Pushpendra Kumar vs Delhi Police & Anr.
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$~23
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
# CNR No. DLHC010528862026
+ W.P.(C) 16238/2026, CM APPLs. 76090/2026, 76091/2026,
76092/2026 & 79656/2026
PUSHPENDRA KUMAR .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Purushottam Sharma
Tripathi, Ms. Vani Vyas and Mr. Ravi
Chandra Prakash, Advs.
versus
DELHI POLICE & ANR. .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Rajesh Kumar, CGSPC
with Mr. Abhishek Kumar Singh, Adv. for
UOI
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
% 20.11.2026
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1. The petitioner participated in a selection for the post of
Constable (Executive) in the Delhi Police. The written test was held in
four separate sets in which the same questions, apparently, were
rearranged so as to ensure that unfair means were not adopted.
2. Mr. Purushottam Sharma Tripathi, learned Counsel for the
petitioner points out that the entire examination had to be cancelled
twice and that it was finally held a third time. The petitioner
participated in all three rounds of the examination. However, as the
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:02:32
W.P.(C) 16238/2026 Page 1 of 8
first two rounds of the examination were cancelled, they need not
detain us.
3. Consequent to the third examination, a provisional merit list of
candidates who had cleared the examination was declared on 13 July
2015. The petitioner was shown as successful in the said provisional
merit list.
4. However, as candidates who were over six feet in height were
entitled to one additional mark, a second provisional merit list was
announced on 17 July 2015 after awarding the said additional mark.
5. Mr. Tripathi acknowledges that his client was not more than six
feet in height and was not, therefore, entitled to the said additional one
mark.
6. In the second provisional merit list, after grant of one additional
mark to candidates over six feet in height, the cut-off was fixed at
71.290. The petitioner scored 71.264 marks and, therefore, could not
make the cut-off.
7. The petitioner, as well as certain other candidates, at this stage,
1
approached the Central Administrative Tribunal by way of OA
3657/2015, in which it was sought to be contended that the answer
keys in respect of eight questions were incorrect on various grounds.
The eight questions viz. Question Nos.17, 55, 56, 71, 75, 79, 86 and
1
“the Tribunal” hereinafter
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:02:32
W.P.(C) 16238/2026 Page 2 of 8
90 in set C, corresponded to questions in set D, too, which was the set
attempted by the petitioner.
8. The Tribunal, in its judgment dated 8 January 2016, noted the
concession, on the part of the Delhi Police, that there were certain
typographical errors in the question papers and that, therefore, an
Expert Committee had been constituted to examine the grievances of
the candidates. The Tribunal, therefore, disposed of the OA with a
direction to the Expert Committee to consider the grievances of the
petitioner and other candidates, and return a report within one month.
9. The Expert Committee, in its report in January 2016, found
merit in the challenge to the aforesaid eight questions and cancelled all
of them on various grounds, including erroneous answers, mismatch
between the English and Hindi versions and the like. The Committee
also cancelled 13 more questions on various grounds.
10. As a result, the score of the petitioner, as well as other
candidates, increased but, even after the said increase, the petitioner
could not make the cut-off.
11. The petitioner, at this stage, re-approached the Tribunal by way
of OA 2429/2016, now contending that, on the grounds on which the
Committee had deemed it appropriate to cancel the result with respect
to 21 questions, 10 more questions were liable to be cancelled.
12. The Tribunal dismissed the OA on the following reasoning:
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:02:32
W.P.(C) 16238/2026 Page 3 of 8
“5. The applicants have challenged the final select list dated
22.02.2016 on the ground that certain additional questions were
allegedly incorrect and that the applicants were entitled to
additional bonus marks. As the respondents did not extend the
benefit of all such discrepancies, the applicants were excluded
from the final select list for the post of Constable (Executive).
6. From a perusal of the record, it is evident that the
recruitment process underwent multiple stages of scrutiny. Initially,
the results were declared and subsequently revised to account for
the omission of height-based one bonus mark. Further, the material
on record clearly establishes that the respondents constituted an
Expert Committee to comprehensively examine all objections
relating to the answer key and question paper, pursuant to earlier
directions of this Tribunal.
7. The Expert Committee undertook a comprehensive review,
identified discrepancies and recommended appropriate remedial
measures, declaring 21 questions as null/void and awarding marks
uniformly to all candidates for such questions, and correcting
specific answer keys. Acting upon these recommendations, the
respondents re-evaluated the entire result by adopting a uniform
scaling method and awarded due benefit to all the candidates,
including the applicants. Consequently, a final result was declared
on 22.02.2016.
8. It is significant to note that the respondents have acted in
accordance with law, followed due process, and implemented the
recommendations of the Expert Committee fairly. The benefit of
corrected answers and void questions was extended uniformly to
all candidates through a scaling method, ensuring parity and
fairness. The revised evaluation resulted in an overall increase in
cut-off cut-off marks across categories and although some new
candidates entered the selection zone. The applicants, having failed
to secure marks above the prescribed cut-off even after such re-
evaluation, cannot claim inclusion in the select list, as a matter of
right.
9. It is not the case of the applicants that they were denied the
benefit of the corrections identified by the Expert Committee,
rather their contention is that more questions ought to have been
treated as incorrect. The applicants have not been able to
substantiate that additional questions beyond those identified by
the Expert Committee were demonstrably incorrect or that the
methodology adopted by the Committee was arbitrary or irrational.
Such plea, in the absence of any substantive material to discredit
the findings of the Expert Committee, cannot be accepted.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:02:32
W.P.(C) 16238/2026 Page 4 of 8
10. The scope of judicial review in such academic matters is
limited, particularly where an Expert Body has examined the issue,
and this Tribunal cannot substitute its own assessment for that of a
duly constituted expert body unless the decision is shown to be
mala fide, arbitrary or perverse.”
13. The Tribunal also placed reliance on an earlier judgment
2
rendered by it on 5 May 2016 in OA 969/2016 .
14. Aggrieved by the aforesaid dismissal of her OA, the petitioner
has now approached this Court by means of the present writ petition.
15. We have heard Mr. Purushottam Sharma Tripathi, learned
Counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Rajesh Kumar, learned CGSPC for
the respondents at some length.
16. While we must acknowledge that Mr. Tripathi has competently
and passionately espoused to the case of his client, we find it difficult
to grant relief to him.
17. Mr. Tripathi submits that the grounds on which the Expert
Committee decided to cancel 21 questions out of the 100 questions in
the examination would mutatis mutandis also justify cancellation of
the ten additional questions as prayed by his client in OA 2429/2016.
He contests the Tribunal’s finding that there was no material placed on
record to indicate that the additional questions were demonstrably
incorrect or that the methodology adopted by the Committee was
arbitrary or irrational. He requested the Court to examine the questions
themselves, with the submission that, if they were so examined, it
2
Sandeep Kumar v. Commission of Police
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:02:32
W.P.(C) 16238/2026 Page 5 of 8
would become clear that, in respect of several questions, there was a
mismatch between Hindi and English versions of the questions, which
was one of the considerations on the basis of which the Expert
Committee had cancelled some of the 21 questions.
18. Mr. Tripathi also draws our attention to various judicial
authorities which hold that, where merit is demonstrably apparent in
the challenge to the answer keys, the Court is empowered to examine
the matter. There is no absolute embargo on a Court examining a
challenge to the answer keys. As such, he submits that the Tribunal
abdicated its function in not doing so.
19. We are aware of the position, in law, that there is no absolute
embargo on a Court examining a challenge to the correctness of
answer keys in an examination. If the suggested answer is
demonstrably unacceptable – say, by way of an extreme example, if
the suggested answer for the sum of 2 and 2 is 5 – the Court can
certainly step in and grant relief.
20. Ordinarily, therefore, a Court would be justified in examining
the merit of the challenge when raised by an unsuccessful candidate in
the examination, albeit to a limited extent.
21. In the present case, however, the circumstances are somewhat
peculiar. The petitioner has bitten the cherry once, and, as the first
bite has failed to satiate him, now seeks a second bite.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:02:32
W.P.(C) 16238/2026 Page 6 of 8
22. The petitioner earlier approached the Tribunal by way of OA
3657/2015. At that instance, the petitioner had every opportunity to
raise a challenge to all the questions in respect of which, according to
the petitioner, the answer key was not acceptable or the questions
themselves were required to be deleted from the Questions paper. The
petitioner chose to restrict her challenge to 8 questions. The Tribunal,
therefore, directed the Expert Committee to examine the said
challenge and return a finding within one month. The Expert
Committee did so. Having done so, the Expert Committee cancelled
all the said 8 questions, apart from certain 13 other questions which
were found to be incorrect. The result of the petitioner, as a
consequence, improved.
23. Having failed, even after this, to reach the cut-off and secure
appointment, we cannot permit the petitioner to re-approach the
Tribunal with another fresh set of questions which according to the
petitioner, should have been cancelled or deleted. Such an attempt
would clearly be barred by the principle of constructive res judicata.
That apart, if such an attempt were to be accepted, there would be no
end to litigation, which would never attain finality. A precedent by us
in that regard would enable candidates to come again and again to the
Court, challenging different sets of answers each time, seeking a re-
visitation of the answer key. Each time, the Court would have to re-
examine the matter and, perhaps, re-constitute the Expert Committee
to once again look into the challenge.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:02:32
W.P.(C) 16238/2026 Page 7 of 8
24. That, to our mind, would be clearly unacceptable in law and
would set a precedent which, as we have already observed, could
result in the litigation never achieving quietus.
25. The Tribunal has correctly noted that there was no error pointed
out in the manner in which the Expert Committee had examined the
issue. The Expert Committee considered the challenge to all the eight
questions raised by the petitioner and found merit in them. That the
Expert Committee acted objectively is manifest from the fact that it
also cancelled the suggested answers for 13 more questions.
26. If the petitioner, despite this, was not able to make the cut-off
and secure appointment, we empathize with him, but are of the view
that no further remedy would be available to the petitioner in law.
27. In that view of the matter, for the aforesaid reasons, we concur
with the decision of the Tribunal to dismiss the OA.
28. We, therefore, find no merit in this present writ petition, which
is accordingly dismissed in limine .
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA, J.
NOVEMBER 20, 2026 /aky
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed By:AJIT
KUMAR
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:02:32
W.P.(C) 16238/2026 Page 8 of 8