Dr. Pranajit Paul vs Tripura Gramin Bank and 2 Ors.

Court
Tripura High Court

TRHC010018092026 2026:THC:1491

HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A G A R T A L A
WP(C) No.721 of 2026
Dr. Pranajit Paul,
S/O Sri Pradip Kumar Paul, resident of Opposite of Govt. Press, Milan
Sangha, P.O. A.D. Nagar, Agartala, District West Tripura, PIN 799003.
……… Petitioner(s)
– V e r s u s –
1. Tripura Gramin Bank,
A Government Undertaking, to be represented by it’s Chairman, Tripura
Gramin Bank, Head Office at Abhoynagar, P.O. Agartala, PIN 799005.
2. The Chairman,
Tripura Gramin Bank, (A Government Undertaking), Head Office at
Abhoynagar, P.O. Agartala, PIN 799005.
3. The General Manager (HR),
Tripura Gramin Bank, (A Government Undertaking), Head Office at
Abhoynagar, P.O. Agartala, PIN 799005.
……..Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s) : Mr. P. Roy Barman, Senior Advocate.
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s) : Mr. Prabir Saha, Advocate.
th
Date of hearing : 14 October, 2026.
Date of delivery of
th
Judgment & Order : 13 November, 2026.

YES NO
√
Whether fit for reporting :

HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The petitioner has filed this petition challenging the transfer order
dated 09.09.2026 issued by the Chairman of Tripura Gramin Bank, Agartala.

[2] Though in this writ petition, no counter affidavit is submitted from
the side of respondents but they have submitted 2 (two) nos. of detailed
affidavit-in-opposition in the connected stay matter divulging their entire

Page 2 of 8


defence. Accordingly, both the parties were heard at length on the merit of the
writ petition.
[3] The petitioner was promoted to the post of Chief Manager, Scale IV
on 01.04.2025 and was posted at Tripura Gramin Bank, Agartala Branch w.e.f.
01.07.2025. On 09.09.2026, an order of transfer has been issued by the
Chairman of the Bank on the ground that on 26.08.2026, indifferent attitude and
poor customer service was provided to one Senior Executive of the State
Government by him which was a serious departure from the standards of
courtesy, promptness and professionalism and considering that lapses and in
view of the interest of public and Bank’s administrative exigencies, he has been
transferred to Poangbari Branch with immediate effect. He has been also
directed to join his new place of posting forthwith without availing joining time.
[4] On the following day i.e. on 10.09.2026, the petitioner submitted a
representation to the Chairman, Tripura Gramin Bank disclosing that on
26.08.2026, one customer namely, Tapas Roy, Secretary to the State of Tripura
visited Bank branch asking for a personalized cheque book in relation to a joint
account of himself and his son. Then he politely informed him that it will take
time as the cheque book is required to be printed and posted to his home
address from outside the State and he also entered the said requisition of
personalized cheque book in CBS at that moment but said customer was not
satisfied and insisted for immediate delivery of such cheque book. The KYC
documents of his son as was submitted by him was also not having signatures
of his major son and therefore, the petitioner informed him that such KYC
documents are required to be attested and signed by the person concerned but
the said gentleman said that he being father would sign the said documents.
The petitioner then replied that if requires, he would send staff from his Bank
branch for obtaining signature of his son from his house and he never
misbehaved with him. Therefore, he requested for revoking said transfer order.
Thereafter on 14.09.2026, a show cause notice was issued to him on that
ground asking him to show cause in writing as to why disciplinary action should
not be initiated against him.
[5] He submitted his reply to said show cause notice on 18.09.2026
denying the allegations and asserting that insistence for compliance with KYC

Page 3 of 8


requirements cannot constitute indifferent behavior and the customer was dealt
with politely and with courtesy. It is also stated by him that compliance with
banking requirement is also obligatory on his part which cannot be diluted at the
customers’ request.
[6] The Bank authority in their counter affidavit has asserted that after
promotion to the post of Chief Manager, it was noticed that the attitude of the
petitioner became unprofessional towards customer services and he was
verbally cautioned to rectify himself in this regard and on 26.08.2026, he
misbehaved with said Secretary of Labour Department, Government of Tripura
and failed to provide customer service towards a customer like a Senior
Executive of the State Government and therefore, exercising the power under
the provision of Section 74(1) of the Tripura Gramin Bank (Officers and
Employees) Service Regulations, 2010 and considering administrative exigency
he was transferred as such. It is also stated that it has been the Bank’s policy
that misbehavior/rude behavior with customers shall be treated with zero
tolerance and immediate action will be taken. It is further stated that since the
petitioner failed to provide banking service towards the customers specially to
the Senior Executive i.e. Secretary, Labour Department, Government of Tripura
and since the petitioner failed to maintain decorum regarding the behavior with
customer like a Senior Executive of the State Government, he has been
transferred inasmuch as, the petitioner by such unprofessional activities
towards said Executive has destroyed the image and business of the bank in
the eye of the public domain.
[7] Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
referring to above said facts of the case submits that before the petitioner was
transferred, no show cause notice was issued to him alleging any sort of
misbehavior or rude behavior towards the said customer and even no enquiry
was also done by the Bank in this regard. Referring to a minutes of meeting
dated 27.08.2026 (Annexure R/2 of the stay petition), learned senior counsel
submits that as per said document itself, one Shri Sujit Roy, Senior Regional
Manager, West Tripura Region, the present petitioner and another Shri
Subhradeep Bhowmik, Marketing Officer, Regional Office of Tripura Gramin
Bank met said Sri Tapas Roy, Secretary, Labour Department and details of their
conversation was minuted in the said document and in the said document itself,

Page 4 of 8


it is mentioned that the Bank delegation clarified the stringent regulatory
framework set by Reserve Bank of India and internal compliance norms,
explaining that updates to an account’s KYC record strictly require the personal
signature of the primary account holder i.e. the son of said customer rather than
a third-party or parental attestation. Referring to that, Mr. Roy Barman, learned
senior counsel strongly argues that when the petitioner insisted the customer to
comply with the banking norms under RBI guideline, that cannot be treated as
misbehavior towards the customer. It is also submitted by him that the said
document itself will show that just to give over importance to said customer and
to satisfy him, punitive action has been taken against the petitioner illegally by
transferring him to Poangbari despite he was having no fault in this regard.
[8] Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel finally relies on a decision
of Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Somesh Tiwari vs. Union of India and
others; (2009) 2 SCC 592 wherein the appellant was an officer of the Indian
Revenue Service and was posted as a Deputy Commissioner of Central Excise
at Bhopal. On the premise that the employees posted at the Bhopal office of the
respondents apprehending disciplinary as also criminal proceedings at the
hands of the appellant i.e. the concerned employee on the basis of the
reassessment of the files undertaken by him, an anonymous complaint was
made alleging caste bias on his part, pursuant whereto an order of transfer was
passed against him transferring him to Shillong. It was however there that on
the basis of said anonymous complaint, an enquiry was conducted by an
Assistant Commissioner, Directorate of Vigilance wherein allegations made
against the appellant were not found to be true. In that backdrop, Hon’ble
Supreme Court held the followings at Paragraph no.16:
“16. Indisputably an order of transfer is an administrative order. There
cannot be any doubt whatsoever that transfer, which is ordinarily an
incident of service should not be interfered with, save in cases where
inter alia mala fide on the part of the authority is proved. Mala fide is of
two kinds-one malice in fact and the second malice in law. The order in
question would attract the principle of malice in law as it was not based
on any factor germane for passing an order of transfer and based on
an irrelevant ground i.e. on the allegations made against the appellant
in the anonymous complaint. It is one thing to say that the employer is
entitled to pass an order of transfer in administrative exigencies but it
is another thing to say that the order of transfer is passed by way of or
in lieu of punishment. When an order of transfer is passed in lieu of
punishment, the same is liable to be set aside being wholly illegal.”

Page 5 of 8


[9] Mr. Prabir Saha, learned counsel for the respondents at the outset
refers to the said minutes dated 27.08.2026 (Annexure R/2 of the stay petition)
wherein against the heading “resolution and hospitality” it is noted down that
reassured by the controlling office’s proactive personal visit and transparent
explanation, said Shri Roy accepted the Bank’s apology, agreed to drop his
proposal to close his son’s account, and willingly agreed to complete the
necessary documentation. Mr. Saha, learned counsel referring to it submits
that the misbehavior of the present petitioner ultimately caused serious
displeasure of the customer for which he was likely to withdraw his son’s
account from the Bank and ultimately, the higher officials of the Bank had to
beg apology for the same and the petitioner himself was also a member of the
said team who also sought apology.
[10] Referring to Regulation 39 of said Banking Service Regulations of
2010 which consists of both minor penalties and major penalties for the Bank
employees and officers in case of their negligence, inefficiency or indolence,
Mr. Saha, learned counsel submits that under the said Regulation 39, the
petitioner is liable for departmental proceeding and in this regard, a show
cause notice has already been issued to him. Referring to Regulation 74 which
contains a general provision that every officer or employee is liable for transfer
to any office or branch of the Bank, Mr. Saha, learned counsel submits that the
present petitioner has been transferred by the Bank authority exercising said
power and as per Regulation 49, the petitioner has his right to appeal against
the said order of the Bank but without availing such remedy, he has directly
approached the Court and therefore, the writ petition is not maintainable. He
has also given his stress on another letter dated 18.09.2026 whereby the
Chairman of the Bank sent an apology letter again to Mr. Roy expressing his
deep regret and sincere apology for the inconvenience and hurt caused to him.
In the said letter it is also mentioned that Tripura Gramin Bank has always
maintained a close and valued relationship with the Government of Tripura
and its various Departments and they deeply value the trust and confidence
reposed in the Bank by the State Government, its Departments, institutions,
employees and people of Tripura. Mr. Saha, learned counsel in that context
submits that due to misbehavior and improper service rendered by the
petitioner, the Chairman of the Bank for the second time had to seek apology
by said letter.

Page 6 of 8


[11] It is also argued by him that the petitioner till date is in
unauthorized leave and despite order passed by the Bank authority on
24.09.2026, no medical paper of treatment has yet been submitted by the
petitioner to the Bank though initially he sent a mail on 10.09.2026 informing
that he was suffering from severe abdominal issue for past few days and his
doctor advised him to take bed rest for recovery. Finally, learned counsel
prays for dismissal of the writ petition.
[12] Court has accorded the submissions of both sides and has gone
through the documents and pleadings of the parties.
[13] It is fact that the contents of the said transfer order as indicated
above itself indicates that said order was a punishment transfer with aspersion
on the efficiency, behavior and skill of the petitioner in discharging his official
duty noting that he failed to maintain standard of courtesy, promptness and
professionalism; but before issuance of such transfer order neither any show
cause notice was issued to him nor any enquiry was done by the Bank which is
gross violation of principle of natural justice. Even, said minutes in the form of
confidential visit report prepared on 27.08.2026 itself shows that the Bank
delegation clarified the stringent regulatory framework made by Reserve Bank of
India that KYC documents are required to be signed by the customer concerned
and they also explained to Mr. Roy that regarding personalized cheque book,
branch level printing was not available and all personalized requests are being
processed through a centralized facility in Jalandhar, Punjab, requiring up to 7
working days for delivery of cheque book. Thus, it is evident from above said
document that the request for instant personalized cheque book, signing of KYC
documents by father on behalf major son were not permissible or feasible as per
Bank norms and such regulation was indomitable and unrelaxable.
[14] What sort of misbehavior actually was done by the petitioner is
neither mentioned in the transfer order or in the said resolution/visit report. Even
in the subsequent show cause notice dated 14.09.2026 (Annexure 3 to the writ
petition), a general allegation has been depicted therein that petitioner displayed
indifferent attitude and poor customer service while dealing with a Senior
Executive of the Government on 26.08.2026 but what sort of wrong attitude or

Page 7 of 8


behavior or poor customer service was exhibited by him has not been further
mentioned therein.
[15] In Somesh Tiwari (supra), as quoted earlier, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has observed therein that when an order of transfer is passed in lieu of
punishment, same is liable to be set aside being wholly illegal. When any fault or
deficiency on the part of the petitioner is not established, passing of such order
is not only illegal but also hasty. It may be so that the Bank authority was over
conscious for the disappointment of a Senior Administrative Officer of the State
as their banking business with the State Government Departments may suffer,
not only the petitioner has been transferred rather despite the fact that on the
meeting dated 27.08.2026 itself when said customer Mr. Roy was finally very
happy at the fag end of the visit and even he also hosted tea for the entire
delegation in a highly cordial atmosphere but despite the same, without any
reason or cause, again after lapse of considerable time, the Chairman further
issued an apology letter to him on 18.09.2026 (Annexure R/4). Considering all
these aspects, it appears to be a fit case to interfere with the said transfer order,
same being illegal and arbitrary having punitive contents therein without
sufficient reason and for gross violation of principle of natural justice.
[16] Non-exploration of alternative remedy does not always bar the
Court in exercising its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. In Uttar
Pradesh Junior High School Council Instructor Welfare Association vs.
State of Uttar Pradesh and others; (2026) 5 SCC 321 , the Hon’ble Supreme
Court observed the followings:
"27. Moreover, as held in Rajasthan SEB v. Union of India, (2008) 5 SCC
632, the existence of an alternative remedy under a statutory scheme
does not operate as an absolute bar to the exercise of writ jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution. This is particularly so in cases
where the writ petition has already been entertained by the Court,
pleadings have been completed, and the matter has been adjudicated
on merits. In such circumstances, relegating the parties to an
alternative forum would defeat the ends of justice and render the prior
proceedings redundant.
28. The Supreme Court has consistently clarified that the rule of
exclusion of writ jurisdiction on account of availability of an alternative
remedy is one of prudence and self-restraint, not of compulsion. This
principle was authoritatively reiterated in Harbanslal Sahnia v. Indian
Oil Corpn. Ltd., (2003) 2 SCC 107 wherein it was held that the High
Court, while exercising its writ jurisdiction, must weigh the facts and
circumstances of each case, assess the pros and cons, and then
decide whether interference is warranted. Thus, where the facts so

Page 8 of 8


justify, the Court retains full discretion to entertain and decide a writ
petition notwithstanding the availability of an alternative remedy. Thus,
the objection to the maintainability is unsustainable and is overruled."
[17] Consequently, the writ petition is allowed. The transfer order dated
09.09.2026 (Annexure 1 to the writ petition) is hereby quashed. The
respondents are directed to allow the petitioner to join at Tripura Gramin Bank,
Agartala branch wherein he was posted prior to issuance of said transfer order,
within 7 days from today and to regularize his unauthorized absence with wages
for the said period on submission of his leave application in due course.
With such terms and conditions, the writ petition is disposed of.
Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
















Rudradeep RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
Digitally signed by RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
Date: 2026.11.13 13:49:55 +05'30'