SANJEEV KUMAR vs SUSHILA DEVI AND OTHERS
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
2026:HHC:49134
High Court of H.P.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
FAO (MVA) No.5 of 2021
Date of Decision: 06.11.2026
______________________________________________________________
Sanjeev Kumar …….Appellant
Versus
Smt. Sushila Devi and Others ….Respondents
______________________________________________________________
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Yogesh Jaswal, Judge.
1
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
For the appellant: Mr. Parkash Sharma, Advocate.
For the respondents : Mr. Abhishek Verma, Advocate, for
respondent No.1.
Mr. Reham Tullah, Advocate, vice
Mr. Karan Kapoor, Advocate, for
respondent No.2 .
Mr. Bimal Gupta, Senior Advocate,
with Mr. Trigun Singh Negi,
Advocate, for respondent No.3 .
______________________________________________________________
Yogesh Jaswal, Judge : (oral)
The present appeal is directed against the award
dated 31.10.2020, passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal-II, Sirmaur District at Nahan, H.P. (hereinafter
referred to as 'learned MACT') , in M.A.C. Petition No.58-N/2 of
2014, vide which the claim petition filed by respondent No.1
(petitioner before the learned MACT) was partly allowed and
compensation of ₹ 43,683/- along with interest @9% per annum
1
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-2-
High Court of H.P.
from the date of filing of the petition till realization of the amount
was awarded in favour of respondent No.1 and the liability to
satisfy the award was fastened upon the appellant (respondent
No.1 before the learned MACT). (Parties shall hereinafter be
referred to in the same manner as they were arrayed before the
learned MACT for convenience).
2. Briefly stated, the facts giving rise to the present
appeal are that the petitioner filed a claim petition under Section
166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, (hereinafter referred to
as ‘the Act’) seeking compensation of ₹ 3,00,000/- for the
injuries sustained by her in a motor vehicle accident that took
place on 26.07.2012 at about 04:25 p.m. near Vishwa Karma
Chowk, Devi Nagar, Paonta Sahib, District Sirmaur, H.P. It was
asserted that on the said day and time, the petitioner was
travelling on a scooter bearing registration No.HR-02G-0162,
which was being driven by her husband Suresh Kumar, along
with their minor son. When they reached near Vishwa Karma
Chowk, a motorcycle bearing registration No.HP-17A-3414,
driven by respondent No.2 in a rash and negligent manner, came
from the Housing Board Colony side and hit the scooter. As a
consequence of the collision, the scooter along with its riders fell
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-3-
High Court of H.P.
on the road and sustained multiple severe injuries. FIR
No.274/2012 dated 26.07.2012 for the commission of offences
punishable under Sections 279, 337 and 338 of the Indian Penal
Code was registered against respondent No.2 at Police Station
Paonta Sahib. The petitioner was initially taken to Civil Hospital,
Paonta Sahib, and thereafter treated at Puran Hospital, Paonta
Sahib, where she remained admitted. It was averred that the
petitioner was a housewife doing agricultural work, earning
₹ 10,000/- per month, and had incurred substantial expenditure
on medical treatment, special diet, attendants and
transportation. Hence, the petition was filed seeking
compensation.
3. The petition was resisted by respondent No.1
(appellant herein) by filing a reply, wherein it was asserted that
the accident was caused due to the rash and negligent driving
of the husband of the petitioner himself. It was denied that
respondent No.2 drove the motorcycle rashly or negligently.
Respondent No.1 specifically pleaded that he had sold the
motorcycle bearing No.HP-17A-3414 to respondent No.3
(Sanjeev Kumar S/O Sh. Bhagmal) on 03.09.2008 and had no
concern with the vehicle thereafter.
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-4-
High Court of H.P.
4. Respondent No.2 filed a separate reply denying the
averments made in the petition and asserted that the husband
of the petitioner himself was driving the scooter rashly and
negligently and caused the accident, and that a false case was
registered by the Police.
5. Respondent No.3 also filed a separate reply denying
that any accident took place on 26.07.2012 with motorcycle
No.HP-17A-3414. It was admitted that the motorcycle was
owned and possessed by respondent No.1, but asserted that the
same was never involved in any accident. It was further stated
that the husband of the petitioner was a disabled person who
lost control over his scooter, causing the fall and resultant
injuries.
6. The learned MACT framed the following issues on
22.07.2017:
1. Whether the petitioner received injuries on account of rash
and negligent driving of offending vehicle i.e. motorcycle
bearing No.HP-17A-3414 by respondent No.2 at place
Vishwa Karma Chowk, Paonta Sahib, on 26.07.2012 at
about 4:25 p.m., as alleged?...OPP
2. If issue No.1 is proved in affirmative, to what amount of
compensation the petitioner is entitled to and from
whom?...OPP
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-5-
High Court of H.P.
3. Whether the petition is not maintainable in the present
form?...OPR-1
4. Whether the petitioner has not approached the court with
clean hands and has suppressed the truth, as
alleged?...OPR-1
5. Whether the accident took place due to rash and negligent
driving of the scooter by the petitioner, as alleged?...OPR-3
6. Relief.
7. The parties led oral and documentary evidence in
support of their respective claims. The petitioner examined
herself as PW-1 and tendered in evidence her affidavit Ext.PW-
1/A, copy of FIR Ext.PW-1/B, MLC Ext.PW-1/C, treatment
records Ext.PW-1/D and Ext.PW-1/E, discharge slip Ext.PW-
1/F and medical bills Ext.P1 to Ext.P34. Respondent No.3
appeared as RW-1 and tendered his affidavit Ext.RW-1/A and
screening report Ext.RW-1/B. RW-2 Sh. Dinesh Tomar,
Advocate, and RW-3 Sh. Arun Grover, Advocate, were examined
with regard to affidavits concerning the alleged sale and
purchase of the motorcycle. Respondent No.1 stepped into the
witness box as RW-4 and tendered his affidavit Ext.RW-4/A.
8. The learned MACT held that the accident occurred
due to the rash and negligent driving of motorcycle No.HP-17A-
3414 by respondent No.2. Taking into consideration the medical
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-6-
High Court of H.P.
bills, hospitalization and injuries, the learned MACT awarded a
total compensation of ₹ 43,683/- under various heads, along
with interest @ 9% per annum from the date of filing of the
petition till realization. On the question of liability, the learned
MACT held that as per the screening report of the registering
authority, respondent No.1 continued to be the registered owner
of the motorcycle. Relying upon the binding decisions of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Naveen Kumar v. Vijay Kumar and
others , (2018) 3 SCC 1 , and Prakash Chand Daga v. Saveta
Sharma and others , (2019) 2 SCC 747 , the learned MACT
fastened the liability to satisfy the award upon respondent No.1.
Issues No.1 and No.2 were answered in the affirmative, and
issues No.3 to No.5 were answered in the negative.
9. Feeling aggrieved by the award passed by the learned
MACT, respondent No.1 has preferred the instant appeal. It has
been asserted in the grounds of appeal that the learned MACT
erred in fastening liability upon the appellant when he had
already sold motorcycle bearing No.HP-17A-3414 to respondent
No.3 on 03.09.2008 vide affidavit Ext.RW-3/A and delivered its
possession. It was further asserted that respondent No.3 had
subsequently transferred the vehicle to one Palden vide
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-7-
High Court of H.P.
document Ext.RW-2/A, which was duly proved by RW-2 and
RW-3. Relying upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in HDFC Bank Ltd. v. Reshma and others , (2015) 3 SCC 679 ,
the appellant contended that the registered owner cannot be
held liable if the vehicle was not in his possession and control.
Challenge was also laid to the compensation awarded under the
heads of medical expenses, pain and suffering, attendant
charges and special diet, as well as the award of interest @9%
per annum.
10. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have
gone through the record of the learned MACT with care.
11. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the
learned MACT fell into error in fastening liability upon the
appellant. The appellant had parted with the possession and
ownership of the vehicle as far back as 03.09.2008 through an
affidavit duly proved on record by the attesting Advocate. The
vehicle was in the effective control of respondent No.3 and
subsequent purchasers. Under the principles of possession and
control recognized in Reshma (supra) , the appellant could not be
mulcted with liability. He further argued that the compensation
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-8-
High Court of H.P.
awarded by the learned MACT is on the higher side and the
interest awarded @ 9% per annum is excessive.
12. On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent
No.1-claimant supported the award and contended that the
claimant is an innocent third party who suffered injuries due to
the rash and negligent driving of the offending motorcycle. The
vehicle was unregistered in the name of any other person, and
in the official records of the registering authority, the appellant
continued to be the registered owner. Compliance under Section
50 of the Motor Vehicles Act was never made, and in view of the
settled law, the registered owner remains liable to third parties.
Learned counsel for respondent No.3 submitted that respondent
No.3 had no concern with the vehicle and that the learned MACT
rightly fastened the liability on the registered owner.
13. The first aspect that arises for consideration is
whether the accident occurred on account of the rash and
negligent driving of motorcycle No.HP-17A-3414 by respondent
No.2. The petitioner, Sushila Devi, appeared in the witness box
as PW-1 and clearly deposed that while she was travelling with
her husband and minor son on scooter No.HR-02G-0162, the
offending motorcycle driven by respondent No.2 at a high speed
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-9-
High Court of H.P.
collided with their scooter near Vishwa Karma Chowk. The
prompt lodging of FIR Ext.PW-1/B by an independent
shopkeeper, Naresh Kumar, who witnessed the accident,
corroborates her version in all material particulars. The driver
of the offending motorcycle, respondent No.2, chose not to step
into the witness box to contradict the testimony of the petitioner
or to offer his version of the occurrence. In proceedings under
Section 166 of the Act, the standard of proof is preponderance
of probabilities. An adverse inference was rightly drawn against
respondent No.2 for failing to enter the witness box. The vague
suggestion that the scooter was being driven negligently by the
husband of the petitioner remained wholly unsubstantiated.
Therefore, the finding of the learned MACT holding respondent
No.2 guilty of rash and negligent driving is based on proper
appreciation of evidence and calls for no interference.
14. The primary contention urged on behalf of the
appellant is that having transferred the motorcycle to
respondent No.3 on 03.09.2008 by way of an affidavit, he ceased
to be in possession or control of the vehicle, and as such, could
not be held liable as an owner. This submission cannot be
accepted in view of the statutory scheme of the Act and the
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-10-
High Court of H.P.
authoritative pronouncements of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
and this Court.
15. Section 2(30) of the Act defines an 'owner' as follows:
"2(30) 'owner' means a person in whose name a motor vehicle
stands registered, and where such person is a minor, the
guardian of such minor, and in relation to a motor vehicle which
is the subject of a hire-purchase agreement, or an agreement of
lease or an agreement of hypothecation, the person in
possession of the vehicle under that agreement."
16. The definition of 'owner' under Section 2(30) makes
it clear that for the purposes of the Act, it is the person in whose
name the motor vehicle stands registered who is treated as the
owner. The only exceptions carved out by the statute relate to
minors and vehicles subject to hire-purchase, lease or
hypothecation agreements. In the case of an ordinary transfer of
a motor vehicle, Section 50 of the Act lays down a mandatory
procedure. Section 50(1)(a)(i) requires the transferor to report
the fact of transfer to the registering authority within fourteen
days, and the transferee is likewise required to apply for transfer
of registration within thirty days.
17. In the present case, the appellant admitted in his
cross-examination as RW-4 that in the registration certificate,
he is recorded as the owner of motorcycle No.HP-17A-3414. He
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-11-
High Court of H.P.
admitted that he never reported the fact of the alleged sale to the
registering authority and never issued any notice to respondent
No.3 to have the vehicle transferred in the official records. The
official screening report Ext.RW-1/B also conclusively
established that the motorcycle stood registered in the name of
the appellant.
18. The question as to whether a registered owner
continues to remain liable to third parties despite an
unregistered sale or transfer of possession was settled by a
three-Judge Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Naveen
Kumar v. Vijay Kumar and others , (2018) 3 SCC 1 , wherein
it was observed:
"13. The consistent thread of reasoning which emerges from the
above decisions is that in view of the definition of the expression
'owner' in Section 2(30), it is the person in whose name the
motor vehicle stands registered who, for the purposes of the Act,
would be treated as the 'owner'. However, where a person is a
minor, the guardian of the minor would be treated as the owner.
Where a motor vehicle is subject to an agreement of hire
purchase, lease or hypothecation, the person in possession of
the vehicle under that agreement is treated as the owner. In a
situation such as the present where the registered owner has
purported to transfer the vehicle but continues to be reflected in
the records of the registering authority as the owner of the
vehicle, he would not stand absolved of liability. Parliament has
consciously introduced the definition of the expression 'owner'
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-12-
High Court of H.P.
in Section 2(30), making a departure from the provisions of
Section 2(19) in the earlier Act of 1939. The principle underlying
the provisions of Section 2(30) is that the victim of a motor
accident or, in the case of a death, the legal heirs of the
deceased victim should not be left in a state of uncertainty. A
claimant for compensation ought not to be burdened with
following a trail of successive transfers, which are not
registered with the registering authority. To hold otherwise
would be to defeat the salutary object and purpose of the Act.
Hence, the interpretation to be placed must facilitate the
fulfilment of the object of the law. In the present case, the First
respondent was the 'owner' of the vehicle involved in the
accident within the meaning of Section 2(30). The liability to pay
compensation stands fastened upon him. Admittedly, the
vehicle was uninsured. The High Court has proceeded upon a
misconstruction of the judgments of this Court in Reshma and
Purnya Kala Devi.
14. The submission of the Petitioner is that a failure to
intimate the transfer will only result in a fine under Section 50(3)
but will not invalidate the transfer of the vehicle. In Dr. TV Jose,
this Court observed that there can be transfer of title by
payment of consideration of delivery of the vehicle, but for the
purposes of the Act, the person whose name is reflected in the
records of the registering authority, is the owner. The owner
within the meaning of Section 2(30) is liable to compensate. The
mandate of the law must be fulfilled."
19. The same principle was reiterated by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Prakash Chand Daga v. Saveta Sharma
and others , (2019) 2 SCC 747 , wherein it was held that even
though under civil law there may be a transfer of ownership of
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-13-
High Court of H.P.
the vehicle, that by itself does not absolve the person in whose
name the vehicle stands in the RTO records from liability to a
third party. So long as his name continues in the records of the
registering authority, he remains liable.
20. This Court in Anil Kumar and Others v. Jyoti and
Others , 2022 SCC OnLine HP 6441 , after reviewing the
statutory provisions and the judgments in Naveen Kumar and
Prakash Chand Daga (supra) , held that third-party claimants
cannot be made to suffer and cannot be deprived of the benefits
flowing from beneficial legislation by following a trail of
successive unregistered transfers. It was held that the person
whose name is reflected in the registration certificate continues
to be the owner for the purposes of the Act and remains
answerable to third parties.
21. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Brij Bihari Gupta v.
Manmet and Others , 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1650 , has again
reaffirmed that a private agreement or delivery of possession
without reporting the transfer under Section 50 of the Act does
not extinguish the liability of the registered owner. It was held
that the liability to pay falls squarely on the registered owner
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-14-
High Court of H.P.
and the claimant cannot be burdened to follow the trail of
successive transfers.
22. Similarly, a Coordinate Bench of this Court in Labh
Singh v. National Insurance Company Limited and others ,
2026 SCC OnLine HP 5469 , held that for a legal and valid
transfer of a motor vehicle, the provisions of Section 50 of the
Act must be complied with. In the absence of such compliance,
it is the registered owner who is liable to pay compensation to
third parties. The fact that possession was delivered or that the
vehicle was subsequently released on an application for
sapurdari to an alleged transferee does not come to the aid of
the registered owner.
23. The heavy reliance placed by learned counsel for the
appellant on the judgment of the Reshma (supra) , to contend
that the registered owner cannot be held liable if he has parted
with possession and control of the vehicle, is completely
misplaced and proceeds upon a fundamental misreading of the
statutory provisions. In Reshma (supra) , the Hon'ble Supreme
Court was dealing with the liability of a financier/bank where
the vehicle was the subject matter of an agreement of
hypothecation. Parliament has deliberately structured Section
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-15-
High Court of H.P.
2(30) of the Act into two distinct parts: the general definition
designating the person in whose name the vehicle is registered
as the owner, and specific exceptions carved out for minors as
well as vehicles covered under hire-purchase, lease or
hypothecation agreements, where the person in possession
under that agreement is treated as the owner. The financier in
Reshma (supra) fell squarely within the statutory exception
governing hypothecation agreements. That principle cannot be
imported into a transaction of an ordinary, unregistered sale
between private individuals, which continues to be governed by
the primary definition of registered owner read with the
mandatory obligations under Section 50 of the Act.
24. Indeed, this precise argument was raised before and
authoritatively rejected by a three-Judge Bench of the Hon'ble
Apex Court in Naveen Kumar (supra) , wherein it was explicitly
observed that relying upon Reshma (supra) to absolve a
registered owner who purports to transfer a vehicle without
mutating the records of the registering authority is based on a
complete misconstruction of law. An innocent third-party
claimant cannot be prejudiced by private affidavits of transfer
that have never been reported to the registering authority. The
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-16-
High Court of H.P.
appellant, being the registered owner of the motorcycle in the
records of the registering authority on the date of the accident,
remains statutorily liable to third parties. Therefore, the learned
MACT committed no error in fastening the liability upon the
appellant.
25. Adverting now to the quantum of compensation, the
petitioner claimed that she suffered grievous injuries, remained
hospitalized and incurred medical expenses. The petitioner
produced medical bills Ext.P1 to Ext.P34 totaling ₹ 8,683/-,
which were duly supported by treatment records and discharge
₹
slips. The learned MACT rightly allowed a sum of 8,683/-
towards medical charges. Considering the period of
hospitalization and treatment, the learned MACT awarded
₹ 5,000/- towards attendant charges and ₹ 15,000/- towards
special diet, which cannot be said to be excessive. Having regard
to the nature of injuries and trauma sustained by the petitioner,
the award of ₹ 15,000/- towards pain and suffering is modest,
fair and just. The total compensation of ₹ 43,683/- awarded by
the learned MACT represents just and reasonable compensation
within the meaning of Section 168 of the Act and does not
warrant any reduction.
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS
2026:HHC:49134
-17-
High Court of H.P.
26. Insofar as the award of interest @ 9% per annum
from the date of filing of the petition till realization is concerned,
the same is in accordance with the settled principles governing
compensation in motor accident claims and falls well within the
sound discretion exercised by the learned MACT. No ground is
made out to interfere with the rate of interest.
27. No other point was urged.
In view of the above, the present appeal fails and the
same is dismissed, so also pending miscellaneous application(s),
if any.
(Yogesh Jaswal),
Judge
November 06, 2026
(Rajeev Raturi)
::: Downloaded on - 06/11/2026 13:31:08 :::CIS