Krish vs State Of Haryana And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
315-2026 (O&M)
-1-
CWP-313
IN
THE HIGH COURT OF PUN
NJAB AND HARYANA AT
GARH
CHANDIG
CW
205+207
Reserved
on
WP-31315-2026 (O&M)
Whether only
the operative
part of the
judgment is
pronounced
d Pronounced Uploaded
on on
Whether t
full judgme
is
pronounced
the
ent
d
12.11.202
26 18.11.2026 18.11.2026
No Yes
...PETITIONER
KRISH
VERSUS
OF HARYANA & ORS.
STATE O
...RESPONDENTS
CORAM
M: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S
SUVIR SEHGAL
RAJESH GAUR
R
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE
Present:
Mr. Suresh Kumar Kaushik,
for the petitioner.
Mr. Varun Gupta, DAG, Har
for respondent No.1.
Mr. K.K. Gupta, Advocate
for respondents No.2 to 4.
Ms. Shreyansi Verma, Centra
for respondent No.5.
Mr. Himanshu Malik, Advoc
for proposed respondent No.6
Mr. Dharmender Singh Rawa
for proposed respondents No
Advocate
ryana,
al Govt. Counsel,
cate
6.
at, Advocate
o.6 and 7.
*
SHEETAL
2026.11.18 18:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
315-2026 (O&M)
-2-
CWP-313
SUVIR S
SEHGAL, J.
1.
Petitioner has approached th
his Court under Articles 226/227
7 of
the Cons
titution of India, for issuance
of a writ of certiorari quash
hing
corrigend
um dated 27.08.2026 (Annexur
re P-6), issued by Lala Lajpat
Rai
University
y of Veterinary and Animal
Sciences, Hisar (for short “
“the
University
y”), whereby eligibility conditio
ons prescribed for admission to
the
Bachelor
of Veterinary Science and Ani
imal Husbandry (B.V.Sc. & A.
.H.)
Programm
me for the academic session 20
026-27 have been altered after
the
commenc
cement of the admission proce
ess. A consequential direction
has
been soug
ght to consider petitioner's can
didature for admission against
the
seats earm
marked for wards of regular
employees of the University
in
accordanc
ce with the original prospectus (A
Annexure P-4).
2.
Petitioner's father is a regular
r employee of the University and
d is
working
as a Veterinary Livestock D
Development Assistant (VLD
DA).
Petitioner
r cleared Senior Secondary Ex
xamination in the year 2024 a
and
appeared
in NEET (UG)-2026 examinatio
on, securing 302 marks out of 7
720.
This exam
mination was conducted by Na
ational Testing Agency (NTA)
on
21.06.202
26. Petitioner is desirous of seek
king admission to B.V.Sc. & A
A.H.
Programm
me for academic session 2026-2
27. Prospectus (Annexure P-4) w
was
issued by
y the University on 21.08.2026
for the said programme and ot
ther
courses. A
As per the original schedule, last
date for submission of applicati
ons
was 06.0
09.2026, which was extended
to 09.09.2026. Eight seats w
were
earmarked
d for admission under the Non
n-Resident Indian (NRI) catego
ory.
Note unde
er the heading ‘Admission Capa
acity’ provided that in the event
t of
SHEETAL
2026.11.18 18:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
315-2026 (O&M)
-3-
CWP-313
non-availa
ability of eligible candidates
under the specified categor
ries,
including
NRI quota, two seats out of th
he vacant seats, would be filled
d by
wards of
f regular employees of the Un
niversity. Petitioner submitted
his
applicatio
on on 22.08.2026. Clause 5(ii) o
of original prospectus mandated
the
requireme
ent of appearing in NEET (U
UG)-2026 and clarified that N
NRI
candidate
s who had passed 10+2 exam
mination from India shall have
e to
qualify N
NEET (UG)-2026. Impugned
corrigendum dated 27.08.20
026
(Annexur
re P-6) was issued by the Univ
versity, whereby Clause 5(ii) w
was
substitute
d to provide that admission aga
ainst NRI seats would be made
on
the basis
of merit in the 10+2 examin
nation without pre-requirement
t of
appearing
g in NEET (UG)-2026, and
earlier stipulation was delet
ted.
Apprehen
nding that this modification wou
uld adversely affect his opportun
nity
of consid
deration against two seats mean
nt for wards of regular employe
ees,
petitioner
r has approached this Court chall
lenging the impugned corrigendu
um.
3.
Counsel for the petitioner
r has contended that eligibi
ility
conditions
s mentioned in the prospectus co
ould not have been altered after
the
admission
n process had commenced. H
e has argued that the impugn
ned
corrigend
um enlarges the pool of eligible
e NRI candidates and prejudicia
ally
affects th
e opportunity available to petiti
ioner under the original admiss
sion
scheme. H
He has placed reliance upon j
judicial precedents to support
his
contention
ns.
4.
Per contra, learned counsel
l representing the University
has
made ref
ference to Chapters 1 and 2
of the prospectus to assert t
that
competen
nt authority has reserved the
right to amend the admiss
sion
SHEETAL
2026.11.18 18:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
315-2026 (O&M)
-4-
CWP-313
conditions
s and the same has been done
e in exercise of the power ves
sted
thereunde
er. He has explained that dur
ring previous academic sessio
ons,
candidate
s seeking admission under NR
RI category were not required
d to
qualify N
NEET (UG) examination, and th
his requirement was introduced
for
the very
first time for the academic
session 2026-27. He states t
that
objections
s were received from several c
candidates to the effect that NE
EET
(UG)-202
26 had already been conducted p
prior to issuance of the prospec
ctus
and they c
could not appear in the examinat
tion because they were not aware
e of
this pre-c
ondition. According to the coun
nsel, the grievance was genuine a
and
after cons
sidering it, a decision was taken
to delete the condition by virtue
e of
the impu
ugned corrigendum, which wa
as subsequently approved by
the
Academic
c Council. An objection has tak
ken by him that petitioner is not
t an
NRI cand
didate and, therefore, does not
have locus standi to question
the
eligibility
y criteria applicable to NRI can
ndidates. He states that two se
eats
available
for the wards of regular emp
ployees were dependent upon
the
vacancies
s, if any, after consideration of el
ligible NRI candidates.
5.
Counsel representing NR
RI candidates, who have fi
iled
miscellan
eous applications for being i
impleaded as parties, which
are
pending,
have also been heard. They
y have submitted that impugn
ned
corrigend
um was issued much prior to
o the last date for submission
of
applicatio
ons, which is the crucial date
e to determine the eligibility
of
candidate
s. An argument has been raise
ed by them that admission proc
cess
commenc
ces on the last date for submiss
sion of applications, and alterat
tion
cannot be
e said to have been made mid-s
stream. They have also relied up
pon
SHEETAL
2026.11.18 18:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
315-2026 (O&M)
-5-
CWP-313
judicial pr
recedents to fortify their submiss
sions.
6.
We have considered the riva
al submissions made by counsel
for
the partie
es, examined the documents re
elied upon by them and given
n a
thoughtfu
ul consideration to their respectiv
ve contentions.
7.
It is a settled legal position th
hat eligibility criteria notified at
the
commenc
cement of admission process cann
not be altered midway. Even wh
here
a power
to modify the criteria exist
ts, its exercise must satisfy
the
constitutio
onal requirement of non-arbitr
rariness under Article 14 of
the
Constituti
ion of India. While examining
admission conditions for medi
ical
courses, a
a Full Bench of this Court in Am
mardeep Singh Sahota Vs. State
e of
Punjab,
1993 (2) PLR 212 , declare
ed that a prospectus cannot
be
subsequen
ntly changed by the Governme
ent to the detriment of one set
t of
candidate
s so as to benefit another set of
candidates. It was further held t
that
substitutio
on of an expanded category of N
NRIs cannot be made applicable
e to
applicatio
ons which had already been
submitted once the process
of
admission
n to the college had reached
an advanced stage. Similarly
y, a
Division
Bench of this Court in Devbir
r Singh Vs. State of Punjab a
and
others, La
aw Finder Doc. ID # 2643492 ,
against which SLP was dismis
ssed
on 24.09
.2024, observed that subseque
ent amendment to the prospec
ctus
amounted
d to substitution of a new clause
while defining the category of N
NRI
candidate
s, which resulted in fundamen
ntal changes. While relying up
pon
Tamil Na
adu Medical Officers Associatio
on and Others Vs. Union of In
ndia
and other
rs, (2021) 6 SCC 568 , it was hel
d that by making such amendme
ents
the under
rlying principles for admission
had been changed after admiss
sion
SHEETAL
2026.11.18 18:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
315-2026 (O&M)
-6-
CWP-313
process h
had commenced, which should n
not be permitted. More recently
, in
Mehtab S
Singh Vs. State of Punjab an
d others, Law Finder Doc. ID
D #
2986715 ,
this Bench came to the conclu
usion that respondents cannot m
ake
any mod
dification to the eligibility co
onditions notified in the origi
inal
prospectu
us that is likely to enlarge the sc
cope of the admission criteria. T
This
judgment
was tested before the Hon’b
ble Supreme Court and SLP w
was
dismissed
d on 23.10.2026.
8.
In light of the above legal p
osition, it is apposite to notice a
and
the impug
gned corrigendum, Annexure P-6
6, which is reproduced hereunder
r:-
“ Lala Lajpat Rai University of Veterina
ary and Animal Sciences (LUVAS), Hisar
(Established by Haryana Leg
gislature Act No. 7 of 2010)
Reg./A-1/2026/5928
Dated: 27/08/2026
“CORRIGEND
NDUM”
It is for the information of all th
programme under the NRI Category at
the academic year 2026-27 that the f
prospectus 2026-27:
he aspirants seeking admission in B.V.Sc. &
t COVS, LUVAS and affiliated private colleg
A.H.
ge in
n the
following amendments have been made in
Prospectus of B.V.Sc. & A
A.H. programme 2026-27
Chapter-III
Existing
Amended
Page No. 18:-
5. Admission against NRI Seats:
(ii) The admission will be made on merit o
examination without requirement of appea
the NEET (UG)-2026. However, the candida
has passed his/her 10+2 examination from
shall have to qualify NEET (UG)-2026.
Page No. 18:-
5. Admission against NRI Seats:
(ii) The admission will be made o
of 10+2 examination without requ
of appearing in the NEET (UG)-20
of 10+2
aring in
on merit
uirement
ate who
m India
026.
Sd/-
Registrar”
e above reproduced impugn
9.
A plain reading of the
ned
corrigend
um shows that it deletes a
substantive eligibility condit
tion
expressly
incorporated in Clause 5(ii)
of Chapter III of the prospect
tus.
Under the
e original clause, a candidate w
who had passed 10+2 examinat
SHEETAL
tion
2026.11.18 18:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
315-2026 (O&M)
-7-
CWP-313
from Indi
a was mandatorily required to qu
ualify NEET (UG)-2026 to beco
ome
eligible f
for admission under NRI categ
gory. By virtue of the impugn
ned
corrigend
um, such qualification ceases
s to be necessary. As a res
sult,
candidate
s who were initially ineligible u
under the original prospectus h
ave
been brou
ught within the zone of consid
deration. This alteration materia
ally
changes
the eligibility conditions a
and cannot be termed as
an
inconsequ
uential procedural modification.
It enlarges the pool of candida
ates
desirous o
of seeking admission under the
e NRI quota, which would direc
ctly
mar the pr
rospects of candidates, who are c
claiming admission against lefto
over
NRI seats
s. This would directly affect t
the potentiality of petitioner as
s it
reduces th
he possibility of vacancies arisi
ng under NRI quota. Moreover
r, in
Devbir Si
Singh's case (supra) , a Divisio
on Bench of this Court rejected
d a
similar co
ontention by holding that althou
ugh a candidate has no vested ri
ight
to admiss
sion, he possesses a legitimate e
expectation of fair consideration
n in
accordanc
ce with the original admission
n policy. The objection regard
ding
petitioner
r's locus standi is, therefore, rejec
cted.
10.
In the present case, prospec
ctus (Annexure P-4) was issued
on
21.08.202
26 and petitioner submitted his
s application on the next day,
i.e.
22.08.202
26. Impugned corrigendum (
(Annexure P-6) was issued
on
27.08.202
26, when admission process
had already commenced a
and
applicatio
ons were being received. No dou
ubt, corrigendum was issued bef
fore
the expiry
y of the extended last date for su
ubmission of applications, howev
ver,
the mere
e fact that applications were
e still being received, does
not
automatic
cally validate a substantive chang
ge in the eligibility criteria.
SHEETAL
2026.11.18 18:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
315-2026 (O&M)
-8-
CWP-313
11.
What is required to be exami
ined is whether the alteration is f
fair,
non-arbitr
rary and consistent with legi
itimate expectations arising fr
rom
notified c
conditions. University has exp
plained that representations w
were
received f
from prospective NRI candidates
s because requirement of qualify
ying
NEET (U
UG)-2026 was introduced for th
he first time and examination h
had
already b
een conducted in June, 2026. W
While the explanation given by
the
University
y, may be justified, the timing o
of its implementation is crucial. T
The
fact that
some candidates were dissatisfi
fied with a duly notified eligibi
ility
condition
does not by itself justify the
e withdrawal of that condition
n of
qualifying
g NEET (UG)-2026 after the
commencement of the admiss
sion
process. U
University was entitled to fram
me an appropriate admission pol
licy
before inv
viting applications and could als
so prescribe different conditions
for
subsequen
nt academic sessions, subject to
requisite approvals. However, t
this
does not
justify the amendment in the
e eligibility conditions during
an
ongoing
admission process. Merely
because some other veterin
nary
universitie
es or the respondent-University
y itself in the previous academ
mic
sessions d
did not insist upon NEET qualif
fication, does not establish that
the
notified a
admission condition for the c
current session should be alte
ered
without c
considering its effect upon c
candidates who had applied
for
admission
n relying on the originally notif
fied eligibility conditions and m
may
have fore
gone an opportunity to apply to
o other universities or courses. T
The
deletion o
of eligibility condition, which en
nlarges the pool of NRI candida
ates
and corres
spondingly affects the opportuni
ity of consideration available to
the
wards of
regular employees, cannot be
sustained merely on the basis
s of
SHEETAL
2026.11.18 18:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
315-2026 (O&M)
-9-
CWP-313
power to
o modify the eligibility criteri
ia vested in the University. T
The
amendme
ent has brought about a substa
antive alteration in the eligibi
ility
conditions
s by enlarging the pool of eligib
ble candidates, which has worked
d to
the detrim
ment of those who had acted u
upon the original conditions. T
The
judicial p
precedents mentioned in the pr
receding paragraphs are, therefo
ore,
squarely a
applicable to the facts of the pres
sent case.
12.
The judgment in Ankita Th
Thakur and Others Vs. Himac
chal
Pradesh
Staff Selection Commission a
and Others, (2024) 19 SCC 7
745 ,
relied up
on by learned counsel for the
e proposed respondents, does
not
advance t
their case. The Hon'ble Suprem
me Court examined the validity
y of
relaxation
n of essential eligibility conditi
ons prescribed under the statut
tory
recruitmen
nt rules and emphasized nece
essity of adhering to the notif
fied
eligibility
y conditions. It was held that
power of relaxation, even wh
here
available,
must be exercised consistently
with requirements of transparen
ncy,
adequate
publicity and equal opportunity
y. Such a power does not confer
r an
unrestricte
ed authority upon the Univer
rsity to alter essential eligibi
ility
conditions
s during an ongoing admission
n process. Similarly, reliance up
pon
Abhilashi
i University Vs. Union of India
a and others, Law Finder Doc I
Id #
2978479 ,
is misplaced, as the question inv
volved in the said case was entir
rely
different.
The Single Bench of the Himac
chal Pradesh High Court examin
ned
competen
nce of a statutory University
y to conduct its own entra
nce
examinati
ion for admission to B.V.Sc. & A
A.H. Programme in the light of
the
Minimum
m Standards of Veterinary Educ
cation Regulations, 2016, and h
held
that requi
irement of admission exclusively
y through NEET (UG) merit co
ould
SHEETAL
2026.11.18 18:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
315-2026 (O&M)
-10-
CWP-313
not be im
mposed contrary to the statutory
rules. The deletion or alteration
n of
an eligibi
ility condition during an ongoi
ing admission process was not
an
issue bef
fore the Himachal Pradesh Hi
gh Court. The said judgment
is,
therefore,
clearly distinguishable on fa
acts and is not applicable to
the
controver
rsy involved in the present case.
13.
As the impugned corrigendum
m substantially enlarges the poo
l of
qualified
candidates for admission under
the NRI quota, to the detriment
t of
candidate
s, who had submitted their a
applications on the basis of
the
originally
y notified conditions in the p
prospectus, impugned amendm
ment
cannot be
e sustained.
14.
For the foregoing reasons
s, writ petition is allowed a
and
impugned
d corrigendum dated 27.08.2026
(Annexure P-6) is hereby set asi
ide.
There sha
all be no order as to costs.
15.
Pending miscellaneous app
plication(s), if any, shall sta
and
disposed o
of.
(SUVIR SEHGAL)
JUDGE
RAJESH GAUR
( )
JUDGE
18.11.202
sheetal
26
Whether Speaking/reasoned Ye
Whether Reportable Ye
es/No
es/No
SHEETAL
2026.11.18 18:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document