HATHWAY DIGITAL LTD vs SONAR BANGLA
- Court
- Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal
1
TELECOM DISPUTES SETTLEMENT & APPELLATE TRIBUNAL
NEW DELHI
st
Dated 21 November 2026
Broadcasting Petition No. 528 of 2021
Hathway Digital Limited … Petitioner
Vs.
Sonar Bangla … Respondent
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAM KRISHNA GAUTAM, MEMBER
For Petitioner : Mr. Nasir Husain, Advocate
For Respondent : Ms. Ananya Mukherjee, Advocate
JUDGMENT
1. This Petition, under Section 14, read with Section 14A of the Telecom
Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997, (hereinafter referred to as
“TRAI Act”), has been filed, by Petitioner Hathway Digital Ltd., earlier
known as Hathway Digital Private Limited, against Respondent Sonar
Bangla, with a prayer for a decree, in the tune of Rs. 20,65,000/-
(Rupees Twenty Lakhs Sixty Five Thousand Only), due towards
2
Channel promotion dues, with an interest of 20% per annum rate
over it.
2. In brief, the Petition contends that Petitioner, Hathway Digital Limited
is a Company, incorporated under the provisions of the Companies
th
Act, 1956, having its Registered Office at 805/806 Windsor, 8 Floor
of CST Kalina Road, Santa Cruz (East), Mumbai – 98, and is engaged in
re-transmitting the signals of Cable TV to its various operators on
PAN India basis. It is an MSO, engaged in the business of Distribution
of Television Channels, under License granted to it, under Cable
Television Networks Act. Previously, this concern was known as
Hathway Digital Private Limited, but this name got changed in
present name, w.e.f., 03.06.2020. Respondent, Sonar Bangla, is a
partnership firm, represented by its partners Mr. Panna Lal Dutta
and Ms. Suparna Naskar, having the firm’s registered address at
371/2A, Diamond Harbour Road, Kolkata– 700034. It is a
broadcaster/ Channel Provider, distributing channel namely “Sonar
Bangla”. Respondent was desirous of promoting its channel and the
content thereof, on the Petitioner’s network, so approached
Petitioner, for ensuring maximum coverage of this channel to its
subscribers. This request was accepted by Petitioner, resulting
3
execution of Memorandum of Understanding(MOU), dated
08.02.2019, wherein, Respondent was to make the payment of Rs.
30,00,000/- (Rupees Thirty Lakhs Only), plus applicable taxes per
annum, to be paid as monthly in advance, to the Petitioner for
promotion of its above channel, for a period commencing from
01.02.2019 to 31.01.2020 in the area of West Bengal. This
Memorandum of Understanding, dated 08.02.2019 is Annexure P-1
to Petition. This MOU Annexure P-1, got expired with efflux of time
on 31.01.2020. But, Respondent verbally requested the Petitioner to
continue with the arrangement/ understanding in terms of the MOU,
dated 08.02.2019, under an assurance by Respondent, to make the
payment as per above MOU, and for executing a fresh agreement at
an earliest. Under this mutual understanding, the services were
provided and were got enjoyed by Respondent. Under the pretext of
COVID-19 pandemic, this MOU was not got signed by Respondent.
Though there was assurance for making outstanding cleared, and
fresh MOU got executed, but, it was not done so. Rather, services
were availed by Respondent. Petitioner had raised invoices on the
Respondent, which were duly received by it, without any protest or
demur. Rather, a part payment was made by Respondent. Copies of
some of the invoices sent to Respondent are Annexure P-2 (Colly)
to Petition. The Statement of Account, being maintained by
Petitioner, with regard to Respondent, in usual and ordinary course
4
of business, was with all such details of outstanding, and this is
Annexure P-3 to Petition. Respondent always avoided to clear the
outstanding dues of the Petitioner, towards Channel promotion
dues, despite regular requests, follow-ups and reminders from the
Petitioner to Respondent, instead of coming forward with bonafide
intentions of making the payments, only provided false assurances
and promise to the Petitioner that the payments of the Petitioner will
be cleared soon. But, nothing positive happened. It was apparent
that the Respondent had no intention of making payment, despite
persistent request and reminder for the same. Hence, a notice,
dated 14.07.2020, calling upon the Respondent to clear the
outstanding dues, amounting to Rs. 20,65,000/- (Rupees Twenty
Lakhs and Sixty Five Thousand Only) was got issued, which was of
no response. This notice is Annexure P-4 (Colly) to Petition.
Subsequently, a disconnection notice, dated 20.07.2020 calling for
payment of Rs. 20,65,000/- (Rupees Twenty Lakhs and Sixty Five
Thousand Only) towards promotion of Respondent’s above Channel
and in case of failure, to get it disconnected, was got issued. The
notice along with proof of dispatch is Annexure P-5 (Colly). Inspite
of several emails and recourse, no payment was made, rather, in its
reply email, dated 30.06.2020, Respondent acknowledged and
confirmed that they are ready to make whatever dues are there, till
the month of March, 2020, i.e., Rs.8,85,000/- (Rupees Eight Lakhs
5
Eighty Five Thousand Only) to the Petitioner. Meaning thereby, dues
in the tune of Rs. 8,85,000/- (Rupees Eight Lakhs Eighty Five
Thousand Only) was admitted by that email. This email was replied
by Petitioner on 30.06.2020 for making entire amount paid, but of no
avail. Hence, this connection was got disconnected on 12.08.2020.
A cause of action, within the period limitation, in the territorial
jurisdiction of this Tribunal, had arisen. Hence, this Petition with
above prayer having interim relief prayer, for the admitted amount of
Rs.8,85,000/- (Rupees Eight Lakhs Eighty Five Thousand Only)
under Order XII Rule 6 CPC, was got filed.
3. Reply, is with contention that there had arisen no cause of action
against the Respondent. No liability of Rs.8,85,000/- (Rupees Eight
Lakhs Eighty Five Thousand Only) was ever admitted, vide email of
Respondent, dated 30.06.2020 upto January to March, 2020.
Rather, vide email, dated 30.06.2020, the Respondent had made it
very clear to the Petitioner that at the best, they were ready to pay
the dues only till March, 2020, subject to a discount of 30%, and
time period till November, 2020. Nothing was to be paid for the
period April, 2020 onwards, because of the worsened situation due
to pandemic, and in case of any improvement in the pandemic
situation, the new agreement could be signed. Legal notice, dated
10.03.2020, alleged to be sent by Petitioner to the Respondent,
6
calling upon it to pay the alleged outstanding amount of
Rs.8,85,000/- (Rupees Eight Lakhs Eighty Five Thousand Only)
within seven days, failing which, the Petitioner would discontinue
distribution of channel of the Respondent, was not responded by the
Respondent. But, Petitioner continued to promote the Channel of
Respondent, on its network, at its own sweet will, till 12.08.2020
without any request or assurance from the Respondent. In view of
above disconnection notice, and also in view of response or
assurance from the Respondent, the Respondent cannot be held
liable for the fees payable for promotion for the period February,
2020 onwards. At no point of time till July, 2020, the Petitioner ever
called upon Respondent to pay for the period April, 2020 onwards
and in all the meetings that had taken place in between, the
Respondent had made it expressly clear, that due to pandemic
lockdown and the Cyclone Amphan, they were unable to pay the
alleged outstanding of Rs.8,85,000/- (Rupees Eight Lakhs Eighty
Five Thousand Only), and Respondent was not in position to renew
the MOU. From day one i.e., from the expiry of the MOU, there has
neither been any express, nor any implied consent, or confirmation,
on part of Respondent, for extension or renewal of MOU. Petitioner
itself, by its email, dated 30.03.2020, 04.05.2020, 25.05.2020, and
28.06.2020 has asked the Respondent to confirm the deal i.e., has
inquired about the intention of Respondent in respect of renewal of
7
MOU, which was never responded by the Respondent, until
02.07.2020. Meaning thereby, till 02.07.2020, the Petitioner was
absolutely clear, that the MOU had not been extended or renewed
and the Petitioner was carrying the channel of the Respondent at its
own sweet will, in which case, the Respondent is not liable for any
fees, for promoting the channel of the Respondent on its network.
Invoices attached with the Petition as Annexure P-2 were never
received by Respondent. They were never sent by Petitioner. A
prayer was for dismissing this Petition.
4. Replication was with reiteration of contention of Petition and denial of
the contention of reply.
5. On the basis of pleadings of both side, following issues were got
framed vide Order, dated 16.01.2023:
(1) Whether the instant petition is maintainable in its
present form?
(2) Whether the instant petition is liable to be dismissed
on the ground of concealment of material fact
including Demand Notice dated 10.3.2020 issued by
the Petitioner?
8
(3) Whether the Respondent is in breach of the terms of
Memorandum of Understanding signed between the
parties?
(4) Whether the Petitioner is entitled to a decree for
recovery of Rs.20,65,000/- towards dues of channel
promotion along with interest @ 24% p.a. from the
date the amount became due and payable till its
actual realization?
(5) To what other relief / reliefs the Petitioner is entitled
to?
6. Evidence by way of Affidavit, for and on behalf of Petitioner by Rajeev
Sengupta and of Respondent, Panna Lal Dutta, got filed on record.
7. Written submission by both side got filed.
8. Heard arguments of Learned Counsel for both side and gone through
the materials placed on record.
9. Hon’ble Apex Court in Anil Rishi Vs. Gurbaksh Singh – AIR 2006 SC
1971 has propounded that onus to prove a fact is on the person who
9
asserts it. Under Section 102 of The Indian Evidence Act, initial onus
is always on the plaintiff to prove his case and if he discharges, the
onus shifts to defendant. It has further been propounded in Premlata
Vs. Arhant Kumar Jain- AIR 1976 SC 626 that where both parties have
already produced whatever evidence they had, the question of
burden of proof ceases to have any importance. But while
appreciating the question of burden of proof and misplacing the
burden of proof on a particular party and recording of findings in a
particular way will definitely vitiate the judgment. The old principle
propounded by Privy Council in Lakshman Vs. Venkateswarloo – AIR
1949 PC 278 still holds good that burden of proof on the pleadings
never shifts, it always remains constant. Factually proving of a case in
his favour is cost upon plaintiff when he fulfils, onus shifts over
defendants to adduce rebutting evidence to meet the case made out
by plaintiff. Onus may again shift to plaintiff. Hon’ble Apex Court in
State of J & K Vs Hindustan Forest Co. (2006) 12 SCC 198 has
propounded that the plaintiff cannot obviously take advantage of the
weakness of defendant. The plaintiff must stand upon evidence
adduced by him. Though unlike a criminal case, in civil cases there is
no mandate for proving fact beyond reasonable doubt, but even
10
preponderance of probabilities may serve as a good basis of decision,
as was propounded in M Krishnan Vs Vijay Singh- 2001 CrLJ 4705.
Hon’ble Apex Court in Raghvamma Vs. A Cherry Chamma – AIR 1964
SC 136 has propounded that burden and onus of proof are two
different things. Burden of proof lies upon a person who has to
prove the facts and it never shifts. Onus of proof shifts. Such shifting
of onus is a continuous process in evaluation of evidence.
10. Issue No. 1 – This petition, under Section 14, read with 14A ,of TRAI
Act, has been filed by Hathway Digital Limited, a Company
incorporated under the Companies Act, having license for re-
transmitting the signals of Cable TV, to its various operators on PAN
India basis. It is an MSO, engaged in the business of distribution of
television channels and holds the license under the Cable Television
Network Act. It is a ‘service provider’, under TRAI Act. Respondent,
‘Sonar Bangla’ is a partnership firm’ represented by its partners’ Mr
Panna Lal Dutta and Ms. Suparna Naskar, having its Office, as above,
and is a broadcaster/ Channel Provider, and distributor of the
channel namely “Sonar Bangla”. They have entered in a
Memorandum of Understanding for Channel promotion in the area
11
of West Bengal, by way of a written Memorandum of Understanding,
dated 08.02.2019, for a period from 01.02.2019 to 31.01.2020,
annexed as Annexure P-1 to Petition. The dispute in between, with
regard to claimed promotional charge, in the tune of Rs. 20,65,000/-
(Rupees Twenty Lakhs and Sixty Five Thousand Only) had arisen, and
for redressal of same, this Petition has been filed. Hence, it is well
within the jurisdiction and period limitation for it. Respondent failed
to prove otherwise. Hence, this issue is being decided in favour of
Petitioner.
11. Issue Nos. 2, 3 and 4 – Issue Nos. 2, 3 and 4 are one and common
issues. Hence, are to be decided in one discussion.
The very perusal of the Memorandum of Understanding, annexed as
Annexure P-1 to Petition, and proved by way of affidavit evidence, it
is apparent that Hathway Digital Limited, MSO and Sonar Bangla-
broadcaster, had entered in this Memorandum, on 08.02.2019, for a
term of twelve months, with a condition of termination situation in
it, having specification with regard to area of operation and payment
schedule written in it. It was for Rs. 30,00,000/- (Rupees Thirty Lakhs
12
Only) plus applicable taxes per annum, with a condition of monthly
advance in lieu of its Channel, being promoted by Hathway through
its platform in the agreed territory. This Memorandum was for a
period, commencing from 01.02.2019 to 31.01.2020, and for this
period, the execution of MOU, and the payment for that period, said
to be made by Respondent, is undisputed. The dispute is that,
renewal of agreement was not there, post 31.01.2020, and the
alleged claim, as well as invoices attached, are for the period post
31.01.2020. As per admitted fact, the reply to emails, for the first
time, was made by Respondent on 12.08.2020. But, in Para 2 of the
reply, it has been specifically admitted by Respondent, that
Petitioner continued to promote the Channel of Respondent on its
sweet will till 12.08.2020, without any request or
network at its own
assurance from the Respondent. Hence, Respondent may not be
held liable for the promotional charges for the period February, 2020
onward till 12.08.2020, whereas, the Petitioner in its evidence had
specifically said that Respondent, who was desirous of promoting
the said Channel ‘Sonar Bangla’ and content thereof, to be
transmitted by Petitioner, made a request to Petitioner, to place the
Channel at a better Channel position/ frequency on the Petitioner’s
Network, so, as to ensure that the Channel gets maximum
13
coverage/ viewership to the viewers/ subscribers. Upon this request,
Petitioner agreed to place the Channel of Respondent, and
accordingly, got Memorandum of Understanding, dated 08.02.2019
executed under the terms agreed in between. This MOU is not
under dispute at all. It is also not under dispute that this MOU, dated
08.02.2019 got expired with efflux of time, on 31.01.2020. The
verbal request by Respondent to Petitioner to continue with the
arrangement/ understanding in terms of MOU, dated 08.02.2019,
with an assurance to make the payment for it, and getting fresh
agreement executed, at an earliest, is also said on oath, for which
there is no request for cross examination by Respondent. This is
also not disputed fact that Respondent enjoyed the said service of
Petitioner, as per MOU, 08.02.2019, even after its expiry by efflux of
time, till actual disconnection made by Petitioner and the email sent
by Respondent, making request for no chance of any renewal of
agreement, owing to pandemic situation, even then there was a
promise for getting agreement renewed, if the situation changes.
Meaning thereby, there was an implied consent, and it was the
Covid-19 pandemic, which did not permit the physical form of
execution of agreement of renewal. But, services were being
provided, and it was being availed by Respondent till August, 2020.
Notice, as well as invoices, sent to Respondent have been exhibited
as Exhibit P-3 and Exhibit P-2 (Colly) by Petitioner in its evidence.
14
Hence, the Respondent in its evidence too, has admitted the
execution of MOU, the existence of relationship, the conditions
written in MOU, the facts of MOU, dated 08.02.2019, being of no
dispute. The COVID-19 situation and continuation of services till
12.08.2020, avail of this service till 12.08.2020, repeated requests
and emails by Petitioner, for getting the renewal of the agreement,
and making of the payment towards invoices. Respondent itself in
its affidavit evidence, in Para 8, has said, that “I say that till July
2020 there had been a demand of Rs. 8,85,000/- only from the
Petitioner for the payment of which certain conditions had been put
by the Respondent meaning thereby the offer to the Respondent to
pay the said amount was conditional and not absolute. I further say
that the demand of Rs. 20,65,000/- had been made by the Petitioner
in July 2020 only which was not maintainable. I say that by way of
th nd
its Email of 30 June and 2 July of 2020 the Respondent had
made it clear beyond all doubts that the payment till March 2020
could only be made subject to certain conditions. Copy of email
nd
dated 2 July 2020 has been filed by the Petitioner in this petition at
Page No.39 which is relied upon by the Respondent also and is
th
marked as Exhibit – R2 . Copy of the email dated 30 June 2020
along with its attachment has been filed by the Petitioner in the
petition at Page Nos. 42 – 44 which are relied upon by the
Respondent and are marked as Exhibit – R3 (Colly) .” In Para 11, it
15
has been admitted that disconnection notice, dated 20.07.2020 was
th
issued by Petitioner and before it, a legal notice, dated 10 March
2020, was also given to Respondent. Meaning thereby, it has been
admitted by Respondent that reply to email was given by
Respondent, only on 30.06.2020 and 02.07.2020. The connection
was got discontinued on 12.08.2020. Hence, this statement of
account filed by Petitioner is with no Statement of Account, for and
on behalf of Respondent, to show as to whether what was remaining
as against Respondent for making payment to Petitioner. Exhibit –
P4 (Colly) to Petition, is notice, dated 14.07.2020, sent by Petitioner
to Respondent, with a specific mention of demand of outstanding
dues for marketing and promotion Channel, for the period
01.02.2020 till 31.07.2020, and this amount till 31.07.2020 was Rs.
20,65,000/- including the taxes. The disconnection notice, under
Clause 17, of the
Telecommunication (Broadcasting and Cable)
Services Interconnection (Addressable Systems) Regulations, 2017,
dated 03.03.2017, Annexure P-5, is with a specific mention of that
claimed amount, for the additional period till actual disconnection.
Hence, as the amount claimed is from the month of February to July,
with a specific bill value and GST in the tune of Rs. 20,65,000/-, the
remaining balance of the undisputed period has been shown in this
Statement of Account to be of Rs. 2,95,000/-(Rupees Two Lakhs
16
Ninety Five Thousand only), and the same is there in this claimed
amount, for which there is no Statement of Account by the
Respondent on record, nor there is any evidence to say, that there
was no balance to be paid by Respondent, for undisputed MOU
period. Hence, though disconnection was said to be of 12.08.2020,
but the claimed amount is till July 2020, hence, this balanced amount
is to be paid by Respondent to Petitioner. Hence, these three issues
are being decided in favour of Petitioner.
12. With regard to interest, this Tribunal in many of Petitions previously
decided, as well as considering the fiscal and current scenario of the
interest in trade activities etc., has awarded 9% Simple Interest per
annum. Hence, in the present fact and circumstances of this Petition,
the same will be just and reasonable rate of interest to be awarded
in present Petition too.
ORDER
17
This Petition is being decreed. Respondent is being directed to
make payment, in the Tribunal, within two months of Judgment,
Rs.20,65,000/- (Rupees Twenty Lakhs Sixty Five Thousand only)
towards outstanding promotional/ placement charges, for making
payment to Petitioner, alongwith a Simple Interest, pendente lite and
future, @ 9% per annum, for making payment to Petitioner, failing
which the same will be realised, as an execution of the decree.
Formal order / decree be got prepared by the office,
accordingly.
….......………………
(Justice Ram Krishna Gautam)
Member
21.11.2026
/NC/