CHABI RANI BANDHOPADHYAY @ CHHABI RANI BANOPADHYAY vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR

Court
Calcutta High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE

Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta


C.R.R. No. 562 of 2023
With
CRAN 1 of 2024

CHABI RANI BANDHOPADHYAY @ CHHABI RANI
BANOPADHYAY
Versus

THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR.




For the Petitioner : Mr. Bibhas Aditya Chakraborty, Adv.

For the Opposite Party No. 2 : Mr. Pratip Kumar Chatterjee, Adv.
Ms. Maitrayee Chatterjee, Adv.

Heard on : 01.10.2026
Judgment on : 19.11.2026
Uploaded on : 19.11.2026
Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.:-
1. By filing this Criminal Revisional application under Section 482 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (In short, ‘Cr.P.C.’), the
petitioner/Mother of the opposite party no. 2 has challenged the

2

correctness, legality and propriety of the impugned Judgment dated
06.01.2023 passed by the Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Kandi,
Murshidabad in relation to the Criminal Revision No. 15 of 2022
(Partha Sarathi Bandopadhyay Vs. Chhabi Rani Bandopadhyay and
Others).
2. By the said judgment, the learned Additional Sessions Judge allowed
the revisional application filed by the Opposite Party No. 2, son of the
petitioner, thereby setting aside the impugned order dated May 12,
2022 passed by the SDO, Kandi, in case No. 30/2022 initiated by the
petitioner against the opposite party no. 2.

3. The facts leading to the filing of the instant application are that the
Petitioner/mother of the opposite party no. 2, being an elderly lady,
lodged a complaint before the Sub Divisional Officer, Kandi,
Murshidabad on July 13, 2022, inter alia , alleging that her husband,
who was employed in the office of the Sub Divisional Officer, Kandi,
Murshidabad, endured tremendous torture during his lifetime by the
Opposite Party No. 2, his eldest son. In 2006, the Petitioner’s
husband transferred all his property in his favour through a
registered Gift Deed. However, thereafter, at the request of the
Opposite Party No. 2, the Petitioner transferred most of her properties
to her son, namely, Partha Sarathi Bandopadhyay, and his family
members, Karuna Ketan Bandopadhyay and Arun Prakash

3

Bandopadhyay, the son of Partha Sarathi Bandopadhyay, by
executing a Deed vide No. 1125 of 2019.
4. The aforesaid Deed was executed under the full supervision of the
Opposite Party No. 2. Upon getting such opportunity, he falsely
obtained the signature of the Petitioner and transferred 11 decimal
"Ga" schedule property consisting of LR plot No. 6050 in favour of his
son. The Petitioner, being illiterate, could only sign her name, and
nobody explained the contents of the said Deed to her.
5. After receiving the said complaint from the Petitioner, the Office of the
Learned Sub Divisional Officer, Kandi, Murshidabad registered the
same as Case No. 30/2020 under Rule 4(1) of the Maintenance and
Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007.
6. On 12.05.2022, the Learned Sub Divisional Officer, Kandi,
Murshidabad, after hearing both the parties, passed an Order with
an observation that the said Deed of 2019 was made fraudulently and
declared the same void and directed the DSR-2, Murshidabad to
cancel the said Deed No. 1125/2019 dated 11.07.2019.
7. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid Order dated 12.05.2022, the
opposite Party No. 2 filed a Criminal Revision vide No. 15 of 2022
before the Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Kandi, Murshidabad.
Upon hearing the parties, the learned Sessions Judge ultimately
entertained the revisional application. However, there is no provision

4

for either appeal or revision other than that a senior citizen or a
parent, as the case may be, aggrieved by an order of a Tribunal may,
within sixty days from the date of the order, prefer an appeal to the
Appellate Tribunal, but the learned Sessions Judge set aside the
order passed by the SDO mechanically without following the actual
provision and without applying his judicious mind.
8. At the time of passing the Judgement, the Learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Kandi, Murshidabad held that the Learned Sub
Divisional Officer, Kandi, Murshidabad passed the Order dated
12.05.2022 without considering that the Petitioner herein never
prayed for any maintenance from her eldest son and for the same the
said Deed of 2019 must not be cancelled for the self-same reason,
where the claim of maintenance of the petitioner was one of the
essential criteria.
9. The Learned Additional Sessions Judge, while passing the said
Judgement dated 06.01.2023, considered that the decision of the
Learned Sub Divisional Officer, Kandi, Murshidabad suffers from
irregularity and illegality and ultimately set it aside.
10. Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the Order and Judgment
dated 06.01.2023 passed by the Learned Additional Sessions Judge,
Kandi, Murshidabad in relation to the Criminal Revision No. 15 of
2022 (Partha Sarathi Bandopadhyay -vs- Chhabi Rani Bandopadhyay

5

and Others), the Petitioner herein filed this Revisional Application
praying for setting aside the impugned aforesaid judgment,
contending the judgment under challenge is incorrect and patently
illegal.
11. Learned counsel representing the petitioner submitted that the
Learned Additional Sessions Judge failed to consider that, according
to Section 16 of the said Act, 2007, an Appeal from the Order passed
by the Tribunal under the said Act of 2007 shall not be filed other
than by a senior citizen or a parent before the Appellate Tribunal,
where the Presiding Officer must not be below the rank of District
Magistrate.
12. Learned counsel further submitted that the learned Judge
mechanically and without applying his judicious mind outrightly set
aside the judgment passed by the SDO, Kandi, although the
revisional application was not at all maintainable in law as mentioned
in the said Act, 2007. The learned Judge, without considering the
actual legal provision, entertained the revisional application and set
aside the Judgment passed by the SDO; as such, the judgment is
liable to be set aside at the threshold.
13. Secondly, it was submitted that Section 23 of the said Act, 2007
specifically states not only for maintenance but also for the basic
physical needs of the parents. Basic physical needs have a wide

6

scope; it is not confined to the question of maintenance. Prior to
execution of the deed, the opposite party’s behaviour with his mother
was very good; however, just after execution and registration of the
deed in favour of the opposite party no. 2 and others, their behaviour
completely changed and they started ignoring the petitioner and her
physical needs; as such, she had lodged a complaint against the
Opposite party no. 2 for his ill-treatment towards her own mother.
The SDO was fully satisfied with the allegation to have been
committed by the elder son of the petitioner and passed the judgment
correctly with sound and correct reasons.

14. It is further contended that where any senior citizen, who, after the
commencement of this Act, has transferred by way of gift or
otherwise, his/her property, subject to the condition that the
transferee shall provide the basic amenities and basic physical needs
to the transferor and such transferee refuses or fails to provide such
amenities and physical needs, the said transfer of property shall be
deemed to have been made by fraud or coercion or under undue
influence and shall at the option of the transferor be declared void by
the Tribunal. Therefore, such order requires no interference by this
court.
15. The learned judge, however, held that the petitioner did not seek
maintenance and she had sufficient means to maintain herself; the

7

SDO, without appreciating the spirit of Section 23 of the Maintenance
and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007, declared the
deed of Gift as void and inoperative as it was procured by the
revisionist/opposite party no. 2, by applying fraudulent means;
therefore, the judgment is not sustainable in law.
16. Per contra, learned counsel representing the Opposite Party no. 2
strenuously controverted the submission made by the learned
counsel for the petitioner and further submitted that the learned
judge has rightly set aside the judgment passed by the Learned
Tribunal as it was passed without ascertaining the terms and
conditions stipulated in the Deed. There were no such conditions that
if the opposite party fails to discharge his duty as son, the deed
would be cancelled. The Section is very specific that if any of the
conditions stipulated in the deed is not complied with by the opposite
party no. 2, then the question arises to declare the same void and
inoperative. However, the Learned SDO held that the deed was
procured by applying fraudulent means, although there is no
question of any fraudulent act. The Opposite Party always looked
after her both before and after the registration of the deed in his
favour. Furthermore, there was no demand for maintenance;
therefore, the question of maintenance does not arise, she being the
recipient of a family pension, and the amount so received being

8

sufficient for her maintenance. She also did not claim any
maintenance from the Opposite Party No.2, although he, being the
elder son, always takes care of her. But somehow, she was
unnecessarily insisted by some unknown interested person to lodged
complaint against the opposite party No.2 without any rhyme and
reasons. As such, the learned judge rightly assessed the provision of
Section 23 of the said Act, and correctly set aside the judgment dated
12.05.2022 passed by the SDO, and therefore, calls for no
interference and the same is liable to be dismissed.
17. Lastly, the learned counsel, in the alternative, submitted that liberty
may be granted to the opposite party to approach before the forum, if
this court observes that there is no provision for either appeal or
revision by the opposite party no. 2 against the order of the Tribunal
and sets aside the judgment passed by the learned judge on the
ground that the revisional application was not maintainable and it
ought to have been dismissed on the ground of not being
maintainable in law.
18. Heard the learned counsels for the respective parties and having gone
through the materials on record and the judgment passed by the
Tribunal and the learned Judge, this court is of the opinion that there
is a specific provision in the Act itself. Therefore, this court finds it
apposite to refer to the relevant provisions/Sections applicable in the

9

current application filed by the senior citizen. The relevant provisions
are quoted herein below for proper assessment for the purpose of
effective adjudication.
“Section 15: Constitution of Appellate Tribunal. —
(1) The State Government may, by notification in the Official
Gazette, constitute one Appellate Tribunal for each district to hear
the appeal against the order of the Tribunal.
(2) The Appellate Tribunal shall be presided over by an officer not
below the rank of District Magistrate.

Section16: - Appeals reads as follows:
(1) Any senior citizen or a parent, as the case may be, aggrieved by
an order of a Tribunal may, within sixty days from the date of the
order, prefer an appeal to the Appellate Tribunal:
Provided that on appeal, the children or relative who is required to
pay any amount in terms of such maintenance order shall continue
to pay to such parent the amount so ordered, in the manner
directed by the Appellate Tribunal:
Provided further that the Appellate Tribunal may, entertain the
appeal after the expiry of the said period of sixty days, if it is
satisfied that the appellant was prevented by sufficient cause from
preferring the appeal in time.
(2) On receipt of an appeal, the Appellate Tribunal shall, cause a
notice to be served upon the respondent.
(3) The Appellate Tribunal may call for the record of proceedings
from the Tribunal against whose order the appeal is preferred.
(4) The Appellate Tribunal may, after examining the appeal and the
records called for either allow or reject the appeal.
(5) The Appellate Tribunal shall, adjudicate and decide upon the
appeal filed against the order of the Tribunal and the order of the
Appellate Tribunal shall be final:
Provided that no appeal shall be rejected unless an opportunity
has been given to both the parties of being heard in person or
through a duly authorised representative.
(6) The Appellate Tribunal shall make an endeavour to pronounce
its order in writing within one month of the receipt of an appeal.
(7) A copy of every order made under sub-section (5) shall be sent
to both the parties free of cost.


10

Section 23. Transfer of property to be void in certain
circumstances: -
(1) Where any senior citizen who, after the commencement of this
Act, has transferred by way of gift or otherwise, his property,
subject to the condition that the transferee shall provide the basic
amenities and basic physical needs to the transferor and such
transferee refuses or fails to provide such amenities and physical
needs, the said transfer of property shall be deemed to have been
made by fraud or coercion or under undue influence and shall at
the option of the transferor be declared void by the Tribunal.
(2) Where any senior citizen has a right to receive maintenance out
of an estate and such estate or part thereof is transferred, the right
to receive maintenance may be enforced against the transferee if
the transferee has notice of the right, or if the transfer is
gratuitous; but not against the transferee for consideration and
without notice of right.
(3) If, any senior citizen is incapable of enforcing the rights under
sub-sections (1) and (2), action may be taken on his behalf by any
of the organisation referred to in Explanation to sub-section (1) of
section 5.”

19. Upon bare perusal of the aforesaid provisions, this Court finds that
there is a specific provision for filing an appeal against the order
passed by the Tribunal either by any senior citizen or a parent,
aggrieved may, within sixty days from the date of the order, appeal to
the Appellate Tribunal. The State Government may, by notification in
the Official Gazette, constitute one Appellate Tribunal for each
district to hear the appeal against the order of the Tribunal. The
Appellate Tribunal shall be presided over by an officer not below the
rank of District Magistrate.
20. Opposite party no. 2 is the son against whom the Tribunal passed the
order. He is neither a senior citizen nor a parent seeking to challenge

11

an order of the Tribunal. Section 16 gives him no remedy, and the Act
provides no revision. The revisional application was, therefore, not
maintainable and ought to have been rejected at the threshold. The
learned Additional Sessions Judge acted without jurisdiction in
entertaining it and setting aside the order of the Tribunal. The
impugned judgment dated 06.01.2023 is, in the circumstances, not
sustainable in law. This Court exercises its inherent power under
Section 482 Cr.P.C. to correct an order passed without jurisdiction
and to prevent abuse of the process of the court. Therefore, the

impugned order under challenge before this Court by the petitioner is
found palpable and ex facie illegal; as such, it calls for interference by
this Court as the same is not sustainable in law.
21. Accordingly, CRR No. 562 of 2023 is, thus, allowed by setting aside
the Judgment dated 06.01.2023 passed by the Learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Kandi, Murshidabad in relation to the Criminal
Revision No. 15 of 2022 (Partha Sarathi Bandopadhyay Vs. Chhabi
Rani Bandopadhyay and Others) and pending application, if any, also
stand disposed of.
22. It is made clear that this court has not entered into the merits of this
case, as the impugned order under challenge in the present
application was found unsustainable as the revisional application
filed by the opposite party no. 2 before the learned Sessions Judge

12

was not indeed maintainable in law. Thus, the opposite party no.2
would be at liberty to take appropriate recourse before the
appropriate forum for his relief in accordance with law, if so advised,
and if such a forum is approached, the proceedings shall be taken to
their logical conclusion without being influenced by any of the
observations made in this judgment. Appropriate recourse may be
taken within two weeks from the date of obtaining certified copy of
this judgment, otherwise, delay, if any, be dealt with in accordance
with law.
23. Let a copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Tribunal for
information.
24. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
25. All parties will act on the server copies of this Judgment duly
downloaded from the official website of this Hon’ble High Court.
26. Urgent photostat certified copy of this Judgment, if applied for, is to
be given as expeditiously to the parties on compliance of all legal and
necessary formalities.

(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)

(P.A.)