk, who was an
occupant of the Cruiser vehicle at the relevant time.
Dundayya Shanmukh Swamy confirmed the version given
by said Shivanand S/o Babu Kavatagi. On the basis of
these allegations, the police registered a case against
Shivanand Babu Kavatagi and proceeded with the
investigation.
39. Further, the record shows that Ex.P12 is the
charge sheet, or final report. Ex.P12 is also in Marathi, and
Ex.P12(a) is its Kannada translation. The charge sheet
contains allegations similar to those recorded in Exs.P1
and P2. The police ultimately filed the charge sheet
against Shivanand S/o Babu Kavatagi, alleging that he was
responsible for the accident in which Shivaji alias Shivappa
was killed. It is relevant to note that Shivanand S/o Babu
Kavatagi was arrayed as respondent No.1 in MVC No.812
of 2014.
40. A perusal of Exs.P1, P2 and P12 may initially
create an impression that the Cruiser vehicle bearing
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
registration No.MH-13/AC-1186, shown as the offending
vehicle, caused the accident. However, a deeper scrutiny
of these materials does not justify that conclusion. The
reasons are as follows.
41. It is necessary to recollect that in Exs.P1 and
P2, said Ghorpade has referred to the statements of
various witnesses, including Sangeeta, the wife of the
deceased, who is the first petitioner in MVC No.812 of
2014. According to the recitals, all those witnesses stated
that Shivaji alias Shivappa became drowsy while riding his
motorcycle and hence the accident had taken place.
42. According to the recitals in Exs.P1 and P2, all
those witnesses stated that Shivaji alias Shivappa became
drowsy while riding his motorcycle and dashed against a
roadside tree. However, Exs.P1 and P2 - the first
information report and the complaint recite that an
objection application was received by the Police alleging
that the accident had been caused by the Cruiser vehicle
bearing registration No.MH-13/AC-1186.
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
43. It is important to note that the identity of the
person who furnished that information is not disclosed
either in Ex.P1 or in Ex.P2. This creates a serious doubt
about the petitioners’ allegation that the accident occurred
due to the rash and negligent driving of the said vehicle by
its driver. However, this Court is conscious that it would be
premature to draw any conclusion on this basis alone. The
entire materials available on record must be examined
before arriving at any conclusion.
44. This Court therefore proceeds to discuss the
oral evidence available on record. As stated above, the
first petitioner, Smt. Sangeeta, who is the wife of the
deceased Shivaji, examined herself as PW1. She filed her
affidavit under Order XVIII Rule 4 of the Code of Civil
Procedure in lieu of her examination-in-chief.
45. In her affidavit, PW1 has not disclosed who
submitted the application alleging that the accident had
been caused by the driver of the vehicle shown as the
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
offending vehicle in MVC No.812 of 2014. During her
cross-examination by the second respondent - the
Insurance Company, PW1 unequivocally admitted that she
came to know about the accident through others. She
further stated that her brother-in-law by name, Krishna,
informed her about the accident. Thus, she was not an
eyewitness to the accident.
46. The record shows that Smt. Sangeeta filed her
th
affidavit on 19 February, 2015 and that her cross-
th
examination was completed on 7 March, 2015.
st
Thereafter, on 21 August 2015, she filed another affidavit
in lieu of her further examination-in-chief. Even in the
subsequent affidavit also, she did not disclose who
informed the police about the involvement of the vehicle
bearing registration No.MH-13/AC-1186 in the accident.
The second affidavit appears to concern only her residence
within Vijayapura District. Her evidence does not establish
that she furnished the information alleging the
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
involvement of the said vehicle bearing registration
No.MH-13/AC-1186.
47. The record further shows that the petitioners
examined Abhijit Pawar son of Ratanrao, working as a
Junior Clerk in Panchayat Samiti, Jath, as PW2. His
evidence concerns the salary and perquisites received by
Shivappa alias Shivaji while working as a Grama Sevak.
48. PW2 has not stated that he witnessed the
accident or submitted an objection application to the police
requesting action against the driver of the offending
vehicle. Consequently, his evidence does not assist the
petitioners in establishing the involvement of the alleged
offending vehicle in the accident in which Shivappa alias
Shivaji lost his life.
49. This Court now proceeds to discuss the
evidence of PW3. Dundayya son of Shanmukha Swamy,
has been examined as PW3. He has also filed his affidavit
under Order XVIII Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure in
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
lieu of his examination-in-chief. In the said affidavit, PW3
has supported the petitioners’ case.
50. It is necessary to recollect that Exs.P1 and P2-
the first information report and the complaint refer to
Dundayya son of Shanmukha Swamy. It is recited therein
that when the owner of the offending vehicle - Shivanand
son of Babu Kavatagi - was summoned by the police,
Dundayya accompanied him. It is further recited that after
Shivanand Kavatagi narrated the details of the accident,
Dundayya confirmed the explanation given by Shivanand.
51. In his affidavit filed in lieu of his examination-
in-chief, PW3 claims to have witnessed the accident. He
th
specifically testifies that on 27 July, 2013, he was an
occupant of the Cruiser vehicle bearing registration
No.MH-13/AC-1186, along with its driver-cum-owner,
Shivanand Kavatagi.
52. PW3 further testifies that while they were
proceeding in Jath - Satara road, a motorcycle bearing
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
registration No.MH-10/BE-9670 approached from the
opposite direction. According to him, the driver of the
Cruiser vehicle drove it in a rash and negligent manner
and at high speed and dashed against the motorcycle,
causing the accident.
53. PW3 also testifies that because of the impact,
the rider lost control of the motorcycle and dashed against
a roadside tree. As a result, the rider sustained severe
injuries to his head and other parts of the body and died
on the spot.
54. According to PW3, the driver of the Cruiser
vehicle panicked and fled from the spot in the offending
vehicle. PW3 further states that when the vehicle reached
near his village, he got down and went home. He also
testifies that he subsequently informed the relatives of the
deceased about the accident. Thus, PW3 has supported
the petitioners’ case.
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
55. Nevertheless, the question of when PW3
informed the relatives of the deceased about the accident
assumes significance. During his cross-examination, at
page No.4 of his deposition, PW3-Dundayya states that
four or five days after the accident, he informed the
deceased’s cousin, Krishna Shivappa Tile, about the
accident. Thus, according to PW3, he informed one of the
relatives of deceased within a week of the accident.
56. It is necessary to note that PW1-Smt. Sangeeta
states during her cross-examination, at page No.4 of her
deposition, that she came to know about the accident
through her brother-in-law, Krishna. Read together, these
statements indicate that PW3 informed Krishna about the
accident and that Krishna was also the person who
informed PW1 about the accident.
57. However, this Court is conscious that, according
to PW1, Krishna informed her about the accident on the
very day it occurred. After receiving that information, she
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
went to Jath Government Hospital on the same day and
saw her husband’s dead body.
58. Thus, Krishna’s knowledge of the accident on
the date of its occurrence must be distinguished from the
information that PW3 claims to have given him four or five
days later regarding the involvement of the Cruiser
vehicle. According to PW3’s version, Krishna came to know
about the involvement of that offending vehicle within a
week of the accident.
59. Krishna, who had informed PW1 about the
accident on the day it occurred, had the opportunity to
convey to her the further information received from PW3
regarding the involvement of the Cruiser vehicle in the
accident. However, the first information was lodged by
Ghorpade, the Head Constable serving at Jath Police
Station, rather than by any of the petitioners.
Nevertheless, this Court is conscious that undue
importance should not be attached merely to the identity
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
of the person who brought the information to the notice of
the police.
60. It is well settled that any person can set the
criminal law into motion. Therefore, much importance
should not be attached to the question of who brought the
information to the notice of the police. However, in the
considered opinion of this Court, when Krishna was able to
inform the first petitioner, Smt. Sangeeta, about the
occurrence of the accident, nothing prevented him from
also conveying to her the information subsequently
received from PW3.
61. PW1 does not state that, after the accident and
the consequent death of her husband-Shivaji alias
Shivappa, said Krishna developed any hostility towards the
petitioners and therefore withheld that information. In the
absence of any such explanation, his conduct assumes
significance.
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
62. The position would have been different if
Shivappa had survived the accident with severe injuries
and had been admitted to a hospital. In such
circumstances, the petitioners’ immediate priority would
naturally have been to secure the best possible treatment
to save his life. A delay in furnishing information to the
police could then have been considered in that
background. However, no such circumstances exist here,
as Shivappa alias Shivaji died on the spot itself. These
circumstances create a serious doubt about the
petitioners’ version.
63. At the cost of repetition, it must be stated that
none of the petitioners lodged a complaint alleging that
the vehicle bearing registration No.MH-13/AC-1186 caused
the accident resulting in Shivappa’s death. The FIR under
Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure was
registered on the information furnished by the Head
Constable serving at Jath Police Station.
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
64. It is also necessary to recollect that an
unnatural death report was initially registered upon receipt
of information about Shivappa’s death. The matter
remained as such until the police subsequently registered
a regular criminal case under Section 154 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure. These circumstances assume
importance while considering the petitioners’ allegation
that the vehicle bearing registration No.MH-13/AC-1186
caused the accident in which Shivappa alias Shivaji lost his
life.
65. The record shows that during the pendency of
this appeal, the petitioners filed an application seeking
permission to examine said Ghorpade, the police officer
who furnished the information on which the criminal case
was registered, and the first respondent- Shivanand son of
Babu Kavatagi.
th
66. By order dated 8 January, 2026, this Court
permitted the petitioners to examine those witnesses and
directed the office to transmit the entire record to the
- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
learned Tribunal for the limited purpose of recording their
evidence. The learned Tribunal was directed to return the
record to this Court after recording the evidence of
Shivanand son of Babu Kavatagi and Patang Rao son of
Vittal Rao Ghorpade.
th
67. However, on 29 January, 2026,
Sri Panchakshari son of Sangayya Vastrad, the learned
advocate representing the petitioners before the learned
Tribunal, filed a memo stating that both witnesses had
died long before this Court granted permission to examine
them. Consequently, the petitioners were unable to
examine those witnesses.
68. In the considered opinion of this Court,
examination of Shivanand Kavatagi and Patang Rao
Ghorpade, during the proceedings before the learned
Tribunal, could have clarified the circumstances in which
the offending vehicle came to be implicated. However, for
reasons best known to them, the petitioners did not make
- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
such efforts at that stage. This omission, considered along
with the other circumstances discussed above, creates a
serious doubt about their version.
69. For the foregoing reasons, this Court does not
find any material warranting a different view from that
taken by the learned Tribunal.
70. However, the petitioners have also produced an
th
accident report form dated 25 February, 2014. This
report shows that the vehicle alleged to be the offending
vehicle, bearing registration No.MH-13/AC-1186, and the
motorcycle bearing registration No.MH-10/BE-9670 were
subjected to motor vehicle inspection. The said report-
Ex.P7 states that the accident was not due to any
mechanical defect in either vehicle. It is relevant to note
th
that the accident occurred on 27 July, 2013, whereas the
th
vehicles were inspected on 25 February, 2014. Thus,
there was a gap of almost seven months between the
accident and the inspection. In these circumstances,
- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
Ex.P7 does not materially assist in establishing the
involvement of the alleged offending vehicle.
71. Ex.P8 is the registration certificate of the
alleged offending vehicle, standing in the name of
Shivanand son of Babu Kavatagi. Ex.P9 is his driving
licence. Ex.P10 is the driving licence of the deceased
Shivappa alias Shivaji, and Ex.P11 is Shivappa’s SSLC
marks card. In the considered opinion of this Court, these
documents do not throw any light on the principal
controversy in this case. Therefore, a detailed discussion
of these documents is unnecessary.
72. The aforesaid facts and circumstances create a
serious doubt about the petitioners’ case. However, it
would not be appropriate to arrive at a final conclusion
without examining the authorities relied upon by the
petitioners.
73. The petitioners have relied upon the judgment
in Saroj and Others v. Het Lal and Others reported in
- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
2011 Kant. MAC 247 (SC) . In that case, the legal
representatives of the deceased Joginder Singh challenged
the dismissal of their claim petition by the Tribunal, which
had been affirmed by the High Court. The Courts below
had treated the accident as a hit-and-run case involving
an unidentified vehicle.
74. The Hon’ble Apex Court noticed that the owner
had expressly admitted in his written statement that his
vehicle was involved in the accident. It held that the
Courts below had erred in ignoring that material
admission. Accordingly, the judgments were set aside, and
the matter was remanded to the Tribunal for
determination of liability for compensation.
75. There can be no dispute regarding the principle
laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court, which this Court
respectfully follows. The question, however, is whether
that principle assists the petitioners in the present case. In
Saroj’s case, the involvement of the vehicle was expressly
- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
admitted in the owner’s written statement. In the present
case, the first respondent remained ex parte, and there is
no such admission on his part. For the reasons discussed
above, the petitioners have failed to establish the
involvement of the vehicle bearing registration
No.MH-13/AC-1186. Therefore, the said decision does not
assist them on the facts of this case.
76. Further, the learned counsel for the petitioners
relies upon the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Ranjeet and Another v. Abdul Kayam Neb and
Another , arising out of SLP (C) No.10351 of 2019,
th
decided on 25 February, 2025. At paragraph-4, the
Hon’ble Apex Court held as follows:
“4. It is settled in law that once a charge
sheet has been filed and the driver has
been held negligent, no further evidence is
required to prove that the bus was being
negligently driven by the bus driver. Even if
the eye-witnesses are not examined, that
will not be fatal to prove the death of the
- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
deceased due to negligence of the bus
driver.”
77. This Court respectfully follows the principle laid
down by the Hon’ble Apex Court. In the present case, it is
true that the police have filed a charge sheet against
Shivanand son of Babu Kavatagi, the driver of the vehicle
shown as the offending vehicle who is the first respondent
herein.
78. However, the Insurance Company’s defence is
not confined to disputing the negligence of the driver. It
disputes the very involvement of the alleged offending
vehicle in the accident. As discussed in the preceding
paragraphs of this judgment, this Court has examined the
oral and documentary evidence and found it insufficient to
establish the petitioners’ allegation regarding the
involvement of that vehicle in the accident in which
Shivappa alias Shivaji lost his life.
- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
79. In Ranjeet’s case, compensation had been
refused because the eyewitnesses were not examined,
despite the filing of a charge sheet against the bus driver.
The present case does not turn merely on the absence of
eyewitness testimony. PW3, who claims to have witnessed
the accident, has been examined, and his evidence has
been considered along with the contemporaneous records
and the other material available on record.
80. The distinction therefore rests on the evidence
and circumstances of the present case, and not merely on
the Insurance Company’s denial of the vehicle’s
involvement. For the reasons already discussed, the
charge sheet, considered along with the entire evidence,
does not persuade this Court to accept the petitioners’
version. Accordingly, the decision relied upon does not
assist the petitioners on the facts of this case.
81. This Court therefore finds no reason to take a
different view from that taken by the learned Tribunal. The
- 40 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:122-DB
MFA No. 201686 of 2016
CNR: KAHC030037982016
points framed for consideration are answered accordingly,
and this Court proceeds to pass the following:
ORDER
i) The appeal filed by the
appellants/petitioners is dismissed .
th
ii) The judgment dated 6 April, 2016,
passed by the learned III Addl.
Sessions Judge and MACT-IV,
Vijayapur, in MVC No.812 of 2014, is
confirmed.
Sd/-
(R.DEVDAS)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(BRUNGESH M)
JUDGE
BL