THE BRANCH MANAGER, vs R.MALLIKA,
- Court
- Madras High Court
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
DATED: 17.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE P. MURUGAN
C.M.A.(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
CNR:{HCMD011101952018}
and
C.M.P.(MD) No. 10309 of 2022
The Branch Manager,
M/s National Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Branch Office No.63, Rasi Plaza,
West Pradhakshinam Road,
Karur. .. Appellant
Vs.
1. R.Mallika,
W/o (late) Ramalingam,
No.33, Indira Nagar,
South Gandhigramam,
Pasupathipalayam Post,
Karur.
2. R. Divya Bharathi,
D/o (late) Ramalingam,
No.33, Indira Nagar,
South Gandhigramam,
Pasupathipalayam Post,
Karur.
3. Minor R. Bharath,
S/o (late) Ramalingam,
No.33, Indira Nagar,
South Gandhigramam, Pasupathipalayam
Post, Karur.
(Rep. by his mother R. Mallika - R1)
__________
Page 1 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
4. M. Rajammal,
W/o (late) Manikkam,
No.33, Indira Nagar,
South Gandhigramam,
Pasupathipalayam Post,
Karur.
5. K. Muniyappan,
S/o Kuppanna Pillai,
No.24, Keerakara Street,
Karur. ..Respondents
PRAYER: Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed under section 30 of
Employee’s Compensation Act, to set aside the award dated
13.06.2018 made in W.C.No.79 of 2013 on the file of the
Commissioner of Workmen Compensation (Tribunal), Dindigul,
served on 25.06.2018 and allow this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal.
For Appellant : Mr. I. Robert Chandra Kumar
For Respondents : Mr. N.Sudhagar Nagaraj
J U D G M E N T
The Insurance Company, who is the second respondent in
W.C.No.79 of 2013 on the file of the Commissioner of Workmen
Compensation, Dindigul, is the appellant before this Court,
challenging the compensation order dated 13.06.2018 passed in
W.C.No.79 of 2013, where claim petition filed by the legal
__________
Page 2 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
representatives of the deceased Ramalingam was partly allowed.
2. The litigative status of the parties is referred to as it
stood before the Tribunal that the appellant is the second
respondent / Insurance Company, the respondents 1 to 4 are the
petitioners, who are the claimants and the fifth respondent is the first
respondent, who is the owner of the vehicle.
3. The brief case of the claimants before the Tribunal is as that
the first petitioner is the wife; the petitioners 2 and 3 are children;
and the fourth petitioner is the mother of one Ramalingam. The said
Ramalingam worked under the first respondent as driver for the past
one year. The first respondent is the owner of the lorry bearing
Registration No.TN-45-AF-5887. The first respondent insured the
said lorry with the second respondent. Ramalingam earned
Rs.20,000/- per month as wages and Rs.20,000/- per year as bonus
from the first respondent. During the course of employment, the said
Ramalingam drove the said lorry for loading and stationed the
vehicle on 16.05.2013 night at CMDA Steel Yard, Sathankadu
inside at Tiruvottiyur, Chennai. When the said Ramalingam was in
the course of employment in the said lorry, on that day of
16.05.2013 unexpectedly fallen down from the lorry and sustained
__________
Page 3 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
grievous injuries in his head and over all body. As a result, the said
Ramalingam died on the spot. Having the petitioners are legal heirs
of the deceased Ramalingam, who was working under the first
respondent, they are entitled to get workmen compensation of
Rs.12,00,000/- (Rupees Twelve Lakhs only). Hence, they
approached the Tribunal for such award.
4. Brief counter of the first respondent, who is the owner of
the subject vehicle referred above, is as that the deceased
Ramalingam worked under the first respondent as a lorry driver to
the lorry bearing Registration No.TN-45-AF-5887 for the past one
year and he was earning Rs.20,000/- per month as wages and
Rs.20,000/- per year as bonus. On the fateful day of 16.05.2013, he
was entrusted the said lorry for loading from CMDA Steel Yard,
Sathankadu inside, Tiruvottiyur, Chennai. In the course of
employment, the said Ramalingam unexpectedly fallen down from
the lorry and sustained multiple injuries and then died. The other
facts in the claim statements are denied. The first respondent availed
insurance from the second respondent under the Workmen’s
Compensation Act. If any award is passed, the second respondent is
liable to pay the compensation, as the insurance policy was valid and
__________
Page 4 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
in force on 16.05.2013.
5. Brief counter of the second respondent is as that all the
allegations in the claim statement is denied. There is no employer
and employee relationship between Ramalingam and the first
respondent. The death was not occurred during the course of
employment. The monthly wages and other aspects are denied. As
per F.I.R, the deceased Ramalingam was under the influence of
alcohol heavily, before falling down. Therefore, the second
respondent is not liable to pay any amount.
6. During the enquiry, to establish the case facts, the first
petitioner / Mallika herself examined as P.W.1 and 7 documents
were marked as Exh.P1 to Exh.P7, which are . . post
கு ஐ சுன்
mortem viscera R.C. insurance
சநிழசவ் சநிழசவ் ழௌ ம்
policy of the first respondent vehicle insured with the second
respondent; driving licence of the deceased Ramalingam and legal
heir certificate of Ramalingam. On the side of the employer / first
respondent one Arumugam was examined as R.W.1 and no
document was marked. On the side of the insurance company /
second respondent, the senior assistant, Mr.Gowthaman was
examined as R.W.2 and 2 documents were marked as Exh.R1 and
__________
Page 5 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
Exh.R2, which are post mortem report of the deceased Ramalingam
and the insurance policy respectively.
7. After hearing both parties, the Tribunal had come to a
conclusion that the deceased Ramalingam was working under the
first respondent, his death was during the course of employment,
there was employer and employee relationship and finding that the
first respondent availed insurance from the second respondent,
determined the deceased age was 44 years and applying proper age
factor awarded Rs.6,64,116/- (Rupees Six Lakhs Sixty Thousand
One Hundred and Sixteen only) as total compensation eligible to be
received by the claimants. Having the first respondent availed the
insurance with the second respondent for Workmen’s Compensation
Act, the second respondent was directed to pay the said amount
together with interest at 12% per anuum from the date of accident
fill the date of realisation. Against the said order, the insurance
company filed this appeal.
8. This appeal was admitted on 09.11.2022 with the
following substantial question of law:
(i) Whether the Commissioner of
Workmen Compensation has erred in rendering a
__________
Page 6 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
finding that the claimants are entitled to get
compensation from the appellant under the
Workmen Compensation Act, despite showing
that the deceased workman was found in drunken
condition during working hours and that the said
accident cannot be said to have arisen or during
the course of employment?
9. Heard both sides. Perused the records. Considered the
submissions raised by both sides.
10 (a). The learned counsel for the insurance company
contended that though the first respondent availed workman
insurance policy with the second respondent as per Exh.R2
equivalent to Exh.P5 for the period from 11.08.2012 to 10.08.2013,
wherein the accident was occurred on 16.05.2013, in which, the
insurance was in force. But as per F.I.R - Exh.P1, the deceased
Ramalingam was in a drunken condition. As per the F.I.R given by
one Mr. Pommuraj, who is the cousin brother of the deceased
Ramalingam, reveals that on the fateful day of 16.05.2013, the
deceased Ramalingam consumed alcohol and t he deceased
accidentally slipped from the lorry cabin and fallen down.
__________
Page 7 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
10 (b). H aving influenced with the alcohol as per section 3(1)
(b)(i) of the Employee’s Compensation Act, 1923 (herein after
referred as ‘1923 Act’), w hen the employee is under the influence
of alcohol or drugs at the time of the accident, the employer shall not
be liable to pay compensation. Section 3 of 1923 Act, provides the
rights of the employee to claim compensation, against the owner,
who is insured with the insurance company. Proviso to the sub-
section (1) in clause (b) (i), says when the employee having been at
the time thereof under the influence of drink or drugs, the employer
is not liable, thereby , fastening such liability on the employer and
directing the insurance company making to pay compensation is not
right. Therefore, the appeal has been filed.
11. Though the deceased’s cousin brother Mr.Pommuraj has
given first information to the police, wherein, the deceased was
consumed alcohol during night of 16.05.2013 and when the
informant wake up at 02.00 am and when he was intended to see the
said Ramalingam, went near to the lorry, found the deceased lying
on the earth. On his enquiry, the deceased at the time of alive told
him when he intend to climb the ladder to reach the lorry cabin, he
__________
Page 8 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
accidentally fallen down and sustained injury. When he tried to lift
the injured into the hospital, the ambulance technician told him that
the person died. Then the body was shifted to the hospital.
12. As per the post mortem report in Exh.P2, there is no
mention about alcohol found. It says the stomach contain 30 ml of
straw coloured fluid with no specific odour. As per Exh.P2, post
mortem certificate issued by the Government Stanley Medical
College, Chennai, did not say about any alcohol found in the
deceased Ramalingam’s stomach. The post mortem was conducted
on 16.05.2013 at about 01.15 pm, that is within 11 hours from the
death of the deceased. As per the viscera report in Exh.P3, no
poison was found, but, there is no mention about any alcohol found
from the tissue taken from the deceased. When the medical opinion,
Exh.P2- post mortem report and Exh.P3-viscera report, did not say
about the deceased found alcohol and, therefore the contention of the
insurance company that the deceased consumed alcohol is without
any basis.
13. The informant Mr.Pommuraj, who is the cousin brother
of the deceased Ramalingam, has given F.I.R stating that when he
saw the deceased at night on 16.05.2013, who was found in a
__________
Page 9 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
drunken condition and thereafter he had seen the deceased at 02.00
am. Even though the cousin brother of the deceased had given
complaint that the deceased consumed alcohol what was the
steadiness of the deceased and the percentage of the alcohol mixed
in the blood, there is no evidence. Even the insurance company
failed to examined the said Pommuraj to establish the surrounding
circumstances. Though the F.I.R stated that the deceased consumed
alcohol before his death, but as per Exh.P2- post mortem and Exh.P3-
viscera report, there is no whisper about the deceased consumed
alcohol. If the deceased consumed alcohol higher than the quantity
prescribed, certainly the alcohol consumed could have been mixed in
the blood. Having there is no medical evidence that the deceased
consumed alcohol, it cannot be a ground that the deceased fallen
down and died out of the alcohol condition.
12. The other aspect that the deceased was the employee
under the first respondent, which is also proved, is not disputed by
the insurance company. The other aspects, monthly wages and age
factor determined by the Tribunal are not disputed. Having the first
respondent availed workmen insurance as per the policy in Exh.P5,
it was availed for goods carrying, the deceased was a driver under
__________
Page 10 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
the employment date of 16.05.2013, where he possessed valid
licence are not in dispute. Thereby, the legal heirs are entitled to
claim compensation under the 1923 Act. Therefore, looking into all
the aspects, the Tribunal award is found correct and there is no
requirement to interfere into the same.
13. In such view of the matter, the substantial question of
law is answered against the insurance company. Thereby, the appeal
is devoid of merits and accordingly, it is dismissed. There is no
order as to costs.
14. In the result:
(i) This Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is dismissed;
(ii) The award passed by the Tribunal, made in W.C.No.79 of
2013 dated 13.06.2018 is confirmed; and
(iii) There shall be no order as to costs. Consequently,
connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
17.11.2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
LS
__________
Page 11 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
To
The Deputy Commissioner of Labour,
Dindigul,
Copy To :
The Section Officer,
VR Section,
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court,
Madurai.
__________
Page 12 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
DR. P. MURUGAN, J.
LS
CMA(MD) No. 1040 of 2022
17.11.2026
__________
Page 13 of 13
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 12:31:33 pm )