Ms Jfe Steel India Private Limited vs Union Of India And Ors

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court


-1-
CWP-10191-2025

(O&M)
AB AND HARYANA
IN T
THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJA
RH
AT CHANDIGAR
M)

CWP-10191-2025 (O&M
...Petitioner
M/s JFE Steel In
ndia Private Limited
Versus
...Respondents
Union of India an
nd others
*
Reserved on: 18.
Pronounced on:
Judgment upload
.08.2026
17.11.2026
ded on: 18.11.2026

Whet

prono

Whet

ther only the operative part of the ju
ounced or the full judgment is pron
udgment is
nounced : Full Judgment
ther there is delay in uploading the
judgment : NA
*
N'BLE THECHIEF JUSTICE
CORAM: HON
HON

Present: Mr. V
Mr. A
Mr. A
Ms. K
for th

Mr. A
for th
KAPOOR
N’BLE MR. JUSTICE ROHIT KA

V. Lakshmikumaran, Senior Advoc
Amar Pratap Singh, Advocate,
Ankit Atwal, Advocate, and
cate, assisted by
Khushbu Sood, Advocate
he petitioner.
Ajay Kalra, Senior Standing Couns
he respondents-Revenue.


OR , J.
el, CBIC,
ROHIT KAPOO


1. The petition
ner, a Company incorporated unde
er the provisions of the Companie
es
Act 1956, has invo
oked the jurisdiction of this Court
t under Articles 226 and 227 of th
he
Constitution of Ind
dia seeking a writ in the nature of c
certiorari for quashing the Order-in
n-
Original No. 53/GS
ST-GGM/ADC/GD/2024-25 dated
d 09.01.2025 (Annexure P-1) passe
ed
by respondent No
.2, the Additional Commissioner,
, Central Goods and Services Ta
ax,
Gurugram, togethe
er with the summaries thereof uplo
oaded in Form GST DRC-07 date
ed
30.01.2025, and th
he proceedings initiated by the Sh
how Cause Notice No. 476/2024-2
25
dated 30.07.2024 (A
Annexure P-13) from which that or
rder arises.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-2-
CWP-10191-2025


2. By the imp
(O&M)
pugned order, a demand of Rs.1
13,08,57,858/- has been confirme
ed
against the petition
ner under Section 74(1) of the Ce
entral Goods and Services Tax Ac
ct,
2017 (for short, 't
the CGST Act') read with Sectio
on 20 of the Integrated Goods an
nd
Services Tax Act,
2017 (for short, 'the IGST Act'), a
along with interest under Section 5
50
and a penalty of
an equal amount of Rs.13,08,57
,858/- under Section 74 read wi
th
Section 122(2)(b)
of the CGST Act. The deman
nd rests on the premise that th
he
secondment of per
rsonnel by the petitioner's parent
t company, JFE Steel Corporatio
n,
Japan, constitutes
an import of 'manpower supply'
services by the petitioner from
a
related person, on w
which tax was payable by the petiti
ioner on reverse charge basis.
KGROUND
FACTUAL BACK

3. The facts, to
o the extent they are necessary for
the decision of this petition, are n
ot
in dispute and may
be noticed from the pleadings and
d the documents on record.

4. The petition
ner is a company incorporated
in India and is a wholly owne
ed
subsidiary of JFE
Steel Corporation, a company inc
corporated under the laws of Japa
an
(hereinafter referre
ed to as 'JFE Japan'). The petitione
r renders market research and allie
ed
services relating to
o the steel sector to JFE Japan u
under a General Service Agreeme
nt
dated 01.07.2008,
which was restated with effect fro
om 01.04.2013 (Annexure P-2) an
nd
was followed by
a further General Service Agre
eement effective from 01.04.201
17
(Annexure P-6).

5. For its opera
ations in India, the petitioner enga
ages certain personnel of JFE Japa
an.
The arrangement i
is governed by three sets of doc
cuments: (i) a Dispatch Agreeme
nt
executed between
JFE Japan and the petitioner on
01.04.2013 (Annexure P-3); (ii)
a
Secondment Agree
ement dated 01.04.2014 (Annexu
ure P-4), executed pursuant to th
he
Dispatch Agreeme
ent, which records the names an
nd identification particulars of th
he
personnel dispatch
hed; and (iii) individual Employme
ent Contracts executed between th
he
petitioner and each
h such person, a sample whereof is A
Annexure P-5.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-3-
CWP-10191-2025


6. Since much
(O&M)
turns on the manner in which the a
adjudicating authority has dealt wi
th
these documents, th
heir salient terms may be set out:
(i) Under
Article 1(a) of the Dispatch Agre
eement, JFE Japan is to dispatch i
its
personn
nel on the terms and condition
ns of employment set forth in a
an
employ
yment agreement to be entered into
o between the petitioner and each o
of
the disp
patched personnel, and it is the pet
titioner who is to define the positio
n,
role, sc
cope of work and other terms and c
conditions of such employment.
(ii) Under
Article 1(b), the function and wo
rk of the dispatched personnel is
to
be dec
cided solely by the petitioner, wh
hich is solely responsible for the
eir
work.
JFE Japan is not to be responsibl
e for such work nor to assume an
ny
risk fo
or its results, and the dispatched p
personnel, while under employmen
nt
with th
he petitioner, are not subject to an
ny instruction, control, direction o
or
superv
ision of JFE Japan and are to
report to the management of th
he
petition
ner alone.
(iii) Under
Article 1(d), the petitioner has th
he sole right to take punitive step
ps
against
t the dispatched personnel and to t
erminate their employment, and an
ny
dispute
e between the petitioner and such
personnel is to be resolved witho
ut
recours
se to JFE Japan.
(iv) Under
Article 1(e), JFE Japan agrees to r
release and discharge the dispatche
ed
personn
nel from all obligations toward
ds it while they are working a
as
employ
yees of the petitioner, and not to
enforce any contractual obligatio
on
which
they have or had as employees of J
JFE Japan during that period.
(v) Under
Article 3(d), the dispatched pe
ersonnel are not to carry on an
ny
comme
ercial or business activity in India f
for or on behalf of JFE Japan, nor
to
conclu
de contracts or act as its agent.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-4-
CWP-10191-2025

(vi) Under
(O&M)
Article 5(a), the petitioner is solel
ly responsible for the salary costs o
of
the dis
spatched personnel and for the inc
come tax thereon. The remuneratio
on
compri
ises a monthly salary in India, a m
monthly salary in Japan, a bonus
in
Japan a
and other allowances. In respect o
of the components payable in Japa
an,
the pe
etitioner may, at the request o
of the person concerned and fo
for
admini
istrative convenience, ask JFE Jap
pan to make the payment in Japa
an,
which
is then reimbursed by the petitione
er on actual cost basis against a deb
bit
note or
r invoice; the clause records that t
this arrangement shall in no mann
er
be con
sidered as affecting the employer-e
employee status of the petitioner an
nd
the dis
patched personnel. Article 5(c) rec
cords that such reimbursement is o
on
cost-to
o-cost basis and without any mark-u
up.
(vii) Under
Article 5(e), the social security e
xpenses, such as provident fund,
in
accord
ance with the laws prevailing in In
ndia are borne by the petitioner.
(viii) The sa
ample Employment Contract (An
nnexure P-5) appoints the perso
on
concern
ned as a 'Director' of the petitioner
r for a period of four years, stipulate
es
an ann
nual gross salary of which a portion
n is, at the employee's request, to b
be
paid in
n foreign currency in Japan, provid
des that the salary is net of incom
me
tax wh
hich the petitioner shall bear and
deposit under the Income Tax Ac
ct,
1961, a
and requires, by clause 4, that the e
employee shall work under full tim
me
employ
yment with the petitioner and shall
l not undertake any other business o
or
work e
except with its prior written permiss
sion.

7. It is the pe
titioner's case, which is not cont
troverted, that tax was deducted
at
source under Sect
ion 192 of the Income Tax Act
, 1961 on the entire salary of th
he
personnel so engag
ged, including the portion disburse
ed in Japan through JFE Japan, th
hat
Form 16 was issue
ed to each of them, and that they f
filed their returns of income in Ind
dia
under the head 'sala
aries' (Annexures P-18 and P-20).
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-5-
CWP-10191-2025


8. The same a
(O&M)
arrangement had engaged the atte
ention of the Department under th
he
Finance Act, 1994.
. Pursuant to an audit of the petitio
oner's records for the period 2013-1
14
to June 2017, a Sho
ow Cause Notice No. 13/2019-20 d
dated 22.04.2019 was issued allegin
ng
that the petitioner
had received 'manpower recruitme
ent or supply agency' services fro
m
JFE Japan and w
was liable to service tax on reve
rse charge basis. That notice wa
as
adjudicated by the
Principal Commissioner, CGST A
Audit Commissionerate, Panchkul
la,
who, by Order-in-O
Original No. 02/CGST/Commr/PK
KL/AKG/2020-21 dated 24.02.202
21
(Annexure P-7), ex
xamined the Dispatch Agreement a
and the Employment Contracts, he
ld
that the expatriates
s were employees of the petitioner
r during the period in question, an
nd
dropped the procee
edings.

9. The Departm
ment has carried that order in a
appeal to the Customs, Excise an
nd
Service Tax Appel
llate Tribunal, Chandigarh, (for sh
hort ‘CESTAT’) being Appeal N
No.
ST/60284/2021. It
is common ground that the appeal
is pending and that the operation o
of
the order dated 24.0
02.2021 has not been stayed.

10. It transpires
s that on 19.05.2022, the Suprem
me Court delivered its judgment
in
Commissioner of
Customs, Central Excise and Se
ervice Tax, Bangalore v. Norther
rn
SCC 90 . On the strength of th
hat
Operating System
ms Private Limited, (2022) 17
judgment, the offic
ce of the Commissioner, CGST, G
urugram, by letter dated 06.10.202
22
followed by a rem
minder dated 14.10.2022 (Annexure
e P-9), called upon the petitioner
to
furnish the agreem
ments relating to secondment and
the details of reimbursements an
nd
payments made in r
respect of seconded employees from
m 01.07.2017 onwards.

11. The petition
ner responded on 07.11.2022. It
furnished the Dispatch Agreemen
nt,
sample Employmen
nt Contracts and the Restated Gen
neral Service Agreement. It pointe
ed
out the features wh
hich according to it, distinguished
its case from
Northern Operatin
ng
Systems (supra). F
urther, it drew attention to the Ord
der-in-Original dated 24.02.2021 an
nd
in answer to the r
requisition for 'letters of understa
anding' entered into with seconde
ed
employees, it state
ed that no letter of understanding
had been executed and that it ha
MOHIT GOYAL ad
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-6-
CWP-10191-2025

directly executed e
(O&M)
mployment contracts with the pers
sonnel concerned. Further particula
ars
were sought by lett
ters dated 24.11.2023 and 12.12.20
023 (Annexure P-10), in response
to
which the petition
ner, on 29.11.2023 and 19.01.202
24, supplied its Forms 3CEB, th
he
detailed working o
of Form 24Q, the reconciliation o
f Form 24Q with Form 16 and th
he
details of salary, bo
onus and allowances reimbursed to
JFE Japan.

12. In the meant
time, on 13.12.2023, the Central Bo
oard of Indirect Taxes and Custom
ms-
respondent No.5 (h
hereinafter 'the Board') issued Instr
ruction No. 05/2023-GST (Annexu
re
P-11) on the subj
ject of the judgment in Northe
rn Operating Systems , to whic
ch
reference shall be m
made in detail hereafter.

13. An intimatio
on in Form GST DRC-01A was i
issued on 04.06.2024 under Sectio
on
74(5) of the CGST
T Act, to which the petitioner repli
ied on 18.06.2024 (Annexure P-12
2).
On 26.06.2024, th
he Board issued Circular No.
210/4/2024-GST (Annexure P-14
4)
clarifying the valua
ation of import of services by a reg
gistered person from a related perso
on
where the recipient
t is eligible for full input tax credit.


14. The Show C
Cause Notice dated 30.07.2024 fo
llowed. It proposed the recovery o
of
IGST of Rs.13,08,5
57,858/- under Section 74(1) of the
e CGST Act for the period July 201
17
to March 2023, c
omputed at 18% on Rs.75,31,34
4,267/-, being the aggregate of th
he
salaries paid to the
e expatriates as reflected in Form
m 24Q and Form 16 for that perio
d,
together with intere
est and penalty.

15. The petition
ner filed its reply in Form GST DR
RC-06 on 29.10.2024 and addition
nal
submissions on 19
9.12.2024 (Annexure P-15), the
latter placing specific reliance o
on
Circular No. 210/4
4/2024-GST and on the judgment
of the Delhi High Court in Met
al
One Corporation
India Private Limited v. Union
n of India and others, 2024 SC
C
. A personal hearing was held on
n 19.12.2024. The impugned ord
er
OnLine Del 7499
came to be passed
on 09.01.2025, and is stated to hav
ve been received by the petitioner o
on
21.01.2025.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-7-
CWP-10191-2025


16. It is in this
(O&M)
factual backdrop that the present
petition was filed. The responden
nts
have filed a reply
y by way of an affidavit of the
e Principal Commissioner, CGST
T,
Gurugram, to whic
ch the petitioner has filed a rejoin
nder. Written submissions have als
so
been placed on reco
ord on behalf of the petitioner.
NER
SUBMISSIONS O
ON BEHALF OF THE PETITION

17. Learned sen
nior counsel appearing on behalf of
f the petitioner has at the very outs
set
assailed the impug
gned order on the ground that the
jurisdictional pre-condition for th
he
exercise of power
under Section 74 of the CGST A
Act, namely non-payment of tax 'b
by
reason of fraud, o
or any wilful-misstatement or sup
ppression of facts to evade tax',
is
wholly absent. It i
s argued that the only allegation i
in the show cause notice is that th
he
petitioner filed its
returns in Form GSTR-3B witho
out paying IGST on the transactio
n.
This arrangement,
according to the learned senior
r counsel, was fully known to th
he
Department, since
the audit under the service tax re
egime, had been adjudicated in th
he
petitioner's favour
on 24.02.2021, and concerned a
question which was the subject o
of
extensive litigation
n resolved in favour of assessees u
until 19.05.2022. It is contended th
hat
the facts involved
in Northern Operating Systems
s (supra),were quite distinct beside
es
the fact that the Su
upreme Court in the said case had
d itself held the extended period o
of
limitation to be un
navailable. It is urged that the Bo
oard's Instruction No. 05/2023-GS
ST
forbids the mechan
nical invocation of Section 74 in sec
condment cases.

18. Reliance is
placed on Cosmic Dye Chemica
al v. Collector of Central Excis
se,
Bombay, (1995) 6
6 SCC 117;M/s Padmini Produc
cts v. Collector of Central Excis
se,
) 4 SCC 275 ; Continental Foun
Bangalore, (1989)
dation Joint Venture Holding
v.
Central Excise, Chandigarh-I , (
(2007) 10 SCC 337; Uniflex Cable
Commissioner of
es
-II, (2011) 14 SCC 568; and Raz
Limited v. Comm
missioner, Central Excise, Surat-
za
, as also on th
, (1973) 1 SCC 633
he
Textiles Limited v
v. Income Tax Officer, Rampur,
recent decisions of
f the Supreme Court in M/s G.R.
Infra Projects Limited v. State o
of
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-8-
CWP-10191-2025

Madhya Pradesh
(O&M)
r (SC) 5091 and M/s Tata Ste
and others, 2026 Law Finder
eel
Limited v. Union
of India and others, 2026 INSC
C 920 (Civil Appeal arising out o
of
.
SLP (C) No. 16859
9 of 2026, decided on 25.08.2026)

19. It is further
contended that the impugned ord
der has been passed in the teeth o
of
Circular No. 210/4
4/2024-GST dated 26.06.2024, wh
hich is binding on respondent No
.2
under Section 168(
(1) of the CGST Act. The petitione
er and JFE Japan are related person
ns.
The petitioner is el
igible for full input tax credit, and
admittedly no invoice was raised b
by
the petitioner in res
spect of the alleged import of servi
ice. In terms of paragraph 3.7 of th
he
Circular read with
the second proviso to Rule 28(1)
of the Central Goods and Service
es
Tax Rules, 2017 (
(for short, 'the CGST Rules'), th
he value of the supply is therefo
re
deemed to be 'Nil'
. The identical question stands co
oncluded by Metal One and by th
he
judgment of the
Karnataka High Court in Alsto
om Transport India Limited
v.
72 .
Commissioner of
Commercial Taxes and others
s, 2025 SCC OnLine Kar 1557
Reliance is also pla
aced on Commissioner of Centra
al Excise, Bolpur v. Ratan Meltin
ng
ries, (2008)13 SCC 1, on the bi
inding nature of circulars upon th
he
and Wire Industr
Department.

20. Submission
is that the identical arrangement,
in the petitioner's own case, havin
ng
been held to be on
ne of employment, the Department
t cannot take a contrary stand for
a
subsequent period
without any change in facts. Relia
ance is placed on M/s Radhasoam
mi
ncome Tax, (1992) 1 SCC 659 an
nd
Satsang, Saomi B
agh, Agra v. Commissioner of In
(2006) 3 SCC 1 .
Bharat Sanchar N
Nigam Limited v. Union of India (

21. It is submi
itted that the impugned order is
s non-speaking. It reproduces th
he
allegations in the sh
how cause notice as its findings an
nd does not deal with the petitioner
r's
detailed reply, the
terms of the agreements, the ord
der dated 24.02.2021 or the Board
d's
Instruction. Relian
nce is placed on Section 75(6) o
of the CGST Act and on Kran
nti
Khan, (2010) 9 SCC 496 , S.N
Associates Privat
te Limited v. Masood Ahmed
N.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-9-
CWP-10191-2025

Mukherjee v. Un
(O&M)
and A.K. Kraipak and others v
ion of India(1990) 4 SCC 594,
vs.
d others (1969) 2 SCC 262 .
Union of India and

22. It is submit
tted that without prejudice to the
other arguments raised, on a tru
ue
reading of the agr
reements, the expatriates are emp
ployees of the petitioner during th
he
period of their en
ngagement, and the services rend
dered by them are services by a
an
employee to the e
employer in the course of employ
yment, which, by virtue of Sectio
on
7(2)(a) read with p
paragraph 1 of Schedule III to the
CGST Act, are neither a supply o
of
goods nor a supply
y of services. Northern Operating
g Systems (supra) turned on its ow
wn
facts and is disting
guishable. In any event, the exerci
ise is revenue neutral, the petition
er
being entitled to cr
redit of any tax paid on reverse ch
harge basis, and neither interest no
or
penalty is leviable.

23. As regards t
the objection of alternative remedy
y, learned senior counsel relies upo
on
1 ,
Whirlpool Corpo
ration v. Registrar of Trade M
Marks, Mumbai, (1998) 8 SCC
Godrej Sara Lee
Limited v. Excise and Taxation
Officer-cum-Assessing Authorit
ty,
e SC 95 , Embassy Property Deve
2023 SCC OnLine
elopments Private Limited v. Sta
te
2020) 13 SCC 308 , Assistant
of Karnataka, (2
Commissioner of State Tax
v.
SC 884 and Magadh Sugar an
Commercial Stee
l Limited, 2021 SCC OnLine
nd
ne SC 801 .
Energy Limited v.
. State of Bihar, 2021 SCC OnLin
DENTS
SUBMISSIONS O
ON BEHALF OF THE RESPOND

24. Learned Se
enior Standing Counsel for the r
respondents has, at the threshol
d,
objected to the p
petition being entertained. It is u
urged that the impugned order
is
appealable under S
ection 107 of the CGST Act and th
hat the petitioner has approached th
his
Court without avai
iling that remedy. Reliance is pla
aced on State of Maharashtra an
nd
C 332 , to contend that a writ petitio
on
others v. Greatshi
ip (India) Limited, (2022) 17 SCC
against an order of
f assessment ought not to be enter
rtained where the statute provides
a
remedy of appeal.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-10-
CWP-10191-2025


25. On merits, th
(O&M)
he respondents support the impugn
ned order for the reasons recorded
in
it. It is submitted
d that the adjudicating authority
has examined the clauses of th
he
agreements and h
has found the arrangement to b
be squarely covered by Norther
rn
ms (supra). The invocation of Secti
ion 74 has been justified in terms o
of
Operating System
the findings in par
ragraphs D-19 and D-20, wherein
it was inter alia observed that th
he
facts regarding th
he alleged contraventions were
not reflected in the regular sel
lf-
assessment returns
filed by the petitioner, and greate
er responsibility casts under the sa
id
system. It was ob
bserved that the petitioner was ob
bliged to declare all material fac
cts
necessary for corre
ect assessment of tax and therefore
e it was held that it appeared to hav
ve
wilfully suppressed
d such facts with intent to evade
payment of GST liabilities. It wa
as
further recorded tha
at had the investigation not been in
nitiated by the department, the matt
er
would have never
come to its notice, and it was the
erefore concluded that the petition
er
appears to have vio
olated the provisions of the releva
ant Act/Rules and notifications. It
is
contended that the
e Circular dated 26.06.2024 and th
he judgment in Metal One (supr
a)
have been duly con
nsidered by the competent authority
y while passing the order in origina
al,
and the same were
e found to be inapplicable becau
use consideration is involved in th
he
present case. It is f
further submitted that the order dat
ted 24.02.2021 under the service ta
ax
regime is under ap
ppeal, and that the principles of n
natural justice were complied wit
th,
since the petitione
er's reply and additional submissi
ions having been considered and
a
personal hearing af
fforded.

26. We have he
eard the learned counsels for the
parties and have gone through th
he
material available o
on record, with their able assistance
e.
R DETERMINATION
QUESTIONS FOR

27. Upon consid
deration of the rival contentions of
f the parties, the following question
ns
arise for determinat
tion:-
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-11-
CWP-10191-2025

(A) Wheth
(O&M)
er the petition ought not to be ente
ertained on account of the remedy o
of
appeal
under Section 107 of the CGST A
ct?;
(B) Wheth
er the proceedings could validly
have been initiated and conclude
ed
under S
Section 74 of the CGST Act?;
(C) Wheth
er the demand could have been c
confirmed notwithstanding Circul
ar
No. 21
0/4/2024-GST dated 26.06.2024?;
and
(D) Wheth
er the impugned order satisfies the
requirement of a reasoned order?
FINDINGS
ANALYSIS AND
medy
(A) Alternative rem

28. That the imp
pugned order is appealable under S
Section 107 of the CGST Act is n
ot
in doubt. The ques
stion is whether that circumstance
should lead this Court to decline
to
examine the petitio
on.

29. The law on
n the subject is well settled. In W
Whirlpool Corporation (supra), th
he
Supreme Court held
d:
"15. U
Under Article 226 of the Constitu
ution, the High Court, having
regard
d to the facts of the case, has a di
iscretion to entertain or not to
enterta
ain a writ petition. But the High C
Court has imposed upon itself
certain
n restrictions one of which is that
if an effective and efficacious
remedy
y is available, the High Court wo
ould not normally exercise its
jurisdic
ction. But the alternative remedy
has been consistently held by
this Co
ourt not to operate as a bar in
at least three contingencies,
namely
y, where the writ petition has bee
en filed for the enforcement of
any of
f the Fundamental Rights or where
e there has been a violation of
the pri
inciple of natural justice or where
e the order or proceedings are
wholly
without jurisdiction or the vires of
f an Act is challenged. ..."
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-12-
CWP-10191-2025


30. In Godrej S
(O&M)
Sara Lee Limited (supra), an appe
eal which arose from an order of th
his
Court relegating th
he assessee to the statutory remedy
y, the Supreme Court reiterated th
hat
the rule requiring a
a party to pursue the alternative rem
medy is a rule of policy, convenienc
ce
and discretion rath
her than a rule of law; that 'maint
ainability' and 'entertainability' of
f a
writ petition are di
stinct concepts; and that the dismi
ssal of a writ petition on the groun
nd
that the alternativ
ve remedy has not been availed
d, without examining whether a
an
exceptional case f
for entertainment has been mad
de out, would not be proper. Th
he
decisions in Emba
assy Property Developments , Com
mmercial Steel and Magadh Suga
ar
and Energy (supra
a) are to the same effect and recogn
nise, as exceptions to the rule, case
es
of want of jurisdic
ction, of violation of the principles
s of natural justice and those whic
ch
turn on a pure ques
stion of law on admitted facts.

31. Greatship (
(India) Limited (supra), on which
h the respondents rely, does not la
ay
down anything to t
the contrary. That was a case whe
ere the High Court had entertained
a
writ petition again
nst an order of assessment and ha
d itself entered into its merits. Th
he
Supreme Court in
n the said case, held that the st
tatute having provided a comple
ete
machinery of appe
eal, the assessee ought to have b
been relegated to it. The judgme
nt
applies the general
l rule, it does not purport to do aw
way with the exceptions which hav
ve
been part of the law
w since long before Whirlpool C
orporation (supra) and which hav
ve
been reaffirmed the
ereafter in Godrej Sara Lee Limit
ted (supra).

32. The present
petition falls within those except
tions on more than one count. Firs
st,
the challenge to t
the invocation of Section 74 go
oes to the very foundation of th
he
proceedings. The e
existence of fraud, wilful misstatem
ment or suppression of facts to evad
de
tax is the condition
n on which the power under that p
provision depends, and whether th
he
show cause notice
discloses that condition is to be a
answered on a reading of the notic
ce
itself. Secondly, the
e complaint is that a statutory autho
ority has refused to follow a circul
ar
issued by the Board
d under Section 168(1) of the CGS
T Act, which the statute obliges it
to
observe and follow
w. That is a pure question of law
w on facts which are not in disput
te.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-13-
CWP-10191-2025

Thirdly, the grievan
(O&M)
nce that the order does not deal w
with the petitioner's defence is one o
of
breach of the princ
ciples of natural justice. No dispu
uted question of fact requires to b
be
resolved to decide
any of these questions. It may be a
added that the petition has remaine
ed
pending before this
s Court since April 2025, pleading
gs are complete, and the matter ha
as
been heard at leng
gth. To relegate the petitioner to a
an appeal at this stage, on question
ns
which can be answ
ered on the face of the record, wou
uld serve no purpose.

33. The prelimin
nary objection is accordingly overr
ruled.
Section 74 of the CGST Act
(B) Invocation of S

34. Section 73 o
of the CGST Act provides for the d
determination of tax not paid or sho
ort
paid 'for any reason
n other than fraud or any wilful-mi
sstatement or suppression of facts
to
evade tax'. Section
n 74 applies where the non-paymen
nt or short payment is 'by reason o
of
fraud, or any wilfu
l-misstatement or suppression of fa
acts to evade tax'. The consequence
es
of the distinction a
are substantial. An order under Sec
ction 73 must be made within thre
ee
years from the due
e date for furnishing the annual re
eturn for the relevant financial yea
ar,
whereas Section 74
4 allows five years, and the penalt
ty under Section 74 is equivalent
to
the tax. Section 74
4 is thus an exception to the ordi
inary rule, available only where i
its
distinct pre-conditi
ons exist.

35. The words u
used in Section 74(1) have a long
g legislative and judicial history. I
In
mical (supra), a Bench of three
Judges, construing the proviso
to
Cosmic Dye Che
Section 11-A of th
he Central Excises and Salt Act, 19
944, held that the intent to evade
is
built into the word
ds 'fraud' and 'collusion'; that 'misst
tatement or suppression of facts' ar
re
qualified by the w
word 'wilful'; and that it is not c
correct to say that there can be
a
suppression or mis
statement of fact which is not wilf
ful and yet constitutes a permissib
ble
ground for invokin
ng the extended period. That sta
atement of the law was applied
to
Section 73 of the F
Finance Act, 1994 in Northern O
Operating Systems itself, where th
he
Supreme Court als
o noticed the earlier view that the
e conclusion that mere non-payme
nt
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-14-
CWP-10191-2025

of duties is equiva
(O&M)
alent to collusion or wilful misst
tatement or suppression of facts
is
untenable. In Sect
tion 74(1) of the CGST Act, Par
rliament has made the requiremen
nt
express by the word
ds 'to evade tax', which govern all t
three expressions.

36. The position
n under the CGST Act has now b
een stated by the Supreme Court
in
two decisions rend
dered in August 2026. In
G.R. In
(supra), th
nfra Projects Limited
he
Court set aside a sh
how cause notice issued under Sect
tion 74 and held:
"10. A
bare reading of the notice would
d indicate that but for a bland
stateme
ent of 'fraud or concealment of fac
cts' nothing is stated as to how
fraud w
was inferred or concealment of fa
facts were detected. ... What is
require
ed for the extended time to be app
plied are the allegations, which
lead to
o the inference of a fraud or the co
oncealment as attempted by the
assesse
ee resulting in suppression of fa
cts, should emanate from the
notice
itself. It cannot be a mechanical u
use of the words 'fraud, willful
misstat
tement or suppression of facts' w
without listing out the aspects
which p
persuades the assessing officer to
o conclude that there has been
employ
yed either of these surreptitious dev
vices by the assessee."

37. The Court f
further declined to look at the cou
unter affidavit filed by the State
to
supply what the no
tice lacked, on the principle that th
he requirements which make a notic
ce
or order valid mus
st be contained in the notice or o
order itself. In Tata Steel Limite
ed
(supra), the Court r
reiterated:
"14. It
is not mere lip service to the provi
isions that is intended when an
extende
ed limitation period is provided ...
. The foundational facts which
led
to the inference arrive
ed at of fraud/willful
misrep
presentation/suppression should be
e evident from the notice itself.
The me
ere employment of such words will
l not indicate an application of
mind, u
upon which alone the satisfaction
can be arrived at. The words
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-15-
CWP-10191-2025

(O&M)
are no
ot to be mechanically recited in
the notice to enable recovery
outside
e the normal limitation provided un
nder the statute"

38. The Board
has taken the same view of the p
provision in the specific context o
of
secondment. Inst
truction No. 05/2023-GST da
ated 13.12.2023, after noticin
ng
representations tha
at field formations were mechan
nically invoking Section 74(1)
in
secondment cases,
states:
"3.3 F
From the perusal of wording of se
ction 74(1) of CGST Act, it is
evident
t that section 74(1) can be invoked
d only in cases where there is a
fraud o
or wilful mis-statement or suppress
sion of facts to evade tax on the
part of
f the said taxpayer. Section 74(1)
cannot be invoked merely on
accoun
nt of non-payment of GST, withou
ut specific element of fraud or
wilful
mis-statement or suppression of f
facts to evade tax. Therefore,
only in
n the cases where the investigation
indicates that there is material
evidenc
ce of fraud or wilful mis-statem
ent or suppression of fact to
evade
tax on the part of the taxpayer, p
provisions of section 74(1) of
CGST
Act may be invoked for issuance o
of show cause notice, and such
evidenc
ce should also be made a part of th
he show cause notice."

39. Tested on th
hese principles, the show cause not
tice dated 30.07.2024 does not mak
ke
out a case for Se
ection 74. The entire justification
n is contained in two paragraph
hs.
Paragraph 9.12 stat
tes that the tax appears recoverabl
e under Section 74 'as it is appare
nt
that M/s JFE India
has resorted to willful-misstateme
ent and suppression of facts as it ha
ad
filed GSTR-3B wit
thout payment of IGST'. Paragraph
h 9.13 states that Section 74 is liab
ble
to be invoked 'in a
s much as that the judgement of H
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matt
er
of Northern Opera
ating Systems is clarificatory in
nature' and that the services we
re
taxable since the ad
dvent of GST, and concludes that
'hence' the tax has not been paid 'b
by
reason of fraud, or
any wilful-misstatement or suppres
ssion of facts to evade tax'.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-16-
CWP-10191-2025


40. Neither para
(O&M)
agraph discloses a single fact from
m which an intent to evade could b
be
inferred. The first e
equates non-payment of tax in the
return with wilful misstatement an
nd
suppression, which
h is the very proposition that has
s been held untenable and that th
he
Board's own Instru
uction forbids. The second is a no
on sequitur . That a judgment of th
he
Supreme Court dec
clares the law as it always was, may
y have a bearing on whether tax wa
as
payable. It says no
othing about the intent of an asses
ssee who did not pay it. Indeed, th
he
judgment relied up
on points the other way. In Northe
ern Operating Systems (supra) , th
he
Supreme Court, hav
ving held the assessee liable on me
erits, went on to hold:
"71. Th
The fact that CESTAT in the presen
nt case, relied upon two of its
previou
us orders, which were pressed int
to service, and also that in the
presen
t case itself, the Revenue dischar
rged the later two show-cause
notices
s, evidences that the view held by
the assessee about its liability
was ne
either untenable, nor mala fide. Thi
is is sufficient to turn down the
Revenu
ue's contention about the existence
of 'wilful suppression' of facts,
or deli
iberate misstatement. For these r
reasons, the Revenue was not
justifie
ed in invoking the extended period
of limitation to fasten liability
on the
assessee."

41. The petition
ner's case stands on a firmer footing
g than that of the assessee before th
he
Supreme Court in N
upra) . The arrangement under whic
ch
Northern Operating Systems (su
personnel of JFE J
Japan work with the petitioner wa
as examined in audit for the perio
od
2013-14 to June 2
2017. The Dispatch Agreement an
nd the Employment Contracts we
re
before the Departm
ment. A show cause notice was
issued on 22.04.2019 on the sam
me
allegation that is n
now made. On 24.02.2021, that is
s, during the period covered by th
he
present demand, a
Principal Commissioner of the De
epartment adjudicated the notice an
nd
held that the exp
atriates were employees of the
petitioner and that no service o
of
manpower supply
had been received. That order h
has not been stayed. It is not th
he
respondents' case
that the arrangement underwent
any change after June 2017. A
An
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-17-
CWP-10191-2025

assessee who has in
(O&M)
n hand an adjudication order of the
e Department itself, holding that th
he
very transaction is
not taxable, cannot be said to ha
ave suppressed that transaction fro
m
the Department wit
th intent to evade tax by not paying
g tax on it. Suppression pre-suppose
es
that something was
s kept back. Here, nothing was.

42. The impugn
ned order does not improve upon th
he notice. Paragraphs 4.18 and 4.1
19
of the order reprod
duce paragraphs 9.12 and 9.13 of
the notice. The only findings of th
he
adjudicating author
rity on the point are in paragraphs
D-19 and D-20, which state that th
he
contraventions cam
me to the knowledge of the Depa
artment only when the investigatio
on
was initiated, that t
the facts were not reflected in the s
self-assessed returns, that 'all sorts o
of
guidance' was avai
lable to the petitioner, and that had
d the investigation not been initiate
ed
the matter would n
ever have come to the notice of the
e Department. These are generalitie
es
which could be rec
cited in any case of non-payment. T
The statement that the facts came
to
light only on inves
stigation is contrary to the record,
for the reasons already noticed. Th
he
order does not adv
vert to the petitioner's specific def
fence that the facts were within th
he
knowledge of the D
Department, to the order dated 24.0
02.2021 in this context, to paragrap
ph
71 of Northern O
perating Systems (supra), or to th
he Board's Instruction No. 05/2023
3-
GST, though each o
of these was pressed in the reply.

43. The reply fi
filed in this Court does no more t
than extract paragraph D-20 of th
he
impugned order. In
n any case, as held in G.R. Infra
Projects Limited (supra), what th
he
notice lacks cannot
t be supplied by an affidavit.

44. It was faint
tly suggested in the impugned ord
der that the petitioner was workin
ng
under a system of
f self-assessment and was obliged
d to declare all material facts in i
its
returns. That an as
ssessee who bona fide believes tha
at a transaction is not a supply, an
nd
does not report it as
s one in its returns, is not making a
a suppression to evade tax. If it wer
re,
every case of non-
-payment would be a case under S
Section 74 and Section 73 would b
be
rendered otiose. Th
hat is precisely what the Board has
s cautioned against in paragraph 3
.3
of its Instruction.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-18-
CWP-10191-2025


45. We accordi
(O&M)
ngly hold that the pre-conditions
s for the exercise of power und
er
Section 74 of the C
CGST Act did not exist, that the sh
how cause notice did not disclose th
he
foundational facts
necessary for its invocation, and t
that the confirmation of the deman
nd
and the imposition
of a penalty equal to the tax under
that provision cannot be sustained
.

46. We are cons
scious that Section 75(2) of the CG
GST Act provides that where a notic
ce
under Section 74(1
) is held not to be sustainable for
the reason that the charges of frau
ud,
wilful misstatemen
nt or suppression are not establishe
d, the proper officer shall determin
ne
the tax payable dee
eming the notice to have been issue
ed under Section 73(1). Whether an
ny
part of the demand
d could have survived on that basi
is would have required examinatio
on
had the demand be
en otherwise sustainable. For the r
reasons which follow under questio
on
(C), it is not, and th
he occasion for such an exercise do
oes not arise.
(C) Circular No. 21
10/4/2024-GST dated 26.06.2024

47. Section 168
(1) of the CGST Act empowers th
he Board, if it considers it necessar
ry
or expedient so to
do for the purpose of uniformity i
in the implementation of the Act,
to
issue such orders, i
instructions or directions to the cen
ntral tax officers as it may deem f
fit,
'and thereupon all s
such officers and all other persons
s employed in the implementation o
of
this Act shall obse
erve and follow such orders, instru
uctions or directions'. That circula
ars
issued by the Board
d are binding on the officers of the
e Department, and that it is not ope
en
to them to contend
that a circular beneficial to the ass
essee is not to be followed, is settle
ed
[see Ratan Meltin
g and Wire Industries (supra)].

48. The impugn
ned order proceeds on the footing
g that the petitioner has imported
a
service from a rela
ated person located outside India. I
It invokes paragraph 4 of Schedule
e I
to the CGST Act,
under which such import in the c
course or furtherance of business
is
treated as a supply
even if made without consideratio
on, and it holds that the valuation o
of
the service 'will b
be determined as per Rule 28 of
CGST Rules, 2017'. Rule 28(1)(
a)
provides that the v
value of a supply between related
d persons shall be the open mark
ket
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-19-
CWP-10191-2025

value, failing which
(O&M)
h the value of supply of like kind
and quality, failing which the valu
ue
determined under R
Rule 30 or Rule 31. The second pro
oviso to Rule 28(1) reads:
"Provid
ded further that where the recipie
ent is eligible for full input tax
credit,
the value declared in the invoice s
shall be deemed to be the open
market
t value of the goods or services."

49. Circular No
. 210/4/2024-GST was issued by
the Board in exercise of its powe
ers
under Section 168
(1). Paragraph 3.5 records that th
he second proviso to Rule 28(1) '
'is
applicable in all th
he cases involving supply of goo
ds or services or both between th
he
distinct persons as
well as the related persons, in case
es where full ITC is available to th
he
recipient', and that
the clarification earlier issued by C
Circular No. 199/11/2023-GST date
ed
17.07.2023 in respe
ect of supplies between distinct per
rsons is equally applicable to impo
ort
of services between
n related persons. Paragraph 3.6 of
f Circular No. 210/4/2024-GST note
es
that in the case of
such import, the registered person
n in India is required to issue a sel
lf-
invoice under Sec
tion 31(3)(f) and pay tax on rev
verse charge basis. The Board the
en
clarifies:
"3.7 In
n view of the above, it is clarified t
that in cases where the foreign
affiliat
te is providing certain services to t
the related domestic entity, and
where
full input tax credit is available
e to the said related domestic
entity,
the value of such supply of services
s declared in the invoice by the
said re
elated domestic entity may be dee
emed as open market value in
terms o
of second proviso to rule 28(1) of
CGST Rules. Further, in cases
where f
full input tax credit is available to
o the recipient, if the invoice is
not iss
sued by the related domestic entit
ty with respect to any service
provide
ed by the foreign affiliate to it, the
e value of such services may be
deemed
d to be declared as Nil, and may be
e deemed as open market value
in term
ms of second proviso to rule 28(1) of
of CGST Rules."
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-20-
CWP-10191-2025


50. Two conditi
(O&M)
ions thus attract the clarification: (i
) that the recipient is eligible for fu
ull
input tax credit, an
nd (ii) that no invoice has been issu
ued by the recipient in respect of th
he
service. Both are
satisfied. That the petitioner iss
sued no self-invoice is not mere
ly
undisputed, it is t
the respondents' own case, the i
impugned order having repeated
ly
recorded the peti
itioner's failure to issue invoic
ces under Section 31(3)(f) as
a
contravention. As t
to the first, the petitioner asserted
before the adjudicating authority,
in
its additional subm
missions dated 19.12.2024, that it is
eligible for full input tax credit, an
nd
has reiterated that
assertion on affidavit before this C
Court. The impugned order does n
ot
record any finding
to the contrary, and the reply filed
in this Court does not dispute it.

51. The adjudic
cating authority has nonetheless
held the Circular, and with it th
he
judgment in Metal
l One (supra), to be inapplicable
in paragraphs D-11 to D-17 of th
he
impugned order. It
t is to the effect that the Circular a
applies 'in cases no consideration
is
involved', that in M
Metal One (supra), 'consideration
is main point for the decision', an
nd
that in the petition
ner's case consideration is involv
ved, the value of the service bein
ng
ascertainable from
the remuneration paid to the secon
nded employees.

52. This reason
ning cannot be accepted, for thr
ree reasons. First, it misreads th
he
Circular. The word
ds on which the adjudicating autho
ority has fastened occur in paragrap
ph
2, which narrates th
he representations received by the
Board from trade and industry. Th
he
clarification itself i
is in paragraphs 3.5 to 3.7. Those p
paragraphs do not make the absenc
ce
of consideration a
condition. Paragraph 3.5 states th
hat the second proviso applies in 'a
all
the cases' of supply
y between related persons where fu
ull input tax credit is available to th
he
recipient. Paragrap
ph 3.7 applies 'in cases where the f
foreign affiliate is providing certa
in
services to the rela
ated domestic entity, and where fu
ull input tax credit is available'. Th
he
second proviso to R
Rule 28(1), which the Circular exp
plains, likewise draws no distinctio
on
between supplies m
made with and without consideratio
on. It is engaged whenever a supp
ly
between related or
r distinct persons is to be valued a
and the recipient is eligible for fu
ull
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-21-
CWP-10191-2025

credit. An officer
(O&M)
bound by a circular cannot read
into its operative part a limitatio
on
which the Board ha
as not placed there.

53. Secondly, it
t misreads Metal One (supra). Th
hat batch of petitions concerned th
he
very controversy th
hat arises here, i.e. show cause n
notices demanding IGST on rever
se
charge basis for Ju
uly 2017 to March 2023 on the sec
condment of expatriates by oversea
as
group companies,
issued in the wake of Northern
n Operating Systems (supra). Th
he
Revenue's stand be
efore the Delhi High Court, extra
acted in the judgment, was that th
he
value of the servic
ce was the total consideration paid
d to the expatriates, including salar
ry
paid in foreign cur
rrency by the overseas company a
and charged to the Indian entity an
nd
salary paid in Indi
ia. The Court was thus dealing w
with a case in which payments ha
ad
admittedly been ma
ade. It held:
"12. U
Undisputedly, although payments,
, as asserted in the counter
affidav
vit, were made, no invoices cam
me to be raised by the writ
petition
ners entities in connection with t
the services provided by their
related
d foreign. ... It would perhaps b
be impossible for any of the
respon
ndents to assert that once the valu
ue of such services were to be
treated
d or accepted to be 'Nil', no further
r tax implication under the Act
would
arise."
"14. In
n the facts of the present writ pe
etitions, it is conceded that no
invoice
es were generated. In view of the ab
bove and in light of the explicit
terms o
of the Circular, the value of the se
ervice rendered would have to
be trea
ated as 'Nil'. This would lead one to
o the inescapable conclusion of
no perc
ceivable or plausible tax liability p
possibly being created. ..."

54. The ground
on which the adjudicating authorit
ty sought to distinguish Metal On
ne ,
namely that consid
deration was involved in the petit
tioner's case, was therefore equal
ly
present in Metal O
One and was expressly noticed by
the Court. The distinction drawn
is
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-22-
CWP-10191-2025

no distinction at a
(O&M)
all. The Karnataka High Court in
ed
Alstom Transport India Limite
(supra), again a ca
ase of secondment where salaries
were paid and the demand was fo
for
July 2017 to Marc
ch 2023, has followed Metal One
e and held that, no invoices havin
ng
been raised, the val
lue of the service must be deemed
to be 'Nil' in terms of paragraph 3
.7
of the Circular and
d that no further tax liability can a
arise. No decision taking a contrar
ry
view has been brou
ught to our notice, and we find our
rselves in respectful agreement wi
th
the view so taken.

55. Thirdly, the
e reasoning defeats itself. The ad
djudicating authority holds that th
he
value is to be deter
mined under Rule 28, extracts the
second proviso, and then determine
es
the value at the rem
muneration paid to the expatriates w
without applying the proviso. If Ru
ule
28 governs, as the a
authority rightly holds it does in th
he case of related persons, the secon
nd
proviso is part of it
t and cannot be left out of the recko
oning.

56. The manner
r in which this part of the ord
der is drawn also deserves notic
ce.
Paragraph D-13 of
f the impugned order reads: ‘ I find
d that in present case, the petitione
er
has failed to issue
invoices ... for the service of sec
conded employees received from i
its
foreign entity i.e.
Metal One Japan’. The petiti
ioner was the noticee before th
he
adjudicating author
rity, not a 'petitioner', and its forei
ign affiliate is JFE Japan, not Met
tal
One Japan. The pa
aragraph has evidently been lifted
from a pleading or order in anoth
er
matter. It is repea
ated, in almost the same words
but with the names corrected,
in
paragraph D-15. Th
his is not a slip of the pen. It show
ws that the one contention on whic
ch
the petitioner had
the support of a binding circular
r and a judgment of a High Cou
urt
directly in point wa
as disposed of without the applicati
ion of mind which it required.

57. We may dea
al with one aspect which, though
not urged by the respondents, bea
ars
on the condition of
f eligibility for full input tax credi
t. Section 17(5)(i) of the CGST A
Act
denies input tax cre
edit in respect of tax paid in accord
dance with the provisions of Sectio
on
74. It may be sugg
ested that tax demanded under Sec
ction 74 would not be creditable an
nd
that the recipient is
s therefore not eligible for full cre
edit. Any such suggestion would b
MOHIT GOYAL be
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-23-
CWP-10191-2025

circular, since it w
(O&M)
would make the applicability of
the valuation rule depend on th
he
provision under wh
hich the Department chooses to r
raise the demand. In any event, w
we
have held that Sec
ction 74 could not have been inv
voked, and the suggestion does n
ot
survive that finding
g.

58. The Delhi H
High Court in (supra) h
Metal One
has observed that the correctness o
of
the position taken
in the Circular may be open to qu
uestion. It is not necessary for us
to
enter upon that. Th
he respondents have not questioned
d the Circular, which they could no
ot,
being bound by it.
Their only contention is that it doe
es not apply, and that contention w
we
have rejected. So l
ong as the Circular stands, the off
ficers of the Department are oblige
ed
by Section 168(1) t
to follow it.

59. The result is
s that, even on the assumption on w
which the impugned order proceed
ds,
namely that the arr
rangement amounts to an import o
f service by the petitioner from JF
FE
Japan, the value of
f such supply is, in terms of the s
second proviso to Rule 28(1) of th
he
CGST Rules read
with paragraph 3.7 of Circular N
No. 210/4/2024-GST, to be taken a
as
'Nil'. No tax is the
en payable. Interest under Section
n 50, which is compensatory and
is
levied on tax whic
ch a person has failed to pay, an
d penalty, which is computed wi
th
reference to the ta
ax evaded, fall with the demand. T
The impugned order, in so far as
it
confirms the dema
and of tax, interest and penalty, is
s contrary to Section 168(1) of th
he
CGST Act and can
nnot be sustained for any part of t
the period from July 2017 to Marc
ch
2023.
ns
(D) Want of reason

60. Section 75(6
6) of the CGST Act requires the p
proper officer to set out in his ord
der
the relevant facts a
and the basis of his decision. The r
requirement is a statutory expressio
on
of what the law in
any case demands of an authority
y exercising quasi-judicial power. I
In
S.N. Mukherjee a
and Kranti Associates (supra), it
has been held that the recording o
of
reasons is an indisp
pensable component of the decision
n-making process, that reasons mu
ust
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-24-
CWP-10191-2025

disclose a consider
(O&M)
ration of the relevant factors, and th
hat a pretence of reasons or 'rubbe
er-
stamp reasons' is no
ot to be equated with a valid decisi
on-making process.

61. The structur
re of the impugned order is as foll
lows. Part A sets out the brief fac
cts
and the allegations
s in the show cause notice. Part B
B lists, by their headings alone, th
he
submissions made
e in the petitioner's reply dated
29.10.2024, and summarises th
he
additional submiss
ions dated 19.12.2024. Part C reco
ords the personal hearing. Part D
is
titled 'Discussions
and Findings', wherein the respo
ondents reproduced the show caus
se
notice, complete w
with the tentative language of a n
notice ('it appears that'). Further,
it
describes the gener
ral concept of supply under the CG
GST Act, secondment arrangemen
nts
in generic terms, a
and extract observations from Nor
rthern Operating Systems (supra
a).
Paragraph D-9, wh
hich purports to record the authorit
ty's observations on a perusal of th
he
petitioner's agreem
ments, is a verbatim repetition of sub
ub-paragraph 4.8, that is, of the sho
ow
cause notice. More
eover, it deals with the Circular and
d Metal One (supra), in the mann
er
already noticed. La
astly, paragraphs D-18 to D-20 list
the provisions contravened and de
eal
with Section 74. Th
he order follows.

62. What is abs
sent is any consideration of the
petitioner's defence on the centr
ral
question of fact, n
namely the nature of the relations
ship between the petitioner and th
he
expatriates under th
he agreements actually on record.
The petitioner had relied, clause b
by
clause, on Articles
s 1, 3, 5 and 9 of the Dispatch A
Agreement and on the Employme
nt
Contracts. None o
of these clauses is referred to in
the findings. The 'observations'
in
paragraph D-9 are
e stated to be drawn from the agr
reements, but they do not cite an
ny
clause, and several
l of them cannot be reconciled wi
ith the documents. To illustrate: th
he
order records that
the terms of employment during
secondment 'are in accord with th
he
policy' of JFE Japa
an and that secondment is part of
f its 'global policy' with repatriatio
on
under a 'global re
epatriation policy', whereas Articl
le 1(a) of the Dispatch Agreeme
nt
leaves the terms o
of employment to be defined by
y the petitioner, and no docume
nt
embodying any su
uch global policy is identified. T
The order records that the 'letter o
of
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-25-
CWP-10191-2025

understanding' betw
(O&M)
ween the petitioner and the expatr
riates does not state that they wou
ld
be treated as the
petitioner's employees after the
e secondment period, whereas th
he
petitioner had state
ed in writing on 07.11.2022 that n
no letter of understanding exists an
nd
that employment c
contracts had been executed direct
tly. The expressions used, 'letter o
of
understanding', 'glo
obal repatriation policy', 'temporari
ily loaned', are those which occur
in
paragraphs 56 to 62
2 of Northern Operating Systems
s in the description of the documen
nts
which were before
the Supreme Court in that case. Th
he features of that case have, in oth
er
words, been attrib
buted to the petitioner without e
examining whether the petitioner
r's
documents bear the
em out.

63. This is the
very approach against which the
e Board had cautioned its officer
rs.
Instruction No. 05/
2023-GST states:
"2.3 It
t may be relevant to note that th
here may be multiple types of
arrang
gements in relation to secondment o
of employees of overseas group
compa
ny in the Indian entity. In each arr
rangement, the tax implications
may be
e different, depending upon the spe
cific nature of the contract and
other t
terms and conditions attached to it
t. Therefore, the decision of the
Hon'bl
le Supreme Court in the NOS jud
dgment should not be applied
mechan
nically in all the cases. Investiga
ation in each case requires a
careful
l consideration of its distinct factu
ual matrix, including the terms
of cont
tract between overseas company a
and Indian entity, to determine
taxabil
lity or its extent under GST and
applicability of the principles
laid do
own by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
's judgment in NOS case."

64. The Suprem
me Court in Northern Operating
g Systems (supra) emphasised th
hat
there is no single
determinative factor and that wha
at is required is 'a close look at th
he
terms of the contra
act, or the agreements'. The Instruc
ction was specifically relied upon b
by
the petitioner. It fin
nds no mention in the findings. N
Nor does the order dated 24.02.202
21
passed by a Princip
pal Commissioner in the petitioner
's own case on the same document
MOHIT GOYAL ts.
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-26-
CWP-10191-2025

We do not suggest
(O&M)
that the adjudicating authority wa
as bound by that order for a differe
nt
period under a diff
ferent enactment, or that it could n
not, for reasons stated, have differe
ed
from it. But an ad
djudication by a senior officer of
the same Department on the sam
me
agreements was a
relevant consideration which, hav
ving been pressed, had to be dea
alt
with. To pass it ove
er in silence is not to deal with it.

65. There is a
further infirmity on the face of
the order. The show cause notic
ce
proposed a demand
d of Rs.13,08,57,858/- for the perio
od July 2017 to March 2023, and th
hat
figure is the aggreg
gate for six financial years ending
with 2022-23. The operative part o
of
the impugned order
r confirms the same amount 'for the
e period July-17 to March-22', whi
ile
a summary in Form
m GST DRC-07 has been issued fo
r the financial year 2022-23 as wel
ll.
The order thus doe
s not, even in its operative part, cor
rrectly state the period for which th
he
liability is fastened
d.

66. It is of some
e significance that the Board itself
f, by Circular No. 258/04/2026-GS
ST
dated 26.10.2026,
has since issued detailed guideli
ines to its officers on adjudicatio
on
under the CGST A
Act. The Circular records that instan
nces of orders which fail to consid
er
the submissions o
f the noticee, have come to the
notice of the Board. The circul
ar
therefore requires
the adjudicating authority to indep
pendently examine the submission
ns
and evidence of th
e taxpayer and to record findings
on each material issue. It states th
hat
mere reference to d
documents or reproduction of their
contents is not sufficient. It require
es
that judgments cite
ed by the noticee be considered an
d, if found inapplicable, the reason
ns
be recorded, and w
with reference to G.R. Infra Projec
cts Limited (supra), it reiterates th
hat
Section 74 may be
e invoked only where the investiga
ation discloses material evidence o
of
fraud, wilful missta
atement or suppression with intent
to evade tax, which must be set o
ut
in the notice. The
Circular post-dates the impugned
order and has been issued after th
he
hearing of the prese
ent petition had concluded, and the
erefore, we do not test the impugne
ed
order against it. We
e refer to it only because it states,
in the Board's own words, standard
ds
which the law alrea
ady required and which the impugn
ned order does not meet.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-27-
CWP-10191-2025


67. We accordin
(O&M)
ngly hold that the impugned order
r does not satisfy the requirement o
of
Section 75(6) of th
he CGST Act and has been passed i
in breach of the principles of natur
ral
justice. Ordinarily,
an order found wanting in reasons
s is set aside and the matter remitte
ed
for a fresh decision
n. That course is not warranted h
here. A remand is directed so that
a
lawful order may b
be passed. It would serve no purpo
ose in the instant case, where on th
he
findings recorded u
under questions (B) and (C), no d
demand can lawfully result from th
he
show cause notice.
The Delhi High Court in Metal O
One (supra), on the same reasonin
ng,
found the continuan
nce of the proceedings to be futile
and quashed the show cause notice
es
themselves.
ided
Questions not deci

68. Elaborate su
ubmissions were addressed on beha
alf of the petitioner on whether, on
n a
true construction
of the Dispatch Agreement and
d the Employment Contracts, th
he
expatriates are emp
ployees of the petitioner so as to a
attract entry 1 of Schedule III to th
he
CGST Act, and on
n whether Northern Operating Sy
ystems (supra) is distinguishable o
on
facts. In view of
the conclusions reached above,
it is not necessary to decide th
hat
question, and we r
efrain from doing so for an additi
onal reason. The characterisation o
of
the same arrangem
ment under the Finance Act, 1994
4 is the subject of the Department
t's
appeal pending bef
fore the Customs, Excise and Serv
vice Tax Appellate Tribunal again
nst
the order dated 24.0
02.2021. It would not be appropria
ate for this Court, in a petition whic
ch
can be disposed of
f on other grounds, to pronounce up
pon a question which the Tribunal
is
seized of. The que
estion is left open. Nothing in this
s judgment shall be construed as a
an
expression of opini
ion on it, and the Tribunal shall de
ecide the appeal before it on its ow
wn
merits.

69. For the sam
me reason, the submissions founded
d on the principle of consistency, o
on
revenue neutrality,
and on the independent sustainab
bility of the levy of interest and o
of
penalty under Secti
ion 122(2)(b) do not call for separa
ate consideration.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-28-
CWP-10191-2025

CONCLUSION
(O&M)

70. The question
ns framed are answered as follows:
:
(A) The av
vailability of an appeal under Sectio
on 107 of the CGST Act does not,
in
the fac
ts of this case, disentitle the petitio
oner to relief under Article 226 of th
he
Constit
tution.
(B) The pr
re-conditions for the invocation of
f Section 74 of the CGST Act we
re
not dis
sclosed in the show cause notice
and did not exist; the proceeding
gs
under t
that provision, and the penalty imp
osed thereunder, are unsustainable
.
(C) The pe
etitioner being a recipient eligible fo
for full input tax credit which has n
ot
issued
any invoice in respect of the alleg
ed import of service from its relate
ed
person
, the value of such supply is, in t
terms of the second proviso to Ru
ule
28(1)
of the CGST Rules read with
h paragraph 3.7 of Circular N
No.
210/4/2
2024-GST dated 26.06.2024, to be
e deemed to be 'Nil'; the demand o
of
tax, int
terest and penalty confirmed in dis
sregard of the Circular is contrary
to
Section
n 168(1) of the CGST Act.
(D) The im
mpugned order is not a reasoned or
rder as required by Section 75(6) o
of
the CG
GST Act.

71. As a seque
el to the aforementioned discussi
ions and findings, the instant wr
rit
petition is allowed
in the following terms:-
(i) The O
Order-in-Original dated 09.01.20
025 (Annexure P-1) passed b
by
respon
dent No.2, and the summaries th
hereof in Form GST DRC-07 date
ed
30.01.2
2025 for the financial years 2017-1
8 to 2022-23, are quashed.
(ii) The Sh
how Cause Notice dated 30.07.202
24 (Annexure P-13), along with th
he
summa
ary thereof in Form GST DRC-01,
is quashed.
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


-29-
CWP-10191-2025

(iii) Any am
(O&M)
mount deposited by or recovered
from the petitioner pursuant to th
he
impugn
ned order shall be refunded to it
t, in accordance with law within
a
period
of eight weeks from the date of
f receipt of a certified copy of th
his
judgme
ent.

72. There shall b
be no order as to costs.

73. Pending mis
scellaneous application(s), if any, s
hall stand disposed of.


( ASHWANI KUM
CHIEF JU

17.11.2026
Mohit Goyal





MAR MISHRA )
USTICE


(ROHIT KAPOOR)

JUDGE

Whether speaking/reasoned :
Whether Reportable :
Yes/No
Yes/No
MOHIT GOYAL
2026.11.18 19:55
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document