BHARAT KESARWANI vs STATE OF UTTARAKHAND
- Court
- Uttarakhand High Court
UKHC010169822026
2026:UHC:8685
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Writ Petition No. 2951 of 2026 (M/S)
Mukesh Pandey ….....Petitioner
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and Others ….….Respondents
Present:-
Mr. Dushyant Mainali, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. S.N. Babulkar, Advocate General assisted by Mr. Amrinder Pratap
Singh, Additional Advocate General, Mr. Puran Singh Bisht, Chief
Standing Counsel, Mr. Pradeep Hariya, Additional Chief Standing Counsel
and Mr. Akshit Gururani, Brief Holder for the State.
Mr. Rajeev Singh Bisht, Advocate for the Kumaon University.
With
Writ Petition No. 2908 of 2026 (M/S)
Bharat Kesarwani ….....Petitioner
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and Others ….….Respondents
Present:-
Mr. Abhishek Singh Rawat, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. S.N. Babulkar, Advocate General assisted by Mr. Amrinder Pratap
Singh, Additional Advocate General, Mr. Puran Singh Bisht, Chief
Standing Counsel, Mr. Pradeep Hariya, Additional Chief Standing Counsel
and Mr. Akshit Gururani, Brief Holder for the State.
Mr. Rajeev Singh Bisht, Advocate for the Kumaon University.
With
Writ Petition No. 2949 of 2026 (M/S)
Ajay Kumar ….....Petitioner
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and Others ….….Respondents
Present:-
Mr. Dushyant Mainali, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. S.N. Babulkar, Advocate General assisted by Mr. Amrinder Pratap
Singh, Additional Advocate General, Mr. Puran Singh Bisht, Chief
2
Standing Counsel, Mr. Pradeep Hariya, Additional Chief Standing Counsel
and Mr. Akshit Gururani, Brief Holder for the State.
Ms. Mamta Bisht, Advocate for the Kumaon University.
With
Writ Petition No. 2950 of 2026 (M/S)
Manas Arya ….....Petitioner
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and Others ….….Respondents
Present:-
Mr. Saurav Adhikari and Ms. Poorvi Chaudhary, Advocate for the
petitioner.
Mr. S.N. Babulkar, Advocate General assisted by Mr. Amrinder Pratap
Singh, Additional Advocate General, Mr. Puran Singh Bisht, Chief
Standing Counsel, Mr. Pradeep Hariya, Additional Chief Standing Counsel
and Mr. Akshit Gururani, Brief Holder for the State.
Ms. Mamta Bisht, Advocate for the Kumaon University.
JUDGMENT
Hon’ble Ravindra Maithani, J. (Oral)
Since common questions of law and facts are involved
in all these petitions, they are heard together and being decided by
this common judgment. However, for sake of convenience, facts
would be referred from Writ Petition (M/S) No. 2951 of 2026 and
parties shall be referred to accordingly, unless otherwise specifically
specified.
2. The petitioners are students, who intended to contest
the student union election. Petitioners Bharat Kesarwani, Ajay
Kumar and Mukesh Pandey intended to contest the student union
election to the post of Treasurer and petitioner Manas Arya
intended to contest the election to the post of Joint Secretary. All
3
the colleges are affiliated to the Kumaun University, Nainital (“the
University”).
3. On 10.09.2026, the Registrar of the University issued a
press communique thereby informing that student union election of
all the affiliated colleges shall be held on 29.09.2026 and for the
University, it shall be held on 01.10.2026. Thereafter, on
17.09.2026, which is annexure no. 1 to the writ petition, the State
Government made a communication to the Vice Chancellor of the
Government Universities that since the strength of girl students in
the Universities is more than 65%, in the student union election,
they may be given 50% reservation. Post Government Order dated
17.09.2026, the University issued an office order dated 18.09.2026,
whereby various positions were reserved in the student union
election for the girl students. For the purpose of instant petitions, it
is sufficient to mention that the positions of Joint Secretary and
Treasurer were reserved for girl students. Petitioners Bharat
Kesarwani, Ajay Kumar and Mukesh Pandey intended to contest
the student union election to the post of Treasurer and petitioner
Manas Arya intended to contest the election to the post of Joint
Secretary.
4. The petitioner Mukesh Pandey challenged the
Government Order dated 17.09.2026 as well as the office order of
the University dated 18.09.2026, by which this reservation was
provided to the girl students. The other petitioners challenged the
office order dated 18.09.2026 issued by the University.
5. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
4
6. Learned counsel for the petitioner Bharat Kesarwani
submits that the impugned office order by which the reservation
was provided for the first time to the girl students was issued by
the University on 18.09.2026 and 100% reservation was given for
the post of Treasurer and Joint Secretary and the remaining
positions were kept open for all. He would submit that the
reservation that was provided by the office order dated 18.09.2026
of the University makes it approximately 42% reservation to the girl
students, whereas this communication itself says that 50%
positions should be reserved for the girl students. He would submit
that there is a channel for making such amendment in view of the
Lyngdoh Committee recommendation, which has not been followed.
7. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners Manas
Arya adops the arguments made on behalf of the petitioner Bharat
Kesarwani. In addition to it, it is argued that the Constitution of the
student union has been promulgated by the University and its
Article 19 provides provision for amendment in the Constitution. He
would submit that the Constitution of the student union makes
provision for reservation and if any amendment was to be made, it
ought to have been included in the Constitution of the student
union by the University first and thereafter it ought to have been
implemented. Hence, it is argued that the office order dated
18.09.2026 issued by the University is bad in the eyes of law and
deserves to be quashed.
8. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners Ajay
Kumar and Mukesh Pandey adopts the arguments that have been
5
made on behalf of other petitioners. He would also raise the
following points in his submission:-
(i) The State Government could not have issued
Government Order dated 17.09.2026 providing
reservation in the student union election. He would
submit that that Section 66A of the Uttarakhand State
University Act, 1973 (“Act of 1973”) does not empower
the State Government to make indulgence by virtue of
impugned Government Order dated 17.09.2026, as it is
not a policy matter. In support of his argument,
learned counsel has relied upon the judgment of the
Hon’ble Allahabad High Court in the case of Committee
of Management, S.M. College, Chandausi, Moradabad
and others v. State of U.P. and another, 2005 AIR
Allahabad 126.
In the case of Committee of Management ( supra ),
the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court, inter alia, observed
“ Since the University itself cannot frame ordinance
under Section 51(g) of the Act providing for
constitution of Students Union in affiliated degree
colleges as well as for election of office bearers of
the Students’ Union in affiliated degree colleges,
any direction issued by the State Government
under Section 66A of the Act requiring the
University to frame ordinance for constitution of
Student’s Union and election of its office bearers in
affiliated degree colleges, on the face of it would be
inconsistent with the provisions of the Act and,
therefore is unsustainable”.
6
(ii) Learned counsel also submits that pursuant to the
recommendation of the Lyngdoh Committee, the
framework was approved by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of University of Kerala v. Council,
Principals’ College, Kerala and others, (2006) 8 SCC
304, and para 6.10 makes provision with regard to the
student representations and it provides that the
student representation should be regulated by the
statute. In the instant case, it is argued that it has not
been done.
supra
In the case of University of Kerala ( ), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, in para 6.10. observed as
follows:-
“6.10. Miscellaneous recommendations
6.10.1 . Student representation is essential to the
overall development of students and, therefore, it is
recommended that university statutes should
expressly provide for student representation.
6.10.2 . Student representation should be regulated
by statute (either a Central statute, State statute or
individual university statutes), incorporating the
recommendations prescribed herein.
6.10.3 . The institution should organise leadership-
training programs with the help of professional
organisations so as to groom and instil in students
leadership qualities.
6.10.4 . In the event of the office of any major post of
office-bearers falling vacant within two months of
elections, re-elections should be conducted;
otherwise the Vice-President may be promoted to
the post of President and Joint Secretary to the post
of Secretary, as the case may be.”
(iii) The elections are scheduled to be held on 29.09.2026
was pronounced by the Registrar on 10.09.2026.
Thereafter, the reservation was implemented without
proper channel.
(iv) The Government Order dated 17.09.2026 could not
have been adopted by the University the way it has
been done. It has not gone through the Executive
Council, etc. which is competent to make changes in
7
the constitution of the student union. Hence, it is
argued that both the Government Orders dated
17.09.2026 and office order dated 18.09.2026 are liable
to be quashed, as they are not in accordance with law.
9. On the other hand, learned counsel for the University,
Mr. Rajeev Singh Bisht, submits that the number of girl students in
the University is more than 65%. The Director, Higher Education,
State of Uttarakhand has taken note of this situation and since last
year has issued directions to the Universities. He would submit that
Sri Dev Suman Uttarakhand University has already adopted this
direction in the last year. It is argued that post Government Order
dated 17.09.2026, an emergency meeting of Executive Council of
the University was convened on 18.09.2026, which approved the
proposal for implementation of reservation for various positions in
the student union election.
10. Learned counsel submits that the Executive Council is
the highest body, who could make amendments in the constitution
of the student union and could effectively deal with the affairs of
the matter. He would refer to Section 21 of the Act of 1973.
Particularly, he would refer to clause (xvii) of Section 21, which
reads as under:-
“ 21. Powers and duties of Executive Council. (1)
The Executive Council shall be the principal
executive body of the University and subject to the
provisions of this Act, have the following powers,
namely –
...............................................................................
...............................................................................
...............................................................................
.......................................
(xvii) to regulate and determine all other matters
concerning the University as well as Institutes,
constituent, affiliated and associated colleges in
8
accordance with this Act, the Statutes and the
Ordinances.”
11. Learned counsel further submits that no right of the
petitioner is being defeated; there has been no fundamental right to
contest elections. It is argued that the election was notified on
23.09.2026 and prior to it, reservation was notified by the State
Government by virtue of the Government Order dated 17.09.2026
and the Office order dated 18.09.2026.
12. Learned Advocate General, who appears for the State,
submits that the State Government is empowered to issue
Government orders under Article 162 of the Constitution of India
and in the instant matter, the Government Order dated 17.09.2026
has been issued keeping in view the pious obligation of the State
under Article 15(3) of the Constitution of India so as to take pro-
active steps for upliftment of the women. He would submit that this
aspect has been dealt with by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Government of A.P. v. P.B. Vijayakumar and another, (1994)
4 SCC 520.
13. In the case of Government of A.P. ( supra ), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in paras 6 and 7 observed as under:-
“6...... Therefore, in dealing with employment under
the State, it has to bear in mind both Articles 15
and 16 — the former being a more general provision
and the latter, a more specific provision. Since
Article 16 does not touch upon any special
provision for women being made by the State, it
cannot in any manner derogate from the power
conferred upon the State in this connection under
Article 15(3). This power conferred by Article 15(3)
is wide enough to cover the entire range of State
activity including employment under the State.”
7. The insertion of clause (3) of Article 15 in relation
to women is a recognition of the fact that for
9
centuries, women of this country have been socially
and economically handicapped. As a result, they
are unable to participate in the socio-economic
activities of the nation on a footing of equality. It is
in order to eliminate this socio-economic
backwardness of women and to empower them in a
manner that would bring about effective equality
between men and women that Article 15(3) is
placed in Article 15. Its object is to strengthen and
improve the status of women. An important limb of
this concept of gender equality is creating job
opportunities for women. To say that under Article
15(3), job opportunities for women cannot be
created would be to cut at the very root of the
underlying inspiration behind this article. Making
special provisions for women in respect of
employment or posts under the State is an integral
part of Article 15(3). This power conferred under
Article 15(3), is not whittled down in any manner by
Article 16.
14. Further, in the case of Government of A.P. ( supra ), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that “ What then is meant by
“any special provision for women” in Article 15(3)? This
“special provision”, which the State may make to improve
women's participation in all activities under the supervision
and control of the State can be in the form of either affirmative
”.
action or reservation
15. Learned Advocate General would submit that the
reservation, which is horizontal in nature in the instant case may
be enforced by virtue of the Government Order, which has force of
law. He would refer to the judgment in the case of Indra Sawhney
and others v. Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 210, wherein after
noting the arguments and case laws on the subject, in para 740,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that “ It would, therefore,
follow that until a law is made or rules are issued under Article
309 with respect to reservation in favour of backward classes,
10
it would always be open to the Executive Government to
provide for reservation of appointments/posts in favour of
Backward Classes by an executive order .”
16. Learned Advocate General also submits that the
petitioners’ no right has been defeated. The right to elect or contest
election is neither a fundamental right nor a common law right. He
refers to the judgment in the case of Vishwanath Pratap Singh v.
Election Commission of India & another, 2022 SCC OnLine SCC
2213, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that “
The right
to contest an election is neither a fundamental right nor a
common law right. It is a right conferred by a statute ”. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Vishwanath Pratap Singh
( supra ), has referred to the principle of law as laid down in the case
of Javed v. State of Haryana, (2003) 8 SCC 369, wherein the
Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as follows:-
“22. Right to contest an election is neither a fundamental
right nor a common law right. It is a right conferred by a
statute. At the most, in view of Part IX having been added
in the Constitution, a right to contest election for an office
in Panchayat may be said to be a constitutional right — a
right originating in the Constitution and given shape by a
statute. But even so, it cannot be equated with a
fundamental right. There is nothing wrong in the same
statute which confers the right to contest an election also
to provide for the necessary qualifications without which a
person cannot offer his candidature for an elective office
and also to provide for disqualifications which would
disable a person from contesting for, or holding, an elective
statutory office.
23. Reiterating the law laid down in N.P. Ponnuswami v.
Returning Officer, Namakkal Constituency [(1952) 1 SCC 94
: AIR 1952 SC 64 : 1952 SCR 218] and Jagan Nath v.
Jaswant Singh [AIR 1954 SC 210 : 1954 SCR 892] this
Court held in Jyoti Basu v. Debi Ghosal [(1982) 1 SCC 691]
: (SCC p. 696, para 8)
“8. A right to elect, fundamental though it is
to democracy, is, anomalously enough, neither a
11
fundamental right nor a common law right. It is
pure and simple, a statutory right. So is the right to
be elected. So is the right to dispute an election.
Outside of statute, there is no right to elect, no
right to be elected and no right to dispute an
election. Statutory creations they are, and
therefore, subject to statutory limitation.”
17. Learned Advocate submits that the petitions are
misconceived and deserve to be dismissed at the stage of admission
itself. There is no merit in the writ petitions.
18. Learned counsel for the University Mr. Rajeev Singh
Bisht has further argued that the constitution of the student union
was promulgated by the University, which has provided a forum for
redressal of such grievances in complaint redressal forum, wherein
complaint may be filed within three weeks after declaration of
results. Therefore, it is argued that at this stage when election is
already scheduled and nominations have already been done, no
interference is warranted.
19. When these lines were dictated, it is admitted to the
learned counsel for the parties that time for nomination to contest
the election has already been over. The election is scheduled for
29.09.2026 in the colleges and for 01.10.2026 in the University.
20. The question is – whether there is any gross violation,
which may warrant an interference by this Court at this stage?
What are under challenge is the Government Order dated
17.09.2026 and the office order dated 18.09.2026 of the University,
by which reservation has been granted to certain positions in the
student union election. In the instant matter, what is impugned is
the reservation that has been provided to the post of Joint
12
Secretary and the Treasurer. Law is well settled that right to
contest election is not a fundamental right. In the instant case, the
petitioners have not been stopped from contesting election to an
unreserved post. They are free to contest election to some other
post.
21. The State Government may issue Government Orders
under Article 162 of the Constitution of India. In the instant matter,
the impugned Government Order dated 17.09.2026 has been
issued under Article 15(3) of the Constitution of India so as to make
better provision for girl students in the University, so as to provide
them proper representation. What is argued on behalf of the
petitioner Bharat Kesarwani is that the office order dated
18.09.2026 speaks only reservation about 50% to the girl students
in student union election, whereas in the present case it is about
42% only. It makes less affect on the validity of this notification.
22. It is the case of the University that on 18.09.2026, the
Executive Council of the University resolved to give effect to the
Government Order dated 17.09.2026. This fact is undisputed
because this finds mention in the office order dated 18.09.2026.
23. Reference has been made to constitution of student
union, Article 19, which deals with amendment in the constitution.
It deals with the amendment proposed by the student unions. In
fact, it finds mention under Article 19(D) and according to it, if
student union proposes any amendment, it can come through the
Head of the Institution to the Vice Chancellor. It does not speak of
amendment that is incorporated by the Vice Chancellor itself or by
the Executive Council. It is not also disputed that the amendment
13
in the constitution of student union could be proposed by the
Executive Council and in the instant matter, the Executive Council
has taken a call on 18.09.2026. Merely because formal amendment
has not been incorporated in the constitution of student union, it
does not invalidate the office order dated 18.09.2026.
24. Therefore, having considered the entire facts, this
Court is of the view that there is no merit in the writ petitions. The
writ petitions fail and are liable to be dismissed.
in limine.
25. The writ petitions are dismissed
(Ravindra Maithani, J)
25.09.2026
Avneet/