Muzahid vs Shahnwaz And 4 Others
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
A.F.R.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
FIRST APPEAL FROM ORDER No. - 2154 of 2022
Muzahid
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
Shahnwaz And 4 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Anju Shukla, Nigamendra Shukla
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Shashi Kant Srivastava, Shrey Singh
In Chamber
HON'BLE SUDHANSHU CHAUHAN, J.
1. Heard learned counsel for the appellant, Sri Shashi Kant Srivastava,
learned counsel for the respondent no.3 and Sri Shrey Singh, learned
counsel for the respondent no.5.
2. The present appeal has been filed for enhancement of the amount
awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Ghaziabad, in Motor
Accident Claim Petition No. 217/2012 (Muzahid v. Shahnawaz and
others) vide judgment and order dated 26.09.2022.
3. The facts involved in the controversy, in brief, are that the appellant,
while he was traveling as a conductor/cleaner in a vehicle bearing
registration no. UP 13 P 9762, on 02.11.2007 at around 03:00 a.m., met
with an accident, when another vehicle bearing registration no. UP13J
9576 had hit the vehicle on which the appellant was employed on GT
Road, Police Station Mansoorpur, District Muzzafarnagar. The appellant
in the accident had sustained severe injuries, including those of the spine,
and was admitted at District Hospital, Muzzafarnagar and had
subsequently undergone a surgery of the spine and has been bedridden
ever since.
4. The learned tribunal had held that the accident had taken place on
account of the rash and negligent driving of drivers of both the vehicles
and it was a case of contributory negligence. Further, the vehicle bearing
registration no. UP13 J 9576 was insured with New India Insurance
Company-respondent no. 5. However, the vehicle bearing registration no.
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
2
UP13 P 9672 was not insured with United India Insurance Company
Limited - respondent no. 3, as alleged by the owner of the vehicle,
respondent no. 1, and the cover note of insurance was found to be forged
and fabricated. Hence, the learned tribunal had held the respondent no. 5,
insurance, and respondent no. 1, the owner of the vehicle bearing
registration No. UP 13 P 9672, to be equally liable to pay the
compensation awarded.
5. As far as the appellant is concerned, he had sustained severe injuries of
the spine in the accident and was admitted to District Hospital,
Muzaffarnagar, on the date of the accident. He was thereafter shifted to
City Hospital, Meerut, and from there to AIIMS, Delhi. The appellant was
shifted to Safdarganj Hospital, Delhi, on 04.11.2007 and remained
admitted there till 06.12.2007. Thereafter, the appellant remained
admitted at Madhu Hospital, Hapur, from 13.01.2008 to 24.01.2008.
Subsequent thereto, the appellant was admitted at Medical College,
Meerut, from 29.04.2008 to 21.05.2008, and again from 01.09.2008 to
13.09.2008. Again, the appellant was admitted at Subharti Hospital,
Meerut from 29.12.2009 to 09.01.2010 at Madhu Hospital, Hapur from
25.02.2010 to 06.03.2010 and lastly at Narayana Superspeciality Hospital,
Meerut from 24.03.2010 to 05.04.2010. Thus, the appellant remained
admitted for a duration of 116 days in various hospitals.
6. The appellant was diagnosed with quadriplegia and also dislocation of
C4-C5 vertebrae (cervical spine), for which the appellant also underwent
surgery where internal fixation of steel plate and screws was carried out
on his spine. It is also not disputed that after the accident, the appellant
has been completely bedridden and is immobile and unable to use all four
limbs. Besides the applicant has to live with a catheter and defecates on
bed with the assistance from others. The disability certificate dated
07.08.2008 issued by Chief Medical Officer, Ghaziabad, has assessed the
percentage of disability of the appellant at 70%. Besides, the appellant has
also filed a medical certificate regarding disability issued by Dr. R.N.
Gupta, Former Additional Director, Medical Board, Allahabad wherein
the disability of the appellant has been assessed at 100% in accordance
with guidelines laid down vide notification dated 06.08.1986, issued by
the Ministry of Welfare, Government of India. Dr. R. N. Gupta was also
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
3
produced before the learned tribunal, wherein he had deposed that the
appellant is unable to perform daily activities like sitting, walking, and
defecating and also suffers from urinary and fecal incontinence.
7. The learned tribunal, while awarding compensation to the appellant,
has determined his age at the time of accident as 22 years and monthly
income as Rs. 5,000. Subsequently, the learned tribunal has determined
the loss of future income of the appellant at the rate of 40%, and
determined the monthly income as Rs 7,000/- and yearly income as Rs
84,000/. However, the learned tribunal, while assessing the disability of
the appellant at 70% on the basis of the certificate issued by Chief
Medical Officer, Ghaziabad, has determined his yearly income as Rs.
58,800/. Thereafter, the learned tribunal, while applying the multiplier of
18, has determined the future loss of income of the appellant as
Rs10,58,400/(58,800x18).
8. As the appellant remained admitted for a duration of 116 days, the
learned tribunal has awarded an amount of Rs 69,600 (116 × 600) and
additional amount of Rs1,00,000/- under the said head total amounting to
Rs.1,69,600/- towards attendant charges. Besides the learned tribunal
awarded an amount of Rs. 1,00,000/- towards future medical expenses, an
amount of Rs. 1,00,000/- towards mental and physical pain, an amount of
Rs. 50,000/- towards diet and an amount of Rs. 50,000/- towards
ambulance charges.
9. Thus, the learned tribunal awarded an amount of Rs. 15,28,000/- to the
appellant, along with 7% simple interest payable from the date of filing of
the petition till the date of actual payment, further, the liability to pay the
aforesaid amount was fixed upon respondent no. 1, the owner of vehicle
no. UP 13 P 9762, and respondent no. 5, the insurer of vehicle no. UP 13
J 9576, each being liable for 50% of the amount. It is made clear that the
learned tribunal had not awarded any amount towards medical expenses
incurred by the appellant till the time of filing of the petition, in view of
the fact that no medical bills had been produced by the appellant in
support of the claim.
10. Under the circumstances, it is contended on behalf of the appellant
that the learned tribunal was not at all justified in determining the
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
4
permanent disability of the appellant as 70% as certified by the Chief
Medical Officer. The fact of the matter was that the appellant was
permanently disabled to the extent of 100%, in view of the fact that the
appellant was bedridden and was unable to follow his daily routine in the
absence of assistance from others. The learned tribunal, though, arrived at
a finding that the appellant, every day, needed assistance to follow his
daily routine, and as such, an amount of Rs.1,69,600/- towards past and
future attendant charges was very meager to enable the appellant to meet
the expenditure incurred towards attendant charges. It was duly proved
that the appellant was repeatedly admitted in various hospitals for a
duration of 116 days to undergo treatment for the injury sustained, the
prescriptions as well as the medical reports in support thereof were duly
produced, yet the learned tribunal failed to award any amount towards
medical expenses incurred solely on the ground that no medical bills had
been produced. Further, it is contended that, even otherwise, the amounts
awarded towards pain and suffering, diet, compensation for loss of
amenities and pleasures for future life, as well as the future prospects of
the income of the appellant, were very meager and had not been
determined, keeping in view the nature of injuries sustained by the
appellant on account of the accident and the life that was to be led by the
appellant in future.
11. Per contra, it has been contended on behalf of learned counsel for
respondent no. 5-insurance company that disability has been rightly
determined by the learned tribunal on the basis of the disability certificate
issued by the Chief Medical Officer. Further, there is no such concept of
functional disability, and the courts have only recognized the physical
disability determined on the basis of the disability certificate. The
attendant charges have rightly been determined by the learned tribunal,
more so when there was nothing on record to demonstrate that the
appellant was availing the services of any attendant while at home. As the
appellant had failed to produce any documentary evidence of bills in
respect of medical expenses nor any quantification of the amount spent
towards medical expense was filed, hence, the learned tribunal had rightly
refused to award any amount under the head of medical expenses incurred
till the time of filing of the petition. Besides, an amount of Rs. 69,600/-
has already been awarded when the appellant was hospitalized for a
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
5
duration of 116 days @ Rs 600/- per day. Further, it is contended that the
amounts awarded towards pain and suffering, diet, compensation for loss
of amenities and pleasure for future life, and other heads were
commensurate with the nature of injuries sustained as well as the income
of the appellant, and no interference was warranted in the same.
12. Before adverting to the merits of the controversy, this Court is
conscious of the fact that a just compensation is to be awarded while
making an award in proceedings arising under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988. The Apex Court, in the case of Helen C. Rebello v.
Maharashtra SRTC and another (1999) Vol. 1 SCC 90 , held the
following on the contours of just compensation:-
"The word "just", as its nomenclature, denotes equitability, fairness and
reasonableness having a large peripheral field. The largeness is, of course, not
arbitrary; it is restricted by the conscience which is fair, reasonable and equitable, if
it exceeds; it is termed as unfair, unreasonable, unequitable, not just."
A person, therefore, is not only to be compensated for the injury suffered
due to the accident, but also for the loss suffered on account of the injury and
his inability to live the life he led prior to the life-altering event.
13. Further the Apex Court in the case of Jagdish v. Mohan and others,
(2018) 4 SCC 571 had made the following observation on the intrinsic
value of human life and dignity that is attempted to be recognized through
such compensatory awards: -
"The measure of compensation must reflect a genuine attempt of the law to restore the
dignity of the being. Our yardsticks of compensation should not be so abysmal as to
lead one to question whether our law values human life. If it does, as it must, it must
provide a realistic recompense for the pain of loss and the trauma of suffering.
Awards of compensation are not law's doles. In a discourse of rights, they constitute
entitlements under law"
14. This Court has perused the records of the case, and certain undisputed
facts that emerge are that the appellant was employed as a
conductor/cleaner of vehicle no. UP 13P 9762, was aged about 22 years,
and was earning Rs. 5,000/- per month on the date of the accident i.e
02.11.2007. The appellant, as a consequence of the accident, had
sustained severe injuries in the spine and was operated and internal
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
6
fixation of steel plate and screws was done on his spine. Besides, the
appellant also suffered from dislocation of his C4-C5 vertebrae i.e
cervical spine. The appellant remained admitted in various hospitals from
time to time after the accident, a total duration of 116 days prior to filing
of the claim petition. The appellant suffers from quadriplegia, is
completely bedridden, and uses a catheter to pass urine and has to
defecate on the bed, besides, he also suffers from incontinence in passing
urine and faeces. Thus, the appellant is unable to follow his daily routine
without assistance from others.
15. In respect of the loss of future earnings awarded to the appellant, the
learned tribunal, by means of the impugned judgment and order, had
determined the monthly income of the appellant as Rs. 5,000/-, the future
loss of income at 40 %, the percentage of disability as 70% on the basis of
the certificate of Chief Medical Officer, and used the multiplier of 18,
thereby determining the amount under the said head as Rs. 10,58,400/-.
16. In this regard, the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant
is that, as the appellant was completely bedridden and was unable to
perform his daily routine without assistance, there was 100% loss of
earning capacity, whereas it is contended on behalf of the respondent No.
5 that the loss of income has rightly been determined on the basis of the
disability certificate as 70%.
17. In the case of Raj Kumar vs. Ajay Kumar and another, (2011) 1 SCC
343, the Apex Court, while determining this question, was of the view
that what is required to be assessed by the tribunal is the effect of
permanent disability on the earning capacity of the injured person. After
assessing the loss of earning capacity in terms of a percentage of income,
it has to be quantified in terms of money. Further, the Apex Court had
went on to hold as under:-
“ 8. Where the claimant suffers a permanent disability as a result of injuries, the
assessment of compensation under the head of loss of future earnings, would depend
upon the effect and impact of such permanent disability on his earning capacity. The
Tribunal should not mechanically apply the percentage of permanent disability as the
percentage of economic loss or loss of earning capacity. In most of the cases, the
percentage of economic loss, that is, percentage of loss of earning capacity, arising
from a permanent disability will be different from the percentage of permanent
disability. Some Tribunals wrongly assume that in all cases, a particular extent
(percentage) of permanent disability would result in a corresponding loss of earning
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
7
capacity, and consequently, if the evidence produced show 45% as the permanent
disability, will hold that there is 45% loss of future earning capacity. In most of the
cases, equating the extent (percentage) of loss of earning capacity to the extent
(percentage) of permanent disability will result in award of either too low or too high
a compensation. What requires to be assessed by the Tribunal is the effect of the
permanently disability on the earning capacity of the injured; and after assessing the
loss of earning capacity in terms of a percentage of the income, it has to be quantified
in terms of money, to arrive at the future loss of earnings (by applying the standard
multiplier method used to determine loss of dependency). We may however note that
in some cases, on appreciation of evidence and assessment, the Tribunal may find that
percentage of loss of earning capacity as a result of the permanent disability, is
approximately the same as the percentage of permanent disability in which case, of
course, the Tribunal will adopt the said percentage for determination of compensation
(see for example, the decisions of this court in Arvind Kumar Mishra v. New India
Assurance Co.Ltd. - 2010(10) SCALE 298 and Yadava Kumar v. D.M., National
.
Insurance Co. Ltd. - 2010 (8) SCALE 567)
9. Therefore, the Tribunal has to first decide whether there is any permanent disability
and if so the extent of such permanent disability. This means that the tribunal should
consider and decide with reference to the evidence: (i) whether the disablement is
permanent or temporary; (ii) if the disablement is permanent, whether it is permanent
total disablement or permanent partial disablement, (iii) if the disablement percentage
is expressed with reference to any specific limb, then the effect of such disablement of
the limb on the functioning of the entire body, that is the permanent disability suffered
by the person. If the Tribunal concludes that there is no permanent disability then
there is no question of proceeding further and determining the loss of future earning
capacity. But if the Tribunal concludes that there is permanent disability then it will
proceed to ascertain its extent. After the Tribunal ascertains the actual extent of
permanent disability of the claimant based on the medical evidence, it has to
determine whether such permanent disability has affected or will affect his earning
capacity.
10. Ascertainment of the effect of the permanent disability on the actual earning
capacity involves three steps. The Tribunal has to first ascertain what activities the
claimant could carry on inspite of the permanent disability and what he could not do
as a result of the permanent ability (this is also relevant for awarding compensation
under the head of loss of amenities of life). The second step is to ascertain his
avocation, profession and nature of work before the accident, as also his age. The
third step is to find out whether (i) the claimant is totally disabled from earning any
kind of livelihood, or (ii) whether in spite of the permanent disability, the claimant
could still effectively carry on the activities and functions, which he was earlier
carrying on, or (iii) whether he was prevented or restricted from discharging his
previous activities and functions, but could carry on some other or lesser scale of
activities and functions so that he continues to earn or can continue to earn his
livelihood. For example, if the left hand of a claimant is amputated, the permanent
physical or functional disablement may be assessed around 60%. If the claimant was
a driver or a carpenter, the actual loss of earning capacity may virtually be hundred
percent, if he is neither able to drive or do carpentry. On the other hand, if the
claimant was a clerk in government service, the loss of his left hand may not result in
loss of employment and he may still be continued as a clerk as he could perform his
clerical functions; and in that event the loss of earning capacity will not be 100% as
in the case of a driver or carpenter, nor 60% which is the actual physical disability,
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
8
but far less. In fact, there may not be any need to award any compensation under the
head of `loss of future earnings', if the claimant continues in government service,
though he may be awarded compensation under the head of loss of amenities as a
consequence of losing his hand. Sometimes the injured claimant may be continued in
service, but may not found suitable for discharging the duties attached to the post or
job which he was earlier holding, on account of his disability, and may therefore be
shifted to some other suitable but lesser post with lesser emoluments, in which case
there should be a limited award under the head of loss of future earning capacity,
taking note of the reduced earning capacity. It may be noted that when compensation
is awarded by treating the loss of future earning capacity as 100% (or even anything
more than 50%), the need to award compensation separately under the head of loss of
amenities or loss of expectation of life may disappear and as a result, only a token or
nominal amount may have to be awarded under the head of loss of amenities or loss of
expectation of life, as otherwise there may be a duplication in the award of
compensation. Be that as it may.
11. The Tribunal should not be a silent spectator when medical evidence is tendered in
regard to the injuries and their effect, in particular the extent of permanent disability.
Sections 168 and 169 of the Act make it evident that the Tribunal does not function as
a neutral umpire as in a civil suit, but as an active explorer and seeker of truth who is
required to `hold an enquiry into the claim' for determining the `just compensation'.
The Tribunal should therefore take an active role to ascertain the true and correct
position so that it can assess the `just compensation'. While dealing with personal
injury cases, the Tribunal should preferably equip itself with a Medical Dictionary
and a Handbook for evaluation of permanent physical impairment (for example the
Manual for Evaluation of Permanent Physical Impairment for Orthopedic Surgeons,
prepared by American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons or its Indian equivalent or
other authorized texts) for understanding the medical evidence and assessing the
physical and functional disability. The Tribunal may also keep in view the first
schedule to the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 which gives some indication
about the extent of permanent disability in different types of injuries, in the case of
workmen. If a Doctor giving evidence uses technical medical terms, the Tribunal
should instruct him to state in addition, in simple non-medical terms, the nature and
the effect of the injury. If a doctor gives evidence about the percentage of permanent
disability, the Tribunal has to seek clarification as to whether such percentage of
disability is the functional disability with reference to the whole body or whether it is
only with reference to a limb. If the percentage of permanent disability is stated with
reference to a limb, the Tribunal will have to seek the doctor's opinion as to whether it
is possible to deduce the corresponding functional permanent disability with reference
to the whole body and if so the percentage.
12. The Tribunal should also act with caution, if it proposed to accept the expert
evidence of doctors who did not treat the injured but who give `ready to use' disability
certificates, without proper medical assessment. There are several instances of
unscrupulous doctors who without treating the injured, readily give liberal disability
certificates to help the claimants. But where the disability certificates are given by
duly constituted Medical Boards, they may be accepted subject to evidence regarding
the genuineness of such certificates. The Tribunal may invariably make it a point to
require the evidence of the Doctor who treated the injured or who assessed the
permanent disability. Mere production of a disability certificate or Discharge
Certificate will not be proof of the extent of disability stated therein unless the Doctor
who treated the claimant or who medically examined and assessed the extent of
disability of claimant, is tendered for cross- examination with reference to the
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
9
certificate. If the Tribunal is not satisfied with the medical evidence produced by the
claimant, it can constitute a Medical Board (from a panel maintained by it in
consultation with reputed local Hospitals/Medical Colleges) and refer the claimant to
such Medical Board for assessment of the disability.
13. We may now summarise the principles discussed above : (i) All injuries (or
permanent disabilities arising from injuries), do not result in loss of earning
capacity.(ii) The percentage of permanent disability with reference to the whole body
of a person, cannot be assumed to be the percentage of loss of earning capacity. To
put it differently, the percentage of loss of earning capacity is not the same as the
percentage of permanent disability (except in a few cases, where the Tribunal on the
basis of evidence, concludes that percentage of loss of earning capacity is the same as
percentage of permanent disability). (iii) The doctor who treated an injured-claimant
or who examined him subsequently to assess the extent of his permanent disability can
give evidence only in regard the extent of permanent disability. The loss of earning
capacity is something that will have to be assessed by the Tribunal with reference to
the evidence in entirety. (iv) The same permanent disability may result in different
percentages of loss of earning capacity in different persons, depending upon the
nature of profession, occupation or job, age, education and other factors.”
18. In the case of Parminder Singh vs New India Assurance Company
Limited and others, ( 2019) 7, SCC 217 , where the appellant, a driver,
sustained grievous injuries, was aged about 22 years and was earning Rs.
10,000/- per month and had a disability assessed at 75%, the Apex Court,
while considering the law laid down in the case of Govind Yadav vs New
India Insurance Company Limited (2011) 10 SCC 683 , K Suresh vs
New India Assurance Company Limited (2012) 12 SCC 274 , and Raj
Kumar vs Ajay Kumar and others (Supra) , had upheld the determination
of functional disability at 100% by the High Court. The relevant extract of
the judgment is as under: -
“ 5.4. The Appellant was 23 years old at the time when the accident occurred. Applying
the multiplier of 18, the loss of future earnings suffered by the Appellant would work
out to Rs. 15,000 X 12 X 18 = Rs. 32,40,000/-.
5.5. The High Court has rightly assessed the functional disability of the Appellant as
100%. The Appellant is suffering from hemiplegia due to which the left side of his
body is barely functioning. On account of the permanent disability suffered, the
Appellant was deprived of getting married and having a normal family life. His
capacity to earn a living has been completely shattered for the rest of his life, and he
has a become fully dependant person.
5.6. In the present case, it is an admitted position that it is not possible for the
Appellant to get employed as a driver, or do any kind of manual labour, or engage in
any agricultural operations whatsoever, for his sustenance.
In such circumstances, the High Court has rightly assessed the Appellant’s functional
disability at 100% insofar as his loss of earning capacity is concerned. The Appellant
is, therefore, awarded Rs. 32,40,000/ towards loss of earning capacity.
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
10
5.7. We further find that the compensation awarded to the Appellant towards his
medical expenses is highly insufficient. The Appellant has undergone 5 surgeries,
including a surgery for a severe head injury, and 3 throat surgeries. The Appellant
has not been awarded any amount whatsoever either by the MACT, or the High Court
for the successive hospitalizations, surgeries and medical treatment.
In view of the facts and circumstances of the case, it would be just and fair to award a
lump sum amount of Rs. 7,50,000/ towards hospitalization and medical expenses
incurred in the past by the Appellant.”
19. In the case of Jithendran vs New India Assurance Co. Ltd. and
, in which said case the injured was 21 years
another, (2022)15 SCC 620
old and earning about Rs. 4,500/month and suffered from the permanent
disability of 69%, the Apex Court, while considering the law laid down in
the case of Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and another (supra) , Chanappa
Nagappa Muchalagoda v. Divisional Manager, New India Insurance
Company Limited, (2020 )1 SCC 796 , and Pappu Deo Yadav v. Nanesh
, had held as under :-
Kumar and others, 2020 SCC Online 752
“ 10.While the permanent disability as certified by the doctors stands at 69%,the same
by no means, adequately reflects the travails the impaired claimant will have to face
all his life. The 21 year old’s youthful dreams and future hopes were snuffed out by the
serious accident. The young man’s impaired condition has certainly impacted his
family members. Their resources and strength are bound to be stressed by the need to
provide full time care to the claimant. For the appellant to constantly rely on them for
stimulation and support is destined to cause emotional, physical and financial fatigue
for all stakeholders.
11………
12………
13………
14………
15………
16. As noted earlier, the impact on the earning capacity for the claimant by virtue of
his 69% disability must not be measured as a proportionate loss of his earning
capacity. The earning life for the appellant is over and as such his income loss has to
be quantified as 100%. There is no other way to assess the earning loss since the
appellant is incapacitated for life and is confined to home. In such circumstances, his
loss of earning capacity must be fixed at 100%. As his monthly income was Rs.4,500/-,
adding 40% future prospect thereto,the monthly loss of earning is quantified as
Rs.6,300/-. We therefore deem it appropriate to quantify Rs.13,60,800/- (Rs.6,300 x 12
x 18) as compensation for 100% loss of earning for the claimant. Accordingly, under
this head, the amount awarded by the High Court is enhanced proportionately.”
20. Recently, the Apex Court in the case of Parvinder Singh v Honey
Goyal, (2025) SCC where the injured was 21 years old and suffered
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
11
grievous injuries in an accident resulting in quadriplegia, while assessing
the monthly income of the injured at Rs. 7,500/- per month has
determined the loss of future income, taking the disability at 100%, and
had awarded an amount of Rs 36,84,000/-. In the present case, the
appellant was aged about 22 years at the time of the accident and is
suffering from the same illness, quadriplegia. Hence, this court holds that
the appellant for the purposes of determination of loss of future income,
the same is to be made taking the permanent disability at the rate of
100%.
21. Thus, in view of the law discussed above, and the facts of the case
,this court is of the view that the percentage of loss of earning capacity of
the appellant on account of the permanent disability should be 100%.
22. Further, according to Rule 220A of the UP Motor Vehicle Rules,
1998, the claim tribunal may also award compensation for future
prospects according to sub-rule (3) of Rule (3) in case of permanent
disability, depending upon the nature, extent, and its effect on the future
of disabled claimants. Further under the said rule compensation for loss of
future income due to permanent disability is at the rate of 50%, if the
injured is below 40 years of age. However, in the present case, the learned
tribunal has awarded compensation for loss of future income due to
permanent disability at the rate of 40%. As already established above, in
the present case, the appellant would not be able to work and earn in
future in view of the injuries sustained in the accident. In the case of
Sushil Kumar and another v. M/ S Sampark Lojastic Pvt. Ltd. and
another, FAFO No. 2581 of 2011 , decided on 26.04. 2011, Division
Bench of this Court has held that even if the accident occurred prior to
26.09.2011, the date on which Rule 220A was enforced, the claimants are
entitled to compensation on future prospects as per amended Rule 220A
of the U.P. Motor Vehicle Rules, 1998, in view of the fact that the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, is a beneficial legislation.
23. In view of the above, this court assesses the functional disability of
the appellant at 100% and is of the view that the appellant is entitled to
get compensation for future loss of income due to permanent disability at
the rate of 50% in accordance with provisions of Rule 220A. Hence,
keeping in view the fact that the monthly income of the appellant was Rs.
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
12
5,000/-, his future income, being assessed at the rate of 50% would be Rs.
7,500/- per month and yearly income would be Rs 90,000/-.The appellant
was 22 years of age at the time of the accident, and as such, a multiplier
of 18 would be applicable. thus, the loss of future income of the appellant
would be Rs 16,20,000/-.
24. As far as the attendant charges to which the appellant was entitled, the
learned tribunal has awarded an amount of Rs. 69,600/@ Rs. 600 per day
for 116 days the period, during which the appellant had been hospitalized.
Although the learned tribunal has held that the spinal cord of the appellant
is broken, he is bedridden and is even unable to follow daily routine
without assistance, an additional sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- only has been
awarded towards attendant charges.
25. In respect of the attendant charges, this court is of the view that once
the learned tribunal concluded that the appellant was totally bedridden
and had further awarded attendant charges at the rate of Rs. 600/ per day
during the period of hospitalization, it was unreasonable and arbitrary on
the part of the learned tribunal to have awarded only a meager amount of
Rs.1,00,000/ towards attendant charges in future. The learned tribunal
ought to have awarded attendant charges, taking into consideration the
seriously impaired cognitive and physical capabilities of the appellant,
who could not even get up from the bed without assistance from others.
26. The Apex court in the case of Kajal vs Jagdish Chand and others,
(2020 4 SCC 413 , while determining the question of attendant charges,
had held as under :-
“ 22. The attendant charges have been awarded by the High Court @ Rs.2,500/ per
month for 44 years, which works out to Rs.13,20,000/. Unfortunately, this system is
not a proper system. Multiplier system is used to balance out various factors. When
compensation is awarded in lump sum, various factors are taken into consideration.
When compensation is paid in lump sum, this Court has always followed the multiplier
system. The multiplier system should be followed not only for determining the
compensation on account of loss of income but also for determining the attendant
charges etc. This system was recognised by this Court in Gobald Motor Service Ltd. v.
R.M.K. Veluswami. The multiplier system factors in the inflation rate, the rate of
interest payable on the lump sum award, the longevity of the claimant, and also other
issues such as the uncertainties of life. Out of all the various alternative methods, the
multiplier method has been recognised as the most realistic and reasonable method. It
ensures better justice between the parties and thus results in award of ‘just
compensation’ within the meaning of the Act.
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
13
23. It would be apposite at this stage to refer to the observation of Lord Reid in Taylor
v. O’Connor:
"Damages to make good the loss of dependency over a period of years must be
awarded as a lump sum and that sum is generally calculated by applying a multiplier
to the amount of one year's dependency. That is a perfectly good method in the
ordinary case but it conceals the fact that there are two quite separate matters
involved- the present value of the series of the future payments, and the discounting of
that present value to allow for the fact that for one reason or another the person
receiving the damages might never have enjoyed the whole of the benefit of the
dependency. It is quite unnecessary in the ordinary case to deal with these matters
separately. Judges and counsel have a wealth of experience which is an adequate
guide to the selection of the multiplier and any expert evidence is rightly discouraged.
But in a case where the facts are special, I think, that these matters must have
separate consideration if even rough justice is to be done and expert evidence may be
valuable or even almost essential. The special factor in the present case is the
incidence of Income Tax and, it may be, surtax."
24. This Court has reaffirmed the multiplier method in various cases like MCD v.
Subhagwanti, U.P. State Road Transport Corporation v. Trilok Chandra, Sandeep
Khanduja v. Atul Dande. This Court has also recognised that Schedule II of the Act
can be used as a guide for the multiplier to be applied in each case. Keeping the
claimant’s age in mind, the multiplier in this case should be 18 as opposed to 44 taken
by the High Court.
25. Having held so, we are clearly of the view that the basic amount taken for
determining attendant charges is very much on the lower side. We must remember that
this little girl is severely suffering from incontinence meaning that she does not have
control over her bodily functions like passing urine and faeces. As she grows older,
she will not be able to handle her periods. She requires an attendant virtually 24
hours a day. She requires an attendant who though may not be medically trained but
must be capable of handling a child who is bed ridden. She would require an
attendant who would ensure that she does not suffer from bed sores. The claimant has
placed before us a notification of the State of Haryana of the year 2010, wherein the
wages for skilled labourer is Rs.4846/ per month. We, therefore, assess the cost of one
attendant at Rs.5,000/ and she will require two attendants which works out to
Rs.10,000/ per month, which comes to Rs.1,20,000/ per annum, and using the
multiplier of 18 it works out to Rs.21,60,000/ for the attendant charges for her entire
life. This takes care of all the pecuniary damages.”
27. Further, the Apex Court in the case of Jithendran v. New India
, wherein the injured
Assurance Company Limited and another (supra)
was 21 years old and was earning about Rs. 4,500/- per month from
jewellery work and had suffered a permanent disability of 69% in the
nature of severe impairment of cognitive power with hemiparesis and was
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
14
unable to perform everyday functions, had awarded attendant charges
taking a conservative estimate at the rate of Rs. 5,000/- per month and
after applying the multiplier of 18 had awarded compensation under the
bystander head at Rs. 10,80,000/-.
28. Thus, this court, while applying the same principle as has been laid by
the Apex Court and also keeping in view the fact that the learned tribunal
had awarded attendant charges at the rate of Rs. 600/- per day, is of the
view that the appellant is entitled to attendant charges at least at the rate
of Rs. 4,000/- per month, and as such, the annual expenses under the said
head comes to Rs. 48,000/- per month. On applying the multiplier of 18,
as the appellant is aged 22 years, the amount to which the appellant would
be entitled under the head of attendant charges comes to Rs. 8,64,000/-.
29. As far as the award of medical expenses incurred after the accident is
concerned, the learned tribunal arrived at a finding that the appellant was
admitted at various hospitals after the accident on 02.11.2007 and lastly,
on 24.03.2010. However, the learned tribunal refused to award any
amount towards medical expenses solely on the ground that the appellant
had failed to produce any medical bills and had only filed prescriptions of
doctors and medical reports. This court has perused the lower court record
and finds that reference letter of City Hospital Meerut dated 03.11.2007,
admission slip of All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Delhi dated
03.11.2007, discharge summary of Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi dated
6.12.1987, discharge summary of Madhu Hospital, Hapur dated
24.01.2008, discharge slip of Medical College Meerut dated 29.4.2008,
discharge slip of Medical College Meerut dated 01.09.2008, discharge
slip of Subharti Hospital Meerut dated 09.01.2010, discharge summary of
Madhu Hospital, Harpur, dated 06.03.2010 and discharge summary of
Narayana Super Speciality Hospital, Meerut dated 24.03.2010 are on
record. Other than that, there are various medical prescriptions of doctors
and reports of various medical tests conducted from time to time on
record.
30. Hence, it is evident that the appellant was admitted to various
hospitals on as many as eight occasions over a duration of two and half
years after the occurrence of the accident on 02.11.2007. Besides, the
appellant also underwent a surgery during this while, when internal
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
15
fixation of a steel plate and screws on his spine was done. It is beyond
doubt that the appellant would have incurred a substantial expenditure
during the surgery and hospitalization in various hospitals, visiting
doctors from time to time and getting various medical tests conducted.
Thus, this court is of the view that the appellant is required to be
recompensed for the expenditure so incurred in his medical treatment,
even in the absence of medical bills, and the same, on a conservative
basis, is assessed at Rs 2,50,000/-.
31. This Court is also aware of the fact that the Apex Court in the case of
Raj Kumar vs. Ajay Kumar and another (supra) had held that when
compensation is awarded by treating the loss of future earning capacity as
100% (or even anything more than 50%), the need to award compensation
separately under the head of loss of amenities or loss of expectation of life
may disappear. As a result, only a token or nominal amount may have to
be awarded under the head of loss of amenities or loss of expectation of
life. Otherwise, there may be duplication in the award of compensation in
view of the same. Hence, this Court deems it fit not to interfere with the
other claims awarded by the learned tribunal in the judgment and order
dated 26.09.2022, other than that an amount of Rs 1,00,000/- is awarded
for the loss of marriage prospects, as has been awarded by the Apex Court
in similar circumstances in the case of Parvinder Singh Vs Honey Goyal
(Supra) .
32. Thus, in view of the findings recorded above, the compensation
payable to the applicant is re-determined as under :-
Serial No. Particulars Amount
1. Loss of future income due to 100% functional disability. Rs. 16,20,000/-
2. Attendant charges. Rs. 8,64,000/-
3. Medical Expenses. Rs 2,50,000/-
4. Future Medical Expenses. Rs. 1,00,000/-
5. Pain & Suffering. Rs. 1,00,000/-
6. Future Marriage Prospects. Rs. 1,00,000/-
7. Nutritional diet. Rs 50,000/-
FAFO No. 2154 of 2022
16
8. Ambulance Charges. Rs. 50,000/-
TOTAL
Rs. 28,84,000/-
33. Thus, the appellant is entitled to a total compensation of Rs.
28,84,000/-, along with interest at the rate of 7% per annum from the date
of filing of the claim petition before the learned tribunal till its actual
payment, the amount of compensation so determined shall be paid by
respondent no. 1 and respondent no. 5- insurance company, each having a
liability to pay 50% of the amount so awarded, along with interest
accrued thereon.
34. Thus, the present appeal is allowed and the judgment and order dated
26.09.2022 is modified to the above extent.
35. It is made clear that in terms of the impugned judgment and order
dated 26.09.2022 passed by learned Tribunal, if the demand for
documents in respect of the vehicle involved in the accident, U.P. 13 J
9576 and the driving license of the driver driving the said vehicle, is made
by the respondent no. 5-insurance company from the owner of the said
vehicle, Naeem Ahmad, son of Abdul Qayyum and if, the same are not
provided to the respondent no. 5-insurance company by Naeem Ahmad,
then the respondent no. 5-insurance company shall be at liberty to pay the
amount due in terms of this judgment and recover the same from the
owner of the vehicle, Naeem Ahmad-respondent no. 4.
36. The respondent no. 1 and respondent no. 5 are directed to pay the
decreetal amount within one month from today. If the respondent no. 1
and respondent no. 5 have previously paid/deposited any amount in
pursuance to the impugned judgment and order dated 26.09.2022, the
same shall be adjusted against the decreetal amount awarded by means of
the present judgment.
(Sudhanshu Chauhan,J.)
August 20, 2026
Gaurav
Digitally signed by :-
GAURAV PATEL
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad