Adalat Yadav Etc. vs The State Of Bihar

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 403
REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION


CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. 1788-1789 OF 2019


ADALAT YADAV ETC. …APPELLANT(S)



VERSUS


THE STATE OF BIHAR …RESPONDENT(S)


J U D G M E N T

SANJAY KAROL J.,
1. The appellant-convicts before us are the father and son,
namely Adalat Yadav and Anirudh Yadav. Criminal Appeal No.
1788 of 2019 has been filed by Adalat Yadav, and Criminal
Appeal No. 1789 of 2019 has been filed by Anirudh Yadav. Both
th
challenging the common judgment dated 4 February 2017
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
SOURAV PAL
passed in Criminal Appeal (DB)) No. 110 of 2012 and 79 of 2012
Date: 2026.04.22
16:08:13 IST
Reason:
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 1 of 18

respectively, whereby the Division Bench, has confirmed finding
of conviction and sentence awarded by the Additional Sessions
1
Fast Track Court-IV Begusarai in terms of judgment dated
22.11.2011 passed in Sessions Trial No. 251 of 2019 sentencing
them to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for life under Section
2
302 and 149 read with Section 120B of Indian Penal Code, 1860
and also a fine of Rs.10,000/- and in default of payment of fine
they shall undergo Simple Imprisonment for six months. The
above convicts were further sentenced to undergo Rigorous
Imprisonment for 10 years under Sections 307, 149 of the I.P.C.
read with Section 120B of the I.P.C. with a fine of Rs.5000/- and
in default of payment they shall undergo Simple Imprisonment
for three months. Apart from this, they were also sentenced to
undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for 7 years under Section 27 of
the Arms Act with a further direction to run the sentences
concurrently.
2. The facts giving rise to these appeals, as set out by the
Courts below, are as follows.
th
(i) On 4 December, 2008 while Sunil Yadav @ Sunil
Kumar Yadav (PW-5/complainant) was homebound
from the Begusarai Court along with his brother Ram
Sharan Yadav (deceased), certain persons including

1
‘Trial Court’
2
‘IPC’
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 2 of 18

two appellants/convicts surrounded them upon
reaching the grocery store run by one Suresh Mahto.
A-1 hurled abuses at them and stated that despite
repeated directions/clear warnings given to them by
Girdhari Yadav ( who was also an accused before the
High Court ), against giving depositions in the murder
case on one Mahesh Paswan, the deceased had refused
to heed. He then fired his pistol, hitting the deceased on
his head, making him fall to his death, instantly. A-2
had fired upon the deceased and, thereafter, other
members of the group also opened fired on the
complainant as also one Ganesh and Baidyanath Yadav,
who were walking alongside the deceased and the
complainant. The bullet fired by one Shivji Yadav, hit
the complainant on his leg. A written complaint was
lodged about the incident on the same day, resulting in
registration of FIR Number 222/08 at Police Station
Balia.
(ii) Upon completion of the investigation, charge sheets
th
were filed bearing No.38/09 dated 04 March 2009 and
th
No. 310/09 dated 16 March 2009, respectively. The
Trial Court convicted a total of 4 persons including the
appellant-convicts while acquitting one Ram Balak
Yadav. A perusal of the Trial Court judgment reveals
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 3 of 18

that such a finding has been arrived at upon a
cumulative assessment of the testimonies of all the
witnesses. It has been observed that PW-1 to PW-4
consistently supported the prosecution’s case,
especially to the effect that enmity inter se the parties
th
is germane on the earlier occurrence of violence on 28
November 2003, wherein the appellant-convicts were
involved in an act of indiscriminate firing at the house
of the deceased and also deployment of a bomb there.
This had resulted in the death of the daughter of the
deceased. They had also stated that while the
background of the dispute between the parties was as
alluded to above, the primary reason therefor was that
the deceased was a witness against Girdhari Yadav. The
learned Trial Judge, after taking note of the alleged
contradictions between the testimonies of the witnesses
as pointed out by the learned counsel for the parties but
overall, termed them to be minor in nature, not
affecting the sanctity of the statements.
(iii) The High Court, in the impugned judgment while
agreeing with the overall conclusion returned by the
Trial Court, differed in its reasoning. According to the
learned Division Bench, PWs-1 to 4 could not be relied
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 4 of 18

upon as eyewitnesses. The relevant discussion is as
under: -
“…It Is true that the evidence of the witnesses is
to be considered in its totality. Furthermore, the
classification of the witnesses have been found
duly identified as wholly reliable, wholly
unreliable, partly reliable as well as partly
unreliable. Generally, the maxim falsus in uno
and falsus in omnibus is not found applicable in
Indian continent. However, when the evidence of
the witnesses suggests at first hand that they
could not be an eye witness to occurrence, then in
that event, their status being inimical as well as
interested, will play an additional role in order to
discredit their evidences. Moreover, when their
evidences are uncorroborated by an independent
witness, then in that event, the same would
require scrutiny. That being so, status of PW-1,
PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4 could not be considered
as an eye witness to occurrence, more particularly
PW-2 and PW-4, who claimed to have joined
company of deceased as well as injured at Balia
Bazar, where they had gone together from their
house before 3.00 p.m., on account of
inconsistencies as well as contradictions at the
first instance itself. In likewise manner, the status
of PW-1 also becomes doubtful in the background
of the fact that he was to purchase household
articles and for that, he had gone to the shop of
Suresh Mahto, which was closed and then,
staying for one and half hour without any activity
could not inspire confidence regarding his
conduct. So far PW-3 is concerned, admittedly, he
happens to be full brother of PW-5, informant and
was also one of the participants of the fray being
fought amongst the parties as well as depicting
presence of 15-20 persons at the P.O. representing
both groups is a circumstance, which could not be
washed away during course of consideration of
individual status of the witnesses vis-à-vis their
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 5 of 18

credibility as an eye witness to the occurrence.
Their presence might have after the occurrence,
as, the P.O. lies in vicinity of the village… ”
(iv) The High Court, proceeding further, confirmed the
conviction of three persons, one Bihari Yadav and the
other two appellant-convicts on the basis of the sole
testimony of the complainant as PW-5. In doing so
reliance was placed on judgment of this Court in Sudip
3
Kumar Sen v. State of W.B. .
(v) It is as such that the appellant - convicts are before us.
3. We have heard Mr. Ashwani Kumar Singh, learned Senior
Counsel for appellant-convicts and Mr. Azmat H. Amanullah,
learned counsel for the State.
4. The prosecution, to establish the guilt of these persons,
examined a total of 10 witnesses. PWs-1 to 5 were allegedly
eyewitnesses, PW-6 and PW-9 were investigating officers, PW-7
and PW-8 were expert witnesses, PW-10 has been generally
categorized as formal witness. The defense led no evidence and,
in their statements, recorded under Section 313 Code of Criminal
4
Procedure, 1973 issued blanket denial for the prosecution’s case
and pleaded false implication.
5. It is a well settled position in law that this Court under
Article 136 of the Constitution of India, does not interfere in

3
(2016) 3 SCC 26
4
‘CrPC’
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 6 of 18

matters having concurrent findings of the Courts below [See:
5
Goverdhan vs State of Chattisgarh , and Ravasaheb v. State of
6
Karnataka ] as such we need not delve into each and every
individual’s testimonies and instead only examine whether the
path adopted by the Courts below is compromised by any
manifest error. Should that be established, only then individual
reappreciation of all the testimonies would be justified.
6. Challenging the findings against the appellant-convicts,
learned senior counsel has raised the following points:
(a) There is a delay in filing the FIR and the same is
tainted as the original version has been suppressed. The
incident, as per the testimonies, is of the evening hours
between 5 and 6 P.M. However, registration of the FIR
though the very same day is at half past 10 in the night.
(b) The place of occurrence of the alleged incident is
not proved. According to the FIR, the place of incident
was near the grocery shop run by one Suresh Mahto.
However, the Investigating Officer, in his testimony has
deposed that place of occurrence was Bhagatpur Pitch
Road, and in his cross examination has admitted that there
is no grocery shop in that vicinity.

5
(2025) 3 SCC 378
6
(2023) 5 SCC 391
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 7 of 18

(c) There is a direct conflict between the medical and
ocular evidence. PW-9 has deposed that the deceased was
shot on his forehead. However, PW-7 Dr. Ashok Kumar Jha,
who has conducted the postmortem concluded that the entry
wounds was on the base of skull and the exit wound was at
the upper base of the nose thereby inverting the fatal injury.
(d) The next point agitated is that material witnesses
such as officer-in-charge of the Balia Police Station, who
received written report and other members of the police
force who were all important witnesses, were not been
examined during the trial, thereby causing prejudice to the
appellant-convicts.
e) Still further, the presence of 4 of the eyewitnesses
i.e. PWs-1 to 4 has been doubted by the High Court.
Cumulatively, it is submitted that all of these factors, viewed on
the whole, are sufficient to cast doubt upon the prosecution’s case
and as such make it fall short of the threshold of beyond
reasonable doubt. Consequently, the convictions of the appellant-
convicts would be rendered shaky and thus fall.
Per contra , Mr. Amanullah would submit that the case of
the prosecution stands entirely proved and none of the grounds
raised by the appellant – convicts, are sufficient enough to make
the conviction doubtful. It has been submitted that the High
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 8 of 18

Court’s reliance on the testimony of the complainant PW-5 is
justified since the testimony of an injured witness has greater
evidentiary value.
In regard to the place of occurrence, it is submitted that
Bhagatpur Pitch Road, has been clearly identified, and it is stated
therein that the house/land of Suresh Mahto is to the west. The
description of spot by the different prosecution witnesses is
different, only with respect to the reference points, but all of them
converse upon the same area.
In reference to the gun shot injury, and the alleged
contradicting statements of PW-5 and PW-7, it is submitted that
the factum of the deceased having been shot on his head is
indisputable as duly corroborated by the medical report and as
such, difference if any is rendered immaterial.
7. In light of the submissions, we now proceed to examine
the matter. Out of the manifold contentions advanced by the
appellant - convicts, the fact that four PWs have been discounted
by the High Court is a major factor. This cannot be faulted since
convictions on the basis of the testimony of a singular eyewitness
is also permissible. After all, evidence on record is to be
measured for quality, not on the basis of quantity. If the
testimony is of ‘ sterling quality ’, resting a conviction thereon
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 9 of 18

would be entirely permissible. Although this position is well
settled, we may for ready reference reiterate the same as follows:
Evidence to be weighed not counted
7
(i) In Lallu Manjhi v. State of Jharkhand , this Court observed:
“10. The law of evidence does not require any particular
number of witnesses to be examined in proof of a given fact.
However, faced with the testimony of a single witness, the
court may classify the oral testimony into three categories,
namely, ( i ) wholly reliable, ( ii ) wholly unreliable, and ( iii )
neither wholly reliable nor wholly unreliable. In the first two
categories there may be no difficulty in accepting or
discarding the testimony of the single witness. The difficulty
arises in the third category of cases. The court has to be
circumspect and has to look for corroboration in material
particulars by reliable testimony, direct or circumstantial,
before acting upon the testimony of a single witness.
(See: Vadivelu Thevar v. State of Madras [AIR 1957 SC
614 : 1957 Cri LJ 1000] .)”

(ii) A bench of three judges in Amar Singh v. State (NCT of
8
Delhi) , held:
“16. …As a general rule the court can and may act on the
testimony of single eyewitness provided he is wholly
reliable. There is no legal impediment in convicting a
person on the sole testimony of a single witness. That is
the logic of Section 134 of the Evidence Act, 1872. But if
there are doubts about the testimony, the courts will insist
on corroboration. It is not the number, the quantity but
quality that is material. The time-honoured principle is that
evidence has to be weighed and not counted. On this

7
(2003) 2 SCC 401
8
(2020) 19 SCC 165
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 10 of 18

principle stands the edifice of Section 134 of the Evidence
Act. The test is whether the evidence has a ring of truth, is
cogent, credible and trustworthy or otherwise [see Sunil
Kumar v. State (NCT of Delhi) [ Sunil Kumar v. State
(NCT of Delhi) , (2003) 11 SCC 367 : 2004 SCC (Cri)
1055] ].”

8. As per the High Court, the testimony of PW-5 is sufficient
enough to make the needle of guilt rest on the appellant -
convicts. In other words, his testimony is unimpeachable or that
it is of sterling quality. What may qualify as sterling quality is
discussed in the following judgments:
Sterling witness
9
(i) In Rai Sandeep v. State (NCT of Delhi) , this Court observed:
“ 22. In our considered opinion, the “sterling witness”
should be of a very high quality and calibre whose
version should, therefore, be unassailable. The court
considering the version of such witness should be in a
position to accept it for its face value without any
hesitation. To test the quality of such a witness, the status
of the witness would be immaterial and what would be
relevant is the truthfulness of the statement made by such
a witness. What would be more relevant would be the
consistency of the statement right from the starting point
till the end, namely, at the time when the witness makes
the initial statement and ultimately before the court. It
should be natural and consistent with the case of the
prosecution qua the accused. There should not be any
prevarication in the version of such a witness. The
witness should be in a position to withstand the cross-

9
(2012) 8 SCC 21
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 11 of 18

examination of any length and howsoever strenuous it
may be and under no circumstance should give room for
any doubt as to the factum of the occurrence, the persons
involved, as well as the sequence of it. Such a version
should have co-relation with each and every one of other
supporting material such as the recoveries made, the
weapons used, the manner of offence committed, the
scientific evidence and the expert opinion. The said
version should consistently match with the version of
every other witness. It can even be stated that it should
be akin to the test applied in the case of circumstantial
evidence where there should not be any missing link in
the chain of circumstances to hold the accused guilty of
the offence alleged against him. Only if the version of
such a witness qualifies the above test as well as all other
such similar tests to be applied, can it be held that such a
witness can be called as a “sterling witness” whose
version can be accepted by the court without any
corroboration and based on which the guilty can be
punished. To be more precise, the version of the said
witness on the core spectrum of the crime should remain
intact while all other attendant materials, namely, oral,
documentary and material objects should match the said
version in material particulars in order to enable the court
trying the offence to rely on the core version to sieve the
other supporting materials for holding the offender guilty
of the charge alleged.”
10
[See also: Ganesan v. State ]
11
(ii) In Naresh v. State of Haryana , it was observed:
“16. As noticed hereinabove, the evidence of the
eyewitness should be of very sterling quality and calibre
and it should not only instil confidence in the court to
accept the same but it should also be a version of such
nature that can be accepted at its face value.”

10
(2020) 10 SCC 573
11
(2023) 10 SCC 134
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 12 of 18

9. The next argument is that there is a delay in filing the FIR
which leads to the doubt of suppression of the original version.
Delay in lodging FIR
(i) A three judge bench of this Court in State of H.P. v. Gian
12
Chand , held:
“12. Delay in lodging the FIR cannot be used as a
ritualistic formula for doubting the prosecution case and
discarding the same solely on the ground of delay in
lodging the first information report. Delay has the effect of
putting the court on its guard to search if any explanation
has been offered for the delay, and if offered, whether it is
satisfactory or not. If the prosecution fails to satisfactorily
explain the delay and there is a possibility of
embellishment in the prosecution version on account of
such delay, the delay would be fatal to the prosecution.
However, if the delay is explained to the satisfaction of the
court, the delay cannot by itself be a ground for
disbelieving and discarding the entire prosecution case…”

13
(ii) In Ravinder Kumar v. State of Punjab , it was
observed:
“ 14. When there is criticism on the ground that FIR in a
case was delayed the court has to look at the reason why
there was such a delay. There can be a variety of genuine
causes for FIR lodgment to get delayed. Rural people
might be ignorant of the need for informing the police of a
crime without any lapse of time. This kind of
unconversantness is not too uncommon among urban
people also. They might not immediately think of going to
the police station. Another possibility is due to lack of
adequate transport facilities for the informers to reach the

12
(2001) 6 SCC 71
13
(2001) 7 SCC 690
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 13 of 18

police station. The third, which is a quite common bearing,
is that the kith and kin of the deceased might take some
appreciable time to regain a certain level of tranquillity of
mind or sedativeness of temper for moving to the police
station for the purpose of furnishing the requisite
information. Yet another cause is, the persons who are
supposed to give such information themselves could be so
physically impaired that the police had to reach them on
getting some nebulous information about the incident.”

14
(iii) In Ramdas v. State of Maharashtra ,
“24. … The proposition is too broadly stated to merit
acceptance. It is no doubt true that mere delay in lodging
the first information report is not necessarily fatal to the
case of the prosecution. However, the fact that the report
was lodged belatedly is a relevant fact of which the court
must take notice. This fact has to be considered in the light
of other facts and circumstances of the case, and in a given
case the court may be satisfied that the delay in lodging the
report has been sufficiently explained. In the light of the
totality of the evidence, the court of fact has to consider
whether the delay in lodging the report adversely affects
the case of the prosecution. That is a matter of appreciation
of evidence. There may be cases where there is direct
evidence to explain the delay. Even in the absence of direct
explanation there may be circumstances appearing on
record which provide a reasonable explanation for the
delay. There are cases where much time is consumed in
taking the injured to the hospital for medical aid and,
therefore, the witnesses find no time to lodge the report
promptly. There may also be cases where on account of
fear and threats, witnesses may avoid going to the police
station immediately. The time of occurrence, the distance
to the police station, mode of conveyance available, are all
factors which have a bearing on the question of delay in
lodging of the report. It is also possible to conceive of
cases where the victim and the members of his or her
family belong to such a strata of society that they may not

14
(2007) 2 SCC 170
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 14 of 18

even be aware of their right to report the matter to the
police and seek legal action, nor was any such advice
available to them. …In the ultimate analysis, what is the
effect of delay in lodging the report with the police is a
matter of appreciation of evidence, and the court must
consider the delay in the background of the facts and
circumstances of each case. Different cases have different
facts and it is the totality of evidence and the impact that it
has on the mind of the court that is important. No
straitjacket formula can be evolved in such matters, and
each case must rest on its own facts. It is settled law that
however similar the circumstances, facts in one case
cannot be used as a precedent to determine the conclusion
on the facts in another. (See Pandurang v. State of
Hyderabad [(1955) 1 SCR 1083 : AIR 1955 SC 216] .)
Thus mere delay in lodging of the report may not by itself
be fatal to the case of the prosecution, but the delay has to
be considered in the background of the facts and
circumstances in each case and is a matter of appreciation
of evidence by the court of fact.”

15
(iv) Ashok Kumar Chaudhary v. State of Bihar ,
“16. It is trite that mere delay in lodging the first
information report is not by itself fatal to the case of the
prosecution. Nevertheless, it is a relevant factor of which
the court is obliged to take notice and examine whether
any explanation for the delay has been offered and if
offered, whether it is satisfactory or not. If no satisfactory
explanation is forthcoming, an adverse inference may be
drawn against the prosecution. However, in the event, the
delay is properly and satisfactorily explained; the
prosecution case cannot be thrown out merely on the
ground of delay in lodging the FIR. Obviously, the
explanation has to be considered in the light of the totality
of the facts and circumstances of the case.”

15
(2008) 12 SCC 173
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 15 of 18

10. Keeping in view the above judgments, no fault can be
found in the impugned judgment on the count of reliance on a
single witness. The alleged delay in FIR as contended by the
appellant-convicts, too, would not weaken the prosecution case.
11. In so far as the alleged conflict between eyewitness
testimony and medical evidence is concerned, we may only
observe that the same is difficult to comprehend. The relevant
portion of the statement of PW-5 and PW-7 (Dr. Ashok Kumar
Jha) is as follows:
PW-5:
“…Adalat Yadav instigated all accused that kill all these
and dictating it, he shot in Ram Sharan Yadav’s head with
the pistol carrying in his hand; in consequence, he fell
down and died. Annirudh Yadav also fired one bullet at
Ram Sharan Yadav. After it, Bihari Yadav, Vijay Yadav,
Shivji Yadav fired on us with the intention of causing death
to me, Ganesh and Baijnath Yadav. The bullet fired by
Shivji Yadav hit below my right knee…”
PW-7:
“…Entry of the wound of deceased was on the back of the
skull and exit of the wound in just as upper base of the
nose.”

In our view, both these testimonies are consistent for both, albeit
in different terms, say that the deceased was shot on his head.
That apart, if it was the case that there had been some
contradictions between the testimonies, the generally applicable
rule that eyewitness testimony would be superior to the medical
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 16 of 18

opinion which is in the nature of expert testimony, would be
applicable. Since PW-5 has withstood the test of cross-
examination is an undisputed eyewitness to the incident and is
16
also an injured witness , his testimony would be at a higher
pedestal. As such, this factor too would count towards the guilt
of the appellant - convicts.
12. One additional point raised was the absence of any of the
villagers to give statements about the incident, i.e., the lack of
17
independent witnesses . It is well settled that the same does
not compromise the case of the prosecution. In this case
particularly the Court cannot lose sight of societal realities
where, allegedly at the command of an ill-reputed person,
witness in his trial had been gunned down. Hesitation on the
part of the common person is but natural, not wanting to be
entangled, in what was clearly unpleasant and thorny business.
13. In so far as the second appellant - convict is concerned,
the sterling testimony of PW-5 clearly establishes that he had
also fired the weapon. He was part of the group that had
surrounded PW-5 and the deceased and clearly possessed the
intention to kill. It was only a matter of luck that the said bullet

16
Baljinder Singh v. State of Punjab, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2622; Balu Sudam Khalde v.
State of Maharashtra, (2023) 13 SCC 365
17
Manjit Singh v. State of Punjab, (2019) 8 SCC 529; Rizwan Khan v. State of
Chhattisgarh, (2020) 9 SCC 627; Mohd. Naushad v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2024) 12 SCC
494
Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 17 of 18

did not hit the intended target. He has been correctly therefore,
sentenced under Section 307IPC.
14. Viewed on the whole, as above, the appeals fail and are
accordingly dismissed.
Pending application(s) if any shall stand closed.

……………………….……………………..J.
(SANJAY KAROL)




……………………………….………..…….J.
(NONGMEIKAPAM KOTISWAR SINGH)

New Delhi;
April 22, 2026



Crl.Appeal No.1788-1789 of 2019 Page 18 of 18