SMT ANANDAMMA vs M/S ROYAL SUNDARAM GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 13 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.4778 OF 2023(MV-D)
C/W
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.4630 OF 2023(MV-D)
IN MFA No. 4778/2023
BETWEEN:
1. SMT ANANDAMMA,
W/O LATE T.K.KRISHNAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
2. KUM. KRUPA T.K.,
D/O LATE T.K.KRISHNAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS,
3. KUM. MEGHA T.K.,
D/O LATE T.K.KRISHNAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS,
4. CHI.KRUTHISH T.K.,
S/O LATE T.K.KRISHNAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS,
ALL ARE R/AT NO.86,
THARAHUNASE VILLAGE
AND POST,
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
JALA HOBLI,
YELAHANKA TALUK,
BENGALURU - 562 157.
…APPELLANTS
(BY KUMARI BINISHA R., ADVOCATE FOR
SRI HARIPRASAD M.B., ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
M/S. ROYAL SUNDARAM GENERAL
INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
NO.56/1, 2ND FLOOR,
9TH MAIN ROAD,
5TH BLOCK, JAYANAGAR,
BENGALURU - 562 107.
2. MR. VENU S.,
MAJOR,
GCA RAINBOW APARTMENT,
FLAT NO.305, 2ND FLOOR,
ASHOK LEYLAND, NERALUR,
BENGALURU - 562 107.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI RAVI SHANKAR S. SAMPRATHI, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
NOTICE TO R2 IS DISPENSED WITH VIDE ORDER DATED
02.08.2023)
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.173(1) OF MV ACT, AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 29.03.2023 PASSED IN MVC
NO.889/2021 ON THE FILE OF THE CHIEF JUDGE, COURT OF
SMALL CAUSES, MEMBER, PRL. MACT, BENGALURU, PARTLY
ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND
SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF COMPENSATION.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
IN MFA NO. 4630/2023
BETWEEN:
1. ROYAL SUNDARAM GENERAL
INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
NO.56/1, 2ND FLOOR,
9TH MAIN ROAD,
5TH BLOCK, JAYANAGARA,
BENGALURU - 560 041.
REPRESENTED BY REGIONAL OFFICE,
NO.30, 3RD FLOOR, JNR CITY CENTRE,
RAJARAM MOHAN ROY ROAD,
SAMPANGIRAMA NAGAR,
BANGALORE - 560 027.
REPRESENTED BY IS MANAGER.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI RAVI SHANKAR S. SAMPRATHI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. SMT. ANANDAMMA,
W/O LATE T.K.KRISHNAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
2. KUM. KRUPA T.K.,
D/O LATE T.K. KRISHNAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS,
3.
KU. MEGHA T.K.,
D/O LATE T.K. KRISHNAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS,
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
4. CHI. KRUTHISH T.K.,
S/O LATE T.K. KRISHNAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS,
ALL ARE RESIDING AT
NO.86, THARAHUNASE VILLAGE AND POST,
JALA HOBLI, YELAHANKA TALUK,
BENGALURU - 562 157.
5. SRI.VENU S,
FATHERS NAME NOT KNOWN TO APPELLANT,
MAJOR IN AGE,
GCA RAINBOW APARTMENT,
FLAT NO.305, 2ND FLOOR,
ASHOK LEYLAND, NERALUR,
BENGALURU - 562 107.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI HARIPRASAD M.B. , ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R4;
NOTICE TO R5 IS DISPENSED WITH VIDE ORDER
DATED 11.07.2023)
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST
THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 29.03.2023 PASSED
IN MVC NO.889/2021 ON THE FILE OF THE CHIEF JUDGE,
COURT OF SMALL CAUSES, MEMBER, PRINCIPAL MOTOR
ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, BENGALURU,
AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS. 46,64,000/- WITH
INTEREST AT 6 PERCENT P.A. FROM THE DATE OF
PETITION TILL THE DATE OF DEPOSIT IN COURT.
THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
ORAL JUDGMENT
1. MFA No.4778/2023 is filed by the claimants and
MFA No.4630/2023 is filed by the Insurance company
challenging the quantum of compensation awarded in the
Judgment and award dated 29.03.2023 in MVC
No.889/2021 on the file of Chief Judge, Court of Small
Causes, Member Prl. Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Bengaluru (in short, 'the Tribunal').
2. The parties would be referred with their ranks,
as they were before the Tribunal for the sake of
convenience and clarity.
3. The claimants have filed the claim petition
before the Tribunal claiming compensation in respect of
death of T.K. Krishnappa in the road traffic accident that
has taken place on 20.12.2020 at about 05:45 a.m.
involving the motorcycle bearing registration number
KA-50/EC-5020 and the Tipper lorry bearing registration
No.KA-51/AD-2420 (offending vehicle) on Tharahunase to
Yelahanka road. It is the case of the claimants that the
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
deceased was the rider of the motorcycle near
Hunasemaranahalli; the offending Tipper lorry came with
high speed, dashed against the motorcycle from backside
and due to the accident, deceased fall on the road and
succumbed to the injuries on the spot.
4. The claimants are the wife, unmarried
daughters and major son of the deceased.
5. After service of notice, respondent No.1 being
the insurance Company of the offending vehicle has filed
objection statement and denied the contention of the
claimants in toto . He has also taken other available
defence to the insurance Company and prays for dismissal
of the claim petition.
6. After framing issues, recording evidence and
hearing arguments of both sides, the Tribunal concluded
`
that the income of deceased at 50,000/- per month and
awarded the total compensation of ` 46,64,000/- under
following heads:
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
Sl.
Head of compensation Calculation Rs. Amount/ Rs
No.
50,000/-
Monthly income
1
Add: 10% future prospectus
5,000/-
Total
55,000/-
55,000/-
Deduction of 1/4th of income
2
of the deceased towards
13,175/-
personal expenses
41,250/-
41,250x12
Annual income of the
3
petitioner
4,95,000/-
Compensation after
4
4,95,000x9 44,55,000/-
multiplier applied
5 Loss of estate 16,500/-
6 Funeral expenses 16,500/-
Loss of spousal consortium
7
44,000/-
to petitioner No.1 - wife
Parental consortium to
8
44,000/- 1,32,000/-
petitioners No.2 to 4
Total 46,64,000/-
7. Aggrieved by the quantum of the said
compensation, the insurance Company and not satisfied
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
with the said compensation, the claimants are before this
Court.
8. Heard arguments of both sides.
9. The learned counsel for the insurance Company
Sri Ravi Shankar S. Samprathi, would submit that as per
the documents produced by the claimants, the deceased
owned about one acre and odd lands. They also revealed
that he was cultivating said lands and they have not
produced documents to show the income of the deceased.
Admittedly, the deceased was not paying any income tax;
even though he was getting the income from milk vending
and from growing commercial crops. Hence, prays for
modification of the judgment.
10. The learned counsel for the claimants
Sri Hariprasad M.B., would submit that the claimants have
produced relevant documents i.e., Ex.P.8 - RTCs, Ex.P.11-
Water Right Certificates, Ex.P.10 - Crop Certificates;
Certificate issued by the Milk Producers Co-operative
Society; evidence of PW.2 and PW.3 and also the
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
documents to show that the deceased had taken loan for
the education of his daughters, which establish that he
was having financial capacity to repay such huge loan.
Thus the income of the deceased was ` 10,00,000/- p.a.,
but it was not properly taken by the Tribunal and hence
prayed for enhancement of the compensation.
11. Having heard arguments of both sides, verifying
the appeal papers and trial Court records, the point that
arises for consideration is:
"Whether the quantum of compensation
awarded by the Tribunal requires modification?"
12. Finding of this Court on the above point is in
' Affirmative' for the following:
REASONS
13. The facts established before the Tribunal are
that the claimant No.1 is the wife, claimants No.2 and 3
are the unmarried daughters and claimant No.4 is the
major son of deceased Krishnappa. It is also established
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
that on the date of accident, the deceased was the rider of
the motorcycle and offending vehicle dashed against the
motorcycle and caused the accident. Because of the
accident, he died on the spot itself. The age of the
deceased was 59 years as on the date of accident is not in
dispute. The deceased left behind three dependents and
th
thus the Tribunal has correctly taken 1/4 of his income
towards his personal and living expenses. The Tribunal has
taken the multiplier '9', which is also proper and added
future prospects at 10% which is also correct.
14. The only point to be decided is, whether the
income of the deceased taken by the Tribunal is based on
the available evidence.
15. With this background, the documents produced
by the claimants are to be examined.
16. Ex.P.8 – RTCs reveal that the deceased got
properties in several survey numbers totally (145.6
guntas) 3 acre 25 guntas 1.5 cents from the partition that
has taken place between him and other coparceners.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
Ex.P.9 is the Certificate issued by the Horticulture
Department that the deceased has taken financial
assistance to improve his lands. Ex.P.10 is the Certificate
showing that he was growing Capsicum totally in 1.12
acres. Ex.P.11 shows that he was having a right to get
water from borewell situated at survey No.102/2 and 3/6.
Ex.P.12 shows that he was contesting for the office bearer
post in Milk Producers’ Co-operative Society. Ex.P.13 is the
Certificate issued by Milk Producers’ Co-operative Society
that he was supplying milk to the society. Ex.P.14 is the
Certificate showing that he had supplied milk worth
` 72,953.13/- for a period of 8 months from 01.04.2020 to
31.12.2020. Ex.P.15 is the Certificate issued by the
Farmers’ Service Co-operative Society that the loan of
` 50,000/- was outstanding to such society. Ex.P.16 to P28
are the Certificates issued by banks showing that claimant
Nos.2 and 3 were students of Dental College and Medical
College and they have availed Education loan and as they
were minors, loan was given to them represented by the
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
deceased. Ex.P.19 is the Certificate issued by the Revenue
Department to show the cultivation. However, this
certificate is not exactly in consonance with the RTCs
produced by the claimants. Under these circumstances,
RTCs prevail over the certificate. Hence, the total land
holding of the deceased was 3 acre 25 guntas 1.5 cents.
17. The evidence of PW.1, who is the claimant No.1
is that her husband was looking after the agriculture and
other activities and earning ` 10,00,000/- per annum. He
had adopted poly house/green house and net house
techniques in his agricultural field. The adoption of poly
house/green house and net house by the deceased still
continued and it will be made use of by the claimants.
18. In the cross-examination, the claimant No.1 has
deposed that during lifetime of her husband they were
having 3 cows and now she owns only 1 cow. She has not
deposed that what happened to other 2 cows; she might
have sold them or they may be continued with her. Even
after death of her husband, the claimants continued with
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
the cultivation of the landed properties, which were
standing in the name of deceased.
19. The evidence of PW.2 and PW.3 is only hearsay
evidence regarding the income of the deceased and thus
cannot be looked into.
20. The above facts establish that the deceased was
looking after the agriculture and family affairs and even
after his death; the properties are being cultivated by the
claimants. The properties are still in their possession.
However, they lost the person who was supervising those
properties. Hence, the quantification of the supervisory
capacity of the deceased is to be decided.
21. In this regard, the learned counsel for insurance
Company places reliance on the Judgment of Division
Bench of this Court in the case of B. Parimala and
1
Others vs. Riyaz Ahmed and others
, paragraph No.23-
Illustration B reads as under:
1
ILR 2001 Kar 1443
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
Illustration-B: The deceased was owning 10 acres
of land and by cultivating the same, through
labourers under his supervision, was earning
Rs.1.00 lakh per annum. On his death, the
dependent family [wife and children] inherit the
land. But, for lack of experience, they engage a
manager to supervise the cultivation by paying a
salary of Rs.3,000.00 per month and continue to
get an annual income of Rs.1.00 lakh from the
land. In such a case, the annual income of Rs.1.00
lakh earned by the deceased from the land cannot
be the loss of income of the family. Only the value
of the supervision and personal effort put in by the
deceased, which had to be made good by engaging
a manager, can be treated as loss of income. Thus,
the loss of income will have to be taken as
Rs.36,000-00 per annum. Even where a manager is
not engaged, and the family members of the
deceased supervise the land, the loss will be the
value of supervision by the deceased. The notional
value of such effort and supervision determined
with reference to the facts and circumstances, will
be the loss on account of the death.
22. According to Ex.P.14 the deceased got payment
of ` 72,953.13/- for 8 months and thus according to it
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
`
approximately he was getting 9,000/- per month from
milk vending. That entire ` 9,000/- cannot be considered
as the income of the deceased, because he has to feed the
cattle and spend money for milking and other
miscellaneous expenses. Thus, 50% of the aforesaid
income could be considered as the income of the deceased
`
i.e., 4,500/- per month. There is no other document
produced to show the profit deceased was earning by
growing Capsicum or what was the yield he was getting
from that capsicum.
23. Furthermore, the deceased was not an income
tax payee. The learned counsel for the claimants would
submit that because he was getting income from the
agriculture, he need not pay the income tax and he need
not submit IT returns. However, according to the
claimants, the deceased was also doing milk vending
business and growing commercial crops like Eucalyptus
trees and thus if he was getting income from those
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
sources; then such income is taxable; but he not income
tax assessee.
24. The other documents produced are about the
educational loan of his two daughters and it is the primary
responsibility of his daughters to repay the loan
immediately after they became majors and starts earning
and it is not the responsibility of the deceased. Hence,
taking those loans cannot be considered as his financial
capacity to repay the loan. However, these facts were not
at all examined by the Tribunal and has considered the
income of deceased at Rs. 50,000/- per month without
looking into these aspects in an appropriate manner.
Hence, the income of deceased taken at Rs. 50,000/- per
month by the tribunal is exorbitant.
25. Considering the income from supervision on
agriculture, milk vending, the income of the deceased
could be taken at ` 25,000/- per month and not ` 50,000/-
per month. The deceased was aged 59 years. Thus 10% of
` 25,000/- shall be added towards future prospects. He left
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
behind his wife, two unmarried daughters and his major
son who was still a student and thus the Tribunal rightly
th
deducted 1/4 of his income for his personal and living
expenses, out of his income 1/4th to be deducted. The
relevant applicable multiplier is '9'; hence, the claimants
` `
are entitled for 22,27,500/- ( 25,000/- + 10% x 12 x 9 x
`
3/4) towards 'loss of dependency' instead of 44,55,000/-
awarded by the Tribunal. As far as other conventional
heads are concerned, the Tribunal has awarded
compensation under all the conventional heads as per the
guidelines given by Hon'ble Apex Court in National
Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and
2
others . Hence, it requires no interference.
26. Thus totally the claimants are entitled for
` 24,36,500/- under following heads:
2
(2017) 16 Supreme Court Cases 680
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
1 Loss of dependency 22,27,500/-
2 Loss of estate 16,500/-
3 Funeral expenses 16,500/-
Loss of spousal
consortium to
4
44,000/-
petitioner No.1 - wife
Parental consortium to
5
1,32,000/-
petitioner Nos.2 to 4
Total ` 24,36,500/-
27. Hence, the claimant is entitled for total
compensation of ` 24,36,500/- as against ` 46,64,000/-
awarded by the Tribunal.
28. Hence, this Court passes the following:
ORDER
a. The MFA No.4778/2023 filed by the claimants under
Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is
dismissed .
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
b. The MFA No.4630/2023 filed by the Insurance
Company under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 is allowed-in-part .
c. Judgment and award dated 29.03.2023 passed in
MVC No.889/2021 on the file of Chief Judge, Court of
Small Causes, Member Prl. Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Bengaluru is modified holding that the
claimants are entitled for total compensation of
` 24,36,500/- with 6% per annum from the date of
petition till realization instead of ` 46,64,000/-
awarded by the Tribunal.
d. The Insurance Company is directed to deposit the
aforesaid amount within 6 weeks from the date of
receipt of certified copy of this order.
e. The amount and deposit be transmitted to the
Tribunal
f. Apportionment, disbursement and deposit shall be
as per the order of the Tribunal.
g. No order as to costs.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63066
MFA No. 4778 of 2023
C/W MFA No. 4630 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010348812023
h. Draw modified award accordingly.
i. Registry to transmit the TCR to the Tribunal
forthwith.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA
(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
LL
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 17