SMT.SAVITA W/O MALLIKARJUN @ MALLAYYA SWAMY vs VIVEKANAND @ ISHWAR S/O RUDRAYYA AND ORS

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA



KALABURAGI BENCH

TH
DATED THIS THE 13 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA R

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 200016 OF 2017


BETWEEN:

SMT. SAVITA
W/O MALLIKARJUN @ MALLAYYA SWAMY
AGE:55 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. HEDGAPUR VILLAGE, TQ. AURAD(B),
DIST. BIDAR.

…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ASHOK B. MULAGE, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. VIVEKANAND @ ISHWAR S/O RUDRAYYA
AGE:36 YEARS, OCC: MIRCHI BUSINESS,
R/O. HEDGAPUR, NOW AT: YELLAMMA BANDA,
KUKATPALLI, HYDERABAD.

2. RAGI RAJSHEKHAR @ SHESHU
S/O RAGI SURENDRA,
AGE: 29 YEARS, OCC: DRUMMING OF BAND,
R/O. RAIGADD VANPARATI,
NOW GUDEWELL HOTEL,
NEAR HOUSING BOARD COLONY,
YELLAMMA BANDA, KUKATAPALLI,
HYDERABAD.








Digitally signed
by B NAGAVENI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017




3. SAI @ SAIREDDY
S/O PRABHA REDDY BADARI,
AGE:26 YEARS, OCC: CENTERING WORK,
R/O.K.P.H.B. KUKATAPALLI,
YELLAMMA BANDA, HYDERABAD.

4. THE STATE THROUGH KUSHNOOR P.S.
TQ. AURAD, DIST. BIDAR.

…RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. SANDEEP HULI, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SRI. RAJESH G. DODDAMANI, ADVOCATE FOR R2 & R3;
SRI. ANILKUMAR NAVADAGI, ADDL.SPP FOR R4)

THIS CRL.A. IS FILED UNDER SECTION 372 OF CR.P.C
PRAYING TO, ALLOW THE APPEAL AND SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT AND ORDER PASSED BY THE ADDL. DISTRICT AND
SESSIONS JUDGE AT BIDAR IN S.C.NO.89/2012
DATED:28.10.2014, ACQUITTING THE RESPONDENTS NO.1 TO
3 FOR THE OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTIONS 302, 307,
394 AND 397 R/W SECTION 34 OF IPC AND CONVICT THE
RESPONDENT NOS.1 TO 3 FOR THE CHARGES FRAMED ABOUT
AGAINST THEM.

THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA R

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI)

1. This appeal is filed by the defacto complainant under
Section 372 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
(for short, ‘Cr.P.C.,’), challenging the judgment of
acquittal dated 28.10.2014 passed in S.C.No.89 of
2012 by the Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Bidar, (for short, ‘Sessions Court’) acquitting the
respondents for the offences punishable under
Sections 302, 307, 394 and 397 read with Section 34
of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short, ‘IPC’).

2. Brief facts giving rise to filing of this appeal are as
follows:

3. On 14.01.2012, the complainant lodged a complaint
before the police stating that she along with her
husband-Mallikarjun @ Mallayya Swamy was residing
at Hedgapur Village of Aurad(B) Taluk and she is
having 4 children. Out of them, Shivakumar, Deepa

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


and Sonalika are married and her elder son
Shivakumar is an engineer by profession and he is
residing at Bangalore and another son Omkar is a
Teacher and residing at Kalaburagi. In their house
she along with her husband Mallikarjun @ Mallayya
Swamy was residing.

4. On 13.01.2012 at about 10:15 p.m., they had meals
and after closing the door, she slept in the room. Her
husband was watching TV and after half an hour,
about 11:00 p.m., her husband also came in her
room and he also slept. On 14.01.2012 at about
01:00 a.m., they heard sound calling them and her
husband gone there and she continued her sleep.
Since even after 15-20 minutes her husband did not
return, she holding battery in her hand went outside
the room and heard sound on the roof of the room
and noticed in a torch light one person was standing.
She thought thieves have come and she rushed
towards the main door to open. At that time, two

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


persons came there, caught hold her hands, closed
her mouth and threatened her not to cry and told
that they had already committed the murder of her
husband and they will kill her also. The said persons
tied a wire to her neck and dragged and she tried to
escape. One person was telling the other to hold her
hands and legs and to commit murder by tying the
wire to her neck. They took her on the roof and
assaulted on the face and other parts of the body.
She has noticed her husband fallen sustaining
bleeding injury. She also noticed that the said
persons had covered their face with cloth and they
were aged about 25 to 30 years and were talking in
Kannada and Hindi language. Two persons robbed 05
tolas of gold Patli, 04 tolas of 2 gold bangles and 01
tola gold 7 pieces, Mangalasutra and also golden ear
buds, totally about Rs.2 lakhs gold and other
ornaments have been robbed. She also noticed that
the said persons gone out from the back door of their

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


house. Immediately, she came in front of the main
door and Ashok, Sajjanshetty, Ram, Subhash and
Ramayya came there. She narrated the incident to
them and immediately after some time, she became
unconscious and admitted to Hospital in Bidar. After
regaining the consciousness, she came to know that
initially, she was taken to Santapur Government
Hospital and for higher treatment, shifted to the
hospital at Bidar. She identified one person out of 7
to 8 persons. Hence, a complaint was lodged against
the unknown persons in Crime No.4 of 2012 for the
offence punishable under Section 396 of IPC. The
Police after investigation filed charge sheet against
four persons.

5. Perusal of the material on record would disclose that
the learned JMFC took cognizance and furnished
copies of the charge sheet to the
respondents/accused by acting under Section 209 of
Cr.P.C. Thereafter, the case has been committed to

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


the learned Principal District Judge, Bidar, for trial by
order dated 20.04.2012.

6. The learned Session Judge, on the basis of the
charge sheet, framed the charges and the contents
of the charges were read over and explained to the
accused/respondents and they denied the charges
and claimed to be tried.

7. The prosecution, in order to prove its case, examined
26 witnesses as PW1 to PW26 and marked 30
documents as Exs.P1 to P30 and M.Os.1 to 58.

8. After recording the evidence of the prosecution
witnesses, the Sessions Court examined the accused
under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., by way of putting every
incriminating circumstances appearing against them.
They denied each and every incriminating
circumstances appearing against them, but, they
have not led any evidence.

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



9. The Sessions Court, after hearing the learned counsel
for the parties, framed the following points for
consideration:
“1. Whether the prosecution proves that on
14.01.12 at about 1.30am in the house of
complainant at Hedgapur village, in
furtherance of common of all A1 tied the wire
on the neck of Mallayya A2 to A4 stabbed on
his chest, stomach, back, committed his
murder by causing his death?
2. Whether the prosecution proves that on the
date, time and place specified in point no.1, in
furtherance of common intention A1 put the
wire on the neck of PW1, A2 to A4 assaulted
her with their hands and they attempted to
commit her murder?
3. Whether prosecution proves that on the
date time and place specified in point no.1 the
accused were committed robbery by
extorcting the valuables of PW1 worth
` .5,17,500/= on voluntarily causing hurt?
4. Whether the prosecution proves that on the
above, said date, time and place specified in
point no.1, A1 to A4 did commit robbery by

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


extracting ` .5,17,500/= and ornaments and
while carrying them caused grievous hurt to
PW1 Smt Savita and committing the murder
of her husband Mallayya?
5. Whether the prosecution proves the guilt
against the accused beyond all reasonable
doubts?
6. What order?”


10. The Sessions Court, after hearing the learned counsel
for the parties and after appreciating the entire
evidence on record, answered point Nos.1 to 5 in the
Negative and point No.6 as per the final order and
acquitted the respondents by judgment dated
28.10.2014.

11. The defacto complainant aggrieved by the judgment
and order of acquittal dated 28.10.2014 passed in
S.C.No.89 of 2012 filed this appeal under Section
372 of Cr.P.C.

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



12. Heard the arguments of the learned counsel
appearing for the defacto complainant, learned
counsels appearing for respondent Nos.1 to 3/
accused and learned Additional State Public
Prosecutor appearing for respondent No.4-State.

13. Learned counsel appearing for the defacto
complainant submits that PW.1 is an injured witness.
She has supported the case of the prosecution. He
submits that the prosecution has examined the
doctor, as PW.25, who has treated PW.1. PW.1
sustained grievous injuries. The evidence of PW.1 is
sufficient to pass the judgment of conviction. The
learned Session Court has not properly appreciated
the evidence of PW.1. He also submits that the other
witnesses have also supported the case of the
prosecution to prove the guilt of the accused beyond
reasonable doubt. There is no discrepancy in the
evidence of the prosecution witnesses. The Sessions
Court has passed the impugned judgment on the

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


basis of assumption and presumption. Hence, on
these ground, he prays to allow the appeal.
Per contra
14. , learned counsel for respondent Nos.1 to
3/accused submits that, during the course of cross-
examination, PW.1 has admitted that, in her
statement at Ex.P11, she has not disclosed the acts
of accused No.1 in committing the murder of her
husband and also causing hurt to herself and she has
also admitted that she was unconscious. She has
also admitted that at about 01:30 a.m., on
14.01.2012 she fell unconscious and on the next day
morning at about 09:00 a.m., she gained
consciousness. When she gained consciousness, she
saw Ashok, Ramayya, Siddanna and Subhash. She
also admitted that when she gained consciousness,
the police were not in the hospital. It is elicited that
she has not informed the police regarding the alleged
incident and the same was informed by Ashok,
Ramayya, Siddanna and Subhash to the police. He

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


also submits that PW.1 has admitted that in Ex.P1
she has stated that some 7 to 8 persons came and
assaulted herself and her husband and she has not
disclosed the names and address of the persons who
have assaulted. She has also admitted that she was
on the roof of the house and she did not raise any
voice on account of fear of her death. Rest of the
witnesses have not supported the case of the
prosecution. Hence, the Sessions Court has rightly
passed the impugned judgment and order of
acquittal.

15. He also submits that in the case of challenge to a
judgment of acquittal, the scope of judicial
interference is very narrow. To buttress his
arguments, he has placed reliance on the judgment
of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of
1
Jafarudheen and others vs. State of Kerala .
Hence, he submits that the impugned judgment

1
2022 SCC Online SC 495

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


passed by the Sessions Court is just and proper and
does not call for interference at the hands of this
Court. Therefore, on these grounds, he prays to
dismiss the appeal.

16. Perused the records and considered the submissions
of the learned counsel for the parties.

17. The points that would arise for our consideration are:

i. Whether the defacto complainant
proves that the impugned judgment
passed by the Sessions Court is
arbitrary, erroneous and without
appreciation of evidence?

ii. What order?

Reg. Point No.(i):


18. The prosecution, in order to prove its case, examined
the witnesses. The complainant-Savitha is examined
as PW.1. She has reiterated the complaint averments
in the examination-in-chief and copy of the complaint

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


was marked as Ex.P1 and her signature is marked as
Ex.P1(a). She has identified M.Os.29 and 30. She
deposed that, on 06.03.2012, she was called to the
District Jail, Bidar and she was asked to identify
accused No.1, who made to stand in the row
consisting of 10 to 15 members whom she has
identified. She has identified all the accused including
accused No.1 who committed the robbery in her
house and they are accused Nos.1 to 4 before the
Court. She has identified M.Os.1 to 33.

19. During the course of cross-examination, it is elicited
that her husband and father of accused No.1 are the
real brothers and her father-in-law had land to the
extent of 40 acres. It is elicited that her husband and
father of accused No.1 were separated from the joint
family and on such separation, father of accused
No.1 had constructed two residential houses. She
has also admitted that, in the family partition, old
house was allotted to the share of her husband. She

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


and her husband were residing in the said house. It
is also elicited that her family and family members of
the accused were having the visit terms. It is elicited
that she fell unconscious at about 01:30 a.m., and
on the next day morning at about 09:00 a.m., she
gained consciousness. When she gained
consciousness, she saw Ashok, Ramayya, Siddanna
and Subhash and at that time, the police were not
there in the hospital. A question was put to her as to
whether she has intimated about the incident to the
above said persons. She replied stating that the
above said persons were informed by herself
immediately after the incident. Immediately, after
gaining the consciousness, the police came to the
hospital. She has not disclosed the acts of accused
No.1 in committing the murder of her husband and
also causing hurt to PW.1 in Ex.P1.

20. She has further admitted that in Ex.P1, she has
stated that 7 to 8 persons came and assaulted her

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


and her husband and she has not disclosed the
names and address of the persons who assaulted
them. When she was on the roof of the house, she
did not raise voice on account of fear of her death.
She took treatment for about one month in the
Government Hospital. While she was taking
treatment in the Government Hospital, Bidar, the
police came there and enquired regarding the
incident. It is also elicited that when she was in the
hospital, she was not called by the police to the jail
for identifying the accused. She has admitted that
she has not kept the list of the ornaments that had
kept in the almirha of her house. She has deposed
that she can identify her neighbours. She has
deposed that her deceased husband Malikarjunayya
was accused in one of the murder cases. It is
suggested to PW.1 that the accused are no way
concerned with the case and they were unnecessarily
implicated. The said suggestion was denied by PW1.

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



21. Channappa S/o Malshetty Zhalapure was examined
as PW2 and he is said to be a panch witness to the
spot panchanama marked as Ex.P2 and his signature
is marked as Ex.P2(a). He has deposed that the
police have seized the piece of chappal, chewing
gum, hand gloves, Rs.50, M.O.4-tooth, M.O.3-broken
bangle piece, M.O.1-karimani sara, M.O.2-golden
tali, M.O.5-3 golden gundus, M.O.6-2 red manis,
M.O.7-one ear bud and M.O.8-cycle motor
accelerator wire and drawn the panchanama and the
said MOs are marked as M.Os.1 to 8 and he has
identified the said articles. He has also identified the
piece of chappal which is marked as Ex.P34, blood
stained hand gloves marked as M.O.35, chewing gum
marked as M.O.36 and torn hand glove marked as
M.O.37. The police have drawn the inquest
panchanama on the dead body of Mallikarjun
Swamy. The said inquest panchanama is marked as
Ex.P3 and his signature is marked as Ex.P3(a).

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



22. During the course of cross-examination, he has
deposed that, on that day sons and daughters of the
deceased were not available in the house. In
between his house and the complainant’s house,
there are 4 to 5 houses. On the next day morning,
he had not been to the said house on collecting the
information. It is admitted that CW.9 is the sister’s
son of deceased-Mallikarjunayya. It is elicited that he
has not told the police regarding seeing of the
articles. He has put his signature in the police
station.

23. Channappa S/o Sharnappa Yernali was examined as
PW.3 who is a witness to Ex.P4-cloth seizure
panchanama and his signature is marked as
Ex.P4(a). During the course of cross-examination,
he has admitted that that he does not the contents
of Ex.P4 and he has affixed his signature at the
instance of the police.

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



24. Vaijinath who is said to be another panch witness to
Ex.P4 was examined as PW.4. He has deposed that
about one and half years back, one day, at about
03:00 p.m., he was called to the Government
Hospital, Hedgapura and at his presence, cloths were
seized under the mahazar as per Ex.P4 and he has
affixed his signature on Ex.P4 and his signature is
marked as Ex.P4(b). He has identified the clothes
and waste thread and they are marked as M.Os.38 to
43.

25. During the course of cross-examination, he has
deposed that he has not dictated the police for
preparing Ex.P4 and he has denied that he has
affixed his signature on Ex.P4 at the instance of the
police.

26. Omkar Swamy was examined as PW.5. He is the son
of PW.1. He has deposed that he is a permanent
resident of Hedgapura and PW.1 is his mother and

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


deceased-Mallikarjun Swamy is his father. CW.6 is
his elder brother. He knows CWs.8 and 9. CWs.10
and 11 are his sisters. He knows CWs.13 to CW.18.
He has deposed that PW.1 and his father Mallikarjun
Swamy were residing at Hedgapura. On 14.01.2012
at about 02:00 a.m., CW.9 called him to his mobile
phone and informed that his father had been
murdered in his house besides PW.1 had sustained
injuries and dacoits have committed dacoity. On
early morning of 14.01.2012, himself, CWs.10 and
11 came to the Government Hospital, Bidar and
found injuries on the face, chest and other parts of
PW.1 and she was in a serious condition. He talked
with PW.1, who narrated the said incident and she
has told that four persons committed dacoity and
caused injuries to her and killed his father. He has
also deposed that when he returned to his house, he
noticed the dead body of his father on the roof of the
house. He also noticed various stab injuries on the

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


dead body of his father and he observed two golden
rings in the finger on the body of his father. He has
deposed that murder was committed intentionally
and not for the gain. He has deposed that there was
an enmity between accused No.1 and his father.

27. During the course of cross-examination, it is elicited
that there was no dispute between his family and
family of accused No.1 regarding allotment of the
lands to their share. There are no civil and criminal
cases pending between the family of accused and
family of the deceased. It is also admitted that CW.9
is having house within the main door of their house
and he has deposed that in between his house and
house of accused No.1, there are 10 to 15 houses. It
is elicited that he has not enquired PW.1 regarding
who has shifted her to the Government Hospital,
Bidar and he remained in the hospital till 09:15 a.m.
He admits that he has not observed the police in the
hospital while he reached the Government Hospital,

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


Bidar. Again the witness has stated that 2 or 3 police
were in the hospital and he has not seen whether the
police enquired with his mother i.e., PW.1. He admits
that his mother did not reveal the names of 4 or 5
persons and the Police has recorded his statement in
the village.

28. Sangappa S/o Chanbasappa was examined as PW.6.
He has deposed that he saw PW.1 sitting in front of
her house and showing her hand to the roof of her
house. He went on the roof of the house and noticed
the dead body of Mallikarjun Swamy and he has also
noticed injuries on PW.1. He came down and he
awakened CW.9 and went to the roof of the house.
Then CW.15 sent the phone message to the police
regarding the incident. He has deposed that PW.1
has not told anything. He has deposed that PW.1 told
somebody murdered her husband and assaulted her
while committing the dacoity of valuables from the
house.

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



29. During the cross-examination, he has deposed that
PW.1 was not in a position to talk and he had no
conversation with PW.1.

30. Ramayya Swamy was examined as PW.7. He has
deposed on par with PW.6. During the course of
cross-examination, it is elicited that if there was a
noise in the house of PW.1, it could be heard from
his house. Further, he deposed that PW.1 has not
told the names of the person who assaulted her and
her husband.

31. Shivaling was examined as PW.8. He has also
deposed on par with PW.6 and PW.7. During the
course cross-examination, he has admitted that PW.1
did not disclose the names of the persons who had
assaulted her.

32. Sangappa S/o Vaijinath was examined as PW.9 and
he is a witness to panchanamas at Exs.P5 to P8 and
his signature was marked as Exs.P5(a) to P8(a). In

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


the examination-in-chief, he has deposed that no
articles were seized in his presence at the instance of
the accused and he does not know the contents of
Exs.P5 to P8. This witness was treated as hostile
witness. Even when the learned Public Prosecutor
has cross-examined PW.9, he denied all the
suggestions made by the learned Public Prosecutor.

33. Manohar was examined as PW.10 and he is also a
witness to Exs.P5 to P8 and his signatures are
marked as Exs.P5(b) to P8(b). Even this witness
turned hostile. Even during the course of cross-
examination by the learned Public Prosecutor, he has
denied all the suggestions made by the Public
Prosecutor.

34. Mallikarjun who is the cousin brother of accused No.1
was examined as PW.11. Even this witness has
turned hostile.

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



35. Mohd. Hazi who is a vegetable vendor was examined
as PW.12. He has deposed that he knows accused
No.1 who is from his village and he knows the
deceased. Accused No.1 never met him. This witness
was treated as hostile. His statement was recorded
by the police under Section 161 of Cr.P.C., which was
marked as Ex.P10.

36. Umakanth was examined as PW.13. He has deposed
that from 4½ years, he was working as a Police
Constable at Thana Kushnoor Police Station. On
14.01.2012 at about 09:30 a.m. while he was
working as a Police Constable at Kushnoor Police
Station, CW.39 handed over FIR to him to submit it
to the JMFC and he carried the FIR at about 03:30
p.m. Initially, he went to Aurad but he did not find
the Magistrate, as he was on leave on that day,
therefore, he took the FIR to Bidar and handed over
the same to the JMFC, Bidar. He has deposed that for
that reason and non-availability of the bus, delay

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


was caused and FIR was confronted to him the said
FIR was marked as Ex. P11.

37. Shivkumar was examined as PW.14. He has deposed
that from August-2009 to January-2013 he had been
working as a Tahsildar, Aurad. On 14.02.2012, he
received a requisition from the CPI, Kamalnagar for
conducting identification parade. On 17.02.2012, he
sent a letter to CPI, Kamalnagar fixing the period of
identification parade on 06.03.2012. Accordingly, on
06.03.2012 at about 12:50 p.m. he visited the
District Jail for conducting the identification parade
and he had commenced the identification parade at
about 12:50 p.m. which was concluded at about
02:20 p.m. He has taken accused No.1 and has
taken ten other persons of similar physique made
them to stand in a single row and called
PW.1/complainant and asked her to identify accused
No.1 who identified accused No.1.

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



38. He has taken accused No.2 and ten other persons of
similar physique and made them to stand in a single
row and called PW.1 and asked her to identify
accused No.2 who did not identify accused No.2.
Similarly the PW.1 did not identify accused Nos.3 and
4. Thereafter, PW.14 prepared the identification
parade report and the said identification parade
report is marked as Ex.P12 and his signature is
marked as Ex.P12(a). He has deposed that after 25
days after the receipt of requisition, he had
conducted an identification parade. Police did not
accompany him while conducting identification
parade. While he was in a District Jail, he noticed the
presence of PW.1 in the Jail. The Jailer was present
and he enquired accused Nos.1 to 4 regarding their
names. Perhaps in the presence of the Jailer. The
place where he had conducted the test identification
parade was the open space. He has not asked
accused Nos.1 to 4 to stand together in a single row.

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


PW.1 was not present, when he called each accused
Nos.1 to 4 to stand with the other ten accused of
similar physique. Firstly, he arranged the row, then
PW.1 was called to whom the said persons were
shown. It is also elicited that he has not made any
efforts to cover the face of the accused with the help
of mask. PW.1 identified accused No.1 and he did not
enquire her regarding his name and address. He has
deposed that he has availed the permission of the
Jailer for conducting the identification parade and he
had availed the certificate from the jailer. He has not
produced the certificate obtained from the jailer for
conducting an identification parade.

39. Shivaraj Patil was examined as PW.15. He deposed
that as per the request of CPI, Kamalanagar, he has
issued a demand register extract of house of PW.1
and the said extract is marked as Ex.P13 and his
signature is marked as Ex.P13(a).

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



40. Rajkumar was examined as PW.16. He was working
as incharge of village Accountant of Hedgapur and as
per the request of CPI, Kamalnagar, he has issued a
genealogical tree of the deceased of Revanayya
Swamy which is marked as Ex.P14 and his signature
is marked as Ex.P14(a).

41. Dr.Mallikarjun was examined as PW.17. He was
working as a visiting consultant at Gurunanak
Hospital, Bidar. On 15.01.2012, PW.1/complainant
was admitted in the said hospital with a history of
assault. He had provided treatment and she was
discharged on 08.02.2012. The discharge summary
is marked as Ex.P15. During his cross-examination,
he deposed that he did not know who had admitted
PW.1 to the hospital.

42. Nawabkhan was examined as PW.18. He is the Head
Constable, who was on duty on 02.02.2012 and he
has carried the articles to the FSL Gulbarga and on

- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


03.02.2012 himself and CW.31 carried hyoid bone to
BRIMS, Hospital Bidar. During his cross-examination,
he has deposed that the box containing articles was
prepared by the SHO before his reaching to the
police station and he admits that he did not ascertain
the contents in the box since the box was packed.

43. Chandrakant, Junior Engineer at Santapur Sub-
Division was examined as PW.19. He has prepared
the spot sketch and the spot sketch is marked as
Ex.P16 and P17 and his signatures are marked as
Ex.P16(a) and P17(a). During the cross-examination,
he admits that the articles in the house were shown
to him and he had incorporated the existence and
non-existence of the articles in the sketch. In the
sketch, he has not incorporated the existence of
electrical pole besides the electric connection from
the said pole. He admits that he had not shown the
number of windows of the said house. He has denied
that he has not visited to the spot nor drawn the spot

- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


sketch marked as Exs.P16 and P17 and he has
denied that he has not prepared Exs.P16 and P17 in
the Police Station.

44. Dr. Deepak was examined as PW.20 who has issued
a report marked as Ex.P18 and his signature is
marked as Ex.P18(a) and the signature of CW.38 is
marked as Ex.P18(b).

45. Dr. Bukka Rajkumar was examined as PW.21. He
was a Medical Officer and he has deposed that since
3 years he has been working as a Medical Officer at
PHC Thana Kushnoor. On 14.01.2012 at about 01:10
p.m., while he was working as a Medical Officer, he
received a dead body of Mallayya @ Mallikarjun S/o
Revanayya aged about 55 years for postmortem
examination. Between 01:10 p.m., to 03:00 p.m., he
conducted the postmortem examination on the dead
body of deceased Mallikarjun. He has noticed the
following external injuries on the dead body:

- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



i. “Stab wound measuring ½ x ½cm on the
upper part of the chest in the middle line,
5cm below the inter clavicle space.

ii. Stab wound measuring 3cm x 2cm over
the right side of the chest, 7cm above
and medial to the right nipple.

iii. Stab wound measuring 3cm x 2cm over
the right side of the chest.

iv. Stab wound measuring 3cm x ½ cm over
the left side of the chest.

v. Stab wound measuring 3cm x 1cm 16 cm
below the left nipple over the chest.

vi. Stab wound measuring 4cm x 2cm, 18cm
below the right nipple over the chest.

vii. Stab wound measuring 3cm x ½ cm and
9cm lateral to the right nipple and in the
right exillery region.

viii. Stab wound measuring 3cm x ½ cm, and
8cm below lateral to the right nipple.

ix. Stab wound measuring 4cm x ½ cm,
over the lateral upper side of right thigh.

x. Lacerated injury over the left thumb
measuring 1cm x ½ cm.
nd

xi. Abrasion over the base of the 2 finger
of left hand measuring ½ x ½.

xii. Abrasion over below left eye measuring 2
x ½ cm.

xiii. Abrasion over the left side of the face
measuring 2cmx ½ cm.

- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



xiv. Ligature mark seen all around the neck
about 2cm breadth Nosel blood had
seen.”


46. During cross-examination of PW.21, he admits that
he has not received inquest report during the
examination of the dead body. He also admits that in
postmortem report, he did not state regarding the
period of death. All injuries found on the dead body
would be caused by the knives as per M.Os.31 to 33.

47. Manohar was examined as PW.22 who is a retired
ASI. He has deposed that from 2009 to 2013, he
worked as ASI at Kushnoor Police Station. On
14.01.2012 at about 2:10 a.m. while he was working
as an ASI at Kushnoor Police Station, he has received
information over the phone that Mallayya Swamy
died in his house, perhaps his murder was committed
besides causing injuries to PW.1. On receiving such
information, he immediately rushed to the house of
PW.1 and noticed the dead body of Mallayya Swamy

- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


in the said house. PW.1 was not in a position to talk
and she was taken to hospital at Santhapur. Then
she was shifted to Government Hospital, Bidar. In
the hospital, she narrated the incident and he
reduced it into writing. Then he returned to the
police station and based on that Ex.P1 he registered
the case and prepared the FIR and sent the original
FIR to the JMFC. Copy of the FIR marked as Ex.P11
and then CW.10 took further investigation.

48. He admits that in Ex.P1, it is stated that some 7 to 8
unidentified persons killed the husband of PW.1 by
name Mallayya @ Mallikarjun. He also admits that in
Ex.P1 name of accused No.1 was not referred. He
also admits that Ex.P1 does not state that she has
seen accused No.1 on the roof of the house and it
has also not been revealed that accused No.1 had
killed Mallayya and he had put words to PW.1
regarding killing her. He admits that the act of
accused No.1 regarding taking of PW.1 to the roof of

- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


the house has not been incorporated. He also admits
that in Ex.P1, it has not been unfolded that accused
No.1 insisted PW.1 to hand over the key of Almirah
and in Ex.P1 it has not been referred that accused
No.1 put the wire around the neck of PW.1. He
admits that in Ex.P1, it has not been referred that
accused No.1 put PW.1 into fear of death, in the
event of her disclosing the incident to anybody. He
also admits that in Ex.P1, it has not been stated that
while PW.1 went inside the house, she noticed
spreading of articles in the house.

49. Vinod, Police Inspector was examined as PW.23. He
has deposed that he took up further investigation
from PW.22. On the same day, he made a visit to the
spot and he has drawn a spot panchanama marked
as Ex.P2 and he has seized M.O.34 and 35 and
collected the sample blood in the bottle. The bottle is
the same which shown to PW.23. He admits that the
said bottle is marked as M.O.44 and he has also

- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


seized MOs.1, 37, 2, 3, 4 and currency note in the
denomination of Rs.50/- MOs.5 and 6 and another
hand glove which is marked as M.O.45 and M.O.8. he
deposed that in the spot itself, he had drawn the
inquest panchanama now shown to him and the said
panchanama is marked as Ex.P3. The panchanama
was conducted on the dead body of Mallayya and
sent the dead body to the PHC Hedgapur for
conducting postmortem examination with a direction
that the dead body has to be returned to the
relatives after conducting such postmortem
examination and he has also conducted inquest
panchanama marked as Ex.P3 and recorded the
statement of CW.6, PW.5 to 7 and the clothes from
the dead body have been produced before him by
the Police Constable and he has seized them under
mahazar as per Ex.P4. The clothes are marked as
MOs.38 to 43. During the cross-examination, he

- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


admits that the case has been registered against the
unknown person.

50. P.Varadaraju was examined as PW.24. He was
working as CPI, Kamalanagar from 19.09.2009 to
06.09.2012. On 15.01.2012, while he had been
working as a CPI, Kamalanagar Police Station, he
took further investigation from PW.23. On the same
day, he visited the Hedgapur village and recorded
the statements of CWs.9 to 14 and 16 to 18 and
recorded further statement of PW.1 and CW.9 and he
has arrested accused No.1 who produced the golden
necklace as per MOs.9, golden gantina sara as per
M.O.10, golden rings as per MOs.11 to 13, 31 to 33
and he has seized the said material objects and
drawn the mahazar as per Ex.P5. He has also drawn
the mahazar as per Ex.P6 and the sound box is
marked as M.O.46. He opened the sound box and
produced the golden and silver ornaments as per
M.O.14 to 26, carry bag marked as M.O.47 and he

- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


has drawn a mahazar as per Ex.P6. He has also
produced the vanity bag which is marked as MOs.48,
27 and 28. He arrested accused Nos.3 and 4 while
accused Nos.1 and 2 shown him and the accused
have given their voluntary statements and he has
produced MOs.29 and 30 and he has seized the said
Material objects under panchanama marked as
Ex.P7. He has deposed that he requested the
Tahsildar, Aurad for conducting identification parade
of accused Nos.1 to 4 and he had collected the report
to that effect marked as Ex.P12; he has also
collected the documents from the officer of KEB
CW.27 regarding the availability of the electric
energy; he has also collected the injury certificate
marked as Ex.P28. He had collected Exs.P18, 19 to
21. Then he had filed a charge sheet on completion
of investigation report. The FSL report is marked as
Ex.P29 and PW.11 has given a statement as per
Ex.P9.

- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



51. During the cross-examination, it is elicited that PW.1
has stated about the participation of four persons,
she has not stated that she had no golden bangles
and after recording the statement of PW.1 was
available in the hospital. He recorded her statement
in the hospital. She was discharged on 08.02.2012.
He has not shown accused to PW.1. While she was
discharged from the hospital. He admits that two
months after the arrest, identification parade had
conducted and he admitted that there are no marks
on the MOs. He has denied that he has filed a false
chargesheet against accused.

52. Dr.Mohan Jadhav was examined as PW.25. He has
deposed that since 2007, he was working as a
Medical Officer at CHC Santhpur. On 14.01.2012 at
about 03:35 a.m. while he was working as a Medical
Officer, PW.1 was brought for treatment with a
history that she has been assaulted by unknown

- 40 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


persons while examining PW.1, he found the
following injuries:
“i) Abrasion measuring 2cm x 1cm over the
centre of upper of lip.
ii) Loss of upper central incisor tooth.
iii) Ligature mark on interior part of the neck,
which was semi circular way.
iv) Contusion measuring 5cm x 5cm over the
right side of the chest.
v) Abrasion measuring 4cm x 3cm over upper
back on right side.”


53. He has deposed that injury Nos.1, 3, 4 and 5 are
simple in nature. Injury Nos.2 and 6 are grievous in
nature. The injuries were within 6 hours to his
examination and he has issued the injury certificate
marked as Ex.P28 and his signature is marked as
Ex.P28(a). police sent M.O.4 to him and he has given
an opinion that it resembles to the tooth of PW.1.

- 41 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


the said opinion is marked as Ex.P30 and his
signature is marked as Ex.P30(a).

54. During cross-examination of PW.25, he has deposed
that the villagers brought PW.1 to PHC Santhpur for
her treatment. While PW.1 was taking treatment in
the hospital, police came there. She was in a
semiconscious state. The person who was attending
PW.1 furnished the history of assault. He admits that
contusion and abrasion found on PW.1 would have
been caused if she fell on the ground and he denied
that if the force is used on M.O.8 while pulling by
putting to the neck there was a possibility of deep
ligature mark but the ligature mark was not deep.
Police had brought M.O.4. He admits that he did not
notice any mark on M.O.4.

55. Appa Rao was examined as PW.26/CW.27 who is the
Assistant Executive, Technical Section in GESCOM,
who has issued letters marked as Ex.P26 regarding

- 42 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


availability of the electricity between 12:00 a.m. to
04:00 a.m. on 25.01.2012 at Hedgapur village and
his signature is marked as Ex.P26(a). Another letter
regarding availability of electricity between 10:00
p.m., to 06:00 a.m., on 14.01.2012 at Hedgapur
village marked as Ex.P27 and his signature marked
as Ex.P27(a). During cross-examination, it is elicited
that he has deposed that there are 4 or 5
transformers at the village, Hedgapur. He also
admits that he cannot say area-wise supply of
electricity that depends upon the working of a
particular transformer.

56. From the entire perusal of the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses, it is clear that the entire case
of the prosecution is based on the evidence of PW1.
From the perusal of the examination-in-chief of
PW.1, it is elicited that some unknown persons have
committed murder of her husband and also assaulted
her. During her cross-examination, she was unable

- 43 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


to identify persons who have committed murder of
her husband and who have assaulted her. During the
cross-examination, she has clearly admitted that
herself and family members of accused No.1 were
having the visiting terms. She also admitted that she
was unconscious and on the next day morning at
about 09:00 a.m. when she gained consciousness,
she has seen Ashok, Ramayya, Siddanna and
Subhash and she has narrated the incident to the
said persons.

57. From the perusal of evidence of Ashok, Ramayya,
Siddanna and Subhash, they have not deposed that
PW.1 has narrated the alleged incident to them and
further she has also admitted that in Ex.P1, she has
not disclosed the acts of accused No.1 in committing
the murder of her husband and also causing hurt to
her. She also admits that in Ex.P1, she has stated
that some 7 to 8 persons came and assaulted her
and her husband and also admits that she did not

- 44 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


disclose the names and address of the persons who
have assaulted. She has deposed that when she was
on the roof of the house she did not raise any voice
on account of fear of death. None of the witnesses
i.e. Ashok, Ramayya, Siddanna and Subhash have
stated that PW.1 has not disclosed on the account of
fear of her death. PW.1 deposed that dead body was
on the roof of the house and other witnesses have
stated that dead body was in the house. She has also
admitted that her husband deceased-Mallikarjun was
involved in a murder case. PW.2 a pancha witness to
Ex.P2 has not supported the case of the prosecution.
During his cross-examination, he has stated that on
the next day morning he had not been to the house
of PW.1 for collecting the information. PW.3 in his
cross-examination stated that he does not know the
contents of Ex.P4 and he has deposed that he had
affixed his signature at the instance of police.

- 45 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017



58. PW.4 stated to be a panch witness who is said to be
a witness to Ex.P4. He admits that he has not
dictated the police for preparing mahazar. Mahazar
will be prepared at the instance of panchas and he
admits that he does not know the contents of Ex.P4.
PW.5 the son of deceased is a hearsay witness to the
alleged incident. PWs.6, 7 and 8 though they have
stated that PW.1 was sitting in front of her house and
she was showing her hand to the roof of her house.
The said fact has not been stated by PW.1 in the
statement made under Section 161 of Cr.P.C., nor in
the evidence. Hence, the evidence of PWs.6 to 8
does not support the case of the prosecution. PWs.9
to 12 turned hostile. Other witnesses were the official
witnesses.

59. From the perusal of the records, it clearly discloses
that except the evidence of PW.1, none of the other
witnesses disclose the names of the persons who
have assaulted her and committed murder of her

- 46 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


husband in the complaint. While conducting the
identification parade, PW.1 did not identify accused
Nos.2 to 4. She has identified only accused No.1 and
PW.14 has clearly admitted in the cross-examination
that PW.1 was not present while he called each of
the accused Nos.1 to 4 to stand with the other 10
persons of similar physique and he has also admitted
that PW.1 identified accused No.1 and PW.14 did not
enquire her regarding his name and address. He has
not produced the certificate from the Jailer to show
that the Jailer has granted permission to conduct
identification parade.

60. From the perusal of the records, it clearly discloses
that the prosecution has failed to prove the guilt of
the accused beyond the reasonable doubt. The
Sessions Court considering the entire evidence on
record has rightly held that the prosecution has failed
to prove the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable
doubt and also failed to prove that the accused

- 47 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


committed the murder of deceased Mallikarjun
Swamy and also accused Nos.2 to 4 assaulted PW.1
with their hands and they attempted to commit a
murder. The prosecution failed to prove that the
accused committed a robbery by extorting the
valuables of PW.1 worth Rs.5,17,500/- and
voluntarily caused hurt and also failed to prove that
accused Nos.1 to 4 committed a robbery by extorting
Rs.5,17,500/- and ornaments while carrying them
caused grievous hurt to PW.1- Smt. Savitha and
committing the murder of her husband Mallayya.
Thus, the prosecution has failed to prove the guilt of
the accused beyond reasonable doubt.

61. The Sessions Court, after appreciating the entire
evidence has rightly passed the impugned judgment
and order of acquittal. We do not find any error in
the impugned judgment. Hence, we decline to
interfere with the impugned judgment. In view of

- 48 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12262-DB
CRL.A No. 200016 of 2017


CNR: KAHC030002702017


the above discussion, we answer Point No.(i) in the
Negative .
Reg. Point No.(ii):

62. Accordingly, I proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
The criminal appeal is dismissed .

Sd/-
(ASHOK S. KINAGI)
JUDGE


Sd/-
(SUBRAMANYA R)
JUDGE



NB,VNR
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 36/Ct:pk