Madan Mohan(Dead) Through Lrs. vs Thakar Dass (Dead) Thr. Lrs.

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 730
NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO……………………… OF 2026
(@Special Leave Petition (Civil) No.12435 of 2019)


MADAN MOHAN (DEAD) THROUGH LRS. ... APPELLANT(S)

VERSUS

THAKAR DASS (DEAD) THR. LRS. ...RESPONDENT(S)


J U D G M E N T

SANJAY KAROL J.

1 . Leave Granted.

1
2. One Kamla Devi had filed a suit for eviction against the respondent –
tenant, on two grounds: (i) non-payment of rent; and (ii)bona fide requirement for
herself and her son Madan Mohan. Both have since deceased, and now the appeal
before us is being prosecuted by their legal representatives. The Rent Controller,
2 3
Nabha and the Appellate Authority, Patiala , both found the case of the landlord
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
SOURAV PAL
Date: 2026.07.21
17:26:37 IST
Reason:

1
Under Section 13 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949; ‘the Act’
2 th
RA No. 12/15.04.2003 dated 27 May 2010; ‘RA’
3 th
RA No. 12-A of 15.6.2010 dated 6 January 2011 ‘AA’
C.A.No../2026 @ SLP(C)No.12435 of 2019 Page 1 of 9

to be proved and thus decreed the eviction. However, the High Court of Punjab
4
and Haryana in the impugned judgment , reversed these findings.

3. The proceedings before the Courts below were as follows:
3.1 At the outset, it is noted that the relationship of landlord-tenant is
undisputed with the rental of the tenancy at Rs.112.50 per month. In
rd
response to the eviction petition, it was submitted that on 3 June 2003, the
th
respondent-tenant had tendered the rent as claimed with effect from 17
th
July 1998 till 9 June 2003 (the entire period of unpaid rent) along with Rs.
1000 as interest and Rs. 1100 as cost, totalling to an amount of Rs. 8740/-
which was accepted. On the ground of bona fide requirement, the same was
denied as illusionary primarily on the ground that it was inconceivable to
the respondent-tenant that an 80-year-old woman would like to run a
business and also that she had another shop that was being rented out by
her son Adarsh Mohan, and the entire litigation is at his behest, despite the
fact that one of the 3 shops that have been constructed by the appellant-
landlord was still vacant.
3.2. A total of 8 issues were framed by the RA. Below is a tabular
representation thereof:
Sr.No Issue Outcome
1. Whether the tendered arrears of
In favour of the Respondent-
Tenant
rent made by the Respondents
are invalid?
2. Whether the petitioner requires
In favour of the Appellant-
Landlord
the shop in question in her
personal capacity and instead of
her son Madan Mohan?
3. Whether the petitioner and her
In favour of the Appellant-
Landlord
son Madan Mohan are not in
possession of any other non-

4 th
CR No. 1573 of 2011 dated 6 August 2018
C.A.No../2026 @ SLP(C)No.12435 of 2019 Page 2 of 9

residential property except this
shop within Nabha limits?
4. Whether the petitioner and her
In favour of the Appellant-
Landlord
son have not vacated any non—
residential premises After
coming into force of Rent Act
within municipal limits of
Nabha?
5. Whether the petition is
maintainable in its present
form?
In favour of the Appellant-
Landlord
6. Whether the petitioner is
estopped by her act and conduct
from filing the present petition?
In favour of the Appellant-
Landlord
7. Whether the petitioner has no
In favour of the Appellant-
Landlord
cause of action to file the present
suit?
8. Relief Petition allowed with costs.
Respondent-Tenant was directed
to handover possession of the
shop within three months.

3.3. The AA upheld the conclusion of the RA stating that although
Kamla Devi had filed the suit on the basis of personal necessity and since
she had died during the pendency of the petition, her personal necessity did
not subsist but since the requirement of necessity was also attached to
Madan Mohan, the said ground would survive and as such there was no
need to interfere with the order.
3.4 The High Court, speaking through learned Single Judge, differed
with the opinions summarised above. Taking note of Section 13 of the Act,
and the pleadings of the parties, it was observed that despite the fact having
been pointed out, Kamla Devi denied that one of her shops was lying
vacant. In the witness box as well, she stated that Adarsh Mohan, was
running his business from one of the shops and in the other one there was
some garbage that had been stored. The Court further observed that both
C.A.No../2026 @ SLP(C)No.12435 of 2019 Page 3 of 9

the RA and AA had misread the evidence to held that Adarsh Mohan had
been using the third shop as a store – this, according to the learned Single
Judge was not borne out of any record. She had, in fact, concealed the
existence of the third shop and only in the evidence she stated that the third
shop was being used by Adarsh Mohan. As such, she did not approach the
Court with clean hands. The revision petition was allowed.

4. We have heard Mr Anurag, learned Advocate-On-Record for the appellant-
landlord and Mr Manoj Swarup, learned senior counsel appearing as amicus
curiae , for the respondent-tenant.

5
5. In Ram Krishan Grover v. Union of India , three judges of this Court, in
short discussed the origins of rent control legislations as follows:
“44. Rent control legislation are quintessentially social legislation that
were enacted in the 1940s and 1950s to protect and curb exploitation
of tenants in view of the prevailing socio-economic conditions due to
large scale immigration to towns and cities, increase in population,
lack of housing facilities as landed property was owned by a few well-
off and wealthy persons. The rent control legislation, therefore,
interfered with the general freedom of contract and right of the
landlord to seek eviction under the Transfer of Property Act. However,
all such legislations invariably also provide for balancing the
conflicting rights of the landlords. In several decisions, this Court has
emphasised that there is a need for balancing the two rival interests as
has been observed in Malpe Vishwanath Acharya v. State of
Maharashtra [ Malpe Vishwanath Acharya v. State of Maharashtra ,
(1998) 2 SCC 1] , Joginder Pal v. Naval Kishore Behal [ Joginder
Pal v. Naval Kishore Behal , (2002) 5 SCC 397] , Satyawati
Sharma v. Union of India [ Satyawati Sharma v. Union of India ,
(2008) 5 SCC 287] and in the recent decision in Vinod Kumar v. Ashok
Kumar Gandhi [ Vinod Kumar v. Ashok Kumar Gandhi , (2019) 17
SCC 237]”


5
(2020) 12 SCC 506
C.A.No../2026 @ SLP(C)No.12435 of 2019 Page 4 of 9

6. Before proceeding further, let us examine the contours of ‘ bona fide
requirement ’
6.1 First and foremost, the existence of the landlord-tenant relationship
is essential. While it is true that a landlord has the right to enjoy his own
property, the law does not grant its refuge to any arbitrary action, and so a
landlord simply by virtue of that status, cannot show someone the door
without the due process of law. It is here that bona fide requirement comes
in. Bona fide translates to ‘ in good faith ’ which then predicates the
requirement that may be faced by a landlord. A co-ordinate Bench in Shiv
6
Sarup Gupta v. Mahesh Chand Gupta , held thus:

“13… “The degree of intensity contemplated by “requires” is
much more higher than in mere desire. The phrase “required bona
fide” is suggestive of legislative intent that a mere desire which is
the outcome of whim or fancy is not taken note of by the rent
control legislation. A requirement in the sense of felt need which
is an outcome of a sincere, honest desire, in contradistinction with
a mere pretence or pretext to evict a tenant, on the part of the
landlord claiming to occupy the premises for himself or for any
member of the family would entitle him to seek ejectment of the
tenant. Looked at from this angle, any setting of the facts and
circumstances protruding the need of the landlord and its bona
fides would be capable of successfully withstanding the test of
objective determination by the court. The judge of facts should
place himself in the armchair of the landlord and then ask the
question to himself — whether in the given facts substantiated by
the landlord the need to occupy the premises can be said to be
natural, real, sincere, honest. If the answer be in the positive, the
need is bona fide. The failure on the part of the landlord to
substantiate the pleaded need, or, in a given case, positive material
brought on record by the tenant enabling the court drawing an
inference that the reality was to the contrary and the landlord was
merely attempting at finding out a pretence or pretext for getting
rid of the tenant, would be enough to persuade the court certainly
to deny its judicial assistance to the landlord. Once the court is
satisfied of the bona fides of the need of the landlord for the
premises or additional premises by applying objective standards
then in the matter of choosing out of more than one
accommodation available to the landlord his subjective choice
shall be respected by the court. The court would permit the

6
(1999) 6 SCC 222
C.A.No../2026 @ SLP(C)No.12435 of 2019 Page 5 of 9

landlord to satisfy the proven need by choosing the
accommodation which the landlord feels would be most suited for
the purpose; the court would not in such a case thrust its own
wisdom upon the choice of the landlord by holding that not one
but the other accommodation must be accepted by the landlord to
satisfy his such need. In short, the concept of bona fide need or
genuine requirement needs a practical approach instructed by the
realities of life. An approach either too liberal or too conservative
or pedantic must be guarded against.”

7
In Baldev Singh Bajwa v. Monish Saini , ‘ bona fide requirement ’ was discussed
in the following terms with reference to the earlier decisions in Bega Begum v.
8 9
Abdul Ahad Khan ; Surjit Singh Kalra v. Union of India ,
“14. The phrase “bona fide requirement” or “bona fide need” or
“required reasonably in good faith” or “required”, occurs in almost all
Rent Control Acts with the underlying legislative intent which has
been considered and demonstrated innumerable times by various High
Courts as also by this Court, some of which we would like to refer to.
In Ram Dass v. Ishwar Chander [(1988) 3 SCC 131] it is said that the
bona fide need should be genuine and honest, conceived in good faith.
It was also indicated that the landlord's desire for possession, however
honest it might otherwise be, has inevitably a subjective element in it,
and that desire, to become a “requirement” in law must have the
objective element of a “need”, which can be decided only by taking
all the relevant circumstances into consideration so that the protection
afforded to a tenant is not rendered illusory or whittled down.”
(emphasis supplied)

7. As can be seen from the above, the Court has actively engaged with the
question of ‘ bona fide requirement ’ right from the advent of Rent Control
legislations. Across the country and across numerous statutes, this requirement is
found and defined.

8. Whether or not, in a particular set of circumstances a landlord’s decision to
ask his tenant to vacate, falls within ‘ bona fide requirement ’ is not something that

7
(2005) 12 SCC 778
8
(1979) 1 SCC 273
9
(1991) 2 SCC 87
C.A.No../2026 @ SLP(C)No.12435 of 2019 Page 6 of 9

can be determined by a mathematical formula. As such, let us examine the facts
of the present case.

9. The primary reason why the High Court overturned the decision of the
Courts below was that the landlady (Kamla Devi) had not come to the Court with
clean hands and had concealed the availability of the third shop. It was observed
that the said shop was used to store garbage. If the shop that is alleged to be an
alternate accommodation was being used for storing waste material as has been
held by both the RA and the AA, then that being the finding of fact, what
occasioned the High Court to take a different view in civil revisional jurisdiction?
The old saying is, ‘ one man’s trash is another man’s treasure’ . So, even if the
statement is accepted as it is, we fail to see what is wrong with it. Let it be used
as such. After all, right from beginning the ‘ bona fide requirement’ was pleaded
for by both Kamla Devi and Madan Mohan. It was concurrently held as such by
the RA and the AA. The one that had hitherto been rented, will now be used as a
shop to run a boutique.

10. It is well settled that the scope of Section 115 Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 is limited. We may refer to a few pronouncements:
10.1 35 years ago, it was observed in Masjid Kacha Tank, Nahan v.
10
Tuffail Mohammed , that:
“ 3. It is well settled position in law that under Section 115 of the
Code of Civil Procedure the High Court cannot reappreciate the
evidence and cannot set aside the concurrent findings of the courts
below by taking a different view of the evidence. The High Court
is empowered only to interfere with the findings of fact if the
findings are perverse or there has been a non-appreciation or non-
consideration of the material evidence on record by the courts
below. Simply because another view of the evidence may be taken,

10
1991 Supp (2) SCC 270
C.A.No../2026 @ SLP(C)No.12435 of 2019 Page 7 of 9

is no ground by the High Court to interfere in its revisional
jurisdiction. ”

10.2 The Constitution Bench in Hindustan Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. v.
11
Dilbahar Singh , while dealing with this very question of the scope of
revisional power in the context of rent acts, particularly in issue therein
held as under:

“…Revisional power is not and cannot be equated with the
power of reconsideration of all questions of fact as a court of
first appeal. Where the High Court is required to be satisfied that
the decision is according to law, it may examine whether the
order impugned before it suffers from procedural illegality or
irregularity.”

10.3 A three judge Bench of this Court in Ambadas Khanduji Shinde
12
v. Ashok Sadashiv Mamurkar , while dealing with a landlord-tenant
dispute observed as under:

“14. Apart from the factual aspect, order lacks merit on the
ground of jurisdiction. The High Court cannot interfere with the
concurrent factual findings while exercising jurisdiction under
Section 115 of the Civil Procedure Code. It is settled law that
revisional jurisdiction of the High Court is restricted to cases of
illegal or irregular exercise of jurisdiction by the subordinate
courts. Under Section 115 of the Civil Procedure Code, it is not
open for the High Court to correct errors of facts or law unless
they go to root of the issue of jurisdiction. In the facts on hand,
the courts below have passed reasoned orders well within the
jurisdiction conferred upon them. We arrive at the conclusion
that the High Court committed error in interfering with the
judgment and decree of the trial court.”
(Emphasis supplied)


11. On both counts as discussed hereinabove, the final judgment and order dated
th
6 August 2018 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh
in C.R.No.1573/2011 (O&M) is unsustainable and hereby set aside. Ordered

11
(2014) 9 SCC 78
12
(2017) 14 SCC 132
C.A.No../2026 @ SLP(C)No.12435 of 2019 Page 8 of 9

accordingly. The concurrent findings and orders of the Rent Controller, Nabha
th
dated 27 May 2010 and the Appellate Authority, Patiala are hereby affirmed.
Consequently, the respondent is directed to deliver the vacant and peaceful
possession of the demised shop to the appellant(s) within a period of two months
from the date of this judgment. The appeal is allowed accordingly. Pending
application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of. No costs.



……………………………………………J.
(SANJAY KAROL)




……………………………………………J.
(AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH)
New Delhi;
July 21, 2026
C.A.No../2026 @ SLP(C)No.12435 of 2019 Page 9 of 9