DR. DEBASHIS BANERJEE vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
W.P.A. No. 24470 of 2025
Dr. Debashis Banerjee
Vs.
State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Vivekananda Bose
Mr. Ratikanta Pal
Mr. Sattwik Dutta
....For the petitioner.
Ms. Ranjana Chatterjee
Mr. Akash Adak
....For the State.
Hearing Concluded On : 13.11.2026
Judgment Delivered On : 20.11.2026
Judgment Uploaded On : 20.11.2026
2
Krishna Rao, J.:
1. The petitioner has filed the present writ petition praying for setting
st
aside the rejections dated 31 October, 2023 of registration of Live
Spices under the Voluntary Disclosure Scheme. The petitioner has been
breeding more than 150 species of exotic birds and 6 species of
primates, including those which are on the verge of extinction and have
been listed by the Convention on International Trade in Endangered
Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), with remarkable success at
Sunshine Bird World Avian Breeding and Research Centre.
th
2. On 11 June, 2020, the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate
Change issued an advisory to streamline and formalize the process of
importing Exotic Live Species and also to streamline the possession,
breeding, declaration of progeny, acquisition and transfer of Exotic Live
Species in India. The Ministry has framed the procedure for declaration
of stock of Exotic Live Species, import of exotic live species,
registration/ declaration of progeny of previously held stock and
transfer/ transport of stock, in India online through ‘PARIVESH Portal’.
A period of six (6) months was provided for voluntary disclosure for
those who are in possession of exotic live species in the country.
3. The petitioner has declared his stock of exotic birds and animals on
th
14 December, 2020. Physical verification of premises, birds and
animals was conducted by the office of the respondent no. 4 and status
st
of proposal on the PARIVESH Portal was approved on 31 October,
3
2023, except three species, namely (i) Common Marmosets, (ii) Cotton
Top Tamarins and (iii) Sugar Gliders by showing ‘Rejected’ in their
individual “Status” columns of the approved letter uploaded on the
Portal. The reasons for rejections of all three species in the remark
column are mentioned as “ To prevent zoonotic pathogens,
unconventional agents that can spread human or native species. May
cause threat to native wildlife population”.
4. Mr. Vivekananda Bose, Learned Advocate, representing the petitioner
submits that there is no provision in the Advisory empowering the Chief
Wild Life Warden (hereinafter referred to as “CWLW”) to reject a
declaration based on a subjective or substantive assessment of the
animal’s potential ‘zoonotic risk’ or ‘threat to native biodiversity’.
st
5. Mr. Bose submits that on 1 April, 2023, the Wild Life (Protection)
th
Amendment Act, 2022, came into force and on 28 February, 2024, the
Living Animal Species (Reporting and Registration) Rules, 2024, were
notified by the Ministry. As per the Rules, every person who is in
possession of any animal species has to make an application for
registration electronically to the Management Authority or to the
authorized officer in Form-I within six (6) months from the date of
commencement of the Rules. It is further mentioned that where the
animal species was acquired prior to the commencement of the Wild
Life (Protection) Amendment Act, 2022, the application shall be
accompanied with the proof of acquisition prior to such
commencement.
4
6. Mr. Bose submits that the petitioner has applied for possession of all
birds and animals declared under the Voluntary Disclosure Scheme on
th
26 July, 2024, as “proof of acquisition”. The physical verification was
rd
conducted by the office of the respondent no. 4 on 23 August, 2024
but the status of the application on the PARIVESH Portal is showing as
‘Pending to fill Part-2’.
7. Ms. Ranjana Chatterjee, Learned Advocate, representing the
respondent authorities submits that the breeders of species licence is
for breeding Schedule-IV, Appendix-I species which are given the
highest level of protection in accordance with the Convention of
International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora,
which is an international agreement between Governments.
8. Ms. Ranjana submits that the protection given to Schedule-IV
Appendix-I species is at par with the protection given to animals
mentioned in Schedule-I of the amendment Act, 2022. The aim is to
ensure that the trade in species covered under Schedule-IV Appendix-I
do not threaten the survival of the species which may eventually lead to
extinction if not closely regulated.
9. The Parivesh Rules of 2020, are the relevant guidelines. Clause-I
provides for “Developing an inventory of exotic live species in India
through Voluntary Disclosure Scheme” which reads as follows:
“a) The phrases "exotic live species" used in this
advisory shall be construed to mean only "the
animals named under the Appendices I, II and III of
5
the Convention of International Trade in
Endangered Species (CITES) of Wild Fauna and
Flora" for the purpose of this advisory and does not
include species from the Schedules of the Wild Life
(Protection) Act 1972.
b) It is stated through this advisory that the
declarer would not be required to produce any
documentation in relation to the exotic live species
if the same has been declared within six months of
the date of issue of the advisory. For any
declaration made after 6 months of the date of
issue of this advisory, the declarer shall be
required to comply with the documentation
requirement under the extant laws and regulations.
c) A period of 6 months (from the date of the order)
may be given for voluntary disclosure for those who
are in possession of exotic live species in the
country.
d) All exotic live species shall be declared by the
owner/ holder (stock, as on 1 January 2020) to the
Chief Wildlife Warden (CWLW) of the concerned
State or UT in a format at Annexure-1 of this
Advisory.
e) The CWLW shall, after physical verification,
register the stock and maintain a record in their
office and issue an online certificate of possession
within six months of the date of the voluntary
disclosure.
f) The CWLW or the officer(s) authorized shall be
provided with free access to the exotic live species
being declared and housed at the facility round the
clock on any given day for verification
g) Any acquisition/ death/trade/ change of
possession, taken place after the declaration
should be informed to the respective CWLW within
30 days of such acquisition /death/trade and the
CWLW shall issue an acknowledgment in this
regard as per format at Annexure-II
h) The Register of stock shall include details such
as species imported/acquired, the number of
animal of each species imported/acquired,
photographs (for the purpose of identification of the
6
species), and the address where the exotic live
species have been kept.
i) If the owner/holder of the stock desires of
surrendering the stock (part of the stock) to a
recognized Zoo, the concerned Zoo may consider
the request for acceptance appropriately, within the
specified parameters for ensuring the exotic live
species is free of infections/diseases
j) For violation of any of the above procedures laid
down, action as appropriate would be taken by the
Chief Wild life Warden.”
10. In terms of the said scheme, the petitioner has declared all stocks,
progeny and acquisition and transfer within six (6) months through the
th
PARIVESH Portal on 14 December, 2020. Physical verification of the
premises and the birds and animals was done by the office of the
st
respondent no.4 and was approved on the PARIVESH Portal on 31
October, 2023, after the period of two (2) years, ten (10) months and 17
days though the mandated period is six (6) months except three spices,
namely (i) Common Marmosets, (ii) Cotton Top Tamarins and (iii) Sugar
Gliders by showing ‘Rejected’ in their individual “Status” columns of the
approval letter uploaded on the portal. The reasons for rejections of all
three species in the “remarks” column are mentioned as “ To prevent
zoonotic pathogens, unconventional agents that can spread human or
native species. May cause threat to native wildlife population”.
11. In the case of Sukanta Mallick Vs. Union of India and Others
reported in 2023 SCC OnLine Cal 5438 , the Coordinate Bench of this
Court held that:
7
“ 34. Sub-clause (g) of Clause I thereafter
provides that any acquisition/death/trade/change
of possession taking place after the declaration
should be informed to the respective CWLW within
30 days of such acquisition/death/trade, upon
which the mere function of the CWLW is to issue an
acknowledgement as per format as Annexure-II. A
detailed procedure of subsequent physical
verification and registration, after the stage of
declaration, has been envisaged in the Parivesh
Rules, 2020.
35. Thus, the CWLW at that stage is indeed a
mere ‘post-office’ and issues an acknowledgement.
The CWLW does not have any power of accepting
or rejecting or adjudicating on the declaration at
that stage. Sub-clause (h) of Clause I provides that
the register of stock shall include details such as
species imported/acquired, number of animals of
each species imported/acquired, photographs,
address, etc. Sub-clause (j) provides that for
violation of any of the above procedures laid down,
action as appropriate would be taken by the Chief
Wild Life Warden.
36. Although sub-clause (j) provides scope for
action to be taken, at the stage of declaration, there
is no scope of any such action.
37. In any event, Clause I (b) merely provides
that a voluntary declaration is to be made and
there is no scope of any “action” by the CWLW at
that stage. As held by the Supreme Court in
Swetab Kumer (supra), the Advisory is in the
nature of a voluntary disclosure scheme and
provides amnesty and is not a penal provision. The
Supreme Court also observed in the said judgment
that when the Advisory was issued, it was
optional, aimed essentially at regulation of
import/export and the public at large was not put
to notice that failure of opt therefor would lead to
penal and other consequences affecting their right
to possess the animal.”
8
12. The respondent authorities have failed to produce any evidence/
documents and law under which the provisions of law, the Chief Wild
Life Warden has rejected the approval of three species, namely (i)
Common Marmosets, (ii) Cotton Top Tamarins and (iii) Sugar Gliders.
The reasons of rejections are not provided in the Parivesh Rules, 2020.
13. The Coordinate Bench of the Court in the case of Sukanta Mallick
(supra) categorically held that the Chief Wild Life Warden does not have
any power to of accepting or rejecting or adjudicating on the
declaration. The petitioner has submitted the details of species
acquired or imported, the number of animals of each species imported
or acquired and the address where the exotic live species were kept.
The petitioner has submitted the said declaration in compliance of
Clause I (h) of the Scheme.
14. The CWLW has the authority to take appropriate action for violation of
any of the procedure mentioned in Clause I(a) to (j) of the Scheme but
the reason for rejections assigned is not for violation of any of the
provisions of the Scheme.
15. This Court finds that the CWLW has exceeded its jurisdiction by
rejecting the declaration of the three exotic species of the petitioner,
accordingly, the rejection of three exotic species, namely (i) Common
st
Marmosets, (ii) Cotton Top Tamarins and (iii) Sugar Gliders dated 31
October, 2023, are set aside and quashed.
9
16. The respondent authorities are directed to accept the declaration of the
stock of live exotic species submitted by the petitioner in terms of
Voluntary Disclosure Scheme within a period of four (4) weeks from the
date of receipt of this order.
17. WPA No. 24470 of 2025 is disposed of .
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)