JOY KRISHNA NAG @ JOY KUMAR NAG @ ROHIT vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
1
WPA 20950 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Debangsu Basak
And
The Hon’ble Justice Aryak Dutt
WPA 20950 of 2018
Joy Krishna Nag @ Joy Kumar Nag @ Rohit
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
.
For the Petitioner : Mr. Abhimanyu Banerjee, Advocate
Mr. Arnab Saha, Advocate
Mr. Abdul Nooman, Advocate
For the State : Mr. Dibashis Basu, Ld. AGP
Ms. Sneha Dutta, Advocate
Mr. Purnendu Das, Advocate
Hearing concluded & Judgment on : October 5, 2026
DEBANGSU BASAK, J.:-
1. In this habeas corpus writ petition, the writ petitioner claims that he was
under illegal detention for the period from August 6, 2018 to October 5,
2018.
2. Learned Advocate appearing for the writ petitioner submits that, the writ
petitioner was entangled in three criminal cases being Kumargram PS Case
2
WPA 20950 of 2018
No.101/18, 103/18 and 141/18. He submits that, the writ petitioner
secured bails in respect of the three criminal cases. Writ petitioner was
required to be released from custody on August 6, 2018. However, the writ
petitioner was ultimately released on October 5, 2018.
3. Learned Advocate appearing for the writ petitioner submits that, at that
material point of time, the writ petitioner was earning about Rs.600/- per
day as a tea garden worker. At the basic minimum, he submits that, the
writ petitioner should be compensated not only for the loss of employment
but also for illegal detention and mental harassment and agony. He
submits that, the writ petitioner prays for a sum of Rs.20 lakhs as
compensation. He submits that, the quantum of compensation may be
decided by the Court.
4. Learned Additional Government Pleader, on instructions, submits that,
there is hardly any explanation for the period of detention. He submits
that, a MR case was started on August 14, 2018. In such MR Case, the
custody of the writ petitioner was required. Therefore, the writ petitioner
was kept in the custody till his release on October 5, 2018.
5. We find from the records that, three criminal cases were instituted against
the writ petitioner being Kumargram PS Case No.101/18, 103/18 and
141/18. In respect of these police cases, the writ petitioner secured orders
of bail. Writ petitioner furnished surety in terms of the orders granting
bail.
3
WPA 20950 of 2018
6. There was an allegation of violation of the bond executed to secure that no
breach of peace in the locality is caused by the writ petitioner. On the
basis of such allegation, MR Case No.780 of 2018 was instituted. In such
MR Case, an order dated August 6, 2018 was passed. Thereafter, a
subsequent order in such MR Case No.780 of 2018 dated August 14, 2018
was passed.
7. On perusal of those two orders in the MR case, we are not in a position to
return a finding that the writ petitioner was required to be kept in custody
beyond the period of the writ petitioner furnishing his bail in the three
police cases.
8. The writ petitioner was kept in custody to be produced before the
jurisdictional Court as sought to be contended on behalf of the State in
respect of MR Case No.780 of 2018.
9. The plea of the State that, the custody of the writ petitioner was required
for the purpose of producing the writ petitioner in respect of MR Case
No.780 of 2018 is not found satisfactory. Orders passed therein did not
require the writ petitioner to be kept in custody.
10. In such circumstances, we hold the period of detention of the writ
petitioner between August 6, 2018 and October 5, 2018 was not
sanctioned by law. The writ petitioner, therefore, is entitled to
compensation for such period.
4
WPA 20950 of 2018
11. On the aspect of the quantum of compensation, the writ petitioner claims
Rs.20 lakhs. However, the writ petitioner is unable to furnish adequate
materials to sustain such a claim.
12. As noted above, the writ petitioner was working as a tea garden worker and
was earning about Rs.600/- per day. The period of illegal detention is 60
days. Multiplying Rs.600/- per day for 60 days, the amount is
Rs.36,000/-.
13. The writ petitioner is entitled to be compensated for mental agony as also
for his plight of illegal detention. We venture to fix a compensation of Rs.5
lakhs in addition to the loss of employment. In aggregate, therefore, we
award a sum of Rs.5,36,000/- as compensation to be paid by the State to
the writ petitioner for the period of illegal detention that the writ petitioner
suffered. Such compensation be paid within four weeks from date.
14. WPA 20950 of 2018 is disposed of .
(Debangsu Basak, J.)
15. I agree.
(Aryak Dutt, J.)
(AD)
ABHIJIT
DAS
Digitally signed by
ABHIJIT DAS
Date: 2026.10.05
17:31:42 +05'30'