Ramanand And Ors vs Ram Kumar And Ors

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010

Rama Nand and others ...Applicants-Appellants
Versus
Ram Kumar and others ...Respondents
Date when judgment was reserved 12.10.2026
Date when judgment was pronounced 20.11.2026
Date of uploading judgment 20.11.2026
Whether operative part or full judgment is Full
pronounced
Delay, if any, in pronouncing of full judgment, NA
and reasons thereof
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRAVINDRA SINGH CHAUHAN
Present Mr. Sanjay Kaushal, Senior Advocate,
assisted by Mr. A.P.Setia, Advocate,
for review-applicant/appellant no.3.
Mr. Aman Bahri, Senior Advocate
assisted by Mr. Ritik Gupta, Advocate and
Ms. Anjali, Advocate, for respondent no.1.
Mr. Gagandeep Rana, Advocate,
for respondent no.2.
*
PRAVINDRA SINGH CHAUHAN, J.
CM-1562-C-2021
The present application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 2
has been filed for condonation of 167 days delay in filing the review
application.
Learned counsel for the applicant-appellant no.3 submits that
the litigation was being pursued by the applicant's elder brother i.e appellant
No.1, but with the passage of time differences arose amongst the brothers
concerning their joint properties and the applicant/appellant no.3 was not
informed about the disposal of the appeal. Subsequently, his son learnt about
the decision in September 2020, whereafter the relevant record was collected
and steps were taken to file the review application. Reference has also been
made to the difficulties faced during the COVID-19 pandemic.
After hearing learned counsel for the applicant and for the
reasons mentioned in the application, which is supported by an affidavit,
application for condonation of delay is allowed and delay of 167 days in
filing the present review application is condoned.
CM-1562-C-2021 stands disposed of.
RA-RS-12-2021
1. Applicant-appellant No.3, namely, Gajraj Singh, through
General Power of Attorney Dinesh Yadav seeks review/recall of the
judgment dated 26.09.2019 (Annexure A/1) whereby RSA-705-2010 was
dismissed by the then Co-ordinate Bench. The review application has been
taken up for consideration on merits. The Regular Second Appeal arose
against concurrent findings whereby a suit filed by the plaintiff-respondents
for declaration of ownership on the basis of adverse possession, with
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 3
consequential relief of permanent injunction was decreed by the learned trial
Court on 16.12.2002 and the appeal preferred by the defendant-appellants
no.1 to 3 was dismissed on 25.09.2009 by the learned First Appellate Court.
At the time of issuance of notice of motion vide order dated 30.08.2010, the
contention raised on their behalf was that plaintiff/respondents could not
maintain a suit claiming ownership on the basis of adverse possession. The
said order is reproduced here as under:
"Ld Counsel appearing for the appellants
contends that suit of the plaintiff/respondents for
declaration of the ownership to suit property on
the basis of adverse possession is not
maintainable.
Notice of Motion for 26.10.2010
In the meantime, respondents are restrained
from alienating the suit land.
Records."
2. A perusal of subsequent proceedings reveal that the question
whether adverse possession could be invoked as a basis of relief, or merely a
defence, had direct bearing on the adjudication of the appeal. As the said
question was pending consideration before Hon'ble the Supreme Court in
another matter. Learned counsel for the parties were ad idem that the hearing
of the appeal be deferred to await its outcome. The order dated 05.12.2014,
as reproduced in para no.7 in the review application, reads as under:
"Present: Mr.JK Sibal, Sr Advocate, with
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 4
Mr. Dhadwal Bhandari, Advocate,
for the appellants.
Sarvshri SK Sehajpal and R Rana,
Advocates, for the respondents.
Learned counsel for the respondents, at the outset,
has drawn my attention to order dated 10.11.2014,
passed by Hon'ble the Supreme Court of India in Special
Leave to Appeal CC Nos. 17445/2014 (Gurucharan
Singh Since Deceased through LRs and others vs.
Gursharan Singh Since Deceased through LRs and
another), which reads as thus:
Delay condoned.
The learned counsel for the petitioner very fairly
draws our attention to the recent decision in Gurudwara
Sahib vs. Gram Panchayat Village Sirthala & Anr.
reported in 2014(1) SCC 669. The question is whether
the adverse possession is available in the form for "shield
or sword". Issue notice.
However, on a glance of the said decision, it
appears that the previous judgments in P.T.
Munichikkanna Reddy & Ors. vs. Revamma & Ors.
reported in 2001(2) SCS 498 have not been considered.
Status-quo as regards possession shall be maintained, in
the meantime.
I am informed that though the matter is still sub
judice, but no date has yet been notified.
As the decision in the aforesaid matter would have
bearing on the matter in issue in the case in hand,
counsel for the parties are ad-idem that let the matter be
adjourned to await the decision of Hon'ble the Supreme
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 5
Court, in the aforesaid matter.
Adjourned to 10.03.2015."
3. The applicant has placed on record order dated 06.03.2017
(Annexure A-2) passed by Hon'ble the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal
No.3756 of 2017,which reads as under:
"Leave granted.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and
have gone through the decision rendered by the trial
court. It appears to us that a substantial question of law
has arisen namely whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a
declaration of ownership of the property in dispute on the
basis of sale deed dated 24 Baisakh 1995 Vikram Samvat
in their favour.
In view of the above, we set aside the order passed
by the High Court and request the High Court to
consider this question along with the substantial question
framed earlier by the High Court namely whether the suit
filed by the plaintiffs declaring them to be owners of the
property in dispute on the basis of adverse possession is
maintainable.
The appeal stands disposed of.
All contentions made by both the parties are left
open for consideration.”
4. Following the subsequent disposal of the aforesaid
proceedings, the present appeal was directed to be listed for hearing. The
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 6
order dated 30.05.2019, as reproduced in para no. 10 of the review
application, reads as under:
"The List of Citations under proper index is filed
on behalf of the Respondents.
Perusal of the third Judgement dated 6th March,
2017 goes to show that Civil Appeal No. 3756 of 2017
was disposed off by the Hon’ble Supreme Court by way
of setting aside the earlier judgment of this Court and
remanded the matter back to this Court for a decision on
the substantial question framed earlier regarding
maintainability of the Suit. Thereafter, the said Appeal
was finally disposed off by a Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court on 20th March, 2019, vide which the substantial
question of law was answered in favour of the Appellant/
Defendant and against the Respondents/Plaintiffs, on
account of which, the Judgements of both the Ld.
Courts below were set aside.
Consequently, there is no need to await any further
decision of Hon'ble Apex Court, in terms of the earlier
Orders dated 5th December, 2014 and 10th March, 2015,
and the present Appeal has, therefore, to be decided on
its own merits regarding the legality and validity of the
Decree in favour of the Respondents, which was affirmed
by the Ld. Appellate Court, and in which the issue
regarding maintainability of the Suit was decided in
favour of the Plaintiffs.
To come up on 11th September, 2019 for hearing."
5. Before the appeal was finally heard, a three-Judges Bench of
Hon'ble the Supreme Court, in Ravinder Kaur Grewal and others v.
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 7
Manjit Kaur and others, (2019) 8 SCC 729 , settled the controversy and
held that a plaintiff could maintain a suit on the basis of title acquired by
adverse possession. When the present appeal came up for hearing thereafter,
learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants himself brought this
decision to the notice of the then Co-ordinate Bench and submitted that the
appeal had been rendered infructuous, as the basis on which notice of
motion had been issued no longer survived. The judgment dated 26.09.2019,
sought to be reviewed, reads as under:
"At the outset, Ld. Counsel for the appellants
draws attention of this Court to the order, vide which
notice of motion was ordered to be issued on 30.08.2010
on the limited submission of the appellants that suit of the
plaintiff-respondents for declaration of ownership to the
suit property on the basis of the plea of adverse
possession is not maintainable.
Ld. Counsel for the appellants today draws
attention of the Court to the decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in 'Ravinder Kaur Grewal and others
Vs. Manjit Kaur and others, Civil Appeal No. 7764 of
2014', pronounced on 07.08.2019 , wherein it has been
held as under:-
'60. When we consider the law of adverse
possession as has developed vis-à-vis to property
dedicated to public use, courts have been loath to
confer the right by adverse possession. There are
instances when such properties are encroached
upon and then a plea of adverse possession is
raised. In Such cases, on the land reserved for
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 8
public utility, it is desirable that rights should not
accrue. The law of adverse possession may cause
harsh consequences, hence, we are constrained to
observe that it would be advisable that concerning
such properties dedicated to public cause, it is
made clear in the statute of limitation that no
rights can accrue by adverse possession.
61. Resultantly, we hold that decisions of
Gurudwara Sahab v. Gram Panchayat Village
Sirthala (supra) and decision relying on it in State
of Uttarakhand v. Mandir Shri Lakshmi Siddh
Maharaj (supra) and Dharampal (dead) through
LRs v. Punjab Wakf Board (supra) cannot be said
to be laying down the law correctly, thus they are
hereby overruled. We hold that plea of acquisition
of title by adverse possession can be taken by
plaintiff under Article 65 of the Limitation Act and
there is no bar under the Limitation Act, 1963 to
sue on aforesaid basis in case of infringement of
any rights of a plaintiff.'
As a consequence, Ld. Counsel for the
appellants submits in all fairness that as per the law laid
down by the Apex Court in the aforesaid judgment the
present appeal itself has been rendered infructuous since
the very basis on which notice was ordered to be issued,
has been cut at its roots.
In view of the aforesaid submission of law,
as declared by the Hon'ble Supreme Court clearly no
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 9
further merit remains in the present appeal and the same,
therefore, stands dismissed."
6. The applicant now contends that the applicant/appellant raised
other grounds against the judgments and decrees of the learned trial Court as
well as learned First Appellate Court, besides the question of maintainability.
It is submitted that the plaintiffs were required to prove the ingredients of
adverse possession and that their evidence ought to have been examined.
According to the applicant, these grounds were not urged on account of a
bona fide error on the part of counsel. Reliance is placed upon the order
dated 30.05.2019 as well as Section 100 CPC and Section 41 of the Punjab
Courts Act, 1918, to contend that the appeal was required to be considered
on merits and its scope could not be confined to the contention raised at the
stage of issuance of notice of motion.
7. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents have
opposed the prayer while submitting that the appeal was disposed of upon
the express submission made by learned Senior Counsel after the legal
controversy stood settled by Hon'ble the Supreme Court, and that the
applicant is seeking a fresh hearing without pointing out any error apparent
on the face of the record.
8. Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the
records.
9. The question in the present proceedings is whether the applicant
has established a ground for review under Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC. Review
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 10
is available where there is an error apparent on the face of the record,
discovery of new and important material which could not have been
produced earlier despite due diligence, or any other sufficient reason
recognised in law. It does not provide a further opportunity to argue an
appeal merely because some additional grounds could have been urged at
the time of original hearing. In Parsion Devi and others v. Sumitri Devi
and others, (1997) 8 SCC 715 , Hon’ble the Supreme Court in paragraph 9,
has observed as under:
"xxxx
A review petition, it must be remembered has a limited
purpose and cannot be allowed to be 'an appeal in
disguise.’
10. Also reference can be made to the judgment of Hon'ble the
Supreme Court in S. Murali Sundaram versus Jothibai Kannan, (2003) 13
SCC 515 . The relevant portion of the aforesaid judgment is reproduced as
under:-
“16. While considering the aforesaid issue two decisions of
this Court on Order 47 Rule 1 read with Section 114 CPC are
required to be referred to? In Perry Kansagra this Court has
observed that while exercising the review jurisdiction in an
application under Order 47 Rule 1 read with Section 114
CPC, the Review Court does not sit in appeal over its own
order. It is observed that a rehearing of the matter is
impermissible in law. It is further observed that review is not
appeal in disguise. It is observed that power of review can be
exercised for correction of a mistake but not to substitute a
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 11
view. Such powers can be exercised within the limits of the
statute dealing with the exercise of power. It is further
observed that it is wholly unjustified and exhibits a tendency
to rewrite a judgment by which the controversy has been
finally decided.
17. After considering a catena of decisions on exercise of
review powers and principles relating to exercise of review
jurisdiction under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC this Court had
summed up as under: (Perry Kansagra case, SCC pp. 768-
69, para 15.1.
"15.1. '33...."... (i) Review proceedings are not by way
of appeal and have to be strictly confined to the scope and
ambit of Order 47 Rule 1 CPC.
(ii) Power of review may be exercised when some mistake or
error apparent on the fact of record is found. But error on the
face of record must be such an error which must strike one on
mere looking at the record and would not require any long-
drawn process of reasoning on the points where there may
conceivably be two opinions.
(iii) Power of review may not be exercised on the ground that
the decision was erroneous on merits.
(iv) Power of review can also be exercised for any sufficient
reason which is wide enough to include a misconception of
fact or law by a court or even an advocate.
(v) An application for review may be necessitated by way of
invoking the doctrine actus curiae neminem gravabit."' (As
observed in: Inderchand Jain v. Motilal, (2009) 14 SCC 663,
p. 675, para 33)"
It is further observed in the said decision that an error which
is required to be detected by a process of reasoning can
hardly be said to be an error on the face of the record.
18. In Shanti Conductors (P) Ltd., it is observed and held that
scope of review under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC read with Section
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 12
114 CPC is limited and under the guise of review, the
petitioner cannot be permitted to reagitate and reargue
questions which have already been addressed and decided. It
is further observed that an error which is not self-evident and
has to be detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly be
said to be an error apparent on the face of record justifying
the court to exercise its power of review under Order 47 a
Rule 1 CPC.”
In Kamlesh Verma v. Mayawati and others, (2013) 8 SCC 320 ,
Hon'ble the Supreme Court held when the review will not be maintainable.
The relevant portion of paragraph 20.2 reads as under:-
"(iii) Review proceedings cannot be equated with the
original hearing of the case."
"(vi) The mere possibility of two views on the subject
cannot be a ground for review."
The distinction, therefore, is between correcting an evident mistake in
the judgment and reconsidering the case upon further arguments. The former
falls within review jurisdiction; the latter ordinarily does not.
11. Examined in this light, the present application does not disclose
a ground for review. The order dated 26.09.2019 was passed in the presence
of learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants and upon his express
submission that the appeal had become infructuous in view of Ravinder
Kaur Grewal’s case ( supra) . The applicant does not dispute that this
submission was made; indeed, it is acknowledged in paragraph 11 of the
review application. Nor has any error been shown in the legal proposition
accepted by counsel and applied by the Court. The objection that a plaintiff
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 13
could not maintain a suit claiming title through adverse possession had been
answered against the appellants by Hon'ble the Supreme Court before the
appeal was decided. The judgment under review thus proceeded upon the
binding law then applicable. The applicant's grievance is essentially that
counsel should nevertheless have pressed the remaining grounds. A general
assertion that those grounds were omitted owing to a bona fide error does
not establish an apparent mistake in the Court's judgment or entitle the
applicant to have the appeal heard again.
12. The reliance upon the order dated 30.05.2019 does not lead to a
different conclusion. That order directed the appeal to be heard on its own
merits because there was no further need to await the outcome of the other
proceedings. Thereafter, Hon'ble the Supreme Court delivered its judgment
in Ravinder Kaur Grewal’s case ( supra) and learned Senior Counsel
addressed the effect of the said judgment when the appeal was taken up for
hearing. The earlier direction to hear the appeal did not prevent its disposal
upon the submission subsequently made on behalf of the appellants. Equally,
the order dated 06.03.2017 was passed in another appeal and left the
contentions of the parties in those proceedings open; it was not an order
remanding the present second appeal. Neither order, therefore, shows that
the judgment dated 26.09.2019 overlooked a binding direction governing the
disposal of this appeal.
13. It is correct that maintainability of a suit founded upon adverse
possession and proof of adverse possession are separate questions. Ravinder
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 14
Kaur Grewal’s case (supra) does not dispense with the plaintiff's obligation
to prove the claim. However, the plaintiff-respondents had obtained decrees
from learned trial Court as well as learned First Appellate Court and any
challenge to the evidentiary basis of those decrees was available when the
Regular Second Appeal was heard. The applicant now seeks examination of
those grounds after the appeal was disposed of upon the submission
recorded on behalf of the appellants. Entertaining such appeal would entail a
fresh examination of the grounds and evidence on record. Merely
incorporating the original grounds of appeal in the review application does
not bring that exercise within Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC. The reference to
Section 100 CPC and Section 41 of the Punjab Courts Act, 1918 also does
not assist the applicant. Even accepting that other grounds were available to
be urged in the Regular Second Appeal, the scope of that appeal cannot
enlarge the separate and limited jurisdiction of review.
14. The applicant has thus shown neither a new circumstance
which could not have been brought before the Court earlier nor an error
apparent in the judgment sought to be reviewed. His case rests upon the plea
that the appeal should have been argued differently. The fact that he was
represented by counsel is not, by itself, a bar to review; however, the
admitted submission made at the hearing, the correct application of the
binding judgment in Ravinder Kaur Grewal’s case ( supra) , and the absence
of any demonstrated error leave no ground for reopening the decision. In
these circumstances, the plea that a litigant should not suffer for a bona fide
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

RA-RS-12-2021(O&M) in
R.S.A.No.705-2010 15
mistake of counsel cannot justify a fresh hearing of the appeal. Accordingly,
finding no ground to review or recall the judgment dated 26.09.2019, the
review application is dismissed on merits.
CM-1563-C-2021
15. In view of dismissal of the review application, the prayer for
restraining alienation of the suit property during its pendency no longer
survives and the application having been rendered infructuous is disposed of
as such. There shall be no order as to costs.
16. Pending applications, if any, shall also stands dismissed.
20.11.2026 (PRAVINDRA SINGH CHAUHAN)
mamta JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether Reportable Yes/No
MAMTA
2026.11.20 16:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document