VIKRAM SINGH vs STATE OF RAJ AND ORS
- Court
- Rajasthan High Court
[2026:RJ-JP:39528]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 1607/2017
CNR: RJHC020580452017 | URN: CW / 3123U / 2017
Vikram Singh S/o Sh. Gopi Singh, R/o Kumhar Mohalla, Village
Lohagal, Post Makarwali, Distt. Ajmer (Raj.).
----Petitioner
Versus
1. State of Rajasthan through Dept. of Energy, Jaipur.
2. Managing Director, Ajmer Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd., Vidyut
Bhawan, Panchsheel Nagar, Ajmer 305004.
3. Assistant Engineer (O & M), Ajmer Vidyut Vitran Nigam
Ltd., Shastri Nagar, Ajmer.
4. Secretary (Admin.), Ajmer Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd.,
Vidyut Bhawan, Panchsheel Nagar, Ajmer 305004.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s) : Mr. Saurabh Purohit for
Mr. Rakesh Kumar
For Respondent(s) : Ms. Priya Rastogi for
Mr. Ankur Rastogi
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANAND SHARMA
Judgment
REPORTABLE
Date of conclusion of arguments :: 25.09.2026
Date on which judgment was reserved :: 25.09.2026
Whether the full judgment or only the
operative part is pronounced :: Full Judgment
Date of pronouncement :: 05.10.2026
1. This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner
assailing the order dated 20.01.2016 issued by the Secretary
(Administration), Ajmer Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited whereby
services of the petitioner have been terminated in view of
Condition No.10 mentioned in the appointment order.
2. Facts in brief are that father of the petitioner was
employee of respondent-AVVNL, however, he died while in service
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:44 PM)
(2 of 12)
[2026:RJ-JP:39528] [CW-1607/2017]
on 18.06.2014. After his death, the petitioner applied for
compassionate appointment in place of his deceased father and
accordingly appointment order was issued on 20.02.2015 for
appointing the petitioner on the post of 'Helper-II' as probationer
trainee. Condition No.10 of appointment order dated 20.02.2015
is reproduced hereunder:
" 10 - पोबेशनरट्ेनीकीसेवाएँककसीभीसमयएकमाहकी
कलखखतसूचनाअथवाउसके बदलेमेएकमाहकाकफकड
रेमुनरेशनदेकरसमापकीजासकतीहै ]
ककनुदुराचरण
/ कदाचारतथापुकलसदाराचररतसमनीपकतवेदनपकमेनहीं
होनेकेमामलेमेसेवाएँसमापकीजावैगी ] तबककसीपकारकी
"
कलखखतसूचनादेनाअकनवायरनहींहै।
3. As per petitioner pursuant to aforesaid appointment
order, he joined the services and was discharging his duties with
due honesty and dedication. He received one letter dated
29.10.2015 issued by Secretary Administration Ajmer Vidyut
Vitran Nigam Ltd. informing the petitioner to avail personal
hearing before him. However, letter dated 29.10.2015 was vague
in as much as there was no indication whatsoever in the letter
with regard to subject matter on which personal hearing was to be
given to him. Although, it was postponed for 26.11.2015.
4. On 26.11.2015, the petitioner appeared before the
Managing Director Ajmer Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd however,
nothing was disclosed even during personal hearing also and it
was simply an eye wash.
5. As per petitioner, he was shocked to receive the order
dated 20.01.2016 revealing therein that while seeking
appointment, an affidavit dated 31.07.2014 was submitted by the
petitioner in order to make a statement that no criminal case was
pending against him in any Court and he has not been convicted
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:44 PM)
(3 of 12)
[2026:RJ-JP:39528] [CW-1607/2017]
in any criminal case. It was also mentioned in order dated
20.01.2016 that Additional Superintendent of Police, Jaipur has
submitted a police verification report indicating therein that a
criminal case bearing No.29/2013 under Section 19/54 of
Rajasthan Excise Act was registered against the petitioner and the
same was decided on 20.07.2013. However, such fact was
allegedly suppressed by the petitioner therefore, in view of
Condition No.10 of the appointment order, his character and
antecedents were not found satisfactory and accordingly his
services were terminated.
6. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the said
case was registered on 14.01.2013, and date of birth of petitioner
is 04.10.2016. Thus, at the time of registration of criminal case
against the petitioner, he was a minor and till the date of decision
of the aforesaid case vide judgment dated 20.07.2013, he had not
attained majority. He submits that vide judgment dated
20.07.2013 although, the petitioner was convicted by the
Competent Criminal Court for committing offences under Section
19/54 of Rajasthan Excise Act, 1950, yet he was released on
probation after giving benefit of Section 4 of the Probation of
Offenders Act, 1958 (for short 'the Act of 1958').
7. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that Section
12 of the Act of 1958 makes it clear that once a benefit under
Section 4 has been given to any convict then any disqualification
attached to such conviction shall not come in the way of that
person for getting service benefits.
8. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that when
the petitioner submitted his application form for getting
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:44 PM)
(4 of 12)
[2026:RJ-JP:39528] [CW-1607/2017]
compassionate appointment in place of his deceased father and
submitted affidavit dated 31.07.2014, at that time also, age of the
petitioner was less than 18 years. In that tender age, he was not
in a position to understand the nature and consequences of
conviction followed by probation and since he was informed by his
counsel that the Competent Criminal Court has released him,
therefore, under these circumstances, suffering from lack of
abilities to understand the consequences, an affidavit was given
by him, quite bonafidely, stating that no criminal case was pending
against him in any Court, nor was he convicted in the criminal
case.
9. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that
when by virtue of Section 12 of the Act of 1958, the incumbent
stands absolved from any disqualification for getting service, if
any, is attached with the conviction, therefore, under these
circumstances, if it is assumed that such information was withheld
by the petitioner, even then, withholding of such information
cannot be said to be concealment or suppression of material fact
and services of the petitioner could not have been terminated only
on the aforesaid ground.
10. Learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon the
judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Avtar Singh
Vs. Union of India & Ors; AIR (2016) Supreme Court 3598
so as to contend that verification of character and antecedents
although is a criteria to attach suitability of any employee, yet
ultimate action should be based upon due consideration of all the
relevant facts, yet no such consideration is reflected from the
impugned order. Learned counsel also relied upon the judgment of
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:44 PM)
(5 of 12)
[2026:RJ-JP:39528] [CW-1607/2017]
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court at Principal Seat, Jodhpur i n S.B.
CWP No.585/2025 (Mohammed Aslam Silawat Vs. State of
Rajasthan & Anr.) so as to clarify the effect of granting
probation to an offender.
11. Per contra , learned counsel for the respondents
opposed the writ petition and submitted that any person seeking
appointment to a public post is supposed to come with clean
hands but in the instant case, for the purpose of assessment of
character and antecedents, disclosure of information with regard
to judgment of conviction dated 20.07.2013 was although
relevant, yet it was deliberately suppressed by the petitioner to
mislead the employer and rather, he submitted a false affidavit so
as to state that there was no pending criminal case against him,
nor was he ever convicted. It is submitted that petitioner initially
engaged as probationer trainee and as per Condition No.10 for the
appointment order upon verification of antecedents of the
candidates appointed as probationer trainee, in case, it is found
that he was having doubtful or unsatisfactory character then in
that case, his services were liable to be terminated without giving
any notice whatsoever. Learned counsel submits that grant of
benefit of probation to the petitioner while convicting him in a
criminal case is not relevant, but what is relevant is the conduct of
the petitioner where he has suppressed the said information.
Under these circumstances, it is the discretion of the employer,
while assessing the character of the candidate, to continue him in
service or not. In the instant case, after affording personal hearing
to the petitioner, and examining the nature of allegations against
the petitioner in the criminal case, no mistake whatsoever has
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:45 PM)
(6 of 12)
[2026:RJ-JP:39528] [CW-1607/2017]
been committed by the respondents in passing the impugned
order dated 20.01.2016 for terminating his services for the
petitioner. Learned counsel for the respondents has relied upon
the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of
Rajasthan & Ors. Vs. Chetan Jeff reported in (2022) 19 SCC
366 .
12. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
13. Admittedly, the petitioner was a minor when the FIR
came to be registered against him. He continued to be a minor
even when the judgment in the criminal case was rendered.
Though the petitioner was convicted, the learned Criminal Court
extended him the benefit of Section 4 of the Act of 1958.
Significantly, the petitioner was also a minor when he submitted
the application for appointment on compassionate grounds and
when the alleged affidavit was executed declaring that he had not
been convicted in any criminal case. Thus, at every material
stage, the petitioner was a juvenile/minor and there is nothing on
record to establish that he possessed the requisite understanding
of the legal distinction between a conviction simpliciter and a
conviction in respect of which the benefit of probation had been
extended under Section 4 of the Act of 1958. The alleged
declaration, therefore, cannot be examined in isolation, separated
from the petitioner's age and the legal consequence flowing from
the order of the criminal Court.
14. More importantly, the principles of natural justice have
not been duly complied with before passing the impugned order.
The notice issued to the petitioner for personal hearing was vague
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:45 PM)
(7 of 12)
[2026:RJ-JP:39528] [CW-1607/2017]
and did not disclose that the petitioner was required to explain the
alleged suppression of his conviction in the application form or
affidavit. The petitioner was, therefore, not put to notice of the
precise allegation which ultimately became the foundation for
termination of his services. A person cannot be condemned for an
alleged act of suppression without being specifically informed of
the fact alleged to have been suppressed and the manner in which
such suppression is proposed to be treated as misconduct or
disqualification. The opportunity of hearing must be real and
effective and not a mere formality. In the present case, the
petitioner was deprived of an effective opportunity to meet the
very allegation which has subsequently been made the basis of
the impugned order.
15. There is yet another and more fundamental aspect of
the matter. Section 4 of the Act of 1958 enables the Court, in
appropriate cases, to release an offender on probation of good
conduct instead of sentencing him to immediate punishment.
Section 12 of the Act of 1958 further provides that a person dealt
with under the provisions of Sections 3 or 4 shall not suffer
disqualification, if any, attaching to a conviction of an offence
under any law. The statutory consequence of extending the
benefit of Section 4 of the Act of 1958 is thus of considerable
significance. As held by coordinate Bench of this court in
Mohammed Aslam Silawat (supra), the noble intent of
enacting the probation of Offenders Act is recidivism, rehabilitation
as well as re-integration of an offender into the society and
depriving him of appointment would defeat the purpose of the Act.
Besides this, conviction followed by grant of benefit of probation
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:45 PM)
(8 of 12)
[2026:RJ-JP:39528] [CW-1607/2017]
does not operate as a disqualification for the purposes
contemplated by Section 12 of the Act of 1958. Consequently,
where the petitioner, notwithstanding the conviction, had been
extended the benefit of Section 4 of the Act of 1958, the
respondents could not have treated the said conviction as creating
a subsisting disqualification against his appointment or
continuance in service, unless the applicable service rules
expressly created a legally sustainable exception consistent with
the provisions of the Act.
16. The aforesaid statutory position assumes greater
significance in the facts of the present case. Even if the petitioner
had disclosed the fact of his conviction and the subsequent grant
of benefit of Section 4 of the Act of 1958, such disclosure, by
itself, could not have rendered him disqualified in view of the
statutory protection contained in Section 12 of the Act of 1958.
Thus, the alleged non-disclosure did not result in the petitioner
obtaining any appointment or service benefit to which he was
otherwise legally disentitled. The essential element of material
suppression, therefore, is conspicuously absent. Suppression of a
fact can furnish a valid ground for cancellation or termination only
where the suppressed fact was legally relevant and capable of
materially affecting the entitlement of the employee. Where
disclosure of the fact could not, by operation of law, have resulted
in denial of the benefit sought, non-disclosure of such fact cannot
mechanically be elevated to the status of fraud, concealment or
suppression warranting the extreme consequence of termination
from service.
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:45 PM)
(9 of 12)
[2026:RJ-JP:39528] [CW-1607/2017]
17. The issue of suppression of criminal antecedents has to
be examined in the light of the principles authoritatively
summarised by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Avtar Singh
(supra) . It has been held in the above case that for examining
the effect of concealment of any fact relating to criminal
antecedants of the candidate while filling the application form, the
employer is also required to take into consideration the nature of
the offence, the post in question, the applicable rules/instructions
and the surrounding circumstances, and the decision cannot be
mechanical.
18. The aforesaid principle has consistently been applied by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court to prevent disproportionate
consequences flowing from trivial criminal antecedents. In
Commissioner of Police & Ors. vs. Sandeep Kumar reported
in (2011) 4 SCC 644 , the Hon’ble Court held that non-disclosure
of a case under Sections 325/34 IPC, which had subsequently
been compromised, could not justify cancellation of candidature,
particularly having regard to the youthful age of the candidate and
the trivial nature of the incident. The Court observed that youthful
indiscretions of such nature ought not to result in a person being
branded a criminal for the rest of his life.
19. Likewise, in Ram Kumar vs. State of Uttar Pradesh
& Ors. reported in (2011) 14 SCC 709 , the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that even though the candidate had not correctly
disclosed his involvement in a criminal case, the appointing
authority was required to examine the nature of the suppression
and the nature of the criminal case and could not mechanically
cancel the selection merely because an incorrect declaration had
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:45 PM)
(10 of 12)
[2026:RJ-JP:39528] [CW-1607/2017]
been made. The Court found that, in the facts of that case, the
acquittal and the circumstances underlying the prosecution did not
render the candidate unsuitable for appointment as a constable.
20. The principle was reiterated and applied by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Pawan Kumar vs. Union of India & Anr.
reported in (2023) 12 SCC 317 , wherein it was held that mere
suppression of information, irrespective of whether the criminal
case resulted in conviction or acquittal, does not require discharge
or termination automatically. The employer must consider the
relevant facts and circumstances, the antecedents, the objective
criteria governing suitability and the nature of the post before
taking a decision.
21. So far as judgment of Chetan Jeff (supra) as relied
upon by learned counsel for the respondent is concerned, the facts
in that case were altogether different. In para 34 of the judgment,
the Hon’ble court has considered that apart from the criminal case
in question for assessing the character of the candidate in that
case, he was implicated in three to four other FIRs also. The
Hon’ble Supreme court considering the matter of appointment of a
Constable, and it was observed duty of the Constable is to
maintain law and order; and an employee in Uniformed service
presupposes a higher level of integrity. Thus, in entirety character
of the candidate was examined, hence, reliance upon such
judgment would not advance the case of the respondents.
22. Thus, the settled position is not that every suppression
of a criminal case stands condoned, nor that every suppression
automatically warrants termination. The decisive consideration is
whether the information was specifically required to be disclosed,
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:45 PM)
(11 of 12)
[2026:RJ-JP:39528] [CW-1607/2017]
whether its non-disclosure was deliberate and attributable to the
employee, the nature and gravity of the criminal case, its ultimate
outcome, the age and circumstances of the employee at the
relevant time, the nature of the post and whether the antecedent
has any rational bearing upon his suitability. Consequently, an
order of cancellation or termination founded merely upon the fact
of non-disclosure, without an objective consideration of these
relevant circumstances, cannot be sustained.
23. It is also well settled that the consequence of
suppression cannot be determined mechanically merely because
any statement in the affidavit was technically incorrect. The
nature of the offence, the circumstances in which the conviction
was recorded, the age of the person at the relevant time, the
nature of the declaration, the legal effect of the order granting
probation and the materiality of the fact allegedly suppressed are
all relevant considerations. The respondents, instead of examining
these circumstances in their proper perspective, have proceeded
solely on the basis that the petitioner had suffered a conviction
and had not disclosed the same. Such an approach overlooks the
statutory protection available under Section 12 of the Act of 1958
and the peculiar circumstance that the petitioner was himself a
minor when the declaration was made.
24. Consequently, the impugned order, insofar as it
terminates the services of the petitioner on the ground of alleged
suppression/concealment of his conviction, suffers from violation
of principles of natural justice, non-consideration of the statutory
protection under Section 12 of the Act of 1958, and non-
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:45 PM)
(12 of 12)
[2026:RJ-JP:39528] [CW-1607/2017]
application of mind to the material circumstances attending the
alleged declaration.
25. Accordingly, the impugned termination order, being
contrary to the statutory protection available to the petitioner,
having been passed without affording an effective opportunity of
hearing and suffering from non-application of mind to the material
circumstances, cannot be sustained and is liable to be quashed.
26. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The impugned
order dated 20.01.2016 terminating the services of the petitioner
on the ground of alleged suppression/concealment of his
conviction is quashed and set aside. The respondents are directed
to reinstate the petitioner forthwith in service with continuity of
service and all consequential service benefits. However, the
petitioner shall be entitled for notional benefit for the intervening
period from the date of termination to the date of this judgment.
Actual benefits shall be admissible to him from the date of this
judgment.
27. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
(ANAND SHARMA),J
50/NEERU
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 01:14:05 PM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 02:00:45 PM)
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)