DEBASIS PAL vs ANNAPURNA NANDI
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Revisional Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Hiranmay Bhattacharyya
C.O. No. 3786 of 2026
Debasis Pal
Versus
Annapurna Nandi
For the petitioner : Mr. Arup Krishna Das
Mr. Rajarshi Ghosh
For the respondent : Ms. Ritorita Ghosh
Heard on : 16.11.2026
Judgement on : 16.11.2026.
Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.:
1. This instant application under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India is at the instance of the defendant and is directed against
th
an order being No. 78 dated 24 September, 2026 passed by the
st
learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), 1 Court at Serampore,
Hooghly, in Title Suit no. 223 of 2022.
2. By the order impugned, an application under Order 6 Rule 17 of
the Code of Civil Procedure filed by the plaintiff/opposite party
herein stood allowed.
3. Mr. Das, learned advocate appearing for the petitioner submits
that the opposite party filed a suit for eviction on the grounds as
Page 1 of 9
contemplated under Section 6(1) of the West Bengal Premises
Tenancy Act, 1997 by treating the defendant being the present
petitioner as a tenant in respect of the suit property. He submits
that by the proposed amendment, the opposite party sought to
convert the suit for eviction filed under Rent Control
Legislation/Special Statute into a suit for eviction of a
trespasser under general law. He submits that an amendment of
plaint cannot be allowed if it results in changing the nature and
character of the suit. In support of such contention, Mr. Das,
learned advocate appearing for the petitioner relies upon a
judgment and order dated November 13, 2019 passed by the
coordinate Bench in C.O. 3022 of 2019 in the case of Samir
Kumar Kundu vs. Dipali Roy & Ors.
4. The learned advocate for the opposite party submits that during
the pendency of the instant suit, the five year time limit as
contemplated under section 2(g) of the West Bengal Premises
Tenancy Act, 1997, stood expired and upon expiry of the said
five year time limit, the plaintiff/opposite party filed the instant
application for amendment of plaint. She further submits that
the proposed amendments are necessary for the purpose of
deciding the real controversy between the parties in the instant
suit. She also distinguishes the decision in the case of Samir
(supra) on facts.
Kumar Kundu
Page 2 of 9
5. Heard the learned advocates for the parties and perused the
materials placed.
6. A complete copy of the plaint is handed over by the learned
advocate for the opposite party at the time of hearing of the civil
revision application, which is taken on record.
7. In paragraph 3 of the plaint it has been specifically stated that
the father of the present defendant was inducted by the
husband of the plaintiff as a monthly premises tenant in respect
of one shop room and the father of the defendant died around
the year 2018 and since then the defendant is in occupation of
A-1 schedule property which is lying vacant under lock and key
without having any authority.
8. In the written statement, more particularly in paragraph 11
thereof, the defendant has admitted the statements made by the
plaintiff in paragraph 3 of the plaint except the statement that
A-1 scheduled property is lying vacant under lock and key.
9. Thus, it is evident that the time of death of the father of the
defendant around the year 2018 has been admitted by the
defendant/petitioner.
10. The instant suit has been filed after the coming into force of
1997 Act. The suit was filed sometime in the year 2022 when
the time limit of five years was yet to expire. The suit was filed
against the present petitioner on the ground of default
inter alia
in payment of rent, reasonable requirement etc.
Page 3 of 9
11. Section 6 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997
affords protection to a tenant by stating that no order or decree
for recovery of possession of any premises shall be passed
except by way of a suit by the landlord on one or more of the
grounds specified in various clauses of the sub-section (1) of
Section 6. In other words, a tenant gets protection from eviction
until and unless the landlord is successful in proving the
grounds for eviction.
12. Section 7 of the 1997 Act casts an obligation upon the landlord
to make payment or deposit of rent in a suit filed under Section
6(1) in order to get the benefit of protection against eviction.
13. Both Sections 6 and 7 uses the expressions “landlord” and
“tenant’’. Thus, existence of landlord-tenant relationship is a
precondition for filing a suit under Section 6(1) of the 1997 Act.
14. Section 2(g) of the 1997 Act defines “tenant’’. Section 2(g) is
extracted hereinafter.
“Section 2(g) - "tenant" means any person by whom
or on whose account or behalf the rent of any premises is
or, but for a special contract, would be payable, and
includes any person continuing in possession after
termination of his tenancy and, in the event of death of any
tenant, also includes, for a period not exceeding five years
from the date of death of such tenant or from the date of
coming into force of this Act, whichever is later, his spouse,
son, daughter, parent and the widow of his predeceased
son, who were ordinarily living with the tenant up to the
date of death of the tenant as the members of his family
Page 4 of 9
and were dependent on him and who do not own or occupy
any residential premises, and [in respect of premises let out
for non-residential purpose his spouse, son, daughter and
parent who were ordinarily living with the tenant up to the
date of his death as members of his family, and were
dependant on him or a person authorised by the tenant
who is in possession of such premises] but shall not include
any person against whom any decree or order for eviction
has been made by a Court of competent jurisdiction:
Provided that the time-limit of five years shall not
apply to the spouse of the tenant who was ordinarily living
with the tenant up to his death as a member of his family
and was dependent on him and who does not own or
occupy any residential premises:
Provided further that the son, daughter parent or the
widow of the predeceased son of the tenant who was
ordinarily residing with the tenant in the said premises up
to the date of death of the tenant as a member of his family
and was dependent on him and who does not own or
occupy any residential premises, shall have a right of
preference for tenancy in a fresh agreement in respect of
such premises [on condition of payment of fair rent]. This
proviso shall apply mutatis mutandis to premises let out for
non-residential purpose.”
15. The definition of “tenant’’ under Section 2(g) includes any
person continuing in possession after termination of his tenancy
but excludes person against whom any decree or order of
eviction has been made by a Court of competent jurisdiction.
16. In the event of death of a tenant in respect of premises let out
for non-residential purposes, Section 2(g) allows certain persons
Page 5 of 9
to continue as tenant for a certain period. Such period shall not
exceed five years from the date of death of such tenant or from
the date of coming into force of the 1997 Act, whichever is later.
17. Thus, the son of a deceased tenant in respect of premises let out
for non-residential purpose can continue as a tenant for the
aforesaid specified period if the conditions mentioned in Section
2(g) are satisfied.
18. Proviso to Section 2(g) carves out an exception in case of spouse
of the tenant.
19. Upon a reading of Section 2(g) of the 1997 Act, this Court holds
that it provides for cessation of landlord-tenant relationship
between the landlord and the son of the tenant in respect of a
premises let out for non-residential purposes upon expiry of 5
years from the death of the tenant in case the original tenant
died after the commencement of the 1997 Act.
20. In the case on hand, the suit was filed under Section 6(1) of the
Act against the son of the deceased tenant in respect of a
premises let out for non-residential purpose prior to expiry of
the 5 years time limit.
21. The time of death of the original tenant is an admitted fact.
22. The application for amendment of plaint was filed to introduce
the fact of cessation of the landlord-tenant relationship between
the parties upon expiry of the 5 years time limit by operation of
law.
Page 6 of 9
23. In the event, there is change in the relationship between the
parties by operation of law and such change enures to the
benefit of a litigant, there cannot be any impediment to allow
such party to amend his pleadings to incorporate such fact
which took place during the pendency of the suit.
24. Protection afforded to the tenant under Sections 6 and 7 of the
1997 Act is dependant upon the existence of landlord-tenant
relationship. In the event, tenant loses his protection by
operation of law during the pendency of a suit for eviction under
Section 6(1) and such loss of protection enures to the benefit of
the party seeking eviction, the prayer for amendment of plaint to
incorporate the benefits of such loss of protection cannot be
refused on the ground that the proposed amendment would
take away the protection conferred upon the tenant under
Sections 6 and 7 of the 1997 Act. It is a case of loss of
protection of a tenant by operation of law, if any, and not taking
away such protection by way of amendment.
25. In view of the aforesaid discussions, this Court holds that the
amendment was sought for only to incorporate the fact of
change of status of the defendant by operation of law during the
pendency of the suit.
26. It is well-settled that subsequent events can be brought on
record by way of amendment of pleadings and in the instant
case, the subsequent event with regard to change of relationship
Page 7 of 9
between the parties to the suit by operation of law was sought to
be brought on record by way of amendment. The instant suit
was filed for eviction. The proposed amendment cannot be said
to change the nature and character of the said suit which even
after such amendment would remain a suit for eviction.
27. It is well settled that pleading is not a substitute for proof and
the plaintiff has to prove the statements incorporated by way of
amendment by adducing evidence.
28. In Samir Kumar Kundu (supra) the original tenant i.e. the
predecessor in interest of the defendant in that suit died in the
year 1972 i.e. prior to coming into force of 1997 Act, and it was
also pleaded in paragraph 13 of the written statement of the
said case that in 1972 the original landlord granted rent receipt
in favour of the defendant therein.
29. On such facts, the coordinate Bench held that the amendment
in question would entirely displace the defence case and
amount to withdrawal of admission of tenancy. In the case on
hand, there was no such admitted tenancy and the plaintiff only
sought to take the benefit of the change of relationship between
the parties as per the definition of the expression “tenant” under
section 2(g) of the 1997 Act. The learned judge was right in
allowing the application for amendment of plaint.
30. This Court is not inclined to interfere with the order impugned.
Page 8 of 9
31. C.O. 3786 of 2026 stands dismissed. However, there shall be no
order as to costs.
32. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance of all requisite
formalities.
(Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.)
Page 9 of 9