Kishori Saw vs The Union Of India And 2 Ors
- Court
- Gauhati High Court
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010007392016
2026:GAU-AS:16865
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/520/2016
KISHORI SAW
S/O LT. PARMESHWAR SAW, PERMANENT R/O BORNA, P.O. ALINAGAR,
DIST- LAKHISARAI, BIHAR, PIN-811106, PRESENTLY WORKING AT
HEADQUARTER, OFFICER ON SPECIAL DUTY, EAST BORDER ROADS
ORGANIZATION, JALUKBARI, GUWAHATI, CARE 47 BRTF, C/O 99 APO, PIN-
930047
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA and 2 ORS
THROUGH THE SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF DEFENCE,
SOUTH BLOCK, NEW DELHI-1
2:THE DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITY CUM UNDER SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF
INDIA
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
SENA BHAWAN
NEW DELHI-5
3:RAJIV SHARMA
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER CIVIL
INQUIRING AUTHORITY
HQ
CHIEF
ENGINEER
PROJECT VARTAK
C/O 99 AP
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. K KALITA, MR. I H SAIKIA,MR. J KEMPRAI,MR. K
KALITA,MR. S A B KHABIR,MS. S KANUNGOE
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. C SHARMA R-3, MR. S C KEYAL,MR. A HUSSAIN (R-
Page No.# 2/11
3),MR. S SAIKIA (R-3),PP, ASSAM,ASSTT.S.G.I.,MR. C SHARMA (R-3),MR. J ROY(R-3)
BEFORE :
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE NCHUMBEMO MOZHUI
Advocates for the Petitioner(s) : Mr. I.H. Saikia
Advocate for the Respondent(s) : Mr. R.K.D. Choudhury,
CGC
Date on which judgment is reserved : 12.11.2016
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 17.11.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative part of the judgment : Full judgment.
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced : Yes.
JUDGEMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. I.H. Saikia, Learned counsel for the Petitioners. Also heard Mr.
R.K.D. Choudhury, learned CGC, for the Respondents.
2. The instant petition is filed under 226 of the Constitution of India for
issuance of a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction of the like nature praying for setting aside and quashing the
impugned Memorandum of Charges dated. 21.03.2012 (Annexure-1 to the writ
petition), the Enquiry Report submitted by the Enquiry Officer (Annexure-5 to
the writ petition), the impugned punishment order dated 27.11.2015, imposing
Page No.# 3/11
punishment upon the petitioner (Annexure-11 to the writ petition) and by
directing/commanding respondent authorities to exonerate the petitioner from
the charges by giving him all the consequential benefits of his service:
3. The brief fact of the case is that the petitioner was initially appointed on
10.07.2001 as Assistant Executive Engineer (Civil) and was posted at 397 Road
Maintenance Platoon under 70 Road Construction Company in Himachal
Pradesh. He was promoted to the post of Executive Engineer by an order dated.
01.10.2009 and was posted at Leh, Jammu and Kashmir. Thereafter, he was
transferred to Simla, where he joined on 04.01.2012. Sometime in the month of
February, 2014, he was transferred to Naharlagun, Arunachal Pradesh, where he
was attached as Officer on Special Duty, East at Jalukbari, Guwahati, Assam
vide an order dated 10.02.2015 and till date he is attached in the said capacity.
While the petitioner was posted at Jammu and Kashmir, an accident took
place while he was serving as Officer Commanding, 51 Road Construction
Company at Leh, Project Hiamnk, Jammu and Kashmir alleging mishandling
explosive by personnel’s below him. Thereafter, he was asked to show cause, by
issuing a Memorandum of Charges vide letter dated. 21.03.2012, alleging
mishandling of explosive by personnel below him and why appropriate
disciplinary action should be initiated against him. Petitioner submitted his reply
on 13.04.2012, thereby denying the allegations leveled, with a further prayer to
hear him in person. On receipt of the reply, the Disciplinary Authority appointed
Inquiring Authority and Presiding Officer on 07.06.2012. On conclusion of the
Inquiry, the Enquiry Report was prepared and submitted by the Inquiring
Authority holding the charges to be proved. The said Enquiry Report was served
upon the petitioner vide letter dated 09.02.2015. Against the Inquiry Report, the
petitioner submitted his detailed representation on 21.02.2015 with a prayer to
Page No.# 4/11
exonerate him from the charges, mentioning all the deficiencies in the entire
Inquiry process. But, in clear violation of the prevailing Department of Personnel
& Training Guidelines, the Disciplinary Authority concluded the Disciplinary
Proceeding and passed the impugned punishment order dated 27.11.2015,
holding the charged framed against the petitioner to be partially proved and
imposing a penalty of withholding 3 (three) increments of the petitioner without
cumulative effect. Being aggrieved, the petitioner is before this Hon'ble Court for
protecting the petitioner from the arbitrary actions of the respondent
authorities.
4. Mr. I.H. Saikia, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the entire
process of Departmental/Disciplinary Proceeding is vitiated by law in the ground
that since the petitioner was appointed through competitive exam conducted by
the Union Public Service Commission (hereinafter referred to as UPSC), and the
incident happened while he was serving as Executive Engineer in the capacity of
Officer Commanding, 51 Road Construction Company at Leh, Project Hiamnk,
Jammu and Kashmir under the Ministry of Road Transport and Highway, the
manner by which the entire Departmental/Disciplinary Proceedings was
conducted is in contravention to Department of Personnel & Training (DOP&T)
guidelines issued vide Office Memorandum dated 10.05.2011, whereby the
Government has provided that after Enquiry Report is submitted by the
Inquiring Authority together with the representation submitted by the charged
officer, it should be sent to the UPSC, addressing the points raised by the
Charged Officer in his reply. Further, as per the Department of Personnel &
Training Guideline issued vide Office Memorandum dated 05.03.2014, whereby
on receipt of Commission's advice, a copy of the advice may be provided to the
Government Servant, who may be allowed to submit his representation, if any,
Page No.# 5/11
on the Commission's advice within 15 days. The Disciplinary Authority will
consider the Inquiry Report, advice of the Commission and the representation(s)
of the Government Servant before arriving at a final decision. However, in the
instant case the respondent authorities have not followed the guideline and as
such the whole Departmental proceeding and the penalty imposed are bad in
law and liable to be interfered by this Hon’ble Court.
5. The learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the penalty was
imposed upon the petitioner to the extent of withholding 3 (three) increments
without cumulative effect consequent upon a disciplinary proceeding drawn
against him. The penalty so imposed upon the petitioner is in gross violation of
the provisions of Rule 16 of the CCS (CCA) Rules 1965. Rule 16(e) mandates
that no order imposing on a government servant any of that penalties specified
in clauses (i) to (iv) of Rule 11 shall be made except after consulting the UPSC,
where such consultation is necessary. It was the contention of the petitioner
that withholding of increments of pay is a minor penalty under Rule 11(iv) of
the CCS (CCA) Rules 1965, and hence, consultation with the UPSC prior to
imposition of penalty was mandatory. It was the further contention of the
petitioner that he being a civilian in the Border Roads Organization will be
governed by the provisions of CCA(CCA) Rules, 1965. In this connection the
petitioner has also relied upon the decision rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in the case of R. Viswan & Ors -Vs- Union of India & Ors reported in
(1983) 3 SCC 401 .
6. Mr. R.K.D. Choudhury, learned CGC for the respondents submits that under
Regulation 5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958
issued vide Notification No. G.S.R.789 dated 01.09.1958 by the Ministry of
Home Affairs, Government of India, which reads as “It shall not be necessary to
Page No.# 6/11
consult the Commission in regard to any disciplinary matter affecting a person belonging to a
Defence service (Civilian)”.
7. It is further contented by the respondent’s counsel that the issue of
consultation with UPSC in disciplinary matters in respect of serving GREF Civilian
Officers of Border Roads Organisation, has been clarified by the Ministry of
Defence vide OM dated 24.10.2019, by holding that the provisions of Clause
5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958 will apply in
respect of serving GREF Officers of BRO in the matters of disciplinary
proceeding under CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
8. The learned counsel for the respondents further submits that all matters
relating to Border Roads Development Board and Border Roads Organisation,
which was earlier under the Ministry Of Road Transport was brought under the
Ministry of Defence by the Cabinet Secretariat Notification dated 09.01.2025.
9. In support of his contentions above, the counsel relies in the case of R.
Viswan (Supra), wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that the Civilian
Members of the BRO are members of the Armed Forces within the meaning of
Article 33 of the Constitution of India. The counsel further contents that the
previously mentioned decision was rendered way back in 1983, whereas, the
BRO came under the Ministry of Defence only 2015. In that view of the matter
the provision of Regulation Clause 5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from
Consultation) Regulations, 1958 squarely applies to the petitioner and there is
no necessity for consultation with the UPSC.
10. The counsel further reiterates that in the case of R. Viswan (Supra), the
Hon’ble Apex Court has also held that the GREF/BRO has dual disciplinary
authority, namely the authority as prescribed under the Army Act as also under
the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The said proposition laid down in the
Page No.# 7/11
aforementioned case has also been reiterated in the case of Mohammed
Ansari -Vs- Union of India reported in (2017) 3 SCC 740 . The counsel also
relies on the decision followed by a co-ordinate bench of this Hon'ble Court in
the judgment and order dated 14.07.2026 in WP(C) No. 4861/2024 (Randhir
Kumar & Ors -Vs-Union of India & 5 Ors) on the same proposition.
11. The counsel therefore submits that in view of the settled position of law as
stated above, there is no legal infirmity with the departmental proceeding and
the punishment imposed upon the petitioner by the disciplinary authority.
12. Per contra, the learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the incident
occurred when the petitioner was posted at Jammu and Kashmir and the
memorandum of charges was issued on 21.03.2012 and the entire disciplinary
proceedings, whereby the petitioner has replied to the memorandum of charges
including the submission of the Enquiry Report and the submission of the
representation by the petitioner occurred, when the petitioner was serving
Officer Commanding, 51 Road Construction Company at Leh, Project Hiamnk,
Jammu and Kashmir under the Ministry of Road Transport and Highway.
13. The counsel further submits that under such circumstances, the
Department of Personnel & Training (DOP&T) guidelines issued vide Office
Memorandum dated 10.05.2011 ought to have been followed for the fact that
the subsequent Notifications dated 09.01.2015 and Office Memorandum dated
24.10.2019 being adopted only thereafter the proceeding had already been
initiated.
14. Heard the parties at length and the decisions relied upon.
15. The Department of Personnel & Training (DOP&T) guidelines issued vide
Office Memorandum dated 10.05.2011 being statutory in nature, the compliance
Page No.# 8/11
of which are mandatory in nature. Further, the provisions of the Office
Memorandum dated 05.03.2014 mandates that the Enquiry Report along with
the representation of the petitioner should have been forwarded to the UPSC for
advice. Thereafter, on receipt of UPSC advice the same ought to have been
furnished to the petitioner to allow him to submit his representation. The
guidelines also further stipulated that the disciplinary committee as mandated
shall consider the inquiry report, advice of the UPSC and representation before
arriving to any decision.
16. A perusal of the records will reveal that Office Memorandum dated
24.10.2019 has been issued by the Ministry of Defence, Government of India is
reproduced herein below for ready reference: -
“ F. No. BRDB/02(09)/2015-GE.II(Pt)
Government of India
Ministry of Defence
D(Vigilance-MES & BRO)
*
Room No.138,Kashmir House,
New Delhi, dated 24th October, 2019
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
SUBJECT: Consultation with UPSC in disciplinary matters in
respect of serving GREF Civilian Officers of Border Roads
Organization - clarifications regarding
Undersigned is directed to state that the issue regarding need for
consultation with UPSC in disciplinary matters in respect of serving
General Reserve Engineer Force (GREF) Officers of Border Roads
Organization (BRO), has been under consideration of the Ministry of
Defence, in consultation with DoPT and UPSC.
2. With the approval of Competent Authority, of Ministry of Defence, it has
Page No.# 9/11
been decided as under:
The provisions of Clause 5(2) of UPSC (Exemption for
Consultation) Regulations, 1958, will apply in respect of serving
GREF officers of BRO in the matters of disciplinary proceedings, under
CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
3. The disciplinary, cases in respect of GREF Officers, may be processed
accordingly.
Sd/
24/10/19
(S. Khajuria)
Deputy Secretary to the Government of India
Ph: 23793245
1. Directorate General Border Roads
(Lt. Gen. Harpal Singh, PVSM, VSM)
Seema Sadak Bhawan, Ring Road, Delhi Cantt
NEW DELHI-110010
2. Joint Secretary(BR)
South Block, New Delhi
3. Department of Personnel & Training
(Shri Rajbir Singh, US (Estt.B-1)
North Block, New Delhi
w.r.t their ID Note
No.39018/03/2016-Estt.B dated
21.08.2019.”
17. However, in the present proceedings, there is no dispute that the
petitioner is not regular members of the armed forces or the army. No doubt the
army authorities are also the controlling authorities insofar as BRO and GREF is
concerned, however, in the facts of the present proceedings, the authority
merely recommended initiation of departmental proceedings against the
petitioner. There was no recommendation for court-martial proceedings against
Page No.# 10/11
the writ petitioner as per the procedure prescribed under the Army Act read
with the rules. Such proceedings perhaps were not initiated as the petitioner
was civilian personnel and not regular army personnel. The Inquiry therefore
recommended departmental proceedings to be initiated against the petitioners
under CCS(CCA) Rules.
18. Moreover, as per letter dated 24.10.2019 issued by the Ministry of
Defence, Government of India, it reveals that consultation with the UPSC in the
disciplinary proceeding against the petitioner belonging to Defence Service
(Civilian), has been clarified with the approval of the competent authority in the
ministry as per Office Memorandum of even dated 24.10.2019.
As such, that the petitioner being a Civilian Members of the BRO, is also
members of the Armed Forces within the meaning of Article 33 of the
Constitution of India and the BRO came under the Ministry of Defence only
2015, the provision of Regulation Clause 5 (2) of the UPSC (Exemption from
Consultation) Regulations, 1958 squarely applies to the petitioner and there is
no necessity for consultation with the UPSC.
19. This Court has also taken into consideration of the decision in the case of
Mohammed Ansari (Supra) , wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that: -
“ 10. After adverting to the constitutional validity of Section 29 of the 1950 Act, the
Court deliberated upon SRO 329 and 330 issued under the said Act and the Army
Rules 1954 and expressed thus:-
"The history, composition, administration, organisation and role of GREF which we
have described above while narrating the facts clearly show that GREF is an integral
part of the Armed Forces. It is undoubtedly a departmental construction agency as
contended on behalf of the petitioners but it is distinct from other construction
agencies such as Central Public Works Department etc. in that it is a Force intended
primarily to support the Army in its operational requirement. It is significant to note
that the Border Roads organisation, which is in overall control of GREF was originally
created as part of Army Headquarters and it was only later, for reasons of high policy,
Page No.# 11/11
that it was separated from Army Headquarters and placed under the Border Roads
Development Board.”
20. In view of the discussion above, this Court does not find any merit in the
petition seeking the interference of this Court to interfere with the Departmental
Proceeding, Impugned Enquiry report and the Impugned Punishment Order
dated 27.11.2015 issued against the petitioner and further to issue any
consequential orders. Therefore, the claim made by the petitioner fails and the
writ petition being devoid of merit the same is accordingly, dismissed.
21. No order as to cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant