Prem Meena vs D/o Income Tax

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

:: 1 :: OA No. 51/2021

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BECH

Original Application No. OA No. 51/2021

rd
Dated this the 23 day of October, 2026.

CORAM:
Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)

1. Smt. Prem Meena
D/o Shri Ramdhan Meena
Aged: 51 years (DOB being 14.07.1969)
Presently serving as Income Tax Officer, O/o Principle
Commissioner of Income Tax (HQ)-3, Ahmedabad having
Address at C Block, Pratyaksh Kar Bhawan, Opp-Govt
Polytechnic, Ambawadi, Ahmedabad - 380015

…Applicants
(By Advocate: Mr. Hardik V Vora)

V/s.

1. The Union of India through
The Secretary, Ministry of Finance,
Government of India, Department of Revenue,
Room No. 46, North Block,
New Delhi – 110001

2. Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (HQ)-3, Ahmedabad C Block
Pratyaksh Kar Bhawan,
Opp- Govt Polytechnic,
Ambawadi, Ahmedabad - 380015

3. Pr. Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Gujarat
Room No. 206, Second Floor, Aaykar Bhavan,
Ashram Road, Ahmedabad – 380009.
… Respondents

(By Advocate: Mr. Chirayu Mehta)






2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 2 :: OA No. 51/2021

ORDER(ORAL)
Per: Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (Judicial)
In the instant OA, the applicant being aggrieved by the decision of the
respondents in reckoning her seniority in the Gujarat Charge from the date of
his joining the Gujarat Charge, i.e. 09.01.1998, instead of her initial
appointment as Inspector of Income Tax (DR) at Delhi on 04.07.1994 and for
issuance of direction upon the respondents to reallocate seniority for
promotion after the DPC made on the basis of 2003 exams as against the
st
current seniority after considering all the DPCs up to 01 March 2007 as last
examination conducted was in 2003 and no departmental examination was
conducted after 2003 and ad-hoc promotions were made through the period
up to declaration of result for 2006 exams has filed the present OA under
Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act 1985 seeking following
reliefs:-
“8. RELIEF SOUGHT:
In view of the facts and ground mentioned in Para 4 and 5
above applicant respectfully pray:
a) For setting aside impugned Order dated 20.03.2020;
b) To direct the respondents to assign the seniority as
Inspector of Income tax from the date of appointment as
Inspector of Income Tax (DR) and joined at Delhi on
04.07.1994 as against the current seniority reckoned from
the date of joining office of The Chief Commissioner of
Income-Tax, Gujarat i.e. 09.01.1998;
c) To direct the respondents, to reallocate seniority for
promotion after the DPC made on the basis of 2003 exams
as against the current seniority after considering all the
st
DPCs upto 01 March 2007 as last examination conducted
was in 2003 and no departmental examination was
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 3 :: OA No. 51/2021

conducted in the year 2004 and 2005 and adhoc adhoc
promotions were made through the period up to declaration
of result for 2006 exams;
d) To direct the Pr. Chief Commissioner of Income Tax,
Gujarat, to grant all the consequential / notional benefits;
e) Any other order or direction as this Hon’ble Court may
deem fit and proper keeping in view the facts and
circumstances of the present case and in the interest of
justice, equity and good conscience may kindly be issued.”
2. Brief facts of the case are as under:-
2.1 That the applicant was initially appointed as Inspector of Income Tax
(Direct Recruit) and joined at Delhi on 04.07.1994. Subsequently, pursuant to
an Inter-Charge Transfer from the office of the Chief Commissioner of
Income Tax, Delhi to the Gujarat Charge, she joined the office of the Chief
Commissioner of Income Tax, Gujarat, at Ahmedabad on 09.01.1998.
2.2 The applicant submits that, pursuant to the transfer order dated
09.01.1998, her seniority in the Gujarat Charge was fixed at the bottom of the
seniority list of Inspectors of Income Tax, whether permanent or temporary,
in the Gujarat Charge, with effect from the date of his joining the said
Charge, i.e. 09.01.1998. According to her, such fixation of seniority has
resulted in prejudice to her service career, as her previous service rendered in
the Delhi Charge from 04.07.1994 onwards has not been taken into
consideration.
2.3 Further, she contends that the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pratibha
Rani & Others v. Union of India & Others, Civil Appeal No. 3792 of
2019, decided on 10.04.2019 , has laid down principles concerning the
counting of service rendered in the previous Charge. Placing reliance upon
the said judgment, she submitted a representation dated 21.10.2019 seeking
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 4 :: OA No. 51/2021

restoration of her seniority by taking into consideration her initial
appointment in the Delhi Charge.
2.4 It is stated that she appeared in the departmental examination for
promotion to the post of Income Tax Officer in July 2003 but could not
qualify the same.
Thereafter, the Department issued the Income Tax Officer,
Group 'B' Posts, Recruitment Rules, 2004, notified on 21.12.2004, wherein
the requirement of passing the departmental examination was deleted.
Consequently, no departmental examination was conducted during the years
2004 and 2005.
2.5 Further, it is stated that during the aforesaid period, several DPCs were
convened and ad hoc promotions to the post of Income Tax Officer were
granted on various dates, namely January 2004, 02.03.2005, 07.04.2005,
12.12.2005, 04.01.2006, 03.02.2006, 01.03.2006, 06.09.2006 and
04.10.2006.
2.6 Subsequently, vide Notification dated 24.03.2005, the said Recruitment
Rules were amended with retrospective effect from 21.12.2004 and the
requirement of passing the departmental examination for promotion to the
post of Income Tax Officer was reintroduced.
2.7 Thereafter, the applicant appeared in the departmental examination
conducted in October 2006 and qualified the same on 17.04.2007. Thereafter,
she was promoted to the post of Income Tax Officer vide Order No. 05 of
2007-08 and was posted to the office of the Chief Commissioner of Income
Tax, Gujarat, vide Order No. 06 of 2007-08 dated 09.05.2007. Her seniority
in the cadre of Income Tax Officer was consequently fixed after considering
the DPCs conducted prior to her qualifying the departmental examination.
2.8 Further, she submits that the last departmental examination conducted
before the examination of October 2006 was in the year 2003. Since no
examinations were conducted during 2004 and 2005, she was deprived of an
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 5 :: OA No. 51/2021

opportunity to qualify for promotion during the intervening period. She
further contends that the respondents could not have convened DPCs and
granted ad hoc promotions without declaring the result of the departmental
examination conducted in October 2006.
2.9 Thereafter, the applicant vide representation no. 2 dated 05.03.2020,
requested to reallocate her seniority for promotion after the DPC made on the
basis of 2003 exams, however, vide letter dated 20.03.2020, respondent no. 3
has ordered respondent no. 2 to keep the representation no.1 of Applicant in
abeyance for the reason that in light of Hon’ble Supreme Court's decision-
SLP (C) 31728/2018 in the case of Pratibha Rani & Ors, the CBDT(HRD)
has constituted a committee vide OM No. HRD/CM/104/07/2013-14 (Pt.
File-Il) 7764 dated 14.02.2020 to analyze various judgments with respect to
ICT policy in the department.
2.10 However, the grievance of the applicant was not decided, hence the
applicant had approached this Tribunal by way of filing O.A. No. 197/2020
and this Tribunal vide order dated 24.07.2020 directed the respondents to
consider and decide the pending representation of the applicant within
stipulated time limit.
Thereafter, the applicant has again submitted representation
dated 31.07.2020 and 14.10.2020 seeking reallocation of her seniority in the
Income Tax Officer cadre after the DPC conducted on the basis of the 2003
examination, however, the same remained un-answered, hence this OA.
3. In support of the prayer sought in this OA, learned counsel for the
applicant mainly argued as under:-
3.1 That the Departmental examination was to be held in September 2006,
which is scheduled to be held from 11 to 25 September, 2006 and the
eligibility criteria is prescribed in terms of existing Examination Rules, 1998.
It is an admitted fact that no examination had been held in the financial years
2004-05 and 2005-06. Accordingly, DPC could not be held in November
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 6 :: OA No. 51/2021

2005 for considering officials for promotion to the post of ITO when no
examination had been held.
Further, he relied on the Rule 1 of the Rules for Departmental
Examination for Income Tax Officers, 2004, which provides for holding the
examination every year in the first quarter of the financial year. According to
him, the failure of the respondents to conduct examinations during 2004-05
and 2005-06 cannot be used to deny him his rightful consideration for
promotion.
3.2 Further, it is argued that the Applicant was always willing to qualify the
promotional exam for V.Y. 2004-05 or 2005-06. However, due to
amendment in Recruitment Rule, 2004, departmental examination was not
conducted during the year 2004 and 2005. Accordingly, when exams were
not conducted due to amendment in Recruitment Rules, 2004 which were
effective for only 2 years, the petitioner has been deprived of an opportunity
to appear in the examination and resultantly lost his right of consideration for
promotion to the post of ITO. If examination was conducted, applicant could
get promotion on the basis of the said examination. The respondents
thereafter conducted the departmental examination in the year 2006.
However, without waiting for the result of 2006 examination have conducted
DPC on 01.11.2006, 05.12.2006, 03.01.2007 and 01.03.2007. All DPCs after
DPC held on the basis of 2003 exams till April 2007 DPC are unjustified as
they are affected without conducting examination.
In support of the aforesaid contention, the applicant relied on the
order passed by the Allahabad Bench of this Tribunal in O.A. No. 936/2005
wherein in para 8 it was held that “…Respondents are restrained from
holding any DPC for the post of Income Tax Officers without conducting
necessary departmental examination for promotion to the post of I.T.O. The
DPC can be held only after the results of such exams are pronounced and all
those who qualify in the exam are also considered for promotion. No cost.”
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 7 :: OA No. 51/2021

Further, the applicant also relied on the order passed by the
Principal Bench of this Tribunal in case of Sanjeev Kumar Meena & Others
v. Ministry of Finance & Others, O.A. No. 3434/2016 wherein it was held
that “16. There is absolutely no justification in the action of the respondents
in conducting the regular DPC and promoting the private respondents on
regular basis, in utter disregard of the orders of this Tribunal, i.e., without
conducting and declaring the results of 2006 Exam and without considering
the cases of the applicants along with the private respondents and others who
passed the Exam of 2003, as per the directions of this Tribunal. Though the
conducting of regular DPC and promoting the private respondents as ITOs,
on regular basis itself, is prima facie, contumacious, being violative of the
orders of this Tribunal, as the applicants have not challenged the promotion
orders of the private respondents and only sought for fixation of their
seniority as ITOs, vis-a-vis the private respondents, basing on their inter-se
seniority in the feeder category, we resist from considering the said aspect.”
3.3 Further, it is stated that the respondents action of not holding
departmental examination to the grade of ITO in the years 2004 and 2005 is
clearly violative of the stipulation of examination rules, which envisage
holding of the examination every year in the first quarter of financial year.
Accordingly departmental examination is a precondition for promotion to the
cadre of ITO. The examinations were required to be conducted every year
and the officials were to pass the same within the stipulated period. Those
who could not pass within the time frame were to be promoted as and when
they qualify themselves.
Therefore when the examination is not held as per the mandate of
rules, the applicant cannot be penalized for the default of the respondent in
not conducting the examination every year. For this proposition, the applicant
relied on the decision of Honourable Apex Court in the case of State Of
Maharashtra Vs. Jagannath Achyut Karandikar reported vide 1989 supp (1)
SCC 393 and submits that it is highly arbitrary and unfair to penalize
employees by stripping them of their seniority when the delay in passing the
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 8 :: OA No. 51/2021

examination is a direct result of the government's failure to host the exams
annually.
3.4 Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Pratibha Rani & Others v. Union of India & Others, Civil Appeal
No. 3792 of 2019, decided on 10.04.2019, has laid down principles
concerning the counting of service rendered in the previous Charge and
based on it, the claim of the applicant seeking restoration of his seniority by
taking into consideration his initial appointment at Delhi is required to be
allowed by the respondents. Further, he submits that the decision of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pratibha Rani (supra) supports the applicant's
claim for counting the service rendered in the previous Charge and the
respondents have failed to properly apply the principles laid down therein.
Hence, the OA be allowed.
4. Per contra, on receipt of the notice issued by this Tribunal, the respondents
have filed the reply and denied the claim of the applicant. Mr. Chirayu Mehta
learned counsel for the respondents by referring the reply mainly submitted
as under.
4.1 That the applicant's seniority was correctly fixed in accordance with the
applicable instructions governing Inter-Charge Transfer and the Recruitment
Rules governing promotion to the post of Income Tax Officer.
4.2 It is stated that the applicant was transferred from the Delhi to the Gujarat
Charge vide order dated 09.01.1998. The terms of the transfer specifically
stipulated that his seniority in the Gujarat Charge would be reckoned from
the date of his joining duty in that Charge and that his name would be placed
below all Inspectors of Income Tax, whether permanent or temporary,
already borne on the cadre of Gujarat Charge on the date of his joining.
4.3 The respondents further rely upon CBDT Circular F.No. 22020/76/89-
Ad.VII dated 14.05.1990 and submitted that paragraph (f) of the said circular
specifically provides that service rendered in the old Charge would not be
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 9 :: OA No. 51/2021

counted for the purpose of seniority in the new Charge and that the
transferred employee would be placed at the bottom of the seniority list
of the concerned cadre in the new Charge from the date of joining.
4.4 It is stated that the applicant was transferred under the applicable ICT
policy and was required to accept the consequential loss of seniority in the
new Charge. The applicant had accepted the terms of transfer and had not
challenged either the transfer conditions or the governing instructions.
Therefore, he cannot now seek retrospective seniority in the Gujarat Charge
from the date of his initial appointment in Delhi.
4.5 It is contended that the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Pratibha Rani (supra) has been wrongly interpreted by the applicant.
According to them, the issue considered in that case concerned counting of
service rendered in the previous Charge for the purpose of determining the
requisite experience or eligibility for promotion and “not restoration of
seniority in the new Charge.” Therefore, the said judgment is not
applicable in the facts and circumstances of the present case.
4.6 In this regard, learned counse also rely upon the principles laid down in
Union of India & Others v. C.N. Ponnappan, (1996) 1 SCC 524, and M.M.
Thomas & Others v. Union of India & Others, (2017) 13 SCC 722, and
submit that the benefit of previous service for determining eligibility or
experience cannot be equated with a right to carry forward seniority from one
Charge to another.
4.7 Learned counsel further submits that the representation dated 21.10.2019
was kept in abeyance because CBDT (HRD) had constituted a committee
vide O.M. dated 14.02.2020 to examine various judicial pronouncements
concerning the ICT policy of the Department. The matter was also referred to
the higher authorities, including the Pr. DGIT (HRD), New Delhi, and the
concerned authority in the Ministry of Finance, through communications
dated 20.08.2020 and 22.09.2020.
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 10 :: OA No. 51/2021

4.8 With regard to the applicant's claim for reallocation of seniority in the
Income Tax Officer cadre, the respondents submit that the applicant appeared
in the departmental examination in 2003 but failed to qualify. She
subsequently appeared in the examination conducted in October 2006 and
qualified only on 17.04.2007. Consequently, she was promoted to the post of
Income Tax Officer in May 2007 and was assigned seniority in that cadre
accordingly.
4.9 Learned counsel placed reliance upon Rule 14 of the Rules for
Departmental Examination for Income Tax Officers, 2004, which expressly
provides that delay in conducting the examination or declaring its result does
not give rise to any rightful claim for consideration for promotion by
deeming an employee eligible as on 1st January of the relevant vacancy year.
The provision also makes it clear that no relaxation is permissible on account
of delay in conducting the examination or declaration of results.
4.10 Further, it is stated that the Recruitment Rules dated 21.12.2004 initially
prescribed three years' regular service in the grade of Inspector of Income
Tax for promotion to the post of Income Tax Officer. However, the
amendment dated 24.03.2005, made effective retrospectively from
21.12.2004, reintroduced the requirement of passing the departmental
examination as a condition precedent for promotion.
4.11 It is stated that the DPC for the vacancy year 2003-04 was convened on
02.03.2005. In terms of the applicable DoPT instructions, eligibility was
required to be determined with reference to the crucial date of 01.01.2003.
On that date, the applicant had admittedly not qualified the departmental
examination for promotion to the post of Income Tax Officer. Therefore, he
was not eligible for consideration against the vacancies pertaining to the said
vacancy year.
4.12 Learned counsel also pointed out that the applicant is seeking to
challenge the All India inter-se seniority list of Income Tax Officers
circulated in 2015 and the subsequent seniority list circulated on 05.02.2018,
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 11 :: OA No. 51/2021

wherein her name was placed at different serial numbers. The present
Original Application having been filed in 2021, the respondents contend that
the challenge is barred by delay and laches and that reopening settled
seniority positions would adversely affect other officers.
4.13 On the above grounds, learned counsel submits that the applicant has no
enforceable right to claim seniority from 04.07.1994 in the Gujarat Charge or
retrospective promotion/seniority in the Income Tax Officer cadre.
Therefore, the OA be dismissed.
5. In rejoinder, learned counsel for the applicant by relying on the judgment
passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of M.M. Thomas & Ors v.
Union of India (2017) 13 SCC 722 submits that in an All-India Service,
components of multi-regional services must be clubbed together to determine
total regular experience so that officials are not deprived of their hard-earned
feeder cadre experience.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material available on
record.
7. Considering the aforementioned submissions, we are of the opinion that
following issues requires adjudication by this Tribunal:-
(i). Whether the applicant is entitled to restoration of her seniority in the
cadre of Inspector of Income Tax in Gujarat Charge from the date of her
initial appointment in Delhi, i.e. 04.07.1994, instead of 09.01.1998?
(ii). Whether the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pratibha Rani &
Others v. Union of India & Others is applicable to the applicant's claim for
restoration of seniority in the new Charge?
(iii). Whether the applicant is entitled to reallocation of her seniority in the
cadre of Income Tax Officer by placing her immediately after the DPC
conducted on the basis of the departmental examination of 2003?
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 12 :: OA No. 51/2021

(iv). Whether the respondents were justified in not considering the applicant
for promotion against the relevant vacancies when she had not qualified the
departmental examination as on the prescribed crucial date?
8 . With regard to issue no. (i), it is apt to mention that the applicant was
initially appointed as Inspector of Income Tax (Direct Recruitment) at Delhi
on 04.07.1994 and was subsequently transferred to the Gujarat Charge and
joined the Gujarat Charge on 09.01.1998.
8.1 The controversy revolves around the terms and conditions governing
such Inter-Charge Transfer. The respondents have specifically relied upon
CBDT Circular F.No. 22020/76/89-Ad.VII dated 14.05.1990, more
particularly paragraph (f) which provides that the service rendered in the old
Charge shall not be counted for the purpose of seniority in the new Charge
and that the transferred employee shall be placed at the bottom of the
seniority list of the concerned cadre in the new Charge from the date of
joining.
8.2 We have also perused the transfer order/communication dated 09.01.1998
issued in the applicant's case. The said communication specifically stipulated
that her seniority in Gujarat Charge would be reckoned from the date of her
joining duty in that Charge and that he would be placed below all Inspectors
of Income Tax, whether permanent or temporary, already borne on the cadre
of Gujarat Charge on the date of his joining.
8.3 Thus, the applicant by accepting the said Transfer Order and being aware
of the consequences of his transfer and the manner in which his seniority was
to be regulated in the new Charge has joined the Gujarat Charge, therefore,
now he cannot seek to claim seniority in the new Charge from the date of his
initial appointment in the previous Charge, contrary to the express terms
governing such transfer.
8.4 It is settled that seniority in a particular cadre is governed by the
applicable statutory rules and administrative instructions, and an employee
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 13 :: OA No. 51/2021

cannot claim seniority in a new cadre or Charge merely on the basis of the
length of service rendered in the previous Charge when the governing
transfer policy specifically provides otherwise.
8.5 In these circumstances, we find no infirmity in the action of the
respondents in reckoning the applicant's seniority in Gujarat Charge from
09.01.1998, i.e. the date on which he joined the said Charge.
9. So far issue no. (ii) is concerned it is apt to mention that the applicant has
placed considerable reliance upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Pratibha Rani & Others v. Union of India & Others, Civil
Appeal No. 3792 of 2019, decided on 10.04.2019 (supra), to contend that
the service rendered in the previous Charge should also be counted for
determining his seniority in the new Charge.
9.1 On the other hand, the respondents have contended that the applicant has
misunderstood the scope and applicability of the aforesaid judgment.
According to them, the issue considered therein related to counting the
service rendered in the previous Charge for determining the requisite
experience and eligibility for promotion and not for the purpose of
restoration of seniority in the new Charge.
9.2 It is necessary to distinguish between the benefit of counting previous
service for the purpose of determining eligibility for promotion and the right
to claim seniority in the new Charge. These are two distinct concepts. The
fact that an employee may be entitled to have his previous regular service
counted for determining the requisite experience or eligibility for promotion
does not automatically confer upon her a right to carry forward her seniority
from the previous Charge to the new Charge, particularly when the
applicable transfer policy specifically provides for placement at the bottom of
the seniority list in the new Charge.
9.3 In this regard, it is apt to mention the judgment passed by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Union of India & Others v. C.N. Ponnappan, (1996) 1
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 14 :: OA No. 51/2021

SCC 524 wherein it was held that seniority and eligibility for promotion are
distinct legal concepts; an employee transferred on compassionate grounds
forfeits their seniority but retains their past regular service as qualifying
experience for promotion eligibility.
9.4 We are, therefore, unable to accept the applicant's contention that the
judgment in Pratibha Rani (supra) automatically entitles her to restoration of
her seniority in Gujarat Charge from 04.07.1994. In our considered view, the
said judgment cannot be construed as conferring an unrestricted right upon
an employee transferred from one Charge to another to claim seniority in the
new Charge contrary to the applicable transfer policy and the conditions of
transfer.
10. So far issue no. (iii) is concerned that Whether the applicant is entitled to
reallocation of seniority in the Income Tax Officer cadre after the DPC
conducted on the basis of the 2003 examination, it is apt to mention that the
applicant appeared in the departmental examination conducted in 2003 but
could not qualify.
Thereafter, no departmental examination was conducted during
2004 and 2005, and the Department granted several ad hoc promotions
during the said period.
10.1 It is further submitted that the applicant appeared in the examination
conducted in October 2006 and qualified the same on 17.04.2007. However,
even before declaration of the result of the said examination, the respondents
had convened DPCs and granted ad hoc promotions on 01.11.2006,
05.12.2006, 03.01.2007 and 01.03.2007. The applicant contends that such
DPCs have adversely affected her seniority and that she ought to have been
placed immediately after the DPC conducted on the basis of the 2003
examination.
10.2 We have considered the above submissions in the light of the
Recruitment Rules applicable to the post of Income Tax Officer and the
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 15 :: OA No. 51/2021

Rules for Departmental Examination for Income Tax Officers, 2004. The
Recruitment Rules notified on 21.12.2004 initially provided for promotion to
the post of Income Tax Officer on the basis of three years' regular service in
the grade of Inspector of Income Tax. However, by subsequent Notification
dated 24.03.2005, the Recruitment Rules were amended retrospectively with
effect from 21.12.2004 and the requirement of qualifying the departmental
examination was reintroduced as a condition precedent for promotion.
Consequently, passing the departmental examination became an
essential eligibility condition for promotion in accordance with the amended
Recruitment Rules.
10.3 In the present case, the applicant admittedly appeared in the
departmental examination in 2003 but failed to qualify. She subsequently
appeared in the examination conducted in October 2006 and qualified the
same only on 17.04.2007.
10.4 The respondents have specifically explained that the DPC for the
vacancy year 2003-04 was convened on 02.03.2005 and that, in accordance
with the applicable DoPT instructions, the eligibility of the candidates was
required to be determined with reference to the crucial date of 01.01.2003.
10.5 Admittedly, as on 01.01.2003, the applicant had not qualified the
departmental examination prescribed for promotion to the post of Income
Tax Officer. Therefore, he did not fulfil the requisite eligibility condition for
consideration against the vacancies pertaining to the said vacancy year.
10.6 It is important to mention that eligibility for promotion is required to be
determined in accordance with the Recruitment Rules applicable to the
relevant vacancy year and the prescribed crucial date. The mere fact that an
employee subsequently qualifies the departmental examination cannot
retrospectively make her eligible for promotion against an earlier vacancy for
which she did not satisfy the prescribed conditions.
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 16 :: OA No. 51/2021

10.7 The applicant has sought to contend that, since no departmental
examinations were conducted during 2004 and 2005, she should not be made
to suffer on account of the administrative lapse of the respondents. However,
such a contention, by itself, cannot create a right to retrospective promotion
or seniority in the absence of fulfilment of the prescribed eligibility
conditions.
10.8 Therefore, the applicant's claim that she should be placed immediately
after the DPC conducted on the basis of the 2003 examination is not
supported by the applicable Recruitment Rules. The fact that she
subsequently qualified the examination on 17.04.2007 and was promoted in
May 2007 is a material circumstance which cannot be ignored while
examining her claim.
11. So for Issue No. (iv) is concerned that Whether the respondents were
justified in not considering the applicant for promotion against the relevant
vacancies, in this regard, the applicant has contended that the respondents
could not have conducted DPCs and granted ad hoc promotions during the
period when no departmental examination was held or before the declaration
of the result of the October 2006 examination.
In support of this contention, the applicant has relied upon Rule
1 of the Rules for Departmental Examination for Income Tax Officers, 2004,
which provides that the examination shall be held every year in the first
quarter of the financial year.
11.1 We have also considered Rule 14 of the aforesaid Rules, which has been
specifically relied upon by the respondents. The said Rule provides that delay
in conducting the examination or declaration of its result, for whatever valid
reasons, does not give rise to any rightful claim for consideration for
promotion by deeming the employee eligible as on 1st January of the relevant
vacancy year, irrespective of the actual date of holding the examination or
declaration of its result. It further provides that no relaxation shall be granted
on account of such delay.
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 17 :: OA No. 51/2021

11.2 The aforesaid provision is material to the controversy involved in the
present case. The applicant cannot claim deemed eligibility merely on the
ground that the Department did not conduct the departmental examination
during 2004 and 2005 or that the result of the examination conducted in
October 2006 was declared on 17.04.2007. The requirement of passing the
departmental examination was an essential condition under the applicable
Recruitment Rules and the applicant admittedly failed to qualify the
examination conducted in 2003 and acquired the requisite qualification only
on 17.04.2007.
11.3 We are also conscious of the applicant's reliance upon the decision in
Ashwani Kumar Singh (O.A. No. 936/2005) and Sanjeev Kumar Meena &
Others (O.A. No. 3434/2016). However, the decisions relied upon by the
applicant cannot be read as creating an automatic entitlement to retrospective
promotion or seniority in favour of every employee who could not qualify the
prescribed departmental examination by the relevant date. Therefore, the
applicant cannot claim the benefit of a promotional vacancy merely because
other employees were granted ad hoc promotions before declaration of the
result of the examination in which he had appeared.
In the present case, the applicant has failed to establish such
eligibility as on the relevant crucial date. Consequently, the respondents
cannot be directed to grant him retrospective seniority or promotion by
treating him as having qualified the examination before the actual declaration
of the result.
12. In view of the foregoing discussion and findings on the issues framed
above, we find that the applicant has failed to establish any enforceable right
to claim restoration of her seniority in the Gujarat Charge from the date of
her initial appointment at Delhi. She has also failed to establish any
entitlement to retrospective promotion or reallocation of her seniority in the
cadre of Income Tax Officer by disregarding the prescribed eligibility
2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'

:: 18 :: OA No. 51/2021

conditions under the applicable Recruitment Rules, therefore, there is no
merit in the OA accordingly, the same is dismissed.
13. The Original Application is dismissed. Pending MAs, if any, shall also
stand dismissed. No costs.




Sanjiv Kumar Jayesh V Bhairavia
Member (A) Member(J)



/pratik/

2026.11.06
PRATIK VYAS
10:43:49+05'30'