Navdeep Kansal And Others vs Sumit Singla And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
RSA-1304-2025 (O&M) -1-
THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
RSA-1304-2025 (O&M)
Date of decision: 12.11.2026
Navdeep Kansal and others.
....Appellants
Versus
Sumit Singla and others
....Respondents
CORAM : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER
*
Present: Mr. Avinish Mittal, Advocate,
for the appellants.
*
HARSH BUNGER J. (ORAL)
1. The present second appeal has been filed by the plaintiffs
challenging the judgment and decree dated 25.02.2020 passed by the learned
Civil Judge (Junior Division), Sunam, to the extent whereby the counter
claim filed by Naresh Kumar (defendant No.4 in the suit filed by the
appellants-plaintiffs i.e. CS/283/2016) has been decreed and the present
appellants-plaintiffs have been directed to remove the encroachment in the
property comprised in khasra No.304//5/3 (2-9) and 6/3 (2-1) by
demolishing the wall. Further challenge has been made to the judgment and
decree dated 16.01.2025 passed by the learned Additional District Judge,
Sangrur, whereby an appeal filed by the present appellants-plaintiffs against
the trial Court’s judgment and decree dated 25.02.2020 to the extent of
DINESH
2026.11.17 13:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-1304-2025 (O&M) -2-
decreeing the counter claim of Naresh Kumar (defendant No.4 in plaintiffs’
suit), has also been dismissed.
2. Briefly, the present appellants-plaintiffs filed a suit
(CS/283/2016) seeking permanent injunction against the defendants
(including defendant No.4-Naresh Kumar) from dispossessing them from the
property comprised in khasra No.304//6/1 (1-2-4.50) measuring 1 kanal 2-
4.5 marla situated at back side of Government Girls School, near Raj Dulari
Street, City Road Sunam-A and bounded as under:
“ East: 156 ft. Rajesh Kumar and others
West: 154 ft. street
North: 46 ft. Madan Gopal Jagdish Chand and street
South: 48 ft. street”
3. In the aforesaid suit, defendant No.4-Naresh Kumar appeared
and filed his counter claim seeking mandatory injunction against the present
appellants-plaintiffs for directing them to demolish the boundary wall in the
property comprised in khasra No.304//5/3 (2-9) and 6/3 (2-1), measuring 4
kanal 10 marla.
4. Learned trial Court vide judgment and decree dated 25.02.2020,
decreed the suit filed by the appellants-plaintiffs to the effect that defendants
in plaintiffs’ suit were restrained from dispossessing the plaintiffs from the
suit property comprised in khasra No.304//6/1 and at the same time also
decreed the counter claim filed by Naresh Kumar (defendant No.4 in
plaintiffs’ suit) by directing the appellants-plaintiffs to remove the
encroachment in the property comprised in khasra No.304//5/3 (2-9) and 6/3
(2-1) by demolishing the wall.
DINESH
2026.11.17 13:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-1304-2025 (O&M) -3-
5. Feeling aggrieved against decreeing of counter-claim of
defendant No.4 – Naresh Kumar, the present appellants-plaintiffs preferred
an appeal before the learned Additional District Judge, Sangrur, which has
been dismissed vide judgment and decree dated 16.01.2025.
6. In the aforementioned circumstances, the present second appeal
has been filed by the appellants.
7. I have heard learned counsel for the appellants and perused the
paper-book with his able assistance.
8. In the present case, the present appellants-plaintiffs filed a suit
for permanent injunction against the defendants in the suit (including
defendant No.4-Naresh Kumar) for restraining them from dispossessing the
plaintiffs from the property comprised in khasra No.304//6/1 on the plea that
the plaintiffs and their mother Shashi Bala had purchased the said property
vide sale deed dated 03.01.2000 from one Pushpa Devi wife of Parshotam
Dass. The appellants-plaintiffs pleaded that after the death of Shashi Bala,
her share was inherited by the plaintiffs vide mutation No.24852 and since
then they are owners in possession of the suit property and even electricity
connection has been installed therein in the name of appellant/plaintiff
No.3-Hitesh Kansal. It is case of the appellants/plaintiffs that the defendants
in the suit are trying to dispossess them from the suit property with the help
of local police and since the defendants in the suit refused to accede to their
request for not dispossessing them; accordingly, the suit was filed.
9. Upon issuance of notice in the suit, defendant No.1-Sumit
Singla appeared and filed his written statement raising various preliminary
DINESH
2026.11.17 13:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-1304-2025 (O&M) -4-
objections. On merits, he submitted that defendant No.4-Naresh Kumar is
the owner of 10/90 share in the property comprised in khasra
No.304//5/3 (2-9) and 6/3(2-1) on the basis of sale deed dated 10.12.1996. It
was stated that the property of Naresh Kumar is adjoining to the property of
the appellants/plaintiffs and that defendant No.1 in the suit (Sumit Singla) is
the power of attorney of defendant No.4-Naresh Kumar, who has sold 180
square yards property but he is still the owner of 120 square yards property.
He specifically pleaded that the present appellants-plaintiffs have
encroached the said property by constructing a boundary wall. The other
averments of the plaint were denied and prayer for dismissal of the suit was
made.
10. Similarly, defendants No.2, 3 and 4 also filed their separate
written statement, reiterating the stance taken by defendant No.1 and prayed
for dismissal of the suit.
11. Further, defendant No.4-Naresh Kumar filed a counter claim
stating that he is owner of property comprised in khasra No.304//5/3 (2-9)
and 6/3 (2-1) on the basis of a sale deed dated 10.12.1996. He stated that his
property is adjoining to the property of the appellants-plaintiffs and that
defendant No.1-Sumit Singla is his power of attorney. He further maintained
that he has sold 180 square yards property but he is still the owner of 120
square yards property, which has been encroached by the appellants-
plaintiffs by constructing a boundary wall. Accordingly, relief of permanent
injunction was sought for directing the appellants-plaintiff to demolish the
said wall.
DINESH
2026.11.17 13:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-1304-2025 (O&M) -5-
12. From the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial Court framed
the following issues:-
“ 1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to relief of permanent
injunction as prayed for? OPP
2. Whether jurisdiction of civil court is barred? OPD
3. Whether the suit is not maintainable in the present form?
OPD
4. Whether plaintiffs have no locus standi and cause of action
to file the present suit? OPD
4A. Whether defendant no.4 is entitled to relief of mandatory
injunction as per counter claim? OPD4
4B. Whether counter claim is not maintainable in the present
form? OPP
5. Relief.”
13. Thereafter, the parties led their respective evidence (oral as well
as documentary) on the aforesaid issues.
14 Learned trial Court, upon appraisal of the matter, returned the
finding under issue No.1 that the appellants herein-plaintiffs have been able
to prove that they are owners in possession of the property comprised in
khasra No.304//6/1 and as such the defendants have no right to dispossess
them from the said property.
15. Likewise, learned trial Court on appreciation of the facts,
pleadings as well as the evidence on record, returned the finding under issue
No.4A that the present appellants-plaintiffs had never laid any claim in
respect of the property comprised in khasra No.304//5/3 (2-9) and 6/3 (2-1)
DINESH
2026.11.17 13:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-1304-2025 (O&M) -6-
in their pleadings nor they have rebutted the evidence of the counter
claimant-Naresh Kumar.
16. As far as the question of encroachment on the property
comprised in khasra No.304//5/3 and 6/3 is concerned, learned trial Court
returned the following finding:-
“ 17. As far as question of encroachment in property
comprised in khasra no.304//5/3(2-9) and 6/3(2-1) is
concerned, the respondents/ plaintiffs have tendered report of
local commissioner as Ex. P11 as per which
respondents/plaintiffs are in possession of property measuring
809 square yards out of which 25 square yards is vacant and
boundary wall has been constructed around area of 784 square
yards. Further, it has been stated that as per record they should
be in possession of 1 kanal 2.5 marla but they are in possession
of excess area of 104 square yards. It is pertinent to mention
further that PW-1 Navdeep Kansal has admitted in his cross
examination that the plaintiffs have no concern with property
comprised in khasra no. 304//5/3(2-9) and 6/3(2-1) but he is in
possession of extra area of 100 square yards.
18. In view of the foregoing, the court is of the considered
view that it has been established that the respondents/plaintiffs
are in possession of excess area property comprised in khasra
no. 304//5/3(2-9) and 6/3(2-1). As such, the
respondents/plaintiffs are liable to remove the encroachment in
the property comprised in khasra no. 304//5/3(2-9) and 6/3(2-1)
by demolishing the wall. Accordingly, issue no.4A is decided in
favour of the counter claimant/defendant no.4 and against the
respondents/plaintiffs.”
DINESH
2026.11.17 13:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-1304-2025 (O&M) -7-
17. Based upon the findings on various issues, learned trial Court
vide judgment and decree dated 25.02.2020, decreed the suit filed by the
present appellants-plaintiffs so far as the property comprised in khasra
No.304//6/1 is concerned and at the same time the learned trial Court also
decreed the counter claim of defendant No.4-Naresh Kumar by directing the
present appellants-plaintiffs to remove their encroachment over the property
comprised in khasra No.304//5/3 and 6/3 by demolishing the wall.
18. The present appellants feeling aggrieved against the judgment
and decree dated 25.02.2020 passed by learned trial Court decreeing the
counter claim of defendant No.4-Naresh Kumar, preferred an appeal before
the learned Additional District Judge, Sangrur, which was dismissed, vide
judgment and decree dated 16.01.2025 by observing as under:-
“ 30. On the contrary, regarding version of defendants/cross-
objector in respect of their counter claim, report of local
commissioner Ex. P11 reveals that plaintiffs are having 104
square yards excess to their own land and where they have also
constructed the wall. In his cross-examination, PW-1 Navdeep
Kansal stated that he is having possession of 100 square yards
of land in excess of his own land, which indicate that plaintiffs
actually encroached upon the landed property. Report of Local
Commissioner Ex.P11 is tendered into evidence by learned
counsel for plaintiffs themselves and now it cannot be agitated
that same has not been proved in accordance with law, besides,
when plaintiff did not put across their matter on the basis of
equity, the argument that they should have filed suit for
partition or suit for possession being co-sharers does not hold
water. Once plaintiffs/appellants have not based their rebuttal
DINESH
2026.11.17 13:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-1304-2025 (O&M) -8-
to the counter claim of defendant on the basis of equity, justice
demands that they must be mandated to deliver back wrong
possession, which they have occupied and thus learned lower
court rightfully reached the conclusion while allowing the
counter claim. In such situation, the judgments relied upon
learned counsel for plaintiffs/appellants do not advance the
case of plaintiffs/appellants.
31. Thus, as an upshot of my forgoing discussion and as
sequel there to, it is held that no infirmity is found in the
Judgment and decree dated 25.02.2020 which is passed as per
law and after proper appreciation of the evidence on record
and which is accordingly affirmed and resultantly, civil appeal
and cross-objections having no merit, are ordered to be
dismissed with costs….”
19. Before this Court, learned counsel for the appellants has been
unable to dispute the fact that so far as the property comprised in khasra
No.304//6/1 is concerned, the same is distinct from the property claimed by
the counter claimant-defendant No.4 i.e. khasra No.304//5/3 (2-9) and 6/3
(2-1). Learned counsel for the petitioner also could not dispute the report of
the Local Commissioner (Ex.P11), wherein the present appellants-plaintiffs
were found in possession of excess area of 104 square yards. Further, the
present appellant No.1-Navdeep Kansal had admitted during his cross-
examination that they have no concern with the property comprised in
khasra No.304//5/3 (2-9) and 6/3 (2-1) but he is in possession of extra area
of 100 square yards.
20. Learned counsel for the appellants-plaintiffs has failed to show
as to how the findings returned by the learned Courts below are either
DINESH
2026.11.17 13:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-1304-2025 (O&M) -9-
perverse or illegal or based on misreading or mis-appreciation of material
evidence.
21. Upon consideration of the matter, I am of the view that the
findings returned by the learned Courts below are based upon proper
appreciation of facts, pleadings as well as evidence on record, which does
not call for any interference. No question of law much less, a substantial
question of law arises for adjudication in this regular second appeal.
22. Resultantly, the instant regular second appeal fails and same is
accordingly, dismissed.
23. All the pending application(s), if any, shall also stand closed.
(HARSH BUNGER)
12.11.2026 JUDGE
dinesh
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
DINESH
2026.11.17 13:05
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document