JITENDRA KUMAR vs THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN
- Court
- Rajasthan High Court
(1 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
AT JODHPUR
D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 666/2025
CNR: RJHC010398292025
URN: SAW / 1151U / 2025
Jitendra Kumar adopted son of Mohan Lal, Aged About 38 Years,
R/o New Gokulwadi (Heera Bhura Jaav), Sheoganj, Tehsil
Shivganj, District Sirohi, Rajasthan.
----Appellant
Versus
1. The State of Rajasthan through the District Collector,
Sirohi, Rajasthan.
2. Nagar Palika Mandal, Shivganj, District Sirohi through Its
Chairman / President.
3. Executive Engineer, Nagar Palika Mandal, Shivganj,
District Sirohi.
----Respondents
For Appellant(s) : Mr. Girish Kumar Sankhla.
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Ayush Gehlot for
Mr. Rajesh Panwar AAG.
HON'BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SANJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEET PUROHIT
JUDGMENT
Reportable
16/07/2026
(Per Mr. Sanjeet Purohit, J):
1. Present special appeal has been filed challenging judgment
dated 17.01.2025 passed by learned Single Judge, whereby the
writ petition filed by appellant seeking compassionate appointment
on the basis of an adoption deed was dismissed.
2. Facts germane to present special appeal, as narrated by
learned counsel for the appellant, are that appellant is married to
the elder daughter of one Shri Mohan Lal, who was employed as
Jamadar with respondent - Nagar Palika Mandal, Sheoganj. During
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(2 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
his lifetime, said Shri Mohan Lal is stated to have executed an
adoption deed dated 01.11.2012 and thereby adopted appellant as
his son in the presence of witnesses. Shri Mohan Lal passed away
on 03.11.2012, whereafter the adoption deed was registered
posthumously on 17.12.2012 before the Sub-Registrar, Sheoganj,
District Sirohi.
2.1 On the basis of aforesaid adoption deed, appellant submitted
an application before respondent - Nagar Palika Mandal seeking
appointment on compassionate grounds.
2.2 Vide communication dated 11.01.2013, respondent - Nagar
Palika initially raised an objection to said adoption deed on the
ground that signature of late Shri Mohan Lal marked upon the
deed did not match with the signature available in the official
records. In response thereto, Smt. Shanti Devi, widow of late Shri
Mohan Lal, submitted representation dated 17.01.2013 requesting
grant of compassionate appointment to appellant, and both
daughters of late Shri Mohan Lal also submitted their consent
letters supporting appellant’s claim for appointment based on said
adoption deed.
2.3 However, vide order dated 15.05.2013, respondent - Nagar
Palika rejected appellant’s application on the ground that appellant
had failed to produce the required legal documents.
2.4 Aggrieved by said order dated 15.05.2013, appellant
preferred writ petition before learned Single Judge, which was
dismissed vide impugned judgment dated 17.01.2025.
2.5 Challenging order dated 15.05.2013 and judgment dated
17.01.2025, appellant has approached this Court by way of the
present Special Appeal.
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(3 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
3. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that appellant
was entitled to compassionate appointment as adopted son of late
Shri Mohan Lal, particularly in view of the adoption deed as well as
the consent letters submitted by the other family members. It was
argued that respondent – Nagar Palika erred in rejecting the
application of appellant on the ground of having not produced a
valid adoption deed, whereas appellant had already submitted the
duly registered adoption deed before the respondent.
3.1 Learned counsel stated that, prior to his death, late Shri
Mohan Lal remained hospitalized for more than 16 months. It was
submitted that late Shri Mohan Lal died shortly after executing the
adoption deed and since the same could not be registered during
his lifetime due to ill health, therefore, the deed was registered
soon thereafter in the presence of other family members. It was
contended that such posthumous registration would not invalidate
the adoption deed.
3.2 Learned counsel further submitted that although respondent
authorities questioned the validity of said adoption under Section
10 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 ("the
HAMA "), learned Single Judge failed to consider the statutory
presumption of validity attached to a registered adoption deed
under Section 16 of the HAMA.
3.3 It was also submitted that late Shri Mohan Lal was survived
by his widow and two daughters, and appellant, being his adopted
son and the only surviving male member of the family, was
entitled to compassionate appointment, which has wrongly been
denied to him.
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(4 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
3.4 Learned counsel also stated that, at the time of filing the writ
petition, appellant was 27 years of age, and, further, he was 38
years old by the time the matter was finally decided; however,
learned Single Judge erroneously observed in the impugned order
that appellant was 42 years old at the time of filing the writ
petition and 54 years old when the judgment was passed. It was,
therefore, prayed that the present appeal deserves to be allowed.
4. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents,
while supporting the impugned order of respondent – Nagar Palika
rejecting appellant’s application for compassionate appointment,
submitted that the adoption deed was purportedly executed on
01.11.2012 - mere two-days prior to the death of Shri Mohan Lal
on 03.11.2012, and was registered posthumously on 17.12.2012.
Therefore, it was contended, no statutory presumption under
Section 16 of the HAMA could be drawn in favour of appellant.
4.1 It was further contended that, even assuming appellant was
26 years old when he was adopted by late Shri Mohan Lal, the
adoption itself is invalid in view of the provisions of Section 10 of
the HAMA, which stipulates interalia that a person above the age
of 15 years or married cannot be taken in adoption. Although,
learned counsel for the respondents fairly conceded that said
section provides an exception to the age criteria where the
customs or usage applicable to the parties concerned permit such
adoption, learned counsel argued that neither the adoption deed
nor the pleadings contain any averments regarding the existence
of such customs or usage applicable to the family of late Shri
Mohan Lal.
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(5 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
4.2 Learned counsel contended that the adoption deed in
question was created after the death of late Shri Mohan Lal solely
with a view to secure compassionate appointment in place of the
deceased and that such forged documents defeat the very object
of providing for compassionate appointment, namely, to provide
immediate financial assistance to the genuine dependents of a
deceased employee.
4.3 In support of his submissions, learned counsel for the
respondents has placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court delivered in the case of Atluri Brahmanandam
(D) Thr. Lrs v. Anne Sai Bapuji reported in AIR 2011 SC 545 ,
as well as the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court at
Jaipur Bench delivered in the case of Kumari Vinita Sharma v.
Union of India & Ors. , decided on 15.01.2014.
5. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
6. The undisputed facts of the case are that appellant applied
before respondent – Nagar Palika for seeking compassionate
appointment in place of the deceased – Shri Mohan Lal claiming to
be his adopted son. Said claim of adoption was based upon an
adoption deed said to be executed on 01.11.2012 and registered
posthumously on 17.12.2012. Respondents herein have
questioned the validity of said adoption itself in view of Section 10
of the HAMA on the ground that appellant was admittedly married
and above 15 years of age at the time of alleged adoption and
thus was not eligible for adoption. Respondents have also disputed
the applicability of the statutory presumption of validity of the
registered adoption deed under Section 16 of the HAMA on the
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(6 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
ground that the deed was registered after the death of the
adoptive father.
7. Before embarking upon consideration of the challenges thus
raised against the validity of the adoption and the adoption deed,
this Court, upon perusal of the material placed on record, finds
that appellant, Jitendra Kumar, was married to the eldest daughter
of late Shir Mohan Lal, Smt. Asha, and was thus his son-in-law. It
is stated in the adoption deed placed on record that for nearly one
and half years prior to the execution of the adoption deed,
appellant had been residing with his in-laws. The recital of the
deed records that, having no son of their own, late Shri Mohan Lal
and his wife were desirous of adopting appellant as their " adopted
son-in-law ” ( God Jamai ), and when the proposal was put forth,
appellant accepted the same in those very terms. Relevant recital
of the adoption deed reads as below:
“ ;g fd eSa eksguyky dqN le; ls chekjh ls xzflr gksus ls
vf/kdka”kr;k esjk LokLF; [kjkc jgrk gS rFkk vc bl u”oj
“kjhj dk dksbZ Hkjkslk ugha jgk gSA u tkus dc Hkxoku ds ?kj
ls lans”kk vk tk;s fvkSj esjs izk.k ia[ks: mMdj bl l`f’V esa
yhu gks tk;s& blfy;s eq> eksguyky ,oa esjh /keZiRuh
Jlherh “kkfUrckbZ us vkil esa cSBdj ;g fopkj fd;k fd esjk
?kj bl nqfu;k ds fy;s [kqyk jgs ,oa esjh cgu csfV;ksa ds fy;s
mudk ihgj vkckn jgs rFkk esjk uke bl nqfu;k esa jks”ku jgs
rFkk esjs lkFk jg jgs esjs tekbZlk ftrsUnzdqekj dks esjk xksnh
tekbZ ¼?kj tekbZ½ cuk;k tkos rFkk blh izLrko esa vey djrs
gq;s eSaus esjs ifjokj ds leLr yksxksa dks blls voxr djk;k
rFkk djhc 15 fnu iwoZ eq> eksguyky ,oa esjh /keZiRuh Jherh
“kkfUrckbZ us Jh ftrsUnzdqekj iq= Jh lksguykyth ifjgkj
tkfr ekyh dks gekjk xksnh tekbZ dk;e fd;k gS rFkk bldk
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(7 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
fof/kor xksnukek vkt jkst eSa vius ifjokj dh lgefr ls
fy[k jgk gwa rFkk vkt jkst ?kks’k.kk djrk gwa fd esjs tekbZ
ftrsUnzdqekj vkt ds ckn ftrsUnzdqekj xksn tekbZ eksguyky
iq= galkth ekyh ds uke ls tkuk igpkuk o iqdkjk tk;sxk
rFkk fiNys Ms< o’kZ dh Hkkafr vkt ls esjk leLr O;ogkj
dkuwuh :i ls djsaxs rFkk esjk leLr nsuk ysuk nsxk ysxk rFkk
esjh cgu csfV;ksa ds fy;s esjk ?kj ges”kk ds fy;s [kqyk j[ksaxs
rFkk nqfu;k esa esjk uke jks”ku djsaxs rFkk os leLr dk;Z djsaxs
tks esjk ,d tk;nk iq= djrk gSA
3.
eSa ftrsUnzdqekj iq= Jh lksguykyth ifjgkj] tkfr ekyh]
fuoklh U;w xksdqyokMh& f”koxat ;g fy[kdj tkfgj djrk gwa
fd esjh “kknh eksguykyth iq= Jh galkth ekyh dh iq=h vk”kk
ds lkFk gqbZ gS rFkk esjs llqjth ds dksbZ tk;nk iq= ugha
gS ;kfu esjs dksbZ lkyk ugha rFkk muds bZPNk eqrkfcd eSa viuh
iw.kZ LosPNk ls mudk xksnh tekbZ gqvk gwa rFkk vkt ds ckn eSa
ftrsUnzdqekj xksn tekbZ eksguykyth iq= galkth ekyh ds uke
ls tkuk igpkuk ,oa iqdkj tkÅaxk ,oa vkt ls dkuwuu :i
ls eSa ;s leLr dk;Z d:axk& tks vkidk ,d tk;ank iq=
djrk gSa& vkidk leLr nsuk ysuk vc esjk nsuk ysuk
jgsxk ,oa vkidh cgu csfV;ksa gsrq ges”kk ds fy;s vkidk ?kj
[kqyk j[kqaxk ,oa muds “kknh] lxi.k] ekSr ejxr esa lekt ds
jhfr fjokt eqtc “kjhd gksdj [kpkZ d:axk ,oa vkidk uke
bl nqfu;k esa vkckn j[kqaxk ,oa vkidk uke jks”ku d:axkA esjs
ADOPTION DEED
firkth o ekrkth us bl xksnukek ¼ a½ ij
viuh iw.kZ lgefr ns nh gSA ”
The contents of the afore-quoted adoption deed, when read
according to their plain and ordinary meaning, make it abundantly
clear that the deed does not profess to adopt the appellant as a
son. Rather, it discloses an unambiguous intention of late Shri
Mohan Lal and his wife to adopt appellant as their "God Jamai"
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(8 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
(adopted son-in-law) and further declares that he shall
thereafter be known by such status.
7.1. The construction of the deed thus presents a fundamental
conceptual difficulty: We fail to comprehend the legitimacy of such
adoption by which an existing/actual/real son-in-law is sought to
be declared an adopted son-in-law. Adoption under the HAMA, or
indeed under any other law governing adoption for that matter, is
not a private arrangement under which parties may invent or
customize familial relationships according to their own
predilections. Adoption is an institution which confers legal status
upon the parties concerned. One of the legally recognized
consequences of adoption is that the adopted child is transplanted
into the adoptive family as if the child were biologically born
therein. Correspondingly, the only relationship capable of being
brought into existence through adoption is that of an adoptive
parent and adopted son or daughter. There is no legally
recognized category of an “ adopted son-in-law ” or of the converse
status of an “adoptive father-in-law ” which can possibly be
established through the institution of adoption.
Thus, if the deed is construed, strictly and literally, it must be
held to be attempting to establish a status completely unknown to
law. Such a declaration, whatever may have been the social
motivation behind it, cannot attract the incidents of a valid
adoption recognized under the HAMA.
7.2 Even if this Court were to construe the deed generously and
assume, for the benefit of appellant, that the expression God
Jamai was merely an improper choice of words and that the true
intention was indeed to adopt appellant as a son, it would still be
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(9 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
impossible to reconcile the legal consequences arising therefrom
with the governing statutory framework.
7.3 The various branches of Hindu Personal Laws, concerning
marriage, adoption and succession, form a coherent whole. The
effect and consequences of adoption, therefore, are not confined
to the provisions of HAMA but will necessarily inform and impact
the operation of the other branches of personal law as well.
7.4 In the case at hand, if this Court were now to recognize
appellant as the adopted son of late Shri Mohan Lal, when
admittedly appellant stood in the relationship of latter’s son-in-law
prior to said adoption, appellant would, in the eyes of law, become
the brother of his own wife. Is it then to be assumed that the
marriage between the appellant and the daughter of late Shri
Mohan Lal, though valid at the time of solemnization, would
continue alongside another relationship brought into existence
between the same parties through the operation of adoption - one
which is wholly inconsistent with the laws governing marriage?
Such a consequence is neither contemplated nor permitted under
the law and cannot receive judicial acceptance. Similar
incongruities would arise in matters of succession and other rights
and duties flowing from the status of family. Appellant's
construction of the adoption deed thus unsettles the very
foundations of the institution of family as organised under Hindu
personal law. Consequently, whether the deed is construed literally
or liberally and whether appellant is treated as the adopted son-
in-law or the adopted son of late Shri Mohan Lal, the result
remains the same: the alleged adoption cannot be recognized
legally.
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(10 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
7.5 Moreover, even beyond this conceptual discombobulation,
the deed does not stand the scrutiny of the applicable statutory
provisions. Appellant admittedly was both a married person and
well above fifteen years of age at the time of alleged adoption.
Each of these circumstances independently, under the provisions
of section 10 of the HAMA, renders a person incapable of being
taken in adoption unless the adoption can be justified on basis of a
valid custom or usage applicable to the parties. Neither the
adoption deed nor the pleadings disclose the existence of any such
custom.
7.6 Even otherwise, the HAMA stipulates that the customs or
usages sought to be relied upon must be reasonable, certain and
in conformity with the public policy of India. A custom that seeks
to create a status wholly alien to the statutory conception of
adoption while simultaneously unsettling the legal incidents of
marriage and family relationships would find it difficult to satisfy
those parameters.
7.7 In these circumstances, even the statutory presumption of
validity contemplated under section 16 of the HAMA cannot come
to the aid of the appellant as the adoption deed is ex-facie
violative not only of the mandatory provisions of the Act, but also
its foundational elements.
8. Furthermore, even if the contents of the deed are taken at
their face value and it is accepted that the parties intended to
declare appellant as the adopted son in law of late Shri Mohan Lal,
the status thus created would still not entitle him to
compassionate appointment in place of the deceased under the
provisions of the Rajasthan Compassionate Appointment of
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(11 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
Dependents of Deceased Government Servants Rules, 1996 (“ the
Rules of 1996 ”), which apply mutatis mutandis to the
municipalities under the Rajasthan Local Self Government
Department.
8.1 Said Rules of 1996 specifically provide for compassionate
appointment only to the dependents of the deceased Government
Servant. Rule 2(c) provides the definition of " dependent " and
reads as follows:
“ 2. Definitions: - In these rules, unless the context
otherwise requires:-
(a)-(b)…………….
(c) “Dependent” means , -
(i) Spouse, or
(ii) Son including son legally adopted by the
deceased Government servant during his/her life time,
or
(iii) unmarried/widowed/divorced daughter including
daughter legally adopted by the deceased Government
servant during his/her life time, or
(iv) married daughter, if no other dependent of the
deceased Government servant mentioned in clause (ii)
and (iii) above is available, or
(v) mother, father, unmarried brother or unmarried
sister in case of unmarried deceased Government
servant,
who was wholly dependent on the deceased
Government servant at the time of his/her death.”
A bare reading of the definition makes it clear that the same
is exhaustive and specifies the categories of persons who may
claim compassionate appointment. The definition nowhere
mentions a son-in-law or an adopted son-in-law. It must,
therefore, follow that a son-in-law, whether real or adopted, is not
eligible to claim compassionate appointment on the death of
concerned Government Servant.
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(12 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
9. It must also be observed that appellant has not approached
this Court with clean hands. Throughout the pleadings, appellant
has described himself as adopted son of late Shri Mohan Lal,
whereas the adoption deed clearly records that after the adoption,
he was to be known as the adopted son-in-law ( God Jamai ) of Shri
Mohan Lal. Notwithstanding the confusion stirred in our minds in
unravelling the mechanics of such an adoption, this Court is of the
opinion that, in any event, such a document, with its categorical
recitals, cannot be construed as conferring upon the appellant the
status of a legally adopted son.
9.1 Tellingly, the adoption deed itself records that, by way of the
adoption, appellant would become entitled to compassionate
appointment. Said recital is indicative of the oblique motive with
which the deed was executed, namely, to enable appellant to
secure compassionate appointment, knowing fully well that a son-
in-law is otherwise not eligible for such appointment under the
applicable Rules.
9.2 It is trite that the practice of compassionate appointment is
an exception to the normal rule of recruitment. It is a beneficial
provision intended to provide immediate financial relief to the
family of Government Servant who dies while in service by
offering employment to one of his genuine dependents. The
learned Single Judge has thus rightly observed that such relief
cannot be allowed to operate as an alternate mode of recruitment
or as a back-door entry to employment in government services.
10. For all the aforesaid reasons, this Court is of the considered
opinion that appellant’s claim of compassionate appointment is
unsustainable irrespective of the angle from which it is examined:-
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
(13 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:32622-DB] [SAW-666/2025]
I. If the adoption deed is construed according to its plain
language, it purports to create the status of an " adopted
son-in-law "- a status unknown under the applicable law
and incapable of attracting the legal recognition of a valid
adoption.
II. If, on the other hand, the deed is accorded the most
liberal construction possible and is construed as intending
to adopt appellant as a son, it falls within the statutory
prohibitions contained in Section 10 of the HAMA, besides
giving rise to conceptual inconsistencies wholly
incompatible with the integrated framework of Hindu
personal laws.
III. Even otherwise, appellant would still fail to establish his
entitlement under the Rules of 1996, which do not
recognise a son-in-law, whether real or adopted, as a
dependent so as to be eligible for compassionate
appointment.
The appeal, therefore, fails at every level of scrutiny.
11. Consequently, we find no infirmity in impugned judgment
dated 17.01.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge and the
same is hereby upheld.
12. Present special appeal, being devoid of merit, is dismissed .
13. Stay application and all pending applications, if any, stand
disposed of.
(SANJEET PUROHIT),J (SANJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA),ACJ
16/Sumer Singh/635
(Uploaded on 06/08/2026 at 11:06:00 AM)
(Downloaded on 11/08/2026 at 12:34:26 AM)
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)