Bodhgaya Hotel Association vs The State Of Bihar and Ors

Court
Patna High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.7869 of 2026
======================================================
Bodhgaya Hotel Association through its General Secretary Sudama Kumar,
aged about 56 years, Gender- Male, S/o- Late Mangal Chand Prasad, R/o-
Bodhgaya Hotel Mahamaya Palace, Near Sujata Bridge, Bodh Gaya, P.S-
Bodh Gaya, District Gaya.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through Chief Secretary, Govt. Of Bihar, Patna.
2. The Home Secretary Govt. of Bihar, Patna.
3. The Principal Secretary Urban Development and Housing Department,
Govt. of Bihar, Patna.
4. Divisional commissioner Magadh Division, Gaya.
5. The District magistrate, Gaya.
6. Executive Officer, Nagar Panchayat, Bodhgaya.
7. The Secretary Bodhgaya Temple management Committee Bodhgaya.
8. Circle Officer, Bodhgaya.
9. Officer In charged Bodhgaya Police station, Bodhgaya.
10. Monk-In-Charge Maha Bodhi Maha Vihara, Bodhgaya.
11. Monk-In-Charge Maha Bodhi Society of India, Bodhgaya.
12. Monk-In-Charge All India Bhikkhu Sangha, Bodhgaya.
13. Monk-In-Charge Amitabh Meditation Centre (Drikung Charitable Society),
Bodhgaya.
14. Monk-In-Charge Asian Buddhist Cultural Centre, Bodhgaya.
15. Monk-In-Charge Anand Vihara Anandamitra Memorial Trust, Bodhgaya.
16. Monk-In-Charge Dr. Kalyan Priya Bangladesh Buddhist Monastery,
Bodhgaya.
17. Monk-In-Charge Dr. Ratna Buddhist Thai Bharat Society, Bodhgaya.
18. Monk-In-Charge Bodhidruma International Rampur, Bodhgaya.
19. Monk-In-Charge Burmese Vihara Bodhgaya.
20. Monk-In-Charge Buddhagaya Bana Vihara Bodhgaya.
21. Monk-In-Charge Bhante Vishuddhanand Bodhi Bodhgaya.
22. Monk-In-Charge Buddha Dhamma Sangha Bodhgaya.
23. Monk-In-Charge TINH XA VIET AN-Buddha, Near Tergar Monastery
Bodhgaya.

Patna High Court CWJC No.7869 of 2026 dt.09-09-2026
2/11
24. Monk-In-Charge Mahabodhi Chinese Temple Bodhgaya.
25. Monk-In-Charge Chakma Buddhist Foundation Bodhgaya.
26. Monk-In-Charge Cambodian Buddhist Monastery Bodhgaya.
27. Monk-In-Charge Daijokyo Buddhist Temple Bodhgaya.
28. Monk-In-Charge Druk Ngawang Thubten Choeling Bodhgaya.
29. Monk-In-Charge Dhammabodhi Meditation Centre-Vipassana Meditation
Centre Bodhgaya.
30. Monk-In-Charge Fo Guang Shan Institute of Buddhist Studies Bodhgaya.
31. Monk-In-Charge Gadhen Phelgayling Charitable Trust Bodhgaya.
32. Monk-In-Charge Great Holy Land Monastery Bodhgaya.
33. Monk-In-Charge International Mediation Centre Bodhgaya.
34. Monk-In-Charge International Buddhist Brotherhood Association of India-
Indo-San Nipponji (Japanese Temple) Bodhgaya.
35. Monk-In-Charge Kagyupa Monlam International Trust Bodhgaya.
36. Monk-In-Charge Khuva Boonchum Tai Temple Bodhgaya.
37. Monk-In-Charge KARMA THARJAY CHOKHORLING KAGYUPA
BUDDHIST MONASTERY (Karma Temple) Bodhgaya.
38. Monk-In-Charge Mula Sangha Religious Trust, Old Taridih Mastipur,
Bodhgaya.
39. Monk-In-Charge Korea Temple Bodhgaya.
40. Monk-In-Charge Linh Son Monastery Bodhgaya.
41. Monk-In-Charge Maha Bodhi Meditation Centre Bodhgaya.
42. Monk-In-Charge Maitri Charitable trust Bodhgaya.
43. Monk-In-Charge Metta Buddharam Monsatery Bodhgaya.
44. Monk-In-Charge Nyingma Monlam Chenmo International Foundation
Bodhgaya.
45. Monk-In-Charge Nepali Tamang Buddhist Temple Bodhgaya.
46. Monk-In-Charge Panchasila Vihara Bodhgaya.
47. Monk-In-Charge Palyul Namdroling Monastery Penor Rinpoche Charity
Foundation Bodhgaya.
48. Monk-In-Charge Royal Wat Thai Bodhgaya.
49. Monk-In-Charge Root Institute for wisdom and culture Bodhgaya.
50. Monk-In-Charge Ratana Bodhi Vihara Bodhgaya.
51. Monk-In-Charge Ramanyabhumi Buddha Viahara Bodhgaya.
52. Monk-In-Charge Shechen Tennyi Dhargyeline Bodhgaya.
53. Monk-In-Charge Sikkim Temple Guest House Bodhgaya.
54. Monk-In-Charge Sakya Monastery Charitable Trust Bodhgaya.

Patna High Court CWJC No.7869 of 2026 dt.09-09-2026
3/11
55. Monk-In-Charge Taiwan Temple Bodhgaya.
56. Monk-In-Charge Tai Bodhi Kham Bodhgaya.
57. Monk-In-Charge Yongey Terger Monastery Bodhgaya.
58. Monk-In-Charge Vietnam Temple (Bhagalpur).
59. Monk-In-Charge Vien Giac Institute Bodhgaya.
60. Monk-In-Charge Vajrasana Temple, Katorowa Bodhgaya.
61. Monk-In-Charge Wat Thai Magadh Temple Bodhgaya.
62. Monk-In-Charge Wat Lao International, Bodhgaya.
63. Monk-In-Charge Mongolia Temple, Bodhgaya.
64. Monk-In-Charge Bodhidruma International Rmapur, Bodhgaya.
65. Monk-In-Charge Royal Bhuan Temple Bodhgaya.
66. Monk-In-Charge Vimalthung Chai Buddha Hall (New) Sangmitra Buddha
Vihara Bodhgaya.
67. Monk-In-Charge Wat Niranjanawas Bodhgaya.
68. Monk-In-Charge Wat Paknam Temple Bodhgaya.
69. Monk-In-Charge Teza Mangala Vihar Bodhgaya.
70. Monk-In-Charge Wat Thai Buddha Savika Bodhgaya.
71. Monk-In-Charge Wat Bhuripalo Bodhgaya.
72. Monk-In-Charge Wat Thai, Bodhgaya.
73. Monk-In-Charge Sanghamitra Foundation, Bodhgaya.
74. Monk-In-Charge Mahabodhi Charitable Trust, Bodhgaya.
75. Monk-In-Charge Dr. Ambedkar Bhawan, International Buddhist Sansad,
Bodhgaya.
76. Monk-In-Charge International Phat Hoa Binh Trust Bodhgaya.
77. Monk-In-Charge Bodhiraja Monastery Bodhgaya.
78. Monk-In-Charge The Pearl Mahavihar Kotorwa Road Bodhgaya.
79. Monk-In-Charge M.M.C Muni Institute Bodhgaya.
80. Monk-In-Charge Kambodia Monastery Bodhgaya.
81. Monk-In-Charge Mynmar Monastery Bodhgaya.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
with
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 1396 of 2017
======================================================

Patna High Court CWJC No.7869 of 2026 dt.09-09-2026
4/11
Bodhgaya Hotel Association Son of Mandal Chand Prasad Resident of -
Bodhgaya Hotel Mahamaya Palace, near Sujata Bridge, Bodhgaya, P.S.
Bodhgaya, Distt. Gaya.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through Chief Secretary, Govt. of Bihar, Patna.
2. The Home Secretary Govt of Bihar, Patna.
3. The Principal Secretary Urban Development and Housing Department,
Govt. of Bihar, Patna.
4. The Divisional Commissioner, Magadh Division, Gaya.
5. The District Magistrate, Gaya.
6. Executive Officer, Nagar Panchayat, Bodhgaya.
7. The Secretary Bodhgaya Temple Management Committee, Bodhgaya.
8. Circle Officer, Bodhgaya.
9. Officer In Charge Bodhgaya Police Station, Bodhgaya.
10. Monk-In-Charge Myanmar Temple Bodhgaya.
11. Monk-In-Charge Teygar Monasery Temple Bodhgaya. null null
12. Monk-In-Charge Dai Jokya Temple Bodhgaya.
13. Monk-In-charge Vietnam Temple Bodhgaya.
14. Monk-In-Charge Royal Thai Temple Bodhgaya.
15. Monk-In-Charge Holl and Temple Bodhgaya.
16. Monk-In-Charge Srilanka Mahabodhi Temple Bodhgaya.
17. Monk-In-Charge Taiban Temple Bodhgaya.
18. Monk-In-Charge Wat Paknam Monastery Bodhgaya.
19. Monk-In-Charge Bhootan Temple Bodhgaya.
20. Monk-In-Charge Vatpa Thai Temple Bodhgaya.
21. Monk-In-Charge Tregar Karmapa Monastery Bodhgaya.
22. Monk-In-Charge Thai Magadh Temple Bodhgaya.
23. Monk-In-Charge Cambodia Temple Bodhgaya..
24. Monk-In-Charge Nigma Monastery , Bodhgaya.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 7869 of 2026)
For the Petitioner/s : Ms. Shweta Anand, Advocate

Patna High Court CWJC No.7869 of 2026 dt.09-09-2026
5/11
For the Respondent : Mr. Standing Counsel (06)
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 1396 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s : Ms. Shweta Anand, Advocate
For the State : Mr. S.D. Sanjay, AG
Mr. P.V. Verma, AAG 3
Mr. Sanjay Kumar Ghosarvey, AC to AAG 3
For the Nagar Panchayat : Mr. Ashok Kumar, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH KUMAR VERMA
ORAL JUDGMENT
(Per: HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE)
Date : 09-09-2026
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2. The present writ applications have been filed in the
form of Public Interest Litigation for the following reliefs:
"1 (i). For issuance of a writ in the
nature of mandamus for giving a direction to take
suitable action and restrained the respondents no.
10 to 81 to use and utilize in their respective
maths/Monasteries commercial use.
(ii). For giving a direction to make an
enquiry to take actions against the illegal
construction of maths/monasteries of resp. no. 10
to 81 which have been constructed in violation of
Municipal Act and Building Bye Laws.
(iii). For giving a direction to make
implementation of the order and direction passed
by the state Govt. in its review meeting dated
01.07.2016 within stipulated time.
(iv) Any Other relief/reliefs which this
Hon'ble court may deem fit and proper in the fact
and circumstances of the Present case."
3. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that various constructions at different sites in Bodh

Patna High Court CWJC No.7869 of 2026 dt.09-09-2026
6/11
Gaya, including constructions raised by the Maths/Monasteries ,
are unauthorized and have been made in violation of the
applicable Building Bye-Laws and other statutory provisions. It
is further submitted that certain Maths/Monasteries are being
utilised for commercial purposes and that various Monasteries
with facilities like star-category hotels have come up in and
around the Mahabodhi Temple.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits
that such constructions and commercial activities are contrary to
the statutory provisions, and adversely affect the religious and
spiritual character of such Maths/Monasteries . It is also
submitted that the activities being carried on in the name of the
Maths/Monasteries result in loss of revenue to the Government.
Learned counsel, therefore, submits that appropriate directions
be issued to the concerned authorities to enquire into the alleged
violations, take action against unauthorized constructions and
ensure implementation of the directions issued by the State
Government in its review meeting dated 01.07.2016.
5. Learned counsel appearing for the State submits
that the issue relating to the alleged unauthorized constructions
has already been considered by the competent local authority.
Notices were issued in respect of the constructions in question

Patna High Court CWJC No.7869 of 2026 dt.09-09-2026
7/11
and, upon inquiry, five monasteries were found to have
undertaken construction in accordance with the sanctioned
building plans, whereas in respect of certain other monasteries,
deviations from the sanctioned plans were noticed and necessary
action was taken in accordance with law.
6. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent- Maths/Monasteries submits that the various
Maths/Monasteries situated at Bodh Gaya represent different
schools and traditions of Buddhism. It is submitted that the
Buddhist traditions represented by the monasteries include,
broadly, the Theravada, Mahayana and Vajrayana traditions,
each having its own religious practices, teachings and
institutional traditions. The monasteries, therefore, are not
merely establishments engaged in any commercial activity, but
are religious and spiritual institutions serving the followers of
their respective Buddhist traditions.
7. Learned counsel further submits that the
monasteries facilitate their followers, monks, pilgrims and other
persons visiting Bodh Gaya for religious purposes by providing
accommodation and space within their respective campuses,
including through ashrams and other residential facilities. Such
facilities are incidental to the religious and spiritual functions of

Patna High Court CWJC No.7869 of 2026 dt.09-09-2026
8/11
the monasteries and cannot, merely on that account, be
characterised as commercial activities or as being undertaken
for the purpose of conducting business.
8. It is further submitted that Bodh Gaya is a place of
immense religious and spiritual significance for followers of
Buddhism from different parts of the country and the world.
Persons visit Bodh Gaya for meditation, prayer, religious
observances, study and to follow the teachings of the respective
Buddhist traditions. The provision of accommodation and other
facilities by the monasteries to their followers and visitors is,
therefore, essentially connected with the religious and spiritual
purpose for which the monasteries have been established.
9. Having considered the submissions advanced on
behalf of the parties and upon perusal of the materials available
on record, this Court is of the considered view that the present
proceeding, though styled as a Public Interest Litigation,
essentially concerns the manner of use and utilisation of the
various Maths/Monasteries situated at Bodh Gaya.
10. The petitioner is an Association of Hotels. The
principal relief sought in the present proceeding, inter alia, is for
restraining the Maths/Monasteries from using and utilising their
respective premises for commercial purposes. In the facts and

Patna High Court CWJC No.7869 of 2026 dt.09-09-2026
9/11
circumstances of the present case, particularly having regard to
the nature of the activities explained on behalf of the
respondent- Maths/Monasteries , this Court is unable to accept
that the present proceeding constitutes a genuine Public Interest
Litigation.
11. The jurisdiction of this Court in a Public Interest
Litigation is intended to advance a genuine cause of public
interest and cannot be permitted to be invoked for pursuing a
dispute which, in substance, concerns competing interests of
particular establishments or associations. Merely couching the
relief in terms of enforcement of statutory provisions would not,
by itself, confer the character of a Public Interest Litigation
upon a proceeding which essentially seeks to regulate the
activities of particular establishments.
12. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances,
this Court finds no merit in the present Public Interest
Litigation.
13. Accordingly, both the writ applications stand
dismissed.
14. It is, however, made clear that dismissal of the
present proceeding shall not preclude the competent authorities
from taking appropriate action, in accordance with law, in the

Patna High Court CWJC No.7869 of 2026 dt.09-09-2026
10/11
event any construction or activity is found to be in violation of
the applicable statutory provisions.
15. The local administration and the authorities
concerned shall ensure that all constructions in the premises of
the Maths/Monasteries are in consonance with the applicable
Municipal Laws, Building Bye-Laws, Building Rules, land-use
regulations and other applicable statutory provisions. No
construction, addition or alteration shall be undertaken except in
accordance with law and the sanctioned plan, wherever such
sanction is required.
16. The concerned authorities and the management of
the respective Maths/Monasteries shall also ensure compliance
with all applicable safety measures and norms prescribed under
the relevant laws, rules, regulations and guidelines, so as to
prevent any danger or accident and to ensure the safety of the
members of the monasteries, monks, pilgrims and visitors.
17. Further, having regard to the fact that the
Maths/Monasteries receive visitors, followers, monks and
pilgrims from different parts of the country and abroad, the
management of each Math/Monastery shall maintain a proper
register of the persons being provided accommodation or
residential facilities within its premises, mentioning proper

Patna High Court CWJC No.7869 of 2026 dt.09-09-2026
11/11
identification i.e. Government issued identity document and
residential proof for Indian citizens; passport and
travel/immigration documents for foreign nationals. The
Math/Monastery shall maintain the register on a daily basis so
that whenever required the same may be produced before the
competent authority.
18. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.


(Sudhir Singh, ACJ)
( Rajesh Kumar Verma, J)
Vanisha/-
AFR/NAFR AFR
CAV DATE NA
Uploading Date 11.09.2026
Transmission Date NA