DEVESH KUMAR vs HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI
O.A. No. 3988/2024
nd
This the 02 day of November, 2026
Hon’ble Mr. B Anand, Member (A)
DEVESH KUMAR
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
AT: HOUSE NO. 20,
SERVANT QUARTERS,
SOUTH AVENUE, CENTRAL DELHI,
DELHI- 11000l
… Applicant
(By Advocate: Mr. Sagar Shivam Jaishwal with Mr.
Vishal Rao)
Versus
1. MINISTRY OF URBAN DEVELOPMENT
THROUGH SECRETARY
NIRMAN BHAWAN,
NEW DELHI-110002.
2. DIRECTOR GENERAL [CO-ORDINATION]
NORTHERN REGION,
CENTRAL PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
EAST BLOCK-1, FLOOR-7,
R.K. PURAM, NEW DELHI-110066
3. SUPRITENDENT ENGINEER
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
PRESIDENT'S ESTATE CIRCLE
CENTRAL PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
RASHTRAPATI BHAWAN,
NEW DELHI- 110004
… Respondents
(By Advocate: Mr. Pradeep Kumar Sharma)
2
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
O R D E R (ORAL)
The father of the applicant herein was working as a
Beldar in the office of the Executive Engineer, President's
Estate Circle, CPWD, Rashtrapati Bhavan, New Delhi. While
in service, he unfortunately expired on 4th January, 2009,
after completing approximately ten years of service, leaving
behind four family members.
2. The applicant submitted an application dated 27th
February, 2009, seeking compassionate appointment to the
Deputy Secretary, President Secretariat in the Rashtrapati
Bhavan. Thereafter, wife of deceased employee has
submitted an application dated 21st May, 2009, seeking
compassionate appointment for his son, was taken
cognizance of by the respondents and unfortunately the
applicant was unable to garner the requisite weightage
points and on that ground applicant’s request for
compassionate appointment was rejected in the year 2017.
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
3. Aggrieved by the said order of rejection, the applicant
filed an O.A. No. 1002/2018, challenging the rejection order.
The said OA was dismissed by a Coordinate Bench of the
Tribunal vide order dated 24th September, 2019.
3
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
4. Thereafter, the respondents had issued a notification in
the year 2023 inviting applications for compassionate
appointment. Accordingly, the applicant also applied for
compassionate appointment pursuant to the said
notification. However, he was not appointed against any of
the vacancies notified in the year 2023, as he had secured
the lesser weightage points amongst the selected candidates.
Aggrieved by the rejection of his request for compassionate
appointment, the applicant has now filed the present OA
seeking the following reliefs:
“A. DIRECT THE APPOINTMENT OF THE APPLICANT FROM THE
DATE WHEN OTHER CANDIDATE WHOSE RIGHT TO BE
APPOINTED ACCRUED LATER, WAS APPOINTED AGAINST THE
VACANT POSITION, WITH ALL CONSEQUENTIAL BENEFITS
FROM THE DATE OF SUCH APPOINTMENT;
B. DIRECT THE APPOINTMENT OF THE APPLICANT FROM THE
DATE WHEN OTHER CANDIDATE WHOSE RIGHT TO BE
APPOINTED ACCRUED LATER, WAS APPOINTED AGAINST THE
VACANT POSITION, WITH ALL CO SEQUENTIAL BENEFITS FROM
THE DATE OF SUCH APPOINTMENT;
C. AWARD COMPENSATION TO THE APPLICANT FROM THE
RESPONDENTS FOR THE ILLEGAL NON-APPOINTMENT OF THE
APPLICANT AND THE MENTAL AND ECONOMIC AGONY FACED
BY THE APPLICANT AND THE AMILY MEMBERS;
D. ALLOW THE O.A. IN FAVOUR OF THE APPLICANT;”
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
5. The contention of learned counsel for the applicant is
that, by applying under the provisions of the RTI Act, 2005,
he obtained a reply dated 2nd April, 2024, from the
respondents, which reveals that the respondents had
applied the guidelines for compassionate appointment as
4
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
contained in DOPT OM No. A-14014/9/94-Estt. (D), dated
9th October, 1998.
6. He states that inasmuch as the respondents themselves
have stated that they have adopted the criteria contained in
the said DoP&T O.M., which does not speak about any
weightage be assigned for such kind of compassionate
appointment. The ground taken by the respondents in
rejecting his case by applying the yardstick contained in the
subsequent DoP&T OM No. page 7 of counter reply A-
12012/1/2013-Admn.IV dated 6th August, 2018 is
incorrect.
7. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the
DoP&T O.M. dated 9th October, 1998, is the correct O.M.
which ought to have been applied while considering his case
for compassionate appointment, and not the subsequent
DoP&T OM referred to above.
8. Learned counsel for the applicant also contends that,
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
aggrieved by the rejection of his request, he had earlier filed
OA No. 1002/2018, which came to be dismissed by a
Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal vide order dated 24th
September, 2019. The main ground for such rejection was
that the Tribunal was not inclined to interfere with the
5
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
assessment of the respondents in applying weightage points,
as the applicant did not possess sufficient weightage points
entitling him for appointment on compassionate grounds.
9. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that applicant
may be given a fair opportunity by the respondents by
applying the correct DoP&T O.M. dated 09.10.1998, while
deciding his eligibility for compassionate appointment.
10. In support of his contention, learned counsel for the
applicant relies upon the following judgments in that the
applicant's claim ought to have been considered for grant of
compassionate appointment:
i. Judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India
in Malaya Nanda Shetty Vs. State of Orissa, AIR 2022
SC 2836, relevant paragraphs number 11, 12 and 16 to 18
of the judgment reads as under:-
“11. We have heard the learned counsel for the respective parties
at length.
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
12. We have noted that there is a conflict of view, as to whether
the scheme/rules in force on the date of death of the government
servant would apply or the scheme/rules in force on the date of
consideration of the application on compassionate grounds would
apply. There are divergent views and the conflict of opinion in
different decisions of this Court. However, keeping the said
question aside, for the reasons stated hereinbelow, we are of the
opinion that in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case,
the appellant herein shall be entitled for appointment on
compassionate ground as per the 1990 rules, which were
applicable at the time when the deceased employee died and the
6
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
appellant herein made an application for appointment on the
death of his father, i.e., in the year 2010.
…..
16. Before parting with the present order, we are constrained to
observe that considering the object and purpose of appointment on
compassionate grounds, i.e., a family of a deceased employee
may be placed in a position of financial hardship upon the
untimely death of the employee while in service and the basis or
policy is immediacy in rendering of financial assistance to the
family of the deceased consequent upon his untimely death, the
authorities must consider and decide such applications for
appointment on compassionate grounds as per the policy
prevalent, at the earliest, but not beyond a period of six months
from the date of submission of such completed applications.
17. We are constrained to direct as above as we have found that
in several cases, applications for appointment on compassionate
grounds are not attended in time and are kept pending for years
together. As a result, the applicants in several cases have to
approach the concerned High Courts seeking a writ of Mandamus
for the consideration of their applications. Even after such a
direction is issued, frivolous or vexatious reasons are given for
rejecting the applications. Once again, the applicants have to
challenge the order of rejection before the High Court which leads
to pendency of litigation and passage of time, leaving the family of
the employee who died in harness in the lurch and in financial
difficulty. Further, for reasons best known to the authorities and
on irrelevant considerations, applications made for compassionate
appointment are rejected. After several years or are not
considered at all as in the instant case.
18. If the object and purpose of appointment on compassionate
grounds as envisaged under the relevant policies or the rules have
to be achieved then it is just and necessary that such applications
are considered well in time and not in a tardy way. We have come
across cases where for nearly two decades the controversy
regarding the application made for compassionate appointment is
not resolved. This consequently leads to the frustration of the very
policy of granting compassionate appointment on the death of the
employee while in service. We have, therefore, directed that such
applications must be considered at an earliest point of time. The
consideration must be fair, reasonable and based on relevant
consideration. The application cannot be rejected on the basis of
frivolous and for reasons extraneous to the facts of the case. Then
and then only the object and purpose of appointment on
compassionate grounds can be achieved.”
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
ii. Judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Indian Bank and Ors. vs. Promila and Anr. (2020) 2 SCC
7
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
729, relevant paragraphs number 18 and 19, are reproduced
herein below:-
“18. The question of applicability of any subsequent Scheme
really does not apply in view of the judgment of this Court in
Canara Bank. Thus, it would not be appropriate to examine
the case of the respondents in the context of subsequent
Schemes, but only in the context of the Scheme of 4.4.1979,
the terms of which continued to be applicable even as per the
new Scheme of 5.11.1985, i.e. the Scheme applicable to the
respondents. There is no provision in this Scheme for any ex
gratia payment. The option of compassionate appointment
was available only if the full amount of gratuity was not
taken, something which was done. Thus, having taken the
full amount of gratuity, the option of compassionate
appointment really was not available to the respondents.
19. We may also notice that though the subsequent Schemes
were not applicable, even if benefit was sought to be given of
those Schemes, initial non-disclosure and subsequent
disclosure by respondent No.1, of her employment and her
emoluments would disentitle her under those Schemes, too.
Thus, when the appellant was calling upon the respondents
to apply under the subsequent Schemes, that could have
been beneficial to the 2(supra) respondents only if they were
entitled to any of the benefits under that Scheme. That could
not happen because the benchmark provided in those
subsequent Schemes took the emoluments of respondents
beyond the prescribed limit, so as to disentitle them from
both, compassionate employment and ex gratia payment.”
iii. Judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State
of Madhya Pradesh and Others vs. Amit Shrivas, (2020)
10SC 496, relevant paragraph 24, is reproduced herein
below:-
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
“23. We had the occasion of examining the issue of compassion
appointment in a recent judgment in Indian Bank & Ors. v.
Promila & Anr. We may usefully refer to paras 3, 4, & 5 as
under:
“3. There has been some confusion as to the scheme
applicable and, thus, this Court directed the scheme
prevalent, on the date of the death, to be placed before
this Court for consideration, as the High Court appears to
have dealt with a scheme which was of a subsequent
8
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
date. The need for this also arose on account of the legal
position being settled by the judgment of this Court in
Canara Bank & Anr. v. M. Mahesh Kumar, (2015) 7 SCC
412, qua what would be the cut-off date for application of
such scheme.
4. It is trite to emphasise, based on numerous judicial
pronouncements of this Court, that compassionate
appointment is not an alternative to the normal course of
appointment, and that 4 (2020) 2 SCC 729 there is no
inherent right to seek compassionate appointment. The
objective is only to provide solace and succour to the
family in difficult times and, thus, the relevancy is at that
stage of time when the employee passes away…..”
iv. Judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Madhya
Pradesh and Others vs. Ashish Awasthi, (2002) 2 SC 157
and particularly highlights paragraphs 5 and 6, which reads
as under:-
5. As per the settled preposition of law laid down by this Court
for appointment on compassionate ground, the policy prevalent at
the time of death of the deceased employee only is required to be
considered and not the subsequent policy.
6. In the case of Indian Bank and Ors. Vs. Promila and Anr.,
(2020) 2 SCC 729, it is observed and held that claim for
compassionate appointment must be decided only on the basis of
relevant scheme prevalent on date of demise of the employee and
subsequent scheme cannot be looked into. Similar view has been
taken by this Court in the case of State of Madhya Pradesh and
Ors. Vs. Amit Shrivas, (2020) 10 SCC 496. It is required to be
noted that in the case of Amit Shrivas (supra) the very scheme
applicable in the present case was under consideration and it
was held that the scheme prevalent on the date of death of the
deceased employee is only to be considered. In that view of the
matter, the impugned judgment and order passed by the Division
Bench is unsustainable and deserves to be quashed and set
aside.”
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
11. Learned counsel for the respondents has vehemently
opposes the contentions urged by the learned counsel for the
applicant and submits that during the first round of
9
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
litigation the Coordinate Bench of this Tribunal had gone
into the merits of the case and rejected his claim for
compassionate appointment.
12. The counsel for the respondents also states that such
order of the Coordinate Bench of the Tribunal has not been
challenged by the applicant in higher Forum and thus had
attained finality.
13. He also states that principle of res judicata would apply
to the present case and that the applicant cannot be
permitted to raise fresh grounds by filing separate O.As,
which would only lead to multiple litigation on the same
issues that have already been adjudicated and decided by
the Courts.
14. Learned counsel for the respondents also draws the
attention of the Bench to paragraph 8 of the DoP&T O.M.
dated 9th October, 1998, which reads as under:-
“8. Belated Requests for Compassionate Appointment
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
(a) Ministries/Departments can consider requests for
compassionate appointment even where the death or retirement
on medical grounds of a Government servant took place long back,
say five years or so. While considering such belated requests it
should, however, be kept in view that the concept of
compassionate appointment is largely related to the need for
immediate assistance to the family of the Government servant in
order to relieve it from economic distress. The very fact that the
family has been able to manage somehow all these years should
normally be taken as adequate proof that the family had some
dependable means of subsistence. Therefore, examination of such
10
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
cases would call for a great deal of circumspection. The decision
to make appointment on compassionate grounds in such eases
may, therefore, be taken only at the level of the Secretary of the
Department/Ministry concerned.
(b) Whether a request for compassionate appointment is belated or
not may be decided with reference to the date of death or
retirement on medical ground of a Government servant and not
the age of the applicant at the time of consideration.”
15. Learned counsel for the respondents to buttress his
arguments relies upon a judgment of the Hon’ble High Court
of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur in the matter of Smriti Verma
Vs. State of Chhatisgarh , 2025 SCC Online Chh 11091,
relevant paragraphs 6 to 9 of which, read as under:
“6. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the material available in the record.
7. From the material available on record, it is manifest that at the
time of death of the deceased employee on 09/12/2000, the
petitioner was a minor and only after attaining the age of majority
i.e. after one and a half decade, the petitioner moved an
application for grant of compassionate appointment. The provision
of compassionate appointment is a way to provide immediate
financial assistance to the families who have experienced a
sudden hardship. The petitioner shall not be entitiled to
appointment on compassionate ground after a numbers of years
from the date of death of her deceased mother.
8. The supreme Court in the matter of State of Maharastra and
another Vs. Ms. Madhuri Maruti Vidhate, reported in AIR Online
2022 SC 471 held at paragraph Nos. 7 & 8 as under.
"7. Thus, as per the law laid down by this Court in the
aforesaid decisions, compassionate appointment is an
exception to the general rule of appointment in the public
services and is in favour of the dependents of a deceased
dying in harness and leaving his family in penury and
without any means of livelihood, and in such cases, out of
pure humanitarian consideration taking into consideration
the fact that unless some source of livelihood is provided,
the family would not be able to make both ends meet, a
provision is made in the rules to provide gainful
employment to one of the dependents of the deceased who
may be eligible for such employment. The whole object of
granting compassionate employment is, thus, to enable the
family to tide over the sudden crisis. The object is not to
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
11
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
give such family a post much less a post held by the
deceased.
7.1 Applying the law laid down by this Court in the
aforesaid decisions to the facts of the case on hand,
to appoint the respondent now on compassionate
ground shall be contrary to the object and purpose of
appointment on compassionate ground. The
respondent cannot be said to be dependent on the
deceased employee, i.e., her mother. Even otherwise,
she shall not be entitled to appointment on
compassionate ground after a number of years from
the death of the deceased employee.
8. Under the circumstances and in the facts and
circumstances of the case narrated hereinabove, the
Tribunal as well as the High Court have committed serious
error in directing the appellants to appoint the respondent
on compassionate ground. The judgment and order passed
by the Tribunal confirmed by the High Court directing the
appellants to consider the case of the respondent for
appointment on compassionate ground after a number of
years is unsustainable."
9. Considering the submissions advanced by the learned counsel
for the parties, perusing the impugned order and the finding
recorded by the learned Single Judge, we are of the considered
view that the same is just and proper warranting no interference
of this Court.”
16. Heard learned counsels for the parties and perused the
pleadings available on record with their assistance.
17. I agree with the submissions made by learned counsel
for the respondents when he refers to paragraph 8 of the
DoP&T O.M. dated 09.10.1998, regarding compassionate
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
appointment, which provides that compassionate
appointment is primarily intended to provide immediate
succor to the bereaved surviving family members of the
deceased government employee.
12
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
18. However, it is to be noted that the applicant, whose
father had expired on 4th January, 2009, had immediately
submitted his application seeking compassionate
appointment in February, 2009 itself.
19. In the present case, the executive is best suited to know
about the financial conditions of the applicant's family,
including whether the family was in immediate financial
distress or otherwise, falls within the domain of the
executive and is not ordinarily a matter for judicial review.
However, what is to be seen in judicial review in
compassionate appointment is whether the rules and
regulations governing compassionate appointment as extant
at that point of time was applied correctly by the
respondents or not. In this instant case, the respondents
themselves by way a response to applicant’s RTI Application
have admitted by the letter dated 02.04.2024 that they have
applied the yardsticks contained in the DoP&T O.M. dated
09.10.1998 regarding the compassionate appointment
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
request of the applicant. Whereas in reality they have
adopted the yardsticks contained in the subsequent DoP&Ts
O.M. dated 06.08.2018 for rejecting the request of the
applicant, who had applied for the vacancy which arisen in
the year 2023.
13
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
20. I find the judgment relied upon by the applicant quoted
hereinabove in paragraph no. 11, make it quite clear that
the rules and regulations which had existed at the time of
the death of the applicant on 04.01.2009 only is applicable
for deciding whether the person deserves compassionate
appointment or not and having taken such a position in the
RTI response given to the applicant, the respondents cannot
now turn around and apply the yardsticks contained in a
subsequent DoP&T O.M. which is not at all applicable to the
applicant at the relevant point of time.
21. The judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the
respondents in the matter of Smriti Verma Vs. State of
Chhatisgarh may not be of much help to them, inasmuch
as the facts and circumstances of the said case are
distinguishable from those of the present case. In the said
case, the deceased employee had expired on 9th December,
2000, and the petitioner, being a minor at that time, had
waited until one and a half decade for attaining the age of
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
majority before seeking compassionate appointment.
However, such is not the position in the present case,
immediately after demise of the government servant the
breadwinner of the family, the widow of the deceased
employee had applied for compassionate appointment and it
14
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
was only due to administrative reasons that such request
could not be immediately complied with as can be seen from
the records and finally came to be rejected by applying the
weightage points and stating that the applicant did not
possess sufficient weightage points.
22. On the point of res judicata the applicant by way of
filing his rejoinder had stated that the present O.A. is filed
arising out of a fresh cause of action as the applicant had
applied for the latest vacancy released by the respondents in
the year 2023 and the applications for compassionate
ground appointment that previously dealt by the
respondents in accordance with the Schemes which were
promulgative much after the death of the father of the
applicant, whereas the scheme applicable at the time of the
death of the employee, was DoP&T O.M. dated 09.10.1998
for compassionate appointment to the post of Beldar. He
also states that vide response to his RTI application, he has
found that two other employees namely Smt. Geeta Bharti,
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
W/o Late Sh. Nirmal Kumar, who had expired on
31.01.2009 and Smt. Indravati, W/o Lath Sh. Ram Ujagar,
who had expired on 24.06.2011, have selected by way of
compassionate appointment for the post of Beldar whose
family’s breadwinner had expired after the death of
15
Item No. 72 (C-I/SB) O.A. No. 3988/2024
applicant’s father on 4th January, 2009, and that applicant
should be granted a fair opportunity for consideration of his
claim for compassionate appointment, by not disturbing the
appointment of given to the other beneficiary under the
provisions of compassionate ground appointment,
particularly in view of the appointments granted to other
similarly situated persons.
23. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the
matter is remitted back to the respondents to reconsider the
case of the applicant by applying the yardsticks contained in
the DoP&T O.M. dated 9th October, 1998, within a period of
twelve weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of
this order.
24. Accordingly, the present O.A. stands disposed of.
Pending M.A.(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. There
shall be no order as to costs.
[
SHILPI GUPTA
SHILPI GUPTA 2026.11.06
15:57:54+05'30'
(B. Anand)
Member (A)
/SG/