Namdev Singh Alias Kala vs State Of Haryana

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court


1
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH

CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)
Reserved on : 31.08.2026
Pronounced on :17.11.2026

Namdev Singh @Kala
..... Appellant


VERSUS
State of Haryana
..... Respondent
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SURYA PARTAP SINGH

Argued by : Mr.Kanisth Ganeriwala, Advocate
for the appellant.

Ms. Deepali Verma, Asstt. A.G. Haryana.

*

SURYA PARTAP SINGH, J.


This is appeal against conviction.
2. It has been preferred by the appellant/ convict-Namdev Singh
@Kala, who has been held guilty for the commission of offence punishable
under Section 15/16 of the ‘Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances
Act’, hereinafter being referred to as ‘NDPS Act’. The above-named
appellant/convict, hereinafter being referred to as ‘appellant’ only, is
aggrieved of the judgment of conviction dated 30.08.2004, hereinafter being
referred to as ‘impugned judgment’ only, and also the order on the point of
quantum of sentence dated 31.08.2004, hereinafter being referred to as
‘impugned order’ only.
3. The abovementioned verdict was pronounced in a trial,
pertaining to FIR No.76 dated 30.04.2002, Police Station Sadar Dabwali,
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


2
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

Sirsa, for the commission of offence under Section 15 of NDPS Act. By
virtue of impugned order, following sentences were awarded to the
appellant:-

Offence under
Section

Sentence


Rigorous imprisonment for a period of ten years and to
15 of NDPS Act pay a fine of Rs.1,00,000/-. In default thereof to
undergo for the imprisonment (rigorous) for a period of
two years.

4. Briefly stating the facts emerging from record are that the FIR
of this case came into being at the instance of ‘ASI Gurmit Singh’, who
reported that on the intervening night of 29/30 April 2002, he along with
other police officials was on patrolling duty near ‘Monga Filling Station’ at
Sangria Bypass Village Chautala. As per above-named police officer the
police team was manning a check post in that area, where ‘Gulshan Kumar’,
an independent witness, came. According to above-named police officer, in
the presence of ‘Gulshan Kumar’, an unregistered jeep was found to be
approaching the barricade, and to which a signal was given in a usual
manner for the purpose of routine checking. The above-named police officer
further reported that in response to when the signal, given to stop the car the
driver and the person, sitting behind him, jumped out of the jeep and fled
from the spot. As per above-named police officer, when search of the jeep
was conducted, it was found that in the above-mentioned jeep, there were 12
bags, each containing 35 kg of poppy husk.
5. It was a case of the prosecution that pursuant to recovery of
abovementioned contraband, necessary formalities with regard to seizure &
sealing of contraband, lodging of FIR, and formal arrest of the accused were
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


3
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

completed, and further investigation taken up. According to prosecution,
during the course of investigation, the Investigating Officer inspected the
spot, prepared rough site plan of the place of recovery, and completed usual
formalities of investigation. Thereafter, the final report under Section 173 of
CrPC was filed.
6. To discharge its burden, of proving charges against the
appellant, the prosecution in the instant case had relied upon documentary as
well as oral evidence. The documents proved and marked with exhibits, by
the prosecution were:-
Ex.PA - Seizure memo of the driving licence
No.83206/SSA, residue parcels and
sample parcels.
Ex.PB - Report under Section 57 of NDPS Act.
Ex.PB/1 - Endorsement recorded on the report
Ex.PB
Ex.PC - The information-memo sent to the police

station ( ruqqa )
Ex.PC/1 - Copy of First Information Report

Ex.PD - Rough site plan of the place of recovery
of contraband, with marginal notes
Ex.PE - FSL Report
Ex.PF - Affidavit of ‘MHC Ram Kumar’
Ex.PG - Affidavit of ‘Constable Shankar Lal’
Ex.PH - Statement by ‘Gulshan Kumar’ recorded
by police
Ex. PJ - Statement by ‘Rajesh Kumar’ recorded
by police

7. To provide support and corroboration to the above-mentioned
documentary evidence, as many as eight witnesses were examined by the
prosecution. They were:-
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


4
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

PW-1 - DSP Chander Singh
PW-2 - SI Rajbir Singh
PW-3 - ASI Ratan Singh
PW-4 - ASI Gurmit Singh
PW-5 - MHC Ram Kumar
PW-6 - Constable Shankar Lal
PW-7 - Gulshan Kumar
PW-8 - Rajesh Kumar

8. Once the prosecution evidence had been recorded, the learned
trial Court completed all the formalities, prescribed under Section 313 CrPC.
Thereafter, opportunity of defence evidence was afforded to the appellant. In
his defence evidence, the appellant examined only three witness. They
were:-
DW-1 - Kashmiri Lal
DW-2 - Constable Ram Dhari
DW-3 - S.K. Sangwan, Director, FSL

9. When evidence of both the parties was over, the learned trial
Court gave opportunity to the learned public prosecutor and the learned
counsel for the appellant to address arguments. Thereafter, a judgment of
conviction, against the appellant, was pronounced. Accordingly, the
appellant was sentenced to undergo imprisonment, as detailed hereinbefore.
10. Heard.
11. It has been contended on behalf of appellant that the impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence, passed by the learned trial
Court were perverse and unsustainable. According to learned counsel for the
appellant, merely on the basis of conjectures and surmises, the unreliable
and self-contradictory evidence adduced by the prosecution was believed by
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


5
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

the learned trial Court. As per learned counsel for the appellant, the learned
trial Court failed to apply judicious mind to the facts of the case, and merely,
on the basis of conjectures and surmises, the finding of conviction of
appellant, for the commission of offence under Section 15 of NDPS Act,
was recorded.
12. The learned counsel for the appellant has further contended that
instant case was a case of no evidence, whatsoever, against the appellant,
and that an error of judgment was committed by the learned trial Court in
appreciation of prosecution evidence. According to learned counsel for the
appellant, there was no evidence to prove, even prima facie , that it was the
appellant, who was travelling in the jeep at the time of alleged recovery of
contraband or that he was in conscious possession thereof. With regard to
above, the learned counsel for the appellant has contended that any reliable
witness, who was present on the spot at the time of alleged recovery, was not
examined to prove that the appellant was travelling in the same car, in which
the contraband was allegedly recovered. As per learned counsel for the
appellant, merely, on the basis of assumptions and presumptions, the learned
trial Court observed that charge of being in possession of 420 kg of
contraband, being transported in the jeep, had been successfully proved by
the prosecution.
13. The learned counsel for the appellant has also contended that in
the present case, the case set-out by the prosecution itself showed that an
independent witness was joined at the time of recovery of contraband, but
the abovementioned witness did not support the prosecution case and
therefore, he was declared hostile. As per learned counsel for the appellant,
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


6
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

the same person had appeared in the witness-box as PW-7 and testified that
nothing was recovered in his presence from the possession of appellant.
According to learned counsel for the appellant, in fact the deposition of PW-
7, who stated that neither any vehicle was checked nor any contraband was
recovered in his presence, demolished the very foundation of the prosecution
case.
14. It has also been contended by learned counsel for the appellant
that even the PW-8, namely ‘Gulshan Kumar’, who had identified the
appellant, (examined during the course of trial), did not support prosecution
case. It has also been contended by learned counsel for the appellant that
identity of the appellant was otherwise doubtful in view of the fact that he
was not apprehended on the spot, and that name of the appellant as the
accused was later-on added due to extra-judicial confession. In view of
above, the learned counsel for the appellant has contended that there were
very serious issues with regard to identity of the appellant as one of the
occupants of the vehicle, wherein the contraband was allegedly being
transported.
15. As per learned counsel for the appellant, despite
abovementioned contradictions, discrepancies and shortcomings in the
prosecution evidence, merely, on the basis of whims and fences, the learned
trial Court believed the prosecution story and therefore, there is immediate
need for interference and indulgence in the finding of conviction, recorded
by the learned trial Court. In support of his arguments, the learned counsel
for the appellant has relied upon the principles of law propounded by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of ‘P. Sasikumar Vs State’ 2024
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


7
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

8 SCC 600, ‘Nazim Vs State of Uttarakhand’ 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2117,
‘Makhan Singh Vs State of Haryana’2015(12) SCC 247, ‘Khekh Ram Vs
State of Himachal Pradesh’ (2018) 1 SC 202, ‘Bothi Lal Vs Intelligence
Officer, NCB’ 2023 SCC 498, ‘Simranjit Singh Vs State of Punjab’ 2024
(14) SCC 222, ‘Mangilal Vs State of Madhya Pradesh’ 2023 (19) SCC 364,
‘Yusuf @Asif Vs State’ 2024 (14) SCC 217 and ‘Surepally Srinivas Vs
State of Andhra Pradesh’ 2025 SCC 683.
16. The learned counsel for the respondent/State has controverted
the abovementioned arguments. It has been contended by learned counsel for
the respondent/State that instant case was a well-proved case, wherein each
and every component, supposed to bring home guilt of the appellant, was
duly proved by the prosecution, and that on proper appreciation of evidence,
and the relevant law, a right conclusion was drawn by the learned trial Court.
According to learned counsel for the respondent/State, there was no
illegality or perversity in the finding of conviction, recorded by the learned
trial Court against the appellant. In view of abovementioned arguments, the
learned counsel for the respondent/State has contended that there is no scope
for indulgence or interference in the finding of conviction, recorded by the
learned trial Court. As per learned counsel for the respondent/State, the
present appeal is devoid of merits and deserves dismissal.
17. The record has been perused carefully.
18. In order to prove the story, set-out by the prosecution in its final
report under Section 173 CrPC, the prosecution had relied upon the
evidence, which comprised of the testimonies of eight official witnesses.
Amongst them, PW-1 was DSP Dabwali Chander Singh. The PW-1 had
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


8
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

supported the prosecution case by deposing that on 30.04.2002, while posted
as DSP Dabwali he had received the wireless message from ‘ASI Gurmit
Singh’ at around 12:15 A.M. According to PW-1, in response to
abovementioned message, he visited the spot, within the area of Village
Chautala. As per PW-1, when he reached the spot, he found that a police
party headed by ‘ASI Gurmit Singh’ had seized one jeep without number
plate. The PW-1 further testified that on his instructions, search of the 12
bags, being carried in the jeep, was conducted. As per PW-1, 12 bags were
there in the abovementioned jeep, and that in each bag, there was 35 kg of
poppy husk. The PW-1 supported the prosecution case with regard to the
fact that samples were extracted from the abovementioned gunny bags in his
presence.
19. The next witness examined by the prosecution was ‘SI Rajbir
Singh’. He was examined as PW-2. The PW-2 had testified that on
30.04.2002 ‘ASI Gurmit Singh’ had produced the case property and report
under Section 57 of NDPS Act before him. As per PW-2 later on ASI
Gurmit Singh deposited the same with MHC of the Police Station.
20. The next witness, examined by the prosecution, was ‘ASI Ratan
Singh’. He was examined as PW-3. The PW-3, too, was an official witness,
who deposed that on 29.04.2002, an unregistered jeep was seen coming from
Sangria side and was signalled to stop. When the jeep was halted at some
distance, the appellant and his co-accused fled away from the spot. The PW-
3 by reproducing the same chain of events, supported the prosecution case in
all material particulars.
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


9
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

21. The next witness examined by the prosecution was ‘ASI Gurmit
Singh’. He was examined as PW-4. The PW-4 was the most material
witness, being head of the police team, which recovered the contraband. The
PW-4, in his examination-in-chief, thoroughly supported the prosecution
case by reproducing the allegations, which were identical to the contents of
final report under Section 173 CrPC and the FIR. It was specifically deposed
by the PW-4 in his examination that on signal to stop, the jeep was stopped
by its driver at some distance. As per PW-4, the appellant and his co-accused
had managed to flee from the spot. Rest of the story, deposed by PW-4, too,
was identical to the contents of the FIR.
22. The next witnesses, examined by the prosecution were ‘MHC
Ram Kumar’ and ‘Ct. Shankar Lal’. They were examined as PW-5 and PW-
6, respectively. The PW-5 and PW-6 had supported the prosecution case, in
their respective examination-in-chief, which were recorded vide their
affidavits, Ex.PF and Ex.PG, respectively. Bothe of them had deposed that
the case property was deposited with the PW-5 in the store room ( Malkhana )
of the police station, and that the samples were delivered to the chemical
examiner.
23. The next witness, examined by the prosecution, was ‘Gulshan
Kumar’. He was examined as PW-7. The PW-7 was the most material
independent witness of recovery. As per prosecution the PW-7 was witness
being on the spot when the contraband was recovered. However, the PW-7
did not support the prosecution case and he resiled from his previous
statement. The PW-7 was declared hostile by the learned Public Prosecutor
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


10
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

and thereafter he was thoroughly cross-examined. But nothing significant
was extracted during the course of cross-examination of PW-7.
24. Another witness examined by prosecution was PW-8 ‘Rajesh
Kumar’. The PW-8, in his examination-in-chief, did not support the
prosecution case by deposing that none of the accused suffered confessional
statement in his presence. Like PW-7, the PW-8, too, was declared hostile
by the learned Public Prosecutor but his cross-examination, too, failed to
produce any favourable result for the prosecution case.
25. Since in the present case, the basic issue raised by the learned
counsel for the appellant was with regard to identity of the appellant, first of
all it has to be determined as to whether with the help of abovementioned
evidence, the prosecution had been successful in proving that it was the
appellant, who was travelling in the vehicle from which the contraband was
recovered.
26. Qua abovementioned aspect, except the testimony of PW-4,
there was no evidence on record. The deposition of PW-4 with regard to
identity of the appellant, without corroboration from independent witness,
was not reliable, particularly in view of the fact that being Investigating
Officer of the case, the PW-4 was an interested witness.
27. In order to provide support and corroboration to the
abovementioned testimony of the Investigating Officer (PW-4), an
independent witness was examined by the prosecution as PW-7. But the
PW-7 resiled from his previous statement and testified that he was not
present on the spot when the vehicle was stopped and the appellant fled from
the spot. Although in the present case, another independent witness was
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


11
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

examined by the prosecution as PW-8, but PW-8 himself deposed that none
of the accused suffered confessional statement in his presence.
28. In view of the fact that any of the two independent witnesses
had not supported the prosecution case with regard to identity of the
appellant, the identity of accused as carrier of the contraband was rendered
wholly doubtful.
29. As far as the facts and circumstances of the present case were
concerned a careful evaluation of the evidence adduced by the prosecution
would go to show various factors, which were relevant in the present case.
Those factors were:-

i. Credibility of the prosecution evidence with regard to recovery
of contraband from the conscious possession of appellant;

ii. Identification of the appellant as a passenger in the vehicle
being used for transportation of contraband;

iii. Non-compliance of mandatory provisions prescribed under the
law for the safeguard of valuable rights of the accused.
Point No.I
30. With regard to first component the story set-out by the
prosecution was that recovery of contraband had taken place in the presence
of police officials and one witness, and that the contraband being transported
in a jeep was checked in the presence of one Senior Police officer, i.e. the
then DSP Dabwali. The above-said witnesses, i.e. witnesses of recovery
were examined by the prosecution as PW-1, PW-3, PW-4 and PW-7.
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


12
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

Amongst the above-mentioned four prosecution witnesses, the PW-7 was the
most crucial witness as the prosecution had projected that PW-7 was the
witness of recovery. However, the PW-7 in his examination-in-chief itself
did not support the prosecution case. Rather the PW-7 took a stand that any
incident of recovery of contraband, as reported by the prosecution, had not
taken place in his presence. Since the PW-7 did not support the prosecution
case with regard to recovery of contraband, in my considered opinion his
above-mentioned deposition caused a significant damage to the credibility of
prosecution story with regard to recovery of contraband from the jeep,
wherein appellant was travelling.
31. As far as the testimonies of official witnesses were concerned,
qua them it was relevant that the PW-1, PW-3 and PW-4 being police
officials were duty bound to support the prosecution case during the course
of their respective examination-in-chief. All three of them testified that
recovery of contraband had taken place in the manner detailed in the final
report under Section 173 Cr.P.C,
32. However, in order to evaluate the credibility of the depositions
of above-named three police officials their cross-examinations was very
much relevant. A perusal of cross-examinations of PW-1, PW-3 and PW-4
would go to show that with regard to various aspects the above-mentioned
depositions were contradictory. Such as:-
a. As per PW-1 he received telephonic message at 12:15
A.M., but as per PW-3 message to PW-1 was given at
12-12:15 A.M.
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


13
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

b. As per PW-1 he had stayed on the spot till 4:00 o’clock,
but as per PW-3 till 06:00 A.M. and as per PW-4 till
02:30 P.M. only.
c. As per PW-1 and PW-3 writing work was completed by
the PW-3 and PW-4, but as per PW-4 by PW-3 only.
d. As per PW-1 the writing work was completed while
sitting on the chair, but as per PW-3 while sitting on the
Bench and as per PW-4 while sitting on the ground.
e. As per PW-1 the measurement used for measuring the
weights of the contraband were of 50 grams, 100 grams,
500 grams, 200 grams and 1 kg., but as per PW-3 those
weights were of 50 grams, 100 grams and 200 grams
only and as per PW-4 of 10-15 grams only.
f. As per PW-1 for the purpose of weighing the gunny bags
the spring weighing scale was fixed to a stick held by
Constable Rajinder Singh and Constable Rattan Singh,
but as per PW-3 and PW-4 that stick was held by
Constable Ramdhari and Constable Rajinder Singh.
g. As per PW-3 the accused had fled towards left side of the
road, but as per PW-4 towards right side of the road.
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


14
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

h. As per PW-3 police party chased the accused and
returned to the place of recovery after one and half hour,
but as per PW-4 within 20-25 minutes.
33. The above-mentioned contradictions with regard to various
particulars of the events, which unfolded on the spot were material
contradictions in view of the fact that the only independent eye-witness of
the recovery had not supported the prosecution case, and the entire
prosecution case with regard to recovery of contraband was dependent upon
the testimony of police officials only. In my considered opinion once the
depositions of police officers were contradictory to each other, in the given
circumstances the credibility of testimonies of PW-1, PW-3 and PW-4 stood
impeached and therefore, all of them were rendered unreliable witnesses.
Point No.II
34. As far as the second component involved in the present case
was concerned, a careful perusal of the prosecution story would go to show
that the appellant was not apprehended on the spot and he managed to run
away from the spot. In such circumstances, it was incumbent upon the
prosecution to prove on what basis the identity of appellant was established.
However, any such evidence was not led by the prosecution and the sole
independent eye-witness had not supported the prosecution case.
35. Here it shall not be out of place to mention that PW-3 and PW-
4 both had deposed that appellant was not known to them previously, and
therefore, there was no occasion for the above-mentioned two witnesses to
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


15
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

establish the identity of the appellant. Since the independent eye-witness
(PW-7) had not supported the prosecution case with regard to identity of the
appellant, in my opinion the only course available with the prosecution was
to trace the appellant with the help of registration number of the jeep.
However, the above-said course was not adopted by the Investigating
Officer. Rather in the present case the prosecution relied upon one another
independent witness namely ‘Rajesh Kumar’ examined as PW-8. As per
prosecution story the appellant was produced before the Investigating
Officer by the PW-8. However, the PW-8 did not support the prosecution
case with regard to above-mentioned facts, and like PW-7, the PW-8, too,
was declared hostile and subjected to cross-examination.
36. In view of above-mentioned facts and circumstances once the
appellant was not apprehended on the spot and his identity could not be
established by the police party by any means, and the PW-8, who allegedly
produced the appellant before the police did not support the prosecution
case, in my considered opinion there was a very serious doubt with regard to
stand of the prosecution qua the plea that it was the appellant, who was
travelling in the above-mentioned jeep and carrying the contraband. Thus,
the plea of the prosecution, that the appellant was in conscious possession of
the contraband stood demolished.
Point No.III
37. The third component in the present case was the non-
compliance of mandatory provisions of NDPS Act. A perusal of record
would go to show that the case property was not produced before the learned
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


16
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

Illaqa Magistrate for the purpose of extracting representative samples and
sealing the representative samples as well as recovered contraband with his
own seal. In addition to above the inventory was supposed to be prepared by
the above-named Magistrate.
38. With regard to above situation, in a recent judgment, in the case
case of ‘Abdul Rajik v. State of M.P. 2026 Law Finder (SC) 5679’, it has
been observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India that total non-
compliance of Section 52A of ‘NDPS Act’ and breach of chain of custody
rendered the prosecution case unsustainable. According to the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India the absence of credible link evidence and scientific
material to confirm the identity of the contraband as “charas” would lead to
acquittal of the accused.
39. Thus, in my considered opinion a lapse was committed by the
Investigating Agency when it failed to comply with the provisions of Section
52-A of NDPS Act. Here it is also relevant to mention that as per PW-4 at
the time of production of case property in the Court the seals were not intact.
This fact was another factor responsible for impeaching the credibility of
prosecution story with regard to recovery of contraband and its storage.
40. If the cumulative effect of all the above-mentioned factors
would have been considered co-jointly, the only and only inference which
could have been drawn in the present case was that the prosecution story
with regard to recovery of contraband from the possession of appellant was
not proved in accordance with law. Therefore, it is hereby held that the
learned trial Court fell into error of judgment when it ignored all the above-
VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


17
CRA-S-757-SB-2005 (O&M)

discussed factors and returned a finding of conviction of appellant for the
commission of offence under Section 15 of NDPS Act. Thus, it is hereby
held that there is requirement for indulgence and interference in the
impugned judgment.
41. In view of above-mentioned observations, it is hereby held that
this appeal has got merits and the impugned judgment of conviction and
order on sentence deserves to be set aside.
42. As a sequel to above-mentioned observations, the present
appeal is hereby allowed , the impugned judgment and impugned order are
hereby set aside and the appellant is hereby acquitted of the charge framed
against him.
43. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of, accordingly.





(SURYA PARTAP SINGH)

JUDGE

17.11.2026

Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No




VIPIN KUMAR
2026.11.17 21:58
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document