SHAKUNTALA W/O M.B. KATGALKAR vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH


TH
DATED THIS THE 14 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA

AND

THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI


WRIT PETITION NO.105037 OF 2021 (S-KAT)


BETWEEN:

1. SHAKUNTALA W/O. M.B. KATGALKAR,
AGE: 64 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O: PLOT NO. 37, HANUMAN NAGAR,
ND
2 STAGE, BELAGAVI – 590 001.

2. RAMANAND S/O.MARUTI KATAGALKAR,
AGE: 38 YEARS, OCC: NIL,
R/O: PLOT NO 37 HANUMAN NAGAR,
ND
2 STAGE, BELAGAVI – 590 001.

3. DIVYANAND S/O. MARUTI KATGALKAR,
AGE: 27 YEARS, OCC: NIL,
R/O: PLOT NO. 37, HANUMAN NAGAR,
ND
2 STAGE, BELAGAVI – 590 001.
…PETITIONERS
(BY SMT. GAYATRI S.R., ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. MALLIKARJUNSWAMY B. HIREMATH, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT,
MULTI STORIED BUIDLING,
BENGALURU – 560 001.

2. THE CHIEF ENGINEER,
COMMUNICATION AND BUILDINGS (S)









Digitally signed
by PRATIBHA
M PATIL
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
DHARWAD
BENCH
Date:
2026.11.19
14:51:48 +0530

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

NEAR K.R. CIRCLE, BENGALURU – 560 001.

3. THE CHIEF ENGINEER,
NATIONAL HIGHWAY, NEAR K.R. CIRCLE,
BENGALURU – 560 001.

4. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
NATIONAL HIGHWAYS DIVISION,
HUBLI, DISTRICT: DHARWAD – 580 001.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. GIRIJA S. HIREMATH, HCGP FOR R1;
SRI. SHILPA SHAH, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. SHIVARAJ S. BALLOLI, ADVOCATE FOR R3 & R4

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF CONSITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO ISSUE A
WRIT OF CERTIORARI QUASHING THE ORDER DATED
16.12.2017 PASSED BY THE KARNATAKA STATE
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL IN APPLICATION NO.2593/2006
WHICH IS PRODUCED AT ANNEXURE-A AND CONSEQUENTLY
ALLOW APPLICATION NO.2593/2006.

THIS WRIT PETITION COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HEARING IN ‘B’ GROUP THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN
AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI

ORAL ORDER
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA )


1. The petitioners, legal representatives of one M.B.
Katagalkar, are before us calling in question an order passed by
the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the Tribunal’, for short), in Application

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

No.2593/2006, whereby the challenge to the order of penalty
of dismissal and recovery is declined to be interfered with.


2. Heard the learned counsel Miss Gayatri S.R.
appearing for the petitioners, the learned High Court
Government Pleader representing the State/respondent Nos.1
and 2 and Sri. Shilpa Sha representing the employer-the
National Highway Authority of India.


3. Facts, in brief, germane, are as follows: The
petitioners, the legal representatives of the applicant are before
the Court, but the petitioners would be referred to as the
applicant, for the sake of convenience.


4. The petitioner at the relevant point in time was
working as First Division Store Keeper of the Public Works
Department of the National Highways Division at Belgaum
between 11.06.1990 to 01.10.1996. He was transferred out of
the post on 01.10.1996 and hands it over to another person on
31.10.1996. It transpires that while handing over the charge,
physical verification of the stock that was in the warehouse
where the petitioner was the store keeper was done by both

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

the petitioner and the person who took charge from the hands
of the petitioner. Long thereafter, audit is conducted. Report of
the Accountant General is placed before the State. Placing
before the State was not immediately complained of against the
petitioner but after 5 years after receipt of 5 reports. This
leads to the State issuing a charge sheet against the petitioner.
The charge sheet issued against the petitioner had 4 charges
against him. An Inquiry Officer is appointed for conduct of
Departmental Inquiry against the petitioner. The Inquiry officer
issues a notice for appearance. The petitioner appears on the
first day, submits his documents, seeks time on medical
grounds. Later submits a representation on 11.10.2004 seeking
the assistance of an advocate to represent him in the enquiry
as his defence representative. This comes to be rejected by the
State on 18.11.2004. By then, the inquiry itself was over. The
entire inquiry against the petitioner which has led to imposition
of an extreme penalty of dismissal from service is said to have
been concluded in one working day which would be less than
12 hours. The penalty did not stop at dismissal from service but
imposed recovery of ₹85,00,000/- upon the petitioner.
Therefore, it was an amalgam of a penalty of dismissal from

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

service and, apart from dismissal, recovery of ₹85,00,000/- as
arrears of land revenue. This was called in question before the
Tribunal. The Tribunal, after about 11 years, has rejected the
petition on the score that it did amount to misconduct and
there was no warrant of interference in the light of the findings
of fact. This is called in question before us by the legal
representatives of the petitioner, as the employee died in the
year 2018 after the passage of the order by the Tribunal.


5. The learned counsel S.R. Gayatri taking this Court
through the documents appended to the petition would seek to
demonstrate that the entire enquiry is conducted in blatant
violation of principles of natural justice. By taking the Court
through the report of the Inquiry Officer, the learned counsel
would submit that on 19.10.2004, notwithstanding the fact that
the petitioner was not present, exparte proceedings are drawn
and concluded and an extreme penalty of dismissal from
service is imposed in the said ex-parte proceedings and not
stopping at that, recovery of ₹85,00,000/- is also imposed
upon the petitioner. The learned counsel would submit that an

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

enquiry of this nature must not be permitted to be sustained as
it is contrary to all canons of law.


6. Per contra, the learned High Court Government
Pleader would vehemently refute this submission in contending
that all opportunity was granted to the petitioner to represent
himself in the inquiry. He has failed to appear in the inquiry on
the appointed date. The appointed date was 19.10.2004.
Therefore, on the said date owing to the absence of the
petitioner, the Inquiry Officer concluded the proceedings as it
was an open and shut case and the petitioner did replied to all
the notices but failed to appear before the inquiry officer on the
said date. The learned HCGP would draw inference from those
dates contending that the petitioner knew all the dates of
inquiry, but deliberately remained outside the inquiry and
therefore no fault can be found with the hands of the Inquiry
Officer or having imposed the said penalty.


7. The learned counsel Sri. Shilpa Sha appearing for
respondent Nos.3 and 4 contends that they are only a formal
party to the proceedings.

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021


8. We have given our anxious consideration to the
submission made by the learned counsel for the respective
parties and perused the material on record.


9. The afore narrated facts, dates, link in the chain of
events are all a matter of record. They would not require any
iteration but skeletal reference.


10. The petitioner was working as a store keeper at the
relevant point in time at the place narrated hereinabove,
between 1990 to 1996. He is relieved on transfer as store
keeper on 01.10.1996 but takes extension and hands over
complete charge to Sri. H.A. Zendannavar on 01.10.1996.
Thereafter, it was the responsibility of H.A. Zendannavar. The
audit team of the Accountant General's office would inspect the
store in the year 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000. Put together all 5
years, the charge sheet is issued to the petitioner after 5 years
after his relieving of the post of the store keeper. The charge
sheet is issued on 23.07.2001. The charges against the
petitioner are as follows:
“Article of Charges against Sri. M.B. Katagalkar, First
Division Store Assistant.

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

You Sri. M.B. Katagalkar, while working as First
Division Store Assistant in National Highway Division,
Belgaum for the period from 11.6.90 to 1.10.96
shortages have been pointed out to the tune of Rs.
85,68,561/-

Charge No.1: While you were working as First Division
Store Assistant in National Highway division, Belgaum
you have been transferred to WALMI Dharwad and
relieved of your duties on 1.10.96 and directed to
handover the complete charge to Sri.H.A.Zandannavar,
Store Superintendent. You had requested the Office of
Executive Engineer, N.H. Division, Belgaum to give 40
days time to handover the charge. You had handed over
the Charge on 10.10.96 and 31.10.96. On verification of
charge list, shortages pointed out on the grounds of
handing over charge to Sri. H.A. Zandannavar, Store
Superintendent to the tune of Rs. 24,50,703/- As per
Rule 85 of K.C.S.Rs you are bound to handover charge
within 10 days. Even though you have been given a
sufficient time to reconcile the materials; but you have
failed to do so.

The provision laid down in Para 6 and 7 of Stores
Manual have not been followed and thus you have
violated the above rules. Thus you have committed a
serious irregularities and violated Rule 3 of K.C.S
(Conduct) Rules 1966. Hence this charge.

Charge No.2: The Accountant General's Inspection
Party inspected during October 1997 have directed to
verify all the records and arrive the net shortages.
Accordingly, the records have been verified and the
shortages pointed out during February 1998 to the tune
of Rs. 40,15,723/- As per half Yearly return of stock and
yearly return of T & P Register, you have not handed
over the materials to your successor. Even though you
have been given a sufficient time to reconcile the
materials, but you have failed to do so. The provisions
laid down in Paras 6 & 7 of Store Manual, have not been
followed and thus you have violated Rule 3 of K.C.S.
(Conduct) Rules, 1966. Hence this charge.

Charge No.3: After verifying the T & P Register,
the shortage pointed out during September 98 to the

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

tune of Rs. 36,100/- The provisions laid down in para 6
& 7 of Stores Manual have not been followed. Thus you
have violated Rule 3 of K.C.S. (Conduct) Rules, 1966
and hence this charge.

Charge No.4: The Accountant General's Inspection
party inspected during November 98 and pointed out
that the Store articles worth Rs. 20,66,035/-stated to
have been issued as per the Division Stock invoices for
the period from 1993-94 to 1995-96 are not supported
by the Sub-divisional indent or acknowledgement of
materials by the Sub-division. The provision laid not
down in para 6 & 7 of Store Mannual have been followed
and thus you have violated the above rules. Total
shortages to the tune of Rs. 85,68,561/- Thus you have
committed serious irregularities and violated Rule 3 of
Karnataka Civil Services (Conduct) Rules 1966.

By order and in the name of the
Governor of Karnataka.

(B. PUTTANNA)
Under Secretary to Government,
Public Works Department(Services-C)

ANNEXURE-II

Statement of imputations of mis-conduct against
Sri. M.B. Katagalkar, F.D.S.K.
-----
Sri. M.B. Katagalkar, while he was working as
First Division Store Assistant in the Office of the
Executive Enginer, National Highway Division, Belgaum
from 11.6.90 to 1.10.96 has committed irregularities in
maintaining the store accounts and the procedure of
handing over of the Stock and T &P materials, thereby
he utterly failed to discharge his duties as per provisions
laid down in para 6 & 7 of Store Manual and causing loss
to the Government to the tune of Rs. 85,68,561/-

The details of shortages of materials with amount
of shortages is enclosed separately as Statement-1.
Thus he is liable for disciplinary action under K.C.S.
(C.C.A) Rules 1957.”

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021


11. The petitioner submits a reply to the charge sheet.
The reply was found to be unsatisfactory and an Inquiry Officer
was appointed by the Disciplinary Authority to conduct
disciplinary proceedings against the petitioner. The Inquiry
Officer issues notice to the petitioner directing him for
appearance in the inquiry on the particular date. On the first
date, the petitioner appears and hands over certain documents
to the Inquiry Officer and seeks time for further appearance by
the following communication:

“From
M.R.Katagalkar,
Store Keeper
C/o. K.R.Chavan
Plot No.37, Ilanuman Nagar,
II Stage, Belgaum,
14.9.04

To
The Superintending Engineer
and Enquiry officer,
N.H. Circle,
Dharwad.

Sub:- Re: Departmental Enquiry.

Respected Sir,

I am to submit before your kindself that, that I
suffering from Diabetics & Hypertension and C
Hyperfriglyceredic & Depression. My physician has
advised b3ed rest from 13-9-04 till 5-10-2004. 1 am
enclosing the Doctor Certificate dt. 13-9-04. Hence I
respectfully request for adjournment. The enquiry be
kindly posted in the 2nd or 3rd week of October.

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021


I also request you to furnish the copies of
documents and records. Statement copy as per my
request letter dt. 1-3-04.

Hence, it is requested to adjourn the enquiry date
to 2nd or 3rd week of October and the documents be
supplied to me in order to know the contents of the
same.

Yours faithfully,

(M.B.KATAGALKAR)”



12. On 07.10.2004 another notice is issued by the
Inquiry Officer to the petitioner. It reads as follows:
07.10.2004
“²æÃ.JA.©.PÀlUÁ¼ÀPÀgÀ ¢£ÁAPÀ:
PÉ:C¥sï.PÉ.Dgï.ZÀªÁít,
¥Áèl £ÀA.37, ºÀ£ÀĪÀiÁ£À £ÀUÀgÀ,
II

¸ÉÖÃeï, ¨É¼ÀUÁ« EªÀjUÉ,

ªÀiÁ£ÀågÉ,

«µÀAiÀÄ:- ²æÃ JªÀ® ©.PÀlUÁ¼ÀPÀgÀ, ¥ÀæxÀªÀÄ zÀeÉð GUÁæt ¥Á®PÀ EªÀgÀ
ªÉÄð£À GUÁæt PÉÆgÀvÉAiÀÄ §UÉÎ «ZÁgÀuÉ PÀÄjvÀÄ.

1) 1178 14-09-2004.
G¯ÉèÃR:- F PÀZÉÃj ¥ÀvÀæ £ÀA. , ¢£ÁAPÀ:
2) 05-10-2004.

¤ªÀÄä ¥ÀvÀæ ¢£ÁAPÀ:
27-6-2004

F »AzÉ ¢£ÁAPÀ: gÀAzÀÄ «ZÁgÀuÉvÀªÀ£ÀÆß ¤UÀ¢
¥Àr¹zÁUÀ, ¤ÃªÀÅ PÉ®ªÉÇAzÀÄ ¸ÀPÁðj ¥ÀvÀæzÀ zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß PÉý¢ÝÃj. DUÀ¯ÉÃ
¤ªÀÄUÉ ¨ÉÃPÁUÀĪÀ zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß MªÉÄä¯É PÉý ¥ÀqÉzÀÄPÉÆAqÀÄ, «ZÁgÀuÉUÉ
ºÁdgÁUÀ®Ä w½¸À¯ÁVvÀÄÛ. ªÀÄvÀÄÛ CAzÀÄ PÉüÀ¯ÁzÀ zÁR¯É MzÀV¹ «ZÁgÀuÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
1-9-2004
¤ªÀÄä «£ÀAwAvÀAvÉ, ¢£ÁAPÀ: PÉÌ ªÀÄÄAzÀÆqÀ¯Á¬ÄvÀÄ. CAzÀÄ
ºÁdgÁV ªÀÄvÉÛà PÉ®ªÀÅ ¸Àà¶×ÃPÀgÀt PÉýzÁUÀ, CªÀÅUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¥ÀjUÀt¹ «ZÁgÀuÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
14-9-2004
¢: gÀAzÀÄ ¤UÀ¢ ¥Àr¸À¯Á¬ÄvÀÄ. CAzÀÄ ¤ÃªÀÅ UÉÊgÀÄ ºÁdgÁV
ªÉÊzÀåQÃAiÀÄ PÁgÀtUÀ¼ÀÆ ºÁUÀÆ E¤ßvÀgÀ zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß MzÀV¸ÀĪÀÅzÀPÁÌV ªÀÄvÉÛ

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

8-10-2004
ªÀÄÄAzÀÆqÀ®Ä «£ÀAw¹PÉÆArj. CzÀ£ÀÄß ¥ÀjUÀt¹ FUÀ ¢£ÁAPÀ:
gÀAzÀÄ «ZÁgÀuÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¤UÀ¢ ¥Àr¸À¯ÁVvÀÄÛ. ºÁUÀÆ CªÀ±ÀåPÀ zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß PÀZÉÃjUÉ
(1)
§AzÀÄ ¥ÀjÃQë¸À§ºÀÄzÉAzÀÄ ªÉÄÃ¯É PÁt¹zÀ G¯ÉèÃR gÀ ªÀiÁ®PÀ w½¸À¯ÁVzÉ.
FUÀ ªÀÄvÉÛà C£ÁgÉÆÃUÀå ºÁUÀÆ E¤ßvÀgÀ PÁgÀtUÀ¼À £É¥ÀªÉÇrØ JgÀqÀÄ ªÁgÀUÀ¼À
ªÀÄÄAzÀªÁrPÉUÉ «£ÀAw¹gÀÄwÛÃj. EzÀÄ ¸ÀPÁgÀt ºÁUÁ AiÉÆÃUÀåªÉ¤¸ÀĪÀ¢®è.
DzÁUÀÆå ¤ªÀÄä ¥ÀvÀæzÀ CA±ÀUÀ½UÉ GvÀÛgÀ ¤ÃqÀ¯ÁUÀÄwÛzÉ.
¤ªÀÄä ¥ÀvÀæzÀ JgÀqÀ£Éà CA±ÀzÀ°è w½¹gÀĪÀAvÉ ªÀÄAqÀ£Á¢üPÁjUÀ¼ÀÄ, PÁ£ÀÆ£ÀÄ
¸À®ºÉUÁgÀgÁVzÀÝ°è ªÀiÁvÀæ ¤ÃªÀÅ ªÀQîgÀ£ÀÄß £ÉëĹPÉÆ¼ÀÀÄzÀÄ. CxÀªÁ CAvÀºÀ
¸ÀAzÀ¨sÀðªÉ¤¹zÀ°è ²¸ÀÄÛ, ¥Áæ¢üPÁgÀªÀÅ C£ÀĪÀÄw ¤ÃqÀ¨ÉÃPÁUÀÄvÀÛzÉ. PÁgÀt, F ¤ªÀÄä
¨ÉÃrPÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß £ÁªÀÅ ¥ÀjUÀt¹®è. ¨ÉÃPÁzÀgÉ ªÀÄvÉÆÛ§â ¸ÀPÁðjà £ËPÀgÀgÀ£ÀÄß
¸ÀºÁAiÀÄPÀ£À£ÁßV £ÉëĹPÉÆ¼ÀÀÄzÀÄ.
EzÉà ¥ÀvÀæzÀ ªÀÄÆgÀ£Éà CA±ÀzÀ°è ¤ÃªÀÅ ªÉÊzÀå QÃAiÀÄ PÁgÀtUÀ¼À £É¥À ºÉýzÀÄÝ,
CzÀPÉÌ ¥ÁgÀPÀªÁV ªÉÊzÀågÀ ¥ÀæªÀiÁt ¥ÀvÀæ ®UÀwÛ¹gÀĪÀ¢®è. DzÀÝjAzÀ F PÁgÀtªÀÅ
AiÉÆÃUÀåªÁzÀzÉݤ¸ÀĪÀ¢®è.
E£ÀÆß PÉÆ£ÉAiÀÄzÁV ¸ÁQëUÀ¼À ¥ÀnÖ MzÀV¸À®Ä PÉýgÀÄwÛÃj. EzÀÄ FUÁUÀ¯ÉÃ
23-7-2001
¤ªÀÄä ¥ÀvÀæzÀ G¯ÉèÃRzÀ°è ¤ÃªÉà £ÀªÀÄÆ¹gÀĪÀ ¸ÀPÁðgÀzÀ vÁ: gÀ
¥ÀvÀæzÀ¯Éèà M¼ÀUÉÆArgÀÄvÀÛzÉ. ºÁUÀÆ F ¥ÀvÀæzÀ £ÀPÀ®Ä ¤ªÀÄä §½ EgÀĪÀzÁV ¤ÃªÀÅ
27-8-2004 1-9-2004
F »AzÉ ºÁdgÁUÀzÀ ºÁUÀÆ ) PÉýgÀÄ«j. DzÁUÀÆå
FUÀ CzÀgÀ MAzÀÄ ¥ÀæwAiÀÄ£ÀÄß PÀ½¸À¯ÁUÀÄwÛzÉ. G½zÀ zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß MzÀV¸À®Ä
III
ªÀÄvÉÛà PÉýgÀÄwÛÃj. EAvÀºÀ zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß (C£ÉPÀëgÀ- ) F PÀZÉÃjUÉ §AzÀÄ
¥ÀjÃQë¸À§ºÀÄzÉAzÀÄ ºÁUÀÆ CzÀPÁÌj ¸ÀÆPÀÛ ªÀåªÀ¸ÉÜ ªÀiÁqÀĪÀzÁV, F ªÀiÁ®PÀ
w½¸À¯ÁUÀÄwÛzÉ.
F J®è CA±ÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ®PÀëzÀ°èlÄÖPÉÆAqÀÄ, FUÀ «ZÁgÀuÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¤ÃªÀÅ
19-10-2004
«£ÀAw¹zÀAvÉ ªÀÄÄAzÀÆr EzÉà ¢£ÁAPÀ: gÀAzÀÄ ªÀÄÄAeÁ£É
11.00
UÀAmÉUÉ ¤UÀ¢ ¥Àr¸À¯ÁVzÉ .

CAzÀÄ ¤ÃªÀÅ ¸ÀévÀ: ºÁdgÁUÀ¨ÉÃPÀÄ. ¤ªÀÄä ¸ÀªÀÄPÀëªÀÄ ¸ÁQëUÀ¼À ºÉýPÉ
¥ÀqÉAiÀįÁUÀĪÀzÀÄ. ºÁUÀÆ ¤ªÀÄUÀÆ CªÀgÀ£ÀÄß ¥Àæ²ß¸À®Ä CªÀPÁ±À PÀ°à¸À¯ÁUÀĪÀzÀÄ.
CAzÀÄ ¤ÃªÀÅ «ZÁgÀuÉUÉ ºÁdgÁV, ºÉýPÉ ¸À°è¸À¢zÀÝgÉ, DgÉÆÃ¥ÀUÀ¼À §UÉÎ ¤ªÀÄä
¥ÀæwªÁzÀªÉ£ÀÆ E®è JAzÀÄ ¨sÁ«¸À¯ÁUÀÄvÀÛzÉ. ºÁUÀÆ KPÀ ¥ÀQëÃAiÀĪÁV ªÀÄÄA¢£À

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

¤zsÁðgÀªÀ£ÀÄß PÉÊUÉÆ¼Àî¯ÁUÀĪÀzÀÄ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ EzÀÄ ¤ªÀÄUÉ MzÀV¸À¯ÁUÀÄwÛgÀĪÀ PÉÆ£ÉAiÀÄ
CªÀPÁ±À JAzÀÄ, F ªÀÄÆ®PÀ w½AiÀÄ ¥Àr¸À¯ÁUÀÄwÛzÉ.

vÀªÀÄä «±Áé¹PÀ,
¸À»/-
«ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjUÀ¼ÀÄ ºÁUÀÆ
¸ÀÆ¥ÀjmÉArAUÀ EAf¤ÃAiÀÄgÀgÀÄ,
gÁ.ºÉ.ªÀÈvÀÛ, zsÁgÀªÁqÀ”


13. Then the petitioner submits a representation on
11.10.2004 seeking assistance of an advocate as his defence
representative in the Departmental Inquiry. The representation
reads as follows:
From,
Shri. M. B. Katagalkar.
Store Keeper
C/o. Smt. K.R.Chavan,
Plot No.37, IInd Stage,
Hanuman Nagar,
Belgaum.
Dt.11/10/04.
“To,
The Secretary,
Public Works Department
MS. Building,
th
6 Floor, Bangalore.





Sir,

Sub: Regarding seeking permission to engage
Advocate in the Departmental enquiry.

With reference to the above subject, I respectfully
submit as under:

1. A Departmental enquiry has been instituted against
me wide G.O. P.W.D. 260 99 Dld. 24.09.2002.
E¸À«

2. The appraised enquiry is pertaining to the allegation
shortago of materials in the stores of the Office of
Executive Engineer, National Division, Beigaum.

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021


3. The Departmental enquiry is hold by the Enquiry
Officer, i.o. Superintending Engineer, National Highway
Circle, Dharwad.

4. I respectfully submit that since about an year or so I
have been suffering from Diabetes with hypertension
and hyper-triglyceride with depression. The illness of
depression is affecting my memory.

5. It is further submitted that the enquiry is in respect of
my service as a 1st Division Store Keeper during the
period 1990 to 1996, already another enquiry is held by
the learned retired District Judge, Shri. K. R. Kodaganur.
Wide G.O. P.W.D. 205 97 Dtd. 03.05.2002. This
E¸À«
enquiry is pertaining to the period until 1995. As per the
decision passed by the learned District Judge and
Enquiry Officer and the G.O P.W.D. 205. 97 Dtd.
E¸À«
03.05.2002, I am already suffering punishment.
However, it is respectfully stated here that, the order
passed by the learned Rtd. District Judge, I have alroady
prepared an appeal No-8796/02 before the Karnataka
Administrative Tribunal at Bangalore under Section 19 of
the Administrative Tribunal Act 1985.

5. At this stage respectfully submit that the matter in
issue before the enquiry conducted by the learned Rtd.
District Judge and the charges leveled against me in the
present onquiry are intorlinkod and they havo mutually
interdependence. It calls for a detailed study and
availabilities of the documents involved in both enquiry.
The present case is highly complicated. The present
health set up and the depression suffered by me, have
incapacitated me to depend on myself. Since it also
involves mixed question of law and facts, I have to avail
the assistance of an advocate, to defend myself.

7. In this regard, I have already submitted an application
dated 05.10.2004 to the Enquiry Officer, thereby
requesting him to grant permission to engage and
Advocate. However, the Enquiry Officer rejected my
request (Wide letter No. 1331 dtd. 07.10.2004). Hence I
am giving this application.

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

8. For the forgoing reasons, I earnestly request you to
kindly accord permission to engage an Advocate, to
defend myself in the best interest of justice at an early
date.

Thanking you,

Yours faithfully.

(M. B. Katagalkar.)


14. This has reached the doors of the Inquiry Officer on
15.10.2004 as could be seen from the acknowledgment. On
19.10.2004, after the receipt of the representation seeking
engagement of an advocate as the defence representative of
the petitioner, inquiry proceedings are conducted. In the
inquiry proceedings, charge 1 is dropped. Charge 2, 3 and 4
are only inquired into. The proceedings of charge 2, 3 and 4 are
as follows:
2
“DgÉÆÃ¥À- PÉÌ ¸ÀA§AzsÀ¥ÀlÖAvÉ: C©üAiÉÆÃPÉÌ C¢üPÁjAiÀÄÄ CAwªÀĪÁV
²¸ÀÄÛ ¥Áæ¢üPÁjAiÀÄ ¥ÀgÀªÁV ºÁdgÀÄ ¥Àr¹zÀ ªÁzÀ:-
2
DgÉÆÃ¥À- F zÉÆÃµÁgÉÆÃ¥ÀzÀAvÉ ²æÃ JA.©.PÀlUÁ¼ÀPÀgÀ ¥Àæ.zÀ.G.¥Á.
1991 96
EªÀgÀÄ gÁ.ºÉ.«¨sÁUÀ ¨É¼ÀUÁAªÀ jAzÀ gÀ CªÀ¢üAiÀİè MlÄÖ
40,15,723-00
ªÉÆvÀÛzÀµÀÄÖ GUÁæt ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À PÉÆgÀvÉUÉ ºÉÆuÉUÁgÀgÁVzÁÝgÉAzÀÄ
C¥Á¢¸À¯ÁVzÉ. ¸ÀzÀjà C¥Á¢vÀjUÉ ¸ÁPÀµÀÄÖ CªÀ¢ü ¤ÃrzÁUÀÆå F ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß
vÀªÀÄä ªÀUÁðªÀuÉ £ÀAvÀgÀ ªÀÄÄAzÉ ¥Àæ¨sÁgÀ ªÀ»¹PÉÆAqÀ GUÁæt ¥Á®PÀjUÉ ºÀ¸ÁÛAvÀgÀ
6 7
ªÀiÁqÀ°®è JA§ PÁgÀtPÁÌV GUÁæt ¸ÀA»vÉ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ºÁUÀÆ (PÀ£Á¸ÀA.
1966
£ÀqÀªÀ½PÉ) ¤AiÀĪÀÄUÀ¼ÀÄ gÀ G®èAWÀ£ÉAiÀiÁVzÉ JAzÀÄ w½¸À¯ÁVzÉ.

10:97
ªÀĺÁ¯ÉÃR¥Á®gÀÄ ¨ÉAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ EªÀgÀÄ gÀ°è £ÀqɹzÀ ¯ÉPÀÌ
vÀ¥Á¸ÀuÉAiÀİè F ªÀåvÁå¸À UÀªÀĤ¹zÀÄÝ CzÀgÀAvÉ ¥Àj²Ã°¸À¯ÁV CzsÀð ªÁ¶ðPÀ
6
ªÀgÀ¢AiÀİè MlÄÖ E£ïªÉʸÀÄUÀ¼À ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß «¨sÁUÀ PÀZÉÃj¬ÄAzÀ G¥À«¨sÁUÀPÉÌ
1
¤ÃrzÉ JAzÀÄ vÉÆÃj¸À¯ÁVzÉ. («ªÀgÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ®UÀwÛ¸À¯ÁVzÉ ¨sÁUÀ- ) DzÀgÉ

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

ªÁ¸ÀÛªÀªÁV F ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß G¥À«¨sÁUÀzÀªÀgÀÄ vÀªÀÄä ¯ÉPÀÌPÉÌ vÉUÉzÀÄPÉÆArgÀĪÀ¢®è.
ºÁUÀÆ F ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß vÁªÀÅ ¥ÀqÉ¢gÀĪÀÅ¢®èªÉAzÀÄ PÁAiÀÄð¤ªÁðºÀPÀ
EAf¤ÃAiÀÄgÀªÀjUÉ vÀªÀÄä ¥ÀvÀæzÀ°è w½AiÀÄ¥Àr¹gÀÄvÁÛgÉ. (F ¥ÀvÀæzÀ «ªÀgÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß
®UÀwÛ¹zÀ «ªÀgÀUÀ¼À°è G¯ÉèÃT¸À¯ÁVzÉ)

C®èzÉà EvÀgÀ ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼ÁzÀ PÁålD¬Ä¸ï ªÉÊl¥ÉAmï gÉÆÃqÀ qɰ£ÉÃl¸ïð
2
ªÁlgÀ¥ÀÆæ¥sï mÉAmïì ¸ÉÊ£ï¨ÉÆÃqïð EvÁå¢ («ªÀgÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ®UÀwÛ¸À¯ÁVzÉ ¨sÁUÀ- )
¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß CAiÀiÁ wAUÀ¼À GUÁæt ¹éÃPÀÈw ¥ÀvÀæUÀ¼À°è ¯ÉPÀÌPÉÌ vÉUÉzÀÄPÉÆAqÀÄ £ÀAvÀgÀ
CzsÀðªÁ¶ðPÀ ªÀgÀ¢AiÀİè PÉÌ ©qÀ¯ÁVzÉ. »ÃUÉ §ÄzÁå¥ÀǪÀðPÀªÁV PÉÆgÀvÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
ªÀÄÄaÑnÖzÀÄÝ PÀAqÀÄ §A¢zÀÄÝ F PÉÆgÀvÉUÉ DV£À GUÁæt¥Á®PÀgÉ
ºÉÆuÉUÁgÀgÁVgÀÄvÁÛgÉAzÀÄ C©ü¥ÁæAiÀÄ ¥ÀqÀ¯ÁVzÉ.

F DgÉÆÃ¥ÀzÀ §UÉÎ MmÁÖV «±ÉèõÀuÉ £ÀAvÀgÀPÉÆgÀvÉ ªÉÆvÀÛ gÀÆ.
40,15,723-00 39,91,116-00
§zÀ¯ÁV JAzÀÄ PÀAqÀÄ §A¢zÉ EªÀÅUÀ¼À
1 (2)
«ªÀgÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¨sÁUÀ( ) ºÁUÀÆ ¨sÁUÀ JAzÀÄ ¥ÀævÉåÃPÀªÁV £ÀªÀÄÆ¢¹
EzÀgÉÆA¢UÉ ®UÀwÛ¸À¯ÁVzÉ.

2
DgÉÆÃ¥À- PÉÌ ¸ÀA§AzsÀ¥ÀlÖAvÉ D¥Á¢vÀ£ÀÄ «ªÀj¹zÀAvÉ ºÁUÀÆ DvÀ£À ªÁzÀ

VII(b)
F «ZÁgÀuÉUÉ ¸ÀzÀj C¥Á¢vÀ£ÀÄ UÉÊgÀÄ ºÁdgÁVzÀÄÝ F GUÁæt PÉÆgÀvÉUÉ
¸ÀA§AzsÀ¥ÀlÖAvÉ AiÀiÁªÀ ªÁzÀªÀ£ÀÄß ªÀÄAr¹gÀĪÀÅ¢®è. ºÁUÀÆ ¥ÀÇgÀPÀ zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß
¤ÃrgÀĪÀÅ¢®è, C®èzÉà DvÀ£À ¥ÀgÀªÁV AiÀiÁªÀ ¸ÁQëUÀ¼ÀÆ ºÁdgÁVgÀĪÀÅ¢®è.

2
DgÉÆÃ¥À- gÀ §UÉÎ «ZÁgÀuÉAiÀİè MzÀV §AzÀ ²¸ÀÄì ¥Áæ¢üPÁjAiÀÄ ¥ÀgÀ ªÀÄAr¹zÀ
¸ÁQë ¸ÁgÁA±À:-

19-10-2004
¢: gÀAzÀÄ £ÀqÉzÀ «ZÁgÀuÉ PÁ®PÉÌ DUÀ ¯ÉPÀÌ C¢üÃPÀëPÀgÁV
21-6-95 16-7-18
PÁAiÀÄð¤ªÀð»¹zÀ ( jAzÀ ) ²æÃ r.¸ÀA¥ÀvÀPÀĪÀiÁgÀ, ºÁUÀÆ
(6-
PÁAiÀÄð¤ªÁðºÀPÀ EAf¤ÃAiÀÄgÀ JAzÀÄ PÁAiÀÄð¤ªÀð»¹zÀ ²æÃ JA.±ÀgÀt¥Àà
10-96 6-7-98)
jAzÀ EªÀgÀÄ ¸ÁQë £ÀÄr¢zÀÄÝ CzÀ£ÀÄß °TvÀ gÀÆ¥ÀzÀ°è vÀªÀÄä
ºÉýPÉ ¤ÃrzÁÝgÉ. CªÀÅUÀ¼À£ÀÄß F ªÀgÀ¢AiÉÆA¢UÉ ®UÀwÛ¸À¯ÁVzÉ.


(1) ²æÃ r.¸ÀA¥ÀvÀPÀĪÀiÁgÀ, ®PÀÌ C¢üÃPÀëPÀgÀ ¸ÁQë:
DUÀ ¯ÉPÀÌ C¢üÃPÀëPÀgÁV PÁAiÀÄð¤ªÀð»¹zÀ ²æÃ r.¸ÀA¥ÀvÀPÀĪÀiÁgÀ CªÀgÀÄ
¸ÀzÀjà «ZÁgÀuÉ PÁ®PÉÌ ¸ÁQë £ÀÄrAiÀÄÄvÁÛ Drmï £ÀªÀgÀÄ ¸ÀÆa¹zÀAvÉ GUÁæt
PÉÆgÀvÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¥Àj²Ã°¸À®Ä CzsÀðªÁ¶ðPÀ ªÀgÀ¢ vÀAiÀiÁj¸À¯Á¬ÄvÀÄ. CzÀgÀ°è MmÁÖgÉ
6
E£ïªÁ¬Ä¸ïUÀ¼À°è ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß «¨sÁUÀ PÀZÉÃj¬ÄAzÀ G¥À«¨sÁUÀPÉÌ ¤ÃqÀ¯ÁVzÉ
JAzÀÄ vÉÆÃj¸À¯ÁVzÉ. DzÀgÉ DzÀgÉ E£ïªÁ¬Ä¸ïUÀ¼À ªÉÄÃ¯É ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß
¥ÀqÉzÀªÀgÀ ¸ÁQë ¸À»UÀ¼ÀÄ EzÀÄÝ F ¸À»UÀ¼ÀÄ AiÀiÁgÀzÀÄ JA§ÄzÀgÀzÀgÀ ¸ÀvÀå w½AiÀÄ®Ä
G¥À«¨sÁUÀzÀ ¸ÀºÁAiÀÄPÀ PÁAiÀÄð¤ªÁðºÀPÀ EAf¤ÃAiÀÄgÀ UÀ½UÉ ¥ÀvÀæ §gÉzÀÄ
«ZÁj¸À¯ÁV F E£ïªÁ¬Ä¸ïUÀ¼À°è ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß CªÀgÀÄ ¥ÀqÉ¢gÀĪÀÅ¢®è JAzÀÄ
w½¹gÀÄvÁÛgÉ. (¥ÀvÀæUÀ¼ÀÄ PÀqÀvÀzÀ°è EzÉ)

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

F PÁgÀt¢AzÀ GUÁæt ¥Á®PÀgÀÄ GzÉÝñÀ¥ÀǪÀðPÀªÁV
E£ïªÁ¬Ä¸ïUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ºÁUÀÆ ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß zÀÄgÀÆ¥ÀAiÉÆÃUÀ¥Àr¹zÁÝgÉAzÀÄ
C©ü¥ÁæAiÀÄ¥ÀlÖgÀÄ. (°TvÀ ºÉýPÉ ®UÀwÛ¸À¯ÁVzÉ)

(2)
²æÃ JA.±ÀgÀt¥Àà, PÁAiÀÄð¤ªÁðºÀPÀ EAf¤ÃAiÀÄgÀ EªÀgÀ ¸ÁQë:-

£ÀAvÀgÀ ¸ÁQë £ÀÄrzÀ DUÀ PÁAiÀÄð¤ªÁðºÀPÀ EAf¤ÃAiÀÄgÀ DVzÀÝ ²æÃ
6
JA.±ÀgÀt¥Àà CªÀgÀÄ E£ïªÁ¬Ä¸ïUÀ¼À°è ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß G¥À«¨sÁUÀzÀ ¸ÀºÁAiÀÄPÀ
PÁAiÀÄð¤ªÁðºÀPÀ EAf¤ÃAiÀÄgÀ UÀ½UÉ ¤ÃrzÀÄÝ CªÀÅUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¥Àj²Ã°¸À¯ÁV F
¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¥ÀÇgÉʸÀ®Ä G¥À«¨sÁUÀ¢AzÀ ¨ÉÃrPÉ ¥ÀvÀæ EgÀĪÀÅ¢®è. ºÁUÀÆ
PÁAiÀÄð¤ªÁðºÀPÀ EAf¤ÃAiÀÄgÀ CªÀjAzÀ ¸ÁªÀÄVæ ©qÀÄUÀqÉUÉ DzÉñÀ
¥ÀqÉ¢gÀĪÀÅ¢®è. ºÁUÀÆ ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¥ÀqÉ¢gÀĪÀ §UÉÎ G¥À«¨sÁUÀzÀ ¸ÀºÁAiÀÄPÀ
PÁAiÀÄð¤ªÁðºÀPÀ EAf¤ÃAiÀÄgÀ UÀ½UÉ ¥ÀvÀæ §gÉzÁUÀ CªÀgÀÄ ¥ÀqÉ¢gÀĪÀÅ¢®è JAzÀÄ
w½¹gÀÄvÁÛgÉ. (¥ÀvÀæUÀ¼ÀÄ PÀqÀvÀzÀ°è EzÉ)

F PÁgÀt¢AzÀ ¸ÀzÀjà ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼ÀÄ zÀÄgÀÄ¥ÀAiÉÆÃUÀ DVzÉ JAzÀÄ
C©ü¥ÁæAiÀÄ¥ÀlÖgÀÄ. (°TvÀ ºÉýPÉ ®UÀwæ¸À¯ÁVzÉ)

9 (a) 2
zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À DzsÁgÀ¢AzÀ DgÉÆÃ¥À- gÀ ¥Àj²Ã®£É ºÁUÀÆ EzÀPÉÌ
2
¸ÀA§AzsÀ¥ÀlÖ ¸ÁPÀëåzÀ «±ÉèõÀuÉ ºÁUÀÆ F DgÉÆÃ¥À (DgÉÆÃ¥À- )zÀ ªÉÄïÉ
«ZÁgÀuÁ C¢üPÁjUÀ¼À ¤tðAiÀÄ:-

(a) 2
zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À CzsÁgÀ¢AzÀ DgÉÆÃ¥À- gÀ ¥Àj²Ã®£É:- F DgÉÆÃ¥ÀzÀAvÉ
1991 1996
gÁºÉ.«¨sÁUÀ ¨É¼ÀUÁA«AiÀİè jAzÀ gÀ CªÀ¢üAiÀİè MlÄÖ
40,15,723-00
gÀÆ. ªÉÆvÀÛzÀµÀÄÖ GUÁæt ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À PÉÆgÀvÉUÉ JA.©.PÀlUÁ¼ÀPÀgÀ,
EªÀgÉà ºÉÆuÉUÁgÀgÁVgÀÄvÁÛgÉAzÀÄ C¥Á¢¸À¯ÁVzÉ. EªÀjUÉ ¸ÁPÀµÀÄÖ, CªÀ¢ü
¤ÃqÀ¯ÁVzÀÝgÀÆ vÀªÀÄä £ÀAvÀgÀ ¥Àæ¨sÁgÀ ªÀ»¹PÉÆAqÀ GUÁæt ¥Á®PÀjUÉ ºÀ¸ÁÛAvÀgÀ
6 7
ªÀiÁqÀ°®è. JA§ PÁgÀtPÁÌV GUÁæt ¸ÀA»vÉAiÀÄ RArPÉ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ºÁUÀÆ
1966
PÀ£ÁðlPÀ £ÁUÀjÃPÀ ¸ÀA»vÉ (£ÀqÀªÀ½PÉ) ¤AiÀĪÀÄUÀ¼ÀÄ gÀ G®AWÀ£É DVzÉ
JAzÀÄ w½¸À¯ÁVzÉ.

40,15,723-00
F DgÉÆÃ¥ÀzÀ PÉÆgÀvÉ ªÉÆvÀÛ gÀÆ. JAzÀÄ PÁt¸À¯ÁVzÀÝgÀÆ
39,91,116-00
«ªÀgÀªÁzÀ «±ÉèõÀuÉ £ÀAvÀgÀ ªÀiÁvÀæ JAzÀÄ PÀAqÀÄ §gÀÄvÀÛzÉ. EzÀ£ÀÄß
I 33,45,380-00
¨sÁUÀ- gÀÆ. PÉÆgÀvÉ
II .6,45,736-00
¨sÁUÀ- gÀÆ PÉÆgÀvÉ
JAzÀÄ »ÃUÉ JgÀqÀÄ ¨sÁUÀUÀ¼À°è ¨ÉÃ¥Àðr¹ ¤ÃqÀ¯ÁVzÉ.”


15. Charge 2, 3 and 4 are inquired into and completed
within the working hours of 19.10.2004, which would be less
than 10 hours. Witnesses who were present therein are

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

examined. No cross-examination, as the petitioner was absent,
as his representation seeking assistance of a defence
representative was still pending before the Enquiry Officer or
the disciplinary authority as the case would be and had no
notice of the enquiry that was to be held on 19.10.2004. This
could be inferred or vindicatively inferred by the endorsement
dated 18.11.2004, the date on which the representation of the
petitioner seeking engagement of an advocate as his defence
representative comes to be rejected. This is as observed on
18.11.2004. Therefore, between the date of the representation
11.10.2004 to its rejection 18.11.2004, the entire inquiry is
over in less than 10 hours and it is an exparte enquiry, as the
petitioner had no notice of the enquiry that was to be held on
19.10.2004, he may have notice of the inquiry that was earlier
held or earlier to be conducted, but the date 19.10.2004 was
never communicated, as his representation seeking
appointment of an advocate as his defence representative was
yet to be answered by the Disciplinary Authority. The Inquiry
Officer in his hottest haste concludes the proceedings in 10
hours. The conclusion of the proceedings in 10 hours is not the
issue but the penalty that is imposed is one of dismissal from

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

service. It is the extreme penalty of dismissal that shocks the
Court in an ex-parte proceedings against the petitioner.


16. The Inquiry being conducted on 19.10.2004 is an
admitted fact. The enquiry being exparte is another admitted
fact. The penalty of dismissal on such exparte enquiry could not
have been imposed by the Disciplinary Authority. Not stopping
at that, the Tribunal glosses over this fact that it was an
exparte Inquiry on the score that the findings of the inquiry
Officer and the Disciplinary Authority are not amenable to
judicial review. There is a paradigm shift in the judicial thought
with regard to the judicial review over Departmental Inquiry in
the judgments rendered by the Apex Court in State of
1
Jharkhand and Others v. Ranjan Kumar and Others which
reads as follows:
“ 19. The law is settled that the findings of fact
recorded by the disciplinary authority are not to be
interfered with by the Court as a matter of course,
particularly while exercising jurisdiction under Article 226
of the Constitution of India. In departmental
proceedings, the standard of proof is one of
preponderance of probabilities. Where the material on
record reasonably supports the departmental case, the
High Court would not reappreciate the evidence as if
sitting in appeal. In this regard, reference may be made
to the decision of this Court in Union of India v. Subrata
Nath , in Civil Appeal Nos. 7939- 7940 of 2022 decided

1
2026 SCC OnLine SC 824

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

on 22.11.2022, wherein the limits of judicial review in
service disciplinary matters have been authoritatively
reiterated. The following paragraphs are pertinent:

“15. It is well settled that courts ought to
refrain from interfering with findings of facts
recorded in a departmental inquiry except in
circumstances where such findings are patently
perverse or grossly incompatible with the evidence
on record, based on no evidence. However, if
principles of natural justice have been violated or
the statutory regulations have not been adhered
to or there are malafides attributable to the
Disciplinary Authority, then the courts can
certainly interfere.
16. In the above context, following are the
observations made by a three-Judge Bench of this
Court in B.C. Chaturvedi (supra):

“12. Judicial review is not an appeal from a
decision but a review of the manner in which the
decision is made. Power of judicial review is
meant to ensure that the individual receives fair
treatment and not to ensure that the conclusion
which the authority reaches is necessarily correct
in the eye of the court. When an inquiry is
conducted on charges of misconduct by a public
servant, the Court/Tribunal is concerned to
determine whether the inquiry was held by a
competent officer or whether rules of natural
justice are complied with. Whether the findings or
conclusions are based on some evidence, the
authority entrusted with the power to hold inquiry
has jurisdiction, power and authority to reach a
finding of fact or conclusion. But that finding must
be based on some evidence. Neither the technical
rules of Evidence Act nor of proof of fact or
evidence as defined therein, apply to disciplinary
proceeding. When the authority accepts that
evidence and conclusion receives support
therefrom, the disciplinary authority is entitled to
hold that the delinquent officer is guilty of the
charge. The Court/Tribunal in its power of judicial
review does not act as appellate authority to
reappreciate the evidence and to arrive at its own
independent findings on the evidence. The
Court/Tribunal may interfere where the authority
held the proceedings against the delinquent
officer in a manner inconsistent with the rules of
natural justice or in violation of statutory rules

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

prescribing the mode of inquiry or where the
conclusion or finding reached by the disciplinary
authority is based on no evidence. If the
conclusion or finding be such as no reasonable
person would have ever reached, the
Court/Tribunal may interfere with the conclusion
or the finding, and mould the relief so as to make
it appropriate to the facts of each case.

13. The disciplinary authority is the sole judge
of facts. Where appeal is presented, the appellate
authority has coextensive power to reappreciate
the evidence or the nature of punishment. In a
disciplinary inquiry, the strict proof of legal
evidence and findings on that evidence are not
relevant. Adequacy of evidence or reliability of
evidence cannot be permitted to be canvassed
before the Court/Tribunal. In Union of India v.
H.C. Goel 1963 SCC OnLine SC 16 : (1964) 4 SCR
718 this Court held at p. 728 that if the
conclusion, upon consideration of the evidence
reached by the disciplinary authority, is perverse
or suffers from patent error on the face of the
record or based on no evidence at all, a writ of
certiorari could be issued.
xxx xxx xxx
xxx xxx xxx
18. A review of the above legal position would
establish that the disciplinary authority, and on
appeal the appellate authority, being fact-finding
authorities have exclusive power to consider the
evidence with a view to maintain discipline. They
are invested with the discretion to impose
appropriate punishment keeping in view the
magnitude or gravity of the misconduct. The High
Court/Tribunal, while exercising the power of
judicial review, cannot normally substitute its own
conclusion on penalty and impose some other
penalty. If the punishment imposed by the
disciplinary authority or the appellate authority
shocks the conscience of the High Court/Tribunal,
it would appropriately mould the relief, either
directing the disciplinary/appellate authority to
reconsider the penalty imposed, or to shorten the
litigation, it may itself, in exceptional and rare
cases, impose appropriate punishment with
cogent reasons in support thereof.”
[Emphasis laid]

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

17. In State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur v.
Nemi Chand Nalwaya (2011) 4 SCC 584, a two
Judge Bench of this Court held as below :

“7. It is now well settled that the courts will not
act as an appellate court and reassess the
evidence led in the domestic enquiry, nor
interfere on the ground that another view is
possible on the material on record. If the enquiry
has been fairly and properly held and the findings
are based on evidence, the question of adequacy
of the evidence or the reliable nature of the
evidence will not be grounds for interfering with
the findings in departmental enquiries. Therefore,
courts will not interfere with findings of fact
recorded in departmental enquiries, except where
such findings are based on no evidence or where
they are clearly perverse. The test to find out
perversity is to see whether a tribunal acting
reasonably could have arrived at such conclusion
or finding, on the material on record. The courts
will however interfere with the findings in
disciplinary matters, if principles of natural justice
or statutory regulations have been violated or if
the order is found to be arbitrary, capricious,
mala fide or based on extraneous considerations.
(Vide B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India (1995) 6
SCC 749 , Union of India v. G. Ganayutham
(1997) 7 SCC 463 , Bank of India v. Degala
Suryanarayana (1999) 5 SCC 762, and High Court
of Judicature at Bombay v. Shashikant S. Patil
(2000) 1 SCC 416).
[Emphasis laid]

18. In Chairman & Managing Director, V.S.P.
v. Goparaju Sri Prabhakara Hari Babu (2008) 5
SCC 569, a two Judge Bench of this Court referred
to several precedents on the Doctrine of
Proportionality of the order of punishment passed
by the Disciplinary Authority and held that :

“21. Once it is found that all the procedural
requirements have been complied with, the courts
would not ordinarily interfere with the quantum of
punishment imposed upon a delinquent employee.
The superior courts only in some cases may
invoke the doctrine of proportionality. If the
decision of an employer is found to be within the
legal parameters, the jurisdiction would ordinarily

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

not be invoked when the misconduct stands
proved.”

19. Laying down the broad parameters within
which the High Court ought to exercise its powers
under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India
and matters relating to disciplinary proceedings, a
two Judge Bench of this Court in Union of India v.
P. Gunasekaran (2015) 2 SCC 610 held thus :

“12. Despite the well-settled position, it is
painfully disturbing to note that the High Court
has acted as an appellate authority in the
disciplinary proceedings, reappreciating even the
evidence before the enquiry officer. The finding
on Charge I was accepted by the disciplinary
authority and was also endorsed by the Central
Administrative Tribunal. In disciplinary
proceedings, the High Court is not and cannot
act as a second court of first appeal. The High
Court, in exercise of its powers under Articles
226/227 of the Constitution of India, shall not
venture into reappreciation of the evidence. The
High Court can only see whether:
(a) the enquiry is held by a competent authority;
(b) the enquiry is held according to the
procedure prescribed in that behalf;
(c) there is violation of the principles of natural
justice in conducting the proceedings;
(d) the authorities have disabled themselves
from reaching a fair conclusion by some
considerations extraneous to the evidence
and merits of the case;
(e) the authorities have allowed themselves to
be influenced by irrelevant or extraneous
considerations;
(f) the conclusion, on the very face of it, is so
wholly arbitrary and capricious that no
reasonable person could ever have arrived at
such conclusion;
(g) the disciplinary authority had erroneously
failed to admit the admissible and material
evidence;
(h) the disciplinary authority had erroneously
admitted inadmissible evidence which
influenced the finding;
(i) the finding of fact is based on no evidence.

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

13. Under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of
India, the High Court shall not:
(i) reappreciate the evidence;
(ii) interfere with the conclusions in the enquiry,
in case the same has been conducted in
accordance with law;
(iii) go into the adequacy of the evidence;
(iv) go into the reliability of the evidence;
(v) interfere, if there be some legal evidence on
which findings can be based.
(vi) correct the error of fact however grave it
may appear to be;
(vii) go into the proportionality of punishment
unless it shocks its conscience.”

20. In Union of India v. Ex. Constable Ram
Karan, (2022) 1 SCC 373, a two Judge Bench of
this Court made the following pertinent
observations :

“23. The well-ingrained principle of law is
that it is the disciplinary authority, or the
appellate authority in appeal, which is to decide
the nature of punishment to be given to the
delinquent employee. Keeping in view the
seriousness of the misconduct committed by such
an employee, it is not open for the courts to
assume and usurp the function of the disciplinary
authority.

24. Even in cases where the punishment imposed
by the disciplinary authority is found to be
shocking to the conscience of the court, normally
the disciplinary authority or the appellate
authority should be directed to reconsider the
question of imposition of penalty. The scope of
judicial review on the quantum of punishment is
available but with a limited scope. It is only when
the penalty imposed appears to be shockingly
disproportionate to the nature of misconduct that
the courts would frown upon. Even in such a case,
after setting aside the penalty order, it is to be
left to the disciplinary/appellate authority to take
a call and it is not for the court to substitute its
decision by prescribing the quantum of
punishment. However, it is only in rare and
exceptional cases where the court might to

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

shorten the litigation may think of substituting its
own view as to the quantum of punishment in
place of punishment awarded by the competent
authority that too after assigning cogent reasons.”

21. A Constitution Bench of this Court in State
of Orissa (supra) held that if the order of dismissal
is based on findings that establish the prima facie
guilt of great delinquency of the respondent, then
the High Court cannot direct reconsideration of
the punishment imposed. Once the gravity of the
misdemeanour is established and the inquiry
conducted is found to be consistent with the
prescribed rules and reasonable opportunity
contemplated under the rules, has been afforded
to the delinquent employee, then the punishment
imposed is not open to judicial review by the
Court. As long as there was some evidence to
arrive at a conclusion that the Disciplinary
Authority did, such an order becomes unassailable
and the High Court ought to forebear from
interfering. The above view has been expressed in
Union of India v. Sardar Bahadur (1972) 4 SCC
618.

22. To sum up the legal position, being fact
finding authorities, both the Disciplinary Authority
and the Appellate Authority are vested with the
exclusive power to examine the evidence forming
part of the inquiry report. On finding the evidence
to be adequate and reliable during the
departmental inquiry, the Disciplinary Authority
has the discretion to impose appropriate
punishment on the delinquent employee keeping
in mind the gravity of the misconduct. However, in
exercise of powers of judicial review, the High
Court or for that matter, the Tribunal cannot
ordinarily reappreciate the evidence to arrive at its
own conclusion in respect of the penalty imposed
unless and until the punishment imposed is so
disproportionate to the offence that it would shock
the conscience of the High Court/Tribunal or is
found to be flawed for other reasons, as
enumerated in P. Gunasekaran (supra). If the
punishment imposed on the delinquent employee
is such that shocks the conscience of the High
Court or the Tribunal, then the

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

Disciplinary/Appellate Authority may be called
upon to re-consider the penalty imposed. Only in
exceptional circumstances, which need to be
mentioned, should the High Court/Tribunal decide
to impose appropriate punishment by itself, on
offering cogent reasons therefor.

23. Applying the law laid down above to the
instant case, we are of the view that the High
Court ought not to have interfered with the
findings of fact recorded by the Disciplinary
Authority.”

20. Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of
the present case, we are of the considered opinion that
the learned Single Judge correctly appreciated the
limited scope of judicial review and declined to substitute
judicial opinion in place of the findings recorded in the
disciplinary proceedings. However, the Division Bench,
while exercising appellate jurisdiction in the Letters
Patent Appeal, clearly transgressed the settled
parameters of judicial review by reappreciating the
evidence and disturbing concurrent findings of fact
recorded by the disciplinary authority, the Appellate
Authority and the Revisional Authority. Such an
approach cannot be countenanced in law.”

The Apex Court in the case of V.M. Saudagar (dead)
through Legal Heirs v. Divisional Commercial Manager, Central
Railway and Another has held has follows:
“17. Let us look at each of the charges levelled
against appellant and the findings reached by the Courts
below.

17.1 In respect of the first charge of demanding
illegal gratification from three passengers for allotment
of berths in the train, it is to be seen that one of the
passengers, namely Hemant Kumar, was not examined
and the other two passengers, namely Dinesh Choudhary
and Rajkumar Jaiswal have not supported the charges
against the appellant. CAT had reproduced their

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

statements in its order. In response to a specific
question as to whether the appellant demanded illegal
gratification of Rs. 20 from Dinesh Choudhary for
allotment of berths, the witness (Dinesh Choudhary)
categorically says that the appellant had not demanded
any illegal gratification and that the appellant had
categorically told that he would return the balance
amount and would give a receipt afterwards as he was to
attend 2-3 Coaches. In reply to another question, he
again reiterated that the appellant never demanded any
illegal gratification. Similar is the case with another
complainant - Rajkumar Jaiswal whose statement is full
of contradiction inasmuch as the charge is of paying Rs.
50; however, the receipt issued by the appellant for the
same was of Rs. 45. But Rajkumar Jaiswal deposed that
he had made payment of Rs. 120 to the appellant. Thus,
his statement is contrary to the charge itself. It is also to
be seen that the Enquiry Officer relied upon the
statement of Hemant Kumar even though he was not
even examined during enquiry and was thus not
subjected to cross-examination.

17.2 In respect of the second charge the appellant
being found in possession of excess undeclared cash
amounting to Rs. 1254/- (excluding his own private
cash), it is important to bear in mind that the appellant
is said to have deposited the said amount in the Railway
Sundry Accounts on the date of incident. Moreover, no
official document had been placed before the Enquiry
Officer to substantiate this charge. Before CAT, the
respondents had placed reliance on a circular dated
22.08.1997 issued by the Railway Board which was not
accepted by CAT on the ground that the same was
issued after the date of the incident. We are in
agreement with CAT's reasoning for not accepting the
said circular.

17.3 The third charge against the appellant was that
on 31.05.1988, he failed to recover a difference of fare
of Rs. 18/- from a passenger bearing Ticket No. 444750
travelling on berth no. 52 from Dadar to Nagpur. This
amount is said to have been recovered later in the
presence of the vigilance team. This charge was found
proved merely on the basis of the statement of the
Vigilance Inspector - N.C. Dhankode ignoring the fact

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

that the passenger bearing the said ticket number has
not been examined and nor the excess fare receipt book
highlighting about the amount of Rs. 18/- has been
produced before the Enquiry Officer.

17.4 The fourth charge against the appellant was that
he had forged the signature to extend the validity of his
duty card pass no. 030545 which was valid till
31.03.1986. However, the appellant is said to have
forged the signature of G.S. Topre, Office
Superintendent Pass Section, Nagpur, to extend the
validity of his card first up to 29.03.1987 and then
further up to 31.03.1988. This charge was found not
proved by the Enquiry Officer. No evidence has been
adduced to prove the charge of forgery and only the
authenticity of the pass has been verified by the Enquiry
Officer with the statement of the S.M. Gole, then Office
Superintendent Pass Section. CAT noted that even the
alleged forged signature has not been sent to
handwriting expert.

18.
In the above view of the matter, all the charges
have not been found to be proved conclusively against
the appellant and CAT, on the basis of the material on
record, had rightly interfered with the penalty of
dismissal from service against the appellant. The High
Court has failed to take note of the legal position that
when the findings of the Enquiry Officer were perverse
basing on completely misleading of the materials
produced before the Enquiry Officer, CAT was fully
justified in setting aside the order of penalty. The
incident happened on 31.05.1988, that is more than 37
years back. In the meanwhile, the delinquent employee
has passed away. Therefore, while setting aside the
impugned judgment of the High Court and restoring the
order of CAT, we direct that all the consequential
monetary benefits including pensionary benefits shall be
released in favour of the appellants who are legal heirs
of the deceased employee within a period of three
months from today. Ordered accordingly.

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021


17. Notwithstanding the aforesaid facts, the Tribunal
by the following reason has rejected the application. The order
of the Tribunal reads thus :
“14. The applicant has produced his reply dated
14.5.2005 (Annexure-A10). In the said representation,
his specific contention that he has been denied to defend
himself with the assistance of an advocate. As we are
already held in the earlier paras, the applicant has no
legal right to take assistance of the advocate in the
departmental Inquiry. In the said representation, the
applicant has taken an objection that Sri H.Α.
Zandannavar, Stores Superintendent has not been
examined in the enquiry, though he was cited as one of
the witnesses, only 2 witnesses i.e. Sri D. Sampath
Kumar, Accounts Superintendent and Sri M. Sharanappa,
the then Executive Engineer were examined. The said
st
objections have not been considered by the 1
respondent. Hence, the Impugned order is not a
reasoned and considered order.

15. To test above contention, it is relevant to extract the
st
reasons assigned by the 1 respondent as under;
“..........

¸ÀzÀj DgÉÆÃ¥ÀPÉÌ ¥ÀæwAiÀiÁV ²æÃ PÀlUÁ¼ïPÀgïgÀªÀgÀÄ vÀªÀÄä °TvÀ
ºÉýPÉAiÀİè FUÁUÀ¯Éà F »AzÉ PÉÊUÉÆ¼Àî¯ÁzÀ dAn E¯ÁSÁ
«ZÁgÀuÉAiÀİè F DgÉÆÃ¥ÀPÉÌ ¸ÀA§A¢ü¹zÀAvÉ «ZÁgÀuÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
3
PÉÊUÉÆ¼Àî¯ÁVzÀÄÝ, £Éà ¨sÁj «ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjAiÀĪÀgÀÄ E¯ÁSÁ «ZÁgÀuÉ
PÉÊUÉÆArzÁÝgÉAzÀÄ, DgÉÆÃ¥ÀUÀ¼À°è ¸ÀvÁåA±À«gÀĪÀÅ¢®èªÉAzÀÄ, vÁªÀÅ
13.8.96
«¨sÁUÀzÀ°è ¹éÃPÀj¹zÀ ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À ¥Àj²Ã®£ÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¢. gÀAzÀÄ
PÉÊUÉÆ¼Àî¯ÁVzÀÄÝ, F ¸ÀAzÀ¨sÀðzÀ°è J®èªÀÇ ¸ÀjAiÀiÁVvÉÛAzÀÄ ²æÃ dAqÀtÚ£ÀªÀgï
EªÀgÀ£ÀÄß ¸ÁQëAiÀiÁV £ÀªÀÄÆ¢¹zÀÝgÀÆ ¸ÀºÀ ¸ÀzÀjAiÀĪÀgÀ£ÀÄß
«ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjAiÀĪÀgÀÄ E¯ÁSÁ «ZÁgÀuÁ ¸ÀAzÀ¨sÀðzÀ°è
¥Àj²°¹gÀĪÀÅ¢®èªÉAzÀÄ, ²æÃ ¹.J£ï.ªÁ°, »A¢£À PÁAiÀÄð¥Á®PÀ
EAf¤AiÀÄgï gÀªÀgÀÄ PÀbÉÃjAiÀÄ J¯Áè ªÀåªÀºÁgÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß
C£ÀÄªÉÆÃ¢¹gÀÄvÁÛgÉAzÀÄ ²æÃ «.J¯ï. CA¢£À PÁ. EA. gÀªÀgÀÄ ¸ÁUÁtÂPÉ
UÀÄwÛUÉzÁgÀgÉÆA¢UÉ M¥ÀàAzÀ ªÀiÁrPÉÆArzÀÄÝ, PÁAiÀÄð¥Á®PÀ EAf¤AiÀÄgï
gÀªÀgÀ DzÉñÀzÀ C£ÀĸÁgÀ ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß G¥À «¨sÁUÀUÀ½UÉ
¤ÃqÀ¯ÁVzÉAiÉÄAzÀÄ, E¯ÁSÁ «ZÁgÀuÁ ¸ÀAzÀ¨sÀðzÀ°è ¥ÀjUÀt¸À¯ÁzÀ
¸ÁQëUÀ¼ÀÄ ¸ÀA§AzsÀ¥ÀlÖ CªÀ¢üAiÀİè PÉ®¸À ¤ªÀ𻹮èªÁzÀ PÁgÀt CªÀgÀÄUÀ¼ÀÄ
DgÉÆÃ¥ÀUÀ¼À §UÉÎ ZÀað¸À®Ä CºÀðjgÀĪÀÅ¢®èªÉAzÀÄ, «ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjAiÀĪÀgÀÄ

- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

¸ÀzÀj ¸ÁQëUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¥Àj²Ã°¸ÀzÉ ¤tð¬Ä¹gÀĪÀÅzÀÄ
¸ÀªÀÄ¥ÀðPÀªÁVgÀĪÀÅ¢®èªÉAzÀÄ «ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjAiÀĪÀgÀ ªÀgÀ¢AiÀÄ£ÀÄß
wgÀ¸ÀÌj¸À¨ÉÃPÉAzÀÄ w½¹zÁÝgÉ.

²æÃ JA.©.PÀlUÁ¼ïPÀgïgÀªÀgÀÄ vÀªÀÄä °TvÀ ºÉýPÉAiÀÄ eÉÆvÉ ¢.
13.8.96
gÀAzÀÄ PÉÊUÉÆ¼Àî¯ÁzÀ ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À ¨sËwPÀ vÀ¥Á¸ÀuÉAiÀÄ ¥ÀnÖAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
®UÀwÛ¹zÀÝgÀÆ ¸ÀºÀ ¸ÀA§AzsÀ¥ÀlÖ ªÀ»UÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¥Àj²Ã°¸À¯ÁV ²æÃ
39,91,116
PÀlUÁ¼ïPÀgïgÀªÀgÀÄ MmÁÖgÉ gÀÆ.UÀ¼À ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À PÉÆgÀvÉ
GAmÁVgÀĪÀÅzÀÄ PÀAqÀħA¢gÀÄvÀÛzÉ. ºÁUÁV ¸ÀzÀj GUÁæt PÉÆgÀPÉUÉ CªÀgÉÃ
dªÁ¨ÁÝgÀgÁVgÀÄvÁÛgÉ.

3 36,100
£Éà DgÉÆÃ¥ÀzÀ°è gÀÆ.UÀ¼À n CAqï ¦, ¸ÁªÀÄUÀæUÀ¼À
50
PÉÆgÀvÉUÉ ¸ÀA§A¢ü¹zÀAvÉ «ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjAiÀĪÀgÀÄ ¥Àj²Ã°¹zÀÄÝ ¹L
gÁåªÀÄgï UÀ¼À£ÀÄß ºÀħâ½î gÁ.ºÉ. G¥À «¨sÁUÀPÉÌ ¤ÃqÀ¯ÁVzÉAiÉÄAzÀÄ «¨sÁUÀ
PÀbÉÃjAiÀÄ GUÁæt ±ÁSÉAiÀÄ zÁR¯ÉAiÀÄ°è £ÀªÀÄÆ¢¸À¯ÁVzÀÝgÀÆ ¸ÀºÀ ¸ÀzÀj
¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼ÀÄ G¥À «¨sÁUÀzÀ°è ¹éÃPÀÈvÀªÁVgÀĪÀÅ¢®èªÉAzÀÄ zÁR¯ÉUÀ½AzÀ
PÀAqÀħA¢gÀĪÀÅzÁV ªÀgÀ¢ ªÀiÁrzÁÝgÉ. ºÁUÁV ºÀħâ½î gÁ.ºÉ. G¥À
45 1.10.94
«¨sÁUÀPÉÌ «vÀj¸À¯ÁVzÉ J£À߯ÁzÀ E£ïªÁAiÀiïì £ÀA. , ¢£ÁAPÀ
SÉÆnÖ JAzÀÄ ¨É¼ÀUÁA gÁ.ºÉ. «¨sÁUÀzÀ PÁAiÀÄð¥Á®PÀ EAf¤AiÀÄgÀðªÀgÀÄ
¸ÀºÀ w½¹gÀÄvÁÛgÉ. EzÀPÉÌ ¥ÀæwAiÀiÁV ²æÃ PÀmïUÁ¼ïPÀgïgÀªÀgÀÄ vÀªÀÄä °TvÀ
ºÉýPÉAiÀÄ°è «ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjAiÀĪÀgÀÄ GUÁæt C¢üÃPÀëPÀgÁzÀ ²æÃ ºÉZï. J.
dAqÀtÚ£ÀªÀgï EªÀgÀ£ÀÄß ¸ÁQëAiÀÄ£ÁßV ¥ÀjUÀt¹gÀĪÀÅ¢®èªÉAzÀÄ, ²æÃ ¹.J¸À.
ªÁ°, »A¢£À PÁ. EA. gÀªÀgÀ DzÉñÀzÀ C£ÀĸÁgÀ vÁªÀÅ ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß
¸ÁUÁtÂPÉ UÀÄwÛUÉzÁgÀjUÉ ºÉÆgÀr¹gÀĪÀÅzÁVAiÀÄÆ ºÁUÀÆ ¢£ÁAPÀ
13.8.96
gÀAzÀÄ PÉÊUÉÆAqÀ vÀ¥Á¸ÀuÉAiÀÄ°è ¸ÁªÀÄUÀæUÀ¼À ¯ÉPÀÌ ¸Àj¬ÄzÉAiÉÄAzÀÄ
w½¹gÀĪÀÅzÀjAzÀ «ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjAiÀĪÀgÀÄ ¸ÀA§AzsÀ¥ÀlÖ ¸ÁQëUÀ¼À£ÀÄß
¥Àj²Ã°¸ÀzÉà EgÀĪÀÅzÀjAzÀ «ZÁgÀuÁ ªÀgÀ¢AiÀÄ£ÀÄß wgÀ¸ÀÌj¸À¨ÉÃPÉAzÀÄ
w½¹zÁÝgÉ. D¥Á¢vÀ £ËPÀgÀgÀÄ ¥Àæ¸ÀÄÛvÀ DgÉÆÃ¥ÀPÉÌ ¸ÀA§A¢ü¹zÀAvÉ ¸ÀàµÀÖªÁzÀ
ºÉýPÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¸À°è¹gÀĪÀÅ¢®è. «¨sÁUÀ PÀbÉÃjAiÀÄ ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À vÀ¥Á¸ÀuÉ
£Àr¹zÀÝgÀÆ ¸ÀºÀ ºÀħâ½î gÁ.ºÉ. G¥À «¨sÁUÀPÉÌ ºÉÆgÀr¸À¯ÁVzÉ J£À߯ÁzÀ
45 1.10.94
E£ïªÁAiÀiïì £ÀA. , ¢£ÁAPÀ SÉÆnÖ JAzÀÄ
PÀAqÀħA¢gÀĪÀÅzÀjAzÀ ¸ÀzÀj PÉÆgÀPÉUÉ ²æÃ JA.©. PÀlUÁ¼ïPÀgïgÀªÀgÉÃ
dªÁ¨ÁÝgÀgÉAzÀÄ ¸ÀàµÀÖªÁV ¸Á©ÃvÁVgÀÄvÀÛzÉ.

4 1993-94 1995-96
DgÉÆÃ¥À gÀ°è jAzÀ gÀªÀgÉV£À CªÀ¢üAiÀİè
20,66,035
gÀÆ.UÀ¼À GUÁæt ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼ÀÄ «¨sÁUÀ PÀbÉÃjAiÀÄ ªÀ»UÀ½è
ºÉÆgÀr¹gÀĪÀAvÉ vÉÆÃj¸À¯ÁVzÀÝgÀÆ ¸ÀºÀ ¸ÀzÀj zÁR¯ÉUÉ ¥ÀÇgÀPÀªÁV G¥À
«¨sÁUÀUÀ¼À ¨ÉÃrPÉ CxÀªÁ ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß G¥À «¨sÁUÀUÀ½UÉ ¤ÃrzÀ §UÉÎ
¹éÃPÀÈw ¥ÀqÉ¢gÀĪÀÅ¢®èªÁzÀ PÁgÀt ¸ÀzÀj PÉÆgÀvÉUÉ ²æÃ JA.©.
PÀmïUÁ¼ïPÀgïgÀªÀgÉà dªÁ¨ÁÝgÀgÉAzÀÄ DgÉÆÃ¦¸À¯ÁVzÀÄÝ ¸ÀzÀj DgÉÆÃ¥ÀPÉÌ
¸ÀA§A¢ü¹zÀAvÉ «ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjAiÀĪÀgÀÄ ¸ÀªÀÄUÀæªÁV ¥Àj²Ã°¹gÀÄvÁÛgÉ. ¨ÉÃgÉ
¨ÉÃgÉ G¥À«¨sÁUÀzÀ ¹§âA¢UÀ¼ÀÄ PÉ®ªÉÇAzÀÄ ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß (lÆå¨ï, lAiÀÄgï
1,86,530
EvÁå¢) ¹éÃPÀj¹gÀĪÀÅzÀÄ PÀAqÀÄ §A¢zÀÄÝ, EªÀÅUÀ¼À ªÉÆvÀÛ
gÀÆ.UÀ¼ÁVgÀÄvÀÛªÉAiÉÄAzÀÄ, G½zÀ ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ªÁºÀ£ÀUÀ½UÉ C¼ÀªÀr¹zÀÝgÀ
§UÉÎ ¸ÀA§AzsÀ¥ÀlÖ §ÄPÀμÀ°è zÀÈrüÃPÀÈvÀªÁVgÀĪÀÅ¢®èªÉAzÀÄ, G¥À«¨sÁUÀUÀ½AzÀ

- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

¨ÉÃrPÉ E®è¢zÀÝgÀÆ ¸ÀºÀ ©r ¨sÁUÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß Rjâ¹ «ºÀj¹gÀĪÀAvÉ
vÉÆÃj¸À¯ÁVzÀÄÝ, F PÀÄjvÀÄ ¹éÃPÀÈwAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¸ÀºÀ ¥ÀqÉAiÀÄzÉ «¨sÁUÀ PÀbÉÃjAiÀÄ
18,29,406
ªÀ»UÀ¼À°è ¸ÁªÀÄVæUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ºÉÆgÀr¸ÀĪÀAvÉ vÉÆÃj¹zÀÄÝ MmÁÖgÉ
gÀÆ.UÀ¼À PÉÆgÀvÉ PÀAqÀħA¢zÀÄÝ EzÀPÉÌ ²æÃ JA.©. PÀmïUÁ¼ïPÀgïgÀªÀgÉÃ
dªÁ¨ÁÝgÀgÉAzÀÄ PÀAqÀÄ §gÀÄvÀÛzÉ. EzÀPÉÌ ¥ÀæwAiÀiÁV ²æÃ JA.©. PÀmïUÁ¼ïPÀgï
3 4
gÀªÀgÀÄ ¸À°è¹gÀĪÀ °TvÀ ºÉýPÉAiÀÄ°è ªÀÄvÀÄÛ £Éà DgÉÆÃ¥ÀPÉÌ MAzÉÃ
«ªÀgÀuÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¤Ãr «ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjAiÀĪÀgÀ ªÀgÀ¢AiÀÄ£ÀÄß wgÀ¸ÀÌj¹ vÀªÀÄä£ÀÄß
zÉÆÃµÀªÀÄÄPÀÛgÀ£ÁßV¸ÀĪÀAvÉ PÉÆÃjgÀÄvÁÛgÉ. vÁªÀÅ PÉJnAiÀİè Cfð ¸ÀA.
8794/2002
¸À°è¹zÀÄÝ ¸ÀzÀj CfðAiÀÄÄ E£ÀÆß ªÀiÁ£Àå PÉJnAiÀÄ°è ¨ÁQ
EgÀĪÀÅzÀjAzÀ vÀªÀÄä «gÀÄzÀÞ AiÀiÁªÀÅzÉà E¯ÁSÁ «ZÁgÀuÉ
PÉÊUÉÆ¼Àî¨ÁgÀzÉAzÀÄ ºÁUÀÆ «ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjUÀ¼À ªÀgÀ¢AiÀÄÄ ¸ÁQëUÀ¼À
ºÉýPÉAiÉÆA¢UÉ ¸ÀªÀÄyð¸À®ànÖ®èªÁzÀ PÁgÀt «ZÁgÀuÁ ªÀgÀ¢AiÀÄ£ÀÄß
wgÀ¸ÀÌj¸À®Ä PÉÆÃjzÁÝgÉ.

E¯ÁSÁ «ZÁgÀuÉ ¸ÀAzÀ¨sÀðzÀ°è C¥Á¢vÀ £ËPÀgÀgÀÄ UÉÊgÀÄ
ºÁdgÁVzÀÄÝ, «ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjUÀ¼À ªÀÄÄAzÉ ºÁdgÁV vÀªÀÄä ªÁzÀ ªÀÄAr¸ÀĪÀ
AiÀiÁªÀÅzÉà ¥ÀæAiÀÄvÀß ªÀiÁrgÀĪÀÅ¢®è. ºÁUÁV D¥Á¢vÀgÀ ¥ÀgÀªÁV AiÀiÁªÀÅzÉÃ
¸ÁQëUÀ¼À£ÁßUÀ°Ã zÁR¯ÉUÀ¼À£ÁßUÀ°Ã «ZÁgÀuÁ¢üPÁjAiÀĪÀgÀÄ
¥Àj²Ã°¹gÀĪÀÅ¢®è. «ZÁgÀuÁ ªÀgÀ¢UÉ ¥ÀæwAiÀiÁV ¸À°è¹gÀĪÀ °TvÀ
ºÉýPÉAiÀİèAiÀÄÆ ¸ÀºÀ AiÀiÁªÀÅzÉà ¥ÀgÀUÀt£ÁºÀðªÁzÀ CA±ÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß
ªÀÄAr¹gÀĪÀÅ¢®è. DzÀÝjAzÀ ²æÃ JA.©. PÀlUÁ¼ïPÀgï EªÀgÀ «gÀÄzÀÞ
2, 3 4
¸Á©ÃvÁVgÀĪÀ DgÉÆÃ¥À ªÀÄvÀÄÛ PÉÌ ¸ÀA§A¢ü¹zÀAvÉ ¸ÀPÁðgÀPÉÌ
39,91,116 36,100
GAmÁVgÀĪÀ DyðPÀ £ÀµÀÖ PÀæªÀĪÁV gÀÆ.UÀ¼ÀÄ.
18,79,496 59,06,712
gÀÆ.UÀ¼ÀÄ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ gÀÆ.UÀ¼ÀÄ. MmÁÖgÉ gÀÆ.UÀ¼À£ÀÄß ²æÃ
PÀlUÁ¼ïPÀgï EªÀjAzÀ ªÀ¸ÀÆ®Ä ªÀiÁqÀ®Ä ºÁUÀÆ ¸Á©ÃvÁzÀ DgÉÆÃ¥ÀzÀ
UÀA©üÃgÀvÉUÀ£ÀÄUÀÄtªÁV zÀAqÀ£É «¢ü¸À®Ä wêÀiÁð¤¸À¯ÁVzÉ. DzÀÝjAzÀ F
PɼÀPÀAqÀ DzsÉñÀ.
........”
The applicant approached this Tribunal in
A.No.8296/2002 questioning the Impugned order dated
03.5.2002. In the said case, the charge memo was same
as that of charge No.1 in the present application.
Considering the earlier charge memo and the order
st
dated 03.5.2002, the 1 respondent has issued GO
dated 24.9.2002 to conduct Inquiry only on the charge
Nos.2, 3 and 4. After careful consideration of the above
st
mentioned reasoning, while Imposing penalty, the 1
respondent has considered gravity of misconduct. The
Impugned order is a reasoned and considered order.
This Tribunal cannot interfere with the penalty imposed
by the competent authority.

16. For the foregoing reasons, we are of the considered
view, the applicant failed to establish to quash the

- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:17122-DB
WP No. 105037 of 2021


CNR: KAHC020240652021

impugned order. The application is devoid of merits, the
same is liable to be rejected.”

In that light, the petition deserves to succeed.


18. The Writ Petition is allowed. The order dated
16.12.2017 passed by the Karnataka State Administrative
Tribunal, Bengaluru, in application No.2593/2006 stands
quashed. The application stands allowed. The penalty imposed
upon the petitioner, the Government Servant, stands
obliterated. In the light of him being no more today, the legal
representatives, the petitioners would be entitled to all
consequential service benefits that would enure to their benefit
on the death of an employee as if the employee had died while
in service.

Sd/-
(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE


Sd/-
(HEMA KULKARNI)
JUDGE



kmv
CT: ASC