Mahila Mukhi vs Hardas

Court
Madhya Pradesh High Court

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
1 WP-10797-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR

BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
WRIT PETITION No. 10797 of 2025
CNR No.: MPHC030076002025
MAHILA MUKHI AND OTHERS
Versus
HARDAS AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri N K Gupta - Senior Advocate with Shri Y P S Rathore - Advocate
for petitioners.
Shri Dharmendra Nayak - Govt. Advocate for respondents No.5 and
6/State.
Shri Pralok Kumar Tiwari - Advocate for respondents No.1 to 4.
Reserved on : 29.10.2026
Pronounced on : 18.11.2026
ORDER
The petitioners have preferred the present petition under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India, calling in question the legality and validity of the
order dated 23.02.2021 passed by the Commissioner, Gwalior Division,
Gwalior, in Case No.710/Appeal/2017-18, whereby the appeal preferred by
the petitioners came to be dismissed, thereby affirming the order dated
12.07.2018 passed by the Sub-Divisional Officer, Karera, District Shivpuri,
in Case No.100/2012-13/Appeal.
The controversy involved in the present petition relates to settlement
of land bearing Survey No.247/min-1, situated at Village Sirsona, Tehsil
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
2 WP-10797-2025
Karera, District Shivpuri, in favour of late Shri Narayan, the predecessor-in-

interest of the petitioners. The petitioners claim that the land in question was
duly settled in favour of late Shri Narayan by the Tehsildar vide order dated
08.09.1997, after following the prescribed procedure and taking into
consideration the relevant provisions of the Revenue Book Circular.
It is the case of the petitioners that late Shri Narayan had submitted an
application seeking settlement of the aforesaid land, which was adjacent to
his existing land. According to the petitioners, he fulfilled the prescribed
eligibility conditions for settlement of Government land, as his existing
landholding was within the permissible limits. Upon receipt of the
application, the Tehsildar initiated the requisite proceedings, issued
publication inviting objections from the persons likely to be affected,
obtained the spot report from the subordinate revenue authorities and, after
considering the relevant material, passed the order dated 08.09.1997 settling
the land in favour of late Shri Narayan. After a considerable lapse of
approximately fourteen years, the private respondents preferred an appeal
before the Sub-Divisional Officer, Karera, challenging the settlement order
dated 08.09.1997. The challenge was primarily founded on the allegation that
the Tehsildar had not properly examined the eligibility of late Shri Narayan
and the settlement had been made contrary to the provisions of the Revenue
Book Circular. The petitioners have further pleaded that the appeal was
entertained after an inordinate delay of fourteen years, without there being
any application seeking condonation of delay. It is also their case that the
proceedings before the Sub-Divisional Officer were initially heard on
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
3 WP-10797-2025
04.04.2018 and the matter was reserved for orders. However, in the

meantime, the Presiding Officer was transferred and the matter came to be
placed before the newly appointed Presiding Officer. According to the
petitioners, on 08.05.2018, the newly appointed Presiding Officer passed an
order directing that the next date of hearing be communicated to the counsel
appearing for the petitioners. The matter was thereafter fixed for arguments
on 23.05.2018. However, the concerned clerk failed to communicate the said
date to the counsel for the petitioners. Consequently, neither the petitioners
nor their counsel could appear before the authority on the relevant date. The
proceedings thereafter culminated in the order dated 12.07.2018, whereby
the earlier settlement order dated 08.09.1997 was set aside and the land in
question was directed to be treated as Government land. Being aggrieved by
the aforesaid order, the petitioners preferred an appeal before the
Commissioner, Gwalior Division, Gwalior, which was registered as Case
No.710/Appeal/2017-18. However, the learned Commissioner, vide order
dated 23.02.2021, dismissed the appeal and affirmed the order passed by the
Sub-Divisional Officer. Hence, the present petition.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that both the
impugned orders are contrary to law, suffer from jurisdictional infirmities
and have been passed in gross violation of the principles of natural justice. It
is contended that the original settlement order dated 08.09.1997 was passed
by the competent revenue authority after following the prescribed procedure,
including publication inviting objections and obtaining the requisite spot
report. The petitioners, therefore, acquired rights in respect of the land in
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
4 WP-10797-2025
question pursuant to a duly passed order, which could not have been

interfered with in such a casual manner after the lapse of approximately
fourteen years.
It was further submitted that the appeal preferred by the private
respondents before the Sub-Divisional Officer was hopelessly barred by
limitation. The authority entertained the appeal after a lapse of nearly
fourteen years without there being any application for condonation of delay.
In the absence of such an application and an order passed thereon, the
proceedings could not have been lawfully entertained. Learned counsel
submits that the Sub-Divisional Officer could not have bypassed the
statutory requirement of limitation merely by describing the original
settlement as contrary to the applicable rules.
It is also argued that the Sub-Divisional Officer committed a serious
procedural illegality by deciding the matter without affording an effective
opportunity of hearing to the petitioners. The earlier Presiding Officer had
heard the matter on 04.04.2018 and reserved it for orders. Upon transfer of
the said officer, the successor Presiding Officer, on 08.05.2018, directed that
the next date be communicated to the counsel for the petitioners. However,
owing to the failure of the concerned clerk to communicate the date, the
petitioners' counsel could not appear when the matter was taken up for
hearing. The subsequent order dated 12.07.2018, which adversely affected
the valuable rights of the petitioners, was thus passed without providing them
an effective opportunity to contest the proceedings.
Learned counsel further submits that the Sub-Divisional Officer has
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
5 WP-10797-2025
virtually exercised the powers of appeal as well as review under Sections 44

and 51 of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959, in the same
proceedings, which is impermissible in law. It is contended that if the
authority intended to exercise suo motu or review jurisdiction, the same
could not have been exercised beyond the period prescribed by law.
It is further submitted that the Sub-Divisional Officer entertained the
appeal without the certified copy of the original order dated 08.09.1997
passed by the Tehsildar and without any order granting exemption from
filing the same. This, according to learned counsel, constitutes yet another
procedural irregularity which vitiates the entire proceedings.
Referring to Para 24, Part-IV, Chapter 3 of the Revenue Book
Circular, learned counsel submitted that the settlement in favour of late Shri
Narayan was consistent with the applicable provisions. It is pointed out that
the petitioners' land bearing Survey No.250/1 is adjacent to the land bearing
Survey No.247/min-1, and late Shri Narayan fulfilled the prescribed
eligibility conditions. It is, therefore, submitted that the authorities below
have failed to appreciate the relevant provisions as well as the material
available on record.
Learned counsel placed specific reliance upon the decision of the
Division Bench of this Court in Shahid Anwar v. Board of Revenue, 2000
RN 76, wherein it has been held that no order affecting the rights of a party
and reopening concluded proceedings can be passed without affording notice
and an opportunity of hearing to the affected party. It is contended that the
aforesaid principle squarely applies to the facts of the present case, as the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
6 WP-10797-2025
settlement made in favour of the petitioners' predecessor-in-interest in the

year 1997 was reopened and set aside after a considerable lapse of time,
without affording an effective opportunity of hearing to the petitioners. It is,
accordingly, prayed that the impugned orders dated 12.07.2018 and
23.02.2021 be quashed.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the State, while opposing the
petition, submits that no illegality or jurisdictional error has been committed
by the authorities below. It has been specifically contended that the land
bearing Survey No.247/min-1, admeasuring 0.45 hectare, was settled in
favour of late Shri Narayan contrary to the applicable provisions of the
Revenue Book Circular.
Learned counsel for the State submits that under Clause 24(3), Part-
IV, Chapter 3 of the Revenue Book Circular, in respect of a small piece of
land measuring less than two hectares, the settlement was required to be
made in favour of a person having his own adjoining land, after following the
prescribed procedure. However, in the present case, the settlement was made
in favour of late Shri Narayan without preparing the requisite list of
landholders of the village and without issuing any publication or
advertisement in accordance with the applicable procedure.
It is further submitted that the authorities, upon examination of the
revenue record, found that the original settlement had been made contrary to
the prescribed rules and procedure. Therefore, the Sub-Divisional Officer
rightly interfered with the settlement and directed that the land be treated as
Government land. Learned counsel submits that the question of limitation
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
7 WP-10797-2025
would not come in the way of the competent authority when an illegality in

the settlement of Government land is noticed from the record.
It is also submitted that the learned Commissioner, while examining
the matter in appeal, duly considered the relevant facts and circumstances
and rightly concluded that the predecessor of the petitioners, late Shri
Narayan, was not entitled to the settlement of the land in question. It is
further contended that Survey No.250/1, relied upon by the petitioners, is not
adjacent to the land bearing Survey No.247/1, which was settled in favour of
late Shri Narayan. Thus, according to the State, the petitioners have failed to
establish any entitlement to the land in question. Learned counsel for the
State, therefore, submits that the impugned orders have been passed after due
consideration of the revenue record and the applicable provisions of law and
do not warrant interference in the exercise of writ jurisdiction. Accordingly,
dismissal of the petition is prayed for.
Heard counsel for the parties and perused the record.
From the material available on record, it is apparent that the original
settlement order was passed by the Tehsildar on 08.09.1997. The petitioners
have specifically pleaded that the proceedings leading to the said settlement
were undertaken after publication inviting objections, obtaining the spot
report and considering the relevant material. The said settlement remained
operative for a considerable period of approximately fourteen years, until it
was challenged before the Sub-Divisional Officer.
The State has sought to justify the subsequent interference on the
ground that the original settlement was contrary to Clause 24(3), Part-IV,
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
8 WP-10797-2025
Chapter 3 of the Revenue Book Circular, as the requisite procedure had

allegedly not been followed. However, even assuming that the authority was
of the view that some irregularity had occurred in the original settlement,
such an allegation, by itself, could not dispense with the requirement of
following the principles of natural justice before passing an order having
civil consequences and adversely affecting the rights flowing from the earlier
settlement.
The record further indicates that the proceedings before the Sub-
Divisional Officer were initially heard on 04.04.2018, when the matter was
reserved for orders. Thereafter, upon transfer of the Presiding Officer, the
matter came to be placed before the successor Presiding Officer, who, on
08.05.2018, directed that the next date of hearing be communicated to the
counsel for the petitioners. The petitioners have specifically asserted that the
said date was not communicated to their counsel by the concerned clerk and,
consequently, they could not appear when the matter was taken up. The
proceedings ultimately culminated in the order dated 12.07.2018, whereby
the settlement made in favour of their predecessor-in-interest was set aside
and the land was declared to be Government land.
In the considered opinion of this Court, when a matter which had
already been heard by the predecessor Presiding Officer and reserved for
orders was taken up afresh by the successor Presiding Officer, it was
incumbent upon the authority to ensure that the affected parties were duly
informed of the date fixed for further hearing. The direction contained in the
order-sheet itself contemplated communication of the date to the counsel
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
9 WP-10797-2025
appearing for the petitioners. In such circumstances, passing an adverse

order without ensuring effective communication of the hearing date and
without affording an effective opportunity of hearing to the petitioners
cannot be sustained in law.
The aforesaid course of action is also contrary to the settled legal
position laid down by the Division Bench of this Court in Shahid Anwar v.
Board of Revenue and Another, 2000 RN 76. In the said judgment, the
Division Bench has categorically held that even if the authority possesses the
power to review or reopen an earlier order, the affected party is necessarily
required to be put to notice and afforded an opportunity of being heard. No
order affecting the interests of a party and reopening proceedings which had
attained finality can be passed behind the back of such party. The relevant
observation of the Division Bench reads as under:
"Even if it was assumed that the power of review was available in
the given case still appellant deserved to be put on notice and
afforded an opportunity of being heard. Because no order affecting
his interests and re-opening the exchange deal concluded years
back could be passed at his back and without affording him
opportunity of being heard. Moreover, it would be innocuous to
provide him such opportunity in the given facts and circumstances
of the case which would cause prejudice to none, least of all to the
interests of the State."
The aforesaid judgment squarely emphasizes that the requirement of
notice and opportunity of hearing is not an empty formality but an essential
component of fair adjudication, particularly where an earlier order conferring
rights upon a party is sought to be reopened after a considerable lapse of
time. The said principle has also been reiterated by this Court in subsequent
decisions, including Jai Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh, Writ Petition
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
10 WP-10797-2025
No.22033 of 2019, decided on 18.04.2026

Applying the aforesaid principle to the facts of the present case, this
Court is of the considered view that the Sub-Divisional Officer ought to have
ensured that the petitioners were afforded an effective opportunity of hearing
before passing an order which had the effect of setting aside the settlement
made in favour of their predecessor-in-interest and declaring the land in
question as Government land. The fact that the authority was examining the
legality of the original settlement would not absolve it of its obligation to
adhere to the principles of natural justice.
It is equally significant that the original settlement was made on
08.09.1997, whereas the proceedings challenging the same were initiated
after approximately fourteen years. The question as to whether such
proceedings were maintainable in the absence of an appropriate application
for condonation of delay, and whether the authority could exercise its
appellate or review jurisdiction in the manner adopted, were material
questions which required proper consideration by the competent authority.
These issues could not have been brushed aside while passing an order
having serious civil consequences for the petitioners.
The learned Commissioner, while exercising appellate jurisdiction,
was also required to examine the aforesaid procedural infirmities,
particularly the specific grievance regarding non-communication of the date
of hearing and the absence of an effective opportunity of hearing before the
Sub-Divisional Officer. However, the impugned order dated 23.02.2021 does
not satisfactorily address the aforesaid fundamental issue. The appellate
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
11 WP-10797-2025
authority ought to have examined whether the proceedings culminating in

the order dated 12.07.2018 were conducted in accordance with the settled
principles of natural justice.
This Court is conscious of the submission advanced on behalf of the
State that the original settlement was allegedly made contrary to the
provisions of the Revenue Book Circular. However, the legality or otherwise
of the original settlement is a matter which is required to be examined by the
competent authority after affording due opportunity to all concerned parties.
An allegation of irregularity in the original settlement cannot, by itself,
justify dispensing with the mandatory requirement of a fair hearing,
particularly when the subsequent proceedings are intended to deprive a party
of rights flowing from an earlier order.
It is a settled proposition of law that whenever an authority exercises
its jurisdiction in a manner which affects the civil rights of a party,
compliance with the principles of natural justice is indispensable, unless
expressly excluded by the governing statute. An order passed in breach of
such principles cannot be sustained merely on the ground that the authority
otherwise possessed jurisdiction to examine the controversy.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the order dated 12.07.2018 passed by the Sub-Divisional
Officer, Karera, District Shivpuri, suffers from a serious procedural
infirmity, as the petitioners were not afforded an effective opportunity of
hearing before the matter was finally decided. The subsequent order dated
23.02.2021 passed by the Commissioner, Gwalior Division, Gwalior,
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
12 WP-10797-2025
affirming the aforesaid order without adequately addressing the said

infirmity, also cannot be sustained.
Accordingly, the writ petition deserves to be and is hereby allowed.
The impugned order dated 23.02.2021 passed by the Commissioner, Gwalior
Division, Gwalior, in Case No.710/Appeal/2017-18, as well as the order
dated 12.07.2018 passed by the Sub-Divisional Officer, Karera, District
Shivpuri, in Case No.100/2012-13/Appeal, are hereby quashed and set aside.
The matter is remitted to the Sub-Divisional Officer, Karera, District
Shivpuri, for fresh consideration in accordance with law. The authority shall
afford an effective opportunity of hearing to all the concerned parties,
including the petitioners, and thereafter pass a reasoned and speaking order
after considering the objections and submissions advanced by them. The
authority shall also examine the objection relating to limitation,
maintainability of the proceedings and the applicability of the relevant
provisions of the Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code, 1959, independently
and in accordance with law.
It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the
merits of the matter. The competent authority shall decide the controversy
uninfluenced by any observation made hereinabove, strictly in accordance
with law. The aforesaid exercise shall be undertaken expeditiously,
preferably within a period of six months from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this order.
With the aforesaid directions, the petition stands allowed and disposed
of.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-GWL:34446
13 WP-10797-2025

(MILIND RAMESH PHADKE)
JUDGE
ojha

Signature Not Verified
Signed by: YOGENDRA
OJHA
Signing time: 11/19/2026
10:39:32 AM