H RAMAIAH SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS. vs D S SURYANARAYANA RAO

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008





IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM

REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 95 OF 2008 (DEC)
C/W
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 96 OF 2008 (DEC)

IN RSA No. 95/2008




BETWEEN:



H RAMAIAH,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

SMT. JAYAMMA,
W/O LATE H. RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS.

2. HANUMANTHARAYAPPA,
S/O LATE H. RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS.

3. SMT. SHANTHAMMA,
D/O LATE H. RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
AKKUPETE (MELINA THOTA)
DEVANAHALLY, BANGALORE RURAL DIST.

4. KRISHNAMURTHY,
S/O LATE H. RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS.

5.
SRINIVASA,
S/O LATE H. RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS.




1.






Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



6. MURALIDHARA,
S/O LATE H. RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS.

7. USHA,
D/O LATE H. RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS.

ALL ARE R/AT KOTE BEEDI,
DEVANAHALLI TOWN,
BANGALORE RURAL DIST.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SRI H.N SHASHIDHARA, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI H.S SUHAS, ADVOCATE)
AND:

1. D.S. SURYANARAYANA RAO,
S/O D.R.SRINIVASAMURTHY,
AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS,
R/AT NO.443, 6TH CROSS,
7TH MAIN ROAD, J.P.NAGAR III PHASE,
BANGALORE-78.

2. G RAVI,
S/O GUNDU RAO,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
R/AT KOTE BEEDI,
NEAR VENUGOPALASWAMY TEMPLE,
DEVANAHALLI TOWN,
BANGALORE RURAL DISTRICT.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY R1 & R-2 ARE SERVED AND UNREPRESENTED;
SRI T. SESHAGIRI RAO, ADVOCATE FOR R-3 [NOC];
V/O DATED 15.06.2026, THERE IS NO REQUIREMENT TO
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



BRING THE LR'S OF R1 & R2 ON RECORD, AS R3 IS
ALREADY ON RECORD)

THIS RSA IS FILED U/S. 100 OF CPC AGAINST THE
JUDGEMENT & DECREE DATED 6.10.2007 PASSED IN
R.A.NO.4/2001 ON THE FILE OF THE PRESIDING OFFICER,
FTC-II, BANGALORE RURAL DIST., BANGALORE, DISMISSING
THE APPEAL FILED AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 29.11.2000 PASSED IN O.S.NO.436/89 ON THE FILE OF
THE II ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN), BANGALORE RURAL DIST.,
BANGALORE.

IN RSA NO. 96/2008
BETWEEN:

H RAMAIAH,
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

SMT. JAYAMMA,
W/O LATE H.RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS.

2. HANUMANTHARAYAPPA,
S/O LATE H.RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS.

3. SMT. SHANTHAMMA,
W/O LATE H RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
AKKUPETE (MELINA THOTA),
DEVANAHALLY, BANGALORE RURAL.

4.
KRISHNAMURTHY,
S/O LATE H.RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS.

5.
SRINIVASA,

1.
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



S/O LATE H.RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS.

6. MURALIDHARA,
S/O LATE H.RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS.

7. USHA,
D/O LATE H.RAMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS.

ALL ARE R/AT KOTE BEEDI,
DEVANAHALLI TOWN,
BANGALORE RURAL DISTRICT.
...APPELLANTS
(BY SRI H N SHASHIDHARA, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI H.S SUSHAS, ADVOCATE)
AND:
D S SURYANARAYANA RAO,
S/O D.R.SRINIVASAMURTHY,
AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS,
R/AT NO.443, 6TH CROSS,
7TH MAIN ROAD, J.P.NAGAR III PHASE,
BANGALORE 78.
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI R1 - SERVED & UNREPRESENTED;
SRI T. SESHAGIRI RAO, ADVCOATE FOR R-2 [NOC])
THIS RSA IS FILED U/S. 100 OF CPC AGAINST THE
JUDGEMENT & DECREE DATED 6.10.2007 PASSED IN
R.A.NO.5/01 ON THE FILE OF THE PRESIDING OFFICER,
FTC-II, BANGALORE RURAL DIST., BANGALORE,
DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND FILED AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 29.11.2000 PASSED IN
O.S.NO.203/92 ON THE FILE OF THE II ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



(SR.DN), BANGALORE RURAL DIST., BANGALORE.
THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM

ORAL JUDGMENT
These two Regular Second Appeals arise out of a
common judgment and decree rendered in
O.S.Nos.436/1989 and 203/1992, which came to be
affirmed by the First Appellate Court in R.A.Nos.4/2001
and 5/2001 respectively. Since both the suits were
clubbed and disposed of by a common judgment, and the
appeals arising therefrom were also considered together,
these appeals are taken up for consideration together and
are disposed of by this common judgment.
2. For the sake of convenience and to avoid any
confusion in the narration of facts, the rank of the parties
as assigned to them in O.S.No.436/1989 is adopted
throughout this judgment.
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



3. The plaintiff instituted O.S.No.436/1989
seeking the relief of declaration of title and permanent
injunction in respect of a vacant site measuring 66 yards x
54 yards. The plaintiff traced his title to one Ramappa,
who, according to the plaintiff, had acquired the property
under a registered family partition deed dated 31.03.1904.
Upon the demise of Ramappa, the property devolved upon
his son D. Shankar Rao and, thereafter, upon his children,
namely, D.S. Rajagopala Rao, D.S. Sathyanarayana Rao,
Manjunath and Nagendra. The aforesaid persons, claiming
to be the absolute owners of the property, conveyed the
same in favour of the plaintiff under a registered sale deed
dated 10.11.1975 for a sale consideration of Rs.12,000/-.
4. The plaintiff, on the strength of the aforesaid
registered sale deed, asserted that he had acquired
absolute title and was in lawful possession and enjoyment
of the suit schedule property. He further contended that
his name was duly entered in the municipal property
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



records and that he had been regularly paying property
taxes. Alleging that the defendants, who had succeeded to
the property situated on the western side of the suit
schedule property, were attempting to put up construction
by encroaching upon the property purchased by him and
had also sought sanction of a building plan with an
intention to lay claim over his property, the plaintiff
instituted the suit seeking declaration of title and
consequential relief of permanent injunction.
5. The defendants entered appearance and filed
their written statement, stoutly denying the plaint
averments and disputing the plaintiff’s claim of title and
possession. Their principal defence was with regard to the
identity, extent and measurements of the property claimed
by the plaintiff. Referring to the sketch produced in
support of their defence, the defendants contended that
the property purchased by the plaintiff, though situated on
the eastern side of their property, was abutting Bellary
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



Road, which is a National Highway. According to them, in
the course of road widening, the plaintiff had lost a
substantial portion of the property facing the National
Highway. They, therefore, disputed the extent claimed by
the plaintiff under the sale deed dated 10.11.1975 and
contended that the measurements incorporated in the
plaint schedule did not represent the actual extent
available to the plaintiff.
6. Defendant No.1 also instituted an independent
suit in O.S.No.203/1992, asserting his own title and
possession over the property in dispute and seeking a
decree of permanent injunction against the plaintiff in the
connected suit. Defendant No.1 claimed that the suit
schedule property was ancestral property and that his
father had been allotted the same in a family partition.
7. In the said suit, defendant No.1 reiterated his
specific defence that the plaintiff had already lost a
substantial portion of the property purchased by him,
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



particularly the portion facing Bellary Road, on account of
road widening. It was specifically contended that the
plaintiff had lost nearly 15 feet in the East-West
dimension. While acknowledging that the boundaries
recited in the plaintiff’s sale deed may correspond with the
factual position on the ground, defendant No.1 contended
that the vendors of the plaintiff had purported to convey
the entire extent indicated in the sale deed,
notwithstanding the reduction in the available extent
consequent upon road widening. On this premise,
defendant No.1 disputed the plaintiff’s entitlement to seek
declaration in respect of the entire extent claimed in the
plaint schedule. He asserted that he was in actual physical
possession of the property claimed in his suit and sought
an injunction to protect his possession.
8. Since the rival claims in both the suits
substantially overlapped and involved adjudication of
competing claims of title, identity and possession in
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



respect of the properties situated adjacent to each other,
the Trial Court clubbed both the suits and proceeded to
record common evidence in O.S.No.436/1989. On the
basis of the pleadings, appropriate issues were framed and
the parties were called upon to substantiate their
respective claims by leading oral and documentary
evidence.
9. The plaintiff adduced oral and documentary
evidence in support of his claim of title and possession.
The defendants also entered the witness box and produced
documentary evidence, including the title documents relied
upon by them, to substantiate their independent claim
over the property.
10. Upon appreciation of the oral and documentary
evidence, the Trial Court answered Issue Nos.1 and 2 in
O.S.No.436/1989 in the negative. While answering Issue
No.1 against the plaintiff, the Trial Court held that the
plaintiff had failed to establish his title over the suit
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



schedule property. Consequently, it also held that the
plaintiff had failed to establish his lawful possession and
dismissed the suit in O.S.No.436/1989.
11. On the other hand, while considering the issues
framed in O.S.No.203/1992, the Trial Court answered
Issue Nos.1 and 2 in the affirmative and accepted the
claim of defendant No.1 regarding title and possession.
The Trial Court was particularly influenced by the
discrepancy in the measurements indicated in the
plaintiff’s sale deed and the actual extent available on the
ground. It proceeded on the premise that the schedule
incorporated by the plaintiff encompassed an extent which
was not available to him, having regard to the road
widening and the boundaries recited in the respective title
documents. The Trial Court, therefore, concluded that it
was the plaintiff who was attempting to interfere with the
possession of defendant No.1 and, accordingly, decreed
O.S.No.203/1992 in favour of defendant No.1.
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



12. Aggrieved by the dismissal of his suit in
O.S.No.436/1989 and the decree granted in favour of
defendant No.1 in O.S.No.203/1992, the plaintiff preferred
two independent appeals in R.A.Nos.4/2001 and 5/2001
respectively. The First Appellate Court, after issuing notice
to the respondents and upon hearing the parties,
undertook an independent re-appreciation of the oral and
documentary evidence on record. However, concurring
with the findings recorded by the Trial Court on the
questions of title, identity and possession, the First
Appellate Court proceeded to dismiss both the appeals,
thereby affirming the common judgment and decree of the
Trial Court.
It is against these concurrent findings recorded by
the Courts below that the plaintiff has preferred the
present Regular Second Appeals.
13. RSA No.95/2008 is directed against the
judgment and decree dated 6.10.2007 rendered in
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



R.A.No.4/2001, whereby the First Appellate Court affirmed
the judgment and decree passed in O.S.No.436/1989
dismissing the plaintiff’s suit for declaration and
permanent injunction.
14. The connected appeal, RSA No.96/2008, is
directed against the judgment and decree rendered in
R.A.No.5/2001, whereby the First Appellate Court affirmed
the judgment and decree passed in O.S.No.203/1992,
decreeing the suit instituted by defendant No.1 for
permanent injunction.
15. This Court, vide order dated 03.06.2008, has
admitted both the second appeals on the following
substantial questions of law:
In RSA 95/2008
1) Whether the Courts below failed to appreciate that
there was no dispute over the purchase of the suit
schedule property by the appellants father by way of
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



registered sale deed from respondent No.1 and as such
both the Courts below have wrongly declined to grant
decree of declaration and permanent injunction insofar as
appellants suit schedule property is concerned?
2) Whether the Courts below have failed to
appreciate that the appellants father acquired the suit
schedule property by way of registered sale deed and
same has been evidenced by production of original sale
deed?
3) Whether the Courts below were right in refusing to
grant declaration and injunction insofar as the suit
schedule property in O.S.No.436/89 is concerned when the
respondents did not dispute the sale deed dated
10.11.1975?
In RSA 96/2008
1) Whether the Courts below were right in granting a
decree in favour of the respondent No.1 when there was
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



no dimension specifying in the release deed of 1966 in
st
favour of the 1 respondent?
2) Whether the Courts below were right in refusing to
grant decree of injunction in favour of the appellants in
respect of their suit schedule properties in O.S.No.436/89
when the appellants have not sought any relief in respect
of respondent No.1's property?
3) Whether the Courts below were right in granting
decree in favour of respondent No.1 with even considering
the case of respondent No.1 on merits and only on the
ground that the appellants failed to prove their case?
16. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
plaintiff, assailing the concurrent judgments and decrees
passed by the Courts below, would contend that both the
Courts have committed a serious error in dismissing the
suit instituted by the plaintiff in O.S.No.436/1989. Taking
this Court through the chain of title documents, learned
Senior Counsel would submit that the plaintiff’s claim is
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



founded on a registered sale deed executed in his favour
by persons who had derived title through Ramappa, who,
in turn, had acquired the property under a registered
family partition deed. He would contend that the plaintiff’s
title, having been traced to a registered instrument, could
not have been rejected merely on account of certain
discrepancies or ambiguity in the measurements indicated
in the respective documents.
17. Learned Senior Counsel would further contend
that both the Courts below have failed to advert to and
properly appreciate the material documentary evidence
bearing on the plaintiff’s title. According to him, the
findings recorded by the Trial Court, as affirmed by the
First Appellate Court, on the questions of title and
possession are vitiated by non-consideration of material
evidence and, therefore, suffer from perversity. He would
submit that this Court, having examined the title
documents and the nature of the controversy involved,
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



was justified in formulating the substantial questions of
law at the time of admission. He would accordingly urge
this Court to answer the substantial questions of law in
favour of the plaintiff and grant the reliefs sought in the
suit.
18. Learned Senior Counsel would further submit
that the controversy essentially revolves around the actual
extent of the property remaining with the plaintiff after the
widening of Bellary Road. In that regard, he would seek
reconsideration of the plaintiff’s request for local inspection
to ascertain the actual measurements and the extent of
the property presently available. Placing reliance on the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Haryana Waqf
1
Board v. Shanti Sarup and Others , he would contend
that even at the stage of second appeal, this Court is not
precluded from exercising its powers under Order XXVI
Rule 10-A of the Code of Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (for

1
(2008) 8 SCC 671
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



short "the CPC") and directing an appropriate scientific
investigation or local inspection to ascertain the actual
extent of the property. He would submit that such an
exercise has become necessary since a substantial portion
of the plaintiff’s property is stated to have been lost on
account of the widening of the National Highway.
According to him, without ascertaining the actual extent
available on the ground, the Courts below could not have
rejected the plaintiff’s claim on the basis of discrepancies
in measurements.
19. Per contra, Sri T. Sheshagiri Rao, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents, while supporting
the judgments and decrees passed by both the Courts
below, would contend that the findings recorded therein
are based on a proper appreciation of the oral and
documentary evidence. He would particularly draw the
attention of this Court to the admissions elicited from the
plaintiff in the course of cross-examination. Referring to
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



paragraph 12 of the cross-examination, he would submit
that the plaintiff has unequivocally admitted that the
extent of his property has been substantially reduced on
account of road widening. He would further point out that
the width of Bellary Road, which was comparatively
narrower at the time of the plaintiff’s purchase, has since
been substantially increased. However, he would fairly
submit that the exact width of the road as on the date of
institution of the suit is not ascertainable from the
available evidence.
20. Learned counsel would next draw the attention
of this Court to what, according to him, is a fundamental
inconsistency in the plaintiff’s claim of title. Referring to
the extent indicated in the registered sale deed marked as
Ex.P1, he would contend that although the boundaries
recited therein may broadly correspond with the existing
physical features, the extent mentioned in the document,
if accepted in its entirety, would result in the plaintiff
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



claiming a much larger extent than what his vendors
themselves had acquired under the registered family
partition deed. He would, therefore, contend that the
plaintiff cannot rely upon the boundaries in the sale deed
while disregarding the limitations arising from the extent
of title held by his predecessors-in-title.
21. He would further submit that the plaintiff has
failed to establish the identity and continued existence of
the property claimed by him, particularly after the
widening of Bellary Road. In the absence of cogent
evidence establishing the actual extent available to the
plaintiff and its correlation with the property conveyed
under the sale deed, the Courts below were justified in
declining the relief of declaration and injunction. He would
submit that the First Appellate Court, being the final fact-
finding authority, has independently re-appreciated the
evidence and rightly affirmed the findings recorded by the
Trial Court. Consequently, the substantial questions of law
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



framed in RSA No.95/2008 deserve to be answered
against the plaintiff.
22. Learned counsel would also resist the request
for appointment of a Commissioner at the stage of second
appeal. In that regard, he would submit that a
Commissioner had already been appointed at the instance
of the plaintiff before the Trial Court. Though the
Commissioner had undertaken the exercise of measuring
the property, the plaintiff had allegedly raised objections
and failed to extend necessary cooperation for conducting
the local inspection. Nevertheless, the Commissioner
proceeded with the commission work and submitted a
report, which forms part of the record. He would
emphasise that the plaintiff neither filed objections to the
Commissioner’s report nor chose to cross-examine the
Commissioner. On the contrary, it was the defendant who
subjected the Commissioner to cross-examination. In
these circumstances, learned counsel would contend that
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



the plaintiff cannot, at this belated stage, seek a fresh
exercise of local inspection to overcome the deficiencies in
the evidence already adduced.
23. Heard the learned Senior Counsel and the
learned counsel appearing for the respective parties.
Perused the judgments and decrees of the Courts below,
the pleadings, the oral and documentary evidence and the
material available on record.
FINDINGS ON THE SUBSTANTIAL QUESTIONS OF
LAW FORMULATED IN RSA NO.95/2008
24. Before proceeding to examine the rival
contentions and the substantial questions of law framed in
this appeal, it would be appropriate to advert to the sketch
furnished along with the written synopsis, which is sought
to be relied upon by the parties to demonstrate the
location, boundaries and relative measurements of the
properties in dispute. The said sketch is extracted
hereinbelow:
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008




25. It is not in dispute that the suit schedule
property originally belonged to one Shanbhog Appaji, who
had two sons, namely, Ramappa and Ramachandrappa. It
is also an admitted position that there was a family
partition and, under the registered partition deed, both
Ramappa and Ramachandrappa were allotted their
respective legitimate shares in the family properties. It is
equally not in dispute that the property claimed by
defendant No.1 is situated immediately to the western side
of the property claimed by the plaintiff. The controversy,
however, arises on account of the subsequent road
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



widening of Bellary-Bengaluru Road, which has admittedly
resulted in utilisation of a portion of the property originally
owned by the family. During the course of trial, the
defendants, by subjecting the plaintiff to cross-
examination, have succeeded in eliciting an important
admission to the effect that, though the plaintiff had
purchased a portion of the property abutting Bellary-
Bengaluru Road, a portion thereof had subsequently been
lost on account of road widening. Thus, the plaintiff was
conscious of the fact that a portion of the property
purchased by him had been utilised for road widening.
Notwithstanding such admitted factual position, the
plaintiff did not take steps to have the property surveyed
so as to ascertain the exact extent of land remaining in his
possession after the road widening.
26. It is significant to note that the defendants had
consistently taken this specific defence in
O.S.No.436/1989 and had reiterated the same in the
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



independent suit instituted by defendant No.1 in
O.S.No.203/1992. The defendants specifically asserted
that the plaintiff had lost a substantial portion of the
property abutting the National Highway and that the
extent claimed by him in the plaint schedule did not
correspond with the extent actually available on the
ground. The defendants have, in fact, succeeded in
eliciting this material admission from the plaintiff in the
course of his cross-examination.
27. The boundaries indicated in the plaintiff’s title
deed and the pleadings in the connected suit acknowledge
the existence of the defendants’ property on the western
side. However, the crucial question that arises for
consideration is whether, in the peculiar facts and
circumstances of the present case, the plaintiff could have
maintained a comprehensive suit for declaration of title
and consequential relief of permanent injunction without
first ascertaining the actual extent of the property retained
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



by him after a portion thereof was utilised for road
widening.
28. This Court is of the view that where a plaintiff
institutes a comprehensive suit seeking declaration of title
coupled with consequential relief of permanent injunction,
the burden rests squarely upon him to establish not only
his title but also the identity of the property in respect of
which such declaration is sought. Where the very extent
and identity of the property are seriously disputed,
particularly on account of a subsequent event such as road
widening, the plaintiff cannot seek a declaration in respect
of the entire extent originally acquired without establishing
the extent that continues to remain identifiable and
available to him.
29. In this context, the plaintiff cannot seek to
overcome the deficiencies in his pleadings and evidence by
invoking Order XXVI Rule 10-A of CPC. The controversy in
the present case essentially concerns identification,
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



measurement and demarcation of the property claimed by
the plaintiff and not any scientific investigation
contemplated under the said provision. It is, however,
relevant to note that the Trial Court, at the instance of the
plaintiff himself, entertained an application seeking
appointment of a Court Commissioner and permitted local
inspection. What is rather intriguing is that the plaintiff, at
whose instance the Commissioner came to be appointed,
seriously objected to the inspection when the
Commissioner attempted to undertake the exercise of
measurement. Notwithstanding such resistance, the
Commissioner proceeded with the inspection and
submitted a report before the Trial Court.
30. It is also relevant that the plaintiff did not file
any objections to the Commissioner’s report nor did he
choose to cross-examine the Commissioner. On the
contrary, it was the defendants who subjected the
Commissioner to cross-examination. Though this Court
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



does not consider it necessary to rest its conclusions on
the contents of the Commissioner’s report, the aforesaid
circumstances are relevant in appreciating the conduct of
the parties and the nature of the controversy that was
before the Trial Court.
31. The question that nevertheless requires
examination is whether the concurrent findings recorded
by both the Courts below, while dismissing
O.S.No.436/1989, suffer from any perversity or material
irregularity warranting interference under Section 100 of
CPC.
32. It is a settled principle that a litigant who
approaches the Court seeking a comprehensive decree of
declaration of title and consequential injunction must
succeed on the strength of his own title and evidence. The
plaintiff is required to establish his title as well as the
identity and possession of the property as on the date of
institution of the suit. The production of a registered sale
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



deed, by itself, may establish the source of title, but where
the extent and identity of the property conveyed under
such instrument are seriously disputed, the plaintiff must
place sufficient material before the Court to correlate the
property described in the title document with the property
actually available on the ground.
33. In the present case, the plaintiff has admitted
that a portion of the property originally purchased by him
was utilised by the local authorities for widening of the
existing National Highway. It is not his case that he had
undertaken any exercise to ascertain the precise extent so
utilised or the extent that continued to remain in his
possession. In such circumstances, the plaintiff could not
have maintained a suit seeking declaration of title and
consequential injunction in respect of the entire extent
originally held by the family of the propositus, Shanbhog
Appaji, without first establishing the actual extent that
remained with him.
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



34. It is precisely in this factual backdrop that both
the Courts below have examined the discrepancy between
the extent indicated in the plaintiff’s sale deed and the
extent actually available on the ground, particularly in the
light of the admissions elicited from the plaintiff, who was
examined as P.W.1. The Courts below have concurrently
concluded that the plaintiff failed to establish the precise
identity and extent of the property in respect of which he
sought declaration and injunction.
35. This Court is unable to find any perversity in the
aforesaid findings. Though this Court, while admitting the
appeal, formulated substantial questions of law touching
upon the plaintiff’s claim of title on the strength of the
registered sale deed, the mere production of title
documents, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the
present case, would not automatically entitle the plaintiff
to a decree of declaration in respect of an unidentified or
unascertained extent of land. The plaintiff was required to
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



establish the precise extent of land that continued to
belong to him after the alleged utilisation of a portion
thereof for road widening.
36. Had the plaintiff undertaken a proper survey
and established the exact extent retained by him, and
thereafter restricted his claim to such identifiable extent,
the controversy regarding the identity and measurements
of the property could have been examined on a more
precise factual foundation. Instead, the plaintiff has
chosen to assert a claim over the entire extent indicated in
his sale deed, notwithstanding the admitted reduction in
the available extent and the specific defence of the
defendants that such claim overlaps with their property.
37. The conduct of the plaintiff in asserting a claim
over an extent which, on his own admission, has
undergone substantial reduction, particularly when the
defendants’ property is situated immediately to the
western side, assumes significance. The Courts below have
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



taken note of these circumstances and have declined to
grant the relief of declaration and consequential injunction.
This Court finds no infirmity in the approach adopted by
the Courts below.
38. Accordingly, this Court is of the considered view
that the findings recorded by both the Courts below do not
suffer from perversity, non-consideration of material
evidence or any error warranting interference in the
present second appeal. The substantial questions of law
No.(i) and (ii) formulated in RSA No.95/2008 are
accordingly answered in the negative and substantial
question of law No.(iii) is answered in the affirmative.
FINDINGS ON THE SUBSTANTIAL QUESTIONS OF
LAW IN RSA NO.96/2008
39. The claim of defendant No.1 in
O.S.No.203/1992 stands on an independent footing.
Defendant No.1 belongs to the family of the original
owner, Shanbhog Appaji, and traces his title through the
registered family partition deed of the year 1904. His claim
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



is founded on the allotment made in the family partition
and the subsequent devolution of title. The Courts below,
upon examining the registered partition deed, the
pleadings and the documentary evidence, have accepted
the claim of defendant No.1 over the property described in
the schedule to O.S.No.203/1992.
40. It is relevant to note that the plaintiff, in
O.S.No.436/1989, has himself acknowledged the existence
of the defendants’ property on the western side of the
property claimed by him. The boundaries recited in the
plaintiff’s title document, when read along with the
registered partition deed relied upon by defendant No.1,
lend support to the latter’s claim regarding the location
and identity of his property.
41. The findings recorded by both the Courts below
are not founded merely on the failure of the plaintiff to
establish his own title. On the contrary, the Courts have
independently examined the title documents relied upon
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



by defendant No.1, particularly the registered family
partition deed, and have considered the same in the
context of the boundaries and the admissions emerging
from the pleadings and evidence in O.S.No.436/1989.
42. The material discrepancy in the plaintiff’s claim
assumes significance even while examining the relief
sought by defendant No.1. Though the plaintiff relies upon
the boundaries recited in his sale deed, the extent claimed
by him, when compared with the extent available to his
predecessors-in-title under the registered partition deed,
indicates that the plaintiff is asserting a claim beyond the
extent that could have been conveyed to him by his
vendors. Such an assertion, particularly when the property
of defendant No.1 is situated immediately to the western
side, has a direct bearing on the latter’s apprehension of
interference with his possession.
43. In these circumstances, the Courts below were
justified in examining whether the plaintiff, by asserting a
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



claim over the entire extent indicated in his sale deed, was
attempting to extend his claim beyond the property
actually conveyed to him and thereby interfering with the
possession of defendant No.1. The findings recorded in
this regard are supported by the registered title
documents, the boundaries recited therein and the
admissions elicited during the course of trial.
44. It is also necessary to bear in mind that the
First Appellate Court, while affirming the decree passed in
O.S.No.203/1992, has independently re-appreciated the
oral and documentary evidence and concurred with the
findings recorded by the Trial Court. The concurrent
findings regarding the title and possession of defendant
No.1 are supported by the material available on record
and cannot be characterised as perverse or as findings
based merely on the failure of the plaintiff to establish his
own case.
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



45. Consequently, this Court finds no ground to
interfere with the decree passed in O.S.No.203/1992 and
affirmed in R.A.No.5/2001. The substantial questions of
law formulated in RSA No.96/2008 are accordingly
answered in the affirmative and against the
plaintiff/appellant.
46. For the foregoing reasons and in view of the
answers recorded to the substantial questions of law, both
the Regular Second Appeals fail and are liable to be
dismissed. Accordingly, this Court proceeds to pass the
following:
ORDER
(i) The Appeals are dismissed ;
(ii) The judgments and decrees passed by the
Courts below in O.S.Nos.436/1989 and 203/1992,
as affirmed in R.A.Nos.4/2001 and 5/2001
respectively, stand confirmed.
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



(iii) However, it is made clear that the concurrent
findings recorded by the Courts below in
O.S.No.436/1989 and the dismissal of RSA
No.95/2008 shall not preclude the plaintiff from
getting the property claimed by him duly surveyed
and measured through the competent survey
authorities, provided such exercise is undertaken
without encroaching upon or laying any claim over
the property belonging to defendant No.1, as
described in the schedule to O.S.No.203/1992.
(iv) In the event the plaintiff, upon such survey,
is able to ascertain the precise extent of land
lawfully retained by him, he shall be at liberty to
approach the competent municipal authorities
seeking appropriate rectification of the municipal
property records or issuance of a property extract
reflecting the actual extent available to him. If any
portion of the property has been utilised or
acquired for road widening, the plaintiff shall also
be at liberty to pursue such remedies as may be
available to him in law before the competent
authorities.
(v) It is made clear that the aforesaid liberty
shall not be construed as conferring any right
Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026

- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62727
RSA No. 95 of 2008
C/W RSA No. 96 of 2008


CNR: KAHC010171352008



upon the plaintiff over the property decreed in
favour of defendant No.1 in O.S.No.203/1992, nor
shall it entitle the plaintiff to reopen the findings
recorded in the present proceedings. All such
remedies, if otherwise available, shall be worked
out strictly in accordance with law excluding
Defendant No.1‘s property.

Digitally signed by Justice
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
19/11/2026
(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE



CA/ALB
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 1