Smt. Sanju Singh And Ors. vs The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.Throu.Branch Manager And Anr.

Court
Allahabad High Court

A.F.R.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
LUCKNOW
FIRST APPEAL FROM ORDER No. - 871 of 2014
Smt. Sanju Singh and Ors.… ..Appellant(s)
Versus
The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.Throu.Branch Manager and Anr...Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Qazi Mohd. Ahmad,
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Jay Krishna Shukla, Jitendra Narain
Mishra, Zaki Mohammad Ahmad
Along with :
(1) First Appeal From Order No. 1133 of 2012
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Sanju Singh and others
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Jitendra Narain Mishra
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Jay Krishna Shukla, S.K.Srivastava,
Sumit Kr. Srivastava
(2) First Appeal From Order No. 1135 of 201
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Smt. Urmila Singh and others
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Jitendra Narain Mishra
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Akash Deep Singh, Jay Krishna Shukla,
Qazi Mohd.Ahmad, Sachindra Dwivedi
(3) First Appeal From Order No. 24 of 2016
Smt. Urmila Singh and Ors. Vs.The New India Assurance Company
Ltd. and others
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Sachindra Dwivedi, Akash Deep Singh,
Anurag Singh, Harsh Vardhan Singh
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Jay Krishna Shukla, Jitendra Narain
Mishra
Court No. - 19
HON'BLE SYED QAMAR HASAN RIZVI, J.
1. Sri Jitendra Narain Mishra, learned counsel for The New India
Assurance Company Ltd and Sri Qazi Mohd. Ahmad, learned counsel
appearing for the claimants in FAFO No. 871 of 2014 and in FAFO No.
1133 of 2012 and Sri Akash Deep Singh, learned counsel for the

2
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
claimants in FAFO No. 24 of 2016 and in FAFO No. 1135 of 2012; and
Sri Jay Krishna Shukla, learned counsel for owner of the
Vehicle/respondent in the leading and connected appeals, are present.
2. Since, all the four captioned Appeals arise out of the same accident
occurring on the same date and time, involving the same offending
vehicle and having common issues involved for adjudication; they are
being disposed of by this common judgment.
3. By means of the present Appeals filed under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.
(hereinafter referred to as ‘Insurance Company’), as well as the
Claimants, have assailed the common judgment and award dated
13.03.2012 passed by the Learned Additional District Judge / Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No. 5, Pratapgarh (hereinafter referred
to as the ‘Tribunal’) in Claim Petition No. 48 of 2007 (Smt. Sanju Singh
and others versus Ram Chandra Shukla and another) and Claim Petition
No. 49 of 2007 (Smt. Urmila Singh and others versus The New India
Assurance Company Limited and another).
4. The aforesaid impugned judgment dated 13.03.2012 has been assailed
by the Insurance Company by means of Appeals having No. FAFO No.
1133 of 2012 and FAFO No.1135 of 2012.
5. The facts of the case as culled out from the pleadings are that a road
accident occurred on 02.03.2007 at approximately 10:30 P.M. at the
Patti-Pratapgarh Road near Village Devanmau, Police Station Kandhai,
District Pratapgarh, wherein two persons namely Nagendra Pratap Singh
and Surendra Pratap Singh lost their lives. As per the pleadings the
deceased Nagendra Pratap Singh was riding his motorcycle (bearing
registration No. UP 54 E 0395) where as Surendra Pratap Singh was the
pillion rider moving from Pratapgarh to Patti (West to East), when a Tata
Sumo (Jeep) bearing registration number MH 31BB8871 (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘offending vehicle’), owned by the respondent namely,
Ram Chandra Shukla and duly insured by the Insurance Company;
coming from the opposite direction i.e., from Patti to Pratapgarh (East to

3
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
West), caused the accident by hitting the aforementioned motorcycle. As
a result thereof, both the rider and the pillion rider of the motorcycle
sustained grievous injuries. Consequently, Surendra Pratap Singh
succumbed to death at District Hospital, Pratapgarh while Nagendra
Pratap Singh was referred to Medical College, Allahabad where he also
died.
6. Two separate Claim Petitions, being Claim Petition No. 48 of 2007
and Claim Petition No. 49 of 2007 were filed under Section 166 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, before the Learned Tribunal, inter-alia
claiming compensation to the tune of Rs. 27,00,000/- (C.P. 48/2007) and
Rs. 32,30,000/- (C.P. 49/2007) respectively. While deciding the
aforesaid Claim petitions the Learned Tribunal, framed the following
common issues for determination. For ready reference, the issues as
framed in both the Claim Petitions are reproduced herein below:
"1. क्या दिनांक दि ना दिनांक ंक 2.3.07 क ो समय समय 10.30 बजे रात बहद ग्रामरा दिनांक त बहद ग्रामबह  ग्रा दिनांक म
े रात बहद ग्रामवनम प्रत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक पग पट्टी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतजा दिनांक ने रात बहद ग्रामवा दिनांक ली जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतसड़क परअन्त बहद ग्रामगत बहद ग्राम
था दिनांक ना दिनांक क न्ध! दिजला दिनांक प्रत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक पग  में वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रवा दिनांक हनस्वा दिनांक मी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतरा दिनांक मचन््र
शुक्ला दिनांक क ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतटा दिनांक टा दिनांक सूमो समय एम . एच .31 बी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत . बी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत ./8871 क े रात बहद ग्रामड्रा दिनांक इवर
द्वा दिनांक रा दिनांक वा दिनांक हनक ो समय त बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामजी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतवला दिनांक परवा दिनांक ही जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतसे रात बहद ग्रामअसा दिनांक वधा दिनांक नी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपूव क चला दिनांक त बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्राम

्रप्रत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक पदिसंहक ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतमो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लदिजसमें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रसुरे रात बहद ग्रामन््र
हुये रात बहद ग्रामना दिनांक गे रात बहद ग्रामन्
बहा दिनांक ुरदिसंहभी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतछे रात बहद ग्रामबैठे रात बहद ग्रामथे रात बहद ग्राममें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रटक्क रमा दिनांक री जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतदिजससे रात बहद ग्रामना दिनांक गे रात बहद ग्रामन््र
प्रत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक पदिसंहवसुरे रात बहद ग्रामन् ्रबहा दिनांक ुरदिसंहो समय नों को गम्भीर चोटेंक ो समय गम्भी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतरचो समय टें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्र
आयी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतऔरउनमें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रसे रात बहद ग्रामसुरे रात बहद ग्रामन् ्रबहा दिनांक ुरदिसंहक ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतमौक े रात बहद ग्रामपरही जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतमृत्यु
हो समय गयी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत ?
2. क्या दिनांक मो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लक े रात बहद ग्रामचा दिनांक लक ना दिनांक गे रात बहद ग्रामन् ्रप्रत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक पदिसंहने रात बहद ग्राम

त बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामजी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतवला दिनांक परवा दिनांक ही जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतसे रात बहद ग्राममो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक दिलचला दिनांक त बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामहुये रात बहद ग्रामटा दिनांक टा दिनांक सूमो समय
ुर्घटना दिनांक में वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रअंशा दिनांक यी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतउपे रात बहद ग्रामक्षा दिनांक क ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत ? यदि  हा दिनांक ँ तो प्रभाव त बहद ग्रामो समय प्रभा दिनांक व ?
से रात बहद ग्रामहु!
3. क्या दिनांक या दिनांक ची जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतग; ने रात बहद ग्राममो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लदिजससे रात बहद ग्राममृत बहद ग्रामक सुरे रात बहद ग्रामन् ्र
प्रत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक पदिसंह ुर्घटना दिनांक क े रात बहद ग्राम समयया दिनांक त बहद ग्राम्रा दिनांक क ररहा दिनांक था दिनांक मो समय टर

सा दिनांक इदिक लक े रात बहद ग्राम स्वा दिनांक मी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतक ो समय पक्षक ा दिनांक रनबना दिनांक ने रात बहद ग्रामसे रात बहद ग्रामया दिनांक दिचक ा दिनांक में वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्र
पक्षक ा दिनांक रों को गम्भीर चोटेंक े रात बहद ग्रामअसंयो समय जनक ा दिनांक ो समय ष हैहै ?
4. क्या दिनांक उक्त बहद ग्रामटा दिनांक टा दिनांक सूमो समय नं . एम . एच .31 बी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत . वी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत ./8871 ड्रा दिनांक इवर
क े रात बहद ग्राम पा दिनांक स ुर्घटना दिनांक क े रात बहद ग्राम दिना दिनांक ंक क ो समय वैधवप्रभा दिनांक वी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतड्रा दिनांक इदिवंग
ला दिनांक इसें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रसथा दिनांक
?
5. क्या दिनांक क दिथत बहद ग्राम ुर्घटना दिनांक क रने रात बहद ग्रामवा दिनांक ले रात बहद ग्रामवा दिनांक हनक े रात बहद ग्रामस्वा दिनांक मी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतक े रात बहद ग्रामपा दिनांक स
ुर्घटना दिनांक क े रात बहद ग्रामदिना दिनांक ंक क ो समय वा दिनांक हनक ा दिनांक वैधवप्रभा दिनांक वी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतबी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतमा दिनांक था दिनांक त बहद ग्रामथा दिनांक
क ा दिनांक गजा दिनांक त बहद ग्रामवैधथे रात बहद ग्राम ?
6. क्या दिनांक या दिनांक ची जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतग; प्रदित बहद ग्रामक रपा दिनांक ने रात बहद ग्रामक े रात बहद ग्रामअदिधक ा दिनांक री जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतहै ? यदि  हा दिनांक ँ तो प्रभाव त बहद ग्रामो समय
दिक त बहद ग्रामना दिनांक औरदिक सपक्षसे रात बहद ग्राम ?"

4
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
7. However, in addition to the above, the following issues were also
framed in Claim Petition No. 48 of 2007. For a ready reference, the
issues, as framed, are reproduced herein below:
6.
क्या कथि त दुर्घ टना के समय मोटर साइकिकल चालक के पास
?
बैध एवं प्रभावी ड्राइविंवग लाइसेंस ा
7.
क्या कथि त दुर्घ टना के समय उक्त मोटर साइकिकल का बैध एवं
?
प्रभावी बीमा ा
8- ?
क्या याचीगण किकसी अनुतोष को पाने का अधिधकारी है
8. The Learned Tribunal, vide its judgment dated 13.03.2012, awarded
compensation to a tune of Rs. 8,42,224/- to the claimants in Clam
Petition No. 48/2007 and Rs. 5,23,312/- to the claimants in Claim
Petition No. 49/2007 along with simple interest at the rate of 6% per
annum. While deciding the issue of negligence, the Learned Tribunal
held the driver of the offending vehicle solely responsible for the
accident.
9. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and award dated 13.03.2012, the
Insurance Company preferred appeals having FAFO No. 1133 of 2012
and FAFO No. 1135 of 2012. Conversely, the claimants also challenged
the same judgment and award by filing appeals having FAFO No. 871 of
2014 and FAFO No. 24 of 2016 respectively; primarily seeking
enhancement of the awarded amount of compensation.
10. While assailing the impugned judgment and award dated 13.03.2012
the learned counsel for the Insurance Company pressed the following
arguments.
10.1. His first assertion is that the Learned Tribunal has recorded
an erroneous finding in the impugned judgment, to the extent that
the accident was caused entirely due to the negligence of the
driver of the offending vehicle. The contention of the learned
counsel for the Insurance Company is that since, it was a case of
"head-on collision" between two vehicles on a wide road, common
prudence dictates that it is caused due to the negligence of drivers
of both the vehicles involved in the accident and had if one of
them been cautious, the accident in question could have been

5
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
avoided. Therefore, the liability could not be fastened upon the
driver of the offending vehicle alone.
10.2. His next contention is that the compensation awarded by the
Learned Tribunal is not just and proper as, the deceased Nagendra
Pratap Singh was working as an employee in the department of
Sahkari Ganna Vikas Samiti, Mau and the deceased Surendra
Pratap Singh was working in the department of Ganna Vibhag ,
Faizabad. After their death, their sons were given compassionate
appointments in place of their deceased father. Therefore, taking
into consideration that the claimants have been given
compassionate appointment under dying in harness scheme, they
cannot be permitted to profiteer and receive "double benefit" on
account of the death of their deceased father, as they have not
suffered financial loss to the extent of the compensation already
granted by the Learned Tribunal under various other heads, vide
the awarded dated 13.03.2012.
10.3. The Learned Counsel also urged that the purpose of
awarding compensation is to put the claimants in the same
financial position as they would have been if the accident did not
have taken place, and the pecuniary advantage gained through
these compassionate appointments must be considered to prevent
unjust enrichment. To substantiate his argument learned counsel
pointed out that during the cross-examination, PW-3 (Accounts
Officer) stated that the deceased Nagendra Pratap Singh was
earning Rs. 6,533/- per month at the time of his death, while his
son Shailendra Pratap after getting compassionate appointment in
place of his deceased father earned Rs. 13,155/- per month.
Similarly, PW-2/Gyanendra Pratap Singh son of (late) Surendra
Pratap Singh admitted in cross-examination that he was given
compassionate appointment on account of death of his father and
was earning Rs. 10,500/- per month. That goes to show that by
getting higher salary, the claimants can not be said to have

6
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
suffered any financial loss, rather they were placed in a better
financial condition.
10.4. It was further argued on behalf of the Insurance Company
th
that the revision of pay under the recommendations of the VI Pay
Commission was made effective in the year 2010, whereas the
accident occurred in 2007, therefore, the benefit of the said
revision of pay which came into effect after the date of death of
deceased cannot be extended to the claimants for determining the
compensation, especially, when the son(s) of the deceased(s) after
procuring compassionate appointment got the benefits of the said
revised pay scale. It has also been urged by the learned counsel for
the Insurance Company that in the instant case, future prospects
are not liable to be added while determining the compensation,
since, the son(s) of deceased(s) had been given compassionate
appointment in place of their (late) father to secure the
unprecedented economic crises of the family. The addition of
future prospects would be in derogation of the settled law that the
compensation should not be a source of profit.
10.5. Lastly, the learned Counsel submitted that the imposition of
liability to pay interest from the date of filing of the claim
petitions is also unjust, as the Insurance Company, without any
delay, filed its’ written statement. Therefore, any delay in the
adjudication of the said claim petitions is not attributable to the
Insurance Company. Rather, the same was on account of the
delaying tactics on the part of the claimants.
11. Per Contra , confronting the contentions of learned counsel for the
Insurance Company; the assertions of the learned counsel for the
respective counsel for the claimants, advanced the following arguments:
11.1. The first argument placed by the learned counsel appearing
for the claimants is that compassionate appointment cannot be
treated as a pecuniary advantage while determining the
compensation award payable under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

7
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
It is urged by the learned counsel that Learned Tribunal has very
correctly ignored the aspect relating to the factum of the grant of
compassionate appointment to the son(s) of deceased(s) while
adjudicating the claim petition filed by the family members of the
deceased(s).
11.2. The next argument as advanced by the learned counsel for
the claimants is that the amount of compensation as awarded by
the Learned Tribunal is on the lower side. He urged that the
Learned Tribunal while deciding the claims in question could not
have appreciated the fact that the deceased at the time of death
were entitled to the revised Pay Scale as per the recommednations
th
of the VI Pay Commission owing to the fact that the same was
implemented with retrospective effect from 01.01.2006. But the
Learned Tribunal has erroneously considered the deceased’s
unrevised salary as the earning for the purposes of determination
of claim, thereby arrived at a wrong determination while making
the impugned award.
11.3. Further, it is contended by the learned counsel, that the
Learned Tribunal has erred in law by not awarding any amount
towards future prospects. His submission is that in the light of the
law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases of
National Insurance Co. Ltd. versus Pranay Sethi and others
reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680 and New India Assurance Co.
Ltd. Versus Urmila Shukla and Others reported in (2021) SCC
OnLine SC 822 ; keeping in view the ages of the deceased, their
heirs/family members are entitled for future prospects at the rate
of 50% in the case of (Late) Nagendra Pratap Singh and 15% in
the case of (Late) Surendra Pratap Singh, respectively.
11.4. It is vehemently argued that the Learned Tribunal has erred
rd
in law while deducting one-third (1/3 ) toward the personal and
living expenses from the annual income of the deceased in both
the aforementioned cases. He submitted that since the deceased

8
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
Nagendra Pratap Singh left seven (7) dependents while the
deceased Surendra Pratap Singh left six (6) dependents at the time
of their death therefore, as per the law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India, in the case of Sarla Verma and others
versus Delhi Transport Corporation and another , reported in
(2009) 6 SCC 121 the said deduction should be one-fifth (1/5th)
and one-fourth(1/4th), respectively.
11.5. It is also contended on behalf of the claimants that the
Learned Tribunal awarded a sum of Rs. 6,000/- only under
conventional heads while the claimants are entitled for an amount
to a tune of Rs. 70,000/- in the light of the judgment passed by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Pranay Seth i (Supra).
11.6. It is urged by the learned counsel that the Learned Tribunal
while passing the award has fixed 6% simple interest per annum
which is much less and should have been at least 9% per annum in
view of the facts and circumstances of the present case.
12. Heard the learned counsel for the respective parties and perused the
material available on record.
13. In view of the above, the foremost question falling for consideration
before this Court is whether the Learned Tribunal was justified in
holding that the driver of the offending vehicle solely responsible for the
accident. The relevant part of the findings recorded by the Learned
Tribunal is extracted herein below, for convenience:
“……… .. या दिनांक ची जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतग; क ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतओरसे रात बहद ग्रामक दिथत बहद ग्राम ुर्घटना दिनांक क े रात बहद ग्रामसा दिनांक क्षी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतश्री जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतज्ञा दिनांक ने रात बहद ग्रामन््र
प्रत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक पदिसंहक ो समय पी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत . डबलू 2 क े रात बहद ग्रामरुपमें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रपरी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतदिक्षत बहद ग्रामक रा दिनांक या दिनांक गया दिनांक हैदिजसने रात बहद ग्रामअपने रात बहद ग्राम
सशपथबया दिनांक नमें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रक हा दिनांक हैदिक क दिथत बहद ग्रामर्घटना दिनांक ो समय मा दिनांक च 2007 क ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतहै। लगभगलगभग
10.30 बजे रात बहद ग्रामरा दिनांक त बहद ग्रामक ा दिनांक समयथा दिनांक । लगभगर्घटना दिनांक ग्रा दिनांक म े रात बहद ग्रामवनमर्जो समय प्रत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक पगढ से पट्टीसे रात बहद ग्रामपट्टी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत
सडक परपडत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक है , वही जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतंपरहु! थी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत। लगभगउसक े रात बहद ग्रामदिपत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक मृत बहद ग्रामक उसक े रात बहद ग्रामचचे रात बहद ग्रामरे रात बहद ग्रामभा दिनांक !
ना दिनांक गे रात बहद ग्रामन् ्रदिसंहक े रात बहद ग्रामसा दिनांक थमो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लपरपी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतछे रात बहद ग्रामबैठक रर्घरआरहे रात बहद ग्रामथे रात बहद ग्रामवह
ूसरी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतमो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लपरपी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतछे रात बहद ग्रामबा दिनांक लमुक ुन् शमा दिनांक  क ो समय बैठा दिनांक क रक े रात बहद ग्रामदिपत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक जी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतक े रात बहद ग्राम

सा दिनांक थसबलो समय गर्घरजा दिनांक रहे रात बहद ग्रामथे रात बहद ग्राम। लगभगआगे रात बहद ग्रामचचे रात बहद ग्रामरे रात बहद ग्रामभा दिनांक ! क ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतमो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लथी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतछे रात बहद ग्राम
मे रात बहद ग्रामरी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतमो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक ल थी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत। लगभगहमलो समय गसड़क परएक मबा दिनांक यी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपटरी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतसे रात बहद ग्रामजा दिनांक रहे रात बहद ग्राम
थे रात बहद ग्रामदिक सा दिनांक मने रात बहद ग्रामसे रात बहद ग्रामसो समय मो समय जी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपदिजसक ा दिनांक नम्बरएम . एच .31 बी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत . वी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत ./8871 था दिनांक

दिजसक ा दिनांक ड्रा दिनांक इबरजी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपक ो समय बहुत बहद ग्रामत बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामजी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतरफत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक रवला दिनांक परवा दिनांक ही जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपूव क लहरा दिनांक त बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामहुये रात बहद ग्राम
आया दिनांक औरआगे रात बहद ग्राममे रात बहद ग्रामरे रात बहद ग्रामभा दिनांक ! क े रात बहद ग्राममो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लमें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रटक्क रमा दिनांक रा दिनांक ं। लगभगटक्क रसे रात बहद ग्राम ो समय नों को गम्भीर चोटें
लो समय गसडक परदिगरगये रात बहद ग्रामऔरजी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपक ा दिनांक ा दिनांक दिहना दिनांक अगला दिनांक टा दिनांक यरटक्क रसे रात बहद ग्रामफट
गया दिनांक । लगभगउसक े रात बहद ग्रामदिपत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक एवंचचे रात बहद ग्रामरे रात बहद ग्रामभा दिनांक ! क ो समय क ुचलत बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामहुये रात बहद ग्रामउसे रात बहद ग्रामभी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतबगलसे रात बहद ग्रामटक्क र
मा दिनांक रा दिनांक । लगभगवहदिछटक क रक े रात बहद ग्राम ूरबैठे रात बहद ग्रामबा दिनांक लमुक ुन् क ो समय भी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतगम्भी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतरचो समय टआयी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत। लगभग

9
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
दिपत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक वभा दिनांक ! क ो समय मर;ा दिनांक सन्नदिस्थत बहद ग्राममें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रस रअस्पत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक लप्रत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक पगढ से पट्टीले रात बहद ग्रामजा दिनांक या दिनांक
गया दिनांक जहा दिनांक ँ तो प्रभाव पहुँ तो प्रभाव चत बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामपहुँ तो प्रभाव चत बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामउसक े रात बहद ग्रामदिपत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक जी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतक ही जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतंमृत्युहो समय गयी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत । लगभगचचे रात बहद ग्रामरे रात बहद ग्रामभा दिनांक ! क ो समय
इला दिनांक हा दिनांक बा दिनांक  दिरफरक रदिया दिनांक गया दिनांक वहा दिनांक ँ तो प्रभाव पहुँ तो प्रभाव चत बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामपहुँ तो प्रभाव चत बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामउनक ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतमृत्युहो समय गयी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत। लगभग
उसक े रात बहद ग्रामदिपत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक जी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतगन्ना दिनांक दिवभा दिनांक गमें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रगन्ना दिनांक आयुक्त बहद ग्रामक ा दिनांक या दिनांक लयफे रात बहद ग्रामजा दिनांक बा दिनांक  में वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्र
दिलदिपक क े रात बहद ग्रामप  परक ा दिनांक यरत बहद ग्रामथे रात बहद ग्राम। लगभगउनक ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतउम्र वष है  क े रात बहद ग्रामआसपा दिनांक सथी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत। लगभगवह
50
लगभग 12000 रुपये रात बहद ग्रामत बहद ग्रामनख्वा दिनांक हपा दिनांक त बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामथे रात बहद ग्राम। लगभगइसक े रात बहद ग्रामअला दिनांक वों को गम्भीर चोटेंर्घरपरखे रात बहद ग्रामत बहद ग्रामी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतबा दिनांक री जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत ,
पशुपा दिनांक लनआदि  क ा दिनांक क ा दिनांक मक रत बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामथे रात बहद ग्राम , इससे रात बहद ग्रामत बहद ग्रामी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतनचा दिनांक रहजा दिनांक ररुपये रात बहद ग्रामदिक उसक े रात बहद ग्राम
दिपत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक जी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतक ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतजगहपरवहउक्त बहद ग्रामक ा दिनांक या दिनांक लयमें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रदिलदिपक क े रात बहद ग्रामप परक ा दिनांक यरत बहद ग्रामहै। लगभग
…………
दिनस्त बहद ग्रामा दिनांक र; वा दिनांक  दिबन्ु संख्या दिनांक
2
… या दिनांक ची जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतग; क े रात बहद ग्रामदिवद्वा दिनांक नअदिधवक्त बहद ग्रामा दिनांक क ा दिनांक त बहद ग्रामक  हैदिक उपरो समय क्त बहद ग्रामक दिथत बहद ग्रामुर्घटना दिनांक में वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्र
सम्पू;  गल्त बहद ग्रामी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतजी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपचा दिनांक लक क ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतथी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतक्यों को गम्भीर चोटेंदिक मो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लचा दिनांक लक
दिनयमा दिनांक नुसा दिनांक रमो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लक ो समय अपनी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतबा दिनांक यी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपटरी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपरचला दिनांक रहा दिनांक था दिनांक जबदिक
जी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपक े रात बहद ग्रामचा दिनांक लक ने रात बहद ग्रामजी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपक ो समय त बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामजी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतवला दिनांक परवा दिनांक ही जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतसे रात बहद ग्रामचला दिनांक त बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामहुये रात बहद ग्रामएक मा दिनांक दिहने रात बहद ग्राम
गलत बहद ग्रामसा दिनांक इडमें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रआक रमो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लमें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रटक्क रमा दिनांक री जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतदिजसक े रात बहद ग्रामफलस्वरुप

क दिथत बहद ग्राम
ुर्घटना दिनांक र्घदिटत बहद ग्रामहु!। लगभगूसरी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतओरदिवपक्षी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतक े रात बहद ग्रामदिवद्वा दिनांक नअदिधवक्त बहद ग्रामा दिनांक क ा दिनांक त बहद ग्रामक 
हैदिक क दिथत बहद ग्राम ुर्घटना दिनांक में वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रमो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लचा दिनांक लक क ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतभी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतगलत बहद ग्रामी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतहै। लगभग
उपरो समय क्त बहद ग्रामत बहद ग्रामक ो समय  क े रात बहद ग्रामसन्भ में वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रपत बहद ग्राम्रा दिनांक वली जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपरउपलब्धप्रमा दिनांक दि;त बहद ग्रामप्रदित बहद ग्रामनक्शा दिनांक
नजरी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतर्घटना दिनांक स्थलक ा दिनांक गजसंख्या दिनांक 4012 क े रात बहद ग्राम अवलो समय क नसे रात बहद ग्रामदिवदि त बहद ग्रामहो समय त बहद ग्रामा दिनांक हैदिक
क दिथत बहद ग्राम ुर्घटना दिनांक क े रात बहद ग्रामसमयमो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लचा दिनांक लक दिनयमा दिनांक नुसा दिनांक रअपनी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतबा दिनांक थी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत

पटरी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपरप्रत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक पगढ से पट्टीसे रात बहद ग्रामपट्टी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतक ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतओरजा दिनांक रहा दिनांक था दिनांक जबदिक जी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपचा दिनांक लक
ा दिनांक यी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपटरी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपरमुडगया दिनांक त बहद ग्रामथा दिनांक
प‌ट्टी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतसे रात बहद ग्रामप्रत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक पगढ से पट्टीक ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतओरनजा दिनांक त बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामहुये रात बहद ग्रामअपनी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत
मो समय टरसा दिनांक इदिक लमें वाहन स्वामी राम चन्द्रसा दिनांक मने रात बहद ग्रामसे रात बहद ग्रामटक्क रभा दिनांक री जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत। लगभगअत बहद ग्रामः स्पष्ट हैकि कथित दुर्घटनास्पष्टहैदिक क दिथत बहद ग्राम ुर्घटना दिनांक
जी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपचा दिनांक लक क ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत , 
असा दिनांक वधा दिनांक नी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतवउत बहद ग्रामा दिनांक वले रात बहद ग्रामपनक े रात बहद ग्रामक ा दिनांक र; हु! है। लगभगफलस्वरुपवा दिनांक
दिबन् ुसंख्या दिनांक 2 नक ा दिनांक रा दिनांक त्मक रुपसे रात बहद ग्रामदिन;ी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत त बहद ग्रामदिक या दिनांक जा दिनांक त बहद ग्रामा दिनांक है। लगभग … .”
(emphasis supplied by this Court)
14. Upon careful appraisal of the above finding and the material
available on record, this Court finds that it is necessary to consider the
site plan/ Naksha Nazri alongside the testimony of the eyewitness PW-2
(Gyanendra Pratap Singh). A close examination of the same reveals that
the motorcycle was moving ahead on extreme left side (‘ बा दिनांक यी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गतपटरी जाने वाली सड़क पर अन्तर्गत ’ ) of
the road, whereas the offending vehicle was coming from the opposite
direction i.e., from Patti to Pratapgarh (East to West), at a high speed in
zigzag manner (‘ ’ ), and suddenly swerved to the wrong side
लहरा दिनांक त बहद ग्रामे रात बहद ग्रामहुये रात बहद ग्राम
(right side) of the road and caused head-on hit to the motorcycle. It is
relevant to note that mere involvement of two vehicles coming from
opposite directions does not ipso facto establish contributory negligence,
where evidence clearly demonstrates that the offending vehicle deviated
from its permitted lane i.e. left side of the road and encroached upon the
wrong lane. In the present case, the driver of the offending vehicle, DW-
2 (Mohd. Farooq), could not discredit this unprecedented trajectory
during cross-examination. Therefore, taking into consideration the said
facts in its totality, this Court is of the view that the finding returned by

10
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
the Learned Tribunal fastening sole negligence upon the driver of the
offending vehicle, is perfectly justified and requires no interference.
15. The second issue that warrants consideration by this Court is whether
th
the revision of salary pursuant to the recommendations of the VI Pay
Commission, with effect from 01.01.2006, can be taken into account for
the purpose of determining compensation.
16. In order to determine this issue, this Court finds it relevant to
mention that the Hon’be Division Bench of this Court, in the case of
Roshani Devi and Others versus P.S. Malhotra , reported in 2017 SCC
OnLine All 5152 while relying upon judgment passed by the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of Rajesh & Others versus Rajbir Singh &
Others reported in (2013) 9 SCC 54 has held that the benefit of revision
of pay announced subsequent to the death of the deceased, but made
effective retrospectively prior to the death of the deceased, is be taken
into account while granting compensation to the claimants. For a ready
reference, paragraphs 10 and 11 of the aforesaid judgment passed in the
case of Roshani Devi and Others (supra) are extracted herein below:
“10. The appellants have relied upon para 22 of the judgment of
Rajesh (Supra) wherein the Apex Court has granted the benefit of
Sixth Pay Commission benefits which were announced subsequent to
death of deceased making it operative retrospectively from
01.01.2006.
11. Thus, applying the ratio laid down in the case of Rajesh (Supra)
that benefit of revision of pay announced subsequent to death of
deceased but made it effective retrospectively prior to death of
deceased, we set-aside the finding of the Tribunal refusing to grant
benefit of revision of pay. From record we find that the appellants
has filed salary certificate indicating the salary of deceased fixed at
Rs. 11,814/- per month after revision of pay which has not been
rebutted by Insurance Company, therefore, we hold that Rs. 11,814/-
per month be treated as income of deceased for calculating
compensation.”
17. Upon perusal of the record, it emerges that the claimants had brought
on record the salary certificates (Paper No. 49 Ka-1 and 52 Ga-1)
th
indicating that the revised salaries, after the implementation of the VI
Pay Commission recommendations, in respect of the deceased(s)
namely, Nagendra Pratap Singh and Surendra Pratap Singh, stood at Rs.
8,786/- and Rs. 10,770/- per month, respectively. Therefore, in the light

11
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
of the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Rajesh
(Supra) and also the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Division Bench of
this Court in Roshani Devi (supra) wherein the Hon’ble Courts granted
th
the benefits of the VI Pay Commission, even though the same were
made operative subsequent to the death of the deceased, but
retrospectively with effect from 01.01.2006 in the present case, this
Court finds the judgment and award dated 13.03.2012 passed by the
Learned Tribunal erroneous in so far as it refused to grant the benefit of
revision of pay to the claimants. Therefore, it is imperative in the instant
case the aforesaid revised salaries are liable to be treated as the income
of the deceased for the purpose of assessing just and equitable
compensation.
18. The third issue that requires consideration by this Court is that
whether the compassionate appointment of the sons of the deceased(s)
affect the determination of compensation especially with regards to the
future prospects.
19. On the aforesaid issue the learned Counsel for the Insurance
Company has very emphatically asserted that the compassionate
appointments granted to the sons of the deceased(s) must be factored in
to reduce the compensation granted to the claimants as they have not
suffered economic loss to the extent of the compensation granted by the
Learned Tribunal and in view of the same, claimants cannot be permitted
to profiteer and receive "double benefit" on account of the death of their
family members.
20. The above mentioned issue is no longer res integra . As the same, has
been settled by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of National
Insurance Company Ltd. versus Rekhaben & Others reported in
(2017) 13 SCC 547 wherein the Hon’ble Court while distinguishing
between the compensation liable to be paid by the tortfeasor and salary
earned by the claimant through compassionate appointment observed
that,
“14. What needs to be considered is whether compassionate
appointment offered to the dependants of the deceased or the injured,

12
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
by the employer of the deceased/injured, who is not the tortfeasor,
can be deducted from the compensation receivable by him on
account of the accident from the tortfeasor. Certainly, it cannot be
that the one liable to compensate the claimants for the loss of income
due to the accident, can have his liability reduced by the amount
which the claimants earn as a result of compassionate appointment
offered by another viz. the employer.
……………………………………………………………………...
………………………………………………………………………
22. In the present cases, the claimants were offered compassionate
employment. The claimants were not offered any sum of money
equal to the income of the deceased. In fact, they were not offered
any sum of money at all. They were offered employment and the
money they receive in the form of their salary, would be earned from
such employment. The loss of income in such cases cannot be said to
be set off because the claimants would be earning their living.
Therefore, we are of the view that the amount earned by the
claimants from compassionate appointments cannot be deducted
from the quantum of compensation receivable by them under the Act.
23. In the cases before us, compensation is claimed from the owner
of the offending vehicle who is different from the employer who has
offered employment on compassionate grounds to the dependants of
the deceased/injured. The Source from which compensation on
account of the accident is claimed and the source from which the
compassionate employment is offered, are completely separate and
there is no co-relation between these two sources. Since the tort
feasor has not offered the compassionate appointment, we are of the
view that an amount which a claimant earns by his labour or by
offering his services, whether by reason of compassionate
appointment or otherwise is not liable to be deducted from the
compensation which the claimant is entitled to receive from a tort
feasor under the Act. In such a situation, we are of the view that the
financial benefit of the compassionate employment is not liable to be
deducted at all from the compensation amount which is liable to be
paid either by the owner/the driver of the offending vehicle or the
insurer. Hence, we find no merit in these appeals and they are
dismissed accordingly.”
21. As far as the contention of the learned counsel for the Insurance
Company regarding pecuniary advantage availed by the claimants
through compassionate appointment is concerned, it may be noted that
the similar question also came up for consideration before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Vimal Kanwar and Others versus
Kishore Dan and Others reported in ( 2013) 7 SCC 476 wherein the
Hon’ble Court while answering the question as to whether the salary
receivable by the claimant after getting job on compassionate
appointment comes within the periphery of the Motor Vehicles Act to be
termed as ‘Pecuniary Advantage’liable for deduction; has held that
compassionate appointment can be one of the conditions of service of an

13
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
employee, if a scheme to that effect is framed by the employer. This
cannot be stated to be an advantage receivable by the heirs on account of
one’s death and have no correlation with the amount receivable under a
statute occasioned on account of accidental death. Compassionate
appointment may have nexus with the death of an employee while in
service, but it is not necessary that it should have a correlation with the
accidental death. An employee dies in harness even in normal course,
due to illness and to maintain the family of the deceased one of the
dependents may be entitled for compassionate appointment but that
cannot be termed as “Pecuniary Advantage” that comes under the
periphery of Motor Vehicles Act and any amount received on such
appointment is not liable for deduction for determination of
compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act.
22. Further, it is also well settled in law that deductions cannot be
allowed from the amount of compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act
either on account of insurance, or on account of pensionary benefits or
gratuity or grant of employment to kin of the deceased. The main reason
is that all these amounts are earned by the deceased on account of
contractual relations entered into by the deceased with others. It cannot
be said that these amounts accrued to the dependents or the legal heirs of
the deceased on account of his death in a motor vehicle accident. The
claimants/dependents are entitled to ‘just compensation’ under the Motor
Vehicles Act as a result of the death of the deceased in a motor vehicle
accident. Therefore, the natural corollary is that the advantage which
accrues to the estate of the deceased or to his dependents as a result of
some contract or act which the deceased performed in his lifetime cannot
be said to be the outcome or result of the death of the deceased even
though these amounts may go into the hands of the dependents only after
his death.
23. In view of what has been discussed in the proceeding paragraphs, it
is abundantly clear that compassionate appointment or any post retiral
dues given to the dependents of the deceased, cannot be counted towards
compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 on account of

14
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
accidental death. Accordingly, the argument raised by the learned
counsel appearing for the Insurance Company regarding the reduction of
compensation on the said ground, stands demolished and thus, turned
down.
24. Now coming to the issue of determination of future prospects, in the
given facts and circumstances of the present case, this court upon a
perusal of the impugned judgment and award, finds that the Learned
Tribunal has not made any addition toward future prospects. The said
issue has been considered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in catena of
judgments and conveyed that the future prospects would mean
advancement in future career, earnings and progression in one's life. The
promotional avenues, career progression, grant of selection grades, etc.
are some of the features for considering one's future prospects.
Harmonizing the said connotation with the objective of the
compensation granted under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 leads to a
possible conclusion that the pecuniary loss can be ascertained by
balancing the loss caused to the claimant’s future pecuniary benefit and
the pecuniary advantage coming from whatever source on account of the
death, in other words, the balance between the extent of loss caused due
to the death and the support by way of compensation to the family
members of the deceased.
25. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Syed Basheer Ahamed &
Others versus Mohammed Jameel & Another reported in (2009) 2
SCC 225 has been pleased to observe that section 168 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988; enjoins the Learned Tribunal to make an award
determining “the amount of compensation which appears to be just.”
However, the objective factors, which may constitute the basis of
compensation appearing as ‘just’, have not been indicated in the Motor
Vehicles Act. Thus, the expression “which appears to be just” bestows a
wide discretion upon the Learned Tribunal in the matter of determination
of compensation. For a ready reference Section 168 of the Act of 1988 is
reproduced herein below:

15
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
“168. Award of the Claims Tribunal. —(1) On receipt of an
application for compensation made under section 166, the Claims
Tribunal shall, after giving notice of the application to the insurer
and after giving the parties (including the insurer) an opportunity of
being heard, hold an inquiry into the claim or, as the case may be,
each of the claims and, subject to the provisions of section 162 may
make an award determining the amount of compensation which
appears to it to be just and specifying the person or persons to whom
compensation shall be paid and in making the award the Claims
Tribunal shall specify the amount which shall be paid by the insurer
or owner or driver of the vehicle involved in the accident or by all or
any of them, as the case may be: Provided that where such
application makes a claim for compensation under section 140 in
respect of the death or permanent disablement of any person, such
claim and any other claim (whether made in such application or
otherwise) for compensation in respect of such death or permanent
disablement shall be disposed of in accordance with the provisions of
Chapter X.
(2) The Claims Tribunal shall arrange to deliver copies of the award
to the parties concerned expeditiously and in any case within a
period of fifteen days from the date of the award.
(3) When an award is made under this section, the person who is
required to pay any amount in terms of such award shall, within
thirty days of the date of announcing the award by the Claims
Tribunal, deposit the entire amount awarded in such manner as the
Claims Tribunal may direct.”
(emphasis supplied by this Court)
26. Section 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 provides power to the
Learned Tribunal to grant ‘just compensation’ to the claimants.
However, the word ‘just’ is of a very wide amplitude and requires
consideration on the case-to-case basis, in a manner which meets the
object of the Motor Vehicles Act.
27. Further, the Learned Tribunal constituted under the Act, while
passing an award determines the amount of compensation, which must
be just and reasonable. Although, this Court is mindful of the fact that
compensation for loss of limbs or life can hardly be weighed in golden
scales. But at the same time, it must be borne in mind that the
compensation is not expected to be a windfall for the victim. The object
of providing compensation is to financially place the claimant as far as
possible in the same position as he was before the accident. Broadly
speaking, in the case of death, the basis of compensation is loss of
pecuniary benefits to the dependents of the deceased which includes
pecuniary loss, expenses etc. The object to award compensation is to

16
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
mitigate hardship that has been caused to the legal representatives due to
the sudden demise of the deceased in the accident. Therefore,
compensation awarded should not be inadequate and should neither be
unreasonable, excessive, nor deficient.
28. The aforesaid view is further strengthened by the judgment passed
by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Divisional Controller,
KSRTC versus Mahadeva Shetty & Another reported in (2003) 7
SCC 197 wherein the Hon’ble Court while interpreting the meaning of
compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act, held that the compensation
awarded in the case of motor vehicle accident should not be inadequate
and should neither be unreasonable, excessive, nor deficient. For a ready
reference, paragraph 10 and 12 of the said judgment is reproduced
hereinbelow,
“10. ….. Compensation is an act which a court orders to be done, or
money which a court orders to be paid, by a person whose acts or
omissions have caused loss or injury to another in order that thereby
the person damnified may receive equal value for his loss; or be
made whole in respect of his injury; something given or obtained as
an equivalent; rendering of equivalent in value or amount………..
12. ….. . Justice requires that it should be equal in value, although
not alike in kind. The object of providing compensation is to place
the claimant as far as possible in the same position financially as he
was before the accident. Broadly speaking, in the case of death the
basis of compensation is loss of pecuniary benefits to the dependants
of the deceased which includes pecuniary loss, expenses etc. and loss
to the estate. The object is to mitigate hardship that has been caused
to the legal representatives due to the sudden demise of the deceased
in the accident. Compensation awarded should not be inadequate and
should neither be unreasonable, excessive, nor deficient….”
(emphasis supplied by this Court)
29. The Honble Supreme Court while deciding the case of Bhakra Beas
Management Board v. Kanta Aggarwal and Others reported in
(2008) 11 SCC 366 has observed as under:
“13. Learned counsel for the respondent supported the judgment and
additionally submitted that appeal of Respondent 1 is pending. In
normal course, when two appeals are directed against the common
judgment, both the appeals should be heard by the same Bench of the
High Court. But we find that the High Court had lost sight of the fact
that the benefits which the claimant receives on account of the death
or injury have to be duly considered while fixing the compensation.
It is pointed out that Respondent 1 was getting Rs 4700 p.m. and a
residence has been provided to her and actually the compassionate
appointment was given immediately after the accident.”

17
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
(emphasis supplied by this Court)
30. Similarly, in the case of Gobald Motor Service Ltd. And another
v. R.M.K. Veluswami and others reported in (1962) 1 SCR 929 , the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has been pleased to observe as follows:
"7. "The general rule which has always prevailed in regard to the
assessment of damages under the Fatal Accidents Acts is well
settled, namely, that any benefit accruing to a dependant by reason of
the relevant death must be taken into account. Under those Acts the
balance of loss and gain to a dependant by the death must be
ascertained, the position of each dependant being considered
separately: "
31. As has been discussed in the preceding paragraphs, it is well settled
in law that compassionate appointments are given to heir of the deceased
so that they may be able to maintain the family of the deceased. It is
trite in law that compassionate appointment is an exception to the
general rule of appointment in the public services and is in favour of the
dependents of a deceased dying in harness and leaving his family in
penury and without any means of livelihood, and in such cases, out of
pure humanitarian consideration taking into account the fact that unless
some source of livelihood is provided , the family would not be able to
make both ends meet, a provision is made in the rules to provide gainful
employment to one of the dependents who may be eligible for such
employment. The whole object of granting compassionate appointments
is, thus, to enable the family to tide over the sudden crisis. At the same
time, its effect on the determination of compensation also requires
consideration. In the present case, the son(s) of the deceased(s) have
been given compassionate appointments. In this manner, the deceased’s
son(s) have stepped into the shoes of their deceased father(s) to the
extent of securing the future prospects. Therefore, the present case where
the son(s) of the deceased(s) are given compassionate appointment is
distinguishable from the facts and circumstances of the case of Pranay
Sethi (supra), to this extent. It may be noted that in the case of Pranay
Sethi (supra), the dependants were not given employment under the
dying in harness scheme and were not benefitted by the compassionate
appointment.

18
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
32. Taking into consideration the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court on the issue of ‘just compensation’ and the scope and ambit of
Section 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, this Court is of the
considered opinion that no addition towards future prospects is required
to be granted in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present case.
Moreover, since the claimants deceased’s son(s) are earning monthly
salary on revised pay scale, this Court is of the considered opinion that
Learned Tribunal was right in not taking into consideration the addition
toward the future prospects looking to the facts and circumstances of the
present case. Therefore, in view of what has been narrated herein above
any addition towards future prospects would not subserve the principle
of ‘just compensation’ and may result in awarding compensation beyond
what can be termed fair, reasonable and equitable.
33. Now coming the other issue raised by the claimants is with regard to
the percentage of the deduction of the deceased's income toward the
personal and living expenses. The said issue has been dealt with in detail
by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Sarla Verma (supra). The
said judgment has been upheld by the Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of National Insurance Company Ltd.
versus Pranay Sethi and Others, reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680, and,
later on, followed in the case of United India Insurance Company Ltd.
versus Satinder Kaur alias Satwinder Kaur and others, reported in
2020 SCC OnLine SC 410 . Accordingly, it would be apt to quote the
relevant portion of the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of Sarla Verma (supra), wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court
was pleased to hold that:
"30. Though in some cases the deduction to be made towards
personal and living expenses is calculated on the basis of units
indicated in Trilok Chandra [(1996) 4 SCC 362], the general practice
is to apply standardised deductions. Having considered several
subsequent decisions of this Court, we are of the view that where the
deceased was married, the deduction towards personal and living
expenses of the deceased, should be one-third (1/3rd) where the
number of dependent family members is 2 to 3, one-fourth (1/4th)
where the number of dependent family members is 4 to 6, and one-
fifth (1/5th) where the number of dependent family members exceeds
six."

19
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
(emphasis supplied by this Court)
34. In the light of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the
case of Sarla Verma (supra), this Court is of the opinion that in the
present case the Learned Tribunal erred in deducting 1/3rd of the annual
income of the deceased's income towards personal and living expenses
whereas the deceased Nagendra Pratap Singh (Claim Petition No. 48 of
2007) had left behind seven (7) dependents while the deceased Surendra
Pratap Singh (Claim Petition No. 49 of 2007) left behind six (6)
dependents. Therefore, it would be lawful to hold that the said deduction
should have been only 1/5th in the facts of Claim Petition No. 48 of
2007 and 1/4th in the case of Claim Petition No. 49 of 2007 .
35. On the issue regrading the calculations of damages, loss of
consortium under the conventional heads has been dealt with in detail by
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of National Insurance
Company Ltd. versus Pranay Sethi and Others reported in (2017) 16
SCC 680 and subsequently in Magma General Insurance Company
Ltd. versus Nanu Ram and others, reported in (2018) 18 SCC 130. In
the case of Pranay Sethi (supra), the Hon'ble Apex Court has observed
that the amount under the conventional head needs to be appositely
determined and thereby the Hon'ble Apex Court revisited the practice of
awarding compensation under conventional heads. For ready reference,
Paragraph 52 of the judgment passed in the case of Pranay Sethi (supra)
is reproduced herein-below,
"52. As far as the conventional heads are concerned, we find it
difficult to agree with the view expressed in Rajesh[Rajesh v.
Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9 SCC 54 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3
SCC (Cri) 817 : (2014) 1 SCC (L&S) 149] . It has granted Rs 25,000
towards funeral expenses, Rs 1,00,000 towards loss of consortium
and Rs 1,00,000 towards loss of care and guidance for minor
children. The head relating to loss of care and minor children does
not exist. Though Rajesh [Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh, (2013) 9 SCC 54 :
(2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC (Cri) 817 : (2014) 1 SCC
(L&S) 149] refers to Santosh Devi [Santosh Devi v. National
Insurance Co. Ltd., (2012) 6 SCC 421 : (2012) 3 SCC (Civ) 726 :
(2012) 3 SCC (Cri) 160 : (2012) 2 SCC (L&S) 167] , it does not
seem to follow the same. The conventional and traditional heads,
needless to say, cannot be determined on percentage basis because
that would not be an acceptable criterion. Unlike determination of
income, the said heads have to be quantified. Any quantification
must have a reasonable foundation. There can be no dispute over the

20
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
fact that price index, fall in bank interest, escalation of rates in many
a field have to be noticed. The court cannot remain oblivious to the
same. There has been a thumb rule in this aspect. Otherwise, there
will be extreme difficulty in determination of the same and unless the
thumb rule is applied, there will be immense variation lacking any
kind of consistency as a consequence of which, the orders passed by
the tribunals and courts are likely to be unguided. Therefore, we
think it seemly to fix reasonable sums. It seems to us that reasonable
figures on conventional heads, namely, loss of estate, loss of
consortium and funeral expenses should be Rs 15,000, Rs 40,000 and
Rs 15,000 respectively. The principle of revisiting the said heads is
an acceptable principle. But the revisit should not be fact-centric or
quantum-centric. We think that it would be condign that the amount
that we have quantified should be enhanced on percentage basis in
every three years and the enhancement should be at the rate of 10%
in a span of three years. We are disposed to hold so because that will
bring in consistency in respect of those heads."
(emphasis supplied by this Court)
36. Subsequently, the principles governing award of compensation under
conventional heads with regard to award for loss of consortium, have
been crystallized by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Nanu
Ram (supra) . For a ready reference, Paragraph 21 of Magma General
Insurance Company Ltd. versus Nanu Ram and others: (2018) 18 SCC
130 is reproduced herein below,
"21. … In legal parlance, "consortium" is a compendious term which
encompasses "spousal consortium", "parental consortium", and "filial
consortium". The right to consortium would include the company,
care, help, comfort, guidance, solace and affection of the deceased,
which is a loss to his family. With respect to a spouse, it would
include sexual relations with the deceased spouse: [Rajesh v. Rajbir
Singh, (2013) 9 SCC 54 : (2013) 4 SCC (Civ) 179 : (2013) 3 SCC
(Cri) 817 : (2014) 1 SCC (L&S) 149]
21.1. Spousal consortium is generally defined as rights pertaining to
the relationship of a husband-wife which allows compensation to the
surviving spouse for loss of "company, society, cooperation,
affection, and aid of the other in every conjugal relation". [Black's
Law Dictionary (5th Edn., 1979).]
21.2. Parental consortium is granted to the child upon the premature
death of a parent, for loss of "parental aid, protection, affection,
society, discipline, guidance and training".
…
22. Consortium is a special prism reflecting changing norms about
the status and worth of actual relationships. ...
23. The Motor Vehicles Act is a beneficial legislation aimed at
providing relief to the victims or their families, in cases of genuine
claims. … Parental consortium is awarded to children who lose their
parents in motor vehicle accidents under the Act. A few High Courts
have awarded compensation on this count [Rajasthan High Court in
Jagmala Ram v. Sohi Ram, 2017 SCC OnLine Raj 3848 : (2017) 4
RLW 3368; Uttarakhand High Court in Rita Rana v. Pradeep Kumar,

21
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
2013 SCC OnLine Utt 2435 : (2014) 3 UC 1687; Karnataka High
Court in Lakshman v. Susheela Chand Choudhary, 1996 SCC
OnLine Kar 74 : (1996) 3 Kant LJ 570]. However, there was no
clarity with respect to the principles on which compensation could be
awarded on loss of filial consortium.
24. The amount of compensation to be awarded as consortium will
be governed by the principles of awarding compensation under "loss
of consortium" as laid down in Pranay Sethi [National Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680 : (2018) 3 SCC (Civ) 248 :
(2018) 2 SCC (Cri) 205].”
(emphasis supplied by this Court)
37. Now, as the principles regarding the calculation of damages, loss of
consortium and the multiplier under the conventional head of the Second
Schedule appended with the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 are well settled
and have been encapsulated above, the same can be applied in the facts
of the present case. As far as the conventional heads are concerned,
namely loss of consortium, loss of estate, and funeral expenses; this
Court is of the opinion that in the light of the principles enshrined by the
Hon'ble Apex Court as discussed hereinabove, for ensuring consistency
and fairness in compensation, it is appropriate to enhance the amount
falling under the Conventional Heads to Rs. 40,000/- to each claimant
for loss of consortium, Rs. 15,000/- for loss of estate, and Rs. 15,000/-
for funeral expenses.
38. On the issue of application of multiplier, based on the age bracket of
the deceased, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Sarla Verma
(supra) has laid down the categorical table. The said table regarding the
application of multiplier, based on the age bracket of the deceased, has
been affirmed by the Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of Pranay Sethi (supra). Subsequently, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of United India Insurance Co. Ltd. versus Satinder
Kaur alias Satwinder Kaur reported in 2021 11 SCC 780 has been
pleased to hold as under:
" (b) Determination of Multiplier
41 . With respect to the multiplier, the Court in Sarla Verma
(supra), prepared a chart for fixing the applicable multiplier
in accordance with the age of the deceased, after considering
the judgments in General Manager, Kerala S.R.T.C.,
Trivandrum v. Susamma Thomas, (1994) 2 SCC 176,

22
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
U.P.S.R.T.C. v. Trilok Chandra, (1996) 4 SCC 362 and New
India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Charlie, (2005) 10 SCC 720.
42 . The relevant extract from the said chart i.e. Column 4
has been set out hereinbelow for ready reference:--
Age of the deceased Multiplier (Column 4)
Upto 15 years -
15 to 20 years 18
21 to 25 years 18
26 to 30 years 17
31 to 35 years 16
36 to 40 years 15
41 to 45 years 14
46 to 50 years 13
51 to 55 years 11
56 to 60 years 9
61 to 65 years 7
Above 65 years 5
…
44 . In Reshma Kumari (supra), this Court affirmed Column
4 of the chart prepared in Sarla Verma (supra), and held
that this would provide uniformity and consistency in
determining the multiplier to be applied. The Constitution
Bench in Pranay Sethi (supra) affirmed the chart fixing the
multiplier as expounded in Sarla Verma (supra), and
held:--
"44. At this stage, we must immediately say that
insofar as the aforesaid multiplicand/multiplier is
concerned, it has to be accepted on the basis of
income established by the legal representatives of
the deceased. Future prospects are to be added to the
sum on the percentage basis and "income" means
actual income less than the tax paid. The multiplier
has already been fixed in Sarla Verma which has
been approved in Reshma Kumari with which we
concur.
...
59.6. The selection of multiplier shall be as indicated in the
Table in Sarla Verma read with paragraph 42 of that
judgment.”
emphasis supplied
( )

23
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
39. As is evident from the impugned judgment and award dated
13.03.2012 the deceased Nagendra Pratap Singh was of 39 years and
Surendra Pratap Singh was of 56 years of age, their cases would fall in
the age brackets of 36-40 years and 56-60 years, respectively, for which
multipliers of fifteen (15) and nine (9) are prescribed as per the above
quoted judgments. However, the Learned Tribunal has fixed the
multipliers of sixteen (16) and eight (8) respectively, having adopted the
multipliers as per the Schedule-II appended to the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988. However, the Learned Tribunal failed to adhere to the principle
laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Pranay Sethi
( supra ) holding therein that the appropriate multiplier to apply would be
by reference to the table in Paragraph No. 42 of the decision in Sarla
Verma (supra). Therefore, the multipliers applied by the Learned
Tribunal are incorrect and the correct multipliers in the present case will
be fifteen (15) and nine (9).
40. In view of the findings recorded by this Court and in the light of the
law as discussed herein above, the judgment and award dated 13.03.2012
passed by the Learned Tribunal deserves to be modified to ensure the
grant of ‘just compensation’. From the facts and figures emerged from
the records as is available before this court, the compensation is
recalculated in the following manner:
A. Calculation for Nagendra Pratap Singh (C.P. No. 48 of 2007 /
FAFO No. 871 of 2014)
Award by
Learned
Tribunal
Enhanced
Award by
this Court
S.
Head
No.
After taking into
consideration the revised
salary admissible to the
deceased as per VI th. Pay
Commission which was
made operational with effect
from 01.01.2006
Rs.
6,533/-
per month
Monthly
(i)
Income
Rs. 8,786/-
per month
Rs.
1,05,432/-
(8,786 × 12)
Annual
(ii)
Income
Rs.
78,396/-
Based on revised salary
(iii) Deduction
towards
Personal
1/3rd
deducted
1/5th
deducted
Deceased left behind 7
dependents. Deductions
made in the light of the

24
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
judgment of Sarla Verma
(supra) and; Pranay
Sethi(supra)
Expenses
Annual
Dependency
after
deduction for
personal and
living
expense.
Annual Income minus
Deduction towards Personal
Expenses
Rs.
Rs. 84,346/-
52,264/-
(iv)
1,05,432 – 21,086 = 84,346
Age of deceased: 39 years;
applicable multiplier: 15
Pranay Sethi (supra)
Multiplier
(v) 16 15
Applied
Rs.
12,65,190/-
(84,346 ×
15)
Loss of
(vi)
Dependency
Recomputed as per
multiplier
Consortium @ Rs. 40,000 ×
7 dependents = Rs.
2,80,000/- + Rs. 15,000/-
loss of estate + Rs. 15,000/-
funeral expenses. Pranay
Sethi (supra); Nanu Ram
(supra)
Conventional
(vii)
Heads
Rs.
6,000/-
Rs.
3,10,000/-
Total
(viii)
Compensation
Rs.
8,42,224/-
Rs.
15,75,190/-
Just compensation
B. Calculation for Surendra Pratap Singh (C.P. No. 49 of 2007 /
FAFO No. 24 of 2016)
Award by
Learned
Tribunal
Enhanced
Award by
this Court
S.
Head
No.
After taking into
consideration the revised
salary admissible to the
deceased as per VI th. Pay
Commission which was
made operational with effect
from 01.01.2006
Lower
unrevised
pay scale
considered
Monthly
(i)
Income
Rs. 10,770/-
per month
Rs.
1,29,240/-
(10,770 ×
12)
Annual
(ii) —
Income
Based on revised salary.
Deceased left behind 6
dependents. Deductions
made in the light of the
judgment of Sarla Verma
(supra) and; Pranay Sethi
(supra)
(iv) Annual
Dependency
after
deduction for
personal and
living
Deduction
towards
Personal
Expenses
1/3rd
deducted
1/4th
deducted
(iii)
— Rs. 96,930/- Annual Income minus
Deduction towards Personal
Expenses
1,29,240 – 32,310 = 96,930

25
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
expense.
Age of deceased: 56 years;
applicable multiplier: 9
Pranay Sethi (supra)
Multiplier
(v) 8 9
Applied
Rs.
8,72,370/-
(96,930 × 9)
Loss of
(vi) —
Dependency
Recomputed as per settled
multiplier.
Consortium @ Rs. 40,000 ×
6 dependents = Rs.
2,40,000/- + Rs. 15,000/-
loss of estate + Rs. 15,000/-
funeral expenses. Pranay
Sethi (Supra); Nanu Ram
(supra)
Conventional
(vii)
Heads
Rs.
6,000/-
Rs.
2,70,000/-
Total
(viii)
Compensation
Rs.
5,23,312/-
Rs.
‘Just compensation’
11,42,370/-
41. In light of all that has been discussed herein above, the judgment and
award dated 13.03.2012 passed by the Learned Tribunal in Claim
Petition No. 48 of 2007 is modified and the compensation awarded is
enhanced to a total amount of Rs. 15,75,190/- (Rupees Fifteen Lacs
Seventy Five Thousand One Hundred Ninety only). Similarly, the
judgment and award dated 13.03.2012 passed in Claim Petition No. 49
of 2007 is modified and enhanced to a total amount of Rs. 11,42,370/-
(Rupees Eleven Lacs Forty Two Thousand Three Hundred Seventy
only).
42. The total compensation in both cases shall carry simple interest at the
rate of 7% per annum from the date of institution of the respective Claim
Petitions until realization of the said amount. However, any sum of
money already deposited (paid or invested in terms of the judgment and
award dated 13.03.2012 or interim orders of this Court) shall be
accordingly adjusted.
43. It is provided that the New India Assurance Company Ltd would be
entitled to recover the enhanced amount of compensation to be paid by
it, from owner of the offending vehicle involved in the accident.
Therefore both the appeals preferred by the claimants, being FAFO No.
871 of 2014 and FAFO No. 24 of 2016 are partly allowed whereas, the
appeals preferred by the Insurance Company, being FAFO No. 1133 of
2012 and FAFO No. 1135 of 2012, are disposed of accordingly. The

26
FAFO No. - 871 of 2014
impugned judgment and award dated 13.03.2012 is hereby modified
accordingly. There shall be no order as to costs.
44. The original records of the Claim Petitions be transmitted back to the
Tribunal concerned at the earliest.
(Syed Qamar Hasan Rizvi, J.)
May 22, 2026
Manoj K.
--\
Digitally signed by :-
MANOJ KUMAR
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad,
Lucknow Bench