SHANTAMMA AND ANR vs BASAVANTRAYA S/O SHIVAPPA GOUDA PATIL @ BIRADAR

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
TH
DATED THIS THE 11 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA R
WRIT PETITION NO.223821 OF 2020 (GM-CPC)
BETWEEN:

1. SHANTAMMA
W/O NANAGOUDA PATIL @ BIRADAR,
AGED: 64 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TUMBAGI VILLAGE, TQ: MUDDEBIHAL,
DIST: VIJAYAPURA.

2.


(i)
SHIVANAGOUDA S/O NANAGOUDA BIRADAR
DIED BY LRS;

SAVITA W/O LATE SHIVANAGOUDA BIRADAR,
AGE: 33 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O: TUMBAGI VILLAGE, TQ: TALIKOTE,
DIST: VIJAYAPURA

(iii) NANAGOUDA S/O LATE SHIVANAGOUDA BIRADAR,
AGE: 12 YEARS, MINOR U/G OF
PETITIONER NO.2(i),

(iii) PRABHUGOUDA S/O LATE SHIVANAGOUDA BIRADAR,
AGE: 9 YEARS, MINOR,
U/G OF PETITIONER NO.2(i),

(iv) RAVIGOUDA S/O LATE SHIVANAGOUDA BIRADAR,
AGE: 6 YEARS, MINOR,
U/G OF PETITIONER NO.2(i),
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. VINAYAK APTE, ADVOCATE)

Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
D UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



AND:

1. BASAVANTRAYA
S/O SHIVAPPA GOUDA PATIL @ BIRADAR,
SINCE DIED BY LRS;

a) SMT. NEELAMMA W/O LATE BASAVANTRAYA
BIRADAR PATIL
AGE: 52 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD,
R/O ARYA SHANKAR, TQ. NARAGUND,
NOW NIDGUDA, DIST. VIJAYAPURA-586213.

b) SANTOSH S/O BASAVANTRAYA BIRADAR PATIL
AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O ARYA SHANKAR TQ. NARAGUND,
NOW NIDGUDA, DIST. VIJAYAPURA-586213.

c) BASAMMA D/O LATE BASAVANTRAYA BIRADAR
PATIL,
AGE: 26 YEARS, OCC: PRIVATE SERVICE,
R/O ARYA SHANKAR TQ. NARAGUND,
NOW NIDGUDA, DIST. VIJAYAPURA-586213.

d) RAMANAGOUDA S/O LATE BASAVANTRAYA BIRADAR
PATIL,
AGE: 24 YEARS, OCC: STUDENT,
R/O ARYA SHANKAR TQ. NARAGUND,
NOW NIDGUDA DIST. VIJAYAPURA-586213.

…RESPONDENTS

(BY SMT. RATNA N. SHIVAYOGIMATH, ADVOCATE FOR R1 (A
TO D))

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO, CALL
FOR THE RECORDS AND TO, A) ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
QUASHING THE IMPUGNED COMPROMISE PETITION, ORDER
AND DECREE DATED 14.07.2018 AND 06.12.2018 AS PER
ANNEXURE B, C, AND D PASSED IN O.S.NO.240/2018 BY THE

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



LOK ADALAT HELD AT BASAVANA BAGEWADI ON THE FILE OF
CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC AT BASAVANA BAGEWADI, B) ISSUE
ANY OTHER ORDER OR DIRECTIONS AS THIS HON’BLE COURT
DEEMS FIT IN VIEW OF THE FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES BY
REMITTING THE MATTER TO THE TRIAL COURT TO DISPOSE OF
THE SAME IN ACCORDANCE WITH LAW, IN THE INTEREST OF
JUSTICE AND EQUITY.

THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
IN “B” GROUP, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS
UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA R

ORAL ORDER

This Writ Petition is filed seeking the following reliefs:

“a) Issue a writ of certiorari quashing the
impugned compromise petition, order and
decree dated 14.07.2018 & 06.12.2018 as per
Annexure B, C and D passed in O.S.
No.240/2018 by the Lok Adalat held at
Basavana Bagewadi on the file of Civil Judge
and JMFC at Basavana Bagewadi, in the interest
of justice and equity.

b) Issue any other order or directions as this
Hon'ble court deems fit in view of the facts and
circumstances by remitting the matter to the
trial court to dispose of the same in accordance
with law in the interest of justice and equity.”


2. The facts apropos are that the deceased
Basvantraya S/o Shivappagouda Patil @ Biradar filed
O.S.No.240/2018 on the file of the Civil Judge and JMFC,

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



Basavana Bagewadi for the relief of partition and separate
possession of the suit schedule properties by metes and
bounds. The said suit was filed before the Trial Court on
16.07.2018 as per Annexure-C . It is stated that a Compromise
Petition has been filed under Order 23 Rule 3 of CPC and the
said Compromise Petition was posted before the Lok Adalat for
orders.

3. The Lok Adalat passed orders decreeing the suit in
accordance with the Compromise Petition filed under Order 23
Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, alleged to have been
entered into between the parties. The Lok Adalat further
observed that the final decree is to be drawn up in accordance
with the Compromise Petition if the requisite stamp papers are
furnished. The recording of the compromise by the Lok Adalat,
referred to above, is impugned in the present Writ Petition.

4. Sri Vinayak Apte, learned counsel for the Petitioner,
submits that the Lok Adalat has no jurisdiction or authority to
record the compromise alleged to have been filed under Order
23 Rule 3 of the CPC. The learned counsel further submits that
the Lok Adalat is empowered to conciliate between the parties,

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



and the conciliation must be reduced to a joint memo;
thereafter, an award must be passed in terms of the joint
memo filed by the parties concerned. It is further submitted
that the Lok Adalat does not possess the powers of the Court to
record the compromise petition under Order 23 Rule 3 of the
CPC, and the decree cannot be drawn up in terms of the
compromise filed by the parties. It is also submitted that the
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Smt. Akkubai
Vs. Shri Venkatrao and others, reported in ILR 2014 KAR
2051, has held that, under the scheme of the Legal Services
Authorities Act, 1987, the Lok Adalat cannot record the
compromise filed under Order 23 Rule 3 of the CPC.

5. The learned counsel would further submit that
another Co-ordinate Bench of this Court, in the case of Pooja
Vs Siddanna and Ors., reported in 2025 (4) KarLJ 492, has
held that the Lok Adalat is a Conciliatory Forum and that the
judicial officers presiding over the Lok Adalat act as conciliators
and do not possess the power of a judge to pass judicial orders.
That, apart from this, learned counsel would further submit that
no vakalat has been filed on behalf of the defendants before

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



the trial Court, and even the vakalat stated to have been filed
pertains to some other case, does not reflect the suit number,
and suffers from other infirmities. Under the above
circumstances, the learned counsel submits that the order
passed by the Lok Adalat is liable to be set aside.

6. Per contra , learned counsel for the respondents
would support the order passed by the Lok Adalat on the
ground that the parties have entered into a compromise, and
that the compromise has been recorded by the Lok Adalat,
which cannot be faulted.

7. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and
perused the records.

8. Admittedly, the parties alleged that they filed the
Compromise Petition under Order 23 Rule 3 of the CPC before
the Trial Court. The Compromise Petition, as alleged by the
parties, has been recorded in the order sheet maintained by the
Court, and no separate order sheet has been maintained by the
Lok-Adalat while considering the Compromise Petition filed by
the respective parties. Instead of passing an award, the Lok-

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



Adalat passed an order recording the compromise petition,
decreeing the suit in terms of the compromise, and directing
that a final decree be drawn in terms of the compromise
petition alleged to have been filed by the parties. In the opinion
of this Court, the Lok-Adalat does not possess such power, and
it is not traceable to any provision under the Legal Services
Authorities Act, 1987.

9. It is imperative to refer to the decision of the Co-
ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Smt. Akkubai
(supra). The relevant paragraphs are set out below.
“10. The allegations against the Counsel in his
absence cannot be gone into in this proceedings.
The proper forum where it can be gone into is the
Bar Council. But what is explicit from the material
on record is, the Advocate M.C. Bhandari was
representing Annasaheb, Gouravva and Akkubai in
the first suit filed by Indumati for partition in O.S.
No.200/98, where all the properties belonging to
the joint family were the subject matter of the suit.
During the pendency of the said proceedings, he
files a suit on behalf of Venkat Rao in O.S.
No.278/02 against Akkubai, Gouravva and Shanta,
the own sister of Venkata Rao. An application for
temporary injunction is also filed restraining
Akkubai from alienating the suit land and the
house. What is surprising is, on 13.12.2002, the
suit is registered by the Court. The Court
entertained the suit and took cognizance of the
presentation of the plaint. At that stage, R.S.
Ningolli, Advocate files vakalath for all the three
defendants-1 to 3. After vakalath is filed, the

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



Learned Presiding Judge says that the case is taken
before the Lok Adalat in the presence of Conciliator
Basavaraj S. Chegaraddi. This is what at any rate, I
am not able to understand. The plaint was
presented in the Court before the Judge. Before the
Judge, the vakalath was filed. Before the Judge, the
Learned Counsel was present. In the Court, there is
no place for the Conciliator. But the order-sheet
shows that the case, which was presented before
the Court is taken before the Lok Adalat in the
presence of the Conciliator. This statement is part
of the Order dated 13.12.2002, which finds a place
in the ordersheet in the Court. When this matter
was taken before the Lok Adalat, parties submitted
that they have settled the matter. They filed
compromise petition and admitted the compromise.
It is recited that Defendants-1 to 3 admits that they
have received 25,000-00 each outside the Court.
Therefore the suit was decreed in terms of the
compromise petition and a direction was issued to
draw final decree. All this finds a place in the order-
sheet maintained by the Court. Therefore there is
no separation of the proceedings between the
judicial proceedings and the Lok Adalat. This has
become a two-in-one proceedings.

11. I really wonder, whether the Learned Judge
who has entertained this matter was aware of the
elementary aspects of judicial functioning and the
Lok Adalat. A common order-sheet cannot be
maintained by the Court as well as the Lok Adalat.
A Court cannot be converted into a Lok Adalat. In
the order-sheet maintained by the Court, a portion
of the proceedings is referable to the Court
proceedings and another portion refers to the
proceedings of the Lok Adalat. The Conciliator has
no place inside the Court. The very object of
accepting this Lok Adalat as an alternative mode of
resolution of dispute is that, all matters do not need
adjudication. The matter which could be resolved
by persuasion, negotiation and understanding
should be taken out of adjudication process and
should be resolved by means of Lok Adalat
satisfactorily, so that the cases are disposed of

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



expeditiously and the Courts will be saving the time
of adjudicatory process, and they can utilize that
time which is saved, in adjudicating the cases. If on
the day the plaint is presented, the parties are also
present before the Court, they are ready with the
compromise petition and when they are filing an
application under Order 23 Rule 3 CPC, when they
are admitting the terms of the compromise and
execution of the terms and condition, then the
Court before which it is presented, is the competent
Court to record the compromise and dispose of the
suit in terms of the compromise. The question of
referring the said dispute to the Lok Adalat would
not arise. If it is referred, it is a farce. If this is
accepted and encouraged, both the judicial system
and this alternative dispute resolution mechanism
gets a bad name and would be subjected to
redicule in the eyes of public. All persons who are
indulging in this process would be doing great
injustice and dis-service to the judicial system.
They are not conscious of their action and its
repercussions and the image of the Judiciary, which
would create in the mind of the public. That is not
the object with which neither Legal Services
Authority Act of 1987 is passed by the Parliament
providing for the institution of Lok Adalat nor
Section 89 was introduced by the Parliament
amending CPC. The essence of these provisions is
neither understood by the Learned Judge nor by the
Learned Counsels who are appearing for the
parties.

12. It is time that the Legal Service Authority
should conduct workshops and seminars and other
mode of communications to educate these legal
literate persons like Judges, Lawyers and
Conciliators to understand the concept of Lok
Adalat and how the Courts have to function, what is
the duty of the Lawyers and what matters should
be resolved by this process.

13. In this background if we look at the facts of the
case, the daughter files a suit against her father,
sister and others for partition and separate

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



possession complaining of her father preferring one
daughter by executing registered Will. That
fortunate daughter, the father and second wife
engages a common Counsel. No written statement
is filed. During the pendency of the proceedings,
the Advocate who was representing defendants-1 to
3 in the said suit, files a suit against them on behalf
of son of Gouravva, for partition and separate
possession in respect of the property which is the
subject matter of the suit. Therefore there is
conflict of interest between Venkata Rao and
Akkubai in respect of the property. On the date the
suit is filed, the Advocate appears for the
defendants with the vakalath ready. If this is the
indication of the relationship between the parties,
the order-sheet discloses that along with the suit,
an application is filed for temporary injunction
restraining Annasaheb from alienating the property.
Then it is a farce. Immediately after the appearance
of the Advocate, the Learned Judge who received
vakalath transforms himself as the person presiding
over the Lok Adalat, secures the presence of the
Conciliator, acts on the submission of the parties,
receives the compromise petition, records
compromise and directs the office to pass final
decree in terms of the preliminary decree.
Accordingly the office has drawn the final decree.

14. xxxxx

15. If the object of introducing Lok Adalat as
alternative dispute resolution is to avoid the Courts
deciding the matters and ease the burden of the
Courts, if these things are allowed, it is just having
a counter effect. After decision in the Lok Adalat,
now we are seeing writ petitions are filed
challenging those awards. This is not the first case
this Court is deciding. This is not the first case
where Judges and Members of the Lok Adalat are
conducting themselves in this fashion. There is
something seriously wrong in the whole system,
which needs immediate corrective steps.

16. In the circumstances, without casting

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



aspersions on the Learned Judge or the Learned
Counsel who appeared for the parties, the way the
Learned Judge has conducted himself, both inside
the Court and as a Member of the Lok Adalat and
also the Conciliator before the Lok Adalat, it would
be just and appropriate to set-aside the award and
direct the parties to agitate their rights in the suit
and work out their remedy. This Court not only
cannot be a silent spectator of this illegalities, it
would be the bounden duty of this Court to
interfere with such illegal awards and set-aside the
same and restore the valuable rights of the
immovable properties to the parties, which is taken
away through the process of Lok Adalat. Hence, I
pass the following order:

Writ Petition is allowed.

The impugned award passed by the Lok
Adalath on 13.12.2002 in O.S.No.278/02 is hereby
set-aside. The suit is restored to its original file.

Send a copy of this order to:

(a) The Bar Council of Karnataka to look
into the role played by M.C. Bhandari and R.S.
Ningolli, Advocates of Jamkhandi, to enquire
whether their conduct in this proceedings is
consistent with the professional ethics which is up
held by the Bar Council of Karnataka. It also will
enable the Bar council to take appropriate steps to
educate the members of the Bar regarding their
conduct before Lok Adalath and to see that such
allegations and situation do not recur bringing down
the reputation of the profession.

(b) Patron-in-Chief, Karnataka State Legal
Services Authority, Hon’ble the Chief Justice, High
Court of Karnataka.

(c) Legal Services Authority for
appropriate remedial action.”

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020




10. Another Coordinate Bench of this Court, in the case
of Renuka Vs. Ramanand and another, reported in 2022
SCC Online Kar 2008, referring to the aforementioned
decision, has specifically observed that several such cases are
coming before the Court, and accordingly general directions
have been issued at para No.20, which are extracted as under:
“20. This Court has also been coming across several
matters relating to such compromise before the
Lok-Adalat which are challenged by way of writ
petitions. Hence, I also deem it fit to issue general
directions in respect of such matters which are
referred to Lok-Adalat and compromise recorded as
under:

(i) When a compromise is filed before the Court in
terms of the decision in Smt. Akkubai v. Shri
Venkatrao [2014 SCC OnLine Kar 10110 ILR 2014
Kar 2051] (supra) it is for the Court to record the
compromise and not refer the matter to the Lok-
Adalat.
(ii) It is only if there is no settlement arrived at
before the Court and the parties request for the
matter to be referred to Lok-Adalat to enable a
settlement then in such event the parties are to be
referred to the Lok-Adalat and in the event of a
compromise being arrived at before the Lok-Adalat,
the same could be recorded by the lok-Adalat.

(iii) When the matter is referred to Lok-Adalat,
separate order sheets would have to be opened and
maintained by the said Lok-Adalat and the order
sheet of the Court in the suit cannot be used by the
Lok-Adalat.

(iv) The trial Court and or the Lok-Adalat while
recording compromise is required to ascertain if the

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



parties are present personally as also to ascertain
and verify their identities by production of suitable
documentary proof.

(v) In the event of a power of attorney appearing, it
would be the bounden duty of the Court or the Lok-
Adalat to ascertain if the concerned party has been
served with notice.

(vi) The Court as also the Lok-Adalat would always
have to be suspicious if the party were to enter
appearance even before service of notice which is a
red flag that there is something that is fishy in the
matter.

(vii) When recording a compromise being entered
into by a power of attorney, the original of the
power of attorney is required to be examined by
the Court and the Lok-Adalat and necessary
endorsement made in the order to that effect and
the original power of attorney returned to the
parties.

(viii) As far as possible the trial Court and or the
Lok-Adalat to secure the presence of the party and
obtain signature of such party rather than the
power of attorney.
(ix) The Trial Courts shall ensure that proper and
acceptable proof of identity of the parties to
proceedings as mandated by the Government for
various purposes (such as Aadhar Card, Driving
Licence, Passport Copy, Election Identity card,
etc.,) are obtained as a matter of rule.”


11. In the case of Pooja (supra), in a similar situation,
the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court observed as follows:
“7. Having heard the learned counsel for the
parties, this Court perused the material on record
meticulously. On such perusal of the material on
record, it is crystal clear that the proceedings

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



before the Lok Adalat is not a judicial proceedings.
It may be a fact that a Judicial Officer preside over
the Lok Adalat as a conciliator along with an
advocate conciliator. But before the Lok-Adalat
such a Judicial Officer is not entitled to discharge
the job of a 'Judge' and his role is only that of a
conciliator.

8. Therefore, by sheer logic, it would result that the
Lok - Adalat cannot entertain an application filed
under Order 23 Rule 3 of CPC or for that matter,
any other applications where judicial orders are
required to be passed.

9. Further, it is settled principles of law that the
petition filed under Order 23 Rule 3 of CPC is to be
accepted by the Court after entering satisfaction.
Such a power is not available to the conciliators
who preside over the Lok Adalat (One of them
being a Judicial Officer, but will be acting as a
conciliator).


10. Under such circumstances, since the
conciliators have exercised the judicial powers
while presiding over the Lok Adalat, order passed
by the Lok Adalat in accepting the compromise and
directing the decree of the suit needs to be set
aside as it is oppose to the settled principles of
law.”



12. The decisions referred to above reinforce that the
Lok Adalat does not exercise the powers of a civil court when
recording a compromise petition filed under Order 23 Rule 3 of
the CPC. In other words, the Lok Adalat has no authority or
jurisdiction to record the compromise filed under Order 23 Rule

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



3 of the Code of Civil Procedure or to draw up a decree in terms
of the Compromise Petition.

13. In the case on hand, although the impugned order
indicates that it is an order passed by the Lok Adalat, it is
worth noting that no separate order sheet is maintained by the
Lok Adalat, and the compromise filed under Order 23 Rule 3 of
the CPC is recorded in the order sheet of the original suit in
O.S.No.240/2018. Several discrepancies are noticed in the
manner in which the Compromise Petition is recorded;
nonetheless, those aspects need not be gone into at this
juncture, inasmuch as the order passed by the Lok Adalat
recording the compromise filed under Order 23 Rule 3 of the
CPC cannot be sustained in light of the decision rendered by
this Court supra . In the considered view of this Court, the
impugned order passed by the Lok Adalat recording the
Compromise and drawing up the decree in terms of the
Compromise Petition is erroneous and cannot be sustained in
law.

14. Hence, this Court proceeds to pass the following:

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12174
WP No. 223821 of 2020

CNR: KAHC030023922020



ORDER

i. The Writ Petition is hereby allowed .

ii. The Impugned Order dated 14.07.2018
and the Decree dated 06.12.2018, passed
in O.S. No. 240/2018, are set aside .

iii. O.S. No. 240/2018 filed on the file of the
Civil Judge and JMFC at Basavana
Bagewadi is restored to its file for
disposal of the suit in accordance with
law.

Sd/-
(SUBRAMANYA R)
JUDGE


BL
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 14