SAMYUKTHA vs VIJAYAN V

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017





IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.431 OF 2017(MV-D)

C/W

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 57 OF 2017 (MV-I)

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 58 OF 2017 (MV-I)

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 59 OF 2017 (MV-I)

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 429 OF 2017 (MV-I)

IN MFA No.431/2017

BETWEEN:

SAMYUKTHA
D/O SHABU,
AGED 3 YEARS, MINOR
REP. BY R/O NO.145,
ND
2 CROSS, DAADDYS GARDEN,
ELECTRONIC CITY ROAD,
KAMMASANDRA, ANEKAL TALUK,
BANGALORE - 560 100.

THE APPELLANT BEING MINOR
REP. BY HER PARENTAL GRAND FATHER
BY NAME K.RAVINDRAN,
S/O KUNJAN A.,
AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
R/AT NO.64/1, SAI FARMS,
ANNA NAGAR, SAMICHETTI PALYAM (NORTH)
JOTHIPURAM P O.,
COIMBATHORE - 641 047,
TAMILNADU STATE.
…APPELLANT





Digitally signed
by ANUSHA V
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka

(BY SRI SREENIVASAN M Y., ADVOCATE)

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



AND:
1. VIJAYAN V.,
S/O VELAYUDHAN,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
ND
R/AT NO.145, 2 CROSS,
DAADDYA GARDEN,
ELECTRONIC CITY ROAD,
KAMASANDRA, ANEKAL TALUK,
BANGALORE - 560 100.

2. THE BRANCH MANAGER
NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.,
YASHAVANTHAPURA BRANCH,
BANGALORE - 560 023.

3. SURESHA
S/O RAJANNA, MAJOR,
R/AT CHANNIGARAYA EXTENSION,
BANGALORE ROAD, CHANNARAYAPATNA,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573 116.

4. S R JAVARASHETTY
S/O RAMASHETTY, MAJOR,
R/AT SHANTHIGRAM, HASSAN TQ
AND DISTRICT - 573 117.

5. THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER
THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO LTD.,
DIVISIONAL OFFICE, P.B. NO.316,
II BLOCK, J L B ROAD,
MYSORE - 570 023.

…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI O.MAHESH, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
SRI C.R.RAVISHANKAR, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI K SURYANARAYANA RAO, ADVOCATE FOR R5;
R1 & R4 - NOTICE SERVED AND UNREPRESENTED;
V/O/D 31.05.2018 R3 - NOTICE SERVED & PLACED EXPARTE)

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 19.09.2016 PASSED IN MVC
TH
NO.688/2015 ON THE FILE OF THE 5 ADDITIONAL DISTRICT
& SESSIONS JUDGE, ADDITIONAL MACT, HASSAN, PARTLY
ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND
SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF COMPENSATION.
IN MFA NO. 57/2017 & MFA NO.58/2017;
BETWEEN:
THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD.,
DIVISIONAL OFFICE, MYSORE,
THROUGH MOTOR THIRD PARTY CLAIMS HUB,
M.G.ROAD, BANGALORE-1
BY DULY CONSTITUTED ATTORNEY.

...APPELLANT (COMMON)
[BY SRI C.R.RAVISHANKAR, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI K SURYANARAYANA RAO, ADVOCATE (PH)]
AND:
1. SAMYUKTHA
D/O SHAMBU,
AGED ABOUT 2 YEARS,
ND
R/AT NO.145, 2 CROSS,
DAADDYS GARDEN,
ELECTRONICS CITY ROAD,
KAMMASANDRA, ANEKAL TALUK,
BANGALORE - 100.

RESPONDENT NO.1 IS MINOR
REP BY PARENTAL GRAND FATHER
K RAVINDRAN
R/AT 64/1, SAI FARMS, ANNANAGAR,
SAMICHETTI PALYAM (NORTH)
JOTHIPURAM P.O.
COIMBATHORE - 641 047.

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



2. VIJAYAN
S/O VELAYUDHAN,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
ND
NIO.145, 2 CROSS, DAADDYS GARDEN,
ELECTRONIC CITY ROAD, KAMMASANDRA,
ANEKAL TALUK, BANGALORE - 100.

3. THE BRANCH MANAGER
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
YESHWANTHAPUR BRANCH,
BANGALORE - 560 022.

4. SURESH
S/O RAJANNA,
MAJOR IN AGED,
CHANNIGARAYA EXTENSION,
CHANNARAYAPATNA,
HASSAN DIST - 573 201.

5. S R JAVARASHETTY
S/O RAMA SHETTY,
MAJOR IN AGE,
R/AT SHANTHINAGARA,
HASSAN TALUK AND DIST - 573 201.

...RESPONDENTS (COMMON)
[BY SRI M.Y.SREENIVASAN, ADVOCATE FOR R1 (VC);
SRI O.MAHESH, ADVOCATE FOR R3;
SMT.GEETHA RAJ, ADVOCATE FOR R3;
NOTICE TO R2 & R5 - SERVED & UNREPRESENTED;
V/O DTD 21.09.2021/12.11.2026 NOTICE TO R4 IS H/S]
THIS MFA NO.57/2017 IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV
ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED
19.09.2016 PASSED IN MVC NO.688/2015 ON THE FILE OF
THE 5TH ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE,
ADDITIONAL MACT, HASSAN, AWARDING COMPENSATION

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



OF Rs.64,45,000/- WITH INTEREST @ 9% P.A. FROM THE
DATE OF PETITION TILL PAYMENT.

THIS MFA NO.58/2017 IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV
ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED
19.09.2016 PASSED IN MVC NO.685/2015 ON THE FILE OF
THE 5TH ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE,
ADDITIONAL MACT, HASSAN, AWARDING COMPENSATION
OF Rs.15,50,000/- WITH INTEREST @ 9% P.A. FROM THE
DATE OF PETITION TILL PAYMENT.

IN MFA NOs. 59/2017
BETWEEN:
THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD.,
DIVISIONAL OFFICE, MYSORE,
THROUGH MOTOR THIRD PARTY
CLAIMS HUB, M.G.ROAD,
BANGALORE-1
BY DULY CONSTITUTED ATTORNEY.

...APPELLANT
[BY SRI C.R.RAVISHANKAR, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI K SURYANARAYANA RAO, ADVOCATE (PH)]
AND:
1. RENUKA
W/O VIJAYAN
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
ND
R/AT NO.145, 2 CROSS,
DAADDYS GARDEN,
ELECTRONICS CITY ROAD,
KAMMASANDRA, ANEKAL TALUK,
BANGALORE - 100.

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



2. VIJAYAN
S/O VELAYUDHAN,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
ND
NIO.145, 2 CROSS,
DAADDY'S GARDEN,
ELECTRONIC CITY ROAD,
KAMMASANDRA, ANEKAL TALUK,
BANGALORE- 560 100.

3. THE BRANCH MANAGER
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
YESHWANTHAPUR BRANCH,
BANGALORE - 560 022.

4. SURESH
S/O RAJANNA,
MAJOR IN AGED,
CHANNIGARAYA EXTENSION,
CHANNARAYAPATNA,
HASSAN DIST - 573 201.

5. S R JAVARASHETTY
S/O RAMA SHETTY,
MAJOR IN AGE,
R/AT SHANTHINAGARA,
HASSAN TALUK AND DIST - 573 201.

...RESPONDENTS
[BY SRI M.Y.SREENIVASAN, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SRI O.MAHESH, ADVOCATE FOR R3;
NOTICE TO R2 & R5 - SERVED & UNREPRESENTED;
V/O DATED 12.11.2026 NOTICE TO R4 IS H/S]
THIS MFA NO.59/2017 IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV
ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED
19.09.2016 PASSED IN MVC NO.686/2015 ON THE FILE OF
THE 5TH ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE,

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



ADDITIONAL MACT, HASSAN, AWARDING COMPENSATION
OF Rs.25,000/- BUT THE PETITIONER HEREIN LIABLE TO
PAY RS.10,000/- WITH INTEREST @ 9% P.A. FROM THE
DATE OF PETITION TILL PAYMENT.

IN MFA No.429/2017
BETWEEN:
SAMYUKTHA
D/O SHABU,
AGED 3 YEARS, MINOR
REP. BY R/O NO.145,
ND
2 CROSS, DAADDYS GARDEN,
ELECTRONIC CITY ROAD,
KAMMASANDRA, ANEKAL TALUK,
BANGALORE - 560 100.

THE APPELLANT BEING MINOR
REP. BY HER PARENTAL GRAND FATHER
BY NAME K.RAVINDRAN,
S/O KUNJAN A.,
AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
R/AT NO.64/1, SAI FARMS,
ANNA NAGAR, SAMICHETTI PALYAM (NORTH)
JOTHIPURAM P O.,
COIMBATHORE - 641 047,
TAMILNADU STATE.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI SREENIVASAN M Y., ADVOCATE (VC)]
AND:
1. VIJAYAN V.,
S/O VELAYUDHAN,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
ND
R/AT NO.145, 2 CROSS,
DAADDYA GARDEN,
ELECTRONIC CITY ROAD,
KAMASANDRA, ANEKAL TALUK,

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



BANGALORE - 560 100.

2. THE BRANCH MANAGER
NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.,
YASHAVANTHAPURA BRANCH,
BANGALORE - 560 023.

3. SURESHA
S/O RAJANNA, MAJOR,
R/AT CHANNIGARAYA EXTENSION,
BANGALORE ROAD, CHANNARAYAPATNA,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573 116.

4. S R JAVARASHETTY
S/O RAMASHETTY, MAJOR,
R/AT SHANTHIGRAM, HASSAN TQ
AND DISTRICT - 573 117.

5. THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER
THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD.,
DIVISIONAL OFFICE, P.B. NO.316,
II BLOCK, J L B ROAD,
MYSORE - 570 023.

…RESPONDENTS
[BY SRI O.MAHESH, ADVOCATE FOR R2 (VC);
SRI C.R.RAVISHANKAR, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI K SURYANARAYANA RAO, ADVOCATE FOR R5 (PH);
R1 & R4 - NOTICE SERVED AND UNREPRESENTED;
V/O DATED 31.05.2018 NOTICE TO R3 IS SERVED
BY WAY OF PAPER PUBLICATION]
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST
THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 19.09.2016 PASSED
TH
IN MVC NO.685/2015 ON THE FILE OF THE 5
ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE, ADDITIONAL
MACT, HASSAN, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF
COMPENSATION.

THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI

ORAL JUDGMENT
Challenging common judgment and award dated
19.09.2016 passed by V Additional District and Sessions Court
and Additional MACT, Hassan, in MVC nos.685, 686 and 688 of
2015, these appeals are filed. MFAs no.431 and 429 of 2017
are filed by claimants, whereas MFAs no.57, 58 and 59 of 2017
are by insurer.


2. Brief facts leading to these appeals, as stated by
claimants, are that at 02:00 p.m. on 02.11.2013, claimant
Samyuktha was travelling in Car no.KA-51-Z-9269 along with
her mother V.R. Sumi, father Shabu, who was driving car, and
other relatives. Near Ranganathapura Gate on NH-75, Maxi Cab
no.KA-13-6615, proceeding ahead of car, suddenly stopped
without any signal, to alight its passengers. Despite driver's
attempt to avoid accident by applying brakes and turning car

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



towards right side, car dashed against rear right side of maxi
cab and overturned. In accident, claimant Samyuktha sustained
grievous injuries, claimant Renuka sustained injuries, and her
mother died. Claiming compensation, injured claimant
Samyuktha filed MVC no.685/2015, while injured claimant
Renuka filed MVC no.686/2015. Claimant Samyuktha, as a
dependent, filed MVC no.688/2015 seeking compensation for
death of her mother against owners and insurers of Car and
Maxi cab. under Section 166 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

3. Despite service of notice, owners of vehicles did not
appear and were placed ex-parte . Only insurers contested claim
petitions. Based on pleadings, Tribunal framed following issues:
Issues in MVC no.685/2015 & 686/2015
1. Whether the petitioners proves that the accident
occurred due to the actionable negligence on the
part of the driver of the Mahendra Maxi Cab bearing
Registration no.KA-13-6615 and in the accident he
sustained injuries?

2. Whether the petitioner is entitled for the
compensation? If so, what is the quantum and from
whom?

3. What order?

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



Issues in MVC no.688/2014
1. Whether the petitioner proves that the accident
occurred due to the actionable negligence on the
part of the driver of the Mahendra Maxi Cab bearing
Registration no.KA-13-6615 and in the accident
Smt.Sumi V.R., sustained severe injuries and died?
2. Whether the petitioner is entitled for the
compensation? If so, what is the quantum and from
whom?
3. What order?


4. Since all claim petitions arose out of same accident,
they were clubbed together for a common trial. Four witnesses
were examined on behalf of claimants as PWs.1 to 4 and Exs.P1
to P23 were marked. On respondents' side, two witnesses were
examined as RWs.1 and 2 and Exs.R1 to R5 were marked.


5. On consideration, Tribunal answered issue no.1 in
all cases in affirmative and issue no.2 partly in affirmative,
issue No.3, assessing compensation of Rs.15,50,000/- with
interest at 9% per annum in MVC no.685/2015, Rs.25,000/- in
MVC no.686/2015 and Rs.64,45,000/- in MVC no.688/2015.
However, it apportioned negligence between driver of car and
driver of maxi cab at 60% and 40%, respectively and held

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



insurers liable to satisfy award to said extent. Aggrieved by
same, these appeals have been filed.


6. Sri C.R. Ravi Shankar, learned counsel appearing
for Sri K. Suryanarayana Rao in MFAs no.57 to 59 of 2017,
submitted that appeals were filed by insurer of maxi cab
challenging finding of Tribunal holding driver of maxi cab
negligent to extent of 40%, and quantum of compensation,
only insofar as rate of interest awarded at 9% per annum. It
was submitted that accident occurred on an east-west running
road separated by a median, with a width of 40 feet and a 5-
foot kacha road. At time of accident, which occurred during
daytime at 02:00 p.m., driver of maxi cab had stopped vehicle
on extreme left side of road for alighting passengers, when Car
rear-ended it. Said particulars were substantiated by contents
of Ex.P3 - Spot mahazar. It was submitted that complaint was
filed by driver of maxi cab, as per Exs.P1 and P2. It was further
submitted that Motor Vehicle Inspector's report at Ex.P4 would
show that damage to maxi cab was on its right rear end, while
that to Car was on its front left side. It was submitted that

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



Ex.P5, charge sheet, implicate only driver of maxi cab for
causing accident by rash and negligent driving.


7. It was submitted, while passing impugned award,
Tribunal had in fact, referred to material on record and also
observed that it implicated driver of Car for having caused
accident. However, without any detailed reasoning, Tribunal
merely referring to Sections 117 and 122 of MV Act, held that
driver of Maxi cab was also negligent and apportioned
negligence to extent of 40%. It was submitted that same was
contrary to material on record, as claimants failed to
substantiate their contention that accident occurred when
driver of Maxi cab, which was proceeding ahead of car,
suddenly stopped for alighting passengers. Therefore, on said
grounds, learned counsel sought setting aside of award insofar
as it related to driver, owner and insurer of maxi cab. On
quantum, it was submitted that award of interest at 9% per
annum was without any reasoning and reduction was sought.


8. Sri M.Y. Sreenivasan, learned counsel for
claimants/appellants in MFAs no.431 and 429 of 2017,
submitted that MFA no.429/2017 was filed seeking

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



compensation for personal injuries, wherein Samyuktha, a one-
year-old child travelling in car at time of accident, sustained
severe head injuries and injuries to other parts of body, leading
to child being unable to remain conscious, understand or
respond, speak or move her limbs. She lost control over urine
and stool, suffered post-traumatic seizures, lost vision,
moderate loss of hearing and sustained profound mental
retardation, rendering her disabled to extent of 100%. It was
submitted that claimant required continuous medical treatment
and attendance. Despite same, Tribunal had awarded only
Rs.2,00,000/- towards future medical expenses, Rs.25,000/-
towards pain and suffering, Rs.7,13,000/- towards medical
expenses and Rs.12,000/- towards attendant charges, which
was grossly inadequate. It was submitted that compensation
awarded at Rs.6,00,000/- towards disability by following ratio
in Master Mallikarjun v. Divisional Manager, National
Insurance Co. Ltd and Anr. reported in 2013 ACJ 2445
would not be justified, as Hon'ble Supreme Court, in Hitesh
Najibhai Patel v. Bababhai Najibhai Rabari and Anr.
reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 3446 , had held that

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



compensation, even in case of non-earning minors, had to be
assessed by considering their income as notified minimum
wages for skilled workers for year of accident and applying
multiplier of '18' and adding future prospects. Therefore, award
of Rs.6,00,000/- towards disability was not justified.


9. Learned counsel further submitted that Tribunal
erred in not awarding any compensation towards loss of
marriage prospects or loss of amenities and sought appropriate
award.


10. In MFA no.431/2017, it was submitted that only
ground for enhancement was failure of Tribunal to add future
prospects to monthly income while assessing compensation. On
said ground, allowing appeal was sought.


11. On other hand, Sri M.Y. Sreenivasan, learned
counsel, fairly consented to reduction of rate of interest from
9% to 6% per annum.

12. On other hand, Sri O. Mahesh, learned counsel for
insurer of car, opposed appeals.

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017




13. On negligence, it was submitted that, while passing
impugned award, Tribunal had rightly referred to Sections 117
and 122 of M.V. Act, it was submitted that there was no
material to establish that Maxi cab had stopped at a designated
place for alighting passengers. It was further submitted that
PW.3-Renuka had deposed about manner of occurrence of
accident by stating that accident occurred when Maxi cab
proceeding ahead of car suddenly swerved to left and stopped
without signal, for alighting passengers and Car collided with
Maxi cab despite driver's efforts to apply brakes and stop car.
Besides above, use of Maxi cab as a stage carriage was in an
unauthorised and unauthorised stopping of vehicle were duly
appreciated by Tribunal at time of apportionment and
therefore, no modification was called for.


14. On quantum, it was submitted that Tribunal had
granted just compensation and that there was no scope for
enhancement on said grounds, sought dismissal of appeals.


15. Heard learned counsel for parties and perused
impugned judgment and award and record.

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017




16. From above, since insurer is in appeal challenging
finding of Tribunal on negligence as well as on quantum, while
claimants are in appeal seeking enhancement of compensation,
following points arise for consideration:
1. Whether Tribunal was justified in apportioning
negligence at 60% against driver of car and 40%
against driver of maxi car and apportioning liability
to respective insurer?

2. Whether compensation awarded calls for
modification?


Point no.1 :
16. In order to establish actionable negligence against
respective vehicles, claimants relied on police investigation
records, namely, FIR, complaint, spot mahazar, Motor Vehicle
Inspector's report and charge sheet, marked as Exs.P1 to P5.
FIR was registered on basis of complaint filed by driver of Maxi
cab, wherein it was alleged that accident occurred when driver
of car drove in a rash and negligent manner and dashed
against rear end of Maxi cab while it was stopped for alighting
passengers on extreme left side of road.

17. After investigation, police filed a charge sheet
implicating only driver of car for having caused accident due to

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



rash and negligent driving. Ex.P3-Spot mahazar, would indicate
that accident occurred on a road running east to west, with
both Maxi cab and car heading in same direction, road was
separated by a median and was 40 feet in width, with a 5-foot
kacha road. Accident spot was on left side of road. Contents of
Motor Vehicle Inspector's report noted that damage sustained
by Maxi cab was on its right rear side, while that of Car was on
its front left side. Above material would indicate that accident
occurred when Maxi cab had stopped on left side of road for
alighting passengers and Car rear-ended it.

18. It is to be noted that accident occurred during
daytime at 02:00 p.m. Though PW.3 is stated to have deposed
that accident occurred when driver of Maxi cab, which was
proceeding ahead, suddenly stopped without signal and driver
of Car tried to avoid collision by applying brakes and swerving
towards right side, there is absolutely no corroborative material
to that effect.

19. On perusal of reasoning and findings of Tribunal on
apportionment of negligence under issues no.1 and 2, it is

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



evident that only basis was reference to Sections 117 and 122
of MV Act. Though Section 117 of MV Act mandate public
service vehicles to stop at designated places and Section 122
prohibits stopping or parking a vehicle in a dangerous position
on road, there is no material to indicate that stoppage of maxi
cab was blocking road in any manner and as such, rendering it
a dangerous position.

20. There is no corroboration of claimants' version that
accident occurred while Maxi cab was in motion, turned to left
and stopped suddenly. However, records would reveal that
accident occurred on a national highway and that parking
vehicles on highway without signal would attract some
negligence, as vehicles travelling on a national highway are
expected to be at high speeds.

21. At same time, taking note of fact that there is no
corroboration of claimants' version about attempt to avoid
collision by applying brakes or turning vehicle towards right
side. It is found that apportionment of negligence to extent of
40% against driver of Maxi cab would not be justified and is
excessive.

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017




22. Considering facts and circumstances, it is found
appropriate to reduce extent of negligence of driver of Maxi cab
to 10% and enhance apportionment of negligence against
driver of car to 90%. Point no.1 is answered accordingly.
Point no.2:

23. On quantum it is submitted that claimant in MVC
no.685/2015 is a one year child. In his deposition, PW.4-
Dr.Vishwas stated that claimant had sustained severe head
injuries and was treated at SSM Hospital, Hassan and Vikram
Hospital, Bangalore, where she went surgery for left fronto
Parietal acute sub-dural Haematoma. She had underwent
Tracheotomy and Gastrotomi tube insertion. Despite treatment,
she remained neurologically static and she was undergoing
physical rehabilitation and visual stimulation therapy. PW4
stated that claimant was suffering from following:
1. Not conscious, unable to understand or respond.
2. She cannot speak
3. She has weakness of all four limbs, unable to stand
or walk,
4. She has no control over her passing urine or stools
5. She is getting post traumatic seizures

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



6. She has no useful vision
7. She has moderate hearing loss
8. She has profound mental retardation.

24. Based on same, PW4 assessed permanent physical
disability caused to claimant at 100% and also stated that her
situation was not likely to improve. Considering same, Tribunal
awarded compensation by following methodology evolved in
Master Mallikarjun' s case (supra) at Rs.6,00,000/-, but later
decision in Hitesh' s case (supra) has held even in case of non-
earning minors, compensation has to be calculated by taking
notified minimum wages of skilled workmen for relevant year
as income, add future prospects and assess compensation by
applying multiplier of '18'. However, there is no material to
establish notified monthly income of skilled worker for year
2013. In absence, notional income for year 2013 at Rs.8,000/-
has to be considered and future prospects at 40% has to be
added and multiplier applicable would be '18'. Thus,
compensation towards future loss of income would be as
follows:
(Rs.8000/- + 40%) x 100% x 12 x 18 = Rs.24,19,200/-

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017




25. In Hitesh 's case (supra), a 8 year old child
sustained 90% disability and Hon'ble Supreme Court awarded
compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- towards pain and suffering.
Under similar circumstances in Kajal v. Jagdish Chand
reported in (2020) 4 SCC 413, Rs.15,00,000/- was awarded
as compensation towards pain and suffering. Considering facts
and circumstances of this case award of Rs.25,000 towards
pain and suffering would be grossly inadequate. It is found
appropriate to award Rs.5,00,000/- towards pain and
suffering. Tribunal has awarded Rs.7,13,000/- towards
medical expenses which is in full reimbursement of medical bills
produced. Therefore there would be no scope for enhancement.
Insofar as attendant charges, in Kajal' s case (supra) it is held
that it has to be calculated by applying multiplier system as in
case of dependency. Notional income for year 2013 at
Rs.8,000/- is adopted and multiplier of '18' held applicable.
Thus, compensation towards attendant charges would be:
Rs.8,000/- x 12 x 18 = Rs.17,28,000/-

26. Though learned counsel for claimant-appellant
sought for enhancement of compensation towards future

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



medical expenses and PW.4 has stated about need for
continued treatment, there is no material to assess nature of
treatment required or expenses involved. In absence, award of
Rs.2,00,000/- by Tribunal would appear just and proper and
same is sustained. Tribunal has not awarded any compensation
towards loss of marriage prospects and towards loss of
amenities. In Hitesh' s case (supra) compensation of
Rs.3,00,000/- is awarded towards loss of marriage prospects.
Same is awarded to claimant in instant case also. In Hitesh 's
case (supra) Hon'ble Supreme Court awarded Rs.2,00,000/-
towards loss of amenities. Considering young age of claimant at
1 year as against 8 years in Hitesh 's case (supra), it is found
fit to award Rs.3,00,000/- towards loss of amenities. Thus,
claimant is held entitled for total compensation of
Rs.61,60,200/- .

27. Victim in MVC no.688/2015 was a software
engineer aged 27 years working at Tata Consultancy Services
and earning income of more than Rs.45,000/-. After deduction
of professional tax and income tax, tribunal found fit to assess
monthly income at Rs.45,000/- and applied multiplier of '17'

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



rd
and deducted 1/3 towards personal expenses. Same is not
under challenge. Only ground for enhancement urged is about
failure to add future prospects. Considering ratio in National
Insurance Co. Ltd., v. Pranay Sethi reported in (2017) 16
SCC 680 and age as 27 years, 40% has to be added towards
future prospects. Compensation towards loss of dependency
would thus be:
(Rs.45,000/- + 40%) x 2/3 x 12 x 17 = Rs.85,68,000/-


28. Though there is no challenge insofar as assessment
of compensation under conventional heads, award of
Rs.25,000/- towards funeral expenses, Rs.1,00,000/- towards
consortium, Rs.1,00,000/- towards guidance to minor children,
Rs.1,00,000/- towards loss of estate would be far in excess
than in Pranay Sethi 's case (supra) and unacceptable.
Considering fact that claim petition was filed by only minor
daughter of deceased, she would be entitled to Rs.70,000/-
under conventional heads and since more than 9 years have
lapsed after decision in Pranay Sethi 's case, for escalation of
30% i.e., Rs.21,000/- . Thus, claimant would be entitled to
total enhanced compensation of Rs.86,59,000. Point number 2

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



is answered accordingly. Insofar as rate of interest, learned
counsel for claimant has graciously conceded for reduction to
6%. Hence points for consideration are answered partly in
affirmative.

29. Consequently, following:

ORDER

(i) All appeals are allowed in part .

(ii) Judgment and award dated 19.09.2016
passed by V Additional District and Sessions Court
and Additional MACT, Hassan, in MVC nos.685, 686
and 688 of 2015 stands modified.

(iii) Claimant in MVC 685/2015 is held
entitled for reassessed compensation of
Rs.61,60,200/- with interest at 6% p.a. from date
of claim petition till deposit.

(iv) Claimant in MVC 686/2015 is held
entitled for reassessed compensation of
Rs.25,000/- with interest at 6% p.a. from date of
claim petition till deposit.

(v) Claimant in MVC 688/2015 is held
entitled for reassessed compensation of

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



Rs.86,59,000/- with interest at 6% p.a. from date
of claim petition till deposit.

(vi) Insurer of Maxi Cab i.e. National
Insurance Co. Ltd., is held liable to pay 90% of
compensation while insurer of Car - New India
Assurance Co. Ltd., is held liable to pay 10% of
compensation to claimant.

(vii) Amount in deposit in insurer's appeal is
ordered to be transmitted to tribunal for disbursal.

(viii) Excess if any, to be refunded or balance
to be deposited within period of 6 weeks.

(ix) On deposit, lump sum amount of
Rs.20,00,000/- is ordered to be released in favour
of claimant in MVC 685/2015 in order to cover
compensation towards medical expenses and future
medical expenses.

(x) Remaining amount is ordered to be kept
in Fixed Deposit initially for a period of 5 years in
any nationalized bank earning highest rate of
interest with provision for transfer of monthly
interest into account of guardian/next friend.

(xi) Tribunal is directed to ensure welfare
and proper care of minor and usage of

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62703
MFA No. 431 of 2017
C/W MFA No. 57 of 2017
MFA No. 58 of 2017
AND 2 OTHERS


CNR: KAHC010193282017



compensation and periodic interest towards care of
minor either by requiring filing of periodic affidavits
disclosing manner of expenditure of amount
released in favour of claimant or by any other
appropriate means.

(xii) There would also be provision for
seeking release of additional amount in case same
is required for medical treatment or medical
emergencies.

(xiii) In MVC 686/2015, entire compensation
with interest is ordered to be released in favour of
claimant.

(xiv) In MVC 688/2015, Tribunal is directed
to release 40% of compensation and keep
remaining 60% with interest in Fixed Deposit in any
Nationalized Bank earning highest rate of interest
initially for a period of 5 years with provision for
release of periodic interest.


Sd/-
(RAVI V HOSMANI)
JUDGE



TMP,YKL
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 7