Vandana Jain vs Union Of India And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
120/1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CWP No. 20154 of 2026 (O&M)
Vandana Jain
… Petitioner
Versus
Union of India and others
… Respondents
1. The date when the judgment is reserved 28.10.2026
2. The date when the judgment is pronounced 20.11.2026
3. The date when the judgment is uploaded on
the website
20.11.2026
4. Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or whether the full judgment is
pronounced
Operative
5. The delay, if any, of the pronouncement of full
judgment, and reasons thereof
Not applicable
CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK SIBAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUNISH BINDLISH
Argued by: Ms. Aakriti, Advocate, for the petitioner.
Mr. Ranvijay Singh, Senior Standing Counsel,
for the respondents-Income Tax Department.
SUNISH BINDLISH, J.
1. The petitioner, an individual assessee, has invoked the writ
jurisdiction of this Court under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India for
issuance of a writ of certiorari quashing, for Assessment Year 2013-14, the letter
dated 08.05.2026 (Annexure P-14), described in the petition as a notice under
Section 148A(b) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ("the Act"), the order dated
25.06.2026 passed under Section 148A(d) (Annexure P-15), and the consequential
notice dated 25.06.2026 issued under Section 148 (Annexure P-16).
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.20154 of 2026 (O&M) 2
2. The facts, which are borne out from the Department's own record, are
briefly these:
(i) The petitioner filed her return for Assessment Year 2013-14 on
26.03.2014, declaring a total income of Rs.25,73,320/-. The return
was never taken up for scrutiny, and no assessment under Section
143(3) was framed.
(ii) A notice dated 30.03.2021 under Section 148, as it stood prior to its
substitution by the Finance Act, 2021, was issued by the Income Tax
Officer, Ward 7(1), Ludhiana (Annexure P-1). The petitioner states
that she came to know of it only in April 2021. In response to a notice
dated 30.06.2021 under Section 142(1) (Annexure P-2), she filed a
return on 12.07.2021 and, by her communications dated 10.09.2021
and 03.02.2022 (Annexures P-3 and P-5), sought the reasons for
reopening. By communications dated 03.02.2022 and 17.02.2022
(Annexures P-4 and P-6), the Department required her first to verify
that return.
(iii) The reasons were supplied on 23.03.2022 (Annexure P-8). They rest
on a single item of information from the Investigation Wing: bogus
long-term capital gain of Rs.26,40,000/- through trading in penny
stock. Paragraph 6 of the reasons concludes that “an amount of
Rs.26,40,000/- received on account of bogus LTCG/STCL as well as
other income which comes to the notice during the course of
assessment proceedings” had escaped assessment. No other item or
amount finds mention in the reasons.
(iv) Meanwhile, the petitioner had challenged the notice in CWP
No.2880 of 2022, contending that a notice issued after 01.04.2021
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.20154 of 2026 (O&M) 3
could be issued only after following the procedure under Section
148A. By order dated 15.02.2022 (Annexure P-7), the petition was
directed to come up along with CWP No. 14886 of 2021 (DLF
Gayatri Developers v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax), and
interim orders were passed in the same terms as in that case. The
proceedings remained in abeyance thereafter. On 04.05.2022, the
Supreme Court decided Union of India v. Ashish Agarwal, (2023) 1
SCC 617 (Annexure P-9). CWP No.14886 of 2021 was disposed of
on 18.04.2026 (Annexure P-12).
(v) CWP No. 2880 of 2022 was disposed of on 30.04.2026 (Annexure
P-13), on the concession of the Revenue that, in terms of Ashish
Agarwal, the notice dated 30.03.2021, dispatched to the petitioner on
or after 01.04.2021, be treated as a notice under Section 148A(b).
The Revenue was directed “to proceed from the stage of the afore
notice, in terms of the procedure laid down under Section 148A(b)
of the Act”, and the petitioner was left at liberty to raise all pleas
available to her in accordance with law. The concession as to
dispatch was made notwithstanding the statement in the
Department’s communication dated 17.02.2022 (Annexure P-6) that
the notice was “issued and served on 30.03.2021”. The respondents
have not resiled from it and treat the question as concluded (reply,
para 3), and the matter proceeds on that footing.
(vi) By letter dated 08.05.2026 (Annexure P-14), the Income Tax Officer,
Ward 7(1), Ludhiana, referring to the notice dated 30.03.2021 and
the order dated 30.04.2026, enclosed “the requisite information and
material relied upon for initiating the proceedings u/s 147/148” and
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.20154 of 2026 (O&M) 4
called for the petitioner’s reply by 22.05.2026. The two Insight Portal
extracts enclosed with it were both shown as uploaded on
07.03.2021: Rs.26,40,000/- from Dayanand Singh (Upload ID
1000000161), described as “Fictitious Profits in Equity/Derivative
Trading”, with the remark “Information already sent to AO”; and
Rs.58,10,325/- from Mahanivesh (India) Ltd. (Upload ID
1000000184), described as information of beneficiaries of bogus
LTCG/STCL for Financial Year 2012-13, relating to sale of shares.
Only the first item corresponds to the reasons dated 23.03.2022, and
only that item is marked “Information already sent to AO”.
(vii) The petitioner did not reply. By order dated 25.06.2026 under
Section 148A(d) (Annexure P-15), the Assessing Officer, noticing
the absence of a reply, aggregated the two items, held that
Rs.84,50,325/- had escaped assessment, treated it as an “asset”
within the Explanation to Section 149(1), and invoked the ten-year
period under Section 149(1)(b). The notice under Section 148 of even
date (Annexure P-16) followed, with the prior approval of the
Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, NWR, Chandigarh,
accorded on 23.06.2026. The present petition was filed on
03.07.2026.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the notice dated
30.03.2021 was confined to alleged escaped income of Rs.26,40,000/-; that the
item of Rs.58,10,325/- did not form part of it and was put to the petitioner for the
first time on 08.05.2026; that the letter of that date is, to that extent, in substance
a second show cause notice, barred by limitation since 31.03.2024 under the
substituted Section 149; and that neither Ashish Agarwal nor the order dated
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.20154 of 2026 (O&M) 5
30.04.2026 permitted the Department to enlarge the scope of the original notice
or to proceed afresh.
4. Learned Senior Standing Counsel for the respondents, relying on the
reply, makes the following submissions:
(i) No demand has been raised or enhanced. The figure of
Rs.84,50,325/- is only the aggregate of the information suggesting
escapement of income. No assessment has been framed and no tax,
interest or penalty levied.
(ii) The letter dated 08.05.2026 does no more than discharge the
direction in clause (i) of Ashish Agarwal and the order dated
30.04.2026. Nothing was amended and nothing was issued afresh;
the notice under Section 148A(b) is, and remains, the notice dated
30.03.2021.
(iii) Both items were uploaded on the Insight Portal on 07.03.2021, before
the notice dated 30.03.2021, and formed part of the Assessing
Officer’s record. They pertain to the same assessee, the same
assessment year and the same subject matter, namely dealings in
shares routed through entities controlled by entry operators, and do
not constitute separate causes of action. Section 148A(b) and the rule
of audi alteram partem required the whole material to be disclosed;
withholding part of it would have invited a challenge on the ground
of reliance on undisclosed material.
(iv) The reasons themselves reserved the position as to “other income
which comes to the notice during the course of assessment
proceedings”. Even assuming that the second item came to the
Assessing Officer’s notice only after the deemed notice, the
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.20154 of 2026 (O&M) 6
Explanation to Section 147 empowers the Assessing Officer to assess
income in respect of any issue which comes to his notice
subsequently in the course of the proceedings.
(v) Having accepted the legal fiction that the notice dated 30.03.2021 is
a notice under Section 148A(b) for the purpose of escaping the pre-
amendment regime, the petitioner cannot approbate and reprobate by
contending that the reference date for limitation is 08.05.2026.
(vi) The question of limitation is concluded by Union of India v. Rajeev
Bansal , (2024) 469 ITR 46 (SC). The validity of the notice is to be
tested with reference to the deemed notice dated 30.03.2021. Shares
are an “asset” under the Explanation to Section 149(1), and since
Rs.84,50,325/- exceeds Rs.50 lakh, the ten-year period under Section
149(1)(b) is available. The six-year period under the unamended
Section 149(1)(b), which expired on 31.03.2020, stood extended to
30.06.2021 by the Taxation and Other Laws (Relaxation and
Amendment of Certain Provisions) Act, 2020 (“the Relaxation Act”).
Under the third proviso to Section 149(1), the period from
15.02.2022 to 30.04.2026, the period between the deemed notice and
the supply of material, and the time allowed to reply, from
08.05.2026 to 22.05.2026, are all excluded.
(vii) The petitioner did not file any reply to the letter dated 08.05.2026,
either within the time granted or in the period of over a month before
the order dated 25.06.2026 was passed. The petition raises questions
of fact, is premature, and the petitioner has an efficacious alternative
remedy before the Assessing Officer and thereafter in appeal under
Section 246A.
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.20154 of 2026 (O&M) 7
5. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the paper
book and the reply.
6. The issue is no longer res integra. In CWP No. 20141 of 2026 (Tanu
Jain v. Union of India and others), this Court considered the same questions on
materially identical facts. That case involved the same Assessing Officer, the same
assessment year and the same sequence of proceedings: a notice dated 30.03.2021
whose reasons were confined to Rs.26,40,000/-; a writ petition kept pending with
interim protection; an order on concession treating that notice as a show cause
notice under Section 148A(b); and a letter dated 08.05.2026 enclosing two Insight
Portal extracts from the same two sources, Dayanand Singh and Mahanivesh
(India) Ltd. This Court held:
(i) A notice treated as a show cause notice under Section 148A(b) in
terms of Ashish Agarwal remains confined to the grounds on which
it was originally issued. The Assessing Officer may supply the
material underlying it, but cannot use that opportunity to introduce a
new item of escaped income. Availability of information on the
Insight Portal is distinct from reliance upon it, and a description of
material as “relied upon” in a letter issued years later cannot displace
the contemporaneous reasons.
(ii) Two items relating to share dealings in the same year remain separate
pieces of information where they come from different sources, bear
different upload IDs and involve different transactions and amounts.
A similar modus operandi does not make one a part of the other. The
obligation of disclosure under Ashish Agarwal and Section 148A(b)
extends to the material underlying the existing notice, and cannot be
converted into a power to enlarge it.
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.20154 of 2026 (O&M) 8
(iii) An item put to the assessee for the first time on 08.05.2026 amounts,
in substance, to a fresh notice, and its limitation must be tested with
reference to that date. So tested, it is barred: the ten-year period for
Assessment Year 2013-14 expired on 31.03.2024, and the six-year
period under the unamended provision, even as extended by the
Relaxation Act, ended on 30.06.2021. The exclusion of time under
the third proviso to Section 149(1) attaches only to the proceeding
actually pending and stayed, and not to an item that was never part
of it.
(iv) The power to assess income which comes to notice subsequently in
the course of the proceedings arises only in a reassessment, after a
valid notice under Section 148, and cannot be used at the stage of
Section 148A to found jurisdiction or to satisfy the threshold in
Section 149. Nor does the plea that no demand has been raised assist
the Revenue, since the finding of escapement in the order under
Section 148A(d) is the jurisdictional basis for invoking the extended
period.
(v) Without the new item, the original item of Rs.26,40,000/- is below
the threshold of Rs.50 lakh. As held in Rajeev Bansal, a deemed
notice for an assessment year preceding 2021-22 must satisfy both
the first proviso to Section 149(1), which imports the time limit under
the unamended provision, and the time limit, including the monetary
threshold, under the substituted Section 149(1)(b); satisfying the
unamended time limit answers only the first of these conditions. The
proceedings, therefore, cannot be sustained, and a remand confined
to Rs.26,40,000/- would be an empty formality.
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.20154 of 2026 (O&M) 9
(vi) Where limitation goes to the root of jurisdiction and the facts are
borne out by documents on record, the petitioner cannot be relegated
to the alternative remedy ( Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of
Trade Marks , (1998) 8 SCC 1). Failure to reply to the letter dated
08.05.2026 does not confer a jurisdiction which the statute denies.
7. Only the first of the matters noticed below distinguishes the present
case; the remaining three arose equally in, and are answered by, Tanu Jain:
(i) The second item here, Rs.58,10,325/-, by itself exceeds Rs.50 lakh,
whereas in Tanu Jain the second item was below that figure. That
makes no difference. The item is excluded not because of its amount
but because it did not form part of the notice dated 30.03.2021 and
was put to the petitioner for the first time on 08.05.2026. Even if the
ten-year period were available to it on its own, that period expired on
31.03.2024; and the six-year period under the unamended Section
149(1)(b), even as extended by the Relaxation Act, ended on
30.06.2021. The third proviso to Section 149(1) does not help the
respondents, since the only proceeding pending and stayed between
15.02.2022 and 30.04.2026 was the one founded on Rs.26,40,000/-.
What survives is Rs.26,40,000/-, which is below the threshold.
(ii) The words “as well as other income which comes to the notice during
the course of assessment proceedings” in the reasons record no belief
as to any particular escapement. They identify no information, no
item and no amount, and only anticipate the power under the
Explanation to Section 147, which, as held in Tanu Jain, arises only
after a valid notice under Section 148.
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.20154 of 2026 (O&M) 10
(iii) The petitioner did not reply to the letter dated 08.05.2026. That is not
to be commended, but silence on the part of an assessee cannot confer
a jurisdiction which the statute withholds, and her pleas were
expressly preserved by the order dated 30.04.2026.
(iv) The petition assails the impugned action as “time barred insofar has
the demand against the petitioner has been enhanced”, the word
“demand” being used loosely to denote the escaped income alleged,
and also seeks any other appropriate writ, order or direction. The
contention that Rs.26,40,000/- by itself cannot sustain the extended
period of limitation is not specifically pleaded. It is, however, a pure
question of law going to the jurisdiction of the Assessing Officer,
which arises on the documents on record and on the respondents’
own pleadings. All defences under Section 149 were kept open by
Ashish Agarwal and by the order dated 30.04.2026, and the
respondents have met the point in their reply, which rests the
extended period on the aggregate alone. The question can, therefore,
be decided. The respondents’ own case on the extended period rests
entirely on the aggregate of Rs.84,50,325/- exceeding Rs.50 lakh.
The order under Section 148A(d) and the notice under Section 148
dated 25.06.2026 are single jurisdictional acts founded on that
aggregate. Once it fails, nothing survives that could be severed and
saved, and remitting the matter for a fresh order confined to
Rs.26,40,000/- would be an empty formality, since any such order
would be barred on its face. The relief must be moulded accordingly.
8. The present case is, therefore, squarely covered by Tanu Jain (supra).
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The letter dated 08.05.2026 (Annexure
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP No.20154 of 2026 (O&M) 11
P-14), described in the petition as a notice under Section 148A(b), the order dated
25.06.2026 passed under Section 148A(d) (Annexure P-15) and the notice dated
25.06.2026 issued under Section 148 (Annexure P-16) are hereby quashed, along
with all consequential proceedings for Assessment Year 2013-14.
9. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs.
( DEEPAK SIBAL )
JUDGE
( SUNISH BINDLISH )
JUDGE
November 20, 2026
rps
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document