Upendra Khare vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 538
NON-REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1937 OF 2013
UPERNDRA KHARE … APPELLANT
VERSUS
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH … RESPONDENT
J U D G M E N T
PRASANNA B. VARALE, J.
1. The present criminal appeal is directed against the final
judgment and order dated 21.06.2012 passed by the Division
Bench of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur in
Criminal Appeal No. 2330/2007. By the impugned judgment and
order High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the appellant and
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
RASHI GUPTA
Date: 2026.05.26
11:01:44 IST
Reason:
upheld the order of First Additional Sessions Judge, Satna
[hereinafter referred to as “Trial Court”] passed in Session Case
1

No. 405/2002 thereby convicting the accused-appellant under
Section 302 of Indian Penal Code, 18603 and sentencing him to
life imprisonment and pay a fine of Rs. 1,000/-, and in default of
payment of fine, to further undergo R.I. for 1 year.
BRIEF FACTS
2. The factual matrix of the case is that on 20.07.2002, around
6:05 Hours in the morning, information was received at PS City
Kotwali, Satna by one named Anupam Shukla [hereinafter
referred to as “informant”] that his cousin brother Rajesh
Shukla could not be reached out after he met him on 18.07.2002.
Upon visiting the house of Rajesh Shukla on the morning of
20.07.2002, the informant found the back door of the house open
and, on entering the premises, discovered Rajesh Shukla, his wife
Madhu Shukla, his son Prabhanshu Shukla and his sister Vinita
Shukla lying dead with injuries on their bodies [hereinafter
referred to as “deceased persons”] .
3. It was in this background that the First Information Report
Case No. 515/2002 was registered under Section 302 of Indian
Penal Code, 1860 [hereinafter referred to as “IPC” ]. On
lodgement of the FIR, the criminal machinery was set into motion
and the investigating agency proceeded to collect the evidence. By
2

conducting the usual formalities of investigation namely, visiting
the scene of offence, seizure of various articles found on the
scene of offence such as blood stained clothes, bedsheet and
empty phials of calmpose injections from the toilet seats was
made and these articles were sealed. The dead bodies were sent
for autopsy. The postmortem report received by the investigating
officer revealed the cause of death is excessive haemorrhage due
to injuries caused by the sharp object/weapon. Brothers and
sisters of deceased Rajesh Shukla found that the jewellery worn
by the deceased persons as well as jewellery kept in the almirah
was stolen. Accordingly, the offences under Sections 382 and 404
IPC were added. In the process of investigation, it was further
revealed that the accused Devendra Singh, neighbour of the
deceased Rajesh Shukla had an evil eye over deceased Vinita and
he used to tease Vinita. It was also revealed that accused
Devendra Singh used to be in the company of the accused
Upendra Khare (who is present Appellant) before this Court. In
the investigation, it was revealed that the accused persons
namely Devendra Singh, Upendra Khare, Gyanchand @ Chunni,
Neeraj Kumar, Babua @ Abhishek Singh, all together entered the
house of deceased Rajesh Shukla on 18.07.2007. The accused
3

persons were armed with country made pistol, cartridges and
gupti. Initially, the accused persons administered calmpose
injections to the deceased and caused their death by causing
injuries to them. The arrest of the accused persons was effected
by drawing arrest panchnama Ex P-55, 56, 57, 58, 59 and 60.
4. The investigating agency recovered certain articles from the
accused persons namely 315 calibre country made pistol, three
live cartridges, stolen jewelleries from the accused persons and to
be more precise, jewellery was recovered at the instance of the
accused Devendra Singh, empty phials of calmpose injection,
clothes worn, one cotton rope and used syringes were recovered
at the instance of the present appellant Upendra Khare.
5. The investigation concluded by filing charge sheet against
the accused persons, namely Devendra Singh, Neeraj Kumar
Verma, Gyanchand Yadav @ Chunni Yadav. They were charged
for commission of offences under Sections 302, 382, 404 of IPC
read with Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms Act. Accused
Omprakash Soni was charged for offence under Section 411 IPC
whereas accused Ramkaran Yadav was charged under Section 25
of the Arms Act. Accused Babua @ Abhishek Singh and Kunal
4

Singh were absconding and as such, no charge-sheet was filed
against these absconding accused.
6. The case namely, Sessions Case No. 405 of 2002 was
committed to the Sessions Court on 19.12.2002. The Trial Court
charged the present appellant for commission of offences
punishable under Sections 302, 382, 404 read with Section 149
IPC.
7. On appreciation of evidence, the Trial Court vide its
judgment and order dated 15.10.2007 convicted the appellant
under Section 302 IPC on four counts as there were four
deceased persons read with Section 149 IPC and sentenced him
to life imprisonment with fine of Rs.1000/- and in default to
further undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year. The Trial
Court, however, acquitted appellant under Sections 382 and 404
read with Section 149 IPC giving benefit of doubt.
8. Being aggrieved by the judgment and order of the Trial
Court, the accused (appellant) preferred an appeal before the
High Court. Division Bench of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh
vide its judgment and order dated 21.06.2012 dismissed the
appeals sustaining the conviction. Needless to state that the High
Court clarified that the sentence awarded to appellant on all four
5

counts shall run concurrently. Being aggrieved by the judgment
and order of the High Court, the appellant approaches this Court
by filing present appeal.
CONTENTIONS
9. Learned counsel for the appellant namely, Mr. Amit Singh
has made the following submissions:
9.1. Learned counsel for the appellant contended that the High
Court and the Trial Court erred in convicting the appellant based
on a chain of circumstantial evidence that was incomplete and
failed to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt. He further
contended that the conviction was sustained despite the lower
courts observing that the investigation was faulty.
9.2. Learned counsel for the appellant contended that no motive
is assignable to the appellant. He argued that the alleged motive
is attributed to accused Devendra Singh who was the neighbour
of deceased Rajesh Shukla and allegedly harboured feelings
towards deceased Vinita.
9.3. Learned counsel for the appellant further contended that no
recovery of either the stolen property or any weapon of offence is
alleged to have been made from the appellant which clearly
6

shows that the appellant had not shared any common object or
intention with the other co accused.
9.4. Learned counsel for the appellant argued that the only
incriminating material produced against the appellant is the
alleged recoveries made at the instance of the appellant. The
alleged recoveries were not legal and have not been proved before
the Trial Court due to the following discrepancies, namely, that
both the independent witnesses named in the property seizure
memo have turned hostile; that the alleged recovery is made after
2 months of the alleged commission of offence, which is highly
improbable and defies normal human conduct, as no offender
would preserve incriminating items in his residence for such a
duration; and that the alleged recovery is procured through force,
as the record shows that the leg of the co-accused was fractured
during police custody. On this point, learned counsel further
argued that the alleged recoveries are not admissible under
section 27 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872. He contended that
Section 27 provides that when any fact is deposed to and
discovered in consequence of information received from a person
accused of any offence, in the custody of a police officer, so much
of such information, whether it amounts to a confession or not,
7

as, relates distinctly to the fact thereby discovery may be proved.
Learned Counsel for the appellant relying on the judgment of this
Hon’ble Court in Prabhu v. State of U.P. in Criminal Appeal
No. 50 of 1962 dated 03.05.1962 submitted that the High
Court erred in upholding the conviction and sentence of the
appellant as the case of the prosecution relied on circumstantial
evidence and the chain of circumstances was incomplete as there
were missing links. Learned counsel also placed reliance on the
1
judgments of this Court in Boby v. State of Kerala and in
2
Ashish Batham v. State of Madhya Pradesh.
9.5. Learned counsel for the appellant contended that there was
no evidence to show that the alleged articles recovered at the
instance of the appellant were used in the commission of crime.
He further submitted that the High Court has convicted appellant
on wrong facts as firstly, High Court has found that calmpose voil
allegedly recovered from the appellant carry “diazepham”
(tranquilizer) whereas these findings are based on Ex P-42 FSL
Report which has only examined the voils recovered from the
crime scene and the voils recovered from appellant was never
sent for examination. Moreover, the voils recovered from crime
1 (2023) 15 SCC 760
2 2002 (7) SCC 317 .
8

scene did not test positive for diazepham. Secondly, blood-like
stains on the recovered clothes could not be ascertained to be of
human origin much less the ascertainment of blood group of
deceased to connect to the appellant. High Court had
categorically recorded that recovery of the blood stained clothes
cannot be taken against the appellant as the same was not put to
the appellant in his statement under section 313 Cr.P.C. Thirdly,
usage of the rope also finds no corroboration from the
prosecution story as neither of the post mortem report says that
the cause of death is strangulation nor any mark has been found
on the neck of any of the deceased.
9.6. It was further contended that the conviction under Section
302 read with Section 149 of the IPC is legally unsustainable
because the total number of persons convicted in the case was
less than five, thus failing to satisfy the legal requirement for an
“unlawful assembly”.
9.7. In the alternative, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant has submitted that the appellant has already
undergone a substantial period of incarceration and does not
have any criminal antecedents; it is, therefore, prayed that the
9

sentence imposed upon him be reduced to the period already
undergone.
10. Per Contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent, namely, Mr. Bhupenra Pratap Singh, D.A.G. has
contended that the prosecution successfully proved its case by
placing on record overwhelming circumstantial evidence and the
same has rightly found favour of acceptance with both the trial
court as well as the High Court. He argued that merely because
panch witness has turned hostile does not make alleged recovery
doubtful. To support this, learned counsel has relied upon the
full bench judgment of this Hon’ble court in Goverdhan & Anr.
3
v. State of Chhattisgarh wherein this Hon’ble Court has
observed that merely because the witnesses have turned hostile
does not prove that no seizure was affected as the IO had already
proved the seizure memos.
ANALYSIS
11. Heard Learned Counsel for the appellant as well as Ld.
Counsel for the respondent. We have also perused relevant
3 (2025) 3 SCC 378
10

documents on record and the judgments passed by the Courts
below.
12. Admittedly, the case of the prosecution rests on
circumstantial evidence. The learned Trial Court on appreciation
of evidence held the accused persons guilty. At the cost of
repetition, as stated above, we may state that it is the case of
the prosecution that the accused Devendra Singh was having an
evil eye over the deceased Vinita. The present appellant Upendra
Khare used to be in company of the accused Devendra.
Devendra and the present appellant along with other accused
persons armed with various weapons entered in the house of the
deceased Rajesh Shukla. Initially, by administering the
calmpose injection and subsequently by causing the injuries to
the accused committed murder of four members of the family.
13. Insofar as, the case of the prosecution that accused
Devendra was teasing Vinita on occasions and on certain
occasions also threw liquor bottles at the door of her house is
supported by ocular evidence i.e. the testimony of PW1 Kamta
Prasad Shukla and PW 18 Kumari Sangeeta Shukla. As per the
record, accused Devendra preferred an appeal against the
judgment and order of the High Court by filing Special leave
11

petition (Crl) No. 8364 of 2012. Record reveals that accused
Devendra Singh was on parole from August 2012, however he
has failed to appear before this Court and accordingly, his
appeal was dismissed vide order dated 13.07.2016 for non-
prosecution.
14. The other accused persons have not challenged the
judgment and order of the High Court as such we may consider
the case of the appellant who is before us.
15. As stated above, the very important material evidence
against present appellant is in the form of a glaring
circumstance namely, the recovery of articles. As per the
prosecution case, the incident took place between 18.07.2002
to 20.07.2002. The appellant was arrested on 21.09.2002 The
articles namely phial, the clothes worn by him and a rope was
recovered at the instance of the present appellant.
16. As stated above, it is the case of the prosecution that
the accused persons including the present appellant initially
administered calmpose injection to the deceased persons and
thereafter the weapons were used for commission of the
murder of the deceased persons. The perusal of the
postmortem report which is proved by the witness namely
12

medical officer Dr. B.L. Gupta/ P.W.17, would show that the
cause of death is shock due to external and internal injuries
on the vital parts and excessive blood loss has caused the
death of the deceased persons within 24 to 36 hours. Then it
refers to the traces of calmpose injection. Perusal of the
record further shows that Dr. B.G. Hinduja, Dr. H.K Pandey
and Dr. Rekha Tripathi conducted postmortem. The report
was prepared by the team of doctors which was duly signed by
them along with P.W. 17 Dr. B.L. Gupta who was working as
M.D. (Medicine) Assistant Surgeon/Clinical Associate at the
relevant time. P.W.17 Dr. B.L. Gupta in his testimony before
the Court stated that:
“8. [PW17] Dr. B.L. Gupta has stated that on
examining the dead bodies it was found that there
was stiffness on the upper part of the bodies. The
witness has not stated about the external examination
of the bodies. He has further stated that this was the
condition of the bodies of the deceased and on
external examination following things were found:
(i) Cut wound on right wrist 7 cm x 2.5 cm x bone deep
causing the cutting of all the veins of pulse, tender and
blood. The blood was present all around the wound.
(ii) Penetrative wound on the right side lower part of
chest 1.5 cm x 1 cm x bone deep
13

(iii) Penetrative wound below the second wound 1.5
cm x 1 cm x bone deep
(iv) Penetrative wound below A. P. Gasitic 1.5 cm x 1
cm x stomach deep
(v) Penetrative wound on A. P. Gasitic 1 x 3 x stomach
deep
(vi) Penetrative wound on A. P. Gasitic 2 x 1 x stomach
deep
(vii) Penetrative wound above Amlyc in vertical shape
1.5 x 1 x stomach deep
(viii) Penetrative wound above Amlyc 1.5 cm x 1 cm x
stomach deep. This injury was harzanal place.
(ix) Penetrative wound on right side of Amlyc of vertical
shape 2.5 x 1.5 x bone deep.
(x) Penetrative wound on right side of Amlyc. 1.5 x 1 x
stomach deep.
(xi) Penetrative herzanal wound on the right side of
Amlyc 1.5 cm x 1 cm x stomach deep.
(xii) Penetrative wound on the left side of Amlyc 1 cm x
1 cm x bone deep.
(xiii) Penetrative wound on lately lax region 1 cm x 1
cm.... (illegible) deep.
Further the witness has deposed that on internal
examination it was found that
(i)There were many Incised wounds on liver and
intestine
(ii) Blood was filled in the peritorium of the stomach
(iii)Stomach was empty
14

(iv) The hymen of vagina was torn but was appearing
as old. The slide was prepared of the discharge from
the vagina and was handed over to the constable after
sealing it for further examination.
(v) Stomach was empty wherein there was some green
liquid present which was like a mixture of Boyle and
Gasting.
(vi) Both the chamners of heart were empty
(vii) The list of the clothes worn by the decased: Khaki
pajama which was worn inside out, [2] brown t-shirt
which had blood stains, were sealed and given to the
constable. The Visra along with the dead body was
backed in three bottles and given to constable for
chemical examination.
9. Thereafter the witness has opined that according to
medical opinion that shock due to external and
internal injuries on the vital parts and excessive blood
loss has caused the death of the deceased persons
within 24 to 36 hours. In this respect the report Exb.
P-36 has been proved.”
17. The viscera report/Exhibit P-52 was forwarded for chemical
analysis which showed analytical reasons and the same reads
‘Diazepham is present in Article A, B, C, D, E, G, H and JK.
18. Scene of the offence panchnama show that the syringes
were found near the toilet seats. Though an attempt is made by
the learned counsel for the appellant to submit before this Court
15

that the recovery at the instance of the present appellant is not
proved because the panch witnesses to the recovery panchnama
turned hostile. We are unable to accept this submission of the
learned counsel for the simple reason that this Court had
consistently taken a view that merely on account of the panch
witnesses turning hostile cannot be a ground to discard this
important piece of evidence, if the recovery is proved through
the investigating officer. On the backdrop of this fact, perusal of
the record shows that the recovery at the instance of the present
appellant is proved through the testimony of the investigating
officer Arun Singh/PW 24. We may refer to the judgment of this
4
Court in Rameshbhai Mohanbhai Koli v. State of Gujarat ,
wherein this Court has reiterated the settled principle that
recovery is not vitiated merely because the panch witnesses
have turned hostile. The judgment read as follows:
“33. In Modan Singh v. State of Rajasthan [(1978) 4 SCC
435 : 1979 SCC (Cri) 56] it was observed (at SCC p. 438,
para 9) that where the evidence of the investigating officer
who recovered the material objects is convincing, the
evidence as to recovery need not be rejected on the ground
that seizure witnesses did not support the prosecution
version. Similar view was expressed in Mohd. Aslam v.
4 (2011) 11 SCC 111
16

State of Maharashtra [(2001) 9 SCC 362 : 2002 SCC (Cri)
1024] .
34. In Anter Singh v. State of Rajasthan [(2004) 10 SCC
657 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 597] , it was further held that: (SCC p.
661, para 10)
“10. … even if panch witnesses turn hostile, which happens
very often in criminal cases, the evidence of the person who
effected the recovery would not stand vitiated.”
35. This Court has held in a large number of cases that
merely because the panch witnesses have turned hostile is
no ground to reject the evidence if the same is based on the
testimony of the investigating officer alone. In the instant
case, it is not the case of defence that the testimony of the
investigating officer suffers from any infirmity or doubt.
(Vide Modan Singh case [(1978) 4 SCC 435 : 1979 SCC (Cri)
56] , Krishna Gopal case [(1988) 4 SCC 302 : 1988 SCC (Cri)
928] and Anter Singh case [(2004) 10 SCC 657 : 2005 SCC
(Cri) 597] .
36. In view of the above principles and in the light of the
discussion about the recovery as stated and concluded
earlier, those materials produced by the prosecution are
relevant, acceptable and rightly connected these
circumstances with the appellants.”
19. This position was further reiterated by this Court in
5
Mallikarjun v. State of Karnataka , observing as under:
“23........On behalf of the accused, the learned Senior
Counsel contended that the evidence of PW 17 PSI as to the
recovery of MO 1 dagger at the behest of Accused 1 is
5 (2019) 8 SCC 359
17

doubtful and when PWs 8 and 9 have turned hostile, no
weight could be attached to the alleged recovery of MO 1
dagger. There is no merit in the contention that merely
because the panch witnesses turned hostile, the recovery of
the weapon would stand vitiated. It is fairly well settled that
the evidence of the investigating officer can be relied upon to
prove the recovery even when the panch witnesses turned
hostile…..”
20. As the Trial Court acquitted the appellant of the charges
under Sections 382 and 404 IPC by assigning justifiable reasons
on appreciation of evidence as such it may not be necessary for
us to consider this aspect of the matter. It is true that the
investigation in the present matter is not up to the mark and it
was expected of the investigating agency to conduct the
investigation with more sensitivity as it was the case of four
persons losing their lives. But merely the fact that the
investigation was not up to the mark cannot be the reason for
this Court to discard the other material evidence brought by the
prosecution in support of its case, particularly, the evidence
against the present appellant in the form of recovery of the phial
of the injection at the instance of the present appellant supported
by the postmortem report duly proved by substantial evidence of
Dr. B.L. Gupta.
18

21. Accordingly, in our opinion, the judgment of the Trial Court
holding the appellant guilty and awarding the sentence as upheld
and maintained by the High Court is based on a just and proper
appreciation of evidence. We see no reason to show any
interference in both the judgments. Appeal thus being devoid of
merits deserves to be dismissed and the same is accordingly
dismissed.
........................................J.
[PANKAJ MITHAL]
.........................................J.
[PRASANNA B. VARALE]
NEW DELHI;
MAY 25, 2026
19