UNION OF INDIA vs M/S MD JAVED SAYEED

Court
Calcutta High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
COMMERCIAL DIVISION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Debangsu Basak
And
The Hon’ble Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta
AO-COM/31/2026
With
IA NO: CAN/2/2025
UNION OF INDIA
VS
M/S MD JAVED SAYEED
For the Appellant :Ms. Aparna Banerjee, Advocate
Mr. Sukanta Ghosh, Advocate
Mr. Rohan Chamria, Advocate
Heard on : 16.11. 2026
Judgement on: 16.11.2026
Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.
1. The instant appeal is directed against the order dated June 16, 2025
passed by the learned Commercial Court at Alipore in Misc. Arb Case
No. 43 of 2023, renumbered as Misc. Arbitration (Com) 06 of 2023
arising out of an application under Section 34 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act,1996 (in short ‘the said Act”), thereby and whereby
the Award dated September 20, 2021 declared and published by the

2

sole Arbitrator has been affirmed in favour of the
claimant/respondent.
2. The back ground facts leading to filing of this appeal are that the
authorities of the South Eastern Railway, Kharagpur Workshop,
Kharagpur entered into a contract with the respondent herein vide
contract agreement no. 15/WSP/KGP/08-09 dated January 8, 2009, to
execute the replacement of roof sheets and north light glazing in
different shops at the main workshop and wagon shop under the
jurisdiction of ADEN/WSP/KGP.
3. Initially, the contract agreement was valued at Rs. 91,96,538/-.
Subsequently, due to the inclusion of further non-scheduled items, the
Railways raised the contract value to Rs. 1,36,55,978/- only. The
final value of the work executed was Rs. 1,43,79,212/-. Admittedly,
the work was completed on July 30, 2009. The respondent raised the
final bill, and subsequently, the appellant paid the entire amount after
verification and without any demur.
4. After completion of work and expiry of the defect liability period,
following due process, issuance of no-objection certificate and release
of performance Guarantee on 24.02.2010 and Security Deposit on
17.04.2010. The contract stood closed with no dues pending.
5. The Vigilance Department of the Railway inspected the concerned
work file and issued a letter dated May 11, 2010 indicating therein

3

that the rates approved by the Railway for the concerned two non-
scheduled items were very high, and the Railway paid an excess
amount of Rs.24,62,313/- to the respondent because of the high rate.
The Railway Vigilance Department advised the Railway Authority to
recover the said amount from the respondent.
6. The vigilance Department issued a letter on July 18, 2016 advising the
Railway authority to recover the said excess amount of Rs.24,62,313
from the respondent and to report compliance. The appellant
communicated the vigilance recovery advice to the respondent vide
letter dated 31.08.2016, requesting to deposit the over payment.
7. The respondent objected to the same and contended that the same is
illegal and made several representations, but no effect; rather, the
Railway authority recovered a sum of Rs. 2,59,101/- from a running
account bill payable to the respondent under another live contract
agreement No.27/HQ/KGP/16-17 and further withheld Security
Deposit and Performance Guarantee amounting to Rs. 34,40,502/-
under the said contract for recovery of the balance amount.
8. The respondent invoked the Arbitration clause following demand
notice and reminder thereto, resulting in appointment of sole
Arbitrator for resolving the disputes between the parties vide
authority. During arbitration proceeding, evidence was led by the
parties. Considering the contentions and documents brought before

4

the Arbitral tribunal, the Arbitrator published an Award directing
therein to refund Rs. 2,59,101/- and release Rs. 34,40, 502/- in
favour of the Respondent, holding that the recovery is unsustainable
in law after closure of contract and demanding after expiry of seven
years and further directed payment within 60 days; in default, an
interest will be charged @ 7% per annum.
9. Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the award passed by the
Arbitrator dated September 20, 2021, the appellant filed an
application under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 challenging the award, contending therein that the award suffers
from patent illegality, perversity and contrary to the public and
fundamental policy of India and erroneous interpretation of GCC
Clauses 52 and 52A.
10. The learned Commercial Court, after examining the materials on
record, did not find any valid grounds specified in Section 34 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and finally affirmed the award
passed by the learned Arbitrator as there was no infirmity or
perversity on the face of the award passed by the Arbitrator.
11. It was further observed that the Arbitrator rightly held that the claim
for recovery of Rs. 24,62,313/-, made by the Railway/appellant by its
letter dated 31st August, 2016, was without the consent of the
contractor/respondent and in respect of a contract which had ceased

5

to exist about seven years earlier and such claim was barred by
limitation, having been raised about seven years after the contract
came to an end.
12. Learned Counsel on behalf of the appellant submits that as the
Arbitral Tribunal did not consider the evidence, both oral and
documentary, presented by the Railway authorities and decided
against the appellant. The appellant further argues that the Arbitral
Tribunal ignored evidence of overpayment, rendering the award
patently illegal and contrary to public policy. It was further submitted
that neither the Tribunal considered the interpretation of GCC Clauses
52 and 52A of the General Conditions of Contract, nor did the
commercial court duly follow the provisions of section 34 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 while affirming the Award. The
commercial court failed to examine the points raised by the appellant;
as such, the same is liable to be set aside.
13. Having heard the submissions and argument of the learned counsel

for the appellant and having gone through the Materials made
available on record, this court of the view that the scope of
interference under Section 37 is narrower. The court cannot travel
beyond the restrictions laid down under section 34 of the said Act. The
court does not sit in appeal over the Award or decision of the Trial
court under section 34 of the Said Act like Civil Appellate jurisdiction,

6

and cannot re- appreciate evidence, and cannot substitute its own
judgment.
14. The contention that the evidence was not considered is, in substance,
an invitation to re-appreciate it. Both parties led oral and
documentary evidence before the Arbitrator, who, as the final
adjudicator of facts, considered the material and rejected the
Railways’ claim. The Commercial Court, on examination of the record,
found no ground for interference under Section 34 of the said Act. A
plausible view taken by the Arbitrator, affirmed by the Commercial
Court, does not warrant interference.
15. On merits, the work was completed on July 30, 2009, and the
Railways paid the final bill in full after the work had been verified. The
rates for the non-scheduled items were fixed by the Railways, and the
respondent in accordance with the terms of the agreement, and the
contract value was revised accordingly. The Vigilance Department’s
later view, in its letter of May 11, 2010, that the rates were high was
a unilateral, after-the-fact opinion. It cannot reopen a transaction
concluded by mutual agreement after bilateral deliberation, extensive
and exhaustive, with the clear intention of settling the matter finally.
16. The Arbitrator also found that the demand, made about seven years
after the contract had ceased to exist and without the contractor’s
consent, was barred by limitation. The Commercial Court concurred.

7

The appellant has shown no ground at all to set aside the award. This
Court concurs with the view taken by the Arbitrator and the
Commercial Court with regard to disputes involved between the
parties. There is limited scope under Section 37 to disturb these
concurrent findings.
17. Therefore, the appeal being AO-COM/31/2026 along with stay
application being IA NO: CAN/2/2025 are dismissed.
18. Connected application, if any, is also thus disposed of.
19. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
20. Urgent certified copy of this order, if applied for be supplied to the
parties upon usual undertakings.
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)
21. I agree
(Debangsu Basak, J.)

Dd
DEBABRATA
DAS
Digitally signed by DEBABRATA
DAS
Date: 2026.11.17 16:08:40
+05'30'