SMT. YASHODA N RAI vs M/S CHILDREN CORNER
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 7 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN
COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 416 OF 2026
BETWEEN:
1. SMT. YASHODA N RAI
W/O LATE. NARAYANA T RAI
AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS,
R/A POUND GARDEN KADRI,
BEHIND CITY HOSPITAL,
MANGALORE-575 003.
2. SRI. ADITYA N RAI
S/O LATE NARAYANA T RAI,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
R/AT POUND GARDEN
BEHIND CITY HOSPITAL,
KADRI, MANGALORE-575 003.
Digitally
signed by
MALA K N
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
3. THE CHILDREN'S CORNER
A PARTNERSHIP FIRM
REGISTERED UNDER THE
PROVISIONS OF THE INDIAN
PARTNERSHIP ACT,
REPRESENTED BY ITS PARTNERS
APPELLANT NO.1 AND 2
SMT. YASHODA N RAI
SRI. ADITYA N RAI
POUND GARDEN BEHIND CITY HOSPITAL,
KADRI,
MANGALORE-575 003.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI. K CHANDRANATH ARIGA.,ADVOCATE)
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
AND:
1. M/S CHILDREN CORNER
A PARTNERSHIP FIRM,
REPT., BY ITS PARTNER,
SMT. NISHALI RAI,
PLAINTIFF NO.2 INFRA,
HAVING ITS OFFICE AT
HOTEL ROOPA BUILDING,
VALMATTA ROAD,
MANGALORE-575 001.
2. SMT. NISHALI RAI,
W/O ASHWIN SHETTY,
D/O SMT. YASHODA N RAI
LATE. NARAYANA T RAI,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
PARTNER,
M/S CHILDREN'S CORNER,
A PARTNERSHIP FIRM,
R/A PLANET S.K.S KADRI HILLS,
TH
FLAT NO. 904, 9 FLOOR,
MANGALORE-575 004.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. AJAY.T, ADVOCATE FOR
SMT. ARUNA BHAT, ADV., FOR R1 & R2 (VK FILED FOR R2)
THIS COMAP FILED UNDER SECTION 13(1-A) OF COMMERCIAL
COURT ACT R/W ORDER XLIII RULE 1(R) OF THE CODE OF CIVIL
PROCEDURE, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE ORDER DATED
21.07.2026 IN COMMERCIAL OS NO.152/2026 PASSED BY THE I
ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE AND COMMERCIAL COURT,
MANGALORE.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
This Commercial Appeal is filed by the defendants
challenging the Judgment and Decree dated 21.07.2026 passed
by the I Additional District Judge & Commercial Court, D.K.,
Mangaluru ( ‘Commercial Court’ ) in Com.O.S.No.152/2026,
whereby I.A.No.2 filed by the plaintiffs came to be allowed
making the interim ex parte order of injunction dated
30.04.2026 absolute until disposal of the suit or until further
orders.
2. For the sake of convenience, the parties shall be
referred to by their respective ranks before the Commercial
Court.
(i) Facts of the plaintiffs:
3. The case of the plaintiffs is that the business carried
on under the name and style of "Children’s Corner" was initially
started by late Narayana Thimmappa Rai in or about 1981.
According to the second plaintiff, her father initially carried on
the business as a proprietary concern and thereafter converted
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
it into a partnership business. The partnership deed dated
10.10.2008 was entered into between late Narayana T. Rai and
the first defendant, Smt. Yashoda N. Rai. The firm underwent
subsequent reconstitutions. Under the deed dated 12.04.2013,
the second plaintiff and her brother, the second defendant,
were also inducted as partners. The second defendant retired
from the firm with effect from 01.10.2014. After the death of
Narayana T. Rai in November 2018, the firm was reconstituted
under a deed dated 09.11.2018 between the first defendant
and the second plaintiff, with their respective profit-sharing
ratios being 40% and 60%.
4. The second plaintiff further contended that, on
account of differences between the partners, she issued a
notice dated 20.03.2024 dissolving the partnership, which was
served on the first defendant on 22.03.2024. According to her,
the firm continued to exist for the purpose of winding up its
affairs and the rights relating to its goodwill and trade name
were yet to be determined. She alleged that the first
defendant, along with the second defendant, had started
another business under the name "The Children’s Corner",
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
using the goodwill and stock of the erstwhile firm and thereby
misleading its customers. It was claimed that the old business
had earned substantial goodwill over the years and had an
average annual turnover of approximately Rs.5.2 crores. On
these allegations, the plaintiffs instituted Com.O.S.
No.152/2026 seeking a decree of permanent injunction against
the defendants.
(ii) Defence of the defendants:
5. The defendants resisted the suit contending that
the business under the name " Children’s Corner " was
established by late Narayana T. Rai and his wife, the first
defendant, Smt. Yashoda N. Rai. It was specifically contended
that the first defendant was the original proprietor of the
business and had been associated with its establishment and
conduct from the beginning. The business was a family
concern. The subsequent partnership deeds and reconstitutions
were only arrangements made amongst the family members to
facilitate its continued conduct. The first defendant had never
relinquished her association with the business or her right to
use its name. Therefore, according to the defendants, the
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
second plaintiff could not claim exclusive ownership of the
goodwill or trade name of the erstwhile concern.
6. It was further contended that, following the
dissolution notice dated 20.03.2024, disputes concerning the
dissolution, accounts, assets and goodwill of the firm were
referred to arbitration in A.C.No.644/2024. The defendants
asserted that the first defendant and the second defendant
thereafter constituted a new registered partnership under a
deed dated 15.04.2024, carrying on business under the name
The Children’s Corner. They also relied upon the earlier
proceedings in A.A. No.6/2024, wherein the plaintiffs' request
for injunction had been rejected on 10.09.2024, and the
proceedings in Com.O.S. No.284/2024. It was their specific
case that the present suit was another attempt to secure
substantially the same relief, without disclosing the earlier
proceedings and without establishing any exclusive right in
favour of the plaintiffs.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
(iii) Application under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC
and objections:
7. Along with the suit, the plaintiffs filed an application
under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of CPC seeking temporary
injunction restraining the defendants, their men and agents
from selling readymade garments or carrying on any business
in the plaint 'A' schedule premises, at Inland Galore,
Kankanady, Mangaluru, or at any other place within the
territorial jurisdiction of the Court, either under the name " The
Children’s Corner " or under any other name phonetically,
pictorially or otherwise similar to Children’s Corner. The
application was supported by the affidavit of the second plaintiff
reiterating the allegations of appropriation of stock, use of the
trade name and exploitation of the alleged goodwill of the
erstwhile firm.
8. The defendants filed detailed objections denying
these allegations. They contended that the goodwill and the
ownership of the trade name were themselves matters pending
adjudication before the sole Arbitrator in A.C. No.644/2024;
that the original firm had been dissolved on 20.03.2024; that
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
the earlier injunction application in A.A.No.6/2024 had already
been rejected on 10.09.2024; and that the plaintiffs had
suppressed these material facts. They also pointed out that the
present suit was filed without seeking damages, despite the
alleged injury being capable of monetary assessment, and that
the plaintiffs had not established any exclusive right over the
trade name or goodwill.
(iv) Order on the application under Order XXXIX Rules 1
and 2 CPC:
9. The Commercial Court, by order dated 30.04.2026,
had initially granted an ad interim ex parte order of temporary
injunction restraining the defendants from using the name "The
Children’s Corner", which was considered similar to the name
"Children’s Corner". The defendants challenged the said order
before this Court in W.P.No.16621/2026 (GM-CPC). By order
dated 08.06.2026, this Court directed the Commercial Court to
dispose of the injunction application within thirty days.
Thereafter, upon appearance, the defendants sought vacation
of the interim order and contested the application on merits.
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
10. The Commercial Court, by the impugned order
dated 21.07.2026, allowed the plaintiffs' application under
Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC and made the ex parte
injunction dated 30.04.2026 absolute until disposal of the suit
or until further orders. The Court proceeded on the footing that
the original business had acquired goodwill under the name
" Children’s Corner ", that the defendants had subsequently
adopted a deceptively similar name and that continued use of
such name would cause irreparable injury to the plaintiffs. It
also observed that the issue relating to ownership of the
goodwill and trade name was pending before the Arbitrator, but
proceeded on the assumption that the plaintiffs would
ultimately succeed in establishing their right.
(v) Grounds of appeal:
11. Aggrieved by the order dated 21.07.2026, the
defendants have preferred the present appeal, principally
contending that the Commercial Court failed to examine the
actual ownership of the business name and goodwill before
granting an equitable relief of injunction. It is urged that the
first defendant was the original proprietor of the business and
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
had continued as a partner through the subsequent
reconstitutions, whereas the second plaintiff cannot claim
exclusive ownership of the trade name merely because she was
also inducted as a partner. The Commercial Court, according to
the defendants, wrongly treated the plaintiffs as prior users
without examining the partnership deeds and the
circumstances in which the business was established. It is
further contended that the dissolution of the old firm, the
constitution of the new partnership on 15.04.2024, the pending
arbitration in A.C.No.644/2024 and the rejection of the earlier
injunction application in A.A.No.6/2024 on 10.09.2024 were
material circumstances which ought to have been considered.
The defendants also contend that the plaintiffs have not
established the essential ingredients of passing off, namely,
goodwill belonging to them, misrepresentation by the
defendants and resulting or likely damage. The finding that the
balance of convenience and irreparable injury were in favour of
the plaintiffs is, therefore, questioned.
(vi) Reasons and analysis:
12. We have heard Sri.K.Chandranath Ariga, learned
counsel appearing for the defendants and Sri.Ajay T., learned
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
counsel on behalf of plaintiffs. We have considered the rival
contentions and perused the material placed before the
Commercial Court. The controversy cannot be decided merely
by comparing the two names, namely, " Children’s Corner " and
" The Children’s Corner ".
13. The questions which required examination, even at
the interlocutory stage, were whether the plaintiffs had
established a prima facie right to protect the goodwill attached
to the business name and whether the defendants were
attempting to pass off their business as that of the plaintiffs?
14. A passing off action is intended to protect the
goodwill of a business against misrepresentation in the course
of trade and the damage resulting, or likely to result, from such
misrepresentation. The essential considerations are goodwill,
misrepresentation and damage. The fact that a trade name is
not registered does not, by itself, defeat a passing off action.
But the person seeking protection must first establish a prima
facie entitlement to the goodwill and business reputation which
he or she claims to protect. In the present case, that very
entitlement is seriously in dispute. The business was started by
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
late Narayana T. Rai and the first defendant was its original
proprietor.
15. Thereafter, the business was converted into a
partnership under the deed dated 01.04.1992 and was
subsequently reconstituted on several occasions. The first
defendant continued to be associated with the business. These
circumstances could not have been brushed aside while
determining who had the right to claim the goodwill of the
erstwhile concern. The Commercial Court, however, proceeded
on the assumption that the plaintiffs' firm was the first user and
that the goodwill exclusively belonged to it. Such a conclusion,
at this stage, was not warranted by the material on record.
16. There is another important aspect. The partnership
deed dated 09.11.2018 shows that the first defendant and the
second plaintiff were the partners of the erstwhile firm, with
profit-sharing ratios of 40% and 60% respectively. The firm
was dissolved pursuant to the notice dated 20.03.2024, served
on 22.03.2024. What happened to its assets, liabilities and
goodwill thereafter is a matter which has already been placed
before the learned Arbitrator in A.C.No.644/2024.
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
17. The first defendant's claim that she was the original
proprietor and continued to be a partner cannot be treated as
an insignificant defence. Equally, the second plaintiff's claim to
the goodwill cannot be accepted merely because she was a
partner of the firm. The respective rights of the parties have to
be examined in the light of the partnership deeds and the
consequences of dissolution. The Commercial Court itself
noticed that the ownership and valuation of goodwill, along with
the right to use the trade name " Children’s Corner ", were
matters pending before the Arbitrator.
18. Having noticed this, it was not appropriate to
proceed on the assumption that the plaintiffs would ultimately
become the lawful owners of the goodwill. Further, the earlier
application for injunction in A.A. No.6/2024 had been rejected
by order dated 10.09.2024. Though the subsequent suit in
Com.O.S.No.284/2024 was rejected on the ground of non-
compliance with Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act and
not on merits, the earlier proceedings and the conduct of the
parties were relevant circumstances. The Commercial Court
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
ought to have examined their effect before granting
substantially similar relief once again.
19. More importantly, the plaintiffs have not placed
sufficient material to establish, even prima facie , that the
goodwill of the erstwhile business exclusively vested in them or
that the defendants have made any specific misrepresentation
to the customers so as to make them believe that the business
conducted by the defendants is that of the plaintiffs. The
allegation that the defendants are using the goodwill of the old
firm and misleading its customers remains, at this stage, an
assertion.
20. The claim of an annual turnover of approximately
Rs.5.2 crores, by itself, does not establish the second plaintiff's
exclusive entitlement to the goodwill nor does the mere
similarity in the names conclude the question of passing off
when the parties themselves belong to the same family and
have been associated with the business for several decades.
The first defendant's association with the business from its
inception and her subsequent participation as a partner assume
considerable significance. The plaintiffs have also not set out
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
any specific particulars of customers who were misled or the
manner in which the defendants' use of the name has caused
injury to the plaintiffs' business.
21. The relief of injunction is discretionary, and it
cannot be granted merely on the basis of apprehension when
the very right asserted by the applicant is yet to be established.
The balance of convenience also requires consideration of the
fact that the defendants are carrying on the business under the
new partnership constituted on 15.04.2024. An injunction in
the terms granted would virtually bring the business to a
standstill, even before the rights of the parties concerning the
old firm and its goodwill are adjudicated. In these
circumstances, the plaintiffs have not made out the necessary
prima facie case, balance of convenience or irreparable injury.
The order dated 21.07.2026 passed on I.A.No.2, therefore,
cannot be sustained. Accordingly, we pass the following;
ORDER
(i) The Commercial Appeal is allowed;
(ii) The order dated 21.07.2026 passed by the I
Additional District Judge and Commercial Court, Dakshina
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56230-DB
COMAP No. 416 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010595692026
Kannada, Mangaluru, in Com.O.S. No.152/2026, allowing the
application filed under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC, is
hereby set aside .
(iii) The application filed by the plaintiffs under Order
XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 CPC stands dismissed .
(iv) It is made clear that the observations made herein
are confined to consideration of the interlocutory application
and shall not influence the adjudication of the suit or the
pending arbitration proceedings on their respective merits.
Sd/-
(D K SINGH)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
JUDGE
KNM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 24