M/S Dhuri Motors Regd. vs Rashida And Ors

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

I. FAO-522-2021 (O&M)

M/S DHURI MOTORS REGD. DHURI, DISTRICT SANGRUR
. . . . Appellant
Vs.
SAMINA ALIAS SMINA AND OTHERS
. . . . Respondents

I. FAO-524-2021 (O&M)

M/S DHURI MOTORS REGD. DHURI, DISTRICT SANGRUR
. . . . Appellant
Vs.
RASHIDA AND OTHERS
. . . . Respondents


Reserved on: 16.11.2026
Pronounced on:17.11.2026
Pronounced Fully/Operative Part: Fully

CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE DEEPAK GUPTA

Present: - Mr.Ajaipal Singh Brar, Advocate, for the appellant.

Mr.Arhant Goyal, Advocate, for respondent No.5.

Mr.Harinder Kumar, Advocate,
for respondent No.6-Insurance Company.



DEEPAK GUPTA, J.
By this common judgment, two appeals filed by M/s Dhuri Motors are
being disposed of, as both arise out of the same motor vehicular accident dated
29.10.2018 and involve identical questions regarding ownership of the offending
vehicle and liability to satisfy the awards dated 24.02.2021 passed by learned
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sangrur (hereinafter referred to as 'the Tribunal').
VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document

FAO-522-2021 2026:PHHC:202030
FAO-524-2021

2. The appeals are confined to the question of liability. Neither the
findings regarding negligence nor the quantum of compensation have been
assailed.
3. Briefly, the facts are that on 29.10.2018, Dogar Ali and Mohammad Ali
were travelling on motorcycle bearing registration No. PB-13AV-8945 when, near
Bus Stand Sandaur, a bus bearing registration No. PB-03AF-6513, driven by Jagtar
Singh, struck against their motorcycle, resulting in the death of both the occupants.
4. Separate claim petitions under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') were instituted by their respective legal
representatives.
5.1 The Tribunal, vide two different awards both dated 24.02.2021. upon
appreciation of the evidence, held that the accident occurred due to rash and
negligent driving of the offending bus and awarded compensation of ₹3,60,000/- in
the claim petition concerning the death of Dogar Ali; and ₹13,12,000/- in the claim
petition concerning the death of Mohammad Ali, along with interest at the rate of
9% per annum from the date of institution of the respective claim petitions till
realisation.
5.2 While determining liability, the Tribunal held that although M/s Taj
Travels Pvt. Ltd. continued to be the registered owner of the bus on the date of
accident, the vehicle had already been sold to M/s Dhuri Motors on 16.10.2018
and its possession had been delivered to the latter. The Tribunal further held that
the bus was being operated outside its sanctioned route without a valid temporary
or special permit and, consequently, found breach of the insurance policy
conditions. Accordingly, the insurer was directed to satisfy the awards in the first
instance, with liberty to recover the amounts from M/s Dhuri Motors alone.
6. Assailing the awards, Learned counsel for the appellant has raised two
major contentions. Firstly , it is submitted that the appellant was not the registered
owner of the offending vehicle on the date of accident and, therefore, could not
have been fastened with liability as owner under the Act. Reliance is placed upon
the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Naveen Kumar v. Vijay Kumar and

2 8
Page of

VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document

FAO-522-2021 2026:PHHC:202030
FAO-524-2021

others, (2018) 3 SCC 1, and Prakash Chand Daga v. Saveta Sharma and others,
(2019) 2 SCC 747 . Secondly, it is contended that the bus admittedly possessed a
valid route permit and merely because it was found travelling outside the
sanctioned route, the same would not constitute such a fundamental breach of the
insurance policy, as would entitle the insurer to avoid its liability.
7. Per contra , learned counsel representing M/s Taj Travels Pvt. Ltd.
submits that the vehicle had been sold to the appellant on 16.10.2018, well before
the accident, against receipt of the entire sale consideration. Its possession was
also delivered to the appellant, and the requisite documents for transfer of
registration were executed. Thus, the appellant, being the actual purchaser and
person in control of the vehicle, cannot escape the consequences arising from its
operation merely because the registration certificate had not been transferred in
its name.
8. Learned counsel representing the insurance company supports the
findings of the Tribunal and submits that the bus was being operated on a route for
which no permit had been issued. The appellant failed to establish the existence of
any temporary or special permit authorising such operation. It is, therefore,
contended that the Tribunal rightly held the insurer entitled to recovery rights on
account of breach of policy conditions.
9. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and examined the
impugned awards.
10. The controversy requiring determination is twofold: firstly, whether
the appellant, being the purchaser and person in possession of the offending bus
but not its registered owner on the date of accident, could be held liable as owner
under the Act; and secondly, whether operation of a transport vehicle outside its
sanctioned route, notwithstanding the existence of a valid permit for another
route, constitutes a breach sufficient to entitle the insurer to recovery rights.
Ownership and statutory liability
11. Insofar as the first contention is concerned, Section 2(30) of the Act
defines the expression 'owner' to mean the person in whose name the motor

3 8
Page of

VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document

FAO-522-2021 2026:PHHC:202030
FAO-524-2021

vehicle stands registered, subject to the exceptions provided therein. In Naveen
Kumar v. Vijay Kumar and others, (2018) 3 SCC 1 , a three-Judge Bench of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, while interpreting the aforesaid provision, held that the
person in whose name the vehicle stands registered continues to be its owner for
the purposes of the Act, notwithstanding any unregistered transfer. The object is
to ensure that an accident victim is not required to trace successive transfers of the
offending vehicle for enforcing a claim for compensation.
12. Pointedly, in Naveen Kumar (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court also
considered its earlier judgment in Dr. T.V. Jose v. Chacko P.M. alias Thankachan,
(2001) 8 SCC 748, wherein it had been recognised that title to a motor vehicle may
pass upon payment of consideration and delivery of possession, notwithstanding
non-transfer of registration. However, the registered owner continues to remain
liable towards third parties so long as his name remains entered in the records of
the Registering Authority. Thus, the distinction between transfer of ownership
under civil law and statutory ownership for the purposes of the Motor Vehicles Act
stands expressly recognised.
13. The aforesaid principle was reiterated in Prakash Chand Daga (supra),
wherein the registered owner had sold the vehicle and delivered its possession
before the accident. The Hon'ble Supreme Court rejected the contention that the
transferor stood absolved of liability merely because the accident occurred after
the sale or within the statutory period prescribed for reporting the transfer under
Section 50 of the Act. It was held that the person whose name continued in the
registration records remained liable towards third parties.
14. In the present case, the evidence regarding transfer of the offending
bus is particularly significant. Sukhdev Singh (RW-1), representing M/s Taj Travels
Pvt. Ltd., categorically deposed that the vehicle had been sold to the appellant on
16.10.2018 and its possession delivered upon receipt of the entire sale
consideration. The affidavits of sale and purchase, Ex.R-18 and Ex.R-19,
respectively, were produced. The no-objection certificates, Ex.R-16 and Ex.R-17,
were proved by Harbans Singh (RW-4), an official from the Regional Transport
Authority, Bathinda. Forms 28, 29 and 30 had also been executed. Pointedly, the

4 8
Page of

VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document

FAO-522-2021 2026:PHHC:202030
FAO-524-2021

appellant itself admitted in its written statement that it had purchased the bus on
16.10.2018. The registration certificate was subsequently transferred in its favour,
as reflected in Ex.R-4.
15. Thus, the sale, delivery of possession and control of the vehicle by the
appellant before the accident are not in dispute. However, admittedly, M/s Taj
Travels Pvt. Ltd. continued to be the registered owner of the offending bus on
29.10.2018. The subsequent transfer of registration in favour of M/s Dhuri Motors
cannot retrospectively alter the statutory position existing on the date of accident.
16. Consequently, in view of the law laid down by the three-Judge Bench
in Naveen Kumar (supra), as followed in Prakash Chand Daga (supra), the Tribunal
was not justified in completely absolving M/s Taj Travels Pvt. Ltd. merely because it
had sold the vehicle to M/s Dhuri Motors before the accident.
Breach of route permit conditions
17. Coming to the second contention, the record reveals that the
offending bus was insured with United India Insurance Company Limited for the
period from 10.07.2018 to 09.07.2019. Its fitness certificate (Ex.R-9) was valid up to
02.07.2019, while the driving licence (Ex.RW2/1) of Jagtar Singh was valid for a
transport vehicle up to 15.01.2021. Thus, neither the existence of insurance
coverage on the date of accident nor the validity of the driving licence is in dispute.
18. The controversy is confined to the route permit. The Tribunal noticed
that the route permit, Ex.R-11, authorised operation on the Ludhiana–Muktsar
route via Mehal Kalan, Raikot, Barnala, Tapa and Rampura, whereas the accident
occurred near Sandaur, which was outside the sanctioned route. The appellant
relied upon receipt Ex.R-12 showing deposit of ₹1,300/- on 29.10.2018. Mohinder
Kumar (RW-3), an official of the Regional Transport Authority, Sangrur, confirmed
the genuineness of the receipt but could not state whether any temporary or
special permit had actually been issued. On the other hand, Rakesh Joshi (RW-5),
Junior Assistant, categorically stated that no tour permit had been issued for the
offending bus on 29.10.2018 and proved the relevant register, Ex.RW5/A.

5 8
Page of

VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document

FAO-522-2021 2026:PHHC:202030
FAO-524-2021

19. The aforesaid evidence establishes that although the bus possessed a
regular route permit, no additional authorisation for operating on the route where
the accident occurred was proved. Mere deposit of the requisite fee cannot, by
itself, be equated with the grant of a temporary or special permit. The Tribunal
was, therefore, justified in recording that the vehicle was being operated outside
its authorised route.
20. The legal consequence of such deviation, however, requires
consideration in the light of the authoritative pronouncement of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in K. Nagendra v. The New India Insurance Co. Ltd. and others,
2025 INSC 1270, decided on 29.10.2025. In that case, the offending bus possessed
a permit for the Bengaluru–Mysore route but had entered Channapatna City,
which was outside the authorised route, where the accident occurred. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court specifically examined whether deviation from the route prescribed
in the permit would affect the liability of the insurer. After considering National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh and others, (2004) 3 SCC 297, and other
precedents, the Court upheld the direction requiring the insurer to satisfy the
award in the first instance, with liberty to recover the amount from the owner.
21. The aforesaid judgment is directly applicable to the facts of the
present case. The distinction between a vehicle having no permit whatsoever and a
vehicle possessing a valid permit but operating outside its authorised route does
not, in the circumstances of the present case, justify setting aside the recovery
rights granted to the insurer. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in K. Nagendra (supra)
has specifically upheld the application of the principle of 'pay and recover' even
where the breach consisted of deviation from the permitted route. Thus, while the
appellant is correct in submitting that the offending bus was not entirely without a
permit, the further contention that such deviation cannot attract any consequence
under the insurance contract is not sustainable.
22. The principle of 'pay and recover' appropriately balances the interests
of innocent third-party claimants and those of the insurer. The claimants cannot be
deprived of compensation merely because the offending vehicle was being
operated outside its sanctioned route. Equally, the insurer cannot be deprived of

6 8
Page of

VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document

FAO-522-2021 2026:PHHC:202030
FAO-524-2021

its contractual protection, where the insured vehicle was operated contrary to the
conditions governing its permitted use. The Tribunal was, therefore, justified in
directing the insurance company to satisfy the awards in the first instance and
thereafter exercise recovery rights.
Recovery rights and inter se obligations
23. However, the Tribunal was not justified in granting recovery rights
directly against M/s Dhuri Motors by treating it as the statutory owner. As noticed
above, M/s Taj Travels Pvt. Ltd. continued to be the registered owner and insured
under the policy on the date of accident. Therefore, the insurer's recovery rights
shall be enforceable against M/s Taj Travels Pvt. Ltd., rather than directly against
the appellant.
24. This, however, does not absolve M/s Dhuri Motors of its obligations
towards M/s Taj Travels Pvt. Ltd. The sale stood completed between the parties
upon payment of consideration and delivery of possession, leaving only the formal
transfer of registration. The offending bus was thereafter in the possession and
control of M/s Dhuri Motors, and the breach of the route permit conditions
occurred during its operation of the vehicle. The statutory liability of the registered
owner towards third parties cannot be confused with the ultimate financial
responsibility arising between the seller and purchaser. The decisions in Naveen
Kumar and Prakash Chand Daga (supra) do not preclude determination of such
inter se responsibility.
25. In the peculiar facts of the present case, where the transaction of sale,
delivery of possession and subsequent operation of the vehicle by the appellant
are established, the financial consequences of the unauthorised operation ought
ultimately to be borne by M/s Dhuri Motors. Both parties are before this Court and
have been heard on the question of liability. Therefore, exercising appellate
jurisdiction under Section 173 of the Act, read with the principles underlying Order
XLI Rule 33 CPC, this Court considers it appropriate to mould the relief and
determine their inter se responsibility, rather than compeling M/s Taj Travels Pvt.
Ltd. to initiate separate proceedings.

7 8
Page of

VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document

FAO-522-2021 2026:PHHC:202030
FAO-524-2021

26. Consequently, both appeals are partly allowed, and the awards dated
24.02.2021 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sangrur, are modified to
the following extent:
(a) United India Insurance Company Limited shall satisfy the awards in the
first instance, along with interest as awarded by the Tribunal.
(b) The insurance company shall be entitled to recover the amounts so
paid only from M/s Taj Travels Pvt. Ltd., being the registered owner and insured on
the date of accident.
(c) M/s Taj Travels Pvt. Ltd. shall, in turn, be entitled to recover from M/s
Dhuri Motors the entire amount actually recovered from it by the insurance
company pursuant to the aforesaid direction. Such recovery shall be enforceable in
execution of the modified awards without requiring institution of a separate suit.
(d) The insurance company shall have no direct recovery rights against
M/s Dhuri Motors under the impugned awards.
20. The findings regarding negligence, quantum of compensation, interest
and apportionment shall remain undisturbed. Pending miscellaneous applications,
if any, shall also stand disposed of. A photocopy of this order be placed on the file
of connected case.

(DEEPAK GUPTA)
17.11.2026 JUDGE
Vivek
Whether Speaking/reasoned Yes
Whether reportable No

Uploaded on:17.11.2026



8 8
Page of

VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document