ABDUL KHAIYUM vs INSPECTOR OF POLICE

Court
Madras High Court

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Date of Reserving the Judgment Date of Pronouncing the Judgment
23.09.2026 13.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE M. NIRMAL KUMAR
CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
CNR: {HCMA012263852023}
Abdul Khaiyum
S/o.Hillal Azizuddin,
Flat No.4B, Coramandel Towers,
816, EVR Periyar Salai, Kilpauk,
Chennai 600 010.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
The State Rep. by
The Inspector of Police
D6, Anna Square Police Station,
Traffic Investigation Wing,
Chennai.
(Crime No.117/2021)
..Respondent(s)
Prayer:- Criminal Appeal filed under Section 374 of Cr.P.C., to call for the
records and set aside the conviction judgment passed by the learned Sessions
Judge, Mahalir Neethimandram, Allikulam, Chennai, in SC.No.85/2022 dated
13.12.2023 and set the appellant at liberty.
For Appellant(s): Mr.Abudu Kumar Rajaratnam
Senior Counsel
for Mr.V.Johnson Yuvaraj
For Respondent(s): Ms.Sharada Vivek
Additional Public Prosecutor
__________
Page 1 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
JUDGMENT
This Criminal Appeal is directed against the judgment dated 13.12.2023
passed in S.C.No.85 of 2022 by the learned Sessions Judge, Mahalir
Neethimandram, Allikulam, Chennai.
2. Case of the prosecution:-
2.1 . The case of the prosecution is that on 21.05.2021, at about 2.15 p.m.,
the appellant/accused, Abdul Khaiyum, drove a Hyundai Creta car bearing
Registration No.TN-01-AZ-9339 from west to east towards Parrys Corner, near
Kilpauk Medical College Hospital, at the junction of EVR Periyar Highway and
Barnaby Road, opposite Punjab National Bank, Chennai.
2.2 . According to the prosecution, the appellant was driving the vehicle in
an inebriated condition and in a rash and negligent manner, endangering the
safety of other road users. At the relevant time, Selvi Yamuna, an ECG
Technician working at Kilpauk Medical College Hospital, was riding a Honda
Activa bearing Registration No. TN-04-AY-2407.
2.3 . At that time, the appellant, without observing the traffic regulations
and under the influence of alcohol, dashed against the two-wheeler, causing
severe head injuries to the rider. Immediately after the accident, PW-1 and
__________
Page 2 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
PW-2 took the injured victim to Kilpauk Medical College Hospital for
treatment. Subsequently, she was shifted to Government Rajiv Gandhi General
Hospital, Chennai, where, despite treatment, she succumbed to her injuries at
about 5.45 p.m. on the same day.
2.4 . The further case of the prosecution is that the appellant did not stop
his vehicle immediately after the accident and proceeded further. Subsequently,
the vehicle was found stranded near Gengu Reddy Road Subway with extensive
damage to its front portion and a punctured tyre. The appellant was
apprehended by PW-4, Special Sub-Inspector of Police, with the assistance of
members of the public.
2.5 . On receipt of the information regarding the occurrence, PW-13
registered a case in Crime No.117 of 2021. Initially, the case was registered
under Sections 308 and 188 IPC and Section 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
Thereafter, PW-15 took up the investigation, visited the scene of occurrence,
prepared the observation mahazar and rough sketch, examined the witnesses
and doctors who treated the deceased, conducted the inquest and arranged for
postmortem examination. The vehicles involved in the accident were also sent
for inspection by the Motor Vehicle Inspector.
__________
Page 3 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
2.6 . The appellant was under the influence of alcohol. Accordingly, he
was subjected to a breath analyser test through PW-7, and the report was
marked as Ex.P-6. Thereafter, he was produced before PW-10, the Casualty
Medical Officer attached to Government Rajiv Gandhi General Hospital, who
collected his blood and urine samples for chemical examination.
2.7 . The scientific examination was conducted by the Forensic
Department through PW-14. However, the Toxicology Report (Ex.P-11) did not
detect the presence of ethyl alcohol in the blood sample. The prosecution sought
to explain the negative result on the ground that the samples were examined
after a delay of several days owing to the closure of the forensic laboratory
during the COVID-19 pandemic.
2.8 . After completion of the investigation, the respondent police filed the
final report. The case was committed to the Sessions Court and taken up in S.C.
No.85 of 2022.
2.9 . Before the Trial Court, the prosecution examined P.Ws.1 to 16,
marked Exs.P-1 to P-23 and produced M.O.1, the car involved in the accident.
No witness was examined and no document was marked on behalf of the
defence.
__________
Page 4 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
2.10 . Upon conclusion of the trial, the learned Sessions Judge, Mahalir
Neethimandram, Allikulam, Chennai, by judgment dated 13.12.2023, convicted
the appellant under Section 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act and Section 304
Part-II IPC, while acquitting him of the charge under Section 188 IPC.
2.11 . The appellant was sentenced to undergo six months' rigorous
imprisonment and pay a fine of Rs.10,000/- under Section 185 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, in default, to undergo one month simple imprisonment, and five
years' rigorous imprisonment and pay a fine of Rs.10,000/- under Section 304
Part-II IPC, in default to undergo three months simple imprisonment. Both
sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
2.12 . Aggrieved by the said conviction and sentence, the appellant has
preferred the present criminal appeal.
3 . Submissions of the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
appellant:-
3.1 . The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant would submit
that the judgment of conviction and sentence passed by the trial Court is
contrary to law, evidence and the probabilities of the case. The trial Court failed
to properly appreciate the oral and documentary evidence and proceeded to
__________
Page 5 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
convict the appellant without establishing the essential ingredients of the
offences beyond reasonable doubt.
3.2 . The learned Senior Counsel would advance the following
submissions:
3.2.1 . Regarding the manner of occurrence and the conduct of the
deceased :-
(i) The learned Senior Counsel would submit that the appellant was
driving his car in the proper direction, from west to east towards Parrys Corner,
and there was no material to establish that he had driven the vehicle in the
wrong direction.
(ii) On the contrary, the deceased, who was riding the two-wheeler from
the side of Kilpauk Medical College Hospital, attempted to cut across the EVR
Periyar Highway and enter Barnaby Road at a place where there was no
authorised passage.
(iii) Referring to the rough sketch and observation mahazar, the learned
Senior Counsel would submit that a vehicle coming out of KMC Hospital was
required to proceed towards Ega Theatre, take a U-turn and thereafter proceed
towards Central or Parrys Corner. The deceased had not followed the prescribed
route and had suddenly crossed the road. Therefore, the possibility of the
deceased having contributed to the accident cannot be ruled out.
__________
Page 6 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
3.2.2 . Regarding the doubtful presence of PW-1 and PW-2:
(i) The learned Senior Counsel would submit that the presence of PW-1
and PW-2, who are stated to be colleagues of the deceased, is highly doubtful.
(ii) PW-1 has not stated that PW-2 was accompanying him at the time of
the occurrence. On the contrary, PW-1 has stated that he was standing with one
Ramky, who has not been examined by the prosecution.
(iii) PW-2, however, claims that he was present along with PW-1.
(iv) This contradiction creates serious doubt regarding the actual presence
of these witnesses at the scene of occurrence. Further, both witnesses claim that
the traffic signal was red and that the appellant violated the signal, resulting in
the accident.
3.2.3. Regarding the non-functioning of traffic signals:-
(i) The learned Senior Counsel would further submit that PW-4, Special
Sub-Inspector of Police attached to the Traffic Enforcement Wing, has
categorically stated that during the COVID-19 pandemic, the traffic signals
were switched off and only amber lights were blinking. The said fact is also
reflected in the observation mahazar and rough sketch prepared during
investigation and is confirmed by PW-13 and PW-15.
(ii) When the contemporaneous police records themselves establish that
the traffic signals were not functioning in the normal manner, the evidence of
__________
Page 7 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
PW-1 and PW-2 that they were waiting for a red signal and that the appellant
violated the same becomes doubtful.
3.2.4. Regarding the breath analyser test :-
(i) The learned Senior Counsel would submit that the only substantial
circumstance relied upon by the prosecution to establish drunken driving is the
breath analyser report marked as Ex.P-6. However, the original printout of
Ex.P-6 is in a smudged condition and the particulars contained therein are not
decipherable. A photostat copy was marked as Ex.P-7, but no satisfactory
evidence was produced to establish that Ex.P-7 was a true and accurate copy of
the original report. Further, the prosecution has not produced any material to
establish that the breath analyser was properly calibrated and periodically
verified.
(ii) The learned Senior Counsel would also refer to the directions issued
by the Additional Commissioner of Police (Traffic), according to which, the
breath analyser was required to be tested on a normal person's breath before
conducting the test on a suspected drunken driver and the equipment was
required to be calibrated every six months.
(iii) In the present case, no evidence was produced to establish
compliance with the said procedure or to demonstrate when the equipment was
last calibrated. Therefore, the breath analyser report cannot be treated as reliable
scientific evidence to establish the alleged intoxication.
__________
Page 8 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
3.2.5. Regarding the negative blood and urine examination:-
(i) The learned Senior Counsel would submit that the appellant was
subsequently produced before PW-10, the Casualty Medical Officer, who
collected the blood and urine samples for chemical examination. The samples
were forwarded to the Forensic Department and examined by PW-14, Scientific
Officer.
(ii) The Toxicology Report (Ex.P-11) specifically records that ethyl
alcohol was not detected in the blood sample.
(iii) The evidence of PW-10 and PW-14 confirms the collection and
examination of the samples. Therefore, the scientific evidence directly
contradicts the prosecution's allegation that the appellant was driving the vehicle
under the influence of alcohol.
(iv) The learned Senior Counsel would submit that the prosecution cannot
rely upon an unclear breath analyser printout while disregarding the scientific
report obtained from the blood sample.
3.2.6 . In support of his contention, reliance was placed upon the judgment
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Bhagubhai Hassanalli Karyani v. State of
Maharashtra , reported in (1971) 3 SCC 930 , wherein the circumstances relied
upon to establish drunkenness and the evidentiary significance of scientific
testing were considered.
__________
Page 9 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
3.2.7 . Regarding the absence of rashness and criminal knowledge:-
(i) The learned Senior Counsel would submit that the prosecution has
failed to establish that the appellant drove the vehicle in a rash or negligent
manner.
(ii) The mere occurrence of an accident resulting in death cannot
automatically establish criminal liability. Further, the prosecution has not
established that the appellant had the knowledge that his act was likely to cause
death, which is an essential ingredient to attract Section 304 Part-II IPC.
(iii) The learned Senior Counsel would therefore submit that the trial
Court failed to consider the material contradictions and scientific evidence and
that the appellant is entitled to acquittal.
4 . Contra submissions of the learned Additional Public Prosecutor
for the State:-
4.1 . Per contra, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor appearing for the
State would submit that the trial Court has properly appreciated the evidence
available on record and arrived at a correct conclusion.
4.2 . The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would submit that Selvi
Yamuna was working as an ECG Technician at Kilpauk Medical College
__________
Page 10 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
Hospital during the COVID-19 pandemic period. After completing her duty, she
was proceeding towards her residence on her two-wheeler.
4.3 . At that time, the appellant, who was driving the Hyundai Creta car
under the influence of alcohol, drove the vehicle in a rash and negligent manner
and dashed against the two-wheeler, causing fatal head injuries to the deceased.
4.4 . Immediately after the occurrence, PW-1 and PW-2 took the injured
victim to KMC Hospital. Since her condition was serious, she was shifted to
Government Rajiv Gandhi General Hospital, where she succumbed to her
injuries.
4.5 . The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would further submit that
after the occurrence, the appellant continued driving the car and was
subsequently found stranded near Gengu Reddy Road Subway with a punctured
tyre and extensive damage to the front portion of the vehicle.
4.6 . The police apprehended the appellant and noticed that he was in an
inebriated condition. His eyes were congested and there was a smell of alcohol
emanating from him.
4.7 . A breath analyser test was conducted, which revealed that the
appellant had consumed alcohol beyond the permissible statutory limit.
__________
Page 11 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
Thereafter, he was produced before the doctor, who collected his blood and
urine samples.
4.8 . The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would contend that the
negative result in the forensic examination cannot be treated as conclusive proof
of the appellant's innocence, since the samples were examined only after a delay
of several days owing to the COVID-19-related closure of the laboratory. In the
meantime, the alcohol content in the sample could have evaporated.
4.9 . It is further submitted that the evidence of the medical witnesses and
scientific officers, together with the oral evidence of the police witnesses,
establishes that the appellant was driving the vehicle under the influence of
alcohol.
4.10 . The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would also submit that the
Motor Vehicle Inspector's report establishes that the tyre burst could have
occurred due to the high speed at which the vehicle was driven. This
circumstance supports the prosecution's allegation of rash and negligent driving.
4.11 . Regarding the traffic signals, it is submitted that the trial Court has
already considered the relevant evidence and rightly rejected the defence
contention.
__________
Page 12 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
4.12 . The learned Additional Public Prosecutor would therefore submit
that the trial Court has passed a well-reasoned judgment after appreciating the
entire evidence and that no interference is warranted. Hence, the appeal is liable
to be dismissed.
5. Court's findings and reasons:-
5.1 . This Court has carefully considered the submissions made by the
learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant and the learned Additional
Public Prosecutor appearing for the State and perused the entire materials
available on record.
5.2 . The following questions arise for consideration:-
(i) Whether the prosecution has established that the appellant was driving
the vehicle under the influence of alcohol, thereby committing an offence under
Section 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act?
(ii) Whether the prosecution has established that the appellant drove the
vehicle in a rash and dangerous manner and caused the death of Selvi Yamuna?
(iii) Whether the prosecution has established the necessary knowledge on
the part of the appellant to attract Section 304 Part-II IPC?
(iv) Whether the conviction and sentence imposed by the trial Court
warrant interference?
__________
Page 13 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
5.3 . Regarding the presence of PW-1 and PW-2 and the functioning of
traffic signals:-
(i) It is not in dispute that the occurrence took place on 21.05.2021,
during the COVID-19 pandemic period, when restrictions were imposed on the
movement of vehicles and persons.
(ii) During the said period, the traffic signals at several places were
switched off and only amber warning lights were functioning.
(iii) In the present case, PW-4, Special Sub-Inspector of Police attached
to the Kilpauk Traffic Enforcement Police, has categorically stated that the
traffic signals were switched off during the COVID-19 pandemic and only
amber lights were blinking.
(iv) The said fact is also reflected in the observation mahazar and rough
sketch prepared during the investigation and is supported by the evidence of
PW-13 and PW-15. However, PW-1 and PW-2 have specifically stated that the
traffic signal was red and that the appellant crossed the junction by violating the
red signal. This creates a material contradiction in the prosecution case.
(v) Further, PW-1 has not spoken about the presence of PW-2 along with
him at the time of the occurrence. PW-1 has referred to one Ramky, who has
__________
Page 14 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
not been examined by the prosecution. On the other hand, PW-2 claims that he
was accompanying PW-1.
(vi) The contradiction assumes significance because both PW-1 and
PW-2 are projected as eyewitnesses who allegedly witnessed the actual
collision.
(vii) PW-3 has admitted that he heard the noise and only thereafter looked
towards the scene of occurrence. He has not witnessed the actual accident.
(viii) The remaining witnesses are either formal witnesses or persons who
came to know about the occurrence subsequently.
(ix) In the above circumstances, the presence of PW-1 and PW-2 at the
scene of occurrence becomes doubtful. Their evidence, particularly, regarding
the violation of a red traffic signal, cannot be accepted without independent
corroboration.
(x) It is to be noted that both PW-1 and PW-2 were colleagues of the
deceased, and neither of them was a chance or independent witness. Obviously,
they deposed in favour of their colleague.
__________
Page 15 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
5.4. Regarding the alleged drunken condition of the appellant:-
(i) The next important circumstance relied upon by the prosecution is the
allegation that the appellant was driving the vehicle under the influence of
alcohol.
(ii) The prosecution relies upon the breath analyser report marked as
Ex.P-6 and the photostat copy marked as Ex.P-7.
(iii) On perusal of Ex.P-6, it is seen that the original printout is in a
smudged condition and the particulars are not clearly decipherable. Ex.P-7 is
only a photostat copy, and there is no satisfactory evidence to establish that the
same accurately represents the original report.
(iii) Further, the prosecution has not produced any document or other
satisfactory evidence to establish when the breath analyser equipment was last
calibrated.
(iv) The learned Senior Counsel has also drawn the attention of this Court
to the instructions issued by the Additional Commissioner of Police (Traffic),
requiring periodic calibration of the equipment and preliminary testing before
conducting the breath analysis of a suspected drunken driver. However, no
evidence has been adduced by the prosecution to establish that the procedure
was followed in the present case.
__________
Page 16 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
(v) The absence of such evidence assumes significance when the very
original report is not decipherable and the secondary copy is disputed. More
particularly, the appellant was subsequently produced before PW-10, who
collected his blood and urine samples for chemical examination. The samples
were sent to the Forensic Department and examined by PW-14.
(vi) The Toxicology Report (Ex.P-11) does not disclose the presence of
ethyl alcohol.
(vii) The evidence of PW-10 and PW-14 supports the fact that the blood
and urine samples collected and subjected to scientific examination and the
report proved negative. The prosecution has attempted to explain the negative
result by stating that the examination was delayed owing to the COVID-19
pandemic and that the alcohol content might have evaporated scientifically
false. However, the Court cannot accept such an explanation merely on the basis
of an assumption. The prosecution has not placed sufficient scientific material
on record to establish that the negative result was attributable to evaporation of
alcohol in the particular sample.
(viii) The evidence regarding the smell of alcohol, congested eyes and the
alleged unsteady condition of the appellant cannot, in the circumstances of this
case, independently establish the prohibitory alcohol concentration.
__________
Page 17 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
(ix) In this regard, the judgment relied upon by the learned Senior
Counsel in Bhagubhai Hassanalli Karyani v. State of Maharashtra , reported
in (1971) 3 SCC 930 , wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that the
smell of alcohol emanating from a person does not necessarily establish that
such person was under the influence of alcohol. Further, physical conditions
such as unsteady gait, incoherent speech and other apparent symptoms may also
arise due to nervous strain and the circumstances following an accident. In the
absence of a urine test, chemical analysis report or other reliable medical
evidence, the allegation that the accused was intoxicated cannot be conclusively
established. Insofar as the present case is concerned, if the prosecution relies
merely upon the smell of alcohol, the appellant's physical condition after the
accident or the oral observations of witnesses, without producing scientific or
medical evidence, the alleged intoxication remains unproved and cannot be used
as an aggravating circumstance to establish criminal culpability. Hence, this
Court is of the view that the prosecution has failed to establish the alleged
drunken condition of the appellant through reliable and convincing evidence.
Consequently, the charge under Section 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act is not
established beyond reasonable doubt.
5.5 . Regarding the possibility of the deceased having cut across the
road:-
(i) The next circumstance which requires consideration is the exact
manner in which the accident occurred.
__________
Page 18 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
(ii) The learned Senior Counsel for the appellant has specifically relied
upon the rough sketch and observation mahazar to contend that there was no
authorised passage for vehicles coming out of KMC Hospital to directly enter
Barnaby Road.
(iii) It is seen from the materials that vehicles proceeding from the
hospital side were required to travel towards Ega Theatre Junction, take a U-
turn and thereafter proceed towards Central or Parrys Corner and take left turn
for Barnaby Road approach.
(iv) The evidence of PW-13 and PW-15 also requires consideration in this
regard. PW-13 has stated, in response to a question put by the Court, that there
was no passage available to cut across the EVR Periyar Highway from KMC
Hospital. This aspect is also supported by the evidence of PW-15. Further, the
place of occurrence, as reflected in the rough sketch, is stated to be
approximately five metres from the middle of the median. These circumstances
lend support to the defence contention that the deceased had cut across the road
instead of following the prescribed route. This Court is conscious of the fact that
contributory negligence on the part of the deceased is not, by itself, a complete
defence in a criminal prosecution. However, the prosecution is required to
establish the criminal act and culpability of the accused independently.
__________
Page 19 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
(v) In Mahadeo Hari Lokre v. State of Maharashtra reported in (1972)
4 SCC 758, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that sudden crossing of the road by
the deceased and absence of opportunity to avert the accident negate criminal
negligence on the part of the driver. The Hon'ble Supreme Court held that where
a pedestrian suddenly crosses the road without taking note of an approaching
vehicle, there may be every possibility of an accident occurring without the
driver having a reasonable opportunity to avoid the collision. Even if the driver
was proceeding on the road, the occurrence of an accident does not
automatically establish negligence. The Court must examine the precise manner
in which the accident occurred, including the conduct of the deceased and
whether the driver had a reasonable opportunity to avert the accident. Where the
deceased suddenly crosses the road and the driver could not reasonably
anticipate or prevent the collision, criminal negligence cannot be attributed to
the driver merely because the accident resulted in death.
(vi) If the evidence establishes that the deceased suddenly crossed the
road or entered the path of the appellant's vehicle without observing the
approaching traffic, and the appellant had no reasonable opportunity to avoid
the collision, the essential ingredients of rashness and negligence are not
established. Where the evidence creates a reasonable possibility that the
deceased suddenly crossed the road through an unauthorised route, the
__________
Page 20 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
prosecution must establish beyond reasonable doubt that the accident was
nevertheless caused by the criminally rash or negligent act of the appellant.
(vii) In the present case, the prosecution has not satisfactorily excluded
that possibility.
5.6. Regarding the alleged rash and negligent driving:-
(i) The fact that an accident occurred and that a person lost her life is
undoubtedly unfortunate. However, the mere occurrence of an accident
resulting in death cannot automatically lead to the conclusion that the driver
committed an offence involving criminal rashness or negligence.
(ii) The prosecution must establish the manner of driving and the requisite
criminal culpability of the accused.
(iii) The prosecution has relied upon the damage to the car and the
punctured tyre to contend that the appellant was driving at a high speed.
(iv) In State of Karnataka v. Satish reported in (1998) 8 SCC 493 , the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has categorically held that merely because a vehicle
was being driven at a high speed, it does not, by itself, establish rashness or
negligence on the part of the driver. The expression "high speed" is a relative
__________
Page 21 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
term, and the prosecution must produce specific and cogent evidence to
establish the actual speed and the manner in which the vehicle was being driven.
The prosecution cannot rely upon presumptions to establish criminal
negligence. The burden of proving every essential ingredient of the offence rests
upon the prosecution, and the presumption of innocence continues in favour of
the accused till the charge is proved beyond reasonable doubt.
(v) Where the prosecution has failed to establish the actual speed of the
appellant's vehicle, the manner of driving, or any specific rash or negligent act,
the mere allegation that the appellant was driving at high speed cannot form the
basis for conviction under Section 304-A IPC.
(vi) The Motor Vehicle Inspector's evidence regarding the tyre burst is
also relied upon. However, the mere fact that a tyre was punctured or burst
cannot, without further reliable evidence, conclusively establish the speed of the
vehicle or the criminal rashness of the driver. It might have been for various
other reasons, but in the present case, it was to avoid the accident.
(vii) Further, the prosecution has failed to establish the allegation of red-
signal violation, since the evidence of PW-4, PW-13 and PW-15 and the
contemporaneous records indicate that the automatic signals were not
functioning in the usual manner during the relevant period.
__________
Page 22 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
(viii) The evidence of PW-1 and PW-2 regarding the actual occurrence is
also rendered doubtful for the reasons discussed above. Therefore, this Court
finds that the prosecution has not established the exact manner of the accident
beyond reasonable doubt.
5.7 . Regarding the applicability of Section 304 Part-II IPC:-
(i) The appellant has been convicted under Section 304 Part-II IPC. To
sustain such a conviction, the prosecution must establish that the act of the
appellant was committed with the knowledge that it was likely to cause death,
though without any intention to cause death or such bodily injury as is likely to
cause death.
(ii) The distinction between Section 304 Part-II IPC and Section 304A
IPC is well recognised. Mere negligence or the occurrence of a fatal accident
does not automatically attract Section 304 Part-II IPC.
(iii) For attracting criminal liability under Section 304-A IPC, the
prosecution must establish that the rash or negligent act of the accused was the
direct, immediate and proximate cause of the death. It is not sufficient to
establish that the accused's act was merely a causa sine qua non (a necessary or
incidental circumstance). The accused's act must constitute the causa causans
(the effective and operative cause) of the death, without the intervention of
another person's negligence.
__________
Page 23 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
(iv) Where the accident occurs due to the intervening negligence of the
deceased, particularly, when the deceased suddenly enters the road through an
unauthorised opening or makes an unexpected manoeuvre, and the accused is
not the immediate or proximate cause of the fatal accident, criminal liability
under Section 304-A IPC cannot be fastened upon the accused.
(v) Where the evidence establishes that the deceased suddenly crossed or
entered the road in an unexpected manner, resulting in the collision, and the
subsequent fatal injury was caused by a separate intervening event, the
prosecution cannot automatically attribute the death to the appellant's alleged
negligence without establishing proximate causation.
(vi) In the present case, the prosecution's primary foundation for invoking
Section 304 Part-II IPC is that the appellant was driving the vehicle in a heavily
intoxicated condition and that such driving demonstrated knowledge of the
likelihood of death. However, this Court has already found that the alleged
intoxication has not been established through reliable scientific evidence.
(vii) Further, the prosecution has failed to establish beyond reasonable
doubt that the appellant drove the vehicle in a criminally rash or dangerous
manner and that the accident occurred exclusively due to his conduct.
__________
Page 24 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
(viii) The possibility of the deceased having cut across the road and
contributed to the occurrence has also not been ruled out.
(ix) In the absence of reliable evidence establishing the foundational
facts, the requisite knowledge contemplated under Section 304 Part-II IPC
cannot be presumed merely because the appellant was driving a car involved in
a fatal accident. Therefore, this Court finds that the conviction under Section
304 Part-II IPC cannot be sustained.
5.8. Benefit of doubt:-
(i) It is a settled principle of criminal jurisprudence that the prosecution
must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. The burden of establishing the
guilt of the accused rests throughout upon the prosecution.
(ii) The accused is not required to establish his innocence by examining
defence witnesses or producing documentary evidence.
(iii) In the present case, the following circumstances create reasonable
doubt regarding the prosecution case:
(a) The original breath analyser report (Ex.P-6) is smudged and not
decipherable.
(b) The photostat copy (Ex.P-7) has not been satisfactorily established as
an accurate copy of the original.
__________
Page 25 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
(c) There is no satisfactory evidence regarding the calibration and
verification of the breath analyser equipment.
(d) The FSL Toxicology Report (Ex.P-11) does not disclose the presence
of ethyl alcohol.
(e) The evidence of PW-1 and PW-2 regarding their presence at the scene
of occurrence contains material contradictions.
(f) The allegation that the appellant violated a red traffic signal is
contradicted by the evidence of PW-4, PW-13 and PW-15 and the observation
mahazar and rough sketch.
(g) The possibility of the deceased having cut across the road from the
KMC Hospital side cannot be ruled out.
(f) The prosecution has failed to establish the criminal rashness and the
requisite knowledge necessary to attract Section 304 Part-II IPC.
(iv) This Court is conscious of the unfortunate death of Selvi Yamuna and
the irreparable loss suffered by her family. Nevertheless, criminal liability must
be determined on the basis of reliable evidence and the essential ingredients of
the offences charged.
(v) Suspicion, however strong, cannot take the place of proof.
__________
Page 26 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
(vi) In the considered opinion of this Court, the trial Court has not
properly appreciated the above material contradictions and deficiencies and has
placed undue reliance upon the prosecution version without giving sufficient
consideration to the defence contentions.
(vii) Accordingly, the appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt.
6. Conclusion:-
6.1 . In view of the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
State of Karnataka v. Satish , (1998) 8 SCC 493 ; Bachubhai Hassanalli
Karyani v. State of Maharashtra , (1971) 3 SCC 930 ; and Mahadeo Hari
Lokre v. State of Maharashtra , (1972) 4 SCC 758 , as well as the doctrine of
causa causans reiterated in Satya Saai Ram v. The Inspector of Police
[Crl.O.P.No.23492 of 2025, dated 14.07.2026] , the prosecution is under a legal
obligation to establish, through cogent and reliable evidence, that the appellant
had committed a specific rash or negligent act and that such act was the
immediate, proximate and effective cause of the death. Mere involvement of the
appellant's vehicle in the accident, an allegation of high speed or the mere
occurrence of a fatal accident cannot substitute the proof of criminal negligence.
Further, where the evidence indicates that the accident was occasioned by the
sudden and unexpected movement of the deceased or by an intervening act of
negligence, the appellant cannot be held criminally responsible in the absence of
proof establishing the necessary causal connection. Similarly, any allegation of
__________
Page 27 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
intoxication, in the absence of reliable medical or scientific evidence, cannot be
treated as conclusively established.
6.2 . For the reasons stated above, this Court holds that the prosecution has
failed to establish beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant was driving the
vehicle under the influence of alcohol or that he committed an act of such
criminal rashness and knowledge as would attract Section 304 Part-II IPC.
6.3 . The findings recorded by the Trial Court under Section 185 of the
Motor Vehicles Act and Section 304 Part-II IPC are therefore liable to be set
aside.
6.4 . The appellant is entitled to acquittal by extending the benefit of
doubt.
7 . In the result:
7.1 . The Criminal Appeal is allowed.
7.2 . The judgment of conviction and sentence dated 13.12.2023 passed by
the learned Sessions Judge, Mahalir Neethimandram, Allikulam, Chennai, in
S.C.No.85 of 2022, convicting the appellant under Section 185 of the Motor
Vehicles Act and Section 304 Part-II IPC, is hereby set aside.
7.3 . The appellant is acquitted of the charges under Section 185 of the
Motor Vehicles Act and Section 304 Part-II IPC by extending the benefit of
doubt.
__________
Page 28 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
7.4 . The fine amount alone shall be refunded to the appellant.
7.5 . The bail bond, if any, executed by the appellant shall stand
discharged.
7.6 . It is made clear that the appellant has voluntarily deposited a sum of
Rs.5,00,000/- in the bank account of the mother of the deceased, namely,
A.Uma, pursuant to the undertaking given by him at the time of consideration of
his bail application in Crl.O.P.No.9934 of 2021, dated 04.06.2021. Hence, he
shall have no claim over the said amount.
13-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
smn2 / VV-2
To
1.The Sessions Judge,
Mahalir Neethimandram, Allikulam, Chennai.
2.The Inspector of Police
D6, Anna Square Police Station,
Traffic Investigation Wing, Chennai.
3.The Public Prosecutor,
Madras High Court, Chennai.
4.The Section Officer,
Criminal Records,
Madras High Court, Chennai.
__________
Page 29 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )

CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
M.NIRMAL KUMAR, J.
smn2 / VV-2
CRL A No. 1633 of 2023
13-11-2026
__________
Page 30 of 30
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:40 pm )