DR C T PUTTASWAMY vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
R
CNR: KAHC010516142026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 20 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S SUNIL DUTT YADAV
WRIT PETITION NO. 23120 OF 2026 (S-TR)
BETWEEN:
1. DR C T PUTTASWAMY
S/O. SRI. LATE THIMMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
PROFESSOR,
DEPARTMENT OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERING,
B.M.S. COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING,
BENGALURU,
PRESENTLY WORKING AS DIRECTOR
(TECHNICAL CELL),
DEPARTMENT OF FOREST,
ECOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT,
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA,
M.S. BUILDING, DR. B.R. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
BENGALURU - 560 001,
Digitally
signed by
PRAKASH N
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
RESIDING AT NO. 206,
12TH B CROSS, VYALIKAVAL,
MALLESHWARAM, BENGALURU - 560 003
… PETITIONER
(BY SRI. UDAYA HOLLA, SENIOR ADVOCATE A/W
SRI SHAHBAAZ HUSAIN., ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY ITS ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY,
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
DEPARTMENT OF FOREST,
ECOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT,
6TH FLOOR, M.S. BUILDING,
DR. B.R. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
BENGALURU - 560 001.
2.
THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF
CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
(HEAD OF FOREST FORCE),
ARANYA BHAVAN, 18TH CROSS,
MALLESHWARAM, BENGALURU - 560 003.
3. DPAR SECRETARY
M.S. BUILDING, DR. B.R. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
BENGALURU - 560 001.
4. RAMESH B.R. IFS
AGED MAJOR
DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FOREST (RESEARCH)
BENGALURU - 560 003
… RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. ASHVINI PATIL, AGA FOR R1 TO R3;
SRI VIJAYA SHEKARA GOWDA, ADVOCATE FOR R4)
THIS W.P. IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO A) QUASHING THE ORDER
DATED 24.07.2026 NO.E-DPAR 103 SFA 2026 PASSED BY
RESPONDENT NO.1, AT ANNEXURE A, IN SO FAR AS IT CURTAILS
THE DEPUTATION OF THE PETITIONER TO THE POST OF DIRECTOR
(TECHNICAL CELL), DEPARTMENT OF FOREST, ECOLOGY AND
ENVIRONMENT, AS BEING ARBITRARY, UNREASONED, VOID,
ILLEGAL AND BEYOND AUTHORITY AND ETC.
THIS WRIT PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
ON 28.09.2026 AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDERS
THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S SUNIL DUTT YADAV
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
CAV JUDGMENT
The Petitioner who was working as Director
(Technical Cell) Department of Forest, Ecology and
Environment has filed the present petition being aggrieved
by the order dated 24.07.2026 at Annexure-A, whereby he
was summarily relieved by the posting of respondent No.4
in his place.
2. The petitioner has challenged the validity of the
order at Annexure-'A' dated 24.07.2026 and has sought
for issuance of writ of mandamus to direct the respondent
nos.1 to 3 to permit him to continue to discharge the
duties of the post of Director (Technical Cell), Department
of Forest, Ecology and Environment for the tenure of three
years.
3. The facts made out are that the petitioner
holding a degree of Master of Technology had joined the
BMS college of Engineering as a member of the Teaching
Faculty.
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
4. On 27.01.2025, the petitioner was appointed as
Director (Technical Cell) Forest, Ecology and Environment
Department till further orders in terms of Annexure-'B'.
The terms and conditions of his appointment are as per
Annexure-'N' dated 10.06.2025 whereby, his appointment
on contract basis was specified to be for one year
commencing from 27.01.2025 or until further orders
whichever is earlier. In terms of the order at Annexure-P,
the services of the petitioner were extended for a period of
one year from 27.01.2026.
5. It is the grievance of the petitioner that despite
having the benefit of the tenure till 27.01.2027, such
tenure was curtailed by virtue of the impugned order at
Annexure-A relieving him on 24.07.2026. By virtue of the
said order at Annexure-A, the respondent No.4 has
displaced the petitioner.
6. The Respondent-State on the other hand would
contend that the assertion of sanctioned tenure by the
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
petitioner is incorrect and the appointment of the
petitioner is strictly “until further orders”. It is further
submitted that employees serving under deputation
possess no indefeasible legal right to continue in such
borrowed post. It is also contended that the petitioner's
posting on deputation does not preclude the State from
deploying its own Indian Forest Service Officers to the said
post. The State has specifically contended that petitioner
being relieved by his previous employer, i.e., BMS College
of Engineering vide order at Annexure-J dated 27.01.2025
for a period of three years, maintaining a lien on his post
at BMS College of Engineering would not bind the State
Government.
7. The private respondent has adopted the
contentions of the State and has specifically averred that
the petitioner has been relieved and Respondent no.4 has
taken charge and accordingly once the impugned order is
implemented, the present petition is not maintainable.
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
8. Heard Sri.Udaya Holla, learned Senior Counsel
for Sri.Shahbaaz Hussain, learned counsel for petitioner
and Smt.Ashwini Patil, learned AGA for respondent
nos.1 to 3 and Sri.Vijaya Shekara Gowda, learned counsel
for respondent no.4.
9. The only point for consideration is: whether the
order posting the petitioner for a period of 'one year or till
further orders whichever is earlier', would entitle the
respondent-State to curtail the tenure of the petitioner in
the manner resorted to?
10. The initial order appointing the petitioner as
Director (Technical Cell) is in terms of Annexure-B read
with Annexure-N. While Annexure-B would refer to
petitioner's appointment as being till ‘further orders’,
Annexure-N further elucidates that the order of
appointment is for a period of one year or until further
orders whichever is earlier and which engagement is on a
contractual basis.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
11. For the purpose of clarity, the relevant extracts
at Annexure-B and Annexure-N are as follows:
ANNEXURE - B
PÀ£ÁðlPÀ ¸ÀPÁðgÀ
¸ÀA: C¥Àfà 29 EJ£ï« 2025 (¨sÁUÀ-1) PÀ£ÁðlPÀ ¸ÀPÁðgÀ ¸ÀaªÁ®AiÀÄ
§ºÀĪÀĺÀr PÀlÖqÀ
¨ÉAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ. ¢£ÁAPÀ: 27.01.2025.
C¢ü¸ÀÆZÀ£É
qÁ. ¹ n ¥ÀÅlÖ¸Áé«Ä ¥ÁæzsÁå¥ÀPÀgÀÄ, PÉ«ÄPÀ¯ï EAf¤AiÀÄjAUï «¨sÁUÀ, ©JAJ¸ï
EAf¤AiÀÄjAUï PÁ¯ÉÃdÄ, ¨ÉAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ, EªÀgÀ£ÀÄß ¸ÀéAvÀ ªÉÃvÀ£À ±ÉæÃt DzsÁgÀzÀ ªÉÄïÉ
¤zÉÃð±ÀPÀgÀÄ (vÁAwæPÀ PÉÆÃ±À), CgÀtå, ¥Àj¸ÀgÀ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ fë±Á¸ÀÛæ E¯ÁSÉ, ¨ÉAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ,
²æÃ UÉÆÃPÀįï Dgï. LJ¥sïJ¸ï. EªÀgÀ eÁUÀPÉÌ vÀPÀët¢AzÀ eÁjUÉ §gÀĪÀAvÉ ºÁUÀÆ ªÀÄÄA¢£À
DzÉñÀzÀªÀgÉUÉ £ÉëĹ DzÉò¹zÉ.
qÁ. ¹ n ¥ÀÅlÖ¸Áé«Ä EªÀgÀ £ÉêÀÄPÁwUÉ ¸ÀA§A¢ü¹zÀAvÉ ¸ÉêÁ µÀgÀvÀÄÛ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ
¤§AzsÀ£ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¥Àj²Ã°¹ ºÉÆgÀr¸À®Ä ¹D¸ÀÄ E¯ÁSÉAiÀÄÄ PÀæªÀÄPÉÊUÉÆ¼ÀÄîªÀÅzÀÄ.
PÀ£ÁðlPÀ gÁdå¥Á®gÀ DzÉñÁ£ÀĸÁgÀ
ªÀÄvÀÄÛ CªÀgÀ ºÉ¸Àj£À°è,
(©.J£ï. ¥Àæ«Ãuï)
¸ÀPÁðgÀ D¢üãÀ PÁAiÀÄðzÀ²ð,
CgÀtå fë¥Àj¹Üw ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¥Àj¸ÀgÀ E¯ÁSÉ,
(fë¥Àj¹Üw ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¥Àj¸ÀgÀ)
(emphasis supplied)
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
ANNEXURE-N
¸
ÀPÁðgÀzÀ DzÉñÀ ¸ÀASÉå: ¹D¸ÀÄE 81 ¸ÀG¸Éà 2025, ¨ÉAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ, ¢£ÁAPÀ:-10-06-2025.
¥Àæ¸ÁÛªÀ£ÉAiÀÄ°è «ªÀj¹gÀĪÀ CA±ÀUÀ¼À »£É߯ÉAiÀİè, qÁ.¹ n ¥ÀÅlÖ¸Áé«Ä., ¥ÁæzsÁå¥ÀPÀgÀÄ,
PÉ«ÄPÀ¯ï EAf¤AiÀÄjAUï «¨sÁUÀ, ©JAJ¸ï EAf¤AiÀÄjAUï PÁ¯ÉÃdÄ, ¨ÉAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ, ¥Àæ¸ÀÄÛvÀ
¤zÉÃð±ÀPÀgÀÄ (vÁAwæPÀ PÉÆÃ±À), CgÀtå, ¥Àj¸ÀgÀ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ fë±Á¸ÀÛæ, E¯ÁSÉ, EªÀgÀ UÀÄwÛUÉ
DzsÁgÀzÀ £ÉêÀÄPÁwUÉ ¸ÀA§A¢ü¹zÀ µÀgÀvÀÄÛ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¤§AzsÀ£ÉUÀ¼À£ÀÄß F PɼÀPÀAqÀAvÉ ¤UÀ¢¥Àr¹
DzÉò¸À¯ÁVzÉ.
1. qÁ. ¹ n ¥ÀÅlÖ¸Áé«Ä, ¥ÁæzsÁå¥ÀPÀgÀÄ, ©.JA.J¸ï EAf¤AiÀÄjAUï PÁ¯ÉÃdÄ,
¨ÉAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ EªÀgÀ£ÀÄß CgÀtå, ¥Àj¸ÀgÀ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ fë±Á¸ÀÛæ E¯ÁSÉAiÀİè£À ¤zÉÃð±ÀPÀgÀÄ (vÁAwæPÀ
PÉÆÃ±À) ºÀÄzÉÝUÉ ¢£ÁAPÀ 27-01-2025 jAzÀ MAzÀÄ ªÀµÀðzÀªÀgÉUÉ CxÀªÁ ªÀÄÄA¢£À
DzÉñÀzÀªÀgÉUÉ, EzÀgÀ°è AiÀiÁªÀÅzÀÄ ªÉÆzÀ¯ÉÆÃ C°èAiÀĪÀgÉUÉ UÀÄwÛUÉ DzsÁgÀzÀ ªÉÄÃ¯É £ÉëĹzÉ.
2......
3......
4.....
5. M¥ÀàAzÀzÀ µÀgÀvÀÄÛ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¤§AzsÀ£ÉUÀ¼À°è ¤ÃrgÀĪÀ ¸Ë®¨sÀåUÀ¼À ºÉÆgÀvÁV
¨ÉÃgÁªÀÅzÉà ¸Ë®¨sÀåPÉÌ CAzÀgÉ ªÉÃvÀ£À §rÛ, ¥ÀzÉÆÃ£Àßw, ¦AZÀt EvÁå¢ ¸Ë®¨sÀåUÀ½UÉ ¸ÀzÀj
UÀÄwÛUÉ £ËPÀgÀgÀÄ CºÀðgÁVgÀĪÀÅ¢®è.
6.......
7.......
8. CªÀgÀÄ PÀvÀðªÀåUÀ¼À£ÀÄß ¥Á°¸ÀÄwÛgÀĪÀ CxÀªÁ ¤ªÀð»¸ÀÄwÛgÀĪÁUÀ CªÀjUÉ
®¨sÀåªÁUÀ§ºÀÄzÁzÀ CxÀªÁ zÉÆgÀPÀ§ºÀÄzÁzÀ C¢üPÀÈvÀ ªÀiÁ»wAiÀÄ£ÀÄß
UË¥ÀåªÁVlÄÖPÉÆ¼ÀÄîªÀÅzÀ£ÀÄß PÀlÄÖ¤mÁÖV ¥Á°¸À¨ÉÃPÀÄ.
9. 1966 gÀ PÀ£ÁðlPÀ £ÁUÀjPÀ ¸ÉêÁ (£ÀqÀvÉ) ¤AiÀĪÀiÁªÀ½ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 1957 gÀ PÀ£ÁðlPÀ
£ÁUÀjPÀ ¸ÉêÁ (ªÀVÃðPÀgÀt, ¤AiÀÄAvÀæt ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ªÉÄîä£À«) ¤AiÀĪÀiÁªÀ½UÉ CªÀgÀÄ
§zÀÞgÁVgÀÄvÁÛgÉ.
10.......
11........
(emphasis supplied)
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
12. It is also relevant to notice that there was a
further extension of tenure of the petitioner by order dated
23.01.2026 at Annexure-P which specifically recites that
the petitioner's appointment being subject to the order
dated 10.06.2025 at Annexure-N is further extended for a
period of one year from 27.01.2026 on contractual basis.
13. At the outset, it must be noticed that the
appointment of the petitioner to the post of Director
(Technical Cell) is in terms of the Karnataka Government
Secretariat Services (Recruitment) Rules, 2019 ("the
Rules" for short). In terms of the Rules that have been
notified on 10.07.2019, Schedule IX provides for posting
by deputation. The said rule would provide for filling up of
the post by an employee from outside the Department as
well.
14. Extract of the relevant Rules and Schedule IX is
as follows:
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
ANNEXURE -H
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS
NOTIFICATION
No.DPAR 105 SRD 2014, Bengaluru, Dated:10.07.2019.
Whereas the draft of the Karnataka Government Secretariat
Services (Recruitment) Rules, 2019, which the Government of
Karnataka proposes to make in exercise of the powers conferred by
section 3 read with section 8 of the Karnataka State Civil Services
Act, 1978 (Karnataka Act 14 of 1990) was published as required by
clause (a) of sub-section (2) of section 3 of the Karnataka State Civil
Services Act, 1978 in Notification No. DPAR 105 SRD 2014, in part
IVA (PR No. 195) of the Karnataka Gazette dated 23.05.2019 inviting
objections and suggestions from all persons likely to be affected
thereby within fifteen days from the date of its publication in the
Official Gazette.
Whereas, the said Gazette was made available to the public on
23.05.2019.
And Whereas objections and suggestions received in this behalf
have been considered by the Government.
Now, therefore in exercise of the powers conferred by sub
section (1) of section 3 read with section 8 of the Karnataka State
Civil Services Act, 1978 (Karnataka Act 14 of 1990) the Government
of Karnataka hereby makes the following rules.
These rules may be called the "Karnataka Government
Secretariat Services (Recruitment) Rules, 2019."
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
SCHEDULE - IX
TECHNICAL CELL IN THE FOREST, ECOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT
DEPARTMENT
Sl. Category of Post
No. and the scales of
pay
Number
of
Posts
Method of Recruitment Minimum
Qualification
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
1. Director
(Technical Cell)
(Rs.67550-104600)
1 By deputation of an officer
holding a post in an
equivalent grade in a
University established by
Law in India or Scientific
institution of National
Importance;
For Deputation or
posting.- (1) Must
possess a First class
Masters Degree in
Environmental
engineering and if a
suitable person is not
available, the persons
who hold First Class
Masters Degree in any
other branch of
Engineering or Science
may be considered:
Provided that,
preference shall be
given to a person
possessing a doctorate
degree in Engineering
or Science
Or
By Posting of an Additional
or Joint Secretary to
Government, from the
Karnataka Government
Secretariat or by
deputation of an Officer
from the Karnataka
Administrative Service.
(2) Must have an
experience of at least
ten years in the field of
research in a
University established
by Lae in India or in a
Scientific Institution of
National importance.
2 Scientific Officer
Grade-I (Biological
Sciences of
Horticulture
Rs.52650-97100)
1 By deputation from the
cadre of Lecturers or
Assistant Professors of a
University established by
law in India or an officer
holding a post in an
equivalent grade in the
Department of Agriculture
or Fisheries;
For Deputation or
posting.- Must possess
a First Class Master's
degree in Biology or
Zoology or Genetics or
Microbiology or Bio-
Chemistry of Bio-
Technology or
Agricultural Sciences.
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
15. The petitioner's appointment to the post of
Director (Technical Cell) cannot be said to be a simple
order of deputation. The Apex Court in the case of
Union of India and Another v S.N. Maity and
1
Another while considering the case of S.N.Maity, who
was working as a Scientist in the Central Mining Research
Institute and was subsequently appointed by the President
of India on deputation to the post of Controller General of
Patents, Design, and Trademarks for a period of 5 years or
until further orders after undergoing a selection process
and recommendation by the UPSC, was repatriated to his
parent department after serving for only one year in the
post. In the context of challenge to such order, the Apex
Court at para 13 has held as under:
"13. In the above backdrop, this Court
made a distinction between “transfer on
deputation” and “appointment on deputation”
and proceeded to lay down thus: (Ashok
1
(2015) 4 SCC 164
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
Kumar Ratilal Patel case [Ashok Kumar Ratilal
Patel v. Union of India, (2012) 7 SCC 757 :
p. 762, paras 14-15)
…
15. The present case is not a
case of transfer on deputation. It is a
case of appointment on deputation
for which advertisement was issued
and after due selection, the offer of
appointment was issued in favour of
the appellant. In such circumstances,
it was not open for the respondent to
argue that the appellant has no right
to claim deputation and the
respondent cannot refuse to accept
the joining of most eligible selected
candidate except on ground of
unsuitability or unsatisfactory
performance.”
.....
15. The controversy that has emerged in the
instant case is to be decided on the touchstone
of the aforesaid principles of law. We have
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
already opined that it is not a case of simple
transfer. It is not a situation where one can
say that it is a transfer on deputation as
against an equivalent post from one cadre to
another or one department to another. It is
not a deputation from a Government
Department to a Government Corporation or
one Government to the other. There is no cavil
over the fact that the post falls in a different
category and the first respondent had gone
through the whole gamut of selection. On a
studied scrutiny, the notification of
appointment makes it absolutely clear that it is
a tenure posting…”
16. Thus, in terms of Annexure-B read with
Annexure-N passed under the Rules, it is clear that the
petitioner has been 'appointed on deputation' to the post
of Director (Technical Cell), which is in contra-distinction
with posting by way of transfer on deputation. Such
conclusion is to be arrived at, as the petitioner's posting is
by way of orders in exercise of the recruitment Rules
which enable posting by way of appointment.
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
17. We now consider the tenure of such appointment
and if it can be curtailed. The post is a permanent post to
be filled as per the Rules. The Rules by themselves do not
stipulate a tenure. However, by way of an order of
appointment vide Annexure-B read with Annexure-N, the
tenure is one year or until further orders whichever is
earlier. Thus, posting of the petitioner is for a specific
tenure. Though by such stipulation the post cannot be
classified as a 'tenure post', however, the posting of the
petitioner is for a tenure i.e., one year or until further
orders whichever is earlier.
18. Further, to confirm the nature of post of
Director (Technical Cell), we may turn to the Karnataka
Civil Service Rules, 1958, which defines a 'Tenure Post' as
follows:
"8(47) 'Tenure Post' :- means a
permanent post which an individual Government
servant may not hold for more than a limited
period without reappointment. In case of doubt
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
Government will decide whether a particular
post is or is not a tenure post;
8(34) 'Permanent Post' :- means a post
carrying a definite rate of pay sanctioned
without limit of time."
19. On perusal of Annexure-'B' and 'N', and
Schedule IX of the Rules, it is clear that the nature of
petitioner's appointment is that of appointment on
deputation on a tenure basis to a permanent post.
20. The Apex court in P. Venugopal v. Union of
2
India in considering the curtailment of tenure of the
Director of All India Institute of Medical Sciences, held as
under:
“32. … “tenure” means a term during
which office is held. It is a condition of holding
the office. Once a person is appointed to a
tenure post, his appointment to the said post
begins when he joins and it comes to an end on
the completion of tenure unless curtailed on
2
(2008) 5 SCC 1
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
justifiable grounds. Such a person does not
superannuate, he only goes out of the office on
completion of his tenure.
(emphasis supplied)
21. The words 'till further orders' are preceded by a
fixed tenure of one year, a meaningful interpretation of
'one year' or till further orders whichever is earlier would
be that the period of one year would in normal
circumstance be a fixed tenure though the same could be
curtailed.
22. Effectively, tenure is for a period of one year in
terms of Annexure-P. Though additional words used "until
further orders whichever is earlier," the said words do not
have the effect of conferment of unguided power to curtail
the tenure of one year. The interpretation in
P. Venugopal (supra) could be extended to the present
case as though the post is not a tenure post, but the
posting is for a tenure to a sanctioned post. As the
posting is for a tenure, it could be held that the
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
curtailment of tenure could be on 'justifiable grounds'.
Such approach would also require to be adopted in light of
the interpretation as regards tenure at para 19.
23. Though the petitioner's appointment at
Annexure-N states the appointment to be on a contractual
basis, it is not contractual in nature. The Apex court in the
case of K. Anbazhagan and Another v. Registrar
3
General, High Court of Madras and Another in
considering the claim of the appellants, who were lawyers
appointed as Fast Track Court Judges in the State of
Tamil Nadu for a term of five years, which was extended
and later sought for absorption in the regular cadre, had
occasion to analyse the characteristics of contractual
employment in service jurisprudence. The Apex Court
observed as follows:
"34. In service jurisprudence, the
appointments are made by the employer with
different nomenclature/ characteristics.
3
(2018) 9 SCC 293
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
Appointments are made both on permanent or
temporary basis against permanent post or
temporary post. The appointment can also be
made on ad hoc basis on permanent or
temporary post. There is one common feature of
appointments of permanent, temporary or
ad hoc appointment i.e., those appointments
are made against the post whether permanent
or temporary. On the contrary, for contractual
appointment, there is no requirement of
existence of any post. A contractual
appointment is not normally made against a
post. Further, contractual appointments are also
not normally on pay scale. On the mere fact
that the advertisement as well as the
appointment was made initially for a period of
five years, the nature of appointment of the
appellants cannot be termed as contractual
appointment. When a government servant is
contemplated to hold a certain post for a limited
period it is a tenure post."
(emphasis supplied)
24. As the appointment of the petitioner to the post
of Director (Technical Cell) is in terms of the Karnataka
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
Government Secretariat Services (Recruitment) Rules,
2019, in terms of the Rules that have been notified on
10.07.2019, as Schedule IX provides for appointment by
deputation against a permanent post on a sanctioned pay
scale, his appointment cannot be said to be contractual in
nature.
25. Further, once the appointment is in terms of the
Rules, such appointment which permits an outside
employee to be posted as Director (Technical Cell) in the
organization cannot be construed to be transfer on
deputation. Though the Rules does employ the word
'deputation', meaning thereby a posting by deputation, the
posting of an outside employee in terms of the recruitment
Rules must in fact be construed to be an appointment.
26. The Rule presupposes the following of a
procedure while making such appointment. Such
appointment as reflected in the orders at Annexure-B read
with Annexure-N, cannot be construed to be an order of
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
deputation akin to that of deputing a civil servant from one
Department of the Government to the other, or from the
Government to a Local Body. In the present case, the
petitioner being employed in a private engineering college,
i.e., BMS Engineering College, which is not a Department
of Government, but a University, is by virtue of the Rules
allowed a lateral entry to the post of a senior official, i.e.,
Director (Technical Cell).
27. While a deputationist may not normally have an
indefeasible right to continue, though law does extend
protection against arbitrariness, the posting of the
petitioner as described above would confer further
qualitative protection by virtue of it being a deputation by
appointment and not a deputation by transfer.
28. A further protection available to such an
appointee is that the State deals with the petitioner in a
fair manner without any arbitrary exercise of power.
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
29. The appointment secures a tenure which is 'one
year or until further orders whichever is earlier'. The
curtailment of tenure below one year cannot be resorted
to without justifiable grounds and cannot be done in an
arbitrary or capricious manner. This is substantiated by
the observations of the Apex Court in the case of
S.N Maity (supra) wherein the Apex Court has held as
follows:
“15. … and the fixed tenure is five years
unless it is curtailed. But, a pregnant one, this
curtailment cannot be done in an arbitrary or
capricious manner. There has to have some
rationale. Merely because the words “until
further orders” are used, it would not confer
allowance on the employer to act with caprice.”
(emphasis supplied)
30. Such protection flows also from the duty of the
State to deal with its employee consistent with rights
conferred under Article 14. The rights of the petitioner
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
against arbitrary action no doubt cannot be interpreted in
a manner so as to alter terms of the contract/orders of
appointment and interpretation placed herein on the
orders of Annexure-B and Annexure-N. Keeping in mind
the observations of the Apex Court in S.N Maity's
(supra), interpretation placed herein cannot be construed
to rewriting the terms of appointment made under the
recruitment Rules.
31. In the present case, the replacement of the
petitioner by the fourth respondent is with immediate
effect and factually, the petitioner has been displaced
contemporaneous to the order at Annexure-A. However,
the order at Annexure-A does not assign any reason for
displacing the petitioner which would fall within the
description of arbitrary or capricious.
32. Any effort to read into the order at Annexure-A
reasons extraneous to the order would be impermissible in
light of the dicta that an order must speak for itself and
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
cannot be enlarged or extended to include reasons that
may emanate from affidavits or pleadings in light of the
law laid down in the case of Mohinder Singh Gill and
Another v The Chief Election Commissioner, New
4
Delhi and others where the Apex Court pithily held
“ orders are not like old wine becoming better as they grow
older ”.
33. In light of discussion made above, the point for
consideration is answered in the negative, the order at
Annexure-A requires to be set aside and the petitioner is
to be reinstated with continuity in service and all
emoluments as would be attached to the post for the
period between the date of the impugned order till the
date of reinstatement. Such direction is passed in light of
the petitioner being summarily displaced by an order that
has not stood legal scrutiny and has resulted in a Senior
4
(1978) 1 SCC 405
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
Officer being displaced in an impermissible and arbitrary
manner.
34. However, it is clarified that the further relief
sought for by the petitioner for extension of his services till
26.01.2028 would not arise. The order of BMS college of
Engineering at Annexure-J whereby the petitioner has
been relieved for a period of three years with a lien on his
post would bind only the BMS College of Engineering
vis-à-vis the petitioner and would not create a right of
further employment in the Government Department
beyond the tenure at Annexure-P.
35. Accordingly, the following:
ORDER
The petition is allowed in part.
The impugned order at Annexure-A is set aside. The
petitioner would be entitled to continue in service till
27.01.2027. In light of his being relieved of duties, he is
entitled for reinstatement and entitled to pay from the
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:64599
WP No. 23120 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010516142026
date of the impugned order till date. The direction for
reinstatement to be adhered to forthwith and in any event
not later than one week from today. Further, he is
permitted to continue on same terms till the tenure as
conferred as per the order at Annexure-P.
Accordingly, the petition is disposed of.
Sd/-
(S SUNIL DUTT YADAV)
JUDGE
NP/-