Kiran Deshmukh vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh
- Court
- Supreme Court
2026 INSC 884
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO(S). OF 2026
(Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No (s). 18722-18773 of 2025)
KIRAN DESHMUKH ….APPELLANT(S)
VERSUS
THE STATE OF MADHYA
PRADESH AND ORS. ETC. ….RESPONDENT(S)
O R D E R
Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. Leave granted.
3. These appeals by special leave have been
preferred by the appellant, Kiran (wife of deceased-
1
Ravindra Deshmukh ), assailing the judgment and
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
SONIA BHASIN
Date: 2026.08.19
11:49:20 IST
Reason:
1
Hereinafter, referred to as “deceased-Ravindra”.
1
th
order dated 11 July, 2025 passed by the High Court
2
of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur in Criminal Revision
Nos. 2615 of 2025 and 2724 of 2025. By the
impugned judgment, the High Court allowed the
criminal revision petitions preferred by the accused-
respondents, namely, Deepak Shivhare, Prakash
th
Shivhare and Ranjeet Singh, against order dated 9
May, 2025 passed by the learned First Additional
Sessions Judge, Betul, Madhya Pradesh and thereby
discharged the said accused-respondents from the
offences punishable under Section 108 read with
3
Section 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 .
BRIEF FACTS
4. The prosecution case, as emerging from the
th
material placed on record, is that on 7 October,
2024, at about 7:50 a.m., deceased-Ravindra
committed suicide by shooting himself with his
country-made pistol at his residence. During the
course of the inquest proceedings, a six-page suicide
note was recovered from the pocket of the deceased-
Ravindra.
2
Hereinafter, referred to as “the High Court”.
3
Hereinafter, referred to as “BNS”.
2
5. In the suicide note, the deceased-Ravindra
made omnibus allegations attributing responsibility
for his death to, Ranjeet Singh, Prakash Shivhare,
Deepak Shivhare, Pramod Gupta, Abhishek Sahu,
Mohd. Naseem Raza, Shamim Raza, Nazia Bano,
Karan Suryavanshi and Bhola Singh alias
Ramnarayan Singh. The deceased-Ravindra alleged
that he had been subjected to a sustained course of
mental harassment, blackmail, intimidation and
financial extortion, involving demands for payment
aggregating to a substantial sum exceeding
Rs.80,00,000/-. As per the allegations contained in
the note, the episodes of so-called extortion and
illegal demands commenced in December, 2023,
when a purported missing person incident involving
Abhishek Sahu was allegedly staged, followed by a
complaint against the deceased-Ravindra, with the
object of threatening his political career and
tarnishing his reputation.
6. It was further alleged that, in order to prevent
the aforesaid allegations from being publicised and to
safeguard his reputation, the deceased-Ravindra was
compelled to make several payments under threat
and coercion. The amounts allegedly included
3
Rs.15,00,000/- paid to Abhishek Sahu,
Rs.5,00,000/- to Shambhu Singh and
Rs.10,00,000/- to Naseem Raza and his brother,
besides further payments of Rs.8,00,000/- and
Rs.6,00,000/- allegedly made to Karan Suryavanshi
and Bhola Singh, respectively. The deceased-
Ravindra further alleged in the suicide note that,
upon his refusal to accede to a demand of
th
Rs.50,00,000/- on 5 August, 2024, he was
compelled to arrange funds by selling his wife’s
jewellery and borrowing money from acquaintances.
It was alleged that, following another purportedly
staged disappearance involving Naseem Raza, a
th
further payment of Rs.40,00,000/- was made on 15
August, 2024.
7. On the basis of the suicide note, FIR No. 444 of
th
2024 came to be registered on 8 October, 2024.
Upon completion of the investigation, a chargesheet
th
was filed on 11 January, 2025. The learned First
th
Additional Sessions Judge, Betul, order dated 9
vide
May, 2025, upon consideration of the material on
record, proceeded to frame charges against the
accused-respondents and other accused persons for
4
the offences punishable under Section 108 read with
Section 3(5) of the BNS.
8. Aggrieved thereby, the accused-respondents,
namely, Deepak Shivhare, Prakash Shivhare and
Ranjeet Singh preferred criminal revision petitions
before the High Court.
th
9. By a common judgment dated 11 July, 2025,
the High Court allowed these revision petitions and
proceeded to set aside the order framing charge and
discharged the accused-respondents. The High Court
observed that the material placed on record did not
disclose any act or omission on the part of the
accused-respondents which could amount to
instigation or intentional abetment to the deceased-
Ravindra for commission of suicide. There was no
material to establish that the accused-respondents
had either received or derived any benefit from the
alleged payments, or had themselves extended any
direct or indirect threat to the deceased-Ravindra.
Placing reliance upon the decisions of this Court in
Mohit Singhal & Anr. v. State of Uttarakhand &
4
Ors. , and Prakash & Ors. v. State of
4
(2024) 1 SCC 417.
5
5
Maharashtra & Anr. , the High Court held that the
requisite mens rea and active participation necessary
to constitute the offence of abetment of suicide were
not prima facie made out. The High Court,
accordingly, proceeded to discharge the accused-
respondents from the offence punishable under
Section 108 read with Section 3(5) of the BNS.
10. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and order
of the High Court, the appellant has approached this
Court by way of appeal with special leave.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
11. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant
submitted that the judgment and order passed by the
High Court is legally unsustainable and liable to be
set aside. It was contended that, at the stage of
framing of charges, the Court is required to examine
the material placed on record by the prosecution only
for the purpose of determining whether the same
discloses a ground to proceed against the accused.
The Court, at such stage, is not expected to
undertake a meticulous examination or appreciation
of the evidence or conduct a hairsplitting exercise
5
(2026) 6 SCC 251.
6
into the merits of the case so as to determine the
ultimate probability of conviction.
12. Learned counsel submitted that the High Court,
while exercising revisional jurisdiction, travelled
beyond the permissible scope of scrutiny by
evaluating the defence of the accused-respondents
and undertaking a detailed assessment of the
evidentiary material at a preliminary stage of the
proceedings. Such an exercise tantamounted to
conducting a “mini-trial”, which is impermissible
while considering the sustainability of an order
framing charge in the revisional jurisdiction.
13. Learned counsel further submitted that the
High Court fell into error in holding that the requisite
proximity/live link between the alleged acts of the
accused-respondents and the incident of suicide was
absent merely because the last alleged transaction
had taken place nearly two months prior to the
commission of suicide. It was contended that the
allegations in the suicide note, read as a whole,
disclose a continuing course of extortion,
intimidation, blackmail and mental harassment, and
the effect of such sustained conduct could not have
been assessed by isolating the last alleged payment
7
from the continuous series of acts attributed to the
accused-respondents.
14. On these grounds, learned counsel for the
appellant, implored the Court to set aside the
impugned judgment and allow the appeals.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE
RESPONDENTS
15. Learned counsel appearing for respondent No.1-
State of Madhya Pradesh supported the submissions
advanced on behalf of the appellant and contended
that, while examining the legality of the order framing
charges, the High Court travelled beyond the
permissible scope of scrutiny and proceeded to
assess the material on record in a manner akin to
conducting a “mini-trial”.
16. Per contra , learned counsel appearing for the
accused-respondents vehemently and fervently
opposed the submissions advanced on behalf of the
appellant. He supported the impugned judgment
contending that the present appeals are wholly
misconceived, legally untenable and devoid of merit.
It was submitted that the High Court, upon an
apropos consideration of the material available on
record, rightly exercised its revisional jurisdiction
8
and discharged the accused-respondents, and that
no error or infirmity has been demonstrated in the
impugned judgment so as to warrant interference in
exercise of the jurisdiction of this Court under Article
136 of the Constitution of India.
17. Learned counsel further submitted that the
essential ingredients of the offence of abetment to
suicide, namely, the requisite mens rea , instigation
and a proximate nexus between the alleged acts of
the accused-respondents and the suicide by the
deceased-Ravindra, are conspicuously absent from
material collected during investigation and the report
filed under Section 173(2) of the CrPC (corresponding
Section 193(3)(i) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023). It was contended that the mere
naming of the accused-respondents in the suicide
note, by itself, would not constitute the offence
punishable under Section 108 of the BNS. The last
th
alleged transaction took place on 15 August, 2024,
i.e., nearly two months prior to the suicide committed
th
by the deceased-Ravindra on 7 October, 2024, and
that such temporal gap negates any proximate or
causal nexus between the alleged acts attributed to
9
the accused-respondents and the deceased-Ravindra
taking his own life.
18. In light of these submissions, learned counsel
for the accused-respondents supported the
impugned judgment and urged that the appeals,
being devoid of merit, deserve to be dismissed.
ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION
19. We have given our thoughtful consideration to
the submissions advanced at the bar and have
carefully perused the material available on record.
20. The offence of abetment of suicide necessarily
postulates the existence of a live and proximate
nexus between the acts of instigation or abetment
attributed to the accused and the commission of
suicide. Where the alleged prejudicial conduct has
ceased a substantial period prior to the occurrence
and there is no material indicating any intervening
act of instigation, intimidation or harassment in close
proximity to the culminating act, the requisite causal
nexus between the alleged conduct and the act of
suicide becomes difficult to sustain even at the
threshold.
21. In the present case, the last specific act alleged
against the accused-respondents is stated to have
10
th
occurred on 15 August, 2024, when the alleged
payment of Rs.40,00,000/- was made, whereas the
th
deceased-Ravindra committed suicide on 7 October,
2024. There is, thus, an interval of nearly two months
between the last alleged act of harassment and the
commission of suicide by the deceased-Ravindra.
Significantly, the prosecution has not placed any
material on record to indicate that, during this
intervening period, the accused-respondents
subjected the deceased-Ravindra to any further act
of intimidation, extortion or harassment, or otherwise
instigated or intentionally aided him in taking the
extreme step of ending his own life. In such
circumstances, the mere fact that the accused-
respondents have been named in the suicide note, or
the allegation that the deceased-Ravindra had
allegedly been subjected to harassment on earlier
occasions, cannot, by itself, establish the requisite
proximate nexus with the commission of suicide.
22. The absence of any intervening act assumes
significance in determining whether the alleged
conduct of the accused-respondents continued to
operate as a proximate cause of the suicide. The fact
that the deceased-Ravindra ultimately took his own
11
life, by itself, cannot retrospectively convert every
prior act of harassment or coercion into an act of
abetment. In the absence of material disclosing any
continuing course of conduct, fresh demand, threat,
instigation or intentional attempt to harass the
deceased-Ravindra in close proximity to the
occurrence, the requisite mens rea and the causal
nexus necessary to constitute abetment of suicide
cannot be inferred merely from the antecedent
allegations.
23. Another circumstance which merits
consideration is that the deceased-Ravindra did not
make any complaint to the police or seek any form of
legal or other redressal or intervention in respect of
alleged acts of blackmail, intimidation and extortion.
The material on record does not furnish any
explanation as to why the deceased-Ravindra
refrained from reporting the alleged acts attributed to
the accused-respondents and remained silent in that
regard. While this circumstance, by itself, may not be
determinative, it assumes significance in examining
whether the alleged conduct of the accused-
respondents continued to have any discernible
bearing upon the mental state of the deceased-
12
Ravindra and bore a proximate nexus with his
decision to take the extreme step. The suicide note
refers to payment of large sums of money by the
deceased-Ravindra to different accused persons on
different dates under the threat of false implication.
The allegations prima facie appear to be fanciful and
conjectural rather than having any pith or substance
in them. Surprisingly, the investigating agency made
no effort whatsoever to confirm or verify the
foundational truth of these allegations and even did
not care to ascertain whether the deceased-Ravindra
had the capability to pay the huge sums of money
referred to in the suicide note.
24. We are of the view that the allegations contained
in the suicide note, even if accepted in their entirety,
are vague, omnibus and conspicuously devoid of any
material particulars. The note fails to attribute any
specific act, or omission to the accused-respondents
which could amount to instigation, aid or intentional
assistance in the commission of suicide.
Significantly, the allegations do not disclose any
proximate or discernible nexus between the conduct
attributed to the accused-respondents and the
deceased-Ravindra taking the extreme step. Tested
13
against these surrounding circumstances, the
allegations are not only bereft of the foundational
facts necessary to sustain the charge of abetment of
suicide, but also appear inherently improbable. In
such circumstances, a mere reference to the names
of the accused-respondents in the suicide note,
without anything further to substantiate the
allegations, cannot furnish a legally sustainable
basis to prima facie attribute the offence of abetment
of suicide to them.
25. The aforesaid circumstances, when considered
cumulatively, lead to the conclusion that the material
on record, even if accepted at its highest, does not
disclose the essential ingredients of the offence
punishable under Section 108 of the BNS against the
accused-respondents. The High Court, therefore,
cannot be said to have committed any error in
interfering with the order framing charges and
discharging the accused-respondents.
26. As an upshot of the above discussion, we find
no infirmity in the impugned judgment warranting
interference of this Court under Article 136 of the
Constitution of India. Accordingly, the judgment and
th
order dated 11 July, 2025 rendered by the High
14
Court is affirmed. The appeals lack merit and are
dismissed as such.
27. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of.
….……………………J.
(SANDEEP MEHTA)
...…………………….J.
(MANMOHAN)
NEW DELHI;
AUGUST 11, 2026.
15