Vikas vs State Of Haryana And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CWP-26135-20
026 (O&M) 1 of 11



IN THE H
HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND H
HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
109




CWP-26135-2026 (O&M)
Date of decision: 13.11.2026


Vikas

...Petitioner(s)
Vs.

yana and others
State of Hary
...Respondent(s)

HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE NIDHI GU
CORAM:
UPTA

Present:-
Mr. R. K. Girdhwal, Advocate fo
Mr. Rohit Mittal, Advocate
for the petitioners.
r

Mr. Harish Kumar Nain, DAG, Ha
aryana.


NIDHI GUPTA

*
A, J.
Present writ petition has been
filed by the petitioner under
Articles 226/
/227 of the Constitution of India
a for issuance of a writ in the
nature of Ce
ertiorari for quashing the imp
ugned Speaking Order dated
22.05.2026
(Annexure P-18) passed by R
Respondent No.4, being non
speaking cr
ryptic laconic without jurisd
diction but same is also
contemptuou
us in nature and thus legally not
t sustainable in the eyes of law
especially in
view of the fact that this Court
t vide order dated 29.04.2026
while setting
g aside the same very relievin
ng order of the petitioner as
group D dire
ction were also issued by this C
Court to take a decision afresh
at the level
of the head of the departme
ent however despite specific
undertaking
given by the Haryana on behalf
of the state as recorded in the
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 16:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-26135-20
026 (O&M) 2 of 11



order dated 2
29.04.2026 the respondent depa
artment has now again passed
the impugne
ed order dated 22.05.2026 resp
pectively in complete defiance
of the said u
undertaking and the direction o
of this Court illegally relieving
the petitione
er from service on the same li
nes by ignoring the direction
dated 29.04.
2026 the undertaking given by
the learned advocate general
as well as t
the provision of clause 11-A(ii
), of the deployment of the
contractual
person policy, 2022 as am
mended vide circular dated
13.05.2025 (
(Annexure P-18A) in wholly ille
egally arbitrary, discriminatory
and unconst
itutional and thus the impugne
ed action of the respondent is
legally not su
ustainable in the eyes of law; AN
ND/OR for issuance of a writ in
the nature o
f Mandamus directing the resp
ondents to continue/reinstate
the petition
er in service and adjust him
against an available Group-
D/Common
Cadre/Beldar/Canal Guard or
other equivalent sanctioned
post in th
e respondent Department/D
District/Circle or any other
appropriate e
establishment in accordance wi
th the applicable Government
instructions/
/policies and HKRNL policy, with
h continuity of service, arrears
salary/wages
s and all consequential benefits.
2.
It is inter alia submitted by ld. C
Counsel for the petitioner that
the petition
er is working as a Group-D
employee/Beldar under the
respondent
Irrigation Department. The pet
titioner was initially engaged
through cont
tractual/outsourcing arrangeme
ent and has been continuously
discharging h
his duties.
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 16:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-26135-20
026 (O&M) 3 of 11



3.
It is submitted that the petit
tioner was engaged through
Haryana Kau
ushal Rozgar Limited (hereinafte
er referred to as ‘HKRNL’) on
contractual
basis as Beldar on 15.10.2020
0. Thereafter petitioner was
issued reliev
ving order dated 17.01.2025 (A
Annexure P-4). The said order
was challen
ged by the petitioner alongw
with other similarly situated
persons befo
ore this Court by way of CWP-16
6918-2025 titled as Vikas and
others vs. St
tate of Haryana and others ; w
which was disposed of by this
Court vide o
order dated 29.04.2026 (Annex
xure P-17) in terms of order
dated 24.12.
2025 passed in CWP-7437-2025
5 titled as Renu and others vs.
State of Hary
yana and others .
4.
Ld. Counsel submits that the or
rder dated 24.12.2025 passed
in CWP-743
7-2025 categorically records t
the undertaking given by ld.
Advocate Ge
eneral, Haryana before this Cour
rt that the petitioners will not
be relieved
from the posts. However, de
espite the said undertaking,
respondent
No.4 has again passed non-spe
eaking impugned order dated
22.05.2026 (
Annexure P-18), which is in def
fiance of the directions passed
by this Court
t vide order dated 24.12.2025/29
9.4.2026.
5.
It is submitted that besides th
he fact that the order dated
22.05.2026 (
Annexure P-18) is in defiance o
of the directions of this Court,
even otherw
wise, the said order dated 22
2.05.2026 (Annexure P-18) is
unsustainabl
e as it is a non-speaking order. M
Moreover, it is along the same
lines as the p
previous relieving order, without
t assigning any cogent reasons.
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 16:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-26135-20
026 (O&M) 4 of 11



6.
Moreover, petitioner has compl
eted his 5 years’ service and is
therefore e
ntitled to the protection as
provided by the Haryana
Contractual
Employees (Security of Ser
rvice) Act, 2024. However,
respondents
are wrongly applying the rule o
of "First in First Out" in case of
the petitione
er. Thus, the impugned action
of the respondents is totally
illegal, arbitr
rary, discriminatory and uncons
stitutional as by adopting the
rule of First
in First Out in case of the co
ontractual employees like the
petitioner, th
he petitioner is being relieved
and in that event no other
employee li
ke the petitioner would be
able to complete 5 years'
uninterrupte
ed contractual service to gain the
e benefit and protection of the
Act, 2024.
7.
He accordingly prays that pres
ent Writ Petition be allowed;
and following
g prayers be accepted: -
“(i) A writ in the nature of
Certiorari for quashing the
impugned Speaking Order date
ed 22.05.2026 (Annexure P-18)
passed by Respondent No.4,
being non speaking cryptic
laconic without jurisdiction but
same is also contemptuous in
nature and thus legally not su
ustainable in the eyes of law
especially in view of the fact
that Hon'ble High Court vide
order dated 29.04.2026 while
setting aside the same very
relieving order of the petitione
er as group D direction were
also issued by this Hon'ble Hi
igh Court to take a decision
afresh at the level of the head
d of the department however
despite specific undertaking giv
ven by the Haryana on behalf
of the state as recorded in the
e order dated 29.04.2026 the
respondent department has now
w again passed the impugned
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 16:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-26135-20
026 (O&M) 5 of 11



order dated 22.05.2026 respec
tively in complete defiance of
the said undertaking and the d
direction of this Hon'ble High
Court illegally relieving the pe
etitioner from service on the
same lines by ignoring the dir
rection dated 29.04.2026 the
undertaking given by the learne
ed advocate general as well as
the provision of clause 11-A i
ii) of the deployment of the
contractual person policy, 202
22 as amended vide circular
dated 13.05.2025 (Annexure
P-18A) in wholly illegally
arbitrary, discriminatory and u
unconstitutional and thus the
impugned action of the respon
dent is legally not sustainable
in the eyes of law.
(ii) For issuance of a writ in the n
nature of Mandamus directing
the respondents to continue/rei
instate the petitioner in service
and adjust him against an
available Group-D/Common
Cadre/Beldar/Canal Guard or
other equivalent sanctioned
post in the respondent Depa
artment/District/Circle or any
other appropriate establishme
ent in accordance with the
applicable Government instructi
ions/policies and HKRNL policy,
with continuity of service, arre
ears of salary/wages and all
consequential benefits.”
8.
Per contra, ld. State Counsel a
appearing on advance notice
controverts
submissions of the petitioner
and submits that impugned
order dated
22.05.2026 (Annexure P-18) is
a speaking order; and cogent
reasons have
e been given for passing the sam
me. As such, there is no merit
to the presen
nt Writ Petition and the same de
eserves to be dismissed.
9.
No other argument has been
raised on behalf of learned
counsel for t
he parties. I have heard learned
counsel and perused the case
file in detail.
I find no merit in the submission
ns of the petitioner.
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 16:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-26135-20
026 (O&M) 6 of 11



10.
It is the first contention of th
he petitioner that vide order
dated 24.12.
2025 passed in CWP-7437-2025
5 titled as Renu and others vs.
State of Hary
yana and others, ld. Advocate G
General, Haryana had given an
undertaking
that the petitioners and other
persons similarly situate, will
not be reliev
ved. The said contention of th
he petitioner is misleading. A
perusal of
the order dated 24.12.2025
5 categorically records the
undertaking
of the ld. Advocate General, Har
ryana to be as follows: -
“The learned Advocate Genera
al, Haryana, having appeared
before this Court today to rende
er assistance in the matter, has,
undertaken assuring that the i
impugned relieving orders by
which the services of the peti
itioners were dispensed with
shall be withdrawn and they wi
ill be allowed to continue till a
f
fresh decision is taken. It has
further been stated that the
State shall undertake a fresh co
onsideration of the matter by
examining the case of each peti
tioner independently and shall
pass appropriate orders in accor
rdance with law.”
11.
Therefore, the only assurance
e given by the ld. Advocate
General, Ha
aryana was “ That the State
e shall undertake a fresh
consideration
n of the matter by examining
g the case of each petitioner
independentl
ly and shall pass appropriate or
rders in accordance with law.”
and till a fr
resh decision is taken, petitio
ners were to be allowed to
continue in
service. Thus, there is no viola
ation of any direction of this
Court. In the
e present case also, a fresh con
nsideration of the case of the
petitioner w
was undertaken by the respond
dent; whereafter the present
impugned or
rder has been passed.
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 16:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-26135-20
026 (O&M) 7 of 11



12.
It has further been contend
ded by ld. Counsel for the
petitioner th
hat posts are still lying vacant. H
However, perusal of impugned
order dated
22.05.2026 (Annexure P-18) s
shows that respondents have
categorically
stated that there are no posts o
of Beldar presently available.
13.
Petitioner has further stated th
hat he is entitled to protection
under the A
Act, 2024 as he has rendered m
more than 5 years of service.
However, ev
en the said contention of the
petitioner is misconceived as
admittedly, p
petitioner was appointed on 15
.10.2020; whereas the cut off
date as per t
the Act, 2024 is 15.08.2019. As a
appointment of the petitioner
was not pri
or to 15.08.2019, therefore,
petitioner is not entitled to
protection un
nder the Act, 2024.
14.
It has also been contended by
the petitioner that impugned
order dated
22.05.2026 is not a speaking
order. The said contention is
factually inc
orrect. The relevant extract o
f the impugned order dated
22.05.2026 (A
Annexure P-18) reads as follows
s: -
“In com
mpliance with the aforesaid dir
rections, the matter has been
re-exa
mined objectively and independ
ently on the basis of:
1.
Pleadings and representation su
ubmitted by the petitioner;
2.
Service record and engagement
t particulars of the petitioner;
3.
Applicable Government Instruct
ions/policies;
4.
Availability of sanctioned vacan
t posts;
5.
Provisions of the Haryana Contr
ractual Employees (Security of
Service) Act, 2024; and
6.
Record available in the office.
Government Instruction/ Policy
y Position
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 16:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-26135-20
026 (O&M) 8 of 11



The Chief Secretary to Go
vernment Haryana, Human
Resources Department vide m
memo no. 01/39/2023-2CC-I
dated 27.12.2024 and Memo
No. 01/39/2023-2CC-I dated
15.01.2025 has issued deta
ailed instructions regarding
adjustment of newly recruite
ed Group-D/Common Cadre
employees and retention of eligi
ible contractual employees.
.
The relevant provisions inter alia
a provide that:
.
Newly recruited regular Group
-D/Common cadre employees
are to be adjusted against sanct
tioned posts.
.
Contractual employees engag
ed prior to 15.08.2019 and
covered under the Haryana Co
ntractual Employees (Security
of Service) Act, 2024 are to be p
protected.
.
In case of non-availability of v
vacant sanctioned posts after
such adjustment, HKRNL/contra
actual employees not covered
under the said Act are liable
to be relieved as per policy,
applying "First In First Out" prin
ciple wherever applicable.
The pe
etitioner submitted representatio
on dated 06.05.2026 inter alia
stating
g that he has been working
continuously, possesses the
requisi
ite qualifications, has rendered
d satisfactory service and may
be allo
owed to continue.
The s
aid representation has been
duly considered along with
comple
ete service record.
Factua
al Position Regarding Sanctione
ed Posts
After
adjustment of regular Group-D
D/Common Cadre employees
and co
ontractual employees covered u
under the Haryana employees
(Securi
ity of Service) Act, 2024, the po
osition of posts in this office is
as und
der:
Sr.
No.
Name of
f Post Total no.
of sanc-
tioned
Regular em-
ployees in
Position
Contr
Emplo
under
Servic
ractual/HKRNL
Vacant
Post
available
HKRNL Em
ployees n
covered u
der Securi
Act
m-
oyees covered
r Security of
ce Act
ot
un-
ity
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 16:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-26135-20
026 (O&M) 9 of 11



1. Beldar/C
Guard
Canal 78 72 16
Nil 15

Findings
Upon careful
l examination, the following find
ding are recorded:
1. The
petitioner was engaged
through HKRNL/Contractual
arrang
gement and does not hold any re
egular sanctioned post.
2. The p
petitioner is not covered und
der the Haryana Contractual
Emplo
yees (Security of Service) Act, 20
024.
3. After
adjustment of regular Group-
-D employees and protected
contra
actual employees, no vacant s
sanctioned post of Beldar is
availab
ble in this office.
4. Contin
nuation of the petitioner in the a
absence of a sanctioned vacant
post w
would be violative of the Go
overnment instruction dated
27.12.
2024 and 15.01.2025.
5. The pe
etitioner has no indefeasible leg
gal right to continue against a
non-ex
xistent vacant post.
Therefore, af
fter due consideration of the H
Hon'ble High Court Judgment,
the represen
ntation of the petitioner, applic
cable Government instruction,
the provision
ns of the Haryana Contractual E
Employees (Security of Service)
Act, 2024 an
nd the factual position of sanctio
oned posts, it is hereby odered
that:
The Service/E
Engagement of Sh. Vikas, Sh. Ra
kesh Yadav & Sh. Vikash Yadav
engaged th
hrough HKRNL/contractual ar
rrangement as Beldar are
dispensed w
with relieved with immediate eff
fect due to non-availability of
sanctioned v
vacant post after lawful adjustm
ment of regular and protected
contractual e
employees.”
15.
From a bare reading of the
above, it is clear that the
respondents
have examined every aspect o
of the matter threadbare and
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 16:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-26135-20
026 (O&M) 10 of 11



passed the i
mpugned order only thereafte
r. The respondents have duly
considered t
he vacancy position, and passed
d the impugned order, keeping
in mind the
rights of the regularly appoint
ted candidates after following
due process
of selection through HSSC; agai
inst those who have rendered
contractual s
service for five years and are t
herefore protected under the
2024 Act; an
d persons such as the petitione
r who has not been appointed
before the c
ut-off date; thereafter, relieving
g/impugned orders of surplus
employees h
have been issued. In the impug
gned order dated 22.05.2026
(Annexure P-
-18), respondent-State has delin
neated the factual position; as
also the reas
sons for relieving the petitioner
r from the post of Beldar. The
impugned o
order therefore reflects app
lication of mind, equitable
construction
of selection, as also rationale.
16.
Respondents have also catego
rically stated that services of
the petitione
er have been relieved as there is
s no available sanctioned post
after adjust
ting regular appointees and
the protected contractual
employees.
From the above facts, it is cl
ear that continuation of the
petitioner ag
gainst non-available sanctioned
post, would be in violation of
the Governm
ment Instructions dated 27.12
2.2024 and 15.01.2025. Very
importantly,
the said Instructions have n
not been challenged by the
petitioner. It
is also clear that petitioner wa
as appointed after the cut off
date of 15.08
8.2019 and, therefore, protectio
on under the Act, 2024 is not
available to t
the petitioner.
NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 16:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP-26135-20
026 (O&M) 11 of 11



17.
Ld. Counsel for the petitioner
r is unable to controvert or
dispute the a
above said factual position.
18.
Consequentially, I find no meri
t in the present Writ Petition
and the same
e stands dismissed .
19.
Pending application(s) if any also
o stand(s) disposed of.


13.11.2026


Whether speaking/reasoned:
Whether reportable:

(NIDHI GUPTA)
JUDGE
Yes/No
Yes/No
neelam


NEELAM KUMARI
2026.11.17 16:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document